Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
B.A. No.51 of 2026
Sri Haripada Bhattacharjee
S/o Late Jyotirmoy Bhattacharjee, resident of South Hurua, P.O. South
Hurua, PS & Sub-Division – Dharmanagar, District – North Tripura, Pin –
799251.
............Petitioner(s);
The accused persons being lodged in judicial custody, the present petition is
preferred and presented by the petitioner, i.e. the father of accused person Nos.1
to 3 and family friends of accused person Nos. 4 and 5.
1.
Miss Susmita Bhatttacharjee,
D/o Sri Haripada Bhattacharjee, resident of South Hurua, Near Panchayat
Office, PS & Sub-Division – Dharmanagar, District – North Tripura, Tripura, Pin –
799251.
2.
Sri Sourab Bhattacharjee,
D/o Sri Haripada Bhattacharjee, resident of South Hurua, Near Panchayat
Office, PS & Sub-Division – Dharmanagar, District – North Tripura, Tripura, Pin –
799251.
3.
Miss Sangita Bhattacharjee,
D/o Sri Haripada Bhattacharjee, resident of South Hurua, Near Panchayat
Office, PS & Sub-Division – Dharmanagar, District – North Tripura, Tripura, Pin –
799251.
4.
Sri Meghadeep Bhattacharjee,
S/o Sri Madhubendra Bhattacharjee, resident of Madhya Nayapara, DMC
W/No.11, PS & Sub-Division – Dharmanagar, Tripura, District – North Tripura, Pin799251.
5. Miss Piu Dhar,
D/o Sujit Dhar, resident of South Hurua W/No.3, P.S. & Sub-Division –
Dharmanagar, Tripura, District – North Tripura, Tripura – 799251.
............Accused person(s).
–Versus–
1.
The State of Tripura.
2.
Sri Nepal Sarkar,
S/o Gopal Sarkar, resident of Kameswar, Ward No.3, Dharmanagar, PSDharmanagar, North Tripura.
……..Respondent(s);
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Raghunath Mukharjee, Advocate,
Mr. Pratik Bhowmik, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Raju Datta, Public Prosecutor.
Date of hearing
:
09.04.2026.
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
27.04.2026.
Whether fit for reporting
:
YES
NO
√
√
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER
This application under Section 483 of Bharatiya Nagarik
Suraksha Sanhita (for short, BNSS), 2023 praying for the grant of bail to the
above noted accused persons in connection with Dharmanagar PS case No.
2025 DMN 0122 [renumbered as ST (Type-1) 07 of 2026] under Sections
329(4), 115(2), 103(1), 3(5) of BNS, 2023, now pending in the court of
learned Sessions Judge, North Tripura, Dharmanagar who has allowed the
prayer for custodial trial of the accused persons vide order dated 02.03.2026
(Annexure-1).
[2]
One Sri Nepal Sarkar (Respondent no.2), father of the
deceased Prasenjit Sarkar lodged the FIR on 14.12.2025 against said
accused Miss Susmita Bhattacharjee, Miss Sangita Bhattacharjee and three
others (not named in the FIR) regarding the death of his son whose dead
body was found hanging in a jungle nearby his house on that day, with the
allegations that on the previous day at around 06:00 pm, at the Blue Dart
Courier Service office, Rajbari, the accused persons had some acrimony
with his son and recorded the incident on their mobile phones, and
thereafter, made it viral. Then, at some point of time in the night, they killed
him and get the body hanged.
[3]
Initially, the FIR was registered under Sections 329(4), 115(2),
103(1), 3(5) of BNS, 2023 but later on, as per prayer of the Investigating
Officer, Section 108 of BNS, 2023 was added. The police, upon completion
of the investigation, filed the charge-sheet against all the said accused
persons under Sections 126(2), 329(4), 115(2), 108, 3(5) of BNS, 2023. The
Investigating Officer also prayed for custody trial of the accused persons on
the ground that they may flee away, if released on bail to avoid the trial, and
they may influence witnesses as well as temper the evidences and their lives
may also be jeopardised.
[4]
The materials against the accused persons as surfaced in the
charge sheet after completion of investigation are that said Prasenjit Sarkar
was a delivery boy at Blue Dart Courier Service, Dharmanagar and on
13.12.2025, he allegedly abused accused Susmita Bhattacharjee with slang
languages and cancelled her online order. Thereafter, all the accused
persons came to the Blue Dart Courier Service office at Rajbari where they
abused
Prasenjit
Sarkar
with
rough
language.
