Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA No.33 of 2022
1. Sri Matilal Debnath (73)
S/O- Lt. Abani Mohan Debanth
2. Sri. Jagat Lal Nath @ Jagat Lal Debnath (68)
S/O- Lt. Abani Mohan Debnath
3. Sri. Chandra Lal Nath @ Chandra Lal Debnath (63)
S/O- Lt. Abani Mohan Debnath
All are the resident of Gouri Sankarpur, P.O.-Dasda
P.S- Kanchanpur, Dist- North Tripura
……….Plaintiffs-Appellants
Versus
On the basis of the order dated
21.03.2023, passed in I.A.03 of 2023 in
the said appeal Legal Representatives of
Respondent No.1 are incorporated in the
causetitle as follows1(A). Mrs. Sampa Nath
W/O- Lt. Rajkumar Debnath
1(B). Miss. Susmita Debnath
D/O- Lt. Rajkumar Debnath,
(being minor represented by her mother and next friend
Smt. Sampa Nath)
All are the resident of Gouri Sankarpur, P.O.-Dasda, P.S.
Kanchanpur, Dist.- North Tripura.
2. Sri. Ganesh Debnath
3. Sri. Swapan Debnath
4. Sri. Tapan Debnath
5. Sri. Tapas Debnath@Tapu
All are the sons of Lt. Joy Gopal Debnath
All are the resident of Gouri Sankarpur, P.O-Dasda
P.S-Kanchanpur, Dist-North Tripura
………. Defendants-Respondents
6. President / Chairman
Swasti Samabaya Samiti Ltd.
Kanchanpur, North Tripura.
………..Proforma-Respondent
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. S. M. Chakraborty, Sr. Adv,
Mr. S. Noatia, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S. Lodh, Adv,
Mr. S. Majumder, Adv.
Date of Hearing
:
09.05.2024
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order :
14.05.2024
Whether fit for
Reporting
NO
:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This second appeal under Section 100 of C.P.C. is
filed challenging the judgment dated 09.03.2022 and the
decree dated 14.03.2022 passed in Title Appeal No.14 of
by
Learned
District
Judge,
North
Tripura,
Dharmanagar. By the said judgment, Learned District Judge
was pleased to uphold the judgment dated 13.05.2019 and
decree dated 17.05.2019 passed by Learned Civil Judge,
Senior Division, Dharmanagar in Title Suit No.02 of 2018.
02.
Heard
Learned
Senior
Counsel,
Mr.
S.
M.
Chakraborty assisted by Learned Counsel, Mr. S. Noatia for
the appellant and also heard Learned Counsel, Mr. S. Lodh
assisted by Learned Counsel Mr. S. Majumder appearing on
behalf of the respondent-defendants. Before entering into
the merit of the appeal, let us discuss the subject matter of
the dispute cropped up amongst the parties. The present
appellants as plaintiffs filed one suit for declaration and for
injunction before the Court of Learned Civil Judge, Senior
Division, North Tripura, Dharmanagar for land measuring
0.60 acres as mentioned in schedule of the plaint.
03.
According to the appellant-plaintiffs, the suit land
was originally belonged to Swasti Samabaya Samiti Limited,
Kanchanpur and as per rules and regulations of Swasti
Samabaya Samiti Limited, the father of the appellantplaintiffs namely Late Abani Mohan Debnath and the uncle of
the
appellant-plaintiffs
namely,
Late
Joy
Gopal
Debnath(father of the principal defendants) became the
owner of land under Swasti Samabaya Samiti Limited,
Kanchanpur, North Tripura and as per mutual partition, both
the fathers of the appellant-plaintiffs and the father of the
principal-defendants had been possessing their respective
landed property without any interference from each other. In
the year 1992, the father of the appellant-plaintiffs died and
after
his
death
the
appellant-plaintiffs
have/had
been
possessing suit land without any interference. During last
settlement operation, for maintaining good relation, the
lands of the respective parties had been demarcated by
posting pillars in presence of the parties. But the uncle of the
appellant-plaintiffs wanted to keep it as a joint property
although the father of the appellant-plaintiffs and Joy Gopal
Debnath took all steps for recording the landed property in
separate Khatians and Swasti Samabaya Samiti Limited
issued
no
objection
certificate
for
creating
Khatians
separately in their favour. The appellant-plaintiffs submitted
one petition under Section 43 (1) of TLR & LR Act, 1960
before the settlement authority and after hearing vide order
dated 22.02.1996 ordered that hal dag nos. 5150, 5081,
5084/8796 and 5083 total land measuring 0.60 acres be
recorded in the name of the appellant-plaintiffs under Swasti
Samabaya Samiti Limited and accordingly, said land was
recorded in the name of the appellant-plaintiffs in equal
share in Khatian No.393/374. After the death of said Joy
Gopal Debnath, the respondent-defendants started creating
disturbance to grab the suit land for which so many
conciliation meeting took place in presence of the authority
of Swasti Samabaya Samiti Limited but the issue could not
be settled. Even by the intervention of legal aid clinic at
Satnala, the dispute also could not be resolved.
