Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA NO.30 of 2022
Sri Hiralal Acharjee, aged 75 years,
Son of Late Krishna Prasanna Acharjee;
Legal heirs of deceased Sudhir Chandra Acharjee:
2(a) Sri Gobinda Acharjee, aged 65 years,
Son of Late Sudhir Chandra Acharjee;
2(b) Smt. Prabhabati Acharjee, aged 55 years,
Daughter of Late Sudhir Chandra Acharjee;
Legal heirs of deceased Laxmi Kanta Acharjee,
son of deceased Sudhir Chandra Acharjee:
2(c)(i) Smt. Rekha Acharjee, aged 54 years,
Wife of Late Laxmi Kanta Acharjee;
2(c)(ii) Sri. Litan Acharjee, aged 36 years,
Son of Late Laxmi Kanta Acharjee;
2(c)(iii) Sri. Mitan Acharjee, aged 33 years,
Son of Late Laxmi Kanta Acharjee;
2(c)(iv) Sri. Janardhan Acharjee, aged 29 years,
Son of late Laxmi kanta Acharjee;
2(c)(v) Sri. Basudev Acharjee, aged 27 years,
Son of Late Laxmi Kanta Acharjee;
-
All resident of village Murapara, Sastri Colony
(Bashkhet, PS & PO: Kakraban, District: Gomati,
Tripura)
……………………….. Plaintiffs-Appellants
VERSUS
As per the Court’s order dated 09.09.2022 passed in
connected I.A. No.01 of 2022, necessary correction has
been made as follows:-
1. Smt. Alo Rani Debnath,
Wife of Late Manoranjan Debnath;
2. Sri. Biswajit Debnath,
Son of Late Manoranjan Debnath;
3. Sri. Abhijit Debnath,
Son of Late Manoranjan Debnath;
-
All are resident of village Murapara, Sastri Colony
(Bashkhet), PS & PO: Kakraban, District: Gomati,
Tripura.
…………………………..Defendants-Respondents
4. The State of Tripura,
Represented by the District Magistrate & Collector,
Gomati District, Udaipur, Tripura,
5. The Sub-Divisional Magistrate,
Udaipur Sub-Division, PO: Radhakishorepur,
District: Gomati, Tripura
………………..Proforma-Defendants-Respondents
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. D.K. Daschoudhury, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, Adv.
Date of Hearing
:
21.03.2024
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order :
Whether fit for
Reporting
:
04.04.2024
YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment &Order
This appeal is preferred under Section 100 of CPC
challenging the judgment and decree dated 17.03.2022 and
31.03.2022 respectively delivered by Learned Additional
District Judge, Gomati District, Udaipur in connection with
case No.T.A.05 of 2017. By the said judgment, Learned First
Appellate Court was pleased to modify the judgment and
decree
dated
28.02.2017
and
10.03.2017
respectively
delivered by Learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Gomati
District, Udaipur in T.S.30 of 2016.
02.
Heard Learned Counsel, Mr. D.K. Das Choudhury,
representing the appellant-plaintiffs and also heard Learned
Counsel,
Mr.
Suman
respondent-defendants.
Bhattacharjee,
For
representing
convenience,
it
would
the
be
apposite to refer the subject matter of dispute amongst the
parties.
03.
