Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA NO.17 of 2022
Sri Harendra Kumar Das,
S/o Lt. Upendra Kumar Das
Resident of- Pashchim Charakbai (Madhyapara)
P.S- Baikhora, District- South Tripura
……Defendant-Appellant
Versus
01. Sri Moti Lal Saha,
S/o Lt. Jagabandhu Saha
Resident of Pashchim Charakbai (Madhyapara)
P.S.-Baikhora, District- South Tripura.
02. Smt. Chandana Saha (Baishnab)
W/o Sri Ratan Baishnab
Resident of Pashchim Charakbai (Madhyapara)
P.S- Baikhora, District- South Tripura.
03.
Smt. Archana Saha (Paul),
W/o Sri Badal Paul
Resident of Pashchim Charakbai (Madhyapara)
P.S- Baikhora, District- South Tripura.
…..Plaintiff-Respondents
04. The State of Tripura,
Represented by:District Magistrate & Collector, South Tripura
Belonia, District- South Tripura.
05. The Sub-Divisional Magistrate,
Santir Bazaar, South Tripura.
06. Sri Nimai Das,
S/o Lt. Nani Das
Resident of Pashchim Charakbai (Madhyapara)
P.S- Baikhora, District- South Tripura.
07. Smt Santoshi Das,
W/o Sri Nepal Das
Resident of Pashchim Charakbai (Madhyapara)
P.S- Baikhora, District- South Tripura
…..Defedant-Respondents
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. D.R Chowdhury, Sr. Adv,
Mr. S. Sarkar, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, Sr. Adv,
Ms. S. Deb (Gupta), Adv.
Date of Hearing
:
01.03.2024
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order :
13.03.2024
Whether fit for
Reporting
YES
:
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
The appellant Harendra Kumar Das, by means of
this appeal has challenged the judgment and decree dated
16.02.2022 delivered by Learned District Judge, South
Tripura, Belonia in connection with Title Appeal No. 11 of
2016 whereby the Learned First Appellate Court has affirmed
the
judgment
dated
07.05.2016
and
decree
dated
27.05.2016 delivered by Learned Civil Judge, Junior Division,
Belonia in connection with case No. T.S. 16 of 2011.
02.
Heard
Learned
Senior
Counsel,
Mr.
D.R.
Choudhury assisted by Learned Counsel Mr. S. Sarkar for the
appellant-defendant and also heard Learned Senior Counsel
S.M. Chakraborty assisted by Smt. Sujata Deb (Gupta) for
the respondent-plaintiffs. None appeared on behalf of the
rest defendant-respondents i.e. the State.
03.
Before entering into the merit of the case, let us
discuss about the subject matter of the dispute amongst the
parties for which the suit was filed. The respondent-plaintiffs
filed one suit before the Court of Learned Civil Judge, Junior
Division, Belonia, South Tripura which was numbered as T.S.
16 of 2011 seeking a decree for declaration of title of the
plaintiffs over the suit land and along with recovery of
possession over the suit land with further declaration that
the order dated 27.02.2010 passed by SDM, Santirbazar,
cancelling the order of allotment of the suit land in the name
of respondent-plaintiffs as void and illegal. The total suit land
comprised land measuring 0.16 acres as mentioned in
Schedule-B of the plaint. According to the respondentplaintiffs,
the
predecessor
of
the
respondent-plaintiffs,
Jagabandhu Saha got allotment of land measuring 0.20 acres
of land and land measuring 2 acres on 31.07.1973 and
15.03.1974 respectively as per Section 14(1) of TLR & LR Act
and the TLR & LR (Allotment of Land) Rules, 1962 from the
Government. The said allotment was given with condition
that the allottee will not transfer any portion of the allotted
land within 10 years from the date of allotment. After the
allotment 0.20 acres of allotted land was recorded in Khatian
No. 918 comprising Old C.S. Plot No. 1521 and 1522/2383
and another 2 acres of land was recorded in Khatian No. 944
comprising Old C.S. Plot No. 1522/2384 in the name of the
predecessor of the respondent-plaintiffs. Thereafter, on
expiry of 10 years, from the date of allotment, said
Jagabandhu Saha (since dead) sold 1.63 acres of land out of
the aforesaid land and rest land measuring 0.57 acres of
land remained with him. After the death of said Jagabandhu
Saha, the present respondent-plaintiffs and their mother
Late Ashubala Saha, being the legal heirs of late Jagabandhu
Saha became the owner of the suit land and during resurvey
operation the name of the respondent-plaintiffs and their
mother was recorded in Khatian No.937 for land measuring
0.57 acres as joint possessors. In the middle part of
December, 1987, the defendant No.3 of the main suit was
given permission to possess 8 gandas of land i.e. 0.16 acres
of the suit land as mentioned in Schedule-B of the plaint and
later on, during resurvey operation, the name of Nani Das
was mentioned in column No. 16 of the said Khatian as a
permissive possessor and since then, the suit land as
mentioned in Schedule-B was under his peaceful possession.
