The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
11. It is thus clear that the ancillary relief of delivery of possession in a suit for specific performance can be claimed at any stage including that of the execution. In the instant case, the petitioner/plaintiff had prayed for the ancillary relief of delivery of possession of the suit land besides asking for the substantive relief of execution of the agreement by the defendant upon deposit of the balance amount of consideration by the plaintiff. The learned trial Court decreed the suit by directing the defendant to execute the registration of the sale deed in respect of the suit land after taking balance consideration money from the plaintiff but failed to grant the ancillary relief of delivery of possession without which the execution of the registration of the sale deed on the part of the defendant could be only a paper transaction. The learned trial Court, however, refused to amend the decree on the ground that such a prayer cannot be allowed on the ground that Section 152 of the CPC provides for amendment of the judgments, decrees or orders only for correction of clerical or arithmetical mistakes or accidental slip or omission. The opinion of the Apex Court rendered in the case of Manickam alias Thandapani and another (supra), however, makes the legal position clear that such a prayer can also be made at the stage of execution of the decree in a case for specific performance…
11. In the present case, the plaintiff had made a prayer for delivery of possession after execution of the sale deed which the learned trial Court perhaps inadvertently failed to allow. In such circumstances, the impugned order dated 12.12.2022 passed by the learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), Khowai in case No. Title Suit 04 of 2020 be set aside. The matter is remitted to the learned trial Court to consider the application of the petitioner for correction of the decree in accordance with law.
12. Accordingly, the revision petition stands allowed and disposed of. Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of. (APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ Pulak 2024.01.09 PULAK BANIK Date: 17:46:42 +05'30'
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
CRP No.11/2023
Sri Kandarpa Narayan Paul, Son of Late Dhirendra Chandra Paul, resident of
Durganagar, P.O. & P.S.-Khowai, District-Khowai, Tripura.
……… Petitioner(s).
VERSUS
Sri Sudip Datta, Son of Sri Shyamal Datta, resident of North Jambura, P.O. &
P.S.-Khowai, District-Khowai, Tripura.
………Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Sankar Lodh, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: None.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
Date of hearing and judgment: 04th January, 2024.
Whether fit for reporting
: YES.
JUDGMENT & ORDER(ORAL)
Proof of notice through paper publication has been submitted by
the learned counsel for the petitioner on 12.12.2023. The date of appearance of
the respondent was 13.12.2023 but the respondent has not entered appearance
despite valid service of notice.
Heard Mr. Sankar Lodh, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner.
2.
The present revision petition under Article 227 of the Constitution
of India arises out of the order dated 12.12.2022 passed by the learned Civil
Judge (Senior Division), Khowai in case No. Title Suit 04 of 2020 whereby the
learned trial Court has rejected the petition filed by the plaintiff/petitioner for
correction of the judgment and decree dated 09.09.2022.
3.
The plaintiff/petitioner had preferred T.S. No.04 of 2020 for the
following reliefs:
"(i) Pass a decree directing the defendant to perform her part of
obligation by executing the registration of the sale deed for the land,
mentioned in the Schedule below.
(ii) In the event of non-compliance of the decree by the defendant,
the Ld. Court would be pleased to execute the registration of the sale
deed so presented in respect of the suit land in favour of the plaintiff
on behalf of the defendant.
(iii) The Ld. Court would be pleased to direct the defendant to
deliver possession of the suit land to the plaintiff within the period to
be fixed by the Ld. Court and on the failure of the defendant, to
deliver the possession of the suit land to the plaintiff through the
process of Court.
(iv) Pass a decree for costs of the proceeding.
(v) Pass any other Decree/Order as may be deemed fit and proper
for fair ends of justice."
4.
The suit land appertains to Khatian No.4030, comprised in R.S.
Plot No.6038/9098 measuring 0.005 acre according to the revenue record of
Bastu (Nal) class of land as per the boundary described in the schedule. The
learned trial Court framed the following issues for determination:
"(i) Whether the suit is maintainable in its present form and nature?
