Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
A.B.No.65 of 2025
1. Sri Jhutan Saha,
son of Late Birendra Saha
of Ramkrishna para, East Pratapgarh,
P.S. East Agartala, District-West Tripura
2. Sri Nandan Ghosh,
son of Ranjit Ghosh
of Rikshaw Tilla, Subhash Nagar,
P.S. East Agartala, District-West Tripura
---- Accused Petitioners(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura,
----Respondent(s)
______________________________________________________
For Applicant(s)
: Mr. Samrat Ghosh, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Raju Datta, P.P.
________________________________________________________
[---
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Order
04/09/2025
This pre-arrest bail application is filed by the two
petitioner accused namely Sri Jhutan Saha and Sri Nandan Ghosh
for granting them pre-arrest bail in connection with East Agartala
P.S. Case No.75/25 under Section 406/420/506/34 of IPC.
[02]
Heard Learned counsel, Mr. S. Ghosh appearing on
behalf of the petitioner accused and also heard Learned P.P., Mr.
R. Datta appearing on behalf of the State-respondent. As ordered,
Learned P.P. has produced the CD.
[03]
At the time of hearing, Learned counsel for the
petitioner accused drawn the attention of this Court that this
present case is not maintainable against the present petitioner
accused persons because the dispute completely relates to civil
nature and admittedly, there was an agreement in between the
informant of this case and two other persons i.e. one Bidhan
(2)
Sarkar and Jhutan Saha who is one of the petitioner herein for
selling of land measuring .050 acres i.e. 2 gandas 2 karas for an
amount of Rs.7,00,000/- and in the agreement it was stipulated
that within eleven months the agreement would be settled and
those persons namely Jhutan Saha and Bidhan Sarkar would
execute the deed. But surprisingly, within the stipulated period,
the informant could not pay the amount. However, Rs.80,000/was returned back to the informant of this case but the rest
amount could not be returned back because the said money was
utilized for the purpose of development and there was no malafide
intention on behalf of the present petitioner accused persons but
the police is harassing the present petitioners and as such, they
have prayed for issuing notice to the accused persons under
Section 41(a) of Cr.P.C. and for granting the concession of pre
arrest bail.
[04]
On the other hand, Learned P.P. strongly opposed the
submission made by Learned counsel for the accused petitioner
and submitted that there is clear evidence of commission of
offence punishable under Section 420 of IPC against the present
petitioners and Learned Sessions Judge rightly considering the
materials on record rejected the bail application and as such,
there is no scope at this stage to consider the bail application filed
by the present petitioner accused persons and urged for dismissal
of the same.
[05]
The prosecution case in short is that the informant of
this case laid one complaint to the Court of Learned CJM, Agartala
alleging inter alia that he entered into an agreement on
(3)
September, 2019 to purchase a piece of land from one Jhutan
Saha and Bidhan Sarkar for a consideration price of Rs.7,00,000/and accordingly advance payment of Rs.80,000/- was paid and it
was agreed that the informant will pay the rest amount of
consideration price within eleven months from the date of signing
the agreement and thereafter, those persons will execute the
deed. On 01.09.2020, another additional payment of Rs.50,000/was paid to Jhutan Saha which was acknowledged by him. After
that on 07.02.2021, another amount of Rs.2,00,000/- was given
to one Nandan Ghosh i.e. one of the petitioner herein i.e. the
brother in law of Jhutan Saha. Said Rs.2,00,000/- was paid to Sri
Nandan Ghosh by the informant as Bidhan Saha and Jhutan
Sarkar orally requested the informant to pay the said money to
him and the same was acknowledged by said Nandan Ghosh and
in total the informant paid Rs.3,30,000/-. But despite the passage
of time, registration process was delayed due to different plea
taken by the accused petitioner No.1 and Bidhan Sarkar and as
such, the informant demanded for returning back the amount. But
they failed to fulfill the request. Thereafter, he approached to
nearby club when Bidhan Sarkar returned back Rs.80,000/- on
01.09.2023 and submitted that the remaining amount was since
taken by Sri Jhutan Saha. But Jhutan Saha denied to receive the
amount of Rs.2,50,000/- and also he denied about taking of any
money by Sri Nandan Ghosh amounting to Rs.2,00,000/-. He
submitted a complaint to East Agartala P.S. but no case was
registered and after that he made a request to SP but no action
was taken and after that he has filed complaint to the Court of
(4)
Learned CJM which was sent to O/C of the concerned P.S. for
investigation and accordingly, the present case was registered.
