Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA No.03 of 2022
Sri Gopal Dey,
S/O. Late Nagendra Kumar Dey
R/O. M.B.C Nagar, PS:- Belonia
District:- South Tripura
…….Plaintiff Appellant
Versus
1.
Sri Lal Mohan Dey,
S/O. Lt. Khitish Ch. Dey of M.B.C Nagar,
PS:- Belonia, South Tripura (Since dead)
1a.
Sri Harihar Dey,
S/O. Lt. Lal Mohan Dey,
1b.
Sri Khokan Dey,
S/O. Lt. Lal Mohan Dey,
1c.
Sri Prankrishna Dey,
S/O. Lt. Lal Mohan Dey,
1d.
Smt. Upasana Dey,
W/O. Bipul Dey,
D/O. Lt. Lal Mohan Dey,
All are residents of M.B.C Nagar
PS:- Belonia, South Tripura
[Principal defendant respondents No.1a to 1d are the legal heirs of Late
Lal Mohan Dey]
……Defendant Respondents
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
Smt. Niharbala Dey,
W/O. Late Nagendra Kr. Dey (Since dead)
Sri Chandan Dey,
S/O. Late Nagendra Kr. Dey
Sri Keshab Dey,
S/O. Late Nagendra Kr. Dey
Smt. Ujjala Dey,
D/O. Late Nagendra Kr. Dey
Smt. Sajali Dey,
D/O. Late Nagendra Kr. Dey
Sri Goutam Dey,
S/O. Late Haradhan Dey
Sri Litan Dey,
S/O. Late Haradhan Dey (Since dead)
…….Plaintiff‟s Pro-Respondents
On the death of Respondent No.9 Renu Bala Dey, W/O. Late Haradhan
Dey substituted by her legal heirs:-
9(a). Smt. Arati Dey (Das),
W/O Late Maran Das,
Resident of Santir bazaar, R.K. Ganj,
(Near Shanti Ashram) P.O. & P.S.- Santir Bazar,
Dist- South Tripura, Tripura, PIN-799144.
9(b). Smt. Malati Dey (Paul),
W/O. Sri Madhusudan Paul,
Resident of Sonamura, Kathaliya,
(Near Kathaliya Bazar) P.O. & P.S.- Kathaliya,
District-Sepahijala, Tripura, PIN-799132.
10. Smt. Bijali Dey,
W/O Paliton Dey,
{Resident no.3 to 10 are the legal heirs of deceased
Niharbala Dey}
All are R/O. Vill-M.B.C Nagar, P.O. & P.S.:- Belonia,
District:- South Tripura.
……..Proforma Defendant Respondents.
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. Ratan Datta, Adv,
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S. M. Chakraborty, Sr. Adv,
Ms. P. Chakraborty, Adv.
Date of Hearing
:
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order :
Whether fit for
Reporting
:
22.07.2024
29.07.2024
YES
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This appeal is directed against the judgment and
decree dated 29.09.2021 and 01.10.2021 respectively of the
Learned First Appellate Court, Belonia, South Tripura in
connection with case No.T.A.No.14 of 2019 whereby and
where under the Learned First Appellate Court also affirmed
the judgment dated 15.03.2019 and consequential decree
thereof delivered by Learned Civil Judge (Junior Division),
Belonia, South Tripura in T.S. No.20 of 2008.
02.
Heard Learned Counsel, Mr. Ratan Datta for the
appellant and also heard Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. S. M.
Chakraborty
assisted
by
Learned
Counsel,
Ms.
P.
Chakraborty for the contesting respondents. Before entering
into the merit of this appeal, let us project the subject
matter of dispute amongst the rival parties at first. The
appellant as plaintiff and other pro-respondents filed a suit
bearing
No.T.S.20
of
against
the
respondent-
defendants for declaration of right, title and interest and for
recovery of possession over the suit land before the Court of
Learned Civil Judge (Junior Division), Belonia, South Tripura.
03.