But thereafter, in the year 2004, said Nani Das without any
authority handed over the possession of the said land i.e. the
suit land to the present appellant-defendant, Harendra
Kumar Das. The respondent-plaintiffs requested said Nani
Das and Harendra Kumar Das to hand over the possession of
the suit land to the respondent-plaintiffs but they did not pay
any
heed
to
their
request.
Thereafter,
the
appellant-
defendant made an application to the D.M. & Collector, South
Tripura, Udaipur for cancellation of allotment of the suit land
and the SDM, Santirbazar drew up of a revenue proceeding
and on 27.02.2010, the SDM, Santirbazar cancelled the
allotment order of Jagabandhu Saha/Respondent plaintiffs in
respect of the suit land as mentioned in Schedule-B of the
plaint i.e. 0.16 acres in respect of
Plot No. 1552(P)
corresponding to resurvey Plot No. 3878 and Khatian No.
937 with an observation that the appellant-defendant has
been possessing the land for the last 45 years and on the
basis of enquiry report of Tahashildar Belonia, TK. After that,
the respondent-plaintiffs had sent a legal notice to DM &
Collector, South Tripura, Udaipur and SDM, Santirbazar but
inspite of receiving notice they did not take any steps.
04.
Hence, the respondent-plaintiffs filed the suit
before the Learned Trial Court. The appellant-defendant
contested the suit by filing written statement denying the
claim
of
the
respondent-plaintiffs
and
submitted
that
although 0.16 acres of land was recorded in the name of
respondent-plaintiffs even though the said land was under
possession of said Nimai Das and Smt. Santoshi Das i.e. the
defendant Nos. 3(A) and 3(B) of the main suit and the
present appellant-defendant prior to allotment of land to the
respondent-plaintiffs.
According
to
them,
since
the
respondent-plaintiffs were not in possession of the suit land
at any time, so, the SDM, Santirbazar rightly cancelled the
allotment of the suit land as mentioned in Schedule-B of the
plaint.
05.
Upon the pleadings of the parties, Learned Trial
Court (Civil Judge, Junior Division, Belonia, South Tripura)
framed the following issues:
Issues
1) Whether the suit is maintainable in
its present form and nature?
2) Whether the plaintiffs are the joint
owners over the B schedule of the
plaint as mentioned in the plaint?
3) Whether the order passed by the
SDM Shantirbazar in Revenue Case No.
09/09 dated 27.02.2010 is liable to be
declared as illegal and void?
4) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled
to get a decree of recovery of
possession by evicting the defendant
Nos 3 and 4 from the „B‟ schedule of
the land as mentioned in the plaint?
5) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled
to get any other relief or reliefs, as
prayed for?
06.
To substantiate the issues, both the parties have
adduced oral/documentary evidence on record:
A) Plaintiffs‟ Witnesses:PW-1 Sri Matilal Saha
PW-2 Sri Umesh Sutradhar
PW-3 Sri Ratan Das Baishnab
B) Plaintiffs‟ Exhibits:i) Certified Copy of Khatian No. 944
under Mouja-West Charakbai (Exhibit
1),
ii) Khatian No. 918 under Mouja-West
Charakbai (Exhibit 2),
iii) Certified Copy of finally published
Khatian no-937 under Mouja-West
Charakbai (Exhibit 3),
iv)
Postal
receipt
and
acknowledgement there on in respect
to notice u.s 80 (1) of CPC (Exhibit 4
series).
C) Defendants‟ Witnesses:DW-1 Sri Harendra Kr Das
DW-2 Sri Gopal Krishna Debnath
DW-3 Sri Subhash Kuri Reang
DW-3A Sri Nemai Das Banik
DW-4 Sri Shiba Prasad
D) Defendants‟ Exhibits:i) True copy of registered partition
deed (Exhibit D-1 series, 5 sheets)
ii) Certified copy of Khatian No. 937,
Exbt. D-2
iii) Certified copy of sale deed bearing
no 1-670 (Exbt D-3Series 4 sheets)
iv) Certified copy of sale deed bearing
no 1-221 (Exbt D-4Series, 4 sheets)
v) Certified copy of application dated
13.07.2006 (Exbt D-5 Series, 2 sheets)
vi) True copy of map (Exbt D-6)
vii) True copy of map (Exbt D- 7Series,
1 sheet)
Viii) Original copy of show cause
notice (Exbt D-8 Series, 2 sheets)
ix) Original copy of allotment (Exbt D9 Series, 2 sheets)
x) Original copy of allotment order
(Exbt D-10)
xi) Original copy of inquiry report
(Exbt D-11 Series, 2 sheets)
xii) Original copy of inquiry report
(Exbt D-12 Series, 2 sheets)
xiii) Certified copy of Khatian no
628/1, 628/2, 1243 (Exbt D-13 Series,
2 sheets)
xiv) Certified copy of Khatian no 1/81
(Exbt D-14)
xv) Certified copy of order dated
27.02.2010 and 31.07.2010 (Exbt D15 Series, 4 sheets)
xvi) Original copy of notice in revenue
proceeding (Exbt D-16 Series, 2
sheets)
xvii) True copy of Sabek Khatian
bearing No. 396, 457 and 272 (Exbt D17 Series, 3 sheets)
07.
