Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WA No.90 of 2024
Sri Karma Bhutia
Son of Gomchen Bhutia, permanent resident of Atisha Road, PO & PS
Kalimpong, Sub-Division Kalimpong, District Kalimpong, West Bengal, PIN
734301, aged about 59 years.
...... Appellant(s)
VERSUS
1. The Union of India,
Represented by the Secretary, Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of
India, having his office at NDCC-II Building, Jai Singh Road, Near Jantar
Mantar, 110001.
2.
The Union of India,
Represented by the Secretary, Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of
India, having his office at NDCC-II Building, Jai Singh Road, Near Jantar
Mantar, 110001.
3.
The Director General of Police,
Central Reserve Police Force, Block-1, Central Government Office
Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi, 110003.
4.
The Inspector General of Police (Pers),
Central Reserve Police Force, Central Government Office Complex, Lodhi
Road, New Delhi, 110003.
...... Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. Somik Deb, Senior Advocate.
Mr. P. Chakraborty, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. B. Majumder, Dy. S.G.I.
Date of hearing & delivery
of judgment
:
29th July, 2024.
Whether fit for reporting
:
YES
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.D. PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel for the appellant and
Mr. B. Majumder, learned Dy. S.G.I. for the respondents.
[2]
Appellant was posted as Commandant, CRPF in Tripura on
09.08.2021. Upon his promotion on 28.03.2024 as DIG (GD), he was
transferred under the office of IG, Madhya Pradesh. His representation dated
08.04.2024, not to transfer him on certain grounds, inter alia, (a) need to care
for his ailing parents since the writ petitioner is the only male child, (b) his
daughter is studying in Class X at Agartala based school and his transfer would
cause potential disruption to her studies by a school change, and (c) his
impending retirement on 31.07.2025 with a request to provide an opportunity to
serve on the basis of terminal posting in Tripura Sector Headquarters itself was
declined by the impugned order dated 28.05.2024 issued by the IG (Pers) with
approval of the Director General of CRPF (Annexure R/12) on the following
grounds:
“10.
Upon reviewing the officer‟s representation dated
13/05/2024, it is observed that the requests and grounds presented
are identical to those in his earlier representation dated 08/04/2024.
Moreover, the reasons provided lack merit and do not warrant
consideration, as they are general in nature and do not offer any
new or compelling arguments. Regarding the officer‟s request for
cancellation of his transfer to MP Sector Headquarters and
retention in Tripura Sector Headquarters as a terminal posting, it is
noted that Standing Order No.05/2022 supersedes the earlier
guidelines in Standing Order No.07/2014. As per Standing Order
No.05/2022, paragraph 3(C), requests for transfer on
compassionate grounds, including terminal posting, are considered
based on merit, posting particulars, attached documents, available
vacancies, and administrative and operational requirements. Shri
Karma Bhutia, DIG is posted in Tripura Sector Hqr wef 09/08/2024
and completed over 2 years and 9 months period there. Besides, he
had spent over 20 years in the North East Region in various
postings throughout his career. Further, no document in support of
illness of parents is submitted by the officer alongwith his
representation. Shri Dinesh Singh, DIG (IRLA-3999) has reported
on his transfer from O/O IG NES, Shillong to O/O IG Tripura
Sector on 21/05/2024 (AN), therefore presently no post of DIG is
vacant in the O/O IG Tripura Sector or anywhere in Tripura. Hence
request of officer for his retention in Tripura Sector until
superannuation, could not be accommodated on administrative and
operational requirements.
11.
The officer‟s earlier request for retention in Tripura Sector
until superannuation, made on 08/04/2024, was considered
sympathetically by the Transfer Representation Standing
Committee but could not be accommodated due to existing transfer
policies.
12.
Therefore, the officer‟s renewed request for terminal
posting in his representation dated 13/05/2024 is not justified and
acceptable, as it does not provide any new grounds or compelling
reasons for consideration.
13.
The officer‟s transfer to O/O IG, MP Sector, located in
Bhopal, the state capital of Madhya Pradesh, provides access to
excellent medical facilities including educational facilities.
Therefore, the officer can arrange medical treatment for his ailing
parents, if needed, in Bhopal including education of his child.
Additionally, the officer can apply for leave to address personal
issues as required. If needed the officer can be allowed to retain his
Government Quarter in Agartala to facilitate continuation of
education of his daughter from Agartala. The transfer to O/O IG,
MP Sector was made considering operational and administrative
requirements, available vacancies, and the officer‟s suitability for
the posting. In light of these circumstances, the officer‟s request to
cancel his transfer to O/O IG, MP Sector and retain him in O/O IG,
Tripura Sector lacks merit and is not justified.