On
06.03.2018 the appellant-plaintiffs went to the suit land to
give boundary fencing over a portion of the suit land, that
time the respondent-defendants came and threatened the
appellant-plaintiffs not to do any work. Again on 27.03.2018,
when the appellant plaintiffs went to the suit land to do some
works over a portion of the suit land, that time the
respondent-defendants came near the suit land and asked
the plaintiffs not to do any work over the suit land and
threatened the plaintiffs with dire consequences. On hearing
hue and cry, the neighbouring persons appeared that time
the respondent-defendants fled away. Hence, the plaintiffs
having right, title and interest over the suit land filed the suit
for a decree of perpetual injunction. The respondent-
defendants
contested
the
suit
by
filing
one
written
statement. In the written statement, they took the plea that
said Akhil Chandra Debnath, the deceased grandfather of the
appellant-plaintiffs and the principal-defendant-respondents
along with the fathers of the present parties namely Abani
Mohan Debnath (since dead) and Joy Gopal Debnath (since
dead), were the owners in possession of land measuring 0.83
acres under Khatian No.684 and 820 under Mouja and
Tehesil-Dasda, Revenue Circle-Kanchanpur in equal share
i.e. 3.61 acres each. During the life time Akhil Chandra
Debnath, he sold land measuring 0.12 acres to one Umesh
Malakar and 0.28 acres to one Girish Malakar from his own
share portion and after that said Akhil Chandra Debnath
transferred land measuring 2.95 acres to his younger son Joy
Gopal Debnath, i.e. the deceased father of the principal
defendant-respondents. Said Akhil Chandra Debnath also
transferred land measuring 0.26 acres from his own share to
his elder son namely Abani Mohan Debnath, the deceased
father of the plaintiff-appellants. Later on, in the year 1977,
the Swasti Samabaya Samiti Limited, Kanchanpur opened a
record of right in favour of Joy Gopal Debnath, i.e. the
deceased father of the principal-defendants for total land
measuring 6.56 acres and another record of right was also
created in the name of Abani Mohan Debnath, the deceased
father of the plaintiff-appellants for a total land measuring
3.87 acres. Later on, the father of the plaintiff-appellants
sold land measuring 2.05 acres and 1.45 acres to one Mati
Lal Saha, son of Late Khetra Mohan Saha of Dasda from his
total land measuring 3.87 acres. It is also stated by the
principal-respondent-defendants that their father Late Joy
Gopal Debnath and none of the defendant-respondents had
any knowledge about the filing of petition by the plaintiffappellants under Section 43(1) of TLR & LR Act, 1960 before
the Settlement Authority as neither of the father of the
principal-defendant-respondent, Late Joy Gopal Debnath nor
the principal defendant-respondents received any notice
from the Revenue Authority in connection with that petition.
Hence, by the written statement, the contesting respondentdefendants prayed for dismissal of the suit costs.
04.
Upon the pleadings of the parties, Learned Court
below framed the following issues:
1. Whether the suit is maintainable in its
present form and nature?
2. Whether there is any cause of action for
filing the suit?
3. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to get
decree perpetual injunction over the suit
land?
