Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA 12 of 2017
Sri Nani Gopal Ghosh
S/O - Lt. Akhil Chandra Ghosh,
Resident of Panichowkibazar,
P.O. and P.S. - Kailashahar,
-----Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Smt. Sandhya Sinha
D/O - Lt. Soangiri Rajkumar Alias Rajkumar Sinha,
Resident of Kumarghat, P.O. and P.S. - Kumarghat,
near S.E. Office, Dist. - Unakoti Tripura.
2. Sri Basu Ranjan Deb
S/O - Lt. Rasamoy Deb,
Resident of Kumarghat near S.E. Office,
P.O and P.S. - Kumarghat, Dist. - Unakoti Tripura.
3. Sri Biplab Deb
S/O - Lt. Rasamoy Deb,
Resident of Kumarghat near S.E. Office,
P.O. and P.S. - Kumarghat, Dist. - Unakoti Tripura.
4. Sri Debashish Deb
S/O - Rasamoy Deb, Resident of Kumarghat Near S.E. Office, P.O and
P.S. - Kumarghat, Dist. - Unakoti Tripura.
5. Smt. Santa Roy (Saha)
W/O - Dipesh Kumar Saha,
Resident of Kumarghat Near S.E. Office,
P.O. and P.S. - Kumarghat, Dist. - Unakoti Tripura.
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent(s)
Date of hearing
Date of pronouncement
Whether fit for reporting
-----Respondent(s)
: Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Adv.
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, Adv.
: Mr. H. Deb, Adv.
: 03.02.2022.
: 11.02.2022
: No
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
Judgment & Order
This is an appeal under Section 100 of the CPC against the
judgment and decree dated 21.07.2016 passed by the Additional
District Judge, Unakoti, Kailashahar, in the Title Appeal No.10 of 2014.
[2]
At the outset, the controversy that led to filing of the suit
may briefly be introduced. The appellant-plaintiff has instituted the suit
Title Suit No. 41 of 2013 against the respondents for declaration of his
right, title and interest over the suit immovable property and recovery
of possession thereof from the defendants.
[3]
The plaintiff-appellant case in short compass is that the suit
land measuring 1.57 acres recorded under Khatian No.222 of Mouja
Kumargath and other land originally owned by the father namely Akhil
Chandra Ghosh since deceased. The said Akhil Chandra Ghosh gave jot
settlement of the suit land to the plaintiff by executing a lease deed
bearing no. 2861 dated 1962 accordingly, the record of right vide
Khatian No. 222 of the suit land was prepared in the name of the
plaintiff. The record of rights was finally published during revision
survey operation during the year 1987. Thus, the plaintiff had been
possessed the suit land as “RAYAT” through his men by paying revenue
to the Government since the date of settlement.
[4]
In the plaint filed by the plaintiff before the trial court it is
stated that the defendants have/had not right, title, interest or
possession over any portion of the suit land and the permission granted
by the plaintiff in favour of the defendant no.1 was also revoked
demanding possession while the plaintiff came to know about the said
fraudulent collusive and baseless Khatian No.1147 of the defendant No.
1 and other baseless Khatian No. 2113 and 2229 prepared in the name
of the defendant Nos. 2 to 5 and as such, all the said Khatians are
wrong, illegal and fraudulent and baseless and not binding on the
plaintiff and the documents of transfer of land, if any, executed by the
defendant No1 in favour of the defendant Nos. 2 to 5
are fraudulent
and void and not binding on the plaintiff and the defendant No.1 had no
right to put the defendant No.2 into possession of the suit land.