14.
In conclusion, the representation dated 13/05/2024
submitted by Shri Karma Bhutia, DIG (IRLA:3142), seeking
cancellation of his transfer to MP Sector Headquarters and
retention in Tripura Sector Headquarters as a terminal posting, has
been considered sympathetically but not acceded to by the
competent authority as it lacks merit and grounds. The request is
deemed unjustified and without sufficient cause.
15.
[3]
This issues with the approval of Director General.”
In the meantime, one Dinesh Singh, DIG posted in Siliguri has
been transferred and posted in Tripura on 21.05.2024. Writ petitioner was
relieved w.e.f. 08.05.2024.
[4]
Being aggrieved, writ petitioner approached the Writ Court. The
learned Writ Court declined to interfere in the matter and dismissed the writ
petition holding as under:
“10.
I have taken into consideration the decision as referred to
by Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel for the petitioner in the case of
Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan (supra). It is said that though
transfer is incidental to service and cannot be interfered ordinarily,
however, it can be interfered if it is at the instance of any mala fide
or if it is passed in violation of any statutory guidelines or any
extraneous reasons. Similar observation has been made in the case
of Registrar General(supra). In the case of Registrar
General(supra), at para 71, the Hon‟ble supreme Court held that
“The then Judge on the Transfer Committee, in his deposition
before JIC, had clearly admitted that he had not gone into the
annexures, which were attached with the representation of the
petitioner.” In that circumstance, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held
that “Non consideration of the relevant material and consideration
of the extraneous material would come into the realm of
irrationality. An action which is arbitrary, irrational and
unreasonable would be hit by Article 14 of the Constitution of
India. We, therefore, find that the rejection of the representations
of the petitioner dated 9-7-2014 and 11-7-2014, would also not
stand the scrutiny of law.”
11.
From the above observation of the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court in the case of Registrar General(supra) it is clear that while
considering the representation of the petitioner of the said case, the
Transfer Standing Committee could not consider all the documents
enclosed to the representation. Furthermore, it considered some
extraneous material which was definitely an arbitrary exercise of
the jurisdiction vested upon the Transfer Standing Committee. True
it is, when a responsibility is given to a Committee to consider each
and every aspect of the representation, then, it is reasonable and
legitimately expected that the said Committee would consider all
the grievances raised and mentioned by a person in his
representation. Moreover, in the case of Registrar General (supra),
the Transfer Standing Committee had considered some extraneous
materials which formed the decision making process arbitrary,
irrational and unreasonable. It is not the case here.
12.
In the instant case, what this Court finds that the
respondents have considered each and every point raised by the
petitioner in his representation. All the points were considered and
dealt with by the Transfer Representation Standing Committee. As
I have already stated that the second representation which was
submitted at the direction of the Court, was considered and decided
by the Director General of CRPF himself. He meticulously perused
and considered the grievances raised by the petitioner in his
representation as regards the education of his daughter as well as
illness of his old-aged parents. The Director General also had
observed that no supporting documents of illness and treatment of
his parents had been enclosed with the representation. The Director
General also took into consideration the recommendation made by
the Standing Committee. On being analyzed each and every factors
and keeping in mind the administrative requirements, the Director
General had taken a conscious view to reject the representation of
the petitioner directing him to join his new place of posting at MP
Sector as DIG. In this circumstance, in my opinion, it will not be
proper for this Court to sit as an appellate authority over the
decision of the competent authority and interfere with the
impugned order of transfer.
13.
Though not referred to, there is yet another important
aspect to be noticed. Clause 5 of Standing Order No.05/2022 plays
a vital role to decide the merits of the present writ petition, which
reads as under:
“5. Tenure of Posting:
(a) The normal tenure of all officers under this policy will
be 03 years subject to the provisions of para 5(b) of this
S.O.
(b) As CRPF is Central Armed Police Force of GoI
constituted under Special Act and is tasked with
important operational duties regarding maintenance of
security of the nation, therefore there are certain
operational and administrative requirements of the
Force. In view of such requirements, any officer may be
posted to any Unit or office at any point of time. The
above policy does not create any right for any officer
for posting to a particular place or for a particular
tenure as mentioned in Para-5(a).
If during the posting of any officer it comes to the
notice of the supervisory/senior authorities that officer
needs to be transferred out at any time from present place
due to administrative or operational reasons, then the
concerned authority may transfer such officer at any time to
a suitable place.”
14.