Accused
Sourab
Bhattacharjee held the collar of the jacket of Prasenjit and tore it. Thereafter,
deceased Prasenjit Sarkar accepted his fault and begged pardon by
touching his ears. Then the accused persons recorded the said incident on a
mobile phone. After that, accused Sangita Bhattacharjee gave three slaps
on his cheek in front of others and while departing from that place, they also
threatened that if the said video of the said incident was uploaded in the
facebook, he would not be able to show his face anywhere. Thereafter, the
franchise owner Nutan Dhar requested accused Meghadeep Bhattacharjee
not to upload the said video on facebook. At around 07:00 pm, the deceased
left the Blue Dart Courier Service office for his house. In the house, he was
found very depressed by his family members. He was crying, but on query,
did not disclose anything to his family members, rather, he expressed that
he did not want to live anymore. After some time, he went out of his house
again to bring his jacket from the said office of Blue Dart, but ultimately he
did not return on that night. On the following morning, his body was found
hanging in the jungle on a tree nearby his house. The autopsy surgeon gave
the opinion that the cause of death was due to mechanical asphyxia
following ante mortem hanging and no other injury was found on his person.
[5]
During investigation, the Investigating Officer also seized the
mobile phones of deceased, the accused Sangita Bhattacharjee, the NVR of
the Blue Dart Courier Service office along with one pen drive containing the
video footage of the said incident, the mobile phones of accused
Meghadeep Bhattacharjee, Piu Dhar and several other mobile phones. The
said video footage was allegedly circulated in a WhatsApp family group
among the accused persons, where some of their close relatives were
members. After the deceased committed suicide, the video footage was
deleted from that group. Accordingly, the Investigating Officer sent all the
seized mobile phones along with NVR of CCTV footage to the Cyber
Division of State Forensic Science Laboratory (SFSL, for short), Narsingarh.
However, the NVR of CCTV footage was returned to the Investigating Officer
by SFSL authority for the absence of requisite tools in their office for
examination of the same. Therefore it was again sent to the Central Forensic
Science Laboratory, Guwahati for examination and the report is still awaited.
[6]
The respondent no.2, father of the deceased, was notified by
this Court but he has not appeared to contest or object the instant bail
application.
[7]
Learned counsel, Mr. Raghunath Mukharjee, seeking bail of
the petitioners submits that there is no ingredient of 103(1) of BNS, 2023
and the police also did not submit charge-sheet under above said provision
of law. But, despite the same, the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate while
committing the case to the learned Sessions Judge, took cognizance of the
offence under Section 103(1) of the BNS, 2023. Learned counsel further
submits that the accused persons namely Meghadeep Bhattacharjee,
Sangita Bhattacharjee and Piu Dhar are students pursuing Master’s
Degree at Tripura University, and accused Miss Susmita Bhattacharjee is
pursuing Master’s Degree in IGNOU from Dharmanagar. According to
learned counsel, accused Sri Meghadeep Bhattacharjee and Sri Sourab
Bhattacharjee have been in custody for 103 days, and other accused
persons were in custody for 113 days. Except accused Sri Sourab
Bhattacharjee, submits Mr. Mukherjee, all other accused persons are
students and accused Sri Sourab Bhattacharjee is a businessman by
profession. Learned counsel, also submits that the basic allegation was of
uploading video files of said alleged incident of assault upon the deceased
in social media platforms, but none of the accused persons had uploaded
anything on any social media platform. Moreover, the NVR report and the
viscera test report have also not been submitted by the Investigating
Officer till date; therefore, the investigation remains incomplete. Thus,
learned counsel, prays for bail of the accused persons.
[8]
In support of his contention, learned counsel, Mr. Mukharjee
relies on a decision of Hon’ble the Supreme Court in case of Prakash and
others versus the State of Maharashtra and another [SLC – Daily Law
– 87722] wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court observes that Section 306 of
the IPC has two basic ingredients- first, an act of suicide by one person
and second, the abetment to the said act by another person(s). In order to
sustain a charge under Section 306 of the IPC, it must necessarily be
proved that the accused person has contributed to the suicide by the
deceased by some direct or indirect act. To prove such contribution or
involvement, one of the three conditions outlined in Section 107 of the IPC
has to be satisfied. To attract the offence of abetment to suicide, it is
important to establish proof of direct or indirect acts of instigation or
incitement of suicide by the accused, which must be in close proximity to
the commission of suicide by the deceased.