(ii) Whether the defendant had entered into an agreement with the
plaintiff for selling the suit land described in schedule of the plaint in
exchange of total sale consideration of Rs.4,000,00/- (Rupees four
lakhs) only?
(iii) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree directing the
defendant to perform his part of obligation by executing the
registration of the sale deed in respect of the suit land as mentioned in
schedule of the plaint after taking balance consideration money from
the plaintiff?
(iv) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to get any other relief or reliefs
including cost of the proceedings and if so, up to what extent?"
All the issues were decided in favour of the plaintiff.
5.
The suit was decreed without contest as the defendant did not
appear. The operative part of the judgment was couched in the following terms:
"As a corollary to the discussion and decision made on all the
foregoing issues I am of the considered opinion that the plaintiff is
successful in proving that the defendant had entered into an agreement
with the plaintiff for selling the suit land described in schedule of the
plaint in exchange of total sale consideration of Rs.4,000,00/- (Rupees
four lakhs) only. The plaintiff is also successful to prove that he is
entitled to a decree directing the defendant to perform his part of
obligation by executing the registration of the sale deed in respect of
the suit land as mentioned in schedule of the plaint after taking
balance consideration money from the plaintiff.
ORDER
In the result, the suit of the plaintiff is hereby decreed.
It is hereby declared that the plaintiff is entitled to a
decree directing the defendant to perform his part of obligation by
executing the registration of the sale deed in respect of the suit land as
mentioned in schedule of the plaint after taking balance consideration
money from the plaintiff.
Thus, the case is disposed of without contest.
Prepare a decree accordingly and place before me for my
signature within 15 days from today.
PRONOUNCED IN OPEN COURT
Given under my hand and seal on this the 09th day of
September, 2022 at Khowai."
6.
Apparently, the learned trial Court did not direct delivery of
possession in favour of the plaintiff though such a relief was claimed for and
despite the Court granting relief of specific performance of the agreement for
sale by directing execution of registration of the sale deed by the defendant in
respect of the suit land after taking balance consideration money from the
plaintiff. The plaintiff, therefore, sought correction of the decree under Sections
151 and 152 of the CPC by directing complementary relief of handing over of
the possession of the suit land. The learned trial Court after noticing the
provisions of the Section 152 of the CPC, however, rejected the prayer holding
that such amendment in the judgments, decrees or orders contemplated under
Section 152 of the CPC is confined to correction of clerical or arithmetical
mistakes therein arising from accidental slip or omission.
7.
In this regard, learned counsel for the petitioner has relied upon
the decision of the Apex Court in the case of Manickam alias Thandapani and
another vrs. Vasantha reported in 2022 SCC OnLine SC 2096. Learned
counsel for the petitioner has taken this Court to the discussion on the newly
added provisions of Section 22 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963 and the
decisions on this point. He submits that the Apex Court has in a similar
situation relating to delivery of possession at the stage of execution arising out
of a decree for specific performance of the contract discussed the divergence of
opinions in the regime prior to the enactment of the Act as to whether relief of
possession is to be specifically claimed and the judgments of the Apex Court
and thereafter come to a conclusion that the provisions of Section 22 though
couched in a negative language are not mandatory in view of the proviso of
sub-section (2) which allows the plaintiff to amend the plaint on such terms as
may be just for including a claim for such relief "at any stage of the
proceeding". The Apex Court also held that the expression "at any stage of the
proceeding" would include plaintiff to seek relief of possession even at the
appellate stage or in execution even if such prayer was required to be claimed.
It is submitted that in similar circumstances, the Apex Court set aside the order
passed by the High Court denying relief at the execution stage and directed the
Executing Court to ensure that decree is executed even if there is a construction
on any part of the land agreed to be sold, and the possession is delivered in
accordance with law. It is submitted that the learned trial Court was oblivious
of the legal position and as such, committed an error of jurisdiction which
requires to be corrected in exercise of the powers under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India.
8.