[5]
It is further stated in the plaint that while the plaintiff raised
objection knowing the said fraudulent and baseless Khatians and illegal
acts of the defendant No.1 and requested the defendants to vacate the
suit land, the defendant No.1 came forward with a proposal of
compromise and admitting the ownership and possession of the plaintiff
in the suit land on 11.11.2011 she entered into a written agreement
with the plaintiff to purchase the entire suit land by means of a deed at
a consideration of Rs.9,00,000/- and paid some amount as earnest
money but, the said agreement was cancelled and the earnest money
paid by the defendant No.1 was also forfeited after expiry of the
stipulated period and in terms of the said agreement and accordingly,
the plaintiff issued notice dated 21.04.2012 through his lawyer to the
defendant NO.1 under registered post with A/D requesting to vacate the
suit land but, the defendant No.1 receiving the said notice did not give
any reply and comply with the request made by the plaintiff.
[6]
In the written statement filed by the defendants (the
respondents herein) it has been stated that No lawyer’s notice dated
21.04.2012 was received by the defendant requiring to vacate the suit
land was falsely alleged. It is mentionable here that, as the value of the
said land has recently risen up due to formation of new sub-division, the
plaintiff out of his greed for money as ex-zamindar came to defendant
No.1 a woman causing threat for filing false suit and harassment and
the defendant No. 1 who is a village rustic lady out of fear came to the
plaintiff to surrender to him as desired by him. Consequent upon such
happenings the defendant No. was compelled then to settle the matter
with the plaintiff on condition to pay Rs. 9 lakhs to get rid of threat of
false case and other harassments. The defendant No1 also paid Rs. 3
lakhs initially to the plaintiff and later on Rs.80,000 only to him and rest
amount would be paid subsequently. But the defendant within the time
as desired by the plaintiff, tendered him with the rest amount in
presence of her witnesses for settlement of his claim by executing a
deed of settlement but he flatly denied to act as per his commitment
and ultimately demanded for surrendering a portion of the land in his
favour. It is emphatically denied that, on 11.11.11 the answering
defendant No.1 entered into a written agreement to purchase to the
entire suit land by means of a deed at a consideration of Rs.9 lakhs but
there was no talk of such purchase by defendant as falsely alleged.
However a talk of settlement was held for payment of Rs 9 lakhs the
defendant No. 1 was till ready and willing to pay the rest amount as
desired by plaintiff but as the plaintiff failed to perform his part to
execute a deed of settlement/compromise in favour of defendant No.1
by refusing to receive the rest amount as desired by the plaintiff. The
defendant No. 1 reserved her right to file appropriate suit against the
plaintiff for recovery of Rs.3 lakhs 80 thousand against the plaintiff with
appropriate compensation in due course of time. The plaintiff has
already lost his title tin respect of suit property by acquisition of valid
right acquired by defendant No.1 and such right cannot
be defeated
without any proper and valid document. As the plaintiff is not fair in his
deal and has come before this court without clean hands seeking for
declaration of his right against the defendant No.1 who had already
acquired adverse right in respect of suit land beyond the statutory
period of limitation without any interruption from any quarter for which
he is not entitled to get any relief before the court of equity and as such
the suit deserves to be dismissed with cost to the defendant.
[7]
The plaintiff in examination-in-chief has referred to the
lease deed No.1-2861 (Exbt-1 series) of the paper book. The relevant
portion of the said lease deed reads as follows:
The followings are the conditions between the parties which
was made voluntarily between the Akhil Chandra Ghosh (1st Party,
vendor) and Sri Nani Gopal Ghosh (the 2nd party, vendee)
1. As I the 1st party have been remaining as the oner of
the ladn mentioned in the below schedule with Jote title, I
have agreed to delvier Jote of (the land) in favour of you
the 2nd party, accordingly I the 2nd Party agreed to accept
the same.
2. As the annual revenue of 9 kani land for both the
parties is ascertained at the rate of Rs.2.00 per kani thus
totaling Rs.18.00 (Rupees Eighteen) of the below
mentioned related Khas Jote no.45 present Jote no.50
having a measurement of 5X6 Nol (unit of measurement)
of 14 cutis Nol of 18 inches/cubit and cess having an
amount of Rs.19 at the rate Re.1 and 2 annas at the rate
of 1(one) anna of Re 1 of the annual rental, I the 2 nd party
shall remain bound to pay you the annual rental and cess
to you, the first party at the said rate.
