Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA No.22 of 2021
Sri Kabindra Chandra Paul
S/o- Lt. Kamini Mohan Paul
Resident of Khowai Town
P.O-Khowai-799201
P.S-Khowai, Dist.-Khowai Tripura
….Defendant-Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Sri Kanai Lal Paul
2. Sri Jyotirmoy Paul
Both are sons of Lt. Kamini Mohan Paul
Both are residents of Khowai Town,
P.O-Khowai-799201, P.S-Khowai
Dist.-Khowai Tripura
….Plaintiff-Respondent(s)
For the Appellant(s)
:
Mrs. S. Deb(Gupta), Advocate
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharyya, Advocate
Date of hearing
and delivery of
judgment & order
Whether fit for
reporting
02.05.2023
:
:
No
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Judgment and Order (Oral)
Heard Mrs. S. Deb (Gupta), learned counsel appearing for the
appellant. Also heard Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharyya, learned counsel
appearing for the respondents.
This is a second appeal preferred by the appellant, the original
defendant to the suit, against the judgment dated 31.08.2021 and decree
dated 08.09.2021, passed by the learned Addl. District Judge, West
Tripura, Agartala in Title Appeal No. 25/2018, reversing the original
judgment dated 07.07.2018 and decree dated 13.07.2018, passed by the
learned Civil Judge, Agartala, West Tripura, in Title Suit No.36/2006.
2.
The facts of the case as projected by learned first appellate Court
are reproduced here-in-below:
“2.
For
convenience
plaintiffs-appellants
are
hereinafter may be referred as plaintiffs and defendantrespondent
may
be
referred
as
defendant.
The brief fact of the plaintiffs‟ case is that total
land 10 ganda 3 kara and 9 dhurs as mentioned in schedule-1
of the plaint was joint property. By way of registered partition
deed (No.1-1965 dated 11.06.1984) plaintiffs jointly got
schedule-2 land (eastern portion) measuring 4 ganda and 2
kara specifically described in the 3rd schedule of partition deed
by boundary having L -pattern building thereon but by guess
work quantum of the land is mentioned as 3 ganda 1 kara 10
dhurs. It is also pleaded that defendant got schedule-3 land of
plaint measuring 6 ganda, 1 kara, 1 kranta and 5 dhurs having
cloth shop and candle factory namely “Maa Candle factory” by
partition and described in 5th schedule of partition deed. The
joint pathway has been described in schedule-4 of the plaint
measuring 1 ganda, 1 kranta, 14 dhurs and described in 3rd, 5th
and 7th schedule of partition deed. L-pattern building was let
out to the sales emporium namely “Priyadarshani” and United Bank
and for the security of United Bank a Kacca Kitchen was
constructed behind the cloth shop building i.e., on the west
side of the cloth shop building. In the partition deed it is
mentioned that as the said kitchen fell on the share of the
land of defendant, the defendant should shift the kitchen to
the vacant portion of the land of the plaintiffs as said kitchen
was being used by the security guard of the bank who is the
tenant of the plaintiffs and, accordingly, the defendant shifted
the said kitchen to the vacant portion land of the plaintiffs.
Plaintiffs further pleaded that after partition plaintiffs and
defendant and other sharers have been possessing their
respective land without any disturbance and objection from
others. Specifically, it is pleaded that the plaintiffs have been
possessing and enjoying the L-pattern building by taking total
rent and the kitchen (shifted on the land of the plaintiffs)
without any objection. The defendant used to collect rent on
behalf of plaintiffs of L-pattern building and used to pay the
same to the plaintiffs on the basis of power of attorney and
never raised any objection and plaintiffs rebuked the power of
attorney on 08.05.2006. The cause of action arose when on
09.05.2006 the defendant has written a letter to the tenant of
L-pattern building stating that tenants have been paying rent
to the plaintiffs continuously since after partition and raised
claim. It is also pleaded that the defendant illegally mutated
the joint pathway (Schedule-4 land of plaint) and a part of the
land of plaintiffs in his name. It is further pleaded that on the
basis of wrong quantum of land mentioned in the partition
deed and wrong mutation, the defendant has claimed 824
sq.ft area of the L-pattern building of the plaintiff covered by
boundary. It is further pleaded that in the month of December,
2005 when plaintiff No.2 tried to repair the said kitchen the
defendant raised objection. Hence, plaintiffs filed TS 36 of
2006.
