Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAT App. No.03 of 2025
Sri Litan Hrishi Das, age…… years
S/O Lt. Purna Chandra Hrishi Das, resident of Ambasa Colony, P.S. & P.O.
Ambassa, District Dhalai Tripura.
......Appellant(s)
VERSUS
Smt. Rupa Rudra Paul,
W/O Sri Litan Hrishi Das, D/O Sri Sunil Rudra Paul, Village of Dalak, Samatal
Para, P.S. & P.O. Amarpur, District Gomati Tripura.
......Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. Samar Das, Advocate.
Ms. Rashmi Bhattacharjee, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
:
Ms. Piyali Chakraborty, Advocate.
Date of hearing
:
20th November, 2025.
Date of delivery of Judgment
:
28th January, 2026.
Whether fit for reporting
:
YES
NO
√
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER
The appeal has been preferred by the appellant-petitioner
(husband) against the judgment dated 09.12.2024 passed by learned Judge,
Family Court, Ambassa, Dhalai in Title Suit (Divorce) No.01 of 2023 and
related decree drawn thereupon, whereby the petition of the appellant-petitioner
seeking divorce on the ground of cruelty and desertion was dismissed.
[2]
The petitioner filed petition seeking divorce, inter alia, asserting
that his marriage was solemnized with the respondent in the month of March,
2016 and on 02.11.2016, a son namely, Arjun Hrishi Das was born out of said
wedlock. But, after one year of the birth of a son, respondent started exhibiting
unusual behavior and became reluctant in performance of her matrimonial
duties. She would remain busy much of the time in calling and chatting with
some unknown persons. Even she refused to provide food to his old mother and
pressurized him for a separate stay from her mother-in-law. When the petitioner
denied, she became furious and refused to share bed with him. She would also
torture his mother. One day in the morning, she suddenly went elsewhere
without informing anybody, for which he lodged one missing person
information at the police station, but in the late night, she returned and on
asking she informed the petitioner that she was in an illicit relationship with
someone else.
[3]
It is also stated by him that on 21.01.2021, the respondent left the
matrimonial home, leaving her two-year-old son there without giving
intimation to the petitioner and ultimately, it was learnt by him that she went to
her paternal house at Amarpur. In the month of April, 2021, she returned to the
house of the petitioner followed by a meeting held in this regard and in the said
meeting, it was advised by the elders to them to lead a peaceful conjugal life
along with their child. But, there was no change in the behavior of the
respondent and even on the same day, she broke down all the furniture in the
house of the petitioner and on the next day, left for Amarpur again without any
intimation to him.
[4]
The petitioner, according to him, on several occasions requested
the respondent to join him and he also went to the house of the respondent on
different occasions but she did not return rather, once he was even beaten there
by the father of the respondent along with others.
[5]
He also filed one petition for restitution of conjugal rights and as
she was reluctant to join him, he ultimately withdrew the same. As there was no
hope for rejoining of respondent with him, he filed the petition for divorce both
on the grounds of cruelty and desertion.
[6]
The respondent in her written statement submitted that their
marriage was actually solemnized on 04.03.2018 and not in the year 2016. In
her matrimonial home, she would be tortured physically and mentally by the
petitioner and her mother on demand of money which her father, due to his
poverty, could not meet. Moreover, the petitioner also grew illicit relationship
with another lady and he pressurized her to allow said lady in his home. As she
did not agree, she was driven out from the house in the first week of May, 2021
and therefore, having no other alternative, she took shelter in the house of her
maternal uncle namely, Haru Paul of Ambassa. It is also grievance of the
respondent that thereafter, the petitioner never tried to make any
communication with her and though, several village level meetings were held in
presence of respectable persons of the locality, due to adamancy of the
petitioner, no settlement could be arrived at.
[7]
According to the respondent, she did not willfully leave her
matrimonial home; rather, she was forced to take shelter in her father’s house to
save her life and she was always ready to maintain her matrimonial
relationship.
[8]
In the trial, the petitioner submitted examination-in-chief on
affidavit of himself and six others but one witness namely, Kamala Rudrapal
did not appear to face cross-examination. He also proved his marriage
certificate as evidence. From the respondent side, the respondent and her father
were examined as witnesses. Finally, learned Trial Court dismissed the petition,
observing that there was no satisfactory evidence that the petitioner was
subjected to cruelty by the respondent. Learned Trial Court also arrived at the
conclusion that there was no element of animus deserendi on the part of the
respondent.