3. I the 2nd party would realize and shall remain liable to
realize the said imposed revenue and cess you the 1 st
party proportionately in two installments on Ashadh and
Agrahayan (Bengali months) of every T.E or else I shall
party or remain liable to pay the interest or amount of
compensation at the rate of .03 paisa every month.
4. I the 2nd party shall keep the land obtained by way of
proper settlement described in the schedule in its original
condition alongwith the boundary and shall not perform
any sort of harmful act related to the land. If any such act
is conducted, I shall be punished legally and shall remain
liable and bound to pay the compensation.
5. I the 2nd party with the permission of you the 1st party
can make gift, sale and transfer of the land etc. and shall
not conduct any sort of dissatisfactory act towards the 1st
party, the land owner.
6. If the 2nd party fails to realize the revenue and cess as
per the said installments to you the 1 st party, then in
default of every installments of the 2nd party you can file
suit before the court against me the 2 nd party claiming
interest at the said rate and shall get the suit decreed
alongwith realizing the entire court expenses and
compensation and can also realize the entire court
expenses and compensation and can also realize the land
mentioned in the said schedule or other properties of the
2nd party by way of auction, sale, purchase. At this neither
I the 2nd party nor any of my successors shall raise any
objection. If any such act is done, it shall be rejected by
all courts of law. This deed with remain in custody of the
1st party. At this I the 2nd party shall not raise any
objection.
7. All the successors of I the 2nd party shall remain bound
to withdraw their names as per law before you i.e., in the
Seresta (Office/chamber) of the 1st party otherwise they
cannot raise any sort of claim of title over this land.”
[8]
The plaintiff-appellant herein filed the suit in the trial court
for the below mentioned schedule land
1st Schedule Boundary
Land purchased by the 1st party
Land posted in previous Khas Jote No. 45 present
Khas jote NO.50 situated within Mouja-Kumarghat,
P.S- Fatikroy, Pg-Birchandra Nagar.
Butted and bounded.
On the North by : Jote land of Guna Mani das
On the east by: Jote land of Anada Chakraborty and
jote land of Sndhani Khatrani
On the west by: Jote land of Sonai Singha, Raj
Kishore Singh a, Jamini Das, Shena Chetia Singha,
Chandra Ram Das, Kul Chandra Das, Petel Asam and
Basanta Assam
On the south by : Ditch
Within this boundary lies a total area of land
measuring 9(nine) kani 6 (six) ganda 3 (three) kara
2(two) kranta 15 (fifteen) dhur purchased by 1st
party appertaining to Dag nos. 1226, 1233, 1638,
1640, as per survey settlement operation of 1338
T.E posted in Touji no. 98.
2nd Schedule Boundary
Land obtained by 2nd party by way of proper settlement
Butted and bounded:
On the north by: Own Jote land of 1st party, Forcible
possessors- Basanta Assam and Chandra Kanti
Singha
On the east by: Premada Chakraborty in place of
Annada Chakraborty and Canal.
On the south by : dry stremlet, road and Chandra
Kumar Das towards its South.
On the west: Jote land of 1st party. Forcible
possessor- Sona Singha, Umesh Namasudra, Raj
Ram Das, Basanta Ram Das, Rajani Ram Das and
Adhir Ram Das.
Withiin this lies a total area of „Chara‟ class of land
measuring 9 Kani.
[9]
On the basis of the rival pleadings, the Civil Judge (Sr. Div),
Kailashahar, North Tripura District Judiciary in TS No 41 of 2013 dated
12.06.2014 framed the following issues:
1. Whether the suit of the plaintiff is not maintainable in its
present form and law?
2. Whether the defendants have no right, title and interest over
the suit land but plaintiff has his right, title and interest over
the suit land?
3. Whether the story of permissive possession of the defendant
No.1 and her deceased father were true?
