Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC:5459
WP No. 38906 of 2025
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 31ST DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR
WRIT PETITION NO. 38906 OF 2025 (GM-CPC)
BETWEEN:
1.
SRI J SANDEEP
S/O. SRI R. JAYADEV,
AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS,
RESIDING AT NO. D-79,
LAKSHMI ESWAR RAO BUILDING,
DOLLARS SCHEME COLONY,
CIRCULAR ROAD, NANDINI LAYOUT,
BANGALORE - 560 096.
…PETITIONER
(BY SRI. RAMESH CHANDRA, ADVOCATE)
AND:
Digitally signed
by
SHARADAVANI
B
Location: High
Court of
Karnataka
1.
M/S B.RAMALINGAPPA AND SONS
(A REGISTERED PARTNERSHIP FIRM),
HAVING ITS PLACE OF BUSINESS AT
NO. 48/1, 49/2, SHOP NOS.1 AND 2,
2ND MAIN ROAD, 2ND CROSS,
A.P.M.C (R.M.C YARD),
YESHWANTHPUR,
BANGALORE - 560 022.
REPRESENTED BY ITS
ALLEGED PARTNER
SRI N.S. MOHAMED RABBANI
2.
SRI N.S. MOHAMED RABBANI
S/O. LATE SRI SYED NAZIR AHMED,
AGED ABOUT 27 YEARS,
-2NC: 2026:KHC:5459
WP No. 38906 of 2025
HC-KAR
3.
MRS. RAZIYA BEGUM,
W/O. LATE MR. SYED BASHEER AHMED,
AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS,
4.
SRI SYED AMEEN,
S/O. LATE SRI SYED BASHEER AHMED,
AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS
5.
MRS. ASIYA BEGUM
W/O. LATE SRI SYED NAZIR AHMED,
AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS,
(RESPONDENTS 2 TO 5 CLAIMING ARE
PARTNERS OF RESPONDENT NO. 1 FIRM)
RESPONDENTS 2 TO 5,
R/AT NO. 48/1, AND 49/2
SHOP NO. 1, 2ND MAIN ROAD,
2ND CROSS, A.P.M.C. (R.M C YARD)
YESHWANTHPUR, BENGALURU, 560 022.
6.
SRI.R JAYADEV
S/O SRI B RAMALINGAPPA
AGED ABOUT 72 YEARS,
R/AT NO. 48, 8TH CROSS,
3RD MAIN, GANESH BLOCK,
MAHALAKSHMI LAYOUT,
BENGALURU 560 086.
7.
SRI J SATHISH
S/O M JAYADEV
AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS
R/AT NO. 48, 8TH CROSS,
3RD MAIN, GANESH BLOCK,
MAHALAKSHMI LAYOUT,
BENGALURU 560 086.
8.
THE BANK MANAGER
SRI. THAYAGARAJA CO-OPERATIVE
BANK LTD, N R COLONY
BENGALURU 560019
…RESPONDENTS
-3NC: 2026:KHC:5459
WP No. 38906 of 2025
HC-KAR
THIS WP IS FILED UNDER ARTICLE 227 OF THE
CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO CALLING FOR THE
RECORDS IN MIS 1643 OF 2022 ON THE FILE OF XII
ADDITIONAL CITY CIVIL AND SESSION JUDGE, BENGALURU
(CCH-27), BENGALURU, QUASH AND SET AIDE THE ORDER
DATED 8-10-2025 FILED UNDER ORDER IX RULE 4 READ WITH
SECTION 151 OF CODE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, IN MIS 1643 OF
2022 ON THE FILE OF XII ADDITIONAL CITY CIVIL AND
SESSION JUDGE, BENGALURU (CCH-27) AS PER ANNEXURE A
AND ETC.,
THIS PETITION, COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY
HEARING, THIS DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR
ORAL ORDER
This petition by respondent No.2 in Misc.No.1643/2022 is
directed against the impugned order dated 08.10.2025 passed
by the XII Additional City Civil and Sessions Judge, Bengaluru,
whereby the said petition filed by respondents Nos.1 to 5 under
Order IX Rule 4 of CPC seeking restoration of O.SNo.1007/2017
which was dismissed for non-prosecution on 19.11.2022 was
allowed by the trial Court.
2.
Heard
learned
counsel
perused the material on record.
for
the
petitioner
and
-4NC: 2026:KHC:5459
WP No. 38906 of 2025
HC-KAR
3.
A perusal of the material on record will indicate that
respondent Nos.1 to 5/plaintiffs instituted the aforesaid suit
against the petitioner/defendant No.2 and other defendants for
declaration, permanent injunction and other reliefs in relation
to the suit schedule immovable properties. The said suit was
posted before the trial Court on 19.11.2022, on which date the
trial Court dismissed the suit for non-prosecution. Subsequently
respondent Nos.1 to 5/plaintiffs having filed the
instant
Miscellaneous Petition seeking recalling of the said order and
for restoration of the suit, the trial Court recorded oral and
documentary evidence of both sides and proceeded to pass the
impugned order allowing the Miscellaneous Petition by holding
as under.