Finally, on conclusion of trial and after hearing
arguments of the parties, Learned Court below by judgment
dated
07.05.2016
decreed
the
suit
in
favour
of
the
respondent-plaintiffs. For the sake of convenience, the
operative portion of the order of Learned Trial Court runs as
follows:
“In view of my decisions
aforesaid issues the suit
plaintiffs is hereby decreed.
on
of
the
the
It is hereby declared that the plaintiffs
are the joint owners over the land
specified B schedule of the plaint.
It is also declared that the order
passed by the Ld SDM Shantirbazar in
Revenue Case No. 09/2009, dated
27.02.2010
inoperative.
is
illegal,
void
and
The defendant No 3 and 4, their men
and agents are hereby directed to
hand over the possession of the suit
land to the plaintiffs.
With the aforesaid orders, this case is
disposed of on contest.
Prepare a decree accordingly and
place before me for signature within
15 days from today.”
08.
Challenging
that
judgment,
the
present
defendant-appellant preferred an appeal before the Court of
Learned District Judge, South Tripura, Belonia which was
numbered as Title Appeal No.11 of 2016 and the Learned
First Appellate Court, after hearing arguments of both the
sides, by judgment dated 16.02.2022 dismissed the appeal
filed by the appellant. The operative portion of the judgment
of the Learned First Appellate Court runs as follows:
“In the result, I find no merit in the
appeal to interfere with the judgment
and decree passed by the learned trial
Court in Case No. T.S. 16 of 2011.
Therefore, the appeal merits rejection
which I hereby do.
Prepare appellate decree accordingly.
The case
contest.”
09.
is
thus
disposed
of
on
Challenging that judgment of the Learned First
Appellate Court, the appellant-defendant has preferred this
appeal under Section 100 of CPC before the High Court. At
the time of admission of the appeal, vide order dated
18.04.2022 the following substantial question of law was
framed:
I. Whether the Ld‟ courts below
without proper appreciation of the
Exbt. D-11 the field verification report
of the Revenue Inspector and the
order of cancellation of the allotment
in question in the name of the PlantiffRespondents by the SDM, Santir
Bazaar, Belonia, South Tripura District,
Exbt. D-16 passed the judgment and
decree in favour of the PlaintiffRespondents?
II. Whether the judgment and decree
passed by the Ld‟ Courts below are
perverse?
10.
At the time of hearing of argument, Learned
Senior Counsel for the appellant, Mr. D.R. Choudhury
assisted by Learned Counsel Mr. S. Sarkar drawn the
attention of the Court that the respondent-plaintiffs did
never possess the suit land at any point of time rather it was
under peaceful possession of one Nani Das and thereafter,
the present appellant-defendant and for that on the basis of
his prayer, the SDM, Santirbaazar rightly cancelled the
allotment order illegally granted in favour of the respondentplaintiffs. But the Learned Courts below did not consider the
same and most arbitrarily misinterpreted the judgment of
this High Court delivered in connection with case no. W.A.
No.4 of 2015 and cancelled the order of SDM, Santirbazar
without any basis for which the interference of the Court is
required.
Learned Senior Counsel also referred the para no.
5 of the said judgment and submitted that by the said
judgment this High Court considered the period of „3‟ years
but that 3 years would be counted from the date of
knowledge. Because according to Learned Senior Counsel,
the defendant-appellant and Sri Nani Das had no knowledge
that the suit land as mentioned in Schedule-B of the plaint
was allotted
in the name of the respondent-plaintiffs and
when the matter came to his knowledge, immediately, he
sought redress
before the Revenue Authority and the
Revenue Authority after physical verification found that the
suit land was under peaceful possession of the appellantdefendant since last 45 years and cancelled the order of
allotment granted in favour of the respondent-plaintiffs. He
also referred another judgment of the Hon‟ble Andhra
Pradesh High Court reported in AIR (1995) AP 23 and AIR
(2009) SC 3115 and further referred the provision of
Section 14 and 15 of TLR and LR Act, 1960 and finally,
submitted that by the said impugned judgment, the lawful
title of the defendant-appellant has been cancelled by the
Learned Trial Court and finally urged for setting aside the
judgment passed by Learned First Appellate Court.
11.
