Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010563782010
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA
PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3560]
FRIDAY, THE 25th DAY OF SEPTEMBER 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUBHENDU SAMANTA
CRIMINAL REVISION CASE NO: 130/2010
Between:
1. SRI KONJETI SANKAR RAO, TENALI, GUNTUR DIST., & ANR.,
PROPRIETOR, M/S. SRI RAM AGENCIES GOPAL REDDY ROAD,
TENALI, GUNTUR DISTRICT.
2. CH. KONDAIAH, M/S. JYOTHENDRA DAL MILL GOLLAPUDI,
VIJAYAWADA, KRISHNA DISTRICT.
...PETITIONER(S)
AND
1. THE STATE OF A P REP BY P P HYDERABAD ANR, REP. BY
PUBLIC PROSECUTOR HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH,
HYDERABAD, REP. BY ITS SPECIAL DEPUTY TAHSILDAR
(P.D.S.),
2. THE JOINT COLLECTOR, MACHILIPATNAM KRISHNA DISTRICT.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Revision filed under Section 397/401 of CrPC praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the Criminal
Revision Case, the High Court may be pleased to set aside the Order in
E.C. Appeal No. 6 / 2009, dated 31-12-2009 on the file of the District &
Sessions Judge, Machilipatnam in confirming the Order of the Joint
Collector, Krishna District, Machilipatnam in E.C.P. No. 350 / 2008 dated
08-12-2008 and consequently dismiss the E.C.P. No. 350 / 2008.
IA NO:1 OF 2010(CRLRCMP 160 OF 2010
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances
stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be
-2CRL.R.C. No.130 of 2010
pleased to dispense with the filing of the Order copy of the Joint Collector,
Krishna, Machilipatnam.
IA NO: 2 OF 2010(CRLRCMP 191 OF 2010
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances
stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be
pleased to direct the 2nd respondent Joint Collector not to invoke the Bank
Guarantee furnished by the petitioners at the time of interim release of the
stocks pending disposal of the Crl.R.C.,
Counsel for the Petitioners:
1. NARASIMHA RAO GUDISEVA
Counsel for the Respondents:
1. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
The Court made the following order:
1. Instant criminal revision case has been preferred against the order
dated 31.12.2009 passed in E.C. Appeal No.6 of 2009 on the file of
learned District and Sessions Judge, Krishna at Machilipatnam,
confirming the order dated 08.12.2008 passed by the Joint Collector,
Krishna District, Machilipatnam, in E.C.P. No.350 of 2008.
2. Prosecution case, in brief, is as follows:
2.1. On receipt of a credible information that some traders have allegedly
stored pulses in the Central Warehousing Corporation godown
(hereinafter
referred
to
as
“CWC
godown”),
Bhavanipuram,
Vijayawada; Special Deputy Tahsildar, along with Food Inspector,
Vuyyuru, and Vigilance officials, after securing presence of mediators,
inspected the said godown.
-3CRL.R.C. No.130 of 2010
2.2. During the course of inspection, the Manager of CWC godown was
asked to produce the particulars of millers/traders who had stored their
stocks therein. On verification of records, it was found that M/s.Sriram
Agencies, Tenali, had stored 98.98 quintals of red gram under Receipt
No.550/A3/3. On enquiry, it was found that M/s. Sriram Agencies
possessed a licence to deal in pulses business in Guntur District only.
Thereafter the said stock was seized under a panchanama and a report
was submitted to concerned authority under Section 6-A of the
Essential Commodities Act, 1955 (for short, “E.C.Act”). After prima
facie satisfying that stock had stored illegally and conducting business
of pulses without requisite licence, a charge was framed against the
petitioners, which reads as under:
“The respondents have unauthorisedly stored 98.98
quintals of red gram in the CWC Godown,
Bhavanipuram, Vijayawada, without any licence or
permission from the competent authority and thereby
violated Clauses 3(1) and 3(2) of the A.P. Pulses
(Licensing, Storage and Regulation) Order, 2007.”
2.3. The petitioners were issued a show-cause notice, to which they
submitted their written explanation. After considering explanation and
hearing the petitioners, learned Joint Collector has passed the
impugned order, thereby held that the charge was proved and seized
stock is confiscated to 100% to the Government and the same be
adjusted from the bank guarantee of petitioner.
-4CRL.R.C. No.130 of 2010
2.4. The order of confiscation was under challenge before the appellate
authority. Learned appellate authority, after hearing the parties, has
dismissed the appeal by confirming the order of confiscation of the
value of the seized stock. Hence, the present criminal revision case.