On bare perusal of the above clause, it comes to fore that
CRPF Organization is a Central Armed Police Force of
Government of India and is vested with solemn duties and
responsibilities in regard to maintenance of security of the nation
and certainly there would be requirements of posting of any officer
to any Unit or office at any point of time to meet the exigencies of
the Force. It is clearly stated under Clause 5 that the policy under
the aforesaid Standing Order laying down the guidelines for
transfer does not create any right for any officer for posting to a
particular place or for a particular tenure. In other words, no officer
can claim transfer at a place of his choice as a matter of right. That
apart, the framers of the guidelines have given specific right or
power upon the supervisory or senior authorities of the Force to
transfer any officer at any point of time to any place keeping in
view the administrative and operational requirements.
15.
In my opinion, Clause 5 gives a power to the concerned
authority to pass necessary order in regard to all matters incidental
or ancillary to the provisions laid down in the Standing Order
No.05/2022 to enhance or to bring efficiency in the administration
of the CRPF Organization. The doctrine of incidental or ancillary
powers is well recognized in the Indian Law. The said doctrine
postulates that statutory authority is endowed with ancillary and
incidental powers which are necessary to discharge the functions
effectively for the purpose of doing justice to the parties.
16.
In the considered view of this Court, incidental and
ancillary power can be exercised to subvert or abrogate any
statutory rules or guidelines. Such power is exercised to enforce a
provision effectively, but not to usurp.
17.
From the aforesaid discussions, it can easily be said that
the competent authority i.e., Director General of CRPF has not
exercised his discretionary power arbitrarily. He has considered
each and every aspects, the petitioner has agitated in his
representation. However, considering the administrative and
operational exigencies the competent authority i.e. the Director
General has become unable to accede to the request made by the
petitioner.
18.
In the instant case, the petitioner has not alleged mala
fides. In view of the aforesaid discussions and the reasons recorded
here-in-above, the challenge to the decision of the respondents,
rejecting the prayer of the petitioner not to give effect to the
impugned transfer order to the office of the IG, MP Sector is found
to be not legally tenable and thus, is bereft of merit.
19.
As sequel, the instant writ petition stands dismissed.
However, there shall be no order as to costs.
The interim order passed on 07.05.2024 stands vacated.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands dismissed.
The related files containing various notes of the
respondents placed before this Court are returned to learned Dy.
SGI.”
[5]
Mr. Somik Deb, learned senior counsel for the writ petitioner has
drawn the attention of this Court to the order of promotion whereby he was also
transferred to the office of IG, MP Sector. He has also drawn the attention of
this Court to the Standing Order No.07/2014 dated 24.11.2014 (Annexure 8)
and Clause 4 thereof which deals with terminal posting. Learned senior counsel
for the writ petitioner has also drawn attention to the Standing Order
No.05/2022 dated 27.09.2022 (Annexure 11) which provides for transfer policy
for Group „A‟ Gazetted officers under the CRPF. According to this policy the
normal tenure of posting is three years subject to the provisions of para 5(b)
thereof which provides that CRPF being tasked with important operational
duties regarding maintenance of security of the nation and there being certain
operational and administrative requirements of the Force, any officer may be
posted to any Unit or office at any point of time. The instant transfer policy
does not create any right for any officer for posting to a particular place or for a
particular tenure as mentioned in Para-5(a). Learned senior counsel for the writ
petitioner submits that his representation was to be routed through a Transfer
Representation Standing Committee presided over by the Chairman, ADG
Headquarters. Therefore, the rejection of the representation of the writ
petitioner vide impugned order dated 28.05.2024 by the Director General,
CRPF is contrary to the guidelines and warrants interference under writ
jurisdiction of this Court. In support of his submission he has relied upon
Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan vs. Damodar Prasad Pandey and others,
(2004) 12 SCC 299, Para 4 in particular. Learned senior counsel for the writ
petitioner has also placed reliance upon the case of Ms X vs. Registrar General,
High Court of Madhya Pradesh and another, (2022) 14 SCC 187. Based upon
these decisions, it is submitted that the genuine grounds urged for cancellation
of his transfer has been rejected by the Director General by passing the normal
channel of Transfer Representation Standing Committee. The petitioner‟s plea
of being posted anywhere near to Tripura like Shillong has also not been taken
into account though writ petitioner was left with only one year of service.
Learned senior counsel has also referred to the terminal policy at Clause 8(i) of
the Standing Order No.05 of 2022 and submitted that writ petitioner on his own
has not availed of 4 years of posting at Tripura as is being treated by the
respondents. Writ petitioner‟s posting for the last 20 years is spread over the
entire North-Eastern region and should not have been a factor to decline his
representation. It is submitted that therefore, this Court may deem it proper to
interfere in the order of transfer and direct the respondents to post him at any
other place even in West Bengal or Meghalaya so that he can attend to the
needs of his aged ailing parents and his daughter who is studying in Class X in
a school at Agartala. The learned Writ Court has failed to take into
consideration these aspects of the matter. Therefore, the writ appeal may be
allowed.