[9]
Learned counsel, Mr. Mukharjee, also relies on another
decision of Hon’ble the Supreme Court in case of Shenbagavalli and
others versus the Inspector of Police, Kancheepuram District and
another [Criminal Appeal No.4268 of 2024 and Criminal Appeal
No.4269 of 2024] decided on 30.04.2025 wherein the Apex Court
observes that Section 306 requires a person having committed suicide as
a first requirement but for abetment of such commission, which is
essential, the ingredients must be found in Section 107 IPC. The
requirement of abetment under Section 107 IPC is instigation, secondly
engagement by himself or with other person in any conspiracy for doing
such thing or act or a legal omission in pursuance to that conspiracy and
thirdly intentionally aids by any act or an illegal omission of doing that
thing. According to learned counsel there is no prima facie materials to
attract Section 108 of BNS.
[10]
Learned Public Prosecutor, Mr. R. Datta, on the other hand,
refers to the statements of witnesses namely Sri Nepal Sarkar, Sri Nutan
Dhar, Sri Nirmal Rudrapaul, Smt. Sipra Deb (Sarkar), Smt. Priya Dhar and
Sri Nilashish Paul and submits that there are sufficient ingredients of
Section 108 BNS against the accused petitioners. According to Learned
Public Prosecutor, the deceased was a delivery boy working in a courier
service, and considering his academic and social background, the incident
made him mentally hurt severely. Therefore, some of the witnesses have
stated in their statements that just after the incident, the deceased was
crying and expressed that he did not want to live further.
[11]
Learned Public Prosecutor further submits that immediately
after the incident, all the accused persons absconded and were arrested
by the police from Assam- Tripura Border at Churaibari. Moreover, from
the interrogation report of accused Susmita Bhattacharjee, it is found that
she had already destroyed some evidences by deleting the uploaded video
files from social media platform i.e. WhatsApp group. Therefore, according
to learned Public Prosecutor, if released on bail, the accused persons are
not only likely to abscond and may further try to destroy evidences.
Therefore, the bail prayer may be rejected.
[12]
In support of his contention, learned Public Prosecutor relies
on a decision of Hon’ble the Supreme Court in case of Ude Singh and
others versus State of Haryana [(2019) 17 SCC 301] wherein the Apex
Court held as under:
“16.1.
abetted
For the purpose of finding out if a person has
commission
of
suicide
by
another,
the
consideration would be if the accused is guilty of the act of
instigation of the act of suicide. As explained and reiterated
by this Court in the decisions above referred, instigation
means to goad, urge forward, provoke, incite or encourage
to do an act. If the persons who committed suicide had
been hypersensitive and the action of the accused is
otherwise not ordinarily expected to induce a similarly
circumstanced person to commit suicide, it may not be safe
to hold the accused guilty of abetment of suicide. But, on
the other hand, if the accused by his acts and by his
continuous course of conduct creates a situation which
leads the deceased perceiving no other option except to
commit suicide, the case may fall within the four corners of
Section 306 IPC. If the accused plays an active role in
tarnishing the self-esteem and self-respect of the victim,
which eventually draws the victim to commit suicide, the
accused may be held guilty of abetment of suicide. The
question of mens rea on the part of the accused in such
cases would be examined with reference to the actual acts
and deeds of the accused and if the acts and deeds are
only of such nature where the accused intended nothing
more than harassment or snap show of anger, a particular
case may fall short of the offence of abetment of suicide.
However, if the accused kept on irritating or annoying the
deceased by words or deeds until the deceased reacted or
was provoked, a particular case may be that of abetment of
suicide. Such being the matter of delicate analysis of
human behaviour, each case is required to be examined on
its own facts, while taking note of all the surrounding factors
having bearing on the actions and psyche of the accused
and the deceased.
16.2.
We may also observe that human mind could
be affected and could react in myriad ways; and impact of
one's action on the mind of another carries several
imponderables. Similar actions are dealt with differently by
different persons; and so far a particular person's reaction
to any other human's action is concerned, there is no
specific theorem or yardstick to estimate or assess the
same. Even in regard to the factors related with the
question of harassment of a girl, many factors are to be
considered like age, personality, upbringing, rural or urban
set-ups, education, etc. Even the response to the ill action
of eve teasing and its impact on a young girl could also
vary for a variety of factors, including those of background,
self-confidence and upbringing. Hence, each case is
required
to
be dealt
with
on
its
own
facts
and
circumstances.”
