Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
A.B.No.22 of 2023
For Petitioner(s)
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Mr. S. Lodh, Advocate.
Mr. S. Debnath, Addl. P.P.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
_O_ R_ D_ E_ R_
11/09/2023
Heard Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner.
Also heard Mr. S. Debnath, learned Addl. Public Prosecutor appearing for the
respondent-State.
[2]
This is an application filed under Section-438 of Cr. P.C. for
granting anticipatory bail to the accused-person who is wanted in connection with
West Agartala P.S. crime No.2023WAG122 registered under Sections-341, 506
and 34 of the IPC & Section-25 of the Arms Act.
[3]
The facts in brief are that, in the last election of TCA, which was
held on 21.10.2022, the panel of the informant lost in all posts except the post of
President. After losing the election, the informant and his other associates started
mischievous activities against the present body of TCA by alleging false and
concocted stories and tried to create chaos in various ways. As they lost the
election, the informant and his other associates tried to harass the applicant and his
associates in various ways, and lastly, the informant lodged this false case against
the applicant being West Agartala PS Case No. 2023 WAG 122, dated 23.07.2023,
registered under sections 341,506 and 34 of the Indian Penal Code & Section 25 of
Arms Act.
[4]
Apprehending arrest in connection with the instant case, the
applicant filed one present application before this Court, and the same was
registered and marked as AB 17/2023, and vide order dared 10.08.2023, the same
was rejected. The wife of the applicant fell ill, and for better treatment, she is
required to be taken outside the State and presence of the applicant is urgently
required hence, the applicant has filed the present pre-arrest bail application.
[5]
Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel appearing for the accused-petitioner
has submitted that the applicant is an elected Councilor of Apex Council of
Tripura Cricket Association (TCA for short) for the Session 2022-25. The result of
the election was declared by the Electoral Officer of TCA vide Memo dated
21.10.2022. It is further stated that till date neither he resigned from the post of
Councilor of Apex Council of TCA nor he has been declared as disqualified for
holding the post of Councilor of TCA.
[6]
In the last election of TCA, which was held on 21.10.2022, there
were two panels, and the panel of the informant lost in all posts except the post of
President and the informant contested the election for the post of Secretary. After
losing the election, the informant and his other associates started mischievous
activities against the present body of TCA by alleging false and concocted stories
and also tried to create chaos in various ways. As they lost the election, the
informant and his other associates tried to harass the applicant and his associates in
various ways, and lastly, the informant lodged this false case against the applicant
with some mala fide intention.
[7]
The Registrar of Societies, Government of Tripura, received a
complaint from Sri Prasanta Roy, Ex-Cricketer, whereby Sri Roy, alleged that as
Sri Tapan Lodh, selected as nominated Councilor of Agartala Municipal
Corporation, he is dis-qualified to hold the chair of President of TCA, and on
receipt of the same, the Registrar of Societies, vide its letter dated 15.06.2023
sought for clarification on the alleged matter, and on receipt of the same, the TCA
decided to sit in an emergent meeting of Apex Council in terms of Clause 15(7) of
the Memorandum & Rules of Tripura Cricket Association (here-in- after called as
the TCA Rules"), and accordingly, the honorary Secretary of TCA vide notice
dated 15.07.2023 fixed the meeting on 19.07.2023 at 11:00 am in the Conference
Hall of Head Office of TCA. On 19.07.2023 some miscreants under the instigation
of Sri Tapan Lodh and the informant of the instant case and others blocked the
gate of Head Office of the TCA and did not allow the Apex Council members and
the office staffs of TCA to enter into the Head Office of TCA and while the
applicant and other Apex Council members tried to enter into the TCA Head
Office, they threatened them with dire consequences.
[8]
It has been further submitted that on 21.07.2023, the Officer-in-
Charge of West Agartala PS vide his letter dated 21.07.2023 gave a requisition so
the Sub Divisional Magistrate, Sadar alleging that Sri Jayanta Dey, Joint Secretary
of TCA, Sri Tapan Lodh and others approached him and wanted assistance for
opening the TCA office. They told the Officer-in-Charge that the Secretary
illegally affixed an office order stating that TCA office should remain closed and
took the keys of the office. For opening the TCA office, he requested the SDM,
Sadar for deputing an Executive Magistrate, and in furtherance thereof, the DCM,
Sadar came there and the locks of the TCA office were broken and thereafter said
Tapan Lodh claiming himself as President, TCA, took possession of office
chambers of President and Joint Secretary, and by a written note dated 21.07.2023
he acknowledged the same which was also confirmed by the DCM, Sadar.