[06]
At the time of hearing, Learned counsel for the
petitioner accused relied upon one citation of Hon’ble Supreme
Court of India in V.Y. Jose and Another versus State of
Gujarat and Another reported in (2009) 3 SCC 78 wherein in
para Nos.12, 13 and 14 Hon’ble Apex Court observed as under :
“12. Ordinarily, we would not have referred to the
correspondences
passed
between
the
parties
but,
indisputably, the said correspondences have been referred to
in the complaint petition itself. Even before us, a contention
had been raised by Mr. Jain that the appellants' letter dated
7.4.1998 was not replied to.
13. Section 415 of the Indian Penal Code defines cheating as
under :
"Section 415.--Cheating--Whoever, by deceiving any
person, fraudulently or dishonestly induces the
person so deceived to deliver any property to any
person, or to consent that any person shall retain
any property, or intentionally induces the person so
deceived to do or omit to do anything which he
would not do or omit if he were not so deceived, and
which act or omission causes or is likely to cause
damage or harm to that person in body, mind,
reputation or property, is said to `cheat'."
14. An offence of cheating cannot be said to have been made
out unless the following ingredients are satisfied :
"i) deception of a person either by making a false or
misleading representation or by other action or
omission;
(ii) fraudulently or dishonestly inducing any person
to deliver any property; or
(iii) To consent that any person shall retain any
property and finally intentionally inducing that
person to do or omit to do anything which he would
not do or omit."
For the purpose of constituting an offence of cheating, the
complainant is required to show that the accused had
fraudulent or dishonest intention at the time of making
promise or representation. Even in a case where allegations
are made in regard to failure on the part of the accused to
keep his promise, in absence of a culpable intention at the
time of making initial promise being absent, no offence
under Section 420 of the Indian Penal Code can be said to
have been made out.
He also
referred
another citation of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court of India in Uma Shankar Gopalika versus State
of Bihar and Another reported in 2004 SCC 375 wherein in
para No.6 Hon’ble Supreme Court observed as under :
“6” Now the question to be examined by us is as to whether
on the facts disclosed in the petition of complaint any criminal
offence whatsoever is made out much less offences under
(5)
Sections 420/120-B IPC. The only allegation in the complaint
petition against the accused persons is that they assured the
complainant that when they receive the insurance claim
amounting to Rs.4,20,000/-, they would pay a sum of
Rs.2,60,000 to the complainant out of that but the same has
never been paid. Apart from that there is no other allegation
in the petition of complaint. It was pointed out on behalf of
the complainant that the accused fraudulently persuaded the
complainant to agree so that the accused persons may take
steps for moving the Consumer Forum in relation to the claim
of Rs.4,20,000. It is well settled that every breach of contract
would not give rise to an offence of cheating and only in those
cases breach of contract would amount to cheating where
there was any deception played at the very inception. If the
intention to cheat has developed later on, the same cannot
amount to cheating. In the present case it has nowhere been
stated that at the very inception there was any intention on
behalf of the accused persons to cheat which is a condition
precedent for an offence under Section 420 IPC.”
Referring the same, Learned counsel submitted that
since the alleged allegation of the informant discloses dispute of
civil nature and as such, this present case is not maintainable and
he urged for granting pre-arrest bail to the present petitioner
accused persons.
[07]
To counter the submission, Learned P.P. submitted that
if prima facie it appears that the allegation of the informant
discloses dispute of civil nature still in this case there is material
against the petitioner accused Nandan Ghosh who took the money
with acknowledgment by putting his signature on reversed side of
the alleged agreement and this money was received by him at the
request of another petitioner Jhutan Saha. So, prima facie they
cannot escape from the liability of commission of offence
punishable under Section 420 of IPC.