It
was
the
case
of
the
appellant
that
his
predecessor Nagendra Kr. Dey and other pro-respondents
and the plaintiff, Gopal Dey were the owners in possession of
1.24 acres of land recorded in Khatian No.325 and 557 and
after the death of said Nagendra Kr. Dey, the appellantplaintiff and other pro-respondents being the heirs became
the owner and possessor of the suit land. It was also alleged
that on 08.12.2007, the defendant forcefully entered into
some portion of land measuring 0.38 acres and thus,
dispossessed the plaintiff and other pro-respondents from
the said land. The plaintiff and other pro-respondents
requested the defendant on several occasions to vacate his
possession over the suit land, but he refused. Thereafter, the
said plaintiff and other pro-respondents approached the
Local Panchayat and thereafter to the Legal Service Authority
at Belonia for resolution of the dispute. But the defendant did
not accept the settlement and thereafter, the present
appellant and other pro-respondents as plaintiffs filed the
case for declaration of right, title and interest and for
recovery of possession. In the said suit, the defendantrespondents appeared and contested the same by filing
written statement, denying the case of the plaintiff-appellant
and also submitted that the suit suffers from non-joinder of
necessary parties and it was further submitted that the said
defendant and plaintiff, Gopal Dey purchased 40 decimals of
land from the father of the plaintiffs and after disposal he
had left no land for his surviours. Thereafter, plaintiff, Gopal
Dey also disposed of 40 decimals of land to one Pintu Dey by
an unregistered deed. But that fact was suppressed. So, the
contesting defendant by his written statement prayed for
dismissal of the suit land with costs.
04.
It is to be noted here that initially, Learned Civil
Judge, Junior Division on the pleadings of the parties framed
issues and after conclusion of trial by a judgment dated
21.09.2010 dismissed the suit and against the judgment,
one appeal was framed by the plaintiff-appellant vide Title
Appeal No.19 of 2010 before the Court of Learned Additional
District Judge, South Tripura, Belonia and by judgment dated
15.06.2011, the judgment of the Learned Trial Court was set
aside
and
the
suit
was
remanded
back
with
certain
directions.
05.
After remanding back the case record from the
Learned First Appellate Court, Learned Trial Court below
framed further issues afresh:
“i) Whether the suit is maintainable in its
present form?
ii) Whether the suit land is covered by the
Khatian of the plaintiffs or by the
purchased deed of the defendant?
iii) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to get
a decree declaring their title over the suit?
iv) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to get
a decree for recovery of possession of the
suit land?
v) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to get
any other relief/reliefs, if so up to what
extent?”
06.
In order to prove the case, the plaintiff appellant,
Gopal Dey was examined as PW-1 and one Sri. Kantilal Dey
as PW-2 and certain documents were exhibited in this case
which are as follows:
A) PLAINTIFFS WITNESSES:PW-1 Gopal Dey,
PW-2 Kantilal Dey,
B) PLAINTIFFS EXHIBITS:Exbt.1: Allottee Khatian No.325,
Exbt.2: Finally published Khatian No.557.
07.
During
the
period
of
subsequent
trial,
the
respondent-defendant inspite of allowing opportunity could
not adduce any oral/documentary evidence on record in
support of his defence. Although in the earlier suit, four
witnesses were adduced by the said respondent-defendant
and certain documents were exhibited which were marked as
Exhibit-A to Exhibit-D:
A) DEFENDANT WITNESSES:DW 1- Lal Mohan Dey,
DW 2- Babul Majumder,
DW 3- Narayan Majumder,
DW 4- Pintu Dey,
B) DEFENDANT EXHIBITS:Exbt. A: Unregistered sale deed,
Exbt. B: Signature of plaintiff no.4 on the
sale deed,
Exbt. C: Sale deed no.I-2195 of 1996,
Exbt. D: Certified copy of same deed no.I2194 of 1991.
08.
