Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA No.1 of 2021
Sri Gouranga Debnath
S/O-Lt. Jagadish Debnath
Resident of Joykatpur,
P.S. Belonia, Dist: South Tripura.
….Plaintiff-Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Sri Biswajit Malakar
S/O-Lt. Lilu Malakar,
2. Smt. Kajal Malakar (Datta)
W/O Sri Mana Datta D/O Lt. Lilu Malakar,
3. Sri. Bijali Malakar (Dey)
D/O Lt. Lilu Malakar,
All of Joykatpur,
P.S.Belonia, Dist: South Tripura.
….Defendant-Respondent(s)
For the Appellant(s)
:
Mr. D. Sarma, Advocate
For Respondent(s)
:
None
Date of hearing and delivery
of judgment and order
:
22.03.2023
Whether fit for reporting
:
Yes
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Judgment and Order (Oral)
This is a second appeal filed against the judgment and decree dated
04.05.2020 passed by learned First Appellate Court in Title Appeal No.11
of 2019 whereby and whereunder the learned First Appellate Court
confirmed the judgment and decree dated 13.02.2019 passed in TS 14 of
2012 by the learned Civil Judge, Junior Division, Belonia, South Tripura.
2.
The facts of the case as projected by learned trial Court may be
reproduced here-in-below:
“[2] The case of the plaintiff in brief is that the father of the
plaintiff was a Baishnab and by the income of day to day begging
he grown up the plaintiff and later on while the plaintiff started
income by dint of daily labour and barga cultivation after
accumulating some money on 24.12.2001 he entered into an
agreement with the father of defendant no.1 namely Lt. Lilu
Malakar in the style of Nadabi for 0.40 decimal of land comprised
in Khatian no.1133, RS (Plot) no.4443, T.K Sarashima, Mouja
Bashpadua and the said Nadabi was executed by the predecessor of
the defendants late Lilu Malakar (now deceased) and defendant
no.1 writing the contents that due to the cause of marriage
ceremony of the daughter of Lt. Lilu Malakar he took Rs.7500/from the plaintiff and bequeathed possession of 0.40 decimals of
land from R.S Plot no.4443 of Mouja Bashpadua with a condition
that none of the successor of Lilu Malakar shall be able to claim
the above 0.40 decimals of land and if they do so then it shall be
treated as illegal. It was also written in the nature of agreement
that as per government rules in the land shall be registered later on
in the name of the plaintiff and thereafter on promissory transfer of
said un-registered Nadabi agreement the plaintiff started to
possessing the land by constructing house thereon and permanently
residing there since 24.12.2001 which was situated at TK
Sarashima, Mouja Bashpadua, by paying Rs.7500/-. During the life
time of Lt. Lilu Malakar the plaintiff approached him to get
registered sale deed and also helped him in many ways to
regularize the Nadabi to have permission from collector for
transfer the land but unfortunately Lilu Malakar died and
thereafter the plaintiff requested the defendants to have transfer of
0.40 decimals of land as per Nadabi but the defendants showing
this or that ground did not comply the same and in the meantime
the plaintiff developed the land by constructing home and hut
thereon and the defendants being greedy tried to sell the land and
also filed a case bearing no. TS.48/09, dated 12.08.2009 against
the plaintiff which was decreed on exparte in favour of the
defendants and then the plaintiff filed a revision petition before the
Hon’ble Guwahati High Court, Agartala Bench for stay order of
execution.
[3]
On receipt of notice the defendant no.2 appeared and filed
written statement but the suit proceeded exparte against the
defendant no.1 and 3. In the written statement defendant no.2
denying all the assertions of the plaintiff and stated that the actual
fact of the case is that the father of the defendants is the owner of
the suit and including other lands which was under his possession
and after the death of his father all the defendants became the
actual owner and possessor of the suit land including other lands
in Mouja Bashpadua, T.K. Sarashima, Khatian no.1133 plot
no.4443 for which they filed a suit against the plaintiff for
declaration of title and recovery possession vide case no.TS. 49/09
which they got decree on 25.11.2009 and subsequently being the
decree holders filed an execution case vide no.Exe(T) 01 of 10
against the plaintiff but the plaintiff file a revision before the
Hon’ble Gowahati High Court, Agartala Bench which is under
adjudication. Hence, the defendants prayed for dismissed the suit
with cost.”