[13]
This Court has considered the submissions of both sides and
has also considered the materials placed in the record. Law is no longer res
integra that abetment involves a mental process of instigating a person or
intentionally aiding a person to do a particular thing. Without a positive act
on the part of the accused to instigate or aid in committing suicide,
conviction under Section 306 of the IPC [Section 108 of BNS, 2023] cannot
be sustained. In order to sustain a charge under Section 306 of the IPC, it
must necessarily be shown that the accused person has contributed to the
suicide by the deceased by some direct or indirect act and to prove such
contribution or involvement, one of the three conditions outlined in Section
107 of the IPC has to be satisfied and there should also be requisite mens
rea on the part of the accused persons in abetting such offence. According
to the Hon’ble Supreme Court, as discussed in case of Ude Singh and
others (supra), if the acts and deeds are only of such nature where the
accused intended nothing more than harassment or snap show of anger, a
particular case may fall short of the offence of abetment of suicide.
[14]
It appears that concerning the incident that occurred in the Blue
Dart Courier Service office at Dharmanagar, the deceased was very much
mentally shocked and became depressed. Consequently, he committed
suicide on the same day at night. However, this is a case of solitary incident
and not a continuous act of harassment. Prima facie, there is no material
regarding direct inducement, instigation or aiding by the accused persons in
commission of suicide by the deceased, however, whether the accused
persons by their such acts tarnished the self-esteem and self-respect of the
victim to that extent that he was compelled to commit suicide or whether
there is any indirect abatement from their side, are the matter of facts that
can be ascertained only when evidences are recorded.
[15]
It also reveals that all the accused persons are in custody for a
considerable period. Accused Susmita Bhattacharjee, Sourab Bhattacharjee
and Sangita Bhattacharjee were arrested by police on 18.12.2025 at
Churaibari area, which is within the same district where their house is
situated. Similarly, accused Meghadeep Bhattacharjee and Piu Dhar were
arrested from the same area on 27.12.2025. Since then, they are in
custody. All the accused persons have their permanent addresses in
Dharmanager, and therefore, the chance of their abscondence is lesser.
Moreover, four of them are students and one is having his business at
Dharmanagar. Nothing is there in record that they are influential persons.
[16]
Though the Investigating Officer in his prayer for custody trial
vide his petition dated 14.02.2026, mentions that if they are released on
bail, they may flee away from their local area and may also influence
witnesses in exchange of money and muscle power and that their lives may
also be at risk, he has not elaborated these grounds by mentioning relevant
facts to justify such claim. There is also nothing on record to indicate that
their antecedents are bad.
[17]
The learned Sessions Judge, while allowing the petition for
custody trial, took note of an order dated 09.01.2026 passed by learned
Chief Judicial Magistrate, North Tripura, Dharmanagar, during the
investigation stage. The said order reflects the submission of learned
Additional Public Prosecutor that the Investigating Officer had reported that
previously one person, under the instruction of accused Meghadeep
Bhattacharjee, had threatened one witness of the case and on that issue,
one complaint was also filed in the police station. However, learned Chief
Judicial Magistrate did not make any observation or gave any finding as to
whether such allegation was correct or not. The Investigating Officer, in his
petition for custody trial, also did not mention of any such incident. In the
charge-sheet, the Investigating Officer has not mentioned specifically
anything that the video footage of any such incident was uploaded in the
facebook account or in any other open social media platform and that it was
deleted by any of the accused persons from their accounts. The required
mobile phones are already seized by the police.
[18]
Time and again, it has been reiterated by the Apex Court as
well as by the High Courts that that bail is the general rule and jail is the
exception, for, pre-trial detention has its own punitive contents within it and it
is a restriction imposed upon the personal liberty of a person as enshrined in
Art.21 of the Constitution. Unless there are reasonable grounds to curtail
such liberty by keeping the accused person behind the bar during trial, in
normal course, such bail prayer should be considered favourably.
[19]
Long ago, in State of Rajasthan, Jaipur versus Balchand
alias Baliay, (1977) 4 SCC 308 : the followings were observed by the Apex
Court:
“2.
The basic rule may perhaps be tersely put as
bail, not jail, except where there are circumstances
suggestive of fleeing from justice or thwarting the course of
justice or creating other troubles in the shape of repeating
offences or intimidating witnesses and the like, by the
petitioner who seeks enlargement on bail from the Court.
We do not intend to be exhaustive but only illustrative.”
[20]
In Gurcharan Singh and others versus State (Delhi
Administration), (1978) 1 SCC 118, also the following observations were
made by the Hon’ble Supreme Court“22.