Thereafter, on conclusion of trial, the Learned
Trial Court below by judgment and decree dated 15.03.2019
dismissed the suit of the plaintiff-appellant. For the sake of
convenience, I would like to refer herein below the operative
portion of the judgment/order of the Learned Trial Court
(Second judgment) which runs as follows:
“[13] In the result, the instant suit
preferred by the plaintiffs against the
defendant is hereby dismissed without
cost.
[14] Thus the suit stands disposed of on
contested.
[15] Prepare decree accordingly and put its
signature within 14 days from today.”
09.
Challenging that judgment, the plaintiff-appellant
preferred appeal before the Court of Learned District Judge,
South Tripura, Belonia and Learned District Judge by
judgment dated 29.09.2021 passed in Title Appeal No.14 of
2019 dismissed the appeal filed by the appellants. For the
sake of convenience, I would like to refer herein below the
operative portion of the Learned First Appellate Court which
is as follows:
“[14] In the result, I find no merit in the
appeal to interfere with the judgment and
decree passed by the learned trial Court in
Case No. T.S. 20 of 2008. Therefore, the
appeal merits rejection which I hereby do.
[15] Prepare appellate decree accordingly.”
10.
Challenging that judgment, the appellant has
preferred this Second Appeal before this Court. At the time
of admission of appeal, by order dated 31.03.2022, this
Court framed the following substantial question of law:
“Can only ROR of the Plaintiff supersede his
Title Deed for determining title where as
the title deed (Purchase Deed, Exhibit-C)
exhibited without objection?”
11.
At the time of hearing of argument, Learned
Counsel for the appellant first of all drawn the attention of
the Court referring para No.3 of the initial plaint filed before
the Learned Court and submitted that in said para No.3, it
was asserted that the defendant after purchasing of 0.44
acres of land all on a sudden on 08.12.2007 forcefully
dispossessed the plaintiffs from 0.38 acres of land on the
eastern side as mentioned in Schedule-A of the plaint which
is the suit land of that suit.
Thereafter, Learned Counsel further drawn the
attention of the Court referring para No.10 of the written
statement filed by the respondent filed before the Learned
Trial Court, wherein the respondent specifically stated that
on
27.12.1991
by
a
registered
deed,
the
defendant
purchased 44 decimals of land from Nagendra Kr. Dey out of
88 decimals of land from Hal Plot No.1851/1852 which was
situated on the southern side of the said land and the
boundary of the said land was surrounded by North- Allotted
land of Nagendra Kr. Dey by South- Kshitish Dey, by EastLal Mohan Dey and by West- Road.
Learned
Counsel
for
the
appellant,
further
submitted that as per plaint, the suit land was appertaining
to Khatian No.325 but the purchased land of the defendant
was
appertaining
to
Khatian
No.86
which
are
totally
different.
Learned Counsel for the appellant further drawn
the attention of the Court that after remanding back of the
suit, the Learned Trial Court framed the following issue:
“Whether the suit land is covered by the
Khatian of the plaintiffs or by the
purchased deed of the defendant?”
12.
Learned Counsel for the appellant drawn the
attention of the Court referring para No.5 of the judgment
and submitted that after framing of issue, Court appointed
Survey Commissioner to conduct in inspection of the suit
land.
Accordingly,
the
Survey
Commissioner
submitted
report in this case and the report was accepted by this Court
as no objection was raised by the parties before the Learned
Trial Court below and Learned Trial Court in deciding
aforesaid issue in the last part of issue, specifically stated
that the suit land was not covered by the purchased deed of
defendant. But the Learned Court below without considering
the report of the Survey Commissioner
came to the
observation that the plaintiff had no valid title over the suit
land and dismissed the suit, which needs to be interfered
with. Learned Counsel further submitted that the grounds of
Second Appeal have been clearly mentioned in the memo of
appeal.
Learned Counsel for the appellant further drawn
the attention of this Court that although the case was filed
for
recovery
of
0.38
acres
of
land
but
the
Survey
Commissioner after physical inspection found 14 decimals of
land
wrongly/illegally
occupied
by
the
defendant.