"ORDERS
The present petition filed by the petitioner
against the respondent under Order IX Rule 4 read
with Section 151 of CPC to restore the original suit
No. 1007/2017 and recall the order dated
19.11.2022 in the interest of justice and equity.
2.
The petitioner submitted that the suit was
Posted for further evidence of the plaintiff wherein
the plaintiff was supposed to file the necessary
documents and get the same marked before the
court. But the original documents pertaining to the
suit are kept in the safe custody of the court in OS
No.776/2015 which is pending before CCH 41. On
-5NC: 2026:KHC:5459
WP No. 38906 of 2025
HC-KAR
that ground, the petitioner are unable to produce the
document before this court in the original suit. Even
those
documents
are
not
marked
in
OS.No.776/2015. According to the petitioner,
petitioners filed an application under Section 151 of
CPC requesting the court to return the original
documents so as to enable the petitioners to produce
the same before this court in the original suit. But
that application came to be rejected informing the
petitioners that the original documents cannot be
returned until the disposal of the suit. Only on that
ground the petitioners disabling them from producing
the documents before this court and getting those
documents marked through plaintiff.
3.
When the documents are in the safe custody
before the Hon'ble Court in CCH 41, the petitioners
requested that matter may kindly be adjourned to
another date and enable them to lead evidence in
that matter pending on the file of the CCH 41, in
order to take the certified copies of the document.
But that request was denied and the suit came to be
dismissed for default. As such, the present petition
filed by the petitioner against the respondent.
According to the petitioner's, if the petition is not
allowed they will be put to irreparable hardship, loss,
injustice and substantial injury which cannot be
compensated in terms of money. On the other hand,
no injustice, hardship and inconvenience will be
caused to the respondent. Hence, prays for allowing
the petition in the interest of justice and equity and
also seeking order to recall the order dated
19.11.2022 and restore the original suit No.
1007/2017 to its original stage, in the interest of
justice and equity.
4.
After the service of notice to respondent Nos.1
and 3 through paper publication remained absent.
Hence both respondent Nos. 1 and 3 placed exparte.
Only respondent Nos.2 and 4 appeared before this
court. Only Respondent No. 2 files objection to the
-6NC: 2026:KHC:5459
WP No. 38906 of 2025
HC-KAR
main petition. Even though respondent No.4
appeared before the court through his counsel, but
not filed any objection to the main petition. As such,
as per order dated 31.03.2023 objection of
respondent no. 4 to the main petition taken as not
filed.
5.
The gist of the objection statements filed by
the respondent No.2 is as follows:- According to
respondent No.2, the present petition is not
maintainable either on law or on facts and
O.S.No.1007/2017 was dismissed for default, since
the plaintiff has failed to lead evidence and it is
dismissal when the defendant only appears. As such,
Order IX Rule 4 of CPC is not maintainable. On that
ground itself, the petition ought to have been
dismissed. According to Respondent No.2, the
dismissal of the suit after service of summons and
proper course is not filing an application under Order
IX Rule 4 of CPC. The petitioner has not given any
cause for their non appearance before the court on
that day.
6.
According to Respondent No.2, petitioners were
not present deliberately and despite paying costs,
they failed to lead evidence before the court. The
suit was dismissed due to gross negligence of the
plaintiffs and it cannot be restored for want of
sufficient cause for their non appearance before the
court and the date fixed for their evidence. The
petitioners have not given any reason for their non
appearance before the court. Hence, the suit was
dismissed for non prosecution. When the suit was
dismissed for default, it cannot be restored unless
valid and sufficient cause for their non appearance is
shown. Respondent No.2 submits that it is false that
when the suit was posted for further evidence of
plaintiff, the plaintiff was supposed to file the
necessary documents and get the same marked
before the court. In spite of, sufficient opportunity
given to the plaintiff to get back the documents but
-7NC: 2026:KHC:5459
WP No. 38906 of 2025
HC-KAR
not adduced the evidence. It is also denied that the
original documents are kept in the safe custody of
the court in OS No.776/2015. On that ground, the
petitioner is not able to produce those documents
before the court in suit. The respondent is not aware
of filing application seeking return of the document
and the rejection of that application. No further
action taken by the plaintiff to lead the evidence. If
the application is rejected, then the petitioner has
not challenged the order. Moreover, the petition filed
by the petitioner under Order IX Rule 4 read with
Section 151 of CPC is not maintainable. The
petitioners have not made out any sufficient grounds
for allowing the application. If the petition is allowed,
more injustice, inconvenience and loss caused the
respondent and no inconvenience and injustice will
be caused to the petitioner. On that ground, prays
for rejection of the petition in the interest of justice
and equity.