The
appellant-plaintiffs
filed
the
suit
for
declaration of title, recovery of possession and for perpetual
injunction against the respondent-defendants. The gist of the
case filed by the appellant-plaintiffs was in short is that the
suit
land
was
originally
government
khas
land
and
considering the possession of plaintiff No.1 and predecessor
of the other appellant-plaintiffs namely, Sudhir Chandra
Acharjee(since dead), the suit land was allotted in their
name in equal share and accordingly, Khatian No.1054, Hal
Plot No.1254 for land measuring 0.96 acres was recorded in
the name of plaintiff No.1 and the predecessor of other
plaintiffs in equal share and the said Khatian was finally
published on 30.07.1987. Sudhir Chandra Acharjee, the
predecessor of the other appellant-plaintiffs expired on
08.08.1992 and since then the appellant-plaintiff No.1 and
other plaintiffs have been possessing the same and the said
land is described in Schedule A of the plaint. On 20.12.2012
the
respondent-defendants
dispossessed
the
appellant-
plaintiffs from the land as mentioned in Schedule C of the
plaint measuring 8 gandas i.e. 0.16 acres of land and on
repeated request of the appellant-plaintiffs, the defendants
failed to hand over possession of the C Schedule land to the
appellant-plaintiffs
and
on
18.05.2016
the
respondent-
defendants also tried to forcefully dispossess the appellantplaintiffs from the land as mentioned in Schedule B of the
plaint but failed due to timely resistance caused by the
appellant-plaintiffs
and
their
men.
But
they
left
with
threatening to the appellant-plaintiffs to occupy the said land
very shortly. Further, according to the appellant-plaintiffs,
the allotment order of the allottee Khatian was under the
possession
of
deceased
Sudhir
Chandra
Acharjee,
the
predecessor of the other plaintiffs. On his death, they could
not trace out the same and accordingly, they approached to
the office of the SDM, Udaipur to obtain duplicate copy of the
Khatian and allotment order. But the documents could not be
procured as the office staff replied that those were very old
documents, could not be traceable.
04.
The respondent-defendants contested the suit by
filing written statement. Rather they took the plea that the
suit land was originally Government Khas Land and one
Chandrabhan Bibi was the unlawful possessor of the said
land and in the year 1965-1966 said Chandrabhan Bibi left
the said land and since then Manoranjan Debnath (since
dead) and his wife Alu Rani Debnath have/had been
possessing the same but the appellant-plaintiff No.1 and
deceased Sudhir Ch. Acharjee in connivance with the survey
staff managed to get allotment of the same in their favour
without any possession. But due to ignorance of law, said
Manoranjan Debnath could not take any step regarding
correction of record which was illegally created in the name
of appellant-plaintiff No.1 and Sudhir Chandra Acharjee and
was
finally
published
on
30.07.1987.
It
was
further
submitted that since the time of said Manoranjan Debnath,
the respondent-defendants have been possessing the suit
land by constructing their dwelling house and also by
planting various trees within the knowledge of the appellants
and the adjacent persons of that locality. It was further
submitted that the fact of their possession was within the
knowledge of the Government Officials and the Government
Officials also asked and directed to the predecessor of the
appellants to vacate the same but he refused. Thus, they
acquired right, title and interest over the same and in the
middle part of 2015, the appellant-plaintiffs threatened the
respondent-defendants to dispossess them from the suit land
(0.16 acres) of plot No.1245 when the answering defendants
for the first time could know the said fact. It was further
asserted that the respondent-defendants have acquired right
of adverse possession over the suit land denying the right,
title and interest of the Government. So, the respondentdefendants prayed for dismissal of the suit with costs.
05.
Upon the pleadings of the parties, Learned Court
below framed the following issues:
(i) Whether the suit is maintainable?
(ii) Whether there is any cause of action for filing
this suit?
(iii) Whether the plaintiffs are owners of the suit
land described in Schedule A of the plaint by way
of allotment?
(iv) Whether the allotment order was obtained
illegally?
(v) Whether the defendant No.1 to 3 are in adverse
possession (since 1965-1966) and acquired title
over Schedule C land of plaint by way of adverse
possession?
(vi) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to the relief
as prayed for and/or any other relief or reliefs in
this suit?
06.
To substantiate the issues both the parties have
adduced oral/documentary evidence on record:
APPENDIX
(A) Plaintiff’s Witnesses:PW.:- Sri Hiralal Acharjee.
(B) Plaintiffs’ Exhibits:Ext.-1:- The RS Khatian No.1054.