3. SUBMISSIONS OF LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE PETITIONERS:
3.1. Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the petitioners are
carrying wholesale and retail business in pulses under licence issued
by the competent authority. The second petitioner had sold 101 bags of
red gram pulses weighing GMT 10.100 kgs., in the CWC godown,
Vijayawada, to the first petitioner, under Agriculture Market Committee
permit and credit invoice, the sale consideration was paid by cheque.
The transaction was duly reflected in the respective stock registers of
the petitioners. After purchase, the said stock was shown in the stock
register of the first petitioner.
3.2. Learned counsel further submits that the first petitioner having sufficient
licence to conduct wholesale and retail business, only stored the pulses
in the CWC godown, Vijayawada, though he has licence for Krishna
District.
It is submitted that storing red gram pulses in the CWC
godown, Vijayawada, does not itself reflect any mens rea of the
petitioner that he had indulged in any clandestine or illegal transaction
or business. He further submits that merely storing red gram pulses in
CWC godown, Vijayawada, instead of storing it in his licenced godown,
-5CRL.R.C. No.130 of 2010
at Guntur District, itself is not a reason for confiscation of 100% of
storing pulses.
3.3. Learned counsel also submits that there is no evidence to show that the
petitioners had ever conducted any illegal business. Though the
petitioners have submitted explanation regarding the wholesale and
retail business of pulses, the concerned authority without properly
appreciating the facts has illegally hold that the charge was proved.
Further, the order of 100% confiscation of seized stock to the
Government is exorbitant and it is illegal.
He further submits that
learned appellate court should have held that the seized stocks are sold
to the first petitioner by the 2nd petitioner after paying all taxes to the
Government and under proper receipt. Moreover, the stock register
has sufficiently mentioned the respective stocks after purchase. The
Manager of CWC also produced necessary documents regarding the
sale of said pulses from the 2nd petitioner to the 1st petitioner, thereby
the order of learned appellate court is also illegal and liable to be set
aside.
3.4. In support of his contention, learned counsel for the petitioners placed
reliance on the judgment of a Coordinate Bench of the combined High
Court of Andhra Pradesh reported in M/s.T.G.L. Groundnut
Corporation, TGL Road, Adoni, Kurnool District, represented by
its partner T G Taranath and another v. The Government of Andhra
Pradesh, represented by its Additional Commissioner of Civil
-6CRL.R.C. No.130 of 2010
Supplies and Ex.officio Secretary to Government, Secretariat
Bldgs., Hyderabad and others1 , wherein it was held that not every
violation should result in confiscation of the goods. Paragraph 8 of the
said judgment reads as under:
“8. The position is equally so in the case of the groundnuts found in
the premises of Neeta Transporters. If the Joint Collector was
satisfied that the explanation offered by the second petitioner
was “reasonable and logical too”, the matter ends. It must be
borne in mind that not every violation should result in the
confiscation of goods. Only such violations as are committed
consciously with a view to defeat the provisions of law to obtain
some undue advantage have to be viewed seriously. The
violations alleged in the present case are purely technical and
the authorities below should have taken a more reasonable
attitude is of the matter. In the circumstances, I am unable to
uphold the order of the Joint Collector confiscating the
groundnuts of 26,845 kgs. Found in the premises of the Neeta
Transporters. The first respondent acted arbitrarily in affirming
the confiscation in the impugned order. The order of confiscation
is accordingly quashed. There shall be a direction to the
respondents to release the stocks forthwith to the second
petitioner.”
4. SUBMISSIONS OF THE ASSISTANT PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
APEPARING FOR THE STATE:
4.1. Learned Assistant Public Prosecutor raised objection and submits that
the impugned order passed by learned appellate court is justifiable. The
petitioners have no licence to store the said pulses in CWC godown,
Vijayawada, but have a licence to store pulses at Guntur District only.
Storing pulses at different locations other than in the licencing godown
is itself illegal.
APLJ (Criminal) 1989 (AP) 25
-7CRL.R.C. No.130 of 2010
4.2. He further submits that learned appellate court has considered all the
aspects relating to the violation of the control order and passed the
impugned order. Accordingly, there is no merit to entertain the petition.
5. Heard learned counsel for the petitioners and learned Assistant Public
Prosecutor appearing for the State. Perused the order passed by the
Joint Collector, Krishna District in respect of seizing stock and
confiscation of 100% of the seized pulses and also perused the order
passed by learned appellate court.