Accordingly, application for amendment for plaint was filed
by the appellant but the Learned Court below rejected the
said application. In this regard, Learned Counsel for the
appellant further referred the provision of Order II, Rule 2 of
CPC and submitted that in view of the said provision, there
was scope to grant decree for the land wrongfully occupied
by the contesting defendant, but the Learned Trial Court
below did not consider the said provision and referring the
evidence of PW-1 during cross-examination, he stated that
the said witness during his cross-examination specifically
stated that the suit was filed for recovery of 7 gandas of
land, but the Learned Trial Court below did not consider the
same and dismissed the suit and the judgment of the
Learned First Appellate Court was nothing but a replica of the
judgment of the Learned Trial Court and finally, urged for
allowing this appeal by setting aside the judgment and
decree of the Learned First Appellate Court and referred few
citations.
13.
M.
On the contrary, Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. S.
Chakraborty
assisted
by
Learned
Counsel,
Ms.
P.
Chakraborty drawn the attention of the Court that as
submitted by Learned Counsel for the appellant, there was
no subsequent development in the suit and the citations as
referred by Learned Counsel for the appellant are not
applicable in this case, because according to Learned Senior
Counsel, the submission of Learned Counsel for the appellant
cannot be treated as a subsequent development, rather it
could be treated as correction of mistakes. Learned Senior
Counsel, Mr. S. M. Chakraborty also drawn the attention of
the Court referring the provision of Order VII, Rule 3 of CPC
and submitted that the appellant did not came to the Court
with clean hands, because it was the duty of the appellantplaintiff to give proper description of the suit land which the
appellant failed to do so.
Further,
Learned
Senior
Counsel
for
the
respondent submitted that except the appellant, Gopal Dey,
no other legal heirs of Nagendra Kumar Dey have/had any
right, title and interest over the suit land, but the legal heirs
of Nagendra Dey filed the suit without any basis and both the
Courts below rightly came to the conclusion that the
appellants could not establish their valid title over the suit
land. So, the Learned Trial Court below rightly dismissed the
suit which was finally affirmed by the Learned First Appellate
Court and the present appellant could not prove any
substantial question of law to be formulated in this appeal.
So, Learned Senior Counsel urged for dismissal of this appeal
with costs.
14.
At the time of hearing of argument, both the
parties have referred some citations for decision of this
appeal. I have heard detailed argument of both the sides and
gone through the records of the Learned Court below and
perused the citations referred by Learned Counsel of the
parties. At the time of hearing, Learned Counsel for the
appellant further submitted that although the appellant
initially claimed for 38 decimals of land but after survey
commission report which was accepted by the parties
without any objection, they restricted their claim upto 14
decimals of land and abandoned their right over said 24
decimals of land. Accordingly, the appellant filed one
application for amendment before the Trial Court and also to
strike out the name of other plaintiffs who are/were not
relevant for decision of the suit but that petition was rejected
and at the time of filing examination-in-chief on affidavit
before the Learned Court, the said fact was specifically
asserted by the appellant. But that was not considered by
the Learned Trial Court as well as by the Learned Appellate
Court. Learned Counsel for the appellant also submitted that
in view of the provision provided under Order II, Rule 2 of
CPC, there was no bar on behalf of the appellant to restrict
his claim for the said quantum of land measuring 14
decimals. Even, the appellant in course of his crossexamination
specifically
stated
that
his
claim
is
only
restricted to 14 decimals of land and the witnesses of the
contesting respondent-defendants also admitted that the
contesting respondent-defendants forcefully dispossessed the
appellant-plaintiff from 14 decimals of land. So, Learned
Counsel urged for allowing this appeal and to pass decree
only for 14 decimals of land only.
15.
On the other hand, Learned Senior Counsel, Mr.
S. M. Chakraborty assisted by Learned Counsel, Ms. P.
Chakraborty for the respondent-defendants countered the
submission made by the Learned Counsel for the appellant
and submitted that as per Order VII, Rule 3 of CPC, the
appellant did not come before the Court with clean hands for
which the Learned Courts below rightly turned down the
claim of the appellant.