[08]
I have perused the Court complaint which was later on
treated as FIR and also the statements of witnesses so far
recorded by IO in course of investigation under Section 161 of
Cr.P.C. Admittedly, there is no dispute on record regarding
execution of agreement on 20.09.2019 amongst the rival parties.
From the record it appears that the informant paid Rs.3,30,000/-
(6)
to the accused persons of the case out of which Rs.2,00,000/- was
received by Nandan Ghosh and by this time, one of the party to
the agreement Bidhan Sarkar refunded back Rs.80,000/- to the
informant of this case. Learned Sessions Judge at the time of
disposal of the pre-arrest bail application came to the observation
that by refunding the money the petitioner had admitted the
allegation of the informant and there were materials against
accused Nandan Ghosh in the CD.
[09]
At the time of hearing of argument, Learned counsel for
the petitioner accused made one alternative arguments that even
no notice was issued by the IO under Section 41-A of Cr.P.C. in
view of the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in
Arnesh Kumar versus State of Bihar.
[10]
However, after hearing both the parties the following
facts come before this Court :
(1) That there was agreement in respect of transfer of land
measuring 2 gandas 2 karas for an amount of Rs.7,00,000/- under
Mouja-Pratapgarh. (2) That the informant paid Rs.80,000/- to the
second parties namely Jhutan Saha and Bidhan Sarkar on
20.09.1999. (3) That the informant as alleged by him failed to
approach to the Civil Court when the second parties of the
agreement failed to fulfill the terms of agreement or the contract.
(4) The informant during subsistence of the agreement more paid
Rs.50,000/- to Jhutan Saha (5) Due to intervention of the local
club, one of the party of the agreement namely Bidhan Sarkar
refunded back Rs.80,000/- to the informant of this case (6) the
informant thereafter paid more Rs.2,00,000/- to one Nandan
(7)
Ghosh i.e. one of the petitioner of this case on 07.02.2021 at the
request of Jhutan Saha and Bidhan Sarkar. He also put his
signature on the reversed side of the agreement.
[11]
In course of hearing of argument, Learned counsel for
the accused petitioner admitted that they took the money but as
there was violation of terms and condition by the informant, so
they are not ready to refund back the money through this criminal
proceeding. I have also perused the CD. From the CD it appears
that the IO of this case in pursuance of the judgment of Arnesh
Kumar has not issued any notice to the petitioner namely Jhutan
Saha.
[12]
So, after hearing both the sides also it appears that the
informant could not take proper recourse of law in due course of
time. But at the same time, the accused persons also did not show
any proper gesture to refund back the money. The accused
Nandan Ghosh who is not party to the agreement also at the same
time defrauded the present informant of this case and as such, in
the considered opinion of this Court this is not a fit case to grant
concession of pre-arrest bail to the petitioner accused petitioner,
Nandan Ghosh and accordingly, his pre-arrest bail application
stands rejected and dismissed.
[13]
In respect of accused Jhutan Saha who was a party to
the agreement it appears that no notice was served upon him by
the IO in pursuance of the direction passed by Hon’ble Supreme
Court of India in Arnesh Kumar versus State of Bihar and as such,
the IO before taking any action against him shall serve notice
under Section 41-A of Cr.P.C. and thereafter shall proceed in
(8)
accordance with law. The subject matter of the citations as
referred by Learned counsel for the petitioner accused
are
distinguishable in facts and as such, the same principle in toto
cannot be applied in this case. However, it is also made clear that
the informant shall have the liberty to take proper recourse of law,
if he is so advised against the parties to the agreement.
With this observation, the present pre-arrest bail
application stands disposed of. Supply a copy of this order to
Learned counsel of the petitioner accused persons.
Return back the CD to the I/O through Learned P.P.
along with a copy of this order.
Send down the record of Learned Trial Court along with
a copy of this order.
With this observation, the present application stands
disposed of.
JUDGE
signed by
MOUMIT Digitally
MOUMITA DATTA
2025.09.05
A DATTA Date:
05:54:40 +05'30'
Sabyasachi B
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review