4. What other relief/relieves the parties are
entitled to get under law and equity?
05.
The appellant-plaintiffs in support of their case,
adduced two witnesses, PW1 and PW2 and also proved some
documents as already stated. On the other hand, the
principal-defendant-respondents
examined
two
witnesses
namely, Tapan Debnath as DW1 and one Brajendra Nath as
DW2 and also relied upon some documents which were also
marked as exhibits:
Witnesses of the appellant-plaintiffs:
1. PW1- Matilal Debnath
2. PW2- Dhirendra Das
Exhibits of the appellant-plaintiffs:
1. Exhibit-1: Certified copy of Khatian
No.393/374 under Mouja Daska Laxmipur,
TK-Dasda.
2. Exhibit-2: Khatian issued
Samabaya
Samiti
Limited
measuring 0.60 acres.
by Swasti
for
land
3. Exhibit-3: Allotment order issued Swasti
Samabaya Samiti Limited in the name of
appellant-plaintiffs for land measuring 0.60
acres.
4. Exhibit-4: Order of Settlement Authority
in connection with case No.118 under
Section 43 (1) of TLR & LR Act.
5. Exhibit-5: Certified copy of tracemap.
6. Exhibit-6: Certified copy of order dated
26.11.2013, 10.12.2013 and 07.01.2014
issued by District Collector, North Tripura,
Dharmanagar in connection with case
No.Rev/Revision22/2013 u/s.95 of TLR &
LR Act, 1960.
Witnesses of the respondent-defendants:
DW-1: Tapan Debnath.
DW-2: Brajendra Nath.
Exhibits of the respondent-defendants:
Exhibit A series: Certified copy Khatian
Nos.393/177 (2 sheets).
Exhibit B series: Certified copy of Khatian
Nos.393/178(2 sheets).
Exhibit C series: Certified copy of Khatian
Nos.393/179
under
MoujaDasda,
Laxmipur, Tehesil-Dasda, Revenue CirculeKanchanpur (1 sheet).
Exhibit D series: Certified copy of Khatian
Nos.393/375 (2 sheets).
Exhibit E series: Certified copy of Khatian
Nos.393/376 (2 sheets).
Exhibit F (SO) series: Copy of Parcha
bearing No.684 Jer, 820, Jer 1914 under
Mouja-Dasda, Laxmipur, Tehesil- Dasda,
standing in the name of Akhil Chandra
Debnath, on behalf of Swasti Samabaya
Samiti Limited showing three persons
namely, Ram Manik Debnath, Abani Mohan
Debnath and Joy Gopal Debnath in equal
shares.
06.
Finally, after taking evidence and on hearing of
arguments,
Learned
Court
below
by
judgment
dated
13.05.2019 dismissed the suit filed by the appellant-
plaintiffs. The operative portion of the order of the Learned
Trial Court runs as follows:
―In the result, it is hereby held that there is
no cause of action in this suit and suit is
also not maintainable in its present form.
Although plaintiffs got ownership and ROR
for 60 satak of and but practically after
deduction they are not owner of 60 satak of
land and at best they are owner of 37
satak of land for which permanent
injunction cannot be granted against the
defendants as because plaintiffs do not
have right over total 60 satak of land
shown in the schedule of plaint. Plaintiff
failed to establish their legal right and also
exclusive possession for 60 satak of land
for which relief of perpetual injunction
cannot be granted.
Therefore, plaintiffs are not entitled to get
any perpetual injunction over the suit land
against the defendants and plaintiffs are
not entitled to get any other relief.
Thus the suit is dismissed on contest with
cost.
Sheristadar is to prepare the decree of
dismissal in the light of the above order.‖
07.
Challenging that judgment, the appellant-plaintiffs
again preferred an appeal before the Court of Learned
District Judge, North Tripura, Dharmanagar which was
numbered as Title Appeal No.14 of 2019 and after hearing
both the sides, Learned First Appellate Court by judgment
dated 09.03.2022 dismissed the appeal and uphold the
judgment of the Learned Trial Court. The operative portion of
order of the Learned First Appellate Court runs as follows:
―In view of the aforesaid discussion and
findings this title appeal preferred by the
plaintiff-appellants under Section 96 of the
Code of Civil Procedure read with Order 41
of CPC is hereby dismissed on contest being
devoid of any merit.