4. Whether the story of dispossession of the plaintiff from the
suit by the defendants is/was true?
5. Whether thedefendants No.1 on 11.11.2011 entered into a
written agreement with the plaintiff to purchase the entire
suit land on execution of sale deed at consideration of rupees
9,00,000 (nine laces)?
6. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to get decree as prayed for?
7. Any other relief/relieve.
[10]
The trial judge while deciding the issue No. 2 & 3 has
observed that plaintiff had originally his ownership over the suit land in
the strength of Deed Ext.1 series. However, while we read out the
contents of the deed Ext.1 series in its entirety, it appears that the
ownership of the plaintiff over the suit land is limited ownership
inasmuch as it is a lease deed having embodied numerical conditions
imposed upon the plaintiff including that the plaintiff shall have no right
to sell the land embodied in the deed without prior permission of the
executant 1st party.
[11]
The trial court has further observed that it can be viewed
that the plaintiff has his limited interest only in the suit property but has
no absolute right and title thereof. The defendant No.1 has also no
adversary right over the suit land. The defendant No. 1 and before his
turn, his father were only in permissive possession of the suit land.
Resultantly, the issue No.2 is decided partly in favour of the plaintiff and
the issue No.3 is decided fully in favour of the plaintiff.
[12]
The trial judge after having examined all the records so
placed in the plaint and also after examining the written statement filed
by the defendant-appellant, depositions of PWs and DWs in support of
the claim, has observed as herein under:
60. In view of the above detailed discussion and findings of this
court under the above issues, the suit of the plaintiff is hereby
decreed party. The plaintiff‟s limited inters to the extent of the trms
and conditions embodied in the lease deed Ext.1 series is hereby
declared on contest against the defendant No.1 and uncontested
against defendant Nos.2 to 5, but considering the peculiarity of the
facts and circumstances of the suit, no costs is imposed.
[13]
Being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the judgment and
decree passed in the original suit, both the parties preferred separate
appeal against each other being case No. Title Appeal No.10 of 2014
and Title Appeal No. 13 of 2014 in the court of the Additional District
Judge, Unakoti Judicial District, Kailashahar. The lower appellate court
on the basis of the divergent argument and the matter available on
record, the following common points are taken up for discussion in both
TA 10 of 2014 and TA 13 of 2014
1. Whether the plaintiff or defendants have right, title and
interest over the suit land?
2. Whether the defendants No.1 and her deceased father were
the permissive possessor over the suit land?
3. Whether the plaintiff was dispossessed from the suit land by
the defendants?
4. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to get decree as prayed for?
[14]
While deciding the Point No.3 the lower appellate court has
observed that the plaintiff also stated in his evidence that on
11.11.2011 the defendant NO. 1 entered into an agreement to purchase
the suit land at Rs.9 lac and some money was also paid in lieu of the
said agreement, but the said agreement was cancelled as the defendant
No.1 failed to submit the rest of the amount as per terms and
conditions of the agreement. The plaintiff on 21.04.2012 served a
notice upon the defendant to vacate the suit land but she did not
vacate. On perusal of Ext.5 series which is the notice served upon the
defendant No.1 shows that the said notice was issued in relation to
Ext.6 only and not in relation to this present case. The plaintiff in hs
evidence himself admitted that after death of the father of defendant
No.1 she herself was in possession of the suit land. Remaining over the
suit land even after getting the notice i.e. Ext.5 series, does not show
that defendant No. 1 dispossessed the plaintiff from the suit land on
and from 21.04.2012. Thus, the point no.3 is decided against the
plaintiff side.
[15]
By the judgment and decree dated 21.07.2016 passed by
the Additional District Judge, Unakoti, Kailashahar, in the Title Appeal
No.10 of 2014, the said court has observed as follows:
“Hence in the result, the present appeals TA 10 of 2014
and TA 13 of 2014 filed by the appellant-plaintiff and
appellant-defendant against the respondent-defendants
and
respondent-plaintiff,
respondent-pro-defendants
being devoid of merit is accordingly dismissed on contest
with costs.”