16.
Here for the sake of brevity, I would like to refer
herein below the relevant provision of Order II, Rule 2 of CPC
which provides as under:
Order II, Rule 2 of CPC:2. Suit to include the whole claim.-(1)
Every suit shall include the whole of the
claim which the plaintiff is entitled to make
in respect of the cause of action; but a
plaintiff may relinquish any portion of his
claim in order to bring the suit within the
jurisdiction of any Court.
(2) Relinquishment of part of claim.Where a plaintiff omits to sue in
respect
of,
or
intentionally
relinquishes, any portion of his claim,
he shall not afterwards sue in respect
of
the
portion
so
omitted
or
relinquished.
(3) Omission to sue for one of several
reliefs.- A person entitled to more
than one relief in respect of the same
cause of action may sue for all or any
of such reliefs; but if he omits, except
with the leave of the Court, to sue for
all such reliefs, he shall not afterwards
sue for any relief so omitted.
Explanation.- For the purposes of this rule
an obligation and a collateral security for
its performance and
successive claims
arising under the same obligation shall be
deemed respectively to constitute but one
cause of action.
17.
Further, in course of hearing of argument,
Learned Counsel for the appellant referred few citations. In
Smti. Kameswari Saikia vs. Shri Sankarlal Sarkar dated
25.09.1989 reported in (1990) 1 GLR 234, wherein, in para
No.9 the Hon’ble Gauhati High Court observed as under:
“9. It is the duty of the court to take notice
of events subsequent to the filing of the
suit and would decree according to
subsequent events, in a proper suit to avoid
multiplicity of suit for the same subject
matter between the same contesting
parties
and
to
save
unnecessary
expenditure to the parties and time of the
court and to do complete justice between
the parties. This can be done effectively at
the appellate stage also.”
18.
In Pasupuleti Venkateswarlu vs. The Motor &
General Traders dated 18.03.1975 reported in AIR (1975)
SC 1409, wherein Hon’ble the Supreme Court in para No.4
observed as under:
“4. We feel the submissions devoid of
substance. First about the jurisdiction and
propriety vis-à-vis circumstances which
come into being subsequent to the
commencement of the proceedings. It is
basic to our processual jurisprudence that
the right to relief must be judged to exist
as on the date a suitor institutes the legal
proceedings. Equally clear is the principle
that a suitor institutes the legal proceeding.
Equally clear is the principle that procedure
is the handmaid and not the mistress of the
judicial process. If a fact, arising after the
lis has come to court and has a
fundamental impact on the right to relief or
the manner of moulding it, is brought
diligently to the notice of the tribunal, it
cannot blink at it or be blind to events
which stultify or render inept the decretal
remedy. Equity justifies bending the rules
of procedure, where no specific provision or
fairplay is violated, with a view to promote
substantial justice--subject, of course, to
the absence of other disentitling factors or
just
circumstances.
Nor
can
we
contemplate any limitation on this power to
take note of updated facts to confine it to
the trial Court. If the litigation pends, the
power
exists,
absent
other
special
circumstances repelling resort to that
course in law or justice. Rulings on this
point are legion, even as situations for
applications of this equitable rule are
myriad. We affirm the proposition that for
making the right or remedy claimed by the
party just and meaningful as also legally
and factually in accord with the current
realities, the court can, and in many cases
must, take cautious cognisance of events
and developments subsequent to the
institution of the proceeding provided the
rules of fairness to both sides are
scrupulously obeyed. On both occasions the
High Court, in revision, correctly took this
view. The later recovery of another
accommodation by the landlord, during the
pendency of the case, has as the High Court
twice pointed out, a material bearing on the
right to evict, in view of the inhibition
written into S. 10 (3) (iii) itself. We are not
disposed to disturb this approach in law or
finding of fact.”
