Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
B.A.No.43 of 2025
Sri Kartik Kumar Kundu
S/o: Lt. Haripada Kundu,
C/o: Dr. Shyamal Sarkar of Ramnagar Road No.05,
P.S.: West Agartala, P.O.: Ramnagar, PIN:799002,
Dist.: West Tripura.
----Applicant(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura
2. Sri Mitan Das,
S/o: Lt. Kishour Das, of: Mrinmoyee Apartment of
Ramnagar Road No.02, 1st Crossing, P.S.: West Agartala,
PIN: 799002, Dist.: West Tripura.
----Respondent(s)
For Applicant(s)
:
Mr. Subrata Sarkar, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Arpan Jamatia, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Raju Datta, P.P.
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Order
02/08/2025
This bail application under Section 483 read with Section
528 of BNSS, 2023 is filed for cancellation of pre-arrest bail granted to
the accused-respondent namely, Sri Mitan Das in connection with West
Agartala
PS
Case
No.2025
WAG
under
Sections
420/409/423/120(B) of IPC vide order dated 17.04.2025 passed by
Learned Addl. Sessions Judge, Court No. 4, West Tripura, Agartala in
connection with BA No.62 of 2025.
Heard Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. Subrata Sarkar assisted
by Learned Counsel, Mr. Arpan Jamatia appearing on behalf of the de
facto-complainant-cum-applicant. Also Heard Learned P.P., Mr. Raju
Datta appearing on behalf of the respondent-State. None appears on
behalf of the accused-respondent.
(2)
From
the
record
it
appears
that
vide
order
dated
19.06.2025 a direction was given to both the parties of this case to
appear
before
this
court.
The
de
facto
complainant-cum-
applicant(hereinafter referred to as ‘applicant’) appeared but the
accused-respondent did not appear before this court even after
allowing several opportunities.
Today also, the accused-respondent did not appear before
this court. So, the matter is taken up for hearing and decision in
absentia of the accused-respondent.
At the time of hearing, Learned Senior Counsel for the
applicant has drawn the attention of this court that the aforesaid case
was registered on the basis of an F.I.R. laid by the informant, Sri Kartik
Kumar
Kundu
to
O/C
West
Agartala
PS
on
09.04.2025.
The
respondent-accused then preferred one anticipatory bail application
bearing BA No.62 of 2025 before the Court of Learned Addl. Sessions
Judge, Court No.4, West Tripura, Agartala. The present applicant filed
objection to the said bail application but the Learned Trial Court
misinterpreting or misconstruing the legal provisions granted pre-arrest
bail to the accused-respondent causing prejudice to the present
applicant. Hence, the applicant has filed the present bail application
before this Court for cancellation of the bail granted to the accusedrespondent. Learned Senior Counsel for the applicant submitted that
the accused-respondent is a construction builder by profession and on
01.12.2022 he entered into a sale agreement with the applicant for
sale of a flat for consideration money of Rs.37,00,000/- and he paid
Rs.30,00,000/-. As per the said agreement the flat was supposed to be
handed over to the applicant within a period of 1(one) year but the
respondent-accused did not take any step for construction of the flat.
(3)
Being inquired, the accused-respondent informed that 60-70% work
has been completed. After that, the applicant had sent a letter on
07.11.2024 to the accused-respondent to refund the money but he
neither refunded the money nor handed over the possession of the
proposed flat as per agreement to the applicant. Under such compelling
circumstances the present case was filed. It was further submitted by
Learned Senior Counsel that out of Rs.37,00,000/- the applicant, being
a retired government employee gave him Rs.30,00,000/- i.e. the entire
amount which he had received after retirement. But, the respondentaccused has defrauded and cheated him by not handing over the
possession of the flat or refunding back the money paid by him. Even
no construction has begun in accordance with the agreement. Learned
Senior Counsel further submitted that the case was registered under
Sections 420/409/423/120(B) of IPC but the Learned Trial Court came
to the observation that Section 409 of IPC will not attract in this case
and regarding Section 420 of IPC, relying upon the judgment of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Satinder Kuman Antil vs. Central
Bureau of Investigation & Anr., reported in 2022 LiveLaw (SC)
577, Learned Trial Court granted pre-arrest bail to the accusedrespondent. Referring the same, Learned Senior Counsel first of all has
drawn the attention of this court that considering the gravity of the
offence, Sections 420 and 423 of IPC would come under the Scheduled
Offences as per the Schedule, Part A provided in the Prevention of
Money Laundering Act, 2002(for short, PMLA Act). Learned Senior
Counsel submitted that in case of Scheduled Offence there is no scope
to grant bail since it is an economic offence.
