Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WA No.141 of 2023
1. Sri Haripada Debnath, S/O- Lt. Matilal Debnath, resident of Narsingarh,
P.O.- Narsingarh, P.S.- Airport, Dist: West Tripura, Pin-799015.
2. Sri Suman Roy, S/o- Sri Pramod Roy, R/o- Bagadi, Narsingarh, P.O.Narsingarh, Dist.- West Tripura, Pin-799015.
3. Sri Samir Ranjan De, S/O-Lt. Sudir Chandra De, resident of Narsingarh,
P.O.- Narsingarh, P.S.- Airport, Dist: West Tripura, Pin-799015.
4. Sri Haripada Deb, S/oLt. Ashutosh Deb, resident of Narsinghar, P.S.
Airport, P.O. Narshinghar, Dist.- West Tripura, Pin-799015.
5. Smt Laxmi Rani Dey, D/o-Lt. Sankar Deb, resident of - Narshinghar,
P.S.Airport, P.O. - Narshinghar, Dist.- West Tripura, Pin-799015.
6. Smt. Jharna Datta, W/o-Lt. Rakesh Datta, resident of Narshinghar, P.S.
Airport, P.O.- Narshinghar, Dist.- West Tripura, Pin-799015.
7. Smt. Jaba Das, W/o-Sri Kajal Banik, resident of-Narshinghar, P.S. Airport,
P.O. Narshinghar, Dist.- West Tripura, Pin-799015.
8. Smt. Kalpana Sutradhar (Malakar), W/o- Sri Siddhartha Sutradhar
(Malakar), resident of-Narshinghar, P.S. Airport, P.O. Narshinghar, Dist.West Tripura, Pin-799015.
9. Sri Tinku Chakraborty, S/o-Sri Badal Chakraborty, resident ofNarshinghar, P.S. Airport, P.O. Narshinghar, Dist.- West Tripura, Pin-799015.
…......... Appellant(s)
VERSUS
1. The State of Tripura, represented by the Commissioner & Secretary to the
Govt. of Tripura, Education (Higher) Department, Civil Secretariat, Capital
Complex, P.O-Kunjaban, P.S-East Agartala Dist-West Tripura, Pin-799006.
2. The Director of Higher Education, Government of Tripura, Old Secretariat
Complex, P.O-Agartala, Dist- West Tripura.
3. The Secretary, Finance Department, Govt. of Tripura, New Secretariat
Complex, Gorkha Basti, P.O. Kunjaban, P.S. East Agartala, Dist. - West
Tripura
4. The Principal, Tripura Institute of Technology, Narsingarh, P.O. & P.SAirport, Pin-799009, Dist - West Tripura
…...... Respondent(s)
For Appellant (s) :
For Respondent(s) :
Mrs. S. Deb (Gupta), Advocate,
Ms. Rumpa Dey, Advocate.
Mr. D Sharma, Addl. G.A.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. D. PURKAYASTHA
Date of hearing & Judgment: 06.08.2024
Whether Fit for Reporting : YES
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mrs. S. Deb (Gupta) learned counsel together with Ms.
Rumpa Dey, learned counsel for the appellants/writ petitioners and Mr. D.
Sharma, learned additional Government Advocate for the respondents.
[2]
The
writ
petitioners
approached
the
writ
Court
for
regularization of their services. Individual details of the writ petitioners as
culled from the writ record are indicated in paragraph No.3 of the impugned
judgment which has extracted hereunder to avoid repetition:
“3. The facts of the case, as it reveals from the writ
petition, in brief, are that the petitioners were engaged in
erstwhile polytechnic Institute, now renamed as Tripura
Institute of Technology (TIT) under a scheme by the
competent authority. The petitioners no.1 engaged in service
as Group D Casual Worker, Peon (Full Time) on
01.04.1989, the petitioner no.2 joined as Night Guard,
Casual Worker on 10.04.2003, the petitioner no.3 joined in
service as Watch and Ward, Casual worker (4 hours) on
01.04.1987, the petitioner no.4 joined in service as Lab
Helper (Mechanical Shop) Casual Worker (Full Time) on
22.05.1995, the petitioner no.5 joined in service as
Workshop Helper, Group-D casual worker (full time) on
01.01.1996, the petitioner no.6 joined in service as
Workshop Helper (Fitting Shop) GroupD Casual Worker
(Full Time) on 14.08.2004, the petitioner no.7 joined in
service as Supplying of drinking water, Group-D Casual
Worker (Full Time) on 02.05.2004, the petitioner no.8
joined in service as Workshop Helper Group-D Casual
Worker (Full Time) on 10.09.2004, the petitioner no.9
joined in service as Group-D Casual Worker (Full Time) on
05.05.2004 and till then they have been rendering their
service in the said post.”