3.
Mr. D. Sarma, learned counsel appearing for the appellant drawing
my attention to the Memo of appeal has submitted that this Court in the
said revision petition bearing CRP No.65 of 2010, titled as Sri Gouranga
Debnath vs. Biswajit Malakar & 2 Ors, by judgment and order dated
29.01.2015, remanded the matter for recording evidence of the appellant
who was the defendant in TS 48/09, setting aside the ex parte decree
dated 25.11.2009. Thereafter, the respondents of the present appeal i.e.
the plaintiffs of TS 48/09 did not appear before the court and the suit was
dismissed for default.
4.
It is also evident from the record that during the pendency of TS
48/09 instituted by the respondents of the present appeal, the appellant of
the present appeal instituted the present suit bearing no.TS 14 of 2012.
The respondents of the present appeal i.e. the defendants of TS No.14 of
2012 appeared and contested the suit by filing written statement.
5.
Upon hearing the parties on material proposition of law and facts,
the learned trial Court framed the following issues:
“i) Whether the suit is maintainable in its present form?
ii) Whether the predecessor of the defendant has entered into
contract for specific performance as contained in the Nadabi?
iii) Whether there is any other relief to be given to the plaintiff?”
6.
On the basis of the above issues, both the contesting parties
adduced their respective evidences and exhibited the relevant documents
including the “Nadabi Patra”, i.e. the Deed of Relinquishment and
Khatian i.e. Record of Right created in favour of the father of the
respondents.
7.
Upon hearing the arguments of learned counsel appearing for the
parties and on consideration of the materials on record, the learned trial
Court dismissed the suit filed by the plaintiff (the appellant of the present
appeal).
8.
Feeling aggrieved, the plaintiff/appellant preferred first appeal
before the Court of learned District Judge, South Tripura, Belonia which
was registered as TA No.11 of 2019, titled as Sri Gouranga Debnath vs.
Sri Biswajit Malakar and Ors.
9.
Upon hearing the learned counsel appearing for the parties, learned
District Judge dismissed the appeal confirming the judgment and decree
passed by the learned trial Judge.
10.
Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the judgment and decree
dated 04.05.2020, passed in TA No.11 of 2019 confirming the judgment
and decree passed by the learned Civil Judge, Junior Division, South
Tripura, Belonia in connection with TS No. 14 of 2012, the appellant has
preferred the instant second appeal before this Court.
11.
I have heard Mr. Sarma, learned counsel appearing for the
appellant. None appears for the respondents.
12.
The record being examined, it comes to fore that the respondents
long back had received the notices issued by this Court, but till today they
have not entered appearance.
13.
During the course of admission of the appeal, this Court had
framed the following substantial question of law:
“(I) Whether the findings of both the Courts below are perverse
being based on no evidence?”
14.
At the time of hearing, Mr. Sarma, learned counsel has urged for
drawing up another substantial question of law, which is as under:
“(II) Whether Rule 14 of Tripura Land Revenue and Land Reforms
(Allotment of Land) Rules, 1980 will come in the way of entering
into agreement for selling the allotted land?”
15.
On going through the findings of the learned Courts below, in my
opinion, the above substantial question of law needs to be considered for
proper adjudication of the present second appeal. Accordingly, the prayer
of Mr. Sarma, learned counsel is accepted and the above substantial
question of law has been formulated for consideration of the present
second appeal.
16.
On perusal of the findings of the Courts below, it comes to fore
that the Deed of Relinquishment for selling the suit land to the present
appellant by the father of the present respondents is an admitted fact. In
the Deed of Relinquishment (Nadabi Patra), it is clearly written that the
appellant had entered into an agreement i.e. in the style of deed of
relinquishment to the effect that due to urgent need of money, the father
of the defendants/respondents made a proposal to the plaintiff/appellant to
sell the suit land. The appellant had agreed to the proposal and paid the
entire consideration money as per market value of the suit land since the
father of the respondents/defendants was in urgent need of money for the
purpose of the marriage of his daughter.
