Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA 06 of 2022
Sri Manindra Debnath,
son of late Man Mohan Debnath,
resident of Joypur, P.O. Agartala,
P.S. West Tripura, District : West Tripura
---- Plaintiff-Appellant(s)
Versus
Sri Ajit Goswami,
son of late Kalipada Goswami,
resident of Joypur, P.O. Agartala,
P.S. West Agartala
----Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. Raju Datta, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. H.K. Bhowmik, Adv.
Date of Hearing
:
06.03.2024
Date of Judgment
& Order
:
13.03.2024
Whether fit for
reporting
:
YES
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
Heard Mr. Raju Datta, Learned counsel appearing for the
appellant-plaintiff as well as Mr. H.K. Bhowmik, Learned counsel
appearing for the respondent-defendant.
2.
This appeal has been filed under Section 100 of CPC
challenging the judgment dated 23.08.2021 delivered by Learned
District Judge, West Tripura, Agartala in connection with Title Appeal
No.30 of 2018. By the said judgment, the Learned District Judge
affirmed the judgment and decree dated 26.07.2018 delivered by
Learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Court No.2, West Tripura,
Agartala in connection with Case No.Title Suit No.51 of 2015.
3.
Before proceeding with the merit of the appeal, let was
revisit the subject matter of dispute cropped up amongst the parties.
The present appellant as plaintiff filed a suit before the Court of
Learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Court No.2, West Tripura,
Agartala seeking a decree of declaration of right, title and interest
over the suit land as mentioned in Schedule-A of the plaint and also a
decree for recovery of possession over the suit land as mentioned in
Schedule-B of the plaint. According to the appellant-plaintiff on
11.02.1997 the plaintiff purchased land measuring 0.20 acres i.e. 10
gandas vide registered Sale Deed bearing No.1-840 dated 11.02.1997
from one Sukumar Debnath and got possession of the same and was
enjoying the said land by way of cultivation. He also got finally
published khatian for the said land. The respondent-defendant having
adjacent land to the plaintiff on 07.07.2013 at about 9.00 a.m. along
with some other persons created obstruction against the appellantplaintiff and did not allow him to enter into his land and forcefully took
possession of land measuring 3 gandas and 2 karas as mentioned in
Schedule-B of the plaint. Thereafter, in the 3rd week of August, 2013
and in the 1st week of July, 2014 and on 10.05.2015 when the
appellant-plaintiff again tried to enter into the suit land that time
again the respondent-defendant raised obstruction and lastly on
07.06.2015
the
appellant-plaintiff
noticed
that
the
respondent-
defendant was making preparation for digging a pond therein.
4.
The respondent-defendant contested the suit by filing
written statement wherein he asserted that the appellant-plaintiff
purchased 10 gandas of land and on the same day he also purchased
25 gandas of land from the said vendor and both the lands are
adjacent to each other. But the plaintiff actually got possession of 6
gandas 2 karas of land and the remaining 3 gandas and 2 karas of
land covered under C/S Plot No.4910(P) was recorded in the name of
State P.W.D. Department in khatian No.6/29. It was further asserted
that in the year 1967 by notification dated 26.06.1967 the State
Government acquired some portion of land along with other lands
from the different joteders including land measuring 3 gandas 2 karas
appertaining to C/S Plot No.4910(P) which was mentioned in
Schedule-B of the plaint but said 3 gandas 2 karas according to the
respondent-defendant already acquired by the State Government. It
was further asserted that he is in possession of 25 gandas of land and
he never acquired any portion of land belonging to the appellantplaintiff. Hence, he prayed for dismissal of the suit with costs. Upon
the pleadings of the parties following issues were framed by the
Learned Trial Court below.
(i) Is the suit maintainable in its present form and
nature ?
(ii) Whether the plaintiff has right, title and interest
over the suit land?
(iii) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to the decree for
declaration of the title and recovery of khash possession
of the suit land?
5.
To substantiate the issues, both the parties have adduced
oral/documentary evidence on record:
“A) Name of the plaintiff-appellant‟s Witnesses :PW-1- Shri Manindra Debnath
PW-2- Tinku Debnath
PW-3- Ajit Debnath
B) Plaintiff‟s Exhibits :
1) Original Sale Deed vide No.1-840 dated 11.02.1997
(in 3 sheets) marked as Exbt.1.
2) Exbt.2- Original Khatian vide No.6860, 2321, 2914/1,
2914/2, 2914/3, 2914/4 and 2914/5 of MoujaRamnagar, marked as Exbts.2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 & 8.
3) Original Hal Maps dated 23.12.2014 and 20.04.2015
marked as Exbt.9 & 10.
C) Defendant‟s Witnesses :-
DW-1- Shri Ajit Goswami
DW-2- Sukumar Debnath
DW-3- Md. Abu Taher Miah
D) Defendant‟s Exhibits :1) Original registered Sale Deed vide no.1-839 dated
11.02.1997 in 5 sheets marked as Exbt.A/1 to A/5.