Ext.-2:- The certified copy of RS Khatian
No.1054.
Ext.:-3:- The RS Map.
(C) Defendants’ Witnesses:DW.-1 Smt. Laxmi Lindu.
DW.-2 Sri Santi Bhusan Das.
DW.-3 Smt. Rekha Rani Ghosh.
DW.-3A Sri Biswajit Debnath.
DW.-4 Sri Manik Das.
DW.-5 Sri Anil Ch. Debnath.
DW.-6 Sri Prafulla Kr. Debnath.
(D) Defendant’s Exibits:Ext.A- The certified copy of sale No.1-3177.
Ext.B- The certificate of possession.
Ext.C- The old Khatian No.1/60.
Ext.D- The Khatian No.425.
Ext.E- The Khatian No.644.
Ext.F- The certified copy of RS Map.
Ext.G- The certified copy of Map.
07.
Finally on conclusion of trial and after hearing of
arguments, Learned Trial Court below decreed the suit in
favour
of
the
appellant-plaintiffs.
For
the
sake
of
convenience, the operative portion of the order dated
28.02.2017 passed by Learned Civil Judge, Senior Division,
Gomati District, Udaipur, Tripura in case No. T.S. 30 of 2016
runs as follows:
“In the result, the suit of the plaintiffs is
decreed on contest with cost with a
declaration that the plaintiffs have allottee
right, title and interest over A schedule land
of plaint. It also declared that the plaintiffs
are entitled to get a decree of confirmation of
possession over B schedule land of plaint. It is
also declared that the plaintiffs are entitled to
get vacant possession of the C schedule land
of plaint by evicting the defendants. It is
further declared that the plaintiffs are entitled
to a decree of perpetual injunction against the
defendants restraining the defendants and
their men, agent, servant and workmen from
entering into B schedule land of plaint and not
to disturb the peaceful possession of the
plaintiffs over B schedule land of plaint.
Accordingly, the possession of the plaintiffs
over B schedule of plaint is confirmed. The
defendants are directed to deliver and
handover vacant possession of the C schedule
land of plaint to the plaintiffs within 30 days
from today. The defendants and their men,
agent, workmen and servant are directed and
restrained not to enter and disturb the
peaceful possession of the plaintiffs over B
schedule land of plaint.
The decree is conditional one and the
plaintiffs have to make valuation of the suit
land and pay deficient court fees on the value
of the suit land as per Clause (iv) & (v) of
Section 7 of the Court Fees Act as discussed
above before the executing court to execute
the decree as per law.
Accordingly, irrespective of payment of court
fees by the plaintiffs, the defendants are
directed to handover the vacant possession of
the suit land to the plaintiffs within 30(thirty)
days from today.
Prepare decree accordingly and put up before
me for signature within 15 (fifteen) days from
today, latest on 15.03.2017.
The case is disposed of on contest.
Make necessary entry in the relevant trial
register.
The record shall be consigned to the record
room after expiry of appeal period in due
compliance.”
08.
Challenging that judgment dated 28.02.2017, the
defendants of the main suit as appellants have preferred an
appeal before the Court of Learned District Judge under
Section 96 of CPC and the Learned Additional District Judge
on receipt of record on transfer, after hearing both the sides
partly allowed the appeal modifying the judgment of the
Learned
Trial
Court.
The
operative
order/judgment
dated
17.03.2022
portion
passed
by
of
the
Learned
Additional District Judge, Gomati District, Udaipur in Title
Appeal No.05 of 2017 runs as follows:
“In view of the aforesaid discussions, this Court
finds that the learned trial Court was in error and
guided by some misconception of law and thereby
decreed the suit of the plaintiffs i.e. the present
respondents-plaintiffs
vide
decree
dated
10.03.2017 in TS 30 of 2016 over the “Schedule C”
land. Accordingly the judgment and decree dated
10.03.2017 passed by the learned Civil Judge(Sr.