17.
Thereafter, the father of the respondents had taken some time to
obtain consent of the Collector to execute the sale deed. In that
meanwhile, the father of the respondents i.e. Lilu Malakar died.
Thereafter,
the
plaintiff/appellant
was
approaching
the
present
respondents/defendants to execute the sale deed in terms of the agreement
entered into between their father and the plaintiff/appellant, but, the
respondents denied compelling the appellant to institute the present suit
for specific performance of the agreement dated 24.12.2001.
18.
As I said earlier, both the Courts below after consideration of the
evidence and materials on record came to a definite finding that
plaintiff/appellant had been able to prove the due execution of the
agreement dated 24.12.2001 wherein the father of the respondents had
agreed to transfer the suit land by executing a sale deed on payment of
balance consideration money.
19.
But, both the Courts decided the case on different connotation.
According to the Courts below, the said agreement for sale was itself void
ab initio and non est and for this reason, it was not executable. In support
of this finding, both the Courts below had relied upon Rule 14 of Tripura
Land Revenue and Land Reforms (Allotment of Land) Rules, 1980 (for
short, Allotment Rules, 1980).
20.
I have gone through the relevant provisions of the Allotment Rules,
1980. Rule 11 of the Allotment Rules, 1980 stipulates that prior
permission has to be obtained for selling an allotted land. Sub-rule (vi) of
Rule 12 lays down condition that “The allotment will be liable to be
cancelled for breach of any of the provisions of the Act, the Rules or any
of the conditions of allotment”. Sub-rule (iii) of Rule 14 provides that
“the land shall be liable to be resumed by the Government if used for a
purpose other than that for which it has been allotted, or if the allottee
has committed breach of any of the conditions of allotment”.
21.
On careful reading of the above provisions, it can easily be said
that, nowhere of the Allotment Rules, 1980 lays down that if a sale is
transacted without prior consent of the Collector or the competent
authority, the said sale would be void ab initio. It is a mere condition and
there is nothing in the scheme of said provisions that any breach of the
condition shall automatically render the transfer of the allotted land void
ab initio and non est. According to this Court, the power of cancellation
only lies with the Collector itself being the allotting authority. This Court
in a catena of judgments held that the cancellation of allotment also must
be within a reasonable period and the Court held that said reasonable
period is 3 (three) years.
22.
In the light of above, the findings of the Court below in regard to
the interpretation of Rule 14 of Allotment Rules, 1980 are perverse and
contrary to the settled principle of law.
23.
Yet another important aspect which went unnoticed by both the
Courts below is that in Khatian no.1133 that was created in favour of Lt.
Lilu Malakar, the father/predecessor of the respondents/defendants, it is
clearly written at column no.16 that the said allotted land is transferable
after 10(ten) years.
Furthermore, another Khatian was prepared in the name of only
Lilu Malakar where 50 percent share of the entire land was recorded in
his favour. The suit land i.e. the 50 percent of the allotted land in the
name of Lilu Malakar was supposed to be transferred under
the
agreement dated 24.12.2001, that is, much after the expiry of 10(ten)
years. That means, when the deed of agreement for sale in the style of
deed of relinquishment was entered into between Lilu Malakar, the
predecessor of the respondents/defendants and the plaintiff-appellant, at
that time there was no restriction upon Lt. Lilu Malakar, the predecessor
of the present respondents/defendants to enter into the agreement to
transfer the suit land i.e. 50 percent of the allotted land which was
recorded in his name in a separate Khatian. On this score also both the
Courts below have failed to exercise their jurisdiction while appreciating
the documents (Khatians) adduced in evidence, and thus committed
blatant error on facts which rendered the findings recorded in the
judgments perverse.
24.
In view of the aforesaid discussions and the relevant provisions of
the Allotment Rules, 1980 be analysed, the present second appeal
deserves to be allowed.
25.
The appeal stands allowed and the judgments and decrees passed
by the Courts below stand set aside and quashed. Decree be framed
accordingly.
Send down the LCRs immediately after framing the decree.
JUDGE
Snigdha
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review