On the contrary, Learned Senior Counsel for the
respondents, Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, assisted by Learned
Counsel Ms. S. Deb(Gupta) submitted before the Court that
both the Courts below, after considering the evidence on
record decreed the suit in favour of the respondent-plaintiffs
and Learned Senior Counsel submitted that the suit land as
mentioned in Schedule-B was under the possession of the of
the respondent-plaintiffs and their predecessor Jagabandhu
Saha since long back beyond the statutory period of
limitation and finding the predecessor of the respondent-
plaintiffs in possession, the Revenue Authority vide allotment
order dated 15.03.1974 allotted land measuring 2 acres in
favour of the predecessor of the respondent-plaintiffs and
also vide allotment order dated 31.07.1973 allotted land
measuring 0.20 acres in favour of the predecessor of the
respondent-plaintiffs.
Learned Senior Counsel also submitted that had
the defendant-appellant or said Nani Das be in possession of
the suit land as mentioned in Schedule-B, in that case, either
the name of said Nani Das or the present defendantappellant definitely could be reflected in relevant column of
the respective Khatian Nos. 944 and 918. So, it is crystal
clear that on those lands excepting Sri Jagabandhu Saha,
during his life time no other person/persons have/had any
possession over the same which reveals from Exhibit-1 and
2. Learned Senior Counsel further submitted that the
respondent-plaintiffs
in
their
plaint
admitted
that
said
Jagabandhu Saha during his life time transferred land
measuring 1.63 acres of land from his allotted land keeping
the rest land measuring 0.57 acres with him. And after his
death, vide mutation proceeding No.MR 20080049 the said
land measuring 0.57 acres was recorded in the name of the
respondent-plaintiffs and their mother in Khatian No.937.
12.
Learned Senior Counsel further submitted that the
respondent-plaintiffs in their plaint also mentioned that in
the year 1987 they gave permission to one Nani Das
(defendant No.3 of the main suit) to posses land measuring
0.16 acres (8 Gandas) i.e. the suit land as mentioned in
Schedule-B of the plaint for the purpose of utilization for
which his name was reflected in Khatian No.937 in the
respective column of possession against Old C.S. Plot
No.1522(P) corresponding to Revisional C.S. Plot No.3878 as
permissive possessor. But later on, said Nani das, in the year
2004 without any authority handed over the possession of
the suit land as mentioned in Schedule-B of the plaint to the
present defendant-appellant and after that he could manage
the
survey
staff
and
obtained
a
concocted
report
of
possession over the suit land and on the basis of which SDM,
Santirbaazar cancelled the allotment of the suit land most
arbitrarily and illegally as because according to Learned
Senior Counsel, the SDM, Santirbaazar had no authority to
cancel the order of allotment granted to the predecessor of
the respondent-plaintiffs or the present respondent-plaintiffs
in view of Rule 15 of TLR and LR (Allotment of Land) Rules
1980. Furthermore, according to Learned Senior Counsel,
prior to given permission to said Nani Das, in the middle part
of December, 1987, he never possessed the suit land and he
only came to posses the suit land as a permissive possessor
from the month of December, 1987 and thereafter, he
handed over the possession to defendant No.4, i.e. the
present appellant without any authority and managed to
obtain order in his favour for which Learned Trial Court below
rightly decreed the suit in favour of the respondent-plaintiffs
cancelling the order of SDM, Santirbaazar dated 31.07.2010
in Revenue Case No.9 of 2009.
Learned Senior Counsel further submitted that the
judgment of the Division Bench of this High Court passed in
W.A. No.4 of 2015 (supra), the limitation period of 3 years
was rightly mentioned and the Learned Court below in view
of the principle of the said judgment decreed the suit in
favour of the respondent-plaintiffs and finally submitted that
the substantial questions of law in this case stands in favour
of the respondent-plaintiffs and urged for dismissal of this
appeal with costs confirming the judgment and decree of the
Learned First Appellate Court.
13.
I have heard detailed arguments of Learned
Counsel of both the sides and gone through the records of
the Learned Court below. Admittedly, both the Learned
Courts below gave concurrent findings and decreed the suit
in favour of the respondent-plaintiffs. The respondentplaintiffs filed the suit before the Court of Learned Civil
Judge, Junior Division seeking decree of declaration of title of
plaintiffs over the suit land as mentioned in Schedule-B of
the plaint along with recovery of possession with further
declaration that the order dated 27.02.2010 passed by SDM,
Santirbaazar, cancelling the order of allotment in the name
of respondent-plaintiffs as void and illegal.
14.
Their case was that originally their predecessor
Jagabandhu Saha got allotment of land measuring 2 acres on
15.03.1974 and also got allotment of land measuring 0.20
acres on 31.07.1973 as per the TLR and LR Act and its
connected allotment rurles and after the allotment ROR was
prepared in the name of their predecessors. Then after
expiry of 10 years, their predecessors sold land measuring
1.63 acres of land out of the entire land keeping land
measuring 0.57 acres with him and after his death, the
respondent-plaintiffs got their land mutated in their favour.