[16]
Being aggrieved by the said judgment and decree of the
first appellate court dated 21.07.2016, the appellant herein has
preferred this instant appeal under Section 100 of the CPC. At the time
of admitting this appeal, the following substantial question of law was
framed by this court by the order dated 14.03.2018.
“Whether the title of property can be accrued from the
lease deed, even if the name of the lessee is recorded as
the rayat in the record of right?”
[17]
Counsel appearing for the respondents has given a catena
of judgments supporting his contention:
(i) Vijay Kumar Sharma vs. Devehs Behari Saxena reported in AIR
2008 Allahabad 66, where the court has held as follows:
14. Drawing our attention towards V.B. Dharmyat v. Shree
Jagadguru Tontadrya and Ors. (1999) 6 Supreme Court
Cases 15 and Maneklal Mansukhdhai v. Hormusji
Jamshedji Ginwala and sons AIR (37) 1950 Supreme
Court 1, it was submitted by learned Counsel for the
plaintiff-respondent that in instant case, the defendant
was required to execute lease deed in pursuance of the
agreement dated 22.01.1993 and since the agreement to
execute the lease deed does not require registration under
section 17 of the Registration Act or any other law for the
time being in force, hence the agreement in question is
legally enforceable and the decree passed by the court
below for its specific performance does not suffer from
any illegality and interference by this Court in the said
decree is not warranted. We are not at all impressed with
this argument. The agreement to sell dated 22.01.1993
(paper No. 18A) shows that the seller Vijay Kumar Sharma
(defendant-appellant) was required to execute transfer
deed in favour of the purchaser Devesh Behari Saxena
(Plaintiff-respondent)
after
receiving
balance
sale
consideration of Rs. 13,21,000/-. Through this document,
the plaintiff-respondent had purchased plot No. 133,
situate in Block-A, Sector-15, NOIDA for Rs. 20,21,000/and Rs. 7,00,000/- were paid as earnest money on
22.01.1993. According to clause (7) of this agreement,
transfer deed was to be executed in favour of the
purchaser by 02.04.1993. There is nothing in this
agreement to show that the plot in question was taken on
lease by the plaintiff. The transfer of the plot in question
for consideration of Rs. 20,21,000/- was out right sale
and it was not a lease. "The Sale", according to section 54
of the Transfer of Property Act, is a transfer of ownership
in exchange for a price paid or promised or part paid and
part-promised. According to section 105 of this Act, "
lease" of immoveable property is a transfer of a right to
enjoy such property, made for a certain time, express or
implied, or in perpetuity, in consideration of a price paid
or promised, or of money, a share of crops, service or any
other thing of value, to be rendered periodically or on
specified occasions to the transferor by the transferee,
who accepts the transfer on such terms. There is vast
difference in sale and lease. The ownership of the
property is transferred in the sale, whereas the right to
enjoy such property is only transferred in a lease. There is
no transfer of ownership of the property in lease. In
instant case, the parties have described themselves as
seller and purchaser in the agreement to sell dated
22.01.1993 (paper No. 18A) and ownership of plot No.
133 was transferred by the defendant for a sale
consideration of Rs. 20,21,000/-. It is not the case of
plaintiff in plaint that he had taken plot No. 133 on lease.
There is specific averment in the plaint that the defendant
had agreed to sell his plot No. 133 for consideration of Rs.
20,21,000/- and an agreement to sell for that purpose
was executed between the parties on 22.01.1993.
Therefore, having regard to the recitals made in the
agreement to sell dated 22.01.1993 (paper No. 18A) and
averments made in the plaint, there is no scope to
contend that the disputed plot was taken on lease by the
plaintiff. As such, both the rulings cited by the learned
Counsel for the plaintiff-respondent are not applicable in
this case and on the basis of the observations made in
these
rulings,
the
impugned
decree
of
specific
performance of the agreement to sell dated 22.01.1993
can not be sustained. Hence the point No. 2 also is decided
accordingly in favour of the appellant-defendant and
against respondent-plaintiff.
