Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
Mac App No.11 of 2022
Sri Manoranjan Debnath, S/O Late Chitta Ranjan Debnath, VillageMohanpur, P.S.-Ranirbazar, District- West Tripura.
......Appellant(s)
VERSUS
1. Sri. Jiban Debnath, S/O Late Jogesh Debnath, Village-Keprampara, Near
Haradhan Chowmuhani, P.S. Ranirbazar, Dist. West Tripura. (Owner of the
offending vehicle bearing Registration No.TR-01-U- 1770, Bolero Truck
Goods vehicle).
2. Cholamandalam M/S General Insurance Company Ltd. Having its
branch office at RMS Chowmuhani, P.S.- West Agartala, District- West
Tripura (Insurer of the offending vehicle Registration No.TR-01-U- 1770
(Bolero Truck- Goods Vehicle)
......Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. B. Nath, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
:
Ms. R. Purkayastha, Advocate, vice
Mr. Rajib Saha, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
Date of hearing and Judgment : 4th January, 2023.
JUDGMENT & ORDER(ORAL)
Heard Mr. B. Nath, learned counsel appearing for the
appellant and also heard Ms. R. Purkayastha, learned counsel appearing on
behalf of Mr. Rajib Saha, learned counsel for the respondent-insurer.
[2]
The present appeal is directed against the judgment and award
dated 20.11.2021 passed by the learned Member, Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal, West Tripura, Agartala in T.S(MAC) No. 47 of 2016 whereby the
Tribunal awarded compensation of Rs.1,31,000/- in favour of the claimant
with interest @ 9% per annum from the date of filing of the claim petition.
[3]
Mr. B. Nath, learned counsel appearing for the appellant has
prayed for the following relief :
(i) Admit the appeal of the appellant claimant petitioner
(ii) Call for the records relevant to the subject matters;
(iii) Issue usual notice upon the respondents and after
hearing to interfere with the judgment and award dated
20/11/2021 passed in T.S.(MAC) 47 of 2016 and
enhanced the award by granting adequate compensation
with interest 12% per annum from the date of the filing
the claim petition i.e. on 08.03.2016.”
[4]
It is alleged that on 14.09.2014 in an accident near
Lembucherra School Chowmuhani on Mohanpur-Pulakona Road,
Manoranjan Debnath sustained injuries on his legs, chest, head, joe,
hands and face. At the time of accident, he was working as a daily
labourer. Immediately after the occurrence, he was taken to GBP hospital,
Agartala where he had undergone major surgery in his right leg on
26.09.2014. After discharge from the said hospital, he was bed ridden for
seven days. Subsequently, the claimant again was admitted in the said
hospital from 09.10.2014 to 11.10.2014 and during that period he once
again undergone a major surgery in his right leg on 11.10.2014. It was
alleged that the accident took place due to rash and negligence driving of
the driver of the offending vehicle (truck) bearing registration No.TR01U-1770.
[5]
The respondent No.1, owner of the offending vehicle
submitted his written statement and denied all the allegations inter alia
contending that he was the registered owner of the offending vehicle and
it was duly insured with the insurance company (respondent No.2). It was
further stated that at the time of accident, the vehicle was driving by his
driver having valid driving license and there was no rash and negligent
driving on part of the driver. The respondent No.1, therefore, prayed for
fixing the liability on the insurer to pay the compensation. On the other
hand, the respondent No.2 denied all the allegations and put the claimant
as well as the respondent No.1 in strict proof of their respective claim.
[6]
On the basis of the pleadings and after hearing the parties, the
following issues were framed :
(i) Whether the claimant petitioner namely, Manoranjan
Debnath sustained any kind of injury in a vehicular
accident occurred on 14.09.2014 at about 7 pm near
Lembucherra School Chowmuhani on MohanpurPulakona Road under Ranirbazar police station due to
rash and negligent driving of the motor vehicle bearing
No.TR01-U-1770(Truck) by its driver?
(ii) Whether the claimant petitioner is entitle to get ay
compensation due to the said injury, f so what would be
quantum of compensation and who shall be held liable
to pay of the same?
(iii) What other relief/reliefs are the parties entitled to?
[7]
To establish the claim, the claimant examined two witnesses
including the petitioner himself as P.W.1 and Dr. D.B. Roy as P.W.2 and
proved the documents produced by him. On the other hand, the respondent
No.1 examined himself as a sole witness. He also proved the certificate of
registration of the truck, driving license of Swapan Debnath, insurance
policy etc. No evidence was adduced by the respondent No.2.