It was also the case of the respondent-plaintiffs that in the
middle part of December, 1987, they allowed defendant No.3
to possess 8 gandas of land as permissive possessor who
thereafter in the year 1994, without any authority handed
over possession to defendant No.4 i.e. the present appellant.
Then the respondent-plaintiffs requested said Nani Das and
Harendra Das i.e. the appellant to hand over possession but
they did not respond rather made an application to D.M. and
Collector for cancellation of allotment and on the basis of his
prayer, the matter was enquired into and a revenue
proceeding was drawn up and SDM, Santirbaazar by order
dated 27.02.2010 cancelled the allotment of the land as
mentioned in Schedule-2. After that the respondent-plaintiffs
filed the suit. Before the Learned Trial Court, both the parties
have adduced their oral/documentary evidence on record.
From the side of respondent-plaintiffs three witnesses were
adduced and from the side of defendant-appellant five
numbers of witnesses were adduced.
15.
PW1, Matilal Saha is one of the plaintiffs of the
original suit. He in his examination-in-chief in affidavit
submitted his version in the plaint and relied upon the
documentary evidence. In course of cross-examination by
the defendant Nos. 1 and 2, he admitted that Harendra
Kumar Das filed a case before the Revenue Court for
cancellation of the allotment order of the suit land and as per
order of that Court one enquiry was held and thereafter,
allotment
was
cancelled.
During
cross-examination
by
defendant Nos.3(A) and 3(B), he submitted that on the basis
of prayer of Harendra Kumar Das, allotment was cancelled
and he did not prefer any appeal challenging that order.
During cross-examination by PW4, he stated that they sold
some portion of land from the land which was allotted in the
name of their father and further stated that the suit land was
partitioned between him and other plaintiffs by a registered
deed. Nothing more came out relevant. Similarly, PW2
Umesh Sutradhar in his examination-in-chief tried to support
the version of the respondent-plaintiffs in the plaint. During
cross-examination by defendant Nos.1 and 2, he stated that
he cannot say the Dag Number, Khatian Number and the
boundary of the suit land. During cross-examination by
defendant Nos.3 and 4, he submitted that the father of the
defendant Nos.3(A) and 3(B) namely, Nani Gopal Das
expired in the year 1978. PW3 Ratan Das Baishnab in his
examination-in-chief in affidavit supported the case of the
respondent-plaintiff. During cross-examination by defendant
Nos.1, 2 and 3, nothing came out relevant. During crossexamination by defendant No.4, he stated that he was
unable to say the dag number and Khatian Number of the
suit land.
16.
The appellant-defendant adduced few witnesses.
The appellant as DW1 submitted his examination-in-chief
before
the
Court
and
relied
upon
some
documentary
evidence. During cross-examination by the respondentplaintiffs, he stated that in Khatian No.937, nowhere his
name was recorded as permissive possessor or forceful
possessor. He also could not say as to whether his father
raised any objection against the allotment order of land
under Khatian No.937 or not. DW2 Gopal Krishna Debnath
submitted his examination-in-chief in affidavit. He tried to
support the case of the appellant-defendant. During crossexamination by the respondent-plaintiffs, he stated that the
Khatian Number of the suit land is 937 and Plot No. is 3878,
but he could not say in whose name Khatian was issued.
Similarly, DW3, Subhash Kuri also deposed in the same
manner. During cross-examination, he reiterated the same
fact as stated by DW2. DW4 Shiba Prasad Banik also
deposed in the same manner. DW 3A Nimai Das also tried to
support the case of the defendant-appellant and he is the
defendant No.3A of the suit. But during cross-examination,
he stated that the suit land is not under his possession and
he could not say the dag number and Khatian number where
his father constructed hut. These are the synopsis of the
evidence on record.
17.
I have perused Exhibit-1 and 2 i.e. the certified
copy of Khatian No.944 and 918 standing in the name of the
predecessor of the respondent-plaintiffs. From the said
documents it appears that 2 acres of land was recorded in
the name of Jagabandhu Saha vide allotment order No.8/74
dated 15.03.1974 and 0.20 acres of land was recorded in the
name
of
said
Jagabandhu
Saha
vide
allotment
order
No.177/73 dated 31.07.1973 in Khatian No.918. In both the
Khatians, nowhere I find the name of appellant-defendant or
Nimai
Das as
possessor
in the respective
column
of
possession. Had said Nani Das or the present appellant or his
father could utilize any plot of land in the aforesaid lands, in
that case definitely their names could have reflected in the
relevant column of possession either as permissive possessor
or as forceful possessor. So, the contention of the appellantdefendant that they are using the land since last 45 years
cannot be legally accepted as lawful and as per TLR and LR
Act before preparation of finally published Khatian, so many
stages are being followed and after exhausting of all the
processes Khatians are being prepared in final shape. There
is no evidence on record from the side of the appellantdefendant that prior to 1973, the appellant-defendant or his
predecessor had ever possessed any portion of aforesaid
land measuring 2 acres or 0.20 acres and on any portion of
suit land i.e. land measuring 0.20 acres. Even there is no
evidence on record that prior to allotment of the suit land
along with other lands in favour of the predecessor of the
respondent-plaintiffs,
the
defendant
appellant
or
his
predecessor or said Nani Das ever made any attempt to get
allotment of the same.