Divn.), Gomati District, Udaipur in TS 30 of 2016 is
hereby modified in respect of “Schedule C” land
only being devoid of merits. Thus the appeal is
hereby partly allowed.
Parties are directed to bear their own costs.
Thus the appeal is hereby disposed of on contest.
Prepare decree accordingly.”
09.
Being
dissatisfied
and
aggrieved
with
the
judgment of the Learned First Appellate Court, the plaintiffs
as appellants have preferred this Second Appeal under
Section 100 of CPC before the High Court. At the time of
admission
of
appeal
by
order
dated
30.06.2022,
the
following substantial questions of law were formulated:
“(i)
Whether
fact
of
grant
of
allotment
incorporated in the records of right i.e., Khatian
during two successive settlement operation can be
relied on to establish the right, title and interest of
the allottees on the allotted land when the records
of allotment is not traceable in the office of the
Collector?
(ii)
Whether right of allottees in a portion of a
plot of land is accepted as allotted land, if the
remaining portion of same plot can be kept outside
the said grant of allotment?”
10.
At the time of hearing of arguments, Learned
Counsel Mr. D.K. Das Choudhury appearing for the appellantplaintiffs fairly submitted that the appellant-plaintiffs have
got valid right, title and interest over the suit land as
mentioned in the Schedule of the plaint and during first
survey
and
settlement
operation,
the
entire
land
as
mentioned in Schedule A of the plaint was allotted in the
name of Hiralal Acharjee and his deceased brother Sudhir
Chandra Acharjee. And accordingly, ROR was prepared in
their name in relevant Khatian and during resurvey and
settlement operation, again the entire land was recorded in
the name of Hiralal Acharjee and Sudhir Chandra Acharjee
and all along they possessed the suit land without any
objection
or
obstruction
from
any
corner.
Had
the
respondent-defendants be in possession of the suit land, in
that case they could approach to the Settlement Authority or
to
the appropriate forum during
survey
operation for
correction of records.
11.
More so, according to Learned Counsel for the
appellant-plaintiffs, that the appellant-plaintiffs could not
produce the original allotment order cannot be a sole ground
for not awarding the relief to be granted in their favour.
Rather, Learned Counsel for the appellants further submitted
that in para 8 and 9 of the plaint, it was specifically asserted
that the original allotment order was in the name of the
Hiralal Acharjee, one of the appellant-plaintiffs and his
deceased brother could not be procured/collected and on
approach to the office of SDM, Udaipur, the same also could
not be collected. So, for non production of the allotment
order, there is no scope to disbelieve the case of the
appellant-plaintiffs.
Learned
Counsel
for
the
appellant-
plaintiffs further submitted that Learned Trial Court after
considering the oral/documentary evidence on record and
also after considering the facts and circumstances of the
case decreed the suit in favour of the appellant-plaintiffs but
the Learned First Appellate Court ignoring the legal position,
just on the basis of non-production of allotment order by the
appellant-plaintiffs reversed the decree in favour of the
appellant-plaintiffs in respect of land as mentioned in
Schedule ‘C’ and urged for affirming the decree passed by
Learned Trial Court by setting aside the judgment passed by
Learned First Appellate Court. Learned Counsel also referred
the relevant provision of Section 43(3) of TLR and LR Act and
also referred the provision of Section 45 of TLR and LR Act
and submitted that two settlement operations were held but
neither
the
present
respondent-defendants
or
their
predecessor did challenge the creation of Khatian in the
name of the appellant-plaintiffs which shows that the
appellant-plaintiffs have got valid right, title and interest
over the entire A Schedule land. So, Learned Counsel prayed
for allowing the appeal.
12.