I have considered the submission of learned counsel for the
petitioner in the background of the relevant facts, pleadings, relief claimed by
the plaintiff/petitioner and the judgment rendered by the learned trial Court in
T.S. No.04 of 2020 granting the decree of specific performance of the
agreement for sale in favour of the petitioner.
9.
It, however, appears that though a relief for delivery of possession
was specifically claimed by the plaintiff/petitioner but no specific relief was
granted in favour of the petitioner. The suit was decreed without contest. The
petitioner has thereafter sought correction of the decree invoking Sections 151
and 152 of the CPC for incorporating the relief of handing over the possession
of the suit land though it was not specifically granted by the learned trial Court.
In this regard, the opinion of the Apex Court in the cited case of Manickam
alias Thandapani and another (supra) is profitable to be quoted hereinafter.
The facts of the case of Manickam alias Thandapani and another (supra)
indicate that the appellants had approached the Apex Court against the order
dated 14.03.2017 passed by the High Court of Judicature at Madras whereby
the Execution Petition filed by the appellants/decree holders to seek possession
of the property of which sale deed was executed in their favour was found to be
not maintainable. The respondent-defendant being the owner of the vacant plot
measuring 2400 sq. feet had entered into a sale agreement with the appellants.
One of the conditions in the agreement was that the respondent would
handover vacant possession of the suit property to the appellants. The
appellants filed a suit seeking specific performance of the said agreement and
directing the respondent to execute the sale after receiving the balance sale
consideration, failing which the Court may execute the sale deed in favour of
the appellants. The respondent filed a written statement claiming that there
cannot be a sale of any vacant plot unless the competent authority under the
Urban Land Ceiling enactment gives the necessary permission. The respondent
admitted the agreement and averred that the appellants had failed to take steps
for permission from the competent authority. In the additional statement filed
on 29.03.1985, the respondent pleaded that she sold another plot to one
Lakshmipathy in order to discharge the debt of Lakshmipathy. The learned trial
Court vide order dated 27.11.1985 declined to grant decree for specific
performance but granted nominal damages of Rs.5,000/- to the appellants and
recovery of the amount deposited. The First Appellate Court decreed the suit
while setting aside the decree passed by the learned trial Court and the
appellants were given time for depositing the balance sale consideration. The
intra-court appeal preferred by the respondent was also dismissed. The Special
Leave Petition against the said order was also dismissed. The appellants
deposited the balance sale consideration but the respondent did not come
forward to execute the sale deed. Thereafter, the representative of the learned
Executing Court executed the sale deed on 26.04.2007 with the following
assertions:
"NOW by this deed of sale the property fully described in the
schedule hereunder is hereby transferred, conveyed and assigned to
the purchasers with all privileges, easements and advantages
whatsoever to the said property to be occupied and enjoyed with
absolute right, title and interest without any claim of demand
whatsoever to any one, free from all encumbrances.
THE PURCHASERS shall hereafter peacefully and quietly
possess and enjoy the property, described hereunder without any
interruption or disturbances whatsoever from the vendors or any
person claiming through her."
10.