In addition to that, Learned Counsel for the
appellant also referred the following citations:
(i) In Ramesh Kumar vs. Kesho Ram dated
30.09.1991 reported in AIR (1992) SC 700 (relevant para
Nos.4 & 5).
(ii) In Sheshambal (Dead) Through LRS. vs.
Chelur Corporation Chelur Building and Others dated
17.02.2010 reported in (2010) 3 SCC 470 (relevant para
Nos.7 & 10).
(iii) Ram Nibas Gagar (Dead) by L.Rs. vs
Debojyoti Das and Others dated 04.12.2002 reported in
AIR (2003) SC 632 (relevant para No.3)
(iv) Dr. Susanta Ku. Das vs. Ouat dated
20.05.2024, in the Hon’ble Orissa High Court. (Relevant para
Nos.10, 11, 12, 13, 14).
Referring the said provision and citations, Learned
Counsel for the appellant submitted that due to changed
circumstances, Learned Trial Court ought to have grant
decree for 14 decimals of land but the same was not
considered by the Learned Trial Court and dismissed the suit
which was affirmed by the Learned First Appellate Court.
19.
On the other hand, Learned Senior Counsel for
the respondents, in course of hearing of argument referred
provision of Order VII, Rule 3 of CPC which provides as
under and further submitted that the aforesaid provision was
not complied with by the appellant:
Order VII, Rule 3 of CPC:
3. Where the subject-matter of the suit is
immovable property.-Where the subjectmatter of the suit is immovable property,
the plaint shall contain a description of the
property sufficient to identify it, and, in
case such property can be identified by
boundaries or numbers in a record of
settlement or survey, the plaint shall
specify such boundaries or numbers.
20.
In addition to that Learned Senior Counsel also
referred another citation of the Hon’ble Apex Court in
Subhaga and Others vs. Shobha and Others dated
07.07.2006 reported in (2006) 5 SCC 466, wherein Hon’ble
the Supreme Court in para No.6 observed as under:
“6. The High Court has also upheld the title
claimed
by
the
plaintiff
over
Plot
No.1301/1 Ba. Once we accept the
identification made by the Commissioner as
was done by the first appellate court, it is
clear that the plaintiff has the right to have
the disputed construction removed and the
well filed up. That a property can be
identified either by boundary or by any
other
specific
description
is
well
established. Here the attempt had been to
identify the suit property with reference to
the boundaries and the Commissioner has
identified that property with reference to
such boundaries. Even if there was any
discrepancy, normally, the boundaries
should prevail. There was no occasion to
spin a theory that it was necessary in this
suit to survey all the adjacent lands to find
out whether an encroachment was made in
the land belonging to the plaintiff. In this
situation, we are satisfied that the
judgment and decree of the High Court calls
for interference. We are also satisfied that
the lower appellate court was justified in
affirming the decree granted in favour of
the plaintiff on the pleadings and the
evidence in the case.”
Referring
the
same,
Learned
Senior
Counsel
further submitted that the appellant could not give any clear
description of the suit property so as to identify the same.
21.
It is on record that initially on the suit of the
appellant vide No.T.S.20 of 2008 judgment was passed by
the then Learned Civil Judge, Junior Division, Belonia, South
Tripura on 21.09.2010 and consequential decree was passed.
Challenging that judgment, the appellant preferred appeal
which was numbered as T.A. No.19 of 2010 and the then
Learned Additional District Judge, Belonia, South Tripura, in
the said appeal remanded back the suit with the following
direction by judgment dated 15.06.2011. For the sake of
convenience, I would like to refer herein below the operative
portion of the judgment/order of the then Learned First
Appellate Court (Learned Additional District Judge, Belonia
South Tripura), which runs as follows:
“10. For
impugned
aside.
the reasons aforesaid, the
judgment and decree is set
The suit is remanded to the court below.
Learned court below on receipt of the case
record shall readmit the suit under its
original number in the register of civil suits.