On the contrary, Learned Counsel Mr. Suman
Bhattcharjee
appearing
for
the
respondent-defendants
submitted that although the Trial Court decreed the suit in
favour of the present appellant-plaintiffs ignoring the factual
and legal aspects, but the Learned First Appellate Court
rightly and reasonably delivered the judgment and Learned
Counsel further submitted that the appellant-plaintiffs to
substantiate their right, title and interest could not adduce
any valid documentary evidence on record. And furthermore,
according to Learned Counsel for the respondent-defendants,
Khatian does not confer any title over any land, it is only for
the purpose of collection of land revenue and only for the
fiscal purpose. So, Learned First Appellate Court considering
the facts and circumstances, rightly modified the judgment
delivered by the Learned Trial Court and prayed for setting
aside this present appeal by affirming the judgment of the
Learned First Appellate Court. Learned Counsel for the
respondent-defendants
also
referred
some
citations
in
support of his defence.
13.
Admittedly, in this case, the appellant-plaintiffs
could not produce and prove the allotment order, on the
basis of which the total land measuring 0.96 acres was
allotted in favour of Hiralal Acharjee and his brother Sudhir
Chandra Acharjee (since dead). In Second Appeal there is no
legal scope to re-assess/re-appreciate the evidence on
record. I have gone through the records of the Learned
Courts below. It is on record that during first settlement
operation, the suit land, i.e. the entire land measuring 0.96
acres was recorded in the name of Hiralal Acharjee and his
deceased brother and also during re-survey operation also
the suit land was recorded in the name of Hiralal Acharjee
and his deceased brother. In the relevant column of
possession,
there
is
no
any
adverse
entry
regarding
possession of the respondent-defendants or Chandrabhan
Bibi as alleged. During survey operation, also after going
through the different stages, record of rights is prepared in
the name of any person. In this regard, I would like to refer
the relevant provision of Section 43(3) of TLR and LR Act:
“43(3). Every entry in the record of rights as finally
published shall, until the contrary is proved, be
presumed to be correct.”
Here in this case there is no any contrary
evidence on record against the finally published ROR.
14.
Further, I would like to refer herein below the
relevant provision of Section 45 of TLR and LR Act which
runs as follows:
“45. Revision of entries in finally published record
of
rights.Any
revenue
officer
specially
empowered by the State Government may, on
application made to him in this behalf or on his
own motion, within one year from the date of final
publication of the record of rights, correct any
entry in such record which he is satisfied has been
made owing to a bona fide mistake:
Provided that no such entry shall be corrected
without
giving
the
persons
interested
an
opportunity of being heard.”
From the aforesaid provision, it also appears that
any person shall have the scope to challenge the ROR within
one year from the date of publication of the ROR.
15.
Here in the given case, there is no such evidence
on record that either the predecessor of the respondentdefendants or the present respondent-respondents did take
any effort to challenge the ROR standing in the name of
Hiralal Acharjee and his deceased brother.
16.
In
Commissioner
Suraj
&
Bhan
Ors.
&
dated
Ors.
vs.
16.04.2007
Financial
reported
in
(2007) Legal Eagle (SC) 451 Hon’ble the Apex Court in
para No.8 observed as under:
“8. So far as mutation is concerned, it clear that
entry has been made and mutation has been
effected in Revenue Records by Tehsildar on the
basis of an application made by respondent No.5
herein and his name has been entered in Record of
Rights on the basis of the Will said to have been
executed by Ratni Devi. In our opinion, therefore,
it cannot be said that by entering the name of
respondent
No.5
in Revenue Records, the
appellants but the Tehsildar had taken the action
on the basis of Will said to have been executed by
deceased Ratni Devi in favour of respondent No.5.
The said order has been confirmed by the Collector
as also by Financial Commissioner. When the
grievance was made against the said action by
filing a Writ Petition, the High Court also confirmed
all the orders passed by Revenue Authorities under
the Act. We see no infirmity so far as that part of
the order is concerned.”
17.
Referring the same, Learned Counsel for the
respondent-defendants submitted that ROR does not confer
any title rather it is used only for fiscal purpose i.e. payment
of land revenue and no ownership is conferred.
18.