Learned Senior Counsel further drawn the attention of this
court referring the judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in
(4)
Satender Kumar Antil vs. Central Bureau of Investigation & Anr.
reported in (2022) 10 SCC 51 wherein in para No.2, Hon’ble the Apex
Court made some categories in respect of types of offences. The
relevant portion is reproduced hereunder:
“2. After allowing the application for intervention, an
appropriate order was passed on 7-10-2021 [Satender
Kumar Antil v. CBI, (2021) 10 SCC 773 : (2022) 1 SCC (Cri)
153] . The same is reproduced as under : (Satender Kumar
Antil case [Satender Kumar Antil v. CBI, (2021) 10 SCC 773
: (2022) 1 SCC (Cri) 153] , SCC pp. 774-76, paras 2-11)
“2. We have been provided assistance both by Mr
S.V. Raju, learned Additional Solicitor General and
Mr Sidharth Luthra, learned Senior Counsel and
there is broad unanimity in terms of the
suggestions made by the learned ASG. In terms of
the suggestions,
the offences have been
categorised and guidelines are sought to be laid
down for grant of bail, without fettering the
discretion of the courts concerned and keeping in
mind the statutory provisions.
3. We are inclined to accept the guidelines and
make them a part of the order of the Court for the
benefit of the courts below. The guidelines are as
under:
„Categories/Types of Offences
(A) Offences punishable with imprisonment of 7
years or less not falling in Categories B & D.
(B)
Offences
punishable
with
death,
imprisonment for life, or imprisonment for more
than 7 years.
(C) Offences punishable under Special Acts
containing stringent provisions for bail like NDPS
(Section 37), PMLA (Section 45), UAPA [Section
43-D(5)], Companies Act, [Section 212(6)], etc.
(D) Economic offences not covered by Special
Acts.”
Learned Senior Counsel submitted that the present case
would come under category number (D) i.e., economic offences not
covered by Special Acts but the Learned Trial Court relying upon
category (A) granted pre-arrest bail to the accused-respondent. It was
further submitted that in case of economic offence there is very least
scope to grant any bail and in support of his submission Learned Senior
Counsel relied upon another citation of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of
(5)
India in P. Chidambaram vs. Directorate of Enforcement reported
in (2019) 9 SCC 24 wherein in para Nos.74 and 75, Hon’ble the Apex
Court observed as under:
“74. Ordinarily, arrest is a part of the process of the
investigation intended to secure several purposes. There
may be circumstances in which the accused may provide
information leading to discovery of material facts and
relevant information. Grant of anticipatory bail may hamper
the investigation. Pre-arrest bail is to strike a balance
between the individual's right to personal freedom and the
right of the investigating agency to interrogate the accused
as to the material so far collected and to collect more
information which may lead to recovery of relevant
information. In State v. Anil Sharma [State v. Anil Sharma,
(1997) 7 SCC 187 : 1997 SCC (Cri) 1039] , the Supreme
Court held as under: (SCC p. 189, para 6)
“6. We find force in the submission of CBI that
custodial
interrogation
is
qualitatively
more
elicitation-oriented than questioning a suspect who is
well-ensconced with a favourable order under Section
438 of the Code. In a case like this, effective
interrogation of a suspected person is of tremendous
advantage in disinterring many useful informations
and also materials which would have been concealed.
Success in such interrogation would elude if the
suspected person knows that he is well protected and
insulated by a pre-arrest bail order during the time
he is interrogated. Very often interrogation in such a
condition would reduce to a mere ritual. The
argument that the custodial interrogation is fraught
with the danger of the person being subjected to
third-degree methods need not be countenanced, for,
such an argument can be advanced by all accused in
all criminal cases. The Court has to presume that
responsible police officers would conduct themselves
in a responsible manner and that those entrusted
with the task of disinterring offences would not
conduct themselves as offenders.”
75. Observing that the arrest is a part of the investigation
intended to secure several purposes, in Adri Dharan Das v.
State of W.B. [Adri Dharan Das v. State of W.B., (2005) 4
SCC 303 : 2005 SCC (Cri) 933] , it was held as under: (SCC
p. 313, para 19)
“19. Ordinarily, arrest is a part of the process of
investigation intended to secure several purposes.
The accused may have to be questioned in detail
regarding various facets of motive, preparation,
commission and aftermath of the crime and the
connection of other persons, if any, in the crime.