7.
In support of the case of the petitioners,
petitioner No.4 examined himself as PW1 and also
got marked Exhibit P1 to P3. On behalf of the
respondent, respondent No.2 examined as RW1 but
no document marked through RW1.
8.
The point for consideration on the basis of the
petition averments and objection is as follows:
1: Whether the petitioners have made
out ground for allowing the petition and
also recall order dated 19.11. 2022 in
OS No. 1007 of 2017 and to restore The
original suit to its original stage, for the
reason as stated in the petition
averments?
2: What order?
9. My answer to the point no. 1 is in the Affirmative for
the following:-
-8NC: 2026:KHC:5459
WP No. 38906 of 2025
HC-KAR
REASONS
10. According to the petitioners as well as the
evidence of PW1, petitioners have filed OS No.
1007/2017 against the respondents for the reason
that when the suit was posted for further evidence,
by that time the petitioners were supposed to file the
necessary documents and get the same marked
before this court. But the original documents
pertaining to the case were kept in safe custody of
the court in OS No. 776/2015, which was pending
before CCH 41. But the petitioners were unable to
produce those documents at the time of their
evidence. Even those documents are not marked in
OS.No.776/2015. The petitioners filed an application
under Section 151 of CPC requesting the court to
return the original documents so as to enable us to
produce the same before this court, but that
application came to be rejected informing the
petitioners that the original documents cannot be
returned until the disposal of the suit in
O.S.NO.776/2015. Only on that ground the
petitioners were unable to produce the document
before this court in the original suit. In support of
this oral evidence, PW1 has relied upon Ex.P1, the
certified copy of the application under Section 151 of
CPC. This application reflect that the petitioners
herein filed the above said application before CCH 41
in OS No. 776/2015 with request to return the
original documents produced by the plaintiff. The
affidavit annexed to the application in Para No.4, the
petitioners herein have categorically on oath
narrated that,
"it is submitted that at the time of
filing the case, the plaintiff have
produced all the original documents in
support of their case and those
documents yet to be marked as
exhibits. But however the plaintiffs
have also filed another suit
in
-9NC: 2026:KHC:5459
WP No. 38906 of 2025
HC-KAR
OS.No.1007/ 2017 pending on the file
of City Civil Court, CCH-27, Bangalore
and that case is finally posted for
evidence. Thereby, the documents
produced in this case, which are in safe
custody, which are yet to be marked,
may kindly be ordered to return the
same, in order to those documents in
the above said case, failing which the
plaintiff will be put to irreparable loss
and substantial injury for the reasons
that the learned judge CCH 27 has
posted the matter finally as last chance
on 19.11.2022 for evidence. "
11. In the application itself, the petitioner herein
requested the court, which reads thus:
In
the
above
said
facts
and
circumstances, it is just necessary that
the Hon'ble Court may be pleased to
order to return the documents produced
in this case, which are in safe custody,
and the plaintiff undertakes to file the
certified copies of those documents in
this
case
immediately
after
the
documents marked as exhibits, it would
be in the interest of justice to do so. "
Ex.P1 is the interlocutory application filed by the
petitioners herein on 18.11.2022 before CCH.41 in OS
No. 776/2015.
12. By keeping in mind these facts, on careful perusal of
the Ex.P2 certified copy of the order sheet in OS No.
776/2015 in the order sheet dated 18.11.2022, the office
endorsement reflect that advocate for plaintiff has filed an
application under Section 151 of CPC to advance the case
from 14.12.2022 to 18.11.2022. On that day itself, in the
order sheet, it reflects that this case is taken on today's
board on the advancement application. The counsel for
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC:5459
WP No. 38906 of 2025
HC-KAR
the plaintiff files application under Section 151 of CPC for
returning the original documents. The office endorsement
and the order sheet in OS No. 776/2015 itself goes to
show that the petitioners herein filed application under
Section 151 CPC before CCH 41 for return of the
documents in OS No.776/2015. On perusal of the order
sheet in OS No. 1007/2017 dated 19.11.2022, it reflect
that:Learned counsel for the defendant prays
time to lead plaintiff evidence. Learned
counsel for the defendant opposed to
grant an adjournment for the plaintiff
evidence on ground that this court
granted many adjournments even on
costs for plaintiff evidence. Despite the
fact stood thus the plaintiff seeking an
adjournment for plaintiff evidence. Thus
prays to dismiss the suit for default. By
virtue of the Submission of both the
plaintiff and defendant counsel. This
court ordered that, on perusal of the
order sheet, as rightly contended by the
learned counsel for the defendant since
10.08.2020, the matter is pending for
plaintiff's evidence. After that, on the
prayer of the plaintiff granted many
adjournments for plaintiff's evidence.