Learned court below shall frame the issue
No.2 on the point as mentioned above and
shall renumber the remaining issues. He
shall
thereafter
appoint
a
Survey
Commissioner to decide the newly framed
issue No.2. Needless to say, as regards
possession and dispossession of the suit
land, the parties shall be entitled to adduce
further evidence before the court below.
The evidence on record shall, subject to all
just exceptions, be evidence during the
trial.
The parties shall appear before the court
below on 1.7.2011 for the purpose of
receiving directions regarding the further
proceeding of the suit.”
22.
After that, the Trial Court below framed five
issues afresh with the following specific Issue No.2 as per
order of the Learned First Appellate Court:
“ii) Whether the suit land is covered by the
Khatian of the plaintiffs or by the
purchased deed of the defendant?”
And in deciding that issue, Learned Trial Court
below came to the conclusion that the suit land was not
covered by the purchased deed of the defendant and in the
judgment, it was also specifically mentioned in para No.5
that as per the direction of the Learned First Appellate Court,
Survey Commissioner was appointed who submitted his
report in the case and the report of Survey Commissioner
was accepted by the Court in absence of any objection from
either of the parties. But in determining the suit, the Learned
Trial Court in my considered view, ignored the said report of
Survey Commissioner and ultimately, dismissed the suit
which was affirmed by the Learned First Appellate Court. As
already stated, to substantiate the issues both the parties
have adduced their oral/documentary evidence on record.
The appellant as PW-1 in his examination-in-chief in affidavit
in para Nos.2, 3, 4, 8, 9 & 10 observed as under:
“2. I say that 27/12/1991 on payment of
valuable consideration, I purchased .44 decimals
of land from my father, which appertains to
Mouja Madhya Bharat Chandra Nagar, previously
under Maichara Tehshil Kachari; now under
Chittamara Tehshil Kachari. Thus I seized and
possessed of the same.
This is true to my knowledge.
3. I say that on the same date the defendant
Lalmohan Dey purchased remaining .44 decimals
of land from my father Late Nagendra Kumar
Dey just on the eastern side of my purchased
land.
This is true to my knowledge.
4. That I say that after purchasing those entire
.44 decimals of land I applied for mutating my
name in the Revenue Records, accordingly my
name was entered in the Revenue Record by
preparing a separate Khatian being the No 557.
This is true to my knowledge.
8. That I say that on 08.12.2007, the defendant
who is a habitual land grabber pounced upon my
land of and dispossessed me from at least .14
decimals of my purchased land. I tried to resist
him, but he and other family members chased
me away from legally purchased land. I informed
the matter to the O/C of the Belonia Police
Station, but no action was taken.
This is true to my knowledge.
9. I say that on that date the defendant also
took dominion over .24 decimals of khas land
from my possession. As those .24 decimals of
land are khas land I have abandoned my claim
over those .24 decimals of land.
This is true to my knowledge.
10. I say that I had also filed a prayer before the
Sub-divisional Legal Service Authority to assist
me for the recovery of my land. The defendant
agreed to release those encroached upon land if
on survey it was found that he has in possession
of the land of the plaintiff. Accordingly
Honourable Judge of the Temporary Lok Adalat
appointed one Rash Behari Bhattacharjee and on
making survey he found that .14 decimals of
land from Plot No 1851/2363 my purchased land
is in possession of the Defendant and he further
observed that .24 decimals of khas land
encroached upon by the defendant.
This is true to my knowledge.”
During cross-examination said appellant PW-1
stated that the present suit is filed for recovery of 7 gandas
of land.
23.
PW-2 Kantilal Dey in his examination-in-chief in
affidavit in para Nos.3, 4 & 6 observed as under:
“3. I say that my elder brother Lalmohan Dey.
Although he has vast track of terrain producing
rubber latex and paddies, till then this land grabbing
attitude ends never. He has had an irrepressible lust
for land and money.
This is true to my knowledge.
4. I say that on 08.12.2007 my elder brother
Lalmohan Dey dispossessed my cousin brother Sri
Gopal Dey from at least 7 to 8 gandas of land. It was
apparently visible that, what my brother purchased
from Late Nagendra Kr. Dey; he overlapped his
purchased land and encroached upon the land of
Gopal Dey.