There may be circumstances in which the accused
may provide information leading to discovery of
material facts. It may be necessary to curtail his
freedom in order to enable the investigation to
proceed without hindrance and to protect witnesses
and persons connected with the victim of the crime,
to prevent his disappearance, to maintain law and
order in the locality. For these or other reasons,
arrest may become an inevitable part of the process
of investigation. The legality of the proposed arrest
cannot be gone into in an application under Section
(6)
438 of the Code. The role of the investigator is well
defined and the jurisdictional scope of interference by
the court in the process of investigation is limited.
The court ordinarily will not interfere with the
investigation of a crime or with the arrest of the
accused in a cognizable offence. An interim order
restraining arrest, if passed while dealing with an
application under Section 438 of the Code will
amount to interference in the investigation, which
cannot, at any rate, be done under Section 438 of the
Code.”
Further, Learned Senior Counsel for the applicant referred
para Nos.78 and 79 of the same judgment wherein Hon’ble the Apex
Court observed as under:
“Economic offences
78. Power under Section 438 CrPC being an extraordinary
remedy, has to be exercised sparingly; more so, in cases of
economic offences. Economic offences stand as a different
class as they affect the economic fabric of the society. In
Directorate
of
Enforcement
v.
Ashok
Kumar
Jain
[Directorate of Enforcement v. Ashok Kumar Jain, (1998) 2
SCC 105 : 1998 SCC (Cri) 510] , it was held that in economic
offences, the accused is not entitled to anticipatory bail.
79. The learned Solicitor General submitted that the
“scheduled offence” and “offence of money-laundering” are
independent of each other and PMLA being a special
enactment applicable to the offence of money-laundering is
not a fit case for grant of anticipatory bail. The learned
Solicitor General submitted that money-laundering being an
economic offence committed with much planning and
deliberate design poses a serious threat to the nation's
economy and financial integrity and in order to unearth the
laundering and trail of money, custodial interrogation of the
appellant is necessary.”
Referring
the
same,
Learned
Senior
Counsel
again
submitted that there is no scope to grant bail in a case which falls
under economic offence but here in the case at hand, the Learner Trial
Court misinterpreted the guidelines laid down in the judgment of
Satender Kumar Antil (supra) and granted pre-arrest bail. Learned
Senior Counsel has further drawn the attention of this court that
considering the nature and gravity of the offence and the conduct of
the accused-respondent it is urgently required that the order dated
17.04.2025 delivered by Learner Trial Court needs to be interfered with
because the accused-respondent not only cheated and deceived the
(7)
applicant but also by deceiving him the accused-respondent has taken
the entire money which the applicant got after his retirement from the
department. Now, the applicant has become homeless and is staying in
a rented house. It was further submitted that although in the
agreement it was stated by the accused-respondent that necessary
permission was obtained from the municipal authority, but practically
no such permission was taken by him before entering into agreement
with the applicant, which also shows his fraudulent conduct to deceive
a customer.
Learned P.P. appearing on behalf of the respondent-State
submitted that the order dated 17.04.2025 passed by Learned Trial
Court was not in accordance with law and no permission was obtained
by the accused-respondent regarding construction of flat as per
agreement.
I have heard detailed submission of Learned Senior Counsel
for the applicant and Learned P.P. for the State-respondent and also
perused the relevant prosecution papers. I have also gone through the
order dated 17.04.2025 passed by Learned Trial Court.
It appears that at the time of passing of order dated
17.04.2025, Learned Trial Court based on the materials on record
came to the observation that Section 409 of IPC would not attract in
this case and in respect of Section 420 of IPC, Learned Trial Court
came to the observation that Section 420 of IPC provides punishment
for less than 7(seven) years which comes under the category (A) of the
offence as mentioned in the case of Satender Kumar Antil (supra).
So, Learned Trial Court granted pre-arrest bail to the accusedrespondent. However, after perusing the schedule as contained in the
PMLA Act and also after going through the judgment of the Hon’ble
(8)
Supreme Court of India in the aforenoted case, it appears to this Court
that the present case would fall under category (D) which attracts
cases under economic offence and in Part A of the Schedule of PMLA
Act, the relevant provisions of IPC are mentioned.
Further, from the judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court in P.