6. OBSERVATIONS OF THE COURT:
6.1. It is an admitted fact that both the petitioners are having wholesale and
retail business licence from the competent authority.
They have
purchased the pulses from the authority by way of proper bills and
stocks were shown in their respective stock registers. The special
Deputy Tahasildar, PDS, Nandigama, when inspected CWC godown,
Vijayawada, found that pulses were illegally stored there and they are
showing under the stock of the first petitioner. On enquiry, the Manager
CWC godown produced a copy of deposit and copy of way bill. The first
petitioner, on query from the Manager of the said CWC godown, replied
that he purchased the said stock of pulses from the 2nd petitioner with
proper invoices, they have pulses licence in Guntur District only, but it
was stored in CWC godown, Vijayawada. Hence, the petitioners were
charged for violation of Clauses 3(1) and 3(2) of the A.P. Pulses
-8CRL.R.C. No.130 of 2010
(Licensing, Storage and Regulation) Order, 2007. The said control
order reads as under:
“3. Licensing of Dealers.
(1) No person shall carry on business as a dealer or producer or a
commission agent dealing in pulses, except under and in
accordance with the terms and conditions of a licence issued in this
behalf by the Licensing Authority. Provided that persons taken
licences during the period from 23-9-2006 to 28-2-2007 shall
invariably take licences afresh under this Order.
(2) For the purpose of this clause, any person who stores in quantity of
more than 10 quintals of one or more of pulses put together at any
one time, unless the contrary is proved be deemed to be carrying on
business as a Dealer, Producer or a Commission Agent dealing in
pulses, under this Order.
(3) A separate license shall be obtained by a dealer for each place of
business and storage point also except in respect of places of
purchase.
(4) A producer (Miller)/Commission Agent shall take wholesale licence
from the licensing authority.”
6.2. The Joint Collector, Krishna District, in the proceedings under Section
6A of E.C. Act has held that though the petitioners were licence
holders, they were not authorised to store the pulses at CWC godown,
Vijayawada. Accordingly, the Joint Collector, Krishna District, in
passing confiscation order is of the view that the conduct of the
petitioners clearly amount to storage of pulses beyond the permissible
limit without in possession of valid licence to store the pulses in the
premises. Hence, the charge was proved.
-9CRL.R.C. No.130 of 2010
6.3. Learned appellate court has also analysed the entire matter and is of
the view that, though the pulses were purchased under valid invoices,
the first petitioner was not authorised to store them at CWC godown,
Vijayawada. Further, the second petitioner was not authorised to store
pulses more than the quantity permitted under the licence. According
to the licence, for storing any quantity of pulses beyond the permissible
limit, a dealership licence is required, which the petitioners did not
possess at that relevant point of time. Thereby learned appellate court
has confirmed the order of confiscation.
6.4. In the judgment passed by a coordinate bench of combined High Court
of A.P., at Hyderabad, it appears that in the case in hand before
Coordinate Bench, there are violation of licence condition by storing
some of the ground nuts in another location beyond the licence
premises. Thereby, the Joint Collector has conducted enquiry and
seized the entire stock of ground nut not only stored in separate
locations, but also stored in his licence premises. On analysing the
facts, Coordinate Bench of the combined High Court of A.P., at
Hyderabad, was of the view that merely storing some portion of the
stock at different locations itself does not allow the Joint Collector to
confiscate the entire stock. Thereby, the matter was remanded. It was
observed by the Coordinate Bench that the Joint Collector had acted
in an arbitrary manner. Thus, the matter was remanded for a fresh
decision.
-10CRL.R.C. No.130 of 2010
6.5. In the present case, the stock reflected in the stock register belongs to
the first petitioner and was stored in the CWC godown at Vijayawada,
though he has no licence. The entire stock of red gram stored,
weighing 98.98 quintals, was seized. The factual situation of the cited
case before learned Coordinate Bench of the combined High Court of
A.P., at Hyderabad, is different from that of the present case. Thus, it
is distinguishable. Fact suggests there are violation of concerned
control order.
6.6. Learned appellate court has properly assessed the entire issue. I find
no illegality or impropriety in the order passed by appellate court.
Admittedly, there are clear violation of control order under Clauses 3(1)
and (2) of the A.P. Pulses (Licensing, Storage and Regulation) Order,
2007, thereby the order of confiscation is justified.
7. Under the above observation, criminal revision case is dismissed as
devoid of merit.
8. Miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending in this revision case shall stand
closed.
____________________________
JUSTICE SUBHENDU SAMANTA
Dt.25.09.2026
BV
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review