[3]
Further, the case of the writ petitioners are based on letter dated
03.09.2012 (Annexure-10 of the writ petition) issued by the Principal,
Tripura Institute of Technology (TIT), Narsingarh, Tripura West (respondent
No.4) to the Director, Education (Higher) Department, Government of
Tripura, Agartala, Tripura (W) (respondent No.2) for their regularization on
the grounds that they were working in TIT without any interruption. Writ
petitioners also made representations on 07.01.2014 (Annexure-18 of the
writ petition) to the Director of Higher Education; 10.02.2014 (Annexure-19
of the writ petition) to the Hon’ble Education Minister (Higher),
Government of Tripura, Agartala and on 17.10.2014 (Annexure-20 of the
writ petition) to the Secretary, Higher Education, Government of Tripura for
their regularization. Proposal for regularization was further repeated by
respondent No.4 vide letters dated 15.01.2014 (Annexure-14 of the writ
petition), 17.01.2014 (Annexure-15 of the writ petition) and 30.01.2014
(Annexure-16 of the writ petition). Writ petitioners claim themselves to be
fully covered by the memorandum dated 21.01.2009 i.e. the scheme for
regularization of the services of DRWs/ PTWs/ Casual/ Contingent etc
workers. However, this regularization scheme had been repealed vide
memorandum dated 31.07.2018 before the writ petitioners approached the
Court in WPC No.587/2023. Writ petitioners also canvassed that other
persons from the same list (Annexrues-10, 14, 15 and 16) were regularized
pursuant to the directions passed in their case by the writ Court. There are
two set of petitioners who have been regularized out of the same list as
above proposed by respondent No.4 to respondent No.2 and all those stand
on similar footing as that of the present writ petitioners since their
engagement was done with concurrence of the Finance Department. Some of
the writ petitioners though had joined after 31.03.2003 but their
engagements were with concurrence of the Finance Department. Petitioners
pleaded that there was no reason why they were singled out from the benefit
of regularization when persons similarly situated and from the same list have
been regularized only because they had approached the writ Court. The
learned writ Court, however, held that their claim for regularization is barred
by delay and moreover, there is no scheme of regularization in existence.
The learned writ Court also went on to hold that the nature of the
appointments of the writ petitioners were not only irregular but illegal. Being
aggrieved, the writ petitioners have come in appeal.
[4]
Mrs. S. Deb (Gupta) learned counsel for the appellants/writ
petitioners submits that writ petitioners are entitled for regularization on the
principles of parity vis-à-vis other similarly situated persons. The other set of
petitioners covered by the judgment dated 05.07.2021 in WP(C) No.210/2021
and WP(C) No.211/2021 upheld in appeal vide judgment dated 07.09.2021
passed in WA No.249/2021 and also upheld by the Apex Court vide judgment
dated
09.01.2023
passed
in
Special
Leave
Petition
(Civil)
diary
No(s).8546/2022, had approached this Court after repeal of the scheme vide
memorandum dated 31.07.2018, as persons similarly situated to them and the
petitioners were regularized by a memo dated 31.08.2021 pursuant to the
directions dated 04.03.2016 passed in WP(C) No.229/2015, judgment dated
02.12.2016 in WP(C) No.140/2016 and judgment dated 12.04.2018 in WP(C)
No.50/2015. All those petitioners who were covered under memo dated
31.08.2021 and 25.09.2023 are borne on the list proposed by the respondent
No.4 to respondent No.2 vide letters dated 03.09.2012 (Annexure-10 of the
writ petition), 15.01.2014 (Annexure-14 of the writ petition), 17.01.2014
(Annexure-15 of the writ petition) and 30.01.2014 (Annexure-16 of the writ
petition) referred to hereinabove.