[6]
Mr. B. Majumder, learned Dy. S.G.I. for the respondent, Union of
India has, however, strongly opposed the prayer. He has straightaway referred
to the reasons recorded in the order dated 28.05.2024. He submits that each and
every contention of the writ petitioner has been dealt with. The competent
authority has also observed that if needed the officer can be allowed to retain
his Government Quarter in Agartala to facilitate continuation of education of
his daughter from Agartala. He also submitted that the policy of terminal
posting has to be considered on case to case basis and on the existence of a
vacancy. Since an officer has already been posted in place of the writ petitioner
on 21.05.2024, there are no posts available to accommodate the writ petitioner.
Moreover, writ petitioner has served in the entire North-Eastern region for the
last 20 years and in Tripura also since last about 3 years. The transfer policy of
the Central Armed Police Force makes it clear that for operational and
administrative requirements of the force, an officer can be posted to any Unit or
office at any point of time which will supersede the normal tenure of posting of
3 years under Clause 5(a) and (b) read together. As such, the learned Writ Court
rightly refused to interfere in the matter. Learned Dy. S.G.I. has also relied
upon a decision of the Apex Court in the case of State of Madhya Pradesh and
another vs. S.S. Kourav and others, AIR 1995 SC 1056, Para 6 and submitted
that hardship cannot be a ground for interference in transfer matters since
transfer is an incidence of service.
[7]
We have accorded due consideration to the submission of learned
counsel for the parties and taken note of the relevant pleadings placed on
record. We have also gone through the impugned judgment and decisions cited
by the rival parties.
[8]
It is trite to say that transfer is an incidence of service and need not
be interfered unless the decision is shown to be arbitrary or vitiated by malafide
or infraction of any prescribed norms or principles governing the transfer [See
Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan vs. Damodar Prasad Pandey and others,
(2004) 12 SCC 299, relied on behalf of the writ petitioner also]. We are of the
considered view that merely because the Director General of CRPF has decided
the representation of the writ petitioner on this occasion instead through the
channel of Transfer Representation Standing Committee as per addendum to
Standing Order No.05/2022 could not vitiate the decision of the competent
authority. The said provision only provides the procedure for examining the
representation of the aggrieved officer through a standing committee with a
recommendation for approval of the competent authority. On perusal of the
grounds of rejection in the order dated 28.05.2024 extracted above, it appears
that his earlier representation made on 08.04.2024 was considered by the
Transfer Representation Standing Committee sympathetically but could not be
accommodated due to existing transfer policy. In his renewed representation for
terminal policy on 08.05.2024, every ground raised by the writ petitioner has
been dealt with cogent reasons by the Director General of CRPF in the
impugned order dated 28.05.2024. Therefore, mere non-forwarding of his
renewed representation of the writ petitioner on this occasion through this
Transfer Representation Standing Committee would not amount to an illegality
which affects the decision itself. Moreover, the impugned order has dealt with
each and every grounds raised by the writ petitioner for cancellation of his
transfer. It is not in dispute that writ petitioner has been posted for the last 20
years in the North-Eastern region and since 09.08.2021 in the State of Tripura.
This transfer has been occasioned on his promotion from the post of
Commandant, CRPF to DIG, CRPF which necessitated movement for
administrative reasons. Moreover, on relieval of the writ petitioner w.e.f.
08.05.2024, another officer has been posted as DIG, Tripura region on
21.05.2024 and as such no post is vacant. Para 8(i) of the Standing Order
No.05/2022 which provides for terminal policy also stipulates that such a
request can be considered on case to case basis and only if vacancy exists. For
the above reasons therefore, writ petitioner cannot claim to be entitled to take
the benefit of the terminal policy in the absence of a vacancy and his continued
posting for last 20 years in the North-Eastern region and about 2 years and 8
months in the State of Tripura as Commandant, CRPF. The learned Writ Court
has duly considered all aspects of the matter. We, therefore, do not find that the
order of transfer of the writ petitioner and rejection of his representation vide
Annexure R/12 dated 28.05.2024 suffers from any malafide or arbitrariness or
contravention of any guidelines calling for interference by this Court.
Accordingly, the instant appeal is dismissed.
Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.
(S.D. PURKAYASTHA), J
Rudradeep
signed by SATABDI DUTTA
SATABDI DUTTA Digitally
Date: 2024.08.05 14:25:00 +05'30'
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review