[9]
It may be mentioned herein that neither the Officer-in- Charge, West
Agartala PS nor the SDM, Sadar, have jurisdiction to break the keys of TCA office
and hand over the office chambers to said Tapan Lodh and others. It is further
stated that the Officer-in-Charge, West Agartala PS, and the SDM, Sadar did not
take any step to protect the property of TCA rather they most illegally broke the
keys of the TCA office and banded over the same to some unauthorized persons. It
is further stated that Jayanta Dey, Joint Secretary of TCA was present in the
meeting of the Apex Council.
[10]
TCA alongwith the Vice-President of TCA and other Apex Council
members including the applicant went to TCA Head office and while they were
entering into TCA office premise, some anti-social elements being abated by Sri
Tapan Lodh, Sri Jayanta Dey and others, prevented the applicant and others from
entering into the Head Office of TCA, and lastly, they were assaulted by those
anti-socials. It may be mentioned herein that prior to going to TCA office, they
first approached the Officer- in-Charge of West Agartala PS for providing security,
and in furtherance thereof, the Officer-in-Charge deployed some police personnel
along with them for entering into the TCA office, but in-front of the police
personnel, they were assaulted and abused with filthy languages, but police did not
take any action. Thereafter, the Secretary of TCA lodged a written complaint on
22.07.2023 before the Officer-in-Charge of West Agartala PS narrating the entire
incident, and on receipt of the same, police registered a case vide West Agartala
P.S. Case No.2023WAG 0120, dated 22.07.2023 under Sections-341,325,506 and
34 of IPC.
[11]
Per contra, learned Public Prosecutor, appearing for the State-
respondent contended that the petitioner is already a habitual offender and
admittedly, there are several criminal cases pending against him at the Court of
learned Judicial Magistrate 1st Class Belonia. He informed that prosecution has
taken step for cancellation of the bail application since he is on bail in the pretext
of the medical treatment in one case. Learned P.P. also submitted before this Court
that the case of the petitioner would fall under Section-25(1-A) of the Arms Act in
violation of Section-7.
[12]
He further contended that the arguments made by the petitioner with
regard to complaint and counter complaint are incorrect and thus, he prayed to
dismiss the bail application as the same is not maintainable. Further the petitioner
has not approached the Court below before approaching this Court. The petitioner
has approached this Court straightway and no special reasons have been indicated
in the pleadings as to why he has not approached the Sessions Court before
approaching the High Court.
[13]
In view of above and after overall discussion, this Court is of the
opinion that for final conclusion, it would be apposite to discuss the chronology of
the present case. Previously, the petition has approached before this Court for
granting pre-arrest bail and the Court after hearing learned counsel appearing for
the parties and having gone through the material evidence on record, vide order
dated 10.08.2023 has order as under:
“This present application has been filed under Section 438 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure seeking pre-arrest bail against the FIR No. Crime No.2023
WAG 122 which is registered against the petitioner herein under Section 341,
506 and 34 of the IPC & Section 25 of Arms Act. On the strength of the said
complaint dated 23.07.2023, it is indicating that the petitioner Sri Manik Lal
Das with the support of a firearms has threatened the complainant. Hence the
case against the petitioner as mentioned here-in-above.
[2] Heard Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel assisted by Mr. K. Roy, learned
counsel appearing for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. Ratan Datta, learned PP
assisted by Mr. S. Debnath, learned Addl. PP representing the Staterespondent.
[3] Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel appearing for the accused-petitioner herein
submits before this Court that his case under Section 438 of the Cr.P.C. needs
to be considered as the complaint filed against the petitioner herein is only an
afterthought and a counterblast complaint. Since a person supporting the
accused-petitioner herein has filed a complaint on 22.07.2023, the present
compliant has been filed as a counterblast compliant. Further on legal position,
learned counsel indicated that the case of the petitioner falls for violation of
Section 3 of the Arms Act and under Sub-Section 25(1-B)(a) and as such, his
case may be considered for granting bail since the punishment would be up to
3 years.
[4] He further relied on Para-63 of the latest judgment of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court reported in AIR 2022 SC 3386 titled as Satendra Kumar Antil
Vs. Central Bureau of Investigation and anr., which is reproduced here-inunder:“63. We have already dealt with the relevant provisions which
would take care of categories A and B. At the cost of repetition, we wish to
state that, in category A, one would expect a better exercise of discretion on
the part of the court in favour of the accused. Coming to category B, these
cases will have to be dealt with on a case-to-case basis again keeping in view
the general principle of law and the provisions, as discussed by us.”