3.
The
suit
of
the
plaintiffs
was
contested
by
defendant by filing written statement denying the plea of the
plaintiff and, inter-alia, pleaded that by way of partition the
plaintiff only got land measuring 3 ganda, 1 kara 10 dhurs
land as per partition deed and accordingly mutation was done
and 846 sq.ft area of the L-pattern building falls into the share
of defendant and beyond the share of plaintiffs but the benefit
of the said part of the building has been denied to the
defendant for long time by plaintiffs and till date share of the
defendant in the L-pattern building has not been given to the
defendant and enjoyed by the plaintiffs unlawfully for long
time. It is further pleaded that as in the partition the quantum
of the land of the plaintiffs are mentioned as 3 ganda, 1 kara,
10 dhurs, the plaintiffs cannot claim more land defeating the
partition deed being barred by time, acquiescence and
estoppel. It is the clear plea of the defendant that the entire Lpattern building cannot be the land of the plaintiffs as it
occupies more than land 3 ganda, 1 kara, 10 dhurs and excess
part of the building beyond the land measuring 3 ganda, 1
kara, 10 dhurs is the building of defendant. It is further
pleaded that the security guard of the United Bank has been
using the latrine situated within the land of the defendant as
per partition deed and the same was not shifted to the land of
the plaintiffs as till date plaintiffs have not shown any area of
land for shifting the latrine. Thus, it is the plea of the
defendant that the kitchen as alleged by the plaintiffs is in the
land of the defendant.
The defendants claimed that he is the owner of the
share of the building measuring 846 sq.ft and entitled to get
rent of the said share and accordingly intended to file counter
claim. It is also pleaded by the defendant that reliance cannot
be given on the boundary description and boundary described
cannot be determining factor without looking into the
quantum of the area mentioned in the partition deed and the
plaintiffs themselves mutated their share of 0.062 acre land
and never raised any claim more than that area and,
therefore, the suit filed by plaintiffs is liable to be dismissed.
4.
The
trial
court
framed
following
issues
for
consideration:(i) whether the suit land is attracted by the boundary of
the schedule-2 of the deed of partition;
(ii) Whether at the time of partition, possession of the
respective sharers were taken over by the plaintiffs together in
schedule-2 and the defendant in schedule-3 of the said deed
of partition;
(iii) Whether the defendant was appointed as attorney
by the plaintiff No.1;
(iv) Whether the defendant realised rent from the bank
for and on behalf of the plaintiff No.1 in regard to the entire
building;
(v) Whether the defendant paid the said amount as
realised by him to plaintiff No.1 since 1984 to April, 2006;
(vi) Whether the land under present(Hal) dag No.4613
of, Khatian No.79 standing in the name of defdt is a part of the
common path;
(vii) What other relief/reliefs parties are entitled to?
5. Initially, the Ld. Trial Court by Judgment dated
31.03.2011 allowed the suit of the plaintiff with a declaration
that plaintiffs are owner of whole schedule-2 land of plaint and
injuncted the defendant and it was also declared that
schedule-4 land is joint pathway. In appeal the Ld. First
Appellate Court by Judgment dated 28.07.2012 allowed the
appeal and set aside the Judgment of the Ld. Trial Court
mainly considering the discrepancy of the schedule land as in
the first schedule there is only land measuring 10 ganda, 3
kara, 9 dhurs but total land shown in schedule-2, 3 and 4
comes to 12 ganda, 1 kara, 1 kranta and 19 dhurs and thus
plaintiffs have shown erroneous land in schedule-2 claiming
excess land more than allotted to plaintiffs by partition deed.
The appellate court also came to the conclusion that the
kitchen
is
situated
on
the
land
of
the
defendant.