In Tripura Co-operative Milk Producer Union
Limited vs. Madhura Manjuri Singh Deo alias Manika
Rana & Ors. dated 03.03.2020 reported in (2020) Legal
Eagle (TRI) 193 wherein in para 17 Hon’ble this High Court
observed as under:
“17. In our opinion, instead of interfering with the
revision order, the parties ought to have been left
to the remedies before civil court to establish
rights and titles. If the original petitioners wanted
a declaration of ownership or desired that the Milk
Producer Union should vacate the land which
according to them the Union was occupying
without authority of law, they had to institute and
should be left to institute civil proceedings before
the competent court. Minute examination and
interference with the revisional order in a writ
jurisdiction would not be called for. As noted, the
issues pertain to the entries in the revenue records
which were meant only for fiscal purpose and a
presumptive value of possession but not indicative
of title to the land in question. The petitioners do
not dispute the possession of the Milk Union over
the land.”
19.
Referring the same, Learned Counsel for the
respondent-defendant
submitted
that
as
the
appellant-
plaintiffs have failed to prove their right, title and interest
over the suit land, so, Learned First Appellate Court rightly
reversed the judgment of the Learned Trial Court.
20.
In
this
case,
the
respondent-defendants
to
substantiate their defence could not adduce any cogent,
oral/documentary evidence on record to substantiate that,
their predecessors and after their predecessors, the present
respondent-defendants have been lawfully possessing the
suit land.
21.
In course of hearing, Learned Counsel for the
respondents only confined his argument to the point that as
the appellant-plaintiffs have failed to prove/produce any
allotment order in support of their claim, so, Learned First
Appellate Court rightly delivered the judgment, reversing the
judgment of the Learned Trial Court. It is the admitted
position that on the basis of allotment order, Khatians are
being prepared/issued by the Revenue/Settlement Authority.
22.
Learned Counsel for the appellants, at the time of
hearing relied upon one citation of our High Court. In
Bipendra
Behari
Jamatia
vs.
Jagatmuni
Alias
Jagrumuni Jamatia and Ors. dated 18.02.2016 reported in
(2016) 1 TLR 664, wherein Hon’ble this High Court in para
No. 17 observed as under:
“17. The plaintiffs claimed title over the suit land
pursuant to allotment order. It is their case that
they had lost the allotment order. No duplicate
copy could be supplied by the office of the State
respondent. Pro-defendant No.3, i.e. the State of
Tripura in para 10 of their written statement filed
in TS No.23 of 2006 stated, thus—
“10. That, in regard to the statement made in para
7, 8 and 9 of the plaint the answering prodefendant submits that it is not possible in his part
to trace out the allotment case number and year as
it is a very old record and without having any
reference the answering pro-defendant cannot
admit or deny the same. But from the face of ORR
it appears that allotment was made in favour of
Bipendra Behari Jamatia for land measuring 6.0
acre. But now the defendant Nos.1 and 2 are
possessing 5.60 acre of land in total and A. W
Centre are in possession of 0.40 acres of land.”
Similarly, the said defendant in para 10 of their
written statement in TS 24 of 2006 stated thus—
“10. That, in regard to the statement made in para
7 of the plaint it is to be stated by the answering
pro-defendants that it is not possible on the part of
the answering pro-defendants to trace out the year
of allotment without any reference. But it is fact
that in the face of the ORR, it appears that
allotment was made in favour of Ram Chandra
Jamatia. But the possession is found in favour of
defendant No.1 and one Karna Sadhan Jamatia.”
In view of the above pleadings of defendant No.3 it
is clear that the defendant did not deny the fact
that there was an allotment in favour of the
plaintiff/predecessor of the plaintiffs in the suits,
respectively.
DW2 has been examined on behalf of the State of
Tripura,
i.e.,
pro-defendant
No.3.