The judgment dated 13-05-2019 followed
by the decree dated 17-05-2019 passed by
Ld. Civil Judge (Senior Division), North
Tripura, Dharmanagar, Court No.1, in Title
Suit No. 02 of 2018 are hereby affirmed.
The parties of this suit shall have to bear
their own costs.
Senior Sheristadar is hereby directed to
draw an appellate decree within 15 days
from the date of pronouncement of this
judgment.
Send back the L. C. Record with a copy of
this judgment to the Ld. Trial court.
Thus this
contest.‖
08.
appeal
is
disposed
off
on
Before the High Court, at the time of admission of
the second appeal by order dated 05.07.2022, the following
substantial questions of law were framed:
―(i) Whether the learned courts below
misread and misconstrued Exbt. 1, Exbt. 6,
Exbt. B and Exbt. C?
(ii) Whether this court can mould the
relief?‖
09.
Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. S.M. Chakraborty
assisted by Learned Counsel, Mr. S. Noatia on behalf of the
appellant-plaintiffs submitted that in this case although both
the Courts below gave concurrent findings but the Learned
Trial Court at the time of delivery of judgment did not
consider the documentary evidence relied upon by the
appellant-plaintiffs and came to an erroneous observation
and dismissed the suit. He submitted that the suit filed by
the appellant-plaintiffs was only for injunction and on the
basis of documentary evidence on record, the Learned Trial
Court could grant decree applying Section 91 of the Evidence
Act. He also referred the relevant provisions of Order7, Rule
7 and Order 18, Rule 18 of CPC and submitted that the
judgment of the Learned Court below suffers from infirmities,
as such this cannot be sustained and the judgment of the
Learned First Appellate Court was nothing but the replica of
the judgment given by the Learned Trial Court. He also
referred another provision of Section 43 (3) of TLR & LR Act
and finally, urged for allowing this appeal by setting aside
the judgments of the Learned Courts below. Learned Senior
Counsel in addition to his submission further submitted that
from the judgment of the Learned Trial Court, it appears that
in the operative portion of the judgment, Learned Trial Court
below came to an observation that the appellant-plaintiffs
was the owners in possession of the land measuring 0.37
acres, so, in that case he could grant a part decree but
without doing so, most illegally and being misconstrued the
legal position wrongly dismissed the suit. Finally, he also
made an alternative submission before this Court to grant a
decree for land measuring 0.37 acres as observed by
Learned Trial Court.
10.
On the other hand, Learned Counsel, Mr. S. Lodh
representing
the
respondent-defendants
submitted
that
when there is cloud over the title of the appellant-plaintiffs,
there is no scope to grant any decree of injunction in favour
of the appellant-plaintiffs. Furthermore, according to Learned
Counsel, Mr. S. Lodh, for want of cause of action, the suit
was
not
maintainable,
so,
Learned
Counsel
for
the
respondent-defendants fairly submitted that both the Courts
below gave concurrent findings which were proper, lawful,
reasonable and reasoned one, so at this stage, there is no
scope on the part of this Court to interfere with the judgment
delivered by the Learned First Appellate Court and urged for
dismissal of this appeal with costs.
11.
In
course
of
hearing
of
argument,
Learned
Counsel for the respondent-defendants also referred one
citation reported in (2021) SCC OnLine SC 675 dated
07.09.2021 wherein in para Nos.10 and 11, Hon’ble the Apex
Court observed as under:
―10. The short question
consideration before us is:
that
falls
for
Whether the learned Single Judge of the
High Court was right in holding that the
suit simipliciter for permanent injunction
without claiming declaration of title, as
filed by the plaintiff, was not maintainable?
11. The issue is no more res integra. The
position has been crystalised by this Court
in the case of Anathula Sudhakar v. P.