18.
In this regard, I would like to mention herein
below the relevant provisions of Section 43(2) and Section
43(3) of TLR and LR Act which provides as under:
“43(2)When all objections have been
considered
and
disposed
of
in
accordance with the rules made in this
behalf, the survey officer shall cause
the record to be finally published in
the prescribed manner.”
“43(3)Every entry in the record of
rights as finally published shall, until
the contrary is proved, be presumed to
be correct.”
19.
the
In course of hearing, Learned Senior Counsel for
appellant
submitted
that
the
appellant
had
no
information about the allotment of the suit land in favour of
the predecessor of the respondent-plaintiffs and subsequent
mutation of their name in Exhibit-3 and when it came to his
knowledge, immediately, he filed a petition before the
District Collector, South Tripura for cancellation of allotment
of the suit land. Accordingly, a revenue proceeding was
drawn up and SDM, Santirbazar rightly cancelled the order of
allotment in the name of the respondent-plaintiffs or their
predecessor. He further submitted that on careful scrutiny of
the judgment of the High Court, it appears that there was no
embargo to file a petition after gathering information of
allotment of land which the appellant did in the present case.
20.
In course of hearing, Learned Senior Counsel
referred one citation of AIR (1985) AP 23 in Para No. 4 of
the judgment, the Hon‟ble High Court of Andhra Pradesh
observed as under:
“4.****************************
Therefore the Court would not adopt
unduly rigid or overstrict view in
construing whether sufficient cause
has been established or not. The Court
also should not readily accept the
submissions
made,
but
has
to
scrutinize each case on the facts
whether sufficient cause has been
established or not. In this case,
admittedly intimation was given on
the last day of the 90th day from the
date of death of the deceased
defendant. Obviously he wants to avail
of full period of limitation prescribed
to see that the application is filed
beyond 90 days. It should also be
noted that the details of legal
representatives have not been given.
In this case on the above facts,
admittedly a report was submitted to
the petitioner on 15-9-76 informing
the names of the proposed respondent
to be the L.Rs. entitled to represent
the estate of the deceased proprietor
of the first defendant firm. On the next
day i.e., on 16-9-76 an application to
that effect has been filed. I am
satisfied on the facts in this case that
the
petitioner
has
established
sufficient cause for not bringing the
L.Rs. on record within the prescribed
period of limitation.”
The lower Court did not approach the
problem from the above perspective
and
thereby
committed
material
irregularity in exercise of the powers
conferred under S.5 of the Limitation
Act. Accordingly, C.R.P. No. 781/83 is
allowed and the delay mseeking to set
aside abatement to bring the legal
representatives of deceased defendant
on record is condoned. Consequently
I.A. No. 340/77 is allowed and the
abatement is set aside. Hence C.R.P.
No. 1497/82 is allowed. Accordingly,
I.A. No. 959/76 and C.R.P. No.
2231/82 are also allowed and the
lower Court is directed to bring the
proposed respondents as L.Rs. of the
deceased proprietor of the defendant
and proceed with the trial of the suit
according to law, subject to the
petitioner paying a sum of Rs. 250/to Sri G. Krishna Murty, learned
counsel appearing for the respondent.
This amount has to be paid on or
before 13th June 1983 and if the
amount is not paid, the C.R.Ps. shall
stand dismissed. There will be no
order as to costs.”
21.
Referring
the
same,
Learned
Senior
Counsel
submitted that when the matter came to the knowledge of
the defendant-appellant, so, immediately he sought redress.
So, according to Learned Senior Counsel, limitation was not
a bar against the appellant to sought redress before the
Collector in time. Learned Senior Counsel further referred
another citation of this High Court reported in (2015) 2 TLR
661 in Para No.5 of W.A. 4 of 2015, this High Court
observed as under:
“5. At the outset, we may notice that
the land was allotted in favour of the
writ petitioner in the year 1988.
