Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
CRP No.10 of 2024
Sri Manoranjan Debnath & others
......... Petitioner(s);
Versus
Sri Dulal Debnath & others
.........Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. D. Deb, Advocate,
Mr. D. Debnath, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
:
None.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
Order
08/02/2024
Heard Mr. D. Deb, learned counsel for the petitioners.
2.
Petitioners are the proforma-defendants in Title Suit No.75/2021.
The suit has been instituted by the plaintiff/respondent No.1 against the
defendants-legal heirs of late Iman Uddin Chowdhury, the owner of the suit land
as recorded in khatian No.283/1, 283/2 and 283/3 for declaration of his title by
adverse possession and for confirmation of possession and perpetual injunction
with other consequential reliefs. Plaintiff/respondent No.1 filed Civil Misc.(Inj)
No.50/2021 seeking temporary injunction/ad-interim injunction restraining the
defendant-O.P.s, their men and agents from entering the suit land and not to
disturb the possession of the plaintiff-petitioner on the suit land.
3.
The Trial Court of learned Civil Judge (Sr. Div.), Court No.2, West
Tripura, Agartala granted temporary injunction by order dated 07.02.2022 by
which the principal defendants-O.P.s, their men and agents were restrained from
entering into the suit land and/or interfering with the peaceful possession of the
plaintiff over the suit land. The proforma-defendants i.e. the petitioners herein
thereafter preferred a CM Appeal No.07/2022 before the Court of learned
Additional District Judge, Court No.2, West Tripura, Agartala under Order XLIII
Rule 1(r) of CPC on the ground that the appellants and the plaintiff were joint
owners and possessors of the suit land as per khatian. The learned Trial Court did
not consider the right by virtue of constructive possession of the appellants as
they, along with the plaintiff, were joint possessors of the suit land. The plaintiff
had filed the suit concealing the actual facts that the predecessor of the appellants
and the plaintiff namely Mahim Chandra Debnath was the actual owner of the suit
land and after his death, the appellants and plaintiff became the joint owners and
that possession of one owner amounted to possession of other owners. It was also
stated that the suit is not maintainable because a co-owner could not be permitted
to seek declaration of right, title, interest against other co-owners on the ground of
adverse possession. The plaintiff objected before the learned Appellate Court also
claiming that the learned Trial Court has found prima facie possession of the
plaintiff and also the balance of convenience lies in favour of him.
4.
The learned Appellate Court has discussed the bare facts of the case
of the parties which reveal that the plaintiff and the proforma-defendants No.3 to 6
i.e. the present petitioners were the sons and daughters of late Mahim Chandra
Debnath who died on 15.02.1985 and his wife also died on 01.03.2020. The
original owner of the suit land was one Iman Uddin Chowdhury who died long
back. During the lifetime of Iman Uddin Choudhury, the father of the plaintiff i.e.
Late Mahim Chandra Debnath forcibly entered into the suit land on 28.03.1966
with his elder son Haripada Debnath and after developing the land, came in
forceful possession of the suit land. Iman Uddin Chowdhury never resisted the
forceful possession of the plaintiff who was cultivating the suit land, earning
usufruct therefrom by harvesting the crops from 1966. In the year 1981 when Iman
Uddin Chowdhury along with his men tried to evict Mahim Chandra Debnath,
they failed. His sons never gave any objection about the forceful possession of the
suit land or sought to evict Mahim Chandra Debnath from the suit land. Such
forcible possession has also been recorded in the record of rights.
5.
The learned Appellate Court took note of the fact that after the death
of Mahim Chandra Debnath, the forceful possession of the suit land was continued
by his wife and sons, who were residing thereon by constructing dwelling house
and cultivating fishes on the pond and maintaining their livelihood. In the year
2020, the defendant-O.P.s approached the plaintiff with a revenue record showing
the name of the predecessor of the defendants and asked the plaintiff to vacate the
suit land, which he denied as they were in occupation for last 55 years. Plaintiff
further heard that the defendants in collusion with Sri Manoranjan Debnath i.e. the
petitioner herein, tried to forcibly dispossess them from the suit land which would
result in irreparable loss. Therefore, he prayed for a temporary injunction against
the defendant-O.P.s. The proforma-defendants/petitioners herein claim to be the
legal heirs of late Mahim Chandra Debnath and late Renubala Debnath, who were
possessing the suit land along with their family members including all sons and
daughters and after his death, his wife along with her sons and daughters
continued possession over the suit land. The petitioner-Manoranjan Debnath has
purchased some paddy lands adjacent to the suit land in the year 1993 and has also
been cultivating the same and constructed a building over the suit land in 1984. It
was also pleaded that all sons and daughters of Late Mahim Chandra Debnath
were frequently visiting their joint property i.e. the suit land. Therefore, the
proforma-defendants had a right to enjoy the ancestral property. They, therefore,
prayed for rejection of the prayer.