Buchi Reddy (dead) by LRs. in paragraph
21, which read thus:21. To summarise, the position in
regard
to
suits
for
prohibitory
injunction
relating
to
immovable
property, is as under:
(a) Where a cloud is raised over the
plaintiff’s title and he does not have
possession, a suit for declaration and
possession,
with
or
without
a
consequential
injunction,
is
the
remedy. Where the plaintiff’s title is
not in dispute or under a cloud, but he
is out of possession, he has to sue for
possession
with
a
consequential
injunction. Where there is merely an
interference with the plaintiff’s lawful
possession or threat of dispossession,
it is sufficient to sue for an injunction
simpliciter.
(b) As a suit for injunction simpliciter
is concerned only with possession,
normally the issue of title will not be
directly and substantially in issue. The
prayer for injunction will be decided
with reference to the finding on
possession. But in cases where de jure
possession has to be established on
the basis of title to the property, as in
the case of vacant sites, the issue of
title may directly and substantially
arise for consideration, as without a
finding thereon, it will not be possible
to decide the issue of possession.
(c) But a finding on title cannot be
recorded in a suit for injunction,
unless there are necessary pleadings
and appropriate issue regarding title
(either specific, or implied as noticed
in Annaimuthu Thevar [Annaaimuthu
Thevar v. Alagammal, (2005) 6 SCC
202]). Where the averments regarding
title are absent in a plaint and where
there is no issue relating to title, the
court will not investigate or examine
or render a finding on a question of
title, in a suit for injunction. Even
where there are necessary pleadings
and issue, if the matter involves
complicated question of fact and law
relating to title, the court will relegate
the parties to the remedy by way of
comprehensive suit for declaration of
title, instead of deciding the issue in a
suit for mere injunction.
(d)
Where
there
are
necessary
pleadings
regarding
title,
and
appropriate issue relating to title on
which parties lead evidence, if the
matter
involved
is
simple
and
straightforward, the court may decide
upon the issue regarding title, even in
a suit for injunction. But such cases,
are the exception to the normal rule
that question of title will not be
decided in suits for injunction. But
persons
having
clear
title
and
possession suing for injunction, should
not be driven to the costlier and more
cumbersome remedy of a suit for
declaration, merely because some
meddler vexatiously or wrongfully
makes a claim or tries to encroach
upon his property. The court should
use its discretion carefully to identify
cases where it will enquire into title
and cases where it will refer to the
plaintiff to a more comprehensive
declaratory suit, depending upon the
facts of the case.‖
12.
Referring the same, Learned Counsel submitted
that since there was cloud over the title of the appellantplaintiffs, so, the Learned Trial Court below rightly dismissed
the suit filed by the appellant-plaintiffs which has been
rightly uphold by the Learned First Appellate Court.
13.
I have heard rival submission of Learned Counsels
for the parties. There is no dispute on record that the
appellant-plaintiffs filed the suit only for injunction simpliciter
and the quantum of the suit land was shown to be 0.60 acres
and in two schedules (1st schedule 0.04 acres+ 1st schedule
0.56 acres)= in total 0.60 acres.
14.
From the documentary evidence on record, as
relied upon by the appellant-plaintiffs, it appears that the
appellant-plaintiffs tried to show their possession in respect
of the suit land i.e. measuring 0.60 acres. But from the oral
evidence on record and after disposal of some landed
properties by their predecessor and also from the crossexamination of the appellant-plaintiff No.1, Matilal Debnath
as PW1, it appears that he himself admitted that his father
sold land measuring 2.05 acre and 1.45 acres to one Matilal
Saha out of total land measuring 3.87 acres of their
predecessor. So, it is the admitted position that after
disposal of 3.50 acres of land, they have got only land
measuring 0.37 acres of land in their favour. Thus, it appears
that Learned Court below rightly determined that the
appellants had got clear possession of land measuring 0.37
acres after disposal of landed properties. But Learned Court
below instead of granting a decree for the aforesaid land,
dismissed the suit.
15.
Learned Counsel, Mr. S. Lodh, appearing on
behalf of the respondent-defendants did not submit anything
in respect of said 0.37 acres of land but he submitted that
the said land was not properly identifiable for which no relief
was granted either by the Learned Trial Court or by the
Learned First Appellate Court.