[9]
Mr. Samar Das, learned counsel for the petitioner argues that
learned Trial Court has failed to appreciate the evidence adduced from the side
of the petitioner and also has not properly appreciated the evidence of the
respondent, who in her cross-examination, admitted that her husband visited her
father’s house on few occasions to reconcile but was not successful as she did
not agree. Mr. Das, learned counsel also submits that though the respondent
alleged that she was tortured by her husband in her matrimonial home, no
document regarding institution of any criminal case against him was submitted
in the proceeding. According to learned counsel, all the witnesses of the
petitioner corroborated with each other on material particulars and therefore,
decree of divorce ought to have been granted in his favour by the learned Court
below.
[10]
Ms. Piyali Chakraborty, learned counsel of the respondent,
however, contends that the respondent was subjected to both mental and
physical torture on demand of money by the petitioner and his mother, and the
petitioner also developed an extra-marital relationship with another lady and
was pressurizing the respondent to accept her. Learned counsel also submits
that willfully the respondent did not leave her matrimonial home; rather, she
was driven out therefrom and as her life was not safe in her matrimonial home,
she did not further join the petitioner there. According to learned counsel, the
learned Trial Court was completely justified in rejecting the claim of the
petitioner.
[11]
We have considered the submissions of both sides and have also
gone through the evidence adduced by the parties in the proceeding.
[12]
As it appears, the examination-in-chief on affidavits submitted by
all the witnesses are the replica of what were stated by the petitioner in his
petition for divorce. Except PW-1 i.e. the petitioner and PW-2, his mother, all
other witnesses have claimed that they are the next-door neighbours of the
petitioner, but they did not clarify whether they have witnessed personally any
incident between the parties or they have heard it from someone else. Even they
have also contradicted the assertion of the petitioner made in his petition for
divorce to the effect that according to them, in the village meeting it was
advised by the local people to both the parties to stay separately and peacefully,
whereas according to the petitioner, they were advised to stay jointly and
peacefully. They have also stated the facts that the respondent would refuse to
provide food to the mother of the petitioner; would pressurize the petitioner for
a separate stay; would refuse to share bed with the petitioner; would maintain
an illicit relationship with some other person and that the respondent would be
found engaged in talking with others on her mobile phone; petitioner would call
her; and at Amarpur once he was beaten but they did not clarify as to how they
would know all these facts. They did not even name the person with whom the
respondent was residing at Agartala pursuing her illicit relationship, if any.
Therefore, their evidence does not inspire any confidence. The petitioner also
did not disclose the name of the person with whom the respondent had such
alleged extra-marital relationship. Aspersion on the chastity of a married
woman without sufficient basis itself amounts to cruelty.
[13]
The petitioner in his cross-examination also admitted that his
mother i.e. PW-2 had filed one petition under Section 125 of the Cr.P.C.
claiming maintenance for herself and her grandson i.e. the son of the petitioner
and the Court also granted such maintenance to them and that they were staying
separately from him. Thus, it appears that the treatment of the petitioner to his
mother and his son has also not been appreciable. Nowhere he has disclosed
about any specific date or month or year of any maltreatment caused by the
respondent to him.
[14]
The respondent [DW-1] on the other hand, in her cross-
examination, has confirmed the fact that she was physically tortured by the
petitioner in his house for which she had informed the police. She also
explained in her cross-examination that when the petitioner requested her for
reconciliation, she and her family members asked him to come with his family
members and local people, as her family members were not willing to let her go
with him alone. She also confirmed the fact that she had filed a petition for
maintenance against the petitioner and she is also receiving such maintenance
regularly. In her cross-examination, she also stated that she was forced to leave
her matrimonial home.
[15]
It also came out in the evidence through her cross-examination that
because of love affair she eloped with the petitioner, even going against the
decision of her parents and more particularly, when the petitioner was
unemployed. Thus, it appears that during the unemployed condition of the
petitioner also, she did not leave him.
[16]
Regarding the plea of desertion, learned Trial Court has also found
that before completion of 2 (two) years of alleged desertion, the petition for
divorce was filed. When the petitioner has approached the Court seeking
divorce on the ground of cruelty and desertion, burden lies on him to prove the
same under Section 101 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 which he has failed
to prove in this case.
[17]
Considering thus, we do not find any merit in the appeal.
Accordingly, the appeal is dismissed and the judgment and decree of the
learned Trial Court are hereby affirmed.
Registry is to prepare the decree accordingly and furnish a copy of
the same free of cost to the parties.
The record of the learned Trial Court may be sent back with copy
of this judgment and decree.
The appeal is disposed of accordingly.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
(S.DATTA PURKAYASTHA), J
Rudradeep
signed by RUDRADEEP BANERJEE
RUDRADEEP BANERJEE Digitally
Date: 2026.01.28 17:46:56 +05'30'
(M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO), CJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review