Thereafter, the appellants filed Execution Petition No.60 of 2009
for directing the respondent to put the decree-holders in possession of the
property conveyed. Such application was resisted on the ground that it had
been filed under Order XXI Rule 35(3) of the Civil Procedure Code, 1908
which deals with delivery of possession of any building but does not include
vacant site. The application was required to be filed under Order XXI Rule
35(4). It was also pointed out that as per the decree-holders the plot was not a
vacant land and had a pucca brick built double-storey house property and the
judgment debtor was only in possession of 750 sq. feet. Such application was
allowed by the Executing Court holding that since the plaintiff/petitioner had
already obtained a decree of specific performance and the sale deed was also
executed in their favour and as per the sale deed, the Court was of the opinion
that the petitioner/decree holders are entitled for the relief of delivery of
possession. Therefore, the respondent is liable to hand over possession of the
property to the petitioners/decree holders as per the decree. The appeal against
the said order was dismissed. Thereafter, the respondent preferred a petition
under Article 227 of the Constitution of India which was allowed by the High
Court on the ground that no decree was granted to the appellants in respect of
delivery of possession to the decree holders. Therefore, the execution for
delivery of possession is not maintainable. The Apex Court after dealing with
the provisions of Section 22 of the Specific Relief Act which was added upon
recommendation of the Law Commission in its 9th Report submitted on 19th
July, 1958 also noticed the provisions of Section 28(3) & (4) and Section
55(1)(f) of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882. It also considered the
divergence of opinions in the regime prior to the enactment of the Act as to
whether relief of possession is to be specifically claimed and after discussing
the decisions for and against on this proposition came to the following
conclusion which are being profitably extracted hereunder:
"24. The learned Single Bench in the impugned judgment herein has
not taken into consideration the judgment of the Madras High Court
in Krishnamurthy Gounder v. Venkatakrishnan. The said judgment
arose on the fact that the plaintiff filed the suit for Specific
Performance of an Agreement of Sale and also for recovery of
possession but the decree for possession was not granted. The Court
held as under:
“6. In the Judgment of this Court reported in S.
Sampoornam v. P.V. Kuppuswamy, (2007) 3 CTC 529, also the
same principles are reiterated and it was held that even in the
absence of any prayer for possession once a Suit for Specific
Performance is decreed the Court has got every power to order
delivery of possession. Further, according to me, the Court has
got power to grant the relief of possession even in the absence
of any such prayer as per the proviso to Section 22(2) of the
Specific Relief Act the Court shall at any stage of the
proceedings allow the Plaintiff to amend the Plaint to include
the relief. In my opinion, a discretion is vested on the Court to
allow the amendment and even in the absence of any prayer and
even in the absence of any Application for amendment, the
Court can grant the relief of recovery of possession once the
Suit is decreed for Specific Performance. These aspects were
not properly appreciated by the Court below and the Court
below approached the Application in a pedantic manner and
dismissed the application without appreciating the Judgments of
the Hon'ble Supreme Court and of our High Court.”
25. A perusal of the aforesaid judgments would show that relief of
possession is ancillary to the decree for specific performance and need
not be specifically claimed. That was the position even under the
Specific Relief Act, 1877. Section 22 of the Act was introduced in
pursuance of the recommendation of the Law Commission to avoid
multiplicity of proceedings and to cut down the delay. Therefore,
though the preponderance of judicial opinions under the Specific
Relief Act, 1877 was in favour of the fact that relief of possession is
ancillary to the decree for specific performance, it was further clarified
by introducing Section 22 of the Act.
26. The matter can be examined from another angle as well. Section
22(2) of the Act, though is worded in negative language, “no relief
under clause (a) or clause (b) of sub-section (1) shall be granted by the
court unless it has been specifically claimed”, but the proviso takes out
the mandatory nature from the substantive provision of sub-section (2)
when the plaintiff is allowed to amend the plaint on such terms as may
be just for including the plaint for such relief “at any stage of the
proceeding”. “At any stage of the proceeding” would include the
proceeding in suit or in appeal and also in execution. The proviso to
sub-section (2) of Section 22 of the Act contemplates that the Court
shall, at any stage of the proceedings, allow the plaintiff to amend the
plaint on such terms as may be just for including a claim for such
relief. The said proviso makes the provision directory as no penal
consequences follow under sub-section (2) of Section 22. Therefore,
sub-section (2) of Section 22 is a rule of prudence to ask for
possession “in an appropriate case”. The appropriate case would not
include a suit for specific performance simpliciter but may include a
suit for partition or a suit when the decree is to be executed against a
transferee. Sub-section (2) cannot be said to be a mandatory provision
as the power to claim relief at any stage of the proceeding makes subsection (2) directory. Sub-section (2) is a matter of procedure to avoid
multiplicity of proceedings. The procedural laws are handmaid of
justice and cannot defeat the substantive rights. Reference may be
made to Ganesh Trading Co. v. Moji Ram wherein it was held as
under:
“2. Procedural law is intended to facilitate and not to obstruct
the course of substantive justice. Provisions relating to
pleadings in civil cases are meant to give to each side intimation
of the case of the other so that it may be met, to enable courts to
determine what is really at issue between parties, and to prevent
deviations from the course which litigation on particular causes
of action must take.”