[5]
It is therefore, submitted that not only the engagement of these
writ petitioners were irregular and not illegal as held by the learned writ Court
but there was no basis for the respondent-State to deny regularisation to the
present set of petitioners when out of the same list other persons have been
regularized pursuant to the directions passed by this Court as upheld upto the
Supreme Court even after the repeal of the regularization scheme vide memo
dated 31.07.2018. Learned counsel for the writ petitioners submits that
therefore, this Court may direct the respondents to regularize the services of
the writ petitioners on similar line by giving them service benefits notionally
from the date of completion of 10 years of their engagement and financial
benefits prospectively from the date of their regularization. The impugned
judgment may, therefore, be set aside.
[6]
Mr. D. Sharma, learned Additional Government Advocate for the
State has opposed the prayer. He has drawn the attention of the Court to the
counter affidavit filed by respondent Nos.1 to 4. The substance of the stand of
the respondents in their counter affidavit is that the services of writ petitioner
Nos.1, 4, 5, 6, 7 & 8 excluding petitioner No.3 have been regularized as DRW
with effect from 29.12.2015 with prospective effect i.e. from the date of their
joining. It is also stated that the regularization scheme has been abolished
with effect from 31.07.2018. Therefore, there is no scheme in existence
whereby the services of the writ petitioners can be regularized. The writ
petitioners were earlier engaged in a centrally sponsored scheme. The affidavit
also states that the department has complied the judgment and order passed by
the High Court of Tripura in WP(C) No.210/2021 and WP(C) No.211/2021
dated 05.07.2021 by regularizing the services of those writ petitioners to the
post of Group-C (LDC) & Group-D. He submits that the judgment of the
learned writ Court is correct and needs no interference. Learned Additional
Government Advocate, however, has not been able to dispute the contention
of the writ petitioners that the names of the writ petitioners were also present
in the list proposed by respondent No.4 to respondent No.2 vide letters dated
03.09.2012 (Annexure-10 of the writ petition), 15.01.2014 (Annexure-14 of
the writ petition), 17.01.2014 (Annexure-15 of the writ petition) and
30.01.2014 (Annexure-16 of the writ petition) out of which other set of writ
petitions some have been regularized by virtue of the orders passed by this
Court.
[7]
We have considered the submissions of the learned counsel for
the parties and taken note of the relevant materials placed form record. We
have also gone through the impugned judgment. The factual position as it
stands is evident from the tabular chart furnished by the learned counsel for
the writ petitioners in respect of the communications dated 03.09.2012
(Annexures-10 of the writ petition), 15.01.2024 (Annexure-14 of the writ
petition), 17.01.2024 (Annexure-15 of the writ petition) and 30.01.2014
(Annexure-16 of the writ petition) referred to hereinabove. Out of these four
letters addressed by respondent No.4, four persons who had approached the
writ Court earlier namely Sri Kaushik Bhattacharjee, Sri Sajal Kar, Sri Biplab
Datta and Sri Uttam Das have been regularized vide memo dated 31.08.2021
with notional benefits from the date of their completion of 10 years of
engagement. Out of this list another set of writ petitioners namely Sri Litan
Bardhan, Sri Ajit Das, Sri Swapan Biswas and Sri Swarup Saha have been
regularized by memo dated 25.09.2023 pursuant to the order passed by this
Court in WP(C) No.210/2021 and WP(C) No.211/2021 dated 05.07.2021
upheld by judgment dated 07.09.2021 passed in WA No.249/2021
and
judgment dated 09.01.2023 passed in SLP(C) No.8546/2022. In their cases
also the benefits have been given notionally from the date of completion of 10
years of their engagement and prospectively form the date of their
regularization. Learned counsel for the writ petitioners have furnished a
tabular chart of the previous set of petitioners who have been regularized and
the present set of petitioners falling in the same list (Annexures-10, 14, 15 and
16). It therefore, appears that the respondents-State has regularized only those
persons who approached the Court. One set of writ petitioners, as above, who
were regularized on 25.09.2023 had in fact approached the Court vide WP(C)
No.210/2021 and WP(C) No. 211/2021 after repeal of the regularization
scheme on 31.07.2018. The judgment passed by the writ Court dated
05.07.2021 was upheld upto the Apex Court and consequently those four
persons named above were duly regularized.