6.
The learned Appellate Court also took note of the case of the
appellants that Mahim Chandra Debnath had got the land including the suit land in
exchange with Iman Uddin Chowdhury, but because of non-availability of original
deed of exchange, the record of right in the name of Mahim Chandra Debnath
could not be prepared. The learned Appellate Court held that since there was no
denial about the possession of the plaintiff over the suit land, he should be
protected from any kind of disturbance or interference. The question of
constructive possession of the appellants could be proved during the trial. There
was no record of right in the name of Mahim Chandra Debnath and the original
deed of exchange was also not available which the appellants/petitioners herein
had to prove. Therefore, the Appellate Court came to the conclusion that the
plaintiff had been able to establish a prima facie case of possession which is also
accepted by the appellants/petitioners herein, and were thus entitled to injunction
as the balance of convenience lied in their favour and any disposession during
pendency of the suit would result in irreparable injury to him. The proformadefendants/appellants/petitioners herein, being aggrieved by the impugned order
passed by the learned Appellate Court in CM Appeal No.07/2022 have approached
this Court under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
7.
Mr. D. Deb, learned counsel for the petitioners, submits that the
petitioners are not only a co-owner but also are in adverse possession over the
original owner Iman Uddin Chowdhury and constructively possessing the suit land
along with the plaintiff. The plaintiff has sought injunction to claim exclusive
possession of the suit land which he does not own or possess by virtue of any title.
The declaration of title through adverse possession has to be established and the
proforma-defendants/petitioners herein have objected to the exclusive possession
of the plaintiff through their written statement. As such, the case of the plaintiff
that he was in exclusive possession of the suit land is not correct. Therefore, there
was no prima facie case in his favour to allow injunction. Both the learned Trial
Court and the Appellate Court have, therefore, erred in law in granting temporary
injunction in his favour.
8.
I have considered the submission of learned counsel for the
petitioners and taken note of the relevant facts from the pleadings on record. I have
also gone through the impugned order dated 07.02.2022 passed by the learned
Trial Court on the injunction petition and the appellate order dated 11.08.2023
under challenge herein.
The suit for declaration of title on the basis of adverse possession and
confirmation of possession with perpetual injunction is directed against the legal
heirs of late Iman Uddin Chowdhury. Petitioners herein are the proformadefendants who also claim to be the legal heirs of the common ancestors i.e.
Mahim Chandra Debnath from which the plaintiff also claims inheritance. The
revenue records are in the name of the contesting defendants i.e. legal heris of
Iman Uddin Chowdhury from whom the father of the plaintiff, Mahim Chandra
Debnath is said to have got forceful possession over the suit land since 1966. Both
the learned Trial Court and the Appellate Court appear to have taken note of the
fact that the possession of the plaintiff is not in dispute, but the proformadefendants, who are the petitioners herein, claim to be in constructive possession
of the suit land and also assert title through adverse possession over the suit land.
However, constructive possession is a matter of proof during trial and the physical
possession of the suit land in favour of the plaintiff is not being disputed even by
the petitioners herein. The learned Trial Court and the Appellate Court have
thought it proper to protect the possession of the suit land in favour of the plaintiff
till disposal of the suit by grant of temporary injunction finding a prime facie case
in his favour. Moreover, the proforma-defendants do not seem to have set up a
case to claim title through adverse possession like the plaintiff, which they could
have raised independently or through a counter claim in the instant suit. If the
possession of the plaintiff is not in dispute, the findings of the learned Trial Court
as affirmed in appeal that the plaintiff has a prima facie case for grant of interim
injunction, which if not granted, could cause irreparable injury, cannot be said to
be such an error of jurisdiction which can be gone into by this Court in its
supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
9.
Needless to say, the trial of the suit is underway and the petitioners
herein would get an opportunity to adduce evidence as per the case set up through
the written statement. However, this Court does not find any grounds made out to
interfere in the order of temporary injunction granted in favour of the plaintiff by
the learned Trial Court as affirmed in appeal by the impugned order dated
11.08.2023 passed in CM Appeal No.07/2022 by the learned Additional District
Judge, Court No.2, West Tripura, Agartala.
10.
The instant petition is accordingly dismissed. Pending application(s),
if any, shall stand disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
SIDDHARTHA LODH LODH
Date: 2024.02.21 17:08:07 +05'30'
Pijush/
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review