In
his
examination-in-chief in TS No.23 of 2006 he stated
in para 2, thus—
“2. That it is not possible on the part of the prodefendant to trace out the allotment case number
and year as it is a very old record and without
having any reference. But from the face of O.R.R. it
is appears that allotment was made in favour of
Bipendra Behari Jamatia for land measuring 6.00
acres of land. But now the defendant No.1 and 2
are possessing 5.60 acres of land in total and A.W.
Centre are in possession of 0.40 acres of land.”
Similarly, the same witness in his examination-inchief in TS No.24 of 2006 in para 2 stated—
“2. That it is not possible on the part of the prodefendant to trace out the year of allotment
without any reference. But it is fact that in the face
of the O.R.F. it appears that allotment was made in
favour of Ram Chandra Jamatia. But the possession
is found in favour of defendant No.1 and one Karna
Sadhan Jamatia.”
The above evidence of DW2 is consistent with the
pleadings of the defendant No.3, i.e., the State of
Tripura. So it is evident that defendant No.3 did not
deny the fact that the suit land was allotted in the
name of the plaintiff/predecessor of the plaintiffs
of the respective suits.”
23.
the
Referring the above citation, Learned Counsel for
appellant-plaintiffs
submitted
that
the
facts
and
circumstances of that case are similar with the present case.
And in that suit also the appellant-plaintiffs had lost the
allotment order and this High Court ultimately affirmed the
judgment.
24.
Here in this case, the State of Tripura was made
party but the State of Tripura did not submit any thing
rebutting the claim of the appellant-plaintiffs nor filed any
written
statement,
nor
adduced
any
oral/documentary
evidence on record to counter the claim of the appellantplaintiffs. So, after hearing Learned Counsel of both the sides
and after going through the records of the Court below, it
appears that Learned First Appellate Court committed error
in deciding the appeal and came to an erroneous finding with
the believe that in absence of allotment order no decree can
be granted if the connected Khatians are being produced and
proved by any of the parties. Because here in this case,
there is no evidence on record regarding long standing
possession of the respondent-defendants over any part of
the suit land at any point of time, till dispossession of the
appellants from C Schedule land of the plaint in the year
2016.
25.
So, for non-production of allotment order by the
appellant-plaintiffs, it cannot be said that the appellantplaintiffs have failed to prove his valid right, title and
interest, since the appellant-plaintiffs at the time of filing of
the suit specifically asserted that the original order of
allotment could not be procured by them even from the
office of SDM and furthermore, challenging the suit of the
appellant-plaintiffs, the State of Tripura also did not contest
the same, nor filed any written statement, nor produced any
oral/documentary evidence on record to counter the claim of
the
appellant-plaintiffs.
Even
the
Khatian/ROR
of
the
appellants in respect of the suit land was not challenged by
the respondent-defendants. More so, on the basis of order of
allotment, Khatian was prepared in the name of the
appellant-plaintiffs No.1 and his deceased brother. There is
no other evidence on record that the suit land was given or
recorded in the name of some other persons including the
respondent-defendants by the Government or any other
person
excepting
the
appellant-plaintiffs
possessed
the
same. Accordingly, the substantial questions of law are
answered in affirmative in favour of the appellant-plaintiffs.
26.
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellants is
hereby allowed on contest with costs against the respondentdefendants. The judgment and decree dated 17.03.2022 and
31.03.2022 respectively delivered by Learned Additional
District Judge, Gomati District, Udaipur in connection with
case No.T.A.05 of 2017 is hereby set aside. And the
judgment and decree dated 28.02.2017 and 10.03.2017
respectively
delivered
by
Learned
Civil
Judge,
Senior
Division, Gomati District, Udaipur in connection with T.S.30
of 2016 is hereby affirmed and accordingly it is upheld.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
Prepare decree accordingly and send down the LCRs
along with copy of the judgment.
JUDGE
SABYASACHI
BHATTACHARJEE
BHATTACHARJEE Date: 2024.04.06 17:19:26 +05'30'
Purnita
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review