On second appeal, the Hon‟ble High Court of Tripura by Judgment
dated
08.04.2016
in
RSA
of
set
aside the Judgment of the first appellate court and trial court
and remanded the case to the trial court to appoint a survey
commissioner to find out how much land is attracted by the
plinth area of the building which houses the United Bank of
India or the Priyadarshani Emporium vis-a-vis the third
schedule of the partition deed and the fifth schedule of the
partition deed and to pass fresh judgment and decree. The
operative part of the direction of the Hon‟ble High Court of
Tripura runs as follows:“10. Having held so, this court is inclined to interfere
with the Judgment of the first appellate court as well as of
the trial court and both the Judgments are set aside. The
case is remanded to the trial court only for purpose of
appointing a Survey Commissioner and to get a report from
the Survey Commissioner as to the land attracted by the
plinth area of the building which houses the United Bank of
India or the Priyadarshini Emporium vis-a-vis the 3rd
Schedule of the partition deed and the 5th schedule of the
partition deed. The trial court is given liberty to formulate
the reference having due regard to the issues as framed
and, in particular, to the arrangement made in the partition
deed. After the report from the Survey Commissioner is
considered in accordance with law, the trial court shall pass
a fresh judgment and decree. The parties will be afforded
scope to take their own defences in respect of the report of
the Survey Commissioner”.
6. On remand, the Ld. Trial Court obtained report by
appointing Survey Commissioner and by Judgment dated
07.07.2018 decided Issue No.(i),(ii) and (vi) in affirmative but
issue No.(iii) in negative. The Ld. Trial Court while deciding
issue No.(iv) and (v) opined that as per report of survey
commissioner plot No.1 to 4 attracts the second schedule of
partition deed and plot No.5 and 6 attracts 3rd and 5th schedule
of the partition deed and in the L-pattern building there is
excess land measuring 1 ganda, 1 kara, 1 kranta and 15 dhurs
beyond the share of plaintiffs. The Ld. Court while deciding the
issue No.(vii) also came to the conclusion that excess land
more or less 1 ganda, 1 kranta and 15 dhurs is also covered
by the L-pattern building which is beyond the land mutated in
the name of the plaintiffs and as per partition deed the
plaintiffs are only entitled to 3 ganda, 1 kara and 5 dhurs of
the L-pattern building. Thus Ld. Trial Court passed decree
declaring that plaintiffs are owner of land measuring 3 ganda,
1 kara, 5 dhurs only and not of excess land measuring 1
ganda, 1 kranta and 15 dhurs and accordingly the defendant
was restrained from disturbing the possession of the plaintiff
of land measuring 3 ganda, 1 kara and 5 dhurs. Ld. Trial Court
also declared that the schedule 4 land is the joint pathway of
plaintiffs and defendant.”
3.
In addition to the issues formulated by the learned trial Court, the
first appellate Court had drawn up the following two points for
determination:
“(a) Whether this court has territorial jurisdiction to decide appeal?
(b) Whether plaintiffs are owners of the whole L-pattern building and
the land described in plot No.1 to 5 of the report of the survey
commissioner?
4.
In determining the above points, learned first appellate Court had
passed the following order:
“_O__R__D__E__R_____
In the result, the appeal is allowed and, the judgment dated
07.07.2018 and decree dated 13.07.2018 passed by Learned Civil Judge
(Sr. Division), Court No.2, West Tripura, Agartala in TS 36/2006 is
modified as below.
It is hereby declared that plaintiffs have right, title and interest
over the whole L-pattern building and the land of plot No.1 to 5 of the
report of survey commissioner dated 31.08.2017(in three sheets).
Accordingly,the defendant is perpetually injuncted and restrained
from disturbing the possession of the plaintiffs over said building and
land.
It is also declared that the plaintiffs and defendant are joint
owner of the schedule-4 land of plaint. This appeal is disposed of on
contest. Prepare appellate decree accordingly.
The report of survey commissioner dated 31.08.2017 shall form
part of the decree.
Send down the LC Record along with a copy of this Judgment
and decree.
Make entry in Trial register and upload in CIS.”
5.
For convenience, the findings and order passed by the learned trial
Judge may also be reproduced here-in-below:
“ISSUE No. VII:The point to be decided under this issue is what other
relief/reliefs parties are entitled.
As it has already been discuses earlier that the documentary
evidence marked as exhibit 3 is the main source of document in the suit on
which the parties claming their respective shares relies upon, so, from
that source of evidence, it is found that, at the time of the execution of the
said document, parties made some commitment against each other to
fulfill the very language of the recital of the said deed.
As per shares mentioned in exhibit 3, the shares of the plaintiffs
jointly are specifically described in third schedule and seventh schedule
of the said document and the portion of the share of the defendant has
been clearly described in the fifth schedule of the said document. It also
appears from the record that none of the parties in the suit denied about
the portion of the share mentioned in the document marked as exhibit 3.