2) Computerized khatian vide no.5449 of MoujaRamnagar marked as Exbt.B.
3) Computerized Khatian vide No.6/29 of MoujaRamnagar marked as Exbt.C.
4) Notification of Govt. of Tripura dated 26.06.1967 in 3
sheets marked as Exbt.D/1 to D/3.”
6.
Finally, on conclusion of the trial and also after hearing of
argument of both the sides Learned Trial Court below by judgment
dated 26.07.2018 dismissed the suit of the appellant-plaintiff. The
operative portion of the judgment dated 26.07.2018 runs as follows :
“In the result, the suit is dismissed on contest without
cost.
Accordingly, plaintiff is not entitled to the decree for
declaration of title and recovery of khash possession of
the suit land in the suit.
So, the suit is hereby disposed of without cost.”
7.
Challenging
the
judgment,
the
plaintiff-appellant
preferred an appeal under Section 96 of CPC before the Court of
Learned District Judge, West Tripura, Agartala and the Learned
District Judge, West Tripura, Agartala after hearing arguments of both
the sides vide judgment dated 23.08.2021 also dismissed the appeal
of the appellant-plaintiff upholding the judgment of Learned Trial
Court. For the sake of convenience, the operative portion of judgment
and order of the Learned First Appellant Court is mentioned herein
below :
“So far claim of the plaintiff-appellant that the
defendant-respondent dispossessed him from the suit
land as shown in Schedule-„B‟, the same is not
sustainable as there is no evidence to establish the said
plea and the defendant-respondent has successfully
placed before the Ld. Trial Court that he is in possession
of 25 gandas of land, which he purchased from said
Sukumar Debnath.
In view of the aforesaid findings, I find no error in the
impugned judgment and decree of the Ld. Trial Court
passed in T.S. 51 of 2015.
Accordingly, this Title Appeal is dismissed.
The judgment and decree dated 26th July, 2018, passed
by Ld. Civil Judge (Sr. Division), Court No.2, West
Tripura, Agartala is upheld and affirmed.
Prepare the decree accordingly.
This Title Appeal stands disposed of on contest with
cost.”
8.
Being aggrieved with the judgment, the said appellant
again preferred this second appeal under Section 100 of CPC before
the High Court. At the time of admission of appeal by order dated
03.02.2022 following substantial question of law was formulated:
“(I) Whether the learned Trial Court and the Appellate
Court are justified in giving a finding without framing an
issue and under apprehension without there being no
evidence with regard to whether the Government has
acquired the portion of land which is the subject matter
of the dispute ?”
9.
In course of hearing of arguments, Mr. Raju Datta,
Learned counsel appearing for the appellant-plaintiff submitted that
both the Court’s below did not consider for holding survey commission
for identification of the disputed property for which both the Learned
Courts below committed serious error in deciding the issue and
ultimately dismissed the suit and the appeal of the appellant.
10.
Learned
counsel
for
the
appellant-plaintiff
further
submitted that without considering the documentary evidence on
record just on the basis of oral evidence dismissed the suit of the
plaintiff. So, Learned counsel urged for setting aside the judgment of
the First Appellate Court and submitted for remanding back the case
record to the Learned
Trial Court for appointment of survey
commissioner for identification of the suit land.
11.
On the other hand, Mr. H.K. Bhowmik, Learned counsel
appearing for the respondent submitted that both the Learned Courts
below gave concurrent findings and there is no perversity in the
judgment of the First Appellate Court because according to Learned
counsel, all though the appellant-plaintiff purchased 10 gandas of land
by registered deed of instrument but practically he got possession of
lesser quantum of land. So, just to occupy the land of the respondentdefendant he has filed this fabricated suit.
12.
Learned counsel further submitted that the Learned trial
Court below after considering the oral and documentary evidence on
record dismissed the suit and the Learned First Appellate Court also
after hearing both the sides came to the observation that there was
no merit in the appeal filed by the appellant for which the Learned
First Appellate Court dismissed the appeal upholding the judgment of
Learned Trial Court.
Considered.
13.
I have heard detailed argument of both the sides and
gone through the records of Learned Court below including the oral
and documentary evidence on record. Admittedly, in this case, the
appellant-plaintiff and the respondent-defendant purchased land from
the common vendor namely Sukumar Debnath. The appellant-plaintiff
purchased land measuring 20 satak (10 gandas) and the respondentdefendant purchased land measuring 50 satak (25 gandas).
14.
Now, if we go through the title deeds of both the rival
parties it appears that at the time of execution of sale deed the
original vendor in his recital specifically stated that from land
measuring 77 satak he has disposed of land measuring 20 satak (10
gandas) to the appellant-plaintiff and sold land measuring 25 gandas
to the respondent-defendant. If it is so, then still he had left 7 more
sataks in his record. The appellant-plaintiff before the Trial Court
produced Exbt.2 from which it appears that those purchased land has
been recorded in the khatian during draft publication and also during
the final publication of record of rights.
15.