Assuming that there was any error in
the allotment, such allotment should
have
been
challenged
within
a
reasonable time. Allotments cannot be
set aside after expiry of reasonable
period. What is a reasonable period
may depend on the facts of a
particular case but normally the
reasonable period will not exceed 3
years at the most. It is only in cases
where fraud is proved that the period
of limitation will start from the date of
discovery of the fraud. Otherwise
within
a
reasonable
period,
proceedings to cancel allotment must
start. A person who is allotted land
develops the land by dint of his hand
work. He invests money and time on
the land. After he has developed the
land the allotment cannot be set aside
after two decades on the ground that
the objector had a better claim to the
land.”
22.
Learned Senior Counsel submitted that although
the Learned Courts below relied upon the said judgment, but
if the principle of the aforesaid judgment is meticulously
scrutinized, it would be observed that there was no default
on the part of the appellant to seek redress to the Revenue
Authority in time. Learned Senior Counsel also relied upon
another judgment of the Hon‟ble Apex Court reported in AIR
(2009) SC 3115 in Para No.35 observed as under:
“35. Regarding the limitation, the High
Court observed as under:“Undisputedly, the period of limitation
prescribed under the law for such a
suit is three years from the date the
cause of action accrued to the
plaintiff. It has been averred by the
plaintiff in para 9 of his plaint, as to
cause of action, as under:“that the cause of action has arisen on
31.10.87 from death on 20.2.88 from
mutation and on various other dates
from the knowledge of the illegalities
and wrongful actions of Village Jabal
Jamrot Pargana Haripur Teh. and
Distt. Solan within the jurisdiction of
this Court, hence this matter has
jurisdiction in the matter.”
23.
Finally, Learned Senior Counsel submitted that
there was no error in the order passed by SDM, Santirbazaar
in Revenue Case No.9 of 2009 and lastly, Learned Senior
Counsel submitted that since both the Courts below have
misinterpreted the judgment of the High Court as mentioned
above, so, the judgments of the Learned Courts below
cannot sustain in the eye of law and prayed for setting aside
the judgment of the Learned First Appellate Court. Here I
would like to mention herein below the relevant provision of
Section 14 and 15 of TLR Act.
Section 14 of TLR Act
14. Allotment of land.
(1)The Collector may allot land
belonging to the Government for
agricultural
purposes
or
for
construction of dwelling houses, in
accordance with such rules as may be
made in this behalf under this Act; and
such rules may provide for allotment
of land to persons evicted under
section 15.
(2)The [State Government] shall have
power(a)to allot any such land for
the purpose of an industry or
for any purpose of public utility
on such conditions as may be
prescribed, or
(b)to entrust the management
of any such land or any rights
therein to the gram panchayat
of
the
village
established
under any law for the time
being in force.
(3) The rules under sub-sections (1)
and (2) allotment of land shall
provide for giving preference to the
members of the co-operative farming
societies
formed
by
marginal
farmers,
landless
agricultural
labourers, jumias and members of
the Schedules Tribes and Scheduled
Castes in allotting land.
Section 15 of TLR Act
15. Unauthorised occupation of land.
(1)Any person who occupies or
continues
to
occupy
any
land
belonging to Government without
lawful authority shall be regarded as
a trespasser and may be summarily
evicted therefrom by the competent
authority and any building or other
construction erected or anything
deposited on such land, if not
removed within such reasonable time
as such authority may from time to
time fix for the purpose, shall be
liable
to
be
forfeited
to
the
Government and to be disposed of in
such manner as the competent
authority may direct:
Provided
that
the
competent
authority may, in lieu of ordering the
forfeiture of any such building or
other
construction,
order
the
demolition of the whole or any part
thereof.
(2)Such trespasser shall also be
liable by way of penalty to pay a sum
which may extend to six times the
annual assessment on such land as
may be specified by the competent
authority and such sum shall be
recoverable in the same manner as
an arrear of land revenue.
(3)Upon payment of the penalty
referred to in sub-section (2), the
trespasser shall have the right of
tending, gathering and removing any
ungathered crops.
From the aforesaid provisions, it appears as to
how allotment of land is given to any person under the TLR
and LR Act and what procedure is to be followed for
unauthorized occupants of the Government land. From the
records, it appears that till 1973 to 2010, the appellant
defendant could not show any document in respect of his
possession over the suit land save and except the entry of
his possession as “permissive possessor” in Khatian No.937.
Now, if we see the evidence of the respondent-plaintiffs, it
appears that in the middle part of 1997, they allowed said
Nani Das to possess the suit land as permissive possessor
but later on, said Nani Das beyond their knowledge and
without any authority handed over possession of the suit
land to the present appellant.
24.
In course of hearing of argument, Learned Senior
Counsel for the respondent-plaintiffs has drawn the attention
of the Court, Rule 15 of the Tripura Land Revenue and Land
Reforms Allotment Rules, 1980 wherein it provides as under:
“Nothing in these rules shall affect any
previous order of allotment passed
and any right, privilege, obligation or
liability acquired, accrued or incurred
under the Tripura Land Revenue and
Land Reforms (Allotment of Land)
Rules, 1962.”