16.
For the sake of convenience, I would like to refer
herein below the relevant provision of Order VII, Rule 7 of
CPC which provides as under:
Order VII, Rule 7:
―7. Relief to be specifically stated.—Every
plaint shall state specifically the relief
which the plaintiff claims either simply or
in the alternative, and it shall not be
necessary to ask for general or other relief
which may always be given as the Court
may think just to the same extent as if it
had been asked for. And the same rule shall
apply to any relief claimed by the defendant
in his written statement.‖
17.
Further, I would like to refer herein below the
relevant provision of Order XVIII, Rule 18 of CPC which
further provides as under:
Order XVIII, Rule 18
―Power of Court to inspect.—The Court may
at any stage of a suit inspect any property
or thing concerning which any question
may arise [and where the Court inspects
any property or thing it shall, as soon as
may be practicable, make a memorandum
of any relevant facts observed at such
inspection and such memorandum shall
form a part of the record of the suit].‖
18.
I would also like to refer herein below the
provision of Section 91 of the Indian Evidence Act as referred
by Learned Senior Counsel for the appellant-plaintiffs:
Section 91 of the Evidence Act:
―91. Evidence of terms of contracts, grants
and other dispositions of property reduced
to form of document. –– When the terms of
a contract, or of a grant, or of any other
disposition of property, have been reduced
to the form of a document, and in all cases
in which any matter is required by law to
be reduced to the form of a document, no
evidence shall be given in proof of the
terms of such contract, grant or other
disposition of property, or of such matter,
except the document itself, or secondary
evidence of its contents in cases in which
secondary evidence is admissible under the
provisions hereinbefore contained.‖
19.
After going through the aforesaid provisions of
law and also the principle of judgment, laid down by the
Hon’ble Apex Court, relied upon by the Learned Counsel for
the respondent-defendants, it appears to this Court the
respondent-defendant at the time of hearing of arguments
could not raise any cloud over land measuring 0.37 acres
belonging to the appellant-plaintiffs. But at the same time, it
also appears that the appellant-plaintiffs also could not give
any proper schedule of the aforesaid quantum of land before
the Learned Trial Court or to the Appellate Court even to this
Court also. Although before this Court, the scope is very
limited. Learned Court below could grant decree in respect of
land measuring 0.37 acres but the Learned Trial Court failed
to do so and the Learned First Appellate Court at the time of
delivery of judgment also overlooked the said position and
uphold the judgment of Learned Trial Court.
20.
So, in my considered view, in exercise of the
power conferred under Section 107 of CPC, the suit be
remanded back to Learned Trial Court to arrange for
demarcation of the said land measuring 0.37 acres belonging
to the appellant-plaintiffs to avoid further multiplicity of
proceedings by a Survey Knowing Commissioner appointed
under the penal of District Court to identify the said land
measuring 0.37 acres, the cost of which would be borne by
the appellant-plaintiffs. The Commissioner shall measure the
aforesaid land in presence of the parties.
21.
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant-
plaintiffs is hereby allowed. The judgment and decree dated
09.03.2022 and 14.03.2022 respectively of the Learned First
Appellate Court, upholding the judgment and decree dated
13.05.2019 and 16.05.2019 respectively of the Learned Trial
Court is hereby set aside. The suit is remanded back to the
Learned
Trial
Court
with
a
direction
to
arrange
for
measurement of 0.37 acres of land by appointing a Survey
Knowing Commissioner/Person, the cost of which would be
borne by the appellant-plaintiffs and the Survey Knowing
Commissioner
shall
measure
and
identify
the
land
in
presence of both the rival parties and then shall pass a fresh
judgment and decree based on the report of Survey
Commissioner. The entire exercise shall be made within a
period of four months from the date of receipt of a copy of
the judgment of this Court.
Send down the LCRs along with a copy of the
judgment to the respective Courts.
Pending
application(s),
if
any,
also
stands
disposed of.
JUDGE
SABYASACHI
SABYASACHI BHATTACHARJEE
2024.05.15 18:13:00
BHATTACHARJEE Date:
+05'30'
Purnita
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review