Even on the last date of hearing granted
time as last chance on costs. Despite
the fact stood thus, the plaintiff seeking
further adjournment. In fact, this court
found no genuine reason to grant
further
adjournment
for
plaintiff
evidence. Thus, the prayer of the
plaintiff is hereby rejected and suit is
dismissed for default.”
With the above said observation, the
dismissed the OS No. 1007/2017.
court
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC:5459
WP No. 38906 of 2025
HC-KAR
13. Ex.P1 reflect that the petitioner herein filed
application
under
Section
of
CPC
in
OS.No.776/2015 for returning of the document on
18.11.2022, but on 19.11.2022 the suit filed by the
plaintiff in OS No. 1007/15 dismissed by this court
for non production of the document and not adduce
evidence. The reason assigned by the petitioners and
the evidence of PW1 is supported by Exs-P1, P2 and
P3.
14. According to respondent No. 2, the petition
filed by the petitioner under Order IX Rule 4 of CPC
is not maintainable. Regarding this defense, on
careful perusal of the Wordings as employed in Order
IX Rule 4 of CPC, which reads thus:
Plaintiff may bring fresh suit or court
may restore suit to file. Where a suit is
dismissed under Rule 2 or Rule 3, the
plaintiff may subject to the law of
limitation bring a fresh suit or he may
apply for an order to set the dismissal
aside and if he satisfies the court that
there was sufficient cause for such
failure, as is referred to in Rule 2, or
for his non appearance, as the case
may be, the Court shall make an order
setting aside the dismissal and shall
appoint a day for proceeding with the
suit.
15. By virtue of the wordings as spelt out in Order
IX Rule 4 of CPC, on careful perusal of Rule 3, it
reads thus:
Where neither party appears, when the suit
is called on for hearing, the Court may
make an order that the suit be dismissed.
By keeping in mind the wordings as spelt
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC:5459
WP No. 38906 of 2025
HC-KAR
out in Rule 3 and Rule 4 CPC, on careful
perusal of the order dated 19.11.2022 in
OS.No.1007/2017, it is crystal clear that on
the day of dismissal of the suit, counsel for
the plaintiff present before the court and
prays time him for plaintiff’s evidence. On
that day, counsel for the defendant present
before the court and opposed for adjourning
the case for plaintiff's evidence. On that
day, plaintiff and Defendant not appeared
before the court, only their respective
counsel present before the court. As such,
Order IX Rule 3 of CPC is applicable to the
case on hand. When Order IX Rule 3 of CPC
is applicable, then the present petition filed
by the petitioners under Order IX Rule 4 of
CPC is maintainable in the court in
accordance with the law.
16. In support of the objection filed by respondent
No.2 himself examined as RW.1, but not produced
any relevant document, except reiterate the
objection statement, no document produced in
support of his evidence. But the evidence of PW1 as
well as their petition averments is supported with
Ex.P1 to P3. The petitioner has made out sufficient
grounds and proper reason for recalling the order
dated 19-11-2022 in O.S.No.1007/2017 and also the
petitioners have made out ground and reason to
restore the suit in OS.No.1007/2017 to its original
stage. In view of the aforesaid discussions,
without any hesitation I answer point No. 1 in
the Affirmative.
17. Point No.2: In view of the discussions on Point
No.1, I proceed to pass the following
:ORDER:
Petition filed by the petitioner under
Order IX Rule 4 of CPC is hereby allowed
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC:5459
WP No. 38906 of 2025
HC-KAR
with cost of ₹2,000/- and order dated
19.11.2022 in O.S.NO.1007/2017 is
hereby
recalled
and
Original
Suit
No.1007/2017 is restored to its original
stage.
Counsel for the petitioners is hereby
directed to deposit the above said cost
within 15 days from the date of this order
and officer is hereby directed to put up
the original record in OS.No.1007/2017
after the deposit of the cost."
4.
A perusal of the material on record including the
impugned order will indicate that the trial Court has correctly
and properly adopted a justice oriented approach and in order
to provide one more opportunity to the respondent Nos.1 to
5/plaintiffs passed the impugned order, which cannot be said to
have occasioned failure of justice warranting interference by
this Court in the exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 227 of
the Constitution of India as held by the Apex Court in the cases
of Radhey Shyam and Ors. v. Chhabi Nath and Ors
[(2015)
SCC
423],
K.P.Natarajan
and
Ors.
v.
Muthalammal and Ors [AIR 2021 SC 3443] and Mohd. Ali
v. V.Jaya [(2022) 10 SCC 477].
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC:5459
WP No. 38906 of 2025
HC-KAR
5.
Under these circumstances, I do not find any merit
in the petition and the same is accordingly disposed of without
interfering with the impugned order.
Sd/(S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR)
JUDGE
VM
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 4
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review