[5] Learned counsel relying upon para-63 of the Satender Kumar Antil
(supra) submitted that his case falls under Category A of cases and prayed
before this Court to grant the present anticipatory bail application.
[6] Per contra, learned Public Prosecutor, appearing for the State-respondent
contended that the petitioner is already a habitual offender and admittedly,
there are several criminal cases pending against him at the Court of learned
Judicial Magistrate 1st Class Belonia. He informed that prosecution has taken
step for cancellation of the bail application since he is on bail in the pretext of
the medical treatment in one case. Learned P.P. also submitted before this
Court that the case of the petitioner would fall under Section-25(1-A) of the
Arms Act in violation of Section-7. He further contended that the arguments
made by the petitioner with regard to complaint and counter complaint are
incorrect and thus, he prayed to dismiss the bail application as the same is not
maintainable. Further the petitioner has not approached the Court below before
approaching this Court. The petitioner has approached this Court straightway
and no special reasons have been indicated in the pleadings as to why he has
not approached the Sessions Court before approaching the High Court and in
this regard, learned PP has also placed his reliance in a judgment of the
Allahabad High Court in Harendra Singh @ Harendra Bahadur Vs The State
of UP in Criminal Misc. Application No.6478 of 2019 (Bail) wherein it has
been held thus:
16. In a decision reported in 1983(2) KLJ 8 in the case of K.C. Iyya Vs. State
of Karnataka, the High Court of Karnataka has observed
"7. Since both the Courts, the Court of Sessions and this Court have concurrent
powers in the matter, it appears desirable, for more than one reason, that the
Sessions Court should be approached first in the matter.”
17. In the case of Shivasubramanyam Vs. State of Karnataka and another;
2002 CRL.LJ 1998, the Karnataka High Court re-iterated the abovesaid
principles and ultimately held that the application fed under Section 438 of
Cr.P.C. directly to the High Court is maintainable only under exceptional and
under special circumstances, but not as a routine and the party cannot come
before the Court as a matter of right.
18. By looking into the abovesaid discussions. I am of the opinion that the
party has to approach the Sessions Court first and then he has to approach the
High Court which is the normal course. But the courts have also observed that
in extraordinary circumstances with special reasons, the party can also
approach the High Court. The High Court cannot entertain Section 438 of
Cr.P.C. as a matter of routine without examining whether there are any special
reasons or special circumstances to entertain the said application.
19. In the case of Sri Kwmta Gwra Brahma Vs. State of Assam (Bail No.3024
of 2014), The Gauhati High Court has also expressed similar view and held
that the party has to approach the Court of Sessions first under Section 438 of
Cr.P.C. and he can later approach the High Court.
20. The intention of bringing out Section 438 of Cr.P.C. is enabling each and
every person in the country if under extraordinary circumstances under
exigencies either to approach the Court of Sessions or the High Court which
can be concurrently exercised by both the courts. Though such remedy, cannot
be riddled down by imposing any extraordinary condition but still the Court
can refuse to entertain the bail petition and direct the party to approach the
Court of Sessions first because Section 438 of Cr.P.C. shall not be exercised as
a matter of right by the party, though it can be invoked either before the
Sessions Court or before the High Court. It is purely the discretionary power
of the Court to exercise power depending upon the facts and circumstances of
each case. Therefore, the High Court can direct the party to go first before the
Court of Sessions and then come to the High Court though there is no embargo
under the statute itself, but the Court can do so on the basis of various factors.
21. It is worth to note here that whenever the concurrent jurisdiction is vested
under the statute simultaneously in two courts of one is superior to the other,
then it is appropriate that the party should apply to the subordinate Court first,
because the higher Court would have the advantage of considering the opinion
of the Sessions Court. Moreover, the party will get two opportunities to get the
remedy either before the Sessions Court or before the High Court but if once
he approaches the High Court, he would run the risk that, the other remedy is
not available to him if he failed to get the order in the High Court, he cannot
go before the Sessions Court for the same remedy. However, vice versa is
possible.
22. It is also to be notable that the Sessions Court will always be nearest and
accessible Court to the parties. Moreover, considering the work load of the
courts in the country, the superior courts particularly, the High Courts are
flooded with heavy pendency of cases. In order to facilitate the other parties
who come before the Court with other cases before the High Court (which has
got exclusive Jurisdiction) and also in order to provide alternative remedy to
the parties, it is just and necessary that the party shall first approach the
Sessions Court under Section 438 of Cr.P.C. so that the High Court can bestow
its precious time to deal with other pending cases which requires serious
attention and expeditious disposal, where the parties who have come to the
High Court after exhausting remedy before the Magistrate Court or the
Sessions Court for grant of bail and for other reliefs.