xxx
xxx
xxx
29. To examine whether a provision is directory or mandatory, one
of the tests is that the court is required to ascertain the real intention of
the legislature by carefully attending to the whole scheme of the
statute. Keeping in view the scheme of the statute, we find that Section
22(2) of the Act is only directory and thus, the decree-holder cannot be
non-suited for the reason that such relief was not granted in the decree
for specific relief.
30. The defendant in terms of the agreement is bound to handover
possession of the land agreed to be sold. The expression “at any stage
of proceeding” is wide enough to allow the plaintiffs to seek relief of
possession even at the appellate stage or in execution even if such
prayer was required to be claimed. This Court in Babu Lal has
explained the circumstances where relief of possession may be
necessary such as in a suit for partition or in a case of separate
possession where the property conveyed is a joint property. In the suit
for specific performance, the possession is inherent in such suit,
therefore, we find that the decree-holders are in fact entitled to
possession in pursuance of the sale deed executed in their favor.
31. The judgment debtor in the written statement has admitted that
the property is a vacant land and that she has sold other portion in
favor of one Lakshmipathy. The stand of the judgment debtor now that
the respondent is in possession of 750 sq. feet would not defeat the
right of possession of 2400 sq. feet of an area which she has agreed to
sell to the plaintiffs in respect of which decree was passed. All sales
affected, and the construction, if any, raised are subject to lis pendens
and no legal or equitable rights arise in favour of the purchasers during
the pendency of the proceedings. Therefore, the decree-holders are
entitled to actual physical possession of 2400 sq. feet of land which
was agreed to be sold to the appellants.
32. The appeal is thus allowed. The order passed by the High Court
is hereby set aside. The Executable Court shall ensure that such decree
is executed and if any construction is raised on any part of the land
agreed to be sold, the possession shall be delivered with or without
construction in accordance with law."
11.
It is thus clear that the ancillary relief of delivery of possession in
a suit for specific performance can be claimed at any stage including that of the
execution. In the instant case, the petitioner/plaintiff had prayed for the
ancillary relief of delivery of possession of the suit land besides asking for the
substantive relief of execution of the agreement by the defendant upon deposit
of the balance amount of consideration by the plaintiff. The learned trial Court
decreed the suit by directing the defendant to execute the registration of the
sale deed in respect of the suit land after taking balance consideration money
from the plaintiff but failed to grant the ancillary relief of delivery of
possession without which the execution of the registration of the sale deed on
the part of the defendant could be only a paper transaction. The learned trial
Court, however, refused to amend the decree on the ground that such a prayer
cannot be allowed on the ground that Section 152 of the CPC provides for
amendment of the judgments, decrees or orders only for correction of clerical
or arithmetical mistakes or accidental slip or omission. The opinion of the
Apex Court rendered in the case of Manickam alias Thandapani and another
(supra), however, makes the legal position clear that such a prayer can also be
made at the stage of execution of the decree in a case for specific performance
of the agreement for sale even if not claimed by the plaintiff during the
proceedings of the trial.
11.
In the present case, the plaintiff had made a prayer for delivery of
possession after execution of the sale deed which the learned trial Court
perhaps inadvertently failed to allow. In such circumstances, the impugned
order dated 12.12.2022 passed by the learned Civil Judge (Senior Division),
Khowai in case No. Title Suit 04 of 2020 be set aside. The matter is remitted to
the learned trial Court to consider the application of the petitioner for
correction of the decree in accordance with law.
12.
Accordingly, the revision petition stands allowed and disposed of.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
Pulak
2024.01.09
PULAK BANIK Date:
17:46:42 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review