In other non-bailable cases the Court will
exercise its judicial discretion in favour of granting bail
subject to sub-section (3) of Section 437, Cr.P.C. if it
deems necessary to act under it. Unless exceptional
circumstances are brought to the notice of the Court which
may defeat proper investigation and a fair trial, the Court
will not decline to grant bail to a person who is not accused
of an offence punishable with death or imprisonment for
life. …..”
[21]
In Moti Ram and others versus State of Madhya Pradesh,
(1978) 4 SCC 47, Hon’ble Mr. Justice V.R. Krishna Iyer in his Lordship’s
erudite expression observes the followings“14.
The consequences of pre-trial detention are
grave. Defendants presumed innocent arc subjected to the
psychological and physical deprivations of jail life, usually
under more onerous conditions than are imposed on
convicted defendants. The jailed defendant loses his job if
he has one and is prevented from contributing to the
preparation of his defence. Equally important, the burden of
his detention frequently falls heavily on the innocent
members of his family.”
[22]
The Apex Court in State of U.P. through CBI versus
Amarmani Tripathi, (2005) 8 SCC 21, also made the following
observations“18. It is well settled that the matters to be considered
in an application for bail are (i) whether there is any prima
facie or reasonable ground to believe that the accused had
committed the offence; (ii) nature and gravity of the charge;
(iii) severity of the punishment in the event of conviction;
(iv) danger of the accused absconding or fleeing, if
released on bail; (v) character, behaviour, means, position
and standing of the accused; (vi) likelihood of the offence
being repeated; (vii) reasonable apprehension of the
witnesses being tampered with; and (viii) danger, of course,
of justice being thwarted by grant of bail [see Prahlad Singh
Bhati v. NCT, Delhi [(2001) 4 SCC 280 : 2001 SCC (Cri)
674] and Gurcharan Singh v. State (Delhi Admn.) [(1978) 1
SCC 118 : 1978 SCC (Cri) 41 : AIR 1978 SC 179] ]. While
a vague allegation that the accused may tamper with the
evidence or witnesses may not be a ground to refuse bail, if
the accused is of such character that his mere presence at
large would intimidate the witnesses or if there is material
to show that he will use his liberty to subvert justice or
tamper with the evidence, then bail will be refused…..”
[23]
In
Siddharam
Satlingappa
Mhetre
versus
State
of
Maharashtra and others, (2011) 1 SCC 694, the basic principle that
personal liberty is a very precious fundamental right and it should be
curtailed only when it becomes imperative according to the peculiar facts
and circumstances of the case, was reiterated in paragraph no.116.
[24]
Further, in Sanjay Chandra versus Central Bureau of
Investigation, (2012) 1 SCC 40, the followings are again observed at
paragraph no.27“27. This Court, time and again, has stated that bail is
the rule and committal to jail an exception. It has also
observed that refusal of bail is a restriction on the personal
liberty of the individual guaranteed under Article 21 of the
Constitution.”
[25]
Keeping in mind the above said settled position of law and in
view of the materials placed through investigation as discussed earlier, it
appears to the Court that it is a fit case to grant bail to the accused persons.
So far the plea of the investigating officer that if the accused persons
released on bail, their lives may be at risk is concerned, this cannot be a
justifiable ground to deny the bail, since it is the duty of the State to protect
their lives and properties.
[26]
Considering thus, the bail prayer is allowed. It is ordered that all
the above said accused persons may go on bail on furnishing a bond of
Rs.1,00,000/- [Rupees one lakh] only with one surety each of like amount to
the satisfaction of the learned Sessions Judge, North Tripura, Dharmanagar,
with the following further conditions that:
(a)
the surety should be financially sound and should be
permanent resident of Tripura;
(b)
the accused persons will not try to make any contact directly or
indirectly with any of the witnesses of the case and will not try
to influence or terrorize any of them to dissuade them from
divulging the truth before the Court;
(c)
they will regularly attend the Court to face trial;
(d)
the accused persons will not leave the State of Tripura without
prior permission of the learned Sessions Judge;
(e)
Violation of any of these conditions by any of the accused
persons may be a good ground for cancellation of his/her bail.
[27]
With the above observations and directions, the instant bail
application is disposed of. It is, however, clarified that the observations
made hereinabove for limited purpose of deciding the merit of bail
application, will have no bearing in trial.
Communicate a copy of this order forthwith to learned Sessions
Judge, North Tripura, Dharmanagar.
Return the Trial Court record.
JUDGE
Munna MUNNA SAHA Date: 2026.04.27 18:02:21 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review