(ii) Union of India and others vs. Vasavi Co Housing Society Ltd. and
others reported in AIR 2014 SC 937, where the court has held as
follows:
15. The legal position, therefore, is clear that the plaintiff
in a suit for declaration of title and possession could
succeed only on the strength of its own title and that
could be done only by adducing sufficient evidence to
discharge the onus on it, irrespective of the question
whether the defendants have proved their case or not. We
are of the view that even if the title set up by the
defendants is found against, in the absence of
establishment of plaintiff‟s own title, plaintiff must be
non-suited.
17. This Court in several Judgments has held that the
revenue records does not confer title. In Corporation of
the City of Bangalore v. M. Papaiah and another (1989) 3
SCC 612 held that “it is firmly established that revenue
records are not documents of title, and the question of
interpretation of document not being a document of title is
not a question of law.” In Guru Amarjit Singh v. Rattan
Chand and others (1993) 4 SCC 349 this Court has held
that “that the entries in jamabandi are not proof of title”.
In State of Himachal Pradesh v. Keshav Ram and others
(1996) 11 SCC 257 this Court held that “the entries in the
revenue papers, by no stretch of imagination can form the
basis for declaration of title in favour of the plaintiff.”
20. We are of the view that even if the entries in the
Record of Rights carry evidentiary value, that itself would
not confer any title on the plaintiff on the suit land in
question. Ext.X-1 is Classer Register of 1347 which
according to the trial court, speaks of the ownership of the
plaintiff‟s vendor‟s property. We are of the view that these
entries, as such, would not confer any title. Plaintiffs have
to show, independent of those entries, that the plaintiff‟s
predecessors had title over the property in question and it
is that property which they have purchased. The only
document that has been produced before the court was
the registered family settlement and partition deed dated
11.12.1939 of their predecessor in interest, wherein,
admittedly, the suit land in question has not been
mentioned.
[18]
Mr. P Roy Barman, senior counsel for the appellant after
reserving the RSA for judgment has made submission before this court
that if the court feels like it may frame more substantial question of
laws and pass orders. Since the arguments have been complete and the
matter is reserved for judgment, framing substantial question of law at
this juncture does not arise. Once the substantial question of law is
framed, the respective counsel needs to make their submission on the
same. If this request is entertained again it amounts to reopening of the
RSA. Hence this request is rejected.
[19]
It appears to this court that no argument has been made on
the substantial question of law. It is apparent that originally there was
an agreement after execution of the lease deed in favour of the son.
Thereafter, both the parties, the plaintiff and the defendants in the Title
Suit No. 41 of 2013 preferred appeal as appellants in the court
Additional District Judge, Unakoti Judical District, Kailashahar, in T.A. 10
of 2014. The respondents herein who were the defendants in the title
suit stated before the lower appellate court that the lease does not
create title rather it gives only right to use or enjoy the leased out
property. It was further stated that the appellant herein was not under
rayat was the appellant neither cultivates or hold the suit land. So, in a
nutshell it is the case of the respondents here that the appellant is not
entitled to the suit his claiming for and has no right, title and interest
over the suit in question. The suit was accordingly decreed partly in
favour of the appellant and a little portion of the suit was given to him
by way of a lease deed.
[20]
In view of the above, the present RSA is liable to be
dismissed on the ground that exhaustive argument on the substantial
question of law are not advanced and this court is also of the view that
respondents have failed to prove framing of issue regarding execution
of adverse right in favour of the appellant by the trial court.
Hence, this court confirms the order dated 12.06.2014 of
the trial court by rejecting the order dated 21.07.2016 passed by the
lower appellate court.
With the above observation the RSA stands dismissed.
JUDGE
Dipak
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review