25.
Referring
the
same,
Learned
Senior
Counsel
submitted that in view of the aforesaid rule there was no
scope on the part of SDM, Santirbazaar to illegally cancel the
order of allotment in respect of the suit land in favour of the
appellant-defendant. According to Learned Senior Counsel,
both the Courts below in view of the judgment of the Division
Bench of the High Court, rightly decreed the suit in favour of
the respondent-plaintiffs and the aforesaid rule of 1980
clearly bars the cancellation of allotment, by the Government
to any person, if issued, in view of the earlier allotment rules
of 1962.
26.
In Civil Rule No.64 of 1989 dated 02.11.1995
reported in (1996) 2 GLR 27, the then Agartala Bench of
Gauhati High Court in para no.5 Hon‟ble the Gauhati High
Court observed as under:
“5. **************************
A plain reading of the aforesaid Rule12 of the 1980 Rules makes it clear
that an allotment of land made under
Section(1) of Section-14 of the 1960
Act and in accordance with the 1980
Rules only would be subject to the
conditions specified in Rules-12 of the
1980 Rules. Accordingly an allotment
of land under Section(1) of Section-14
of the 1960 Act made in accordance
with the 1962 Rules would not be
subject to the conditions specified in
Rule-12 of the 1980 Rules. This
conclusion is further reinforced by the
fact that in Rule-15 of the 1980 Rules,
orders of allotment under the 1962
Rules have been expressly saved from
the operation of the 1980 Rules and it
has been stated therein that any
rights, privilege, obligation or liability
acquired, accrued or incurred under
the 1962 Rules shall not be affected
by the 1980 Rules. This being the
position of law, I am of the considered
opinion that the Sub-Divisional Officer,
Amarpur could not resort to the
provisions of Rule 12 of the 1980
Rules to cancel the allotment of land
made in favour of the petitioner under
the 1962 Rules. Thus the impugned
order dated 3.2.89 of the SubDivisional Officer, Amarpur, South
Tripura directing issue of notice to the
petitioner to show cause as to why the
allotment of the aforesaid land made
in favour of the petitioner under the
1962 Rules shall not be cancelled
under Rule 12 of the 1980 Rules and
the impugned show cause notice dated
3.2.89
issued
pursuant
to
the
impugned
order
are
without
jurisdiction and are liable to be
quashed.”
27.
From the above citation, it appears that allotment
of land given under Rule 1962 cannot be cancelled by
invoking the rule made under Tripura Land Revenue and
Land Reforms (Allotment of Land) Rules 1980 in view of the
bar provided in Rule 15. The allotment of land in favour of
the predecessor of the respondent-plaintiff, Jagabandhu
Saha was made by the Government in the year 1973 and
1974 in view of the Allotment of Land Rules 1962 as existed
that time but the Revenue Authority i.e. SDM, Santirbazar
vide order dated 27.02.2010 in Revenue case No.9 of 2009
most illegally cancelled the allotment order of the suit land
ignoring the bar provided in Rule 15 of the Tripura Land
Revenue and Land Reforms (Allotment of Land) Rules 1980.
So, in my considered view the Learned First Appellate Court
rightly upheld the order of the Learned Trial Court below
because from the pleadings of the parties and also from the
oral and documentary evidence on record of the parties and
also from the judgment of the Learned Courts below, it
appears that the defendant-appellant or his predecessor or
Nani Das who was arrayed as defendant No.3 of the original
suit never have/had any lawful right, title and interest over
the suit land rather Nani Das in the year 1987, came to
possess the suit land as permissive possessor and thereafter,
he most illegally handed over possession of the suit land to
the present defendant-appellant and on the basis of an
imaginary and concocted report, SDM, Santirbazaar most
arbitrarily and illegally cancelled the order of allotment of the
suit land in favour of the appellant-defendant by order dated
31.07.2010. Accordingly, the substantial questions of law
formulated are answered in affirmative in favour of the
respondent-plaintiffs.
28.
In the result, the appeal filed by the present
appellant-defendant stands dismissed on contest with costs
being devoid of merit. The judgment and decree dated
16.02.2022 delivered by Learned District Judge, South
Tripura, Belonia in connection with Title Appeal No. 11 of
2016 whereby the Learned First Appellate Court affirmed the
judgment dated 07.05.2016 and decree dated 27.05.2016
delivered by Learned Civil Judge, Junior Division, Belonia in
connection with case No. T.S. 16 of 2011 is hereby affirmed
and accordingly it is upheld.
Pending
application(s),
if
any,
also
stands
disposed of.
Prepare decree accordingly and send down the
LCRs.
JUDGE
SABYASACHI
SABYASACHI BHATTACHARJEE
2024.03.15 15:37:30
BHATTACHARJEE Date:
+05'30'
Purnita
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review