[8]
The learned Tribunal after framing the issues and appreciating
the evidence on record, awarded a sum of Rs.1,31,000/- as compensation to
the claimant. He observed that since the claimant was admitted in GBP
hospital for about 20 days, Rs.10,000/- was awarded towards medical
expenditure. Since there was no evidence to substantiate that the claimant
has lost his working capacity, the Tribunal further awarded a sum of
Rs.40,000/- to the claimant for disability sustained in the accident. The
learned Tribunal found no cogent evidence with regard to income of the
claimant. Hence, he awarded to the claimant a sum of Rs.6,000/- per month
as an unskilled labourer. A further sum of Rs.36,000/- was awarded
towards loss of income and a lump sum amount of Rs.30,000/- was
awarded towards pain and suffering. He further added a sum of Rs.10,000/towards transportation, fooding, lodging and Rs. 5,000/- each was also
awarded towards medical attendant and litigation cost. The operative
portion of the judgment is reproduced hereunder :
“The claimant petitioner has proved documents showing
expenditure towards medical treatment only to the extent of
Rs. 1,463/- vide Exhibit 4 series. He also stated to have
undergone surgery of his right leg and thereby became
disabled to the extent of 20%. The Disability Certificate
was also proved by the PW 2 Dr. D.B. Roy. So, considering
the above circumstances including the fact that the claimant
petitioner was admitted to hospital for about 20 days I find
it appropriate to award a sum of Rs. 10,000/- towards
medical expenditure. 20% disability cannot be taken to be
disability to the extent of 100%. That apart, there is nothing
in the evidence on record to indicate that the claimant
petitioner has lost his working capability. In view of this
matter, a sum of Rs. 40,000/- is found to be reasonable for
becoming disabled. In the circumstances pertaining to
suffering injuries and the period of admission in the hospital
it can be said that the claimant petitioner could not have
attend his normal duties for six months. There is no cogent
evidence in regard to the income of the claimant petitioner.
So, we find it appropriate to hold the income of the claimant
petitioner Rs. 6000/- per month as an unskilled labourer. So,
a sum of Rs. 36,000/- is also found to be reasonable towards
loss of income. A lump sum amount of
Rs. 30,000/is also found appropriate towards pain and sufferings. I also
find it appropriate to award a sum of Rs. 10,000/- towards
transportation, fooding, lodging etc. A sum of Rs. 5,000/each towards medical attendant and litigation cost is also
found to be reasonable.
In view of the discussion the total compensation comes to
Rs.10,000/- + 40,000/- + 36,000/- + 30,000/- + 10,000/- +
5,000/- = Rs.1,31,000/-.
Now coming to the question of liability, it appears from the
record that the offending vehicle involved in the accident
was duly insured with the OP No.2 (Cholamnadalam MS
General Insurance Company Ltd.) vide Ext. D to D(i). It
follows therefore, the OP No.2 being the insurer is liable to
pay the compensation to the claimant petitioner.
All the issues accordingly stand answered to the context as
indicated herein above. In the result, claim is awarded in
following terms:Claimant petitioner is entitled to get the award of
Rs.1,31,000/- (Rupees one lac thirty one thousand) only
with 9% Simple interest per annum from the date of
registration of claim i.e. w.e.f. 08.03.2016 till the date of
realization thereof.
The OP No.2, Cholamandalam MS General Insurance
Company Ltd. shall, within 30 days of the date of this
award, deposit the entire amount as awarded, in favour of
the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, West Tripura,
Agartala.”
[9]
Mr. B. Nath, learned counsel appearing for the appellant
submits that the impugned judgment and award suffers from serious
illegality as the learned Tribunal erred in calculating the monthly income of
the injured amounting to Rs.6,000/- per month as a skilled labourer. The
learned Tribunal ought to have awarded the income of the claimant at
Rs.15,000/- per month and also the Tribunal failed to appreciate the fact
that the appellant herein has become permanently disabled insofar as his
occupation is concerned. The Tribunal also did not consider the decision of
the Apex Court reported in 1976 ACJ 141 (SC). He further contends that
the compensation awarded in favour of the claimant is not just proper.
Subsequently, he prays for enhancement of compensation awarded by the
learned Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, West Tripura, Agartala
dated 20.11.2021 in T.S.(MAC) 47 of 2016.
[10]
On the other hand, Ms. R. Purkayastha, learned counsel
appearing on behalf of Mr. Rajib Saha, learned counsel for the respondentinsurer strongly opposed the appeal contending that the learned Tribunal
did not commit any error in passing the award. The learned Tribunal passed
the award after appreciating the evidence on record. Accordingly, she prays
for dismissal of the appeal filed by the appellant.
[11]
After hearing the learned counsel for the respective parties,
this Court is of the considered view that the learned Tribunal did not
commit any error in passing the award. The learned Tribunal has correctly
come to the conclusion and awarded the compensation in favour of the
claimant after appreciating evidence on record and no interference is
required in the award passed by the learned Tribunal.
[12]
Accordingly, the present appeal filed by the appellant is
dismissed and the award dated 20.11.2021 passed by the learned Member,
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, West Tripura, Agartala in T.S(MAC) No.
47 of 2016 is affirmed. Send down the LCRs forthwith.
[13]
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
Dipesh
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review