Now, if we go through the documentary evidence on
record of the respondent-defendant it appears that all though he
purchased 25 gandas i.e. 50 sataks of land but initially, he got
mutation for land measuring 43 sataks and for remaining land
measuring 7 sataks he had filed one petition before the Learned
District Collector, West Tripura, Agartala under Section 95 of TLR & LR
Act and by order dated 29.05.2015 Learned District Collector passed
an order for correction of record deducting land measuring 7 sataks
from the khatian bearing No.2321 of the appellant-plaintiff from the
Survey plot No.7126/9587. But the appellant-plaintiff in his pleading
did not submit anything nor took any step for making District Collector
as party in the suit.
16.
There is also no conclusive evidence on record that he
took any step for correction of record for the land measuring 7 sataks
which was deducted from his khatian. Rather, from the oral evidence
it appears that all though he has purchased 10 gandas of land but he
got possession only for land measuring 6 gandas and 2 karas only and
the remaining 3 gandas and 2 karas of land was either entered in the
‘Nayonjoli’ which was acquired by the Government or the same still
lies under the possession of original vendor Sukumar Debnath
because the respondent-defendant in his pleading or by his evidence
specifically stated that he is possessing his purchased land and he
does not have any claim land beyond his purchased land. There is also
no evidence on record that the respondent-defendant is possessing
any other land beyond his purchased land. In a suit for dispossession,
the plaintiff should always prove that he was in possession of a
particular land from which he was dispossessed.
17.
Here in this case, before the Learned Court all though the
appellant-plaintiff stated that he purchased land measuring 10 gandas
from said Sukumar Debnath but failed to prove that he got possession
over the suit land as mentioned in Schedule-B from which he was
dispossessed by the defendant.
18.
Situated thus, both the Learned Courts below came to the
findings that the appellant-plaintiff is not entitled to relief for recovery
of possession as mentioned in Schedule-B of the plaint. As already
stated, the respondent-defendant did not deny the right, title and
interest of the appellant-plaintiff in respect of 6 gandas 2 karas land
but he submitted that remaining 3 gandas 2 karas land was acquired
by the State Government. It is on record that in the year 1967, some
portion of land was acquired by the Government for the purpose of
embankment or ‘Nayonjoli’ from original Plot No.4910(P), along with
other lands of different jote holders. Still a question will remain as to
whether any land of the appellant-plaintiff has been acquired by the
Government or not or 7 sataks land which discussed to have been not
available within the purchased land of the appellant-plaintiff, in that
case the same may still remain under the possession of the original
vendor Sukumar Debnath. In this regard, none of the Courts below
gave any findings, nor even the parties of the suit specifically the
appellant-plaintiff highlighted anything before the Learned Court
below. Because from 77 sataks of land, in respect of original plot
No.4910, if any land is acquired from the original C/S plot, in that
case, the same might have acquired either from the land of present
appellant-plaintiff or from the original jotedar, Sukumar Debnath. In
the given case, Sukumar Debnath hold 77 sataks of land in the
aforesaid plot No.4910 and from that, he has disposed of 70 sataks
(20 + 50) sataks to the parties of this appeal. So, naturally, he should
have left 7 sataks of land with him. But the present appellant-plaintiff,
all though, purchased 20 sataks of land from said Sukumar Debnath
but he is possessing 13 sataks of land. Meaning thereby, he got only
possession of 13 sataks out of 20 sataks and the rest 7 sataks of his
land has been entered in the ‘Nayonjoli’ and the original owner might
have handed over possession of the said acquired land i.e. 7 sataks +
13 sataks in total 20 sataks keeping rest land measuring 7 sataks with
him, for which the appellant-plaintiff shall have the liberty to take
recourse of law against said Sukumar Debnath because there is no
evidence
on
record
that
the
appellant-plaintiff
got
any
award/compensation for acquisition of land. Rather, there is evidence
on record that as per notification of the year 1967 notice was issued
to Sukumar Debnath and by this time, he might have received the
award/compensation from the authority.
19.
Under the facts and circumstances of the given case
considering the evidence on record it appears to me that the Learned
Trial Court below rightly dismissed the suit of the appellant-plaintiff
for want of proper evidence on record and also the Learned First
Appellate Court after appreciating the evidence on record rightly and
reasonably uphold the judgment of the Learned Trial Court.
20.
Thus, I find no infirmity in the judgment passed by First
Appellate Court and thus the substantial question of law is accordingly
answered.
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant-plaintiff
stands dismissed being devoid of merit and the judgment dated
23.08.2021 passed in Title Appeal No.30 of 2018 by the Learned
District Judge, West Tripura, Agartala confirming the judgment dated
26.07.2018 delivered by Learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Court
No.2, West Tripura, Agartala in connection with Case No.Title Suit
No.51 of 2015 is hereby upheld and accordingly it is affirmed.
Prepare the decree accordingly.
Send down the LCRs forthwith with copy of judgment.
JUDGE
SABYASACHI BHATTACHARJEE
Date: 2024.03.16 14:05:28
+05'30'
Sabyasachi B
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review