[8]
As such, the writ petitioners falling in the same list have been left
out while others have been regularized only because they had approached this
Court in the year 2023. Moreover, when the regularization of the second set of
writ petitioners have been undertaken vide memo dated 25.09.2023.
Therefore, on principles of parity we find that there are no distinguishing
features in the case of the present writ petitioners to deny the benefit of
regularization except that they have approached the Court in the year 2023
when their other fellow colleagues were regularized in service. If on all other
counts, the case of the writ petitioners stands on equal footing with that of the
other set of writ petitioners, we are of the considered view that non
consideration of their claim for regularization would not be proper. Reliance is
placed on the case of State of Uttar Pradesh & Ors. Vs. Arvind Kumar
Srivastava reported in (2015) 1 SCC 347, more particularly para 22, which is
extracted hereunder:
“22. The legal principles which emerge from the reading of the
aforesaid judgments, cited both by the appellants as well as the
respondents, can be summed up as under.
22.1. The normal rule is that when a particular set of employees
is given relief by the court, all other identically situated persons
need to be treated alike by extending that benefit. Not doing so
would amount to discrimination and would be violative of
Article 14 of the Constitution of India. This principle needs to
be applied in service matters more emphatically as the service
jurisprudence evolved by this Court from time to time postulates
that all similarly situated persons should be treated similarly.
Therefore, the normal rule would be that merely because other
similarly situated persons did not approach the Court earlier,
they are not to be treated differently.
22.2. However, this principle is subject to well-recognised
exceptions in the form of laches and delays as well as
acquiescence. Those persons who did not challenge the
wrongful action in their cases and acquiesced into the same and
woke up after long delay only because of the reason that their
counterparts who had approached the court earlier in time
succeeded in their efforts, then such employees cannot claim
that the benefit of the judgment rendered in the case of similarly
situated persons be extended to them. They would be treated as
fence-sitters and laches and delays, and/or the acquiescence,
would be a valid ground to dismiss their claim.
22.3. However, this exception may not apply in those cases
where the judgment pronounced by the court was judgment in
rem with intention to give benefit to all similarly situated
persons, whether they approached the court or not. With such a
pronouncement the obligation is cast upon the authorities to
itself extend the benefit thereof to all similarly situated persons.
Such a situation can occur when the subject-matter of the
decision touches upon the policy matters, like scheme of
regularisation and the like (see K.C. Sharma v. Union of India
[K.C. Sharma v. Union of India, (1997) 6 SCC 721 : 1998 SCC
(L&S) 226] ). On the other hand, if the judgment of the court
was in personam holding that benefit of the said judgment shall
accrue to the parties before the court and such an intention is
stated expressly in the judgment or it can be impliedly found out
from the tenor and language of the judgment, those who want to
get the benefit of the said judgment extended to them shall have
to satisfy that their petition does not suffer from either laches
and delays or acquiescence.”
[9]
As such, respondents are directed to consider the cases of the
present writ petitioners for regularization on similar lines in accordance with
law. Upon consideration, if the writ petitioners are regularized, the benefits
would notionally accrue to them from the date of their completion of 10 years
of engagement and prospectively from the date of regularization. Let such
consideration be made within a period of three months from the date of receipt
of copy of this order.
[10]
The impugned judgment is, accordingly, set aside. The instant
appeal is allowed in the aforesaid terms.
Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.
(S. D. PURKAYASTHA), J
Munna S MUNNA SAHA
Date: 2024.08.16 14:19:05 +05'30'
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review