This is true to my knowledge.
6. I say that perhaps on 20.08.2015 (the exact date I
cannot now recollect), I was present, when a Survey
Commissioner was surveying the land of Gopal Dey
and Lal Mohan Dey; I was present there and found
that from the eastern side of Gopal Dey’s purchased
land, Lal Mohan Dey encroached upon nearly .14
decimals of land.
This is true to my knowledge.”
During cross-examination, he stated that Gopal
Dey is the sole plaintiff of this suit and there were no other
plaintiff in the suit and the Dag No. of the suit land is 2363.
Further stated that the present suit has been filed in respect
of the land of the plaintiff, Gopal Dey and he was present at
the time of measurement of the suit land. The respondentdefendant, Lalmohan Dey in course of his cross-examination
stated that he shall have no objection if the suit is decreed in
favour of Gopal Dey on his land.
24.
I
have
also
perused
the
report
of
Survey
Commissioner. It appears that the contesting respondentdefendant was forcefully occupying 14 decimals of land
belonging to the appellant-plaintiff. From the provision of
Order II, Rule 2 of CPC, it also appears that the plaintiff of
any case may relinquish any portion of his claim in order to
bring the suit within the jurisdiction of any Court.
25.
This present appeal is preferred under Section
100 of CPC. In this regard, Hon’ble the Supreme Court of
India in Boodireddy Chandraiah and Others vs. Arigela
Laxmi and Another dated 17.09.2007 reported in (2007)
8 SCC 155 in para No.12 observed as under:
“12. The principles relating to Section 100
CPC relevant for this case may be
summarized thus:
(i) An inference of fact from the
recitals or contents of a document is a
question of fact. But the legal effect of
the terms of a document is a question
of law. Construction of a document
involving the application of any
principle of law, is also a question of
law.
Therefore,
when
there
is
misconstruction of a document or
wrong application of a principle of law
in construing a document, it gives rise
to a question of law.
(ii) The High Court should be satisfied
that the case involves a substantial
question of law, and not a mere
question of law. A question of law
having a material bearing on the
decision of the case (that is, a
question, answer to which affects the
rights of parties to the suit) will be a
substantial question of law, if it is not
covered by any specific provisions of
law or settled legal principle emerging
from binding precedents, and, involves
a debatable legal issue. A substantial
question of law will also arise in a
contrary situation, where the legal
position is clear, either on account of
express provisions of law or binding
precedents, but the court below has
decided the matter, either ignoring or
acting contrary to such legal principle.
In the second type of cases, the
substantial question of law arises not
because the law is still debatable, but
because the decision rendered on a
material question, violates the settled
position of law.
(iii) The general rule is that the High
Court will not interfere with the
concurrent findings of the courts
below. But it is not absolute rule.
Some
of
the
well-recognised
exceptions are where (i) the courts
below have ignored material evidence
or acted on no evidence; (ii) the
courts have drawn wrong inference
from proved facts by applying the law
erroneously; or (iii) the courts have
wrongly cast the burden of proof.
When we refer to „decision based on
no evidence‟, it not only refers to
cases where there is a total dearth of
evidence, but also refers to any case,
where the evidence, taken as a whole,
is
not
reasonably
capable
of
supporting the finding.”
26.
Situated thus, it appears to this Court that both
the Learned Courts below have erred in ignoring the facts of
forceful occupation of 14 decimals of land by the respondentdefendant and since the respondent-defendant did not raise
any objection over said 14 decimals of land, so, the
appellant-plaintiff is entitled to get recovery of possession of
the said land from the contesting respondent-defendant,
belonging to the appellant-plaintiff. The substantial question
of law formulated, is accordingly answered.
27.
Admittedly, the suit was filed for 38 decimals of
land by the appellant-plaintiff, but later on he abandoned his
claim for the rest 24 decimals of land, rather, restricted his
claim upto 14 decimals of land