The portion of the share of the plaintiffs jointly is mentioned in schedule 2
of the plaint, under which also falls the „L‟ patent building comprising
their shares of three gandas, one kranta and five dhurs. Accordingly,
plaintiffs entered their names in the record of rights as per the said
amount of land allotted to them as per the document marked as exhibit 3.
Whereas, the measurement of the entire portion of the said „L‟ patent
building covers around four gandas and two karas, in local measurement
i.e. measuring more or less 0.09 acres. So, in view of the above
calculation there is an excess land of more or less one ganda, one kara,
one kranta and fifteen dhurs. The question and the dispute in between the
parties in the suit lies in this instant excess land area. However, the
language of the recital of the partition deed (exhibit 3) shows that
plaintiffs are jointly entitled to only three gandas, one kara and five dhurs
in the said plot of „L‟ patent building.
All the respective shares of the co-sharers of the document of
partition deed (exhibit 3) including the parties in the suit are clearly
mentioned and demarcated therein and cannot go beyond what has been
mentioned or described therein.
Hence, this court finds no any relief to the parties in the suit
beyond the entitlement of the register partition deed which has been
marked as exhibit 3 in the suit.
Therefore, issue no. VII is also decided accordingly.
9.
In the light of threadbare discussions made above on several
issues and points, it is clearly established that parties are not entitled to
any decree or relief in the suit.
In view of the issue-wise discussion made above, I hereby pass
the final order in the suit which is as follows:-
10.
In the result, this suit stands decreed partially in favour of the
plaintiffs on contest without cost.
11.
The plaintiffs has the right and title over the land measuring 3
gandas, 1 kranta and 5 dhurs of the land mentioned in Schedule-2 of the
plaint, but is not entitled to the right and title over excess or balance land
measuring 1 ganda, 1 kara and 15 dhurs in Schedule-2 of the plaint.
The defendant, his men and agents are also perpetually
restrained from disturbing the peaceful possession over the land
measuring 3 gandas, 1 kara and 5 dhurs mentioned in Schedule-2 of the
plaint.
The suit is also decreed with the declaration that the plaintiffs
and the defendant has right and title jointly over the land of Schedule-4 of
the plaint which is used as their common path-way.
Sheristadar of this Establishment is hereby directed to prepare
the preliminary decree accordingly and put up the same before me for
seal and signature within 15 days latest by 21-07-2018.”
6.
Considering the controversy raised in this suit, I deemed it fit and
proper to cause an appearance of the parties to the suit. Today both the
appellant and the plaintiffs have personally appeared before this Court.
This Court has an opportunity to interact with both the brothers (i.e. the
plaintiff/respondents and the defendant/appellant). During the course of
interaction, it comes to fore that under the partition deed the
plaintiffs/respondent is entitled to get share of a land measuring 3 gandas,
1 kara and 5 dhurs, but he physically has been possessing a building
measuring 3 gandas, 3 krantas and 11 dhurs, which is an admitted fact.
7.
I have specifically asked the defendant/appellant as to whether he
has any objection or claim over the land, the plaintiffs have been
possessing in excess of the land that mentioned in the partition deed. The
defendant/appellant has fairly stated and conveyed to this Court that since
the plaintiffs are his younger brothers, he has no objection and he will
never raise any claim in the peaceful possession of the excess land
possessed by the plaintiffs. The plaintiffs have further conveyed to this
Court that they will not demand more land other than the land they have
been possessing i.e. 3 gandas, 3 krantas and 11 dhurs. The
plaintiff/respondents have also admitted that as per condition of the
partition deed, the security guard room and kitchen have been relocated at
the cost of defendant/appellant to the land of the plaintiff/respondents as
per the stipulation in the partition deed. Since the construction in
whichever form, whether it is kitchen or the security guard room, has
already been shifted to the land of the sixth party, so, the
defendant/appellant may clean his land in the manner he wishes and in that
case, the plaintiffs shall never raise any objection.
8.
In view of the above interaction and the settlement arrived at
between the parties, both the parties appeared before this Court have
agreed to settle the controversy raised in this appeal in the manner as
indicated here-in-above.
In the light of above, the instant appeal stands disposed in the
manner as indicated here-in-above. Decree may be drawn accordingly.
JUDGE
Snigdha
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review