Chidambaram(supra), it appears that in a case of this nature there is
very least scope to pass any interim order restraining arrest of an
accused person invoking the provision of Section 438 of Cr.P.C., which
will amount to interference in the investigation. But here, in the case at
hand,
Learned
Trial
Court,
by
granting
pre-arrest
bail
to
the
respondent-accused limited the scope of I.O. to proceed further with
the investigation of this case. Situated thus, it appears to this court
that the order passed by Learned Trial Court was not supported by any
logical and legal interpretation and considering the nature and gravity
of the offence, it appears that the Learned Trial Court misinterpreted
the judgment passed in the case of Satender Kumar Antil (supra)
and granted pre-arrest bail, which, in the considered opinion of this
court, needs to be interfered with.
Furthermore, in this regard, Hon’ble the Supreme Court of
India
in
Y.S.
Jagan
Mohan
Reddy
vs.
Central
Bureau
of
Investigation reported in (2013) 7 SCC 439 in para Nos.34 and 35
observed as under:
“34. Economic offences constitute a class apart and need to
be visited with a different approach in the matter of bail.
The economic offences having deep-rooted conspiracies and
involving huge loss of public funds need to be viewed
seriously and considered as grave offences affecting the
economy of the country as a whole and thereby posing
serious threat to the financial health of the country.
35. While granting bail, the court has to keep in mind the
nature of accusations, the nature of evidence in support
thereof, the severity of the punishment which conviction
will entail, the character of the accused, circumstances
which are peculiar to the accused, reasonable possibility of
(9)
securing the presence of the accused at the trial,
reasonable apprehension of the witnesses being tampered
with, the larger interests of the public/State and other
similar considerations.”
In
Dinesh
Sharma
vs.
Emgee
Cables
and
Communication Ltd. & Anr., reported in 2025 SCC OnLine SC 929,
Hon’ble the Apex Court in para Nos.23 and 24 observed as under:
“23. A profitable reference can be made to the case of
Parbatbhai Ahir v. State of Gujrat, (2017) 9 SCC 641
wherein it was observed that economic offences by their
very nature lie beyond the domain of mere dispute between
private parties and the High Court would be justified in
declining to quash where the offender is involved in an
activity akin to a financial or economic fraud or
misdemeanour. The consequences of the act complained of
upon the financial or economic system will weigh in the
balance. Thus, it can be concluded that economic offences
by their very nature stand on a different footing than other
offences and have wider ramifications. They constitute a
class apart. Economic offences affect the economy of the
country as a whole and pose a serious threat to the
financial health of the country. If such offences are viewed
lightly, the confidence and trust of the public will be
shaken.
24. It is true that there is a growing tendency of parties to
rope in their counterparts to harass and extract monetary
transaction, it is the duty of the Court to consider the facts
of each case, in its proper perspective and then to arrive at
the conclusion as to whether the case warrants
investigation or the proceedings are required to be
quashed. The peculiar facts and circumstances of the
present case warrants thorough investigation as there was
a huge amount involved. As we have already stated that
when the petitioner approached the High Court for quashing
of the FIR, the investigation was at its initial stage and
subsequent to filing of the present Special Leave Petition in
this Court it seems that the investigation was concluded by
filing the chargesheet.”
From the aforesaid references it appears that in a case of
this nature, the Court has to keep in mind the nature of accusations,
evidence, severity of the punishment and the character of the accused.
Here, in the case at hand, the accused-respondent deceived
the applicant by receiving a huge amount of money from him in spite of
knowing that he is a retired government employee and had given it to
him in good faith that he would construct the flat and turn it over to
him on time. But, the accused-respondent not only failed to keep his
promise after receipt of money but he also defrauded the applicant by
(10)
entering into the agreement saying that he obtained permission from
the authority for construction. However, factually no such permission
was taken from the respective authority by him. Thus, it appears to
this Court that the respondent-accused is not entitled to get the
privilege of pre-arrest bail. According to this Court, the pre-arrest bail
granted to the accused-respondent was not in accordance with law and
considering the nature and gravity of offence the interference of this
Court is required.
Accordingly,
the
order
dated
17.04.2025
passed
by
Learned Addl. Sessions Judge, Court No.4, West Tripura, Agartala is
hereby set aside and stands cancelled. The accused-respondent may
surrender before the Learned Court of Jurisdictional Magistrate and
may prefer bail, if he is so advised.
With this observation, the present bail application stands
allowed and disposed of.
Send down the record of the Learned Trial Court along with
a copy of this order. Return back the case diary to I.O. through
Learned P.P. along with a copy of this order. Also a copy of this order
be supplied to Learned Senior Counsel for the applicant.
JUDGE
Snigdha
signed by
MOUMIT Digitally
MOUMITA DATTA
2025.08.02
A DATTA Date:
17:31:10 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review