23. The grant of anticipatory bail or regular bail requires appreciation, scrutiny
of facts and after going through the entire materials on record. In that context,
if the Sessions Court has already applied its mind and passed the appropriate
order, it would be easy for the High Court to look into or have a cursory
glance of the observation made by the Sessions Court and dispose of the case,
with expedition.
24. It is also worth to note here that the Sessions Court and the High Court are
concurrently empowered to grant bail under Section 438 of Cr.P.C. The object
is that if the party who is residing in the remote area can directly approach the
Sessions Court which is easily accessible. In order to obviated the very object
and purpose, the party has to explain why he did not go to that Court.
Otherwise, it amounts to making that provision redundant, so far as the
Sessions Courts are concerned. Even once again re-looking into structure of
Section 438 of Cr.P.C., it is purely the discretionary power given to the Court
to entertain the Petition. It is the discretion given to the Courts to exercise that
power. When discretion vests with Court, the party has to explain why he has
come to the High Court directly, for the discretionary relief under the said
provision.
25. Therefore, looking to the abovesaid rulings of different High Courts, I do
not find any strong reason to deviate from the said view taken by the other
High Courts. Hence, I am of the opinion, the point formulated by me noted
above has to be answered accordingly.
26. Hence, I answer the point raised as follows:
"The bail application filed under Section 438 of Cr.P.C. is not maintainable
before the High Court without exhausting remedy before the Court of
Sessions, which has got concurrent jurisdiction. However, for extraneous or
special reasons, the High Court can also exercise such power for grant of the
remedy under the said provision."
[7] Heard the arguments made by both the sides and perused the evidence on
record.
[8] This Court is conscious that in the event if any opinion is expressed by
this Court on merits that would cause an infringement in the investigation for
either side. This is only a pre-arrest bail and the petitioner is already facing
two criminal cases against him and there are no reasonable grounds indicated
in the bail application as to why the anticipatory bail should be entertained
under Section 438 Cr.P.C. bypassing the Court of Sessions Judge.
[9] This Court is also conscious with regard to the fact that the petitioner is
having right under Section 438 of Cr.PC either to approach the High Court or
the Court of Sessions Judge. But this Court finds force in the submission of
learned P.P. and declines to interfere with granting anticipatory bail to Manik
Lal Das, i.e the accused-petitioner. The petitioner herein is directed to
surrender before the concerned Court on or before 18th August, 2023 and seek
appropriate relief by filing appropriate application. On filing of such
application, the concerned Court below shall consider the same on merits.
In the above terms, the present anticipatory bail application
stands dismissed.”
[14]
It reveals from the argument of the learned counsel appearing for the
parties that the order of the Court has not been complied with by the petitioner and
now, the present anticipatory bail application has been filed only on the ground
that h is wife is unwell and to this count one prescription has also been placed on
record. After perusal of the same, it is seen that there is no indication of serious
illness or any report of hospitalization. Without implementing the order of this
Court this present application is filed only on the ground as indicated above.
[15]
It becomes an obligation on the part of a law abiding citizen to
respect and obey the law of the land and the Court proceedings. Generally always
the arguments are advanced in writ petitions or in criminal cases saying the
respondent has violated doctrine of audi alterm partem and not followed procedure
contemplated under law and pray for indulgence. But it becomes equally necessary
to examine as to what accusation the citizen is facing and was he approached the
Court of law with clean hands.
[16]
In the backdrop of the allegations against citizen, it would be better
to decide whether he is entitled to raise such argument. Citizen also is equally
responsible to comply the requirements under the law. Law is not one sided as if
only respondents should follow. Even the citizen/petitioner should first make out a
prima facie case in his favour. A citizen cannot claim/plead equities, where he
himself is not following the due process of law. As a law abiding citizen, the
accused petitioner first ought to have appeared before the Court of law once
summons are issued at first stage and at second stage warrants are issued he ought
to have followed as contemplated under Cr. P.C.
[17]
This Court does not invite, warranting of discretionary powers Under
Section-438 of Cr. P.C. for granting anticipatory bail for an accused person who is
already facing criminal cases. In the earlier case investigation is still pending and
in the present case also the investigation is pending. This Court finds that there are
specific statements made against the accused-person. In view of the above, this
Court is of the considered opinion that the accused-person shall surrender before
the concerned Court having jurisdiction on or before 20.09.2023.
[18]
Accordingly, the instant anticipatory bail application stands
dismissed. Return the case diary.
JUDGE
A. Ghosh
ANJAN
GHOSH
ANJAN GHOSH
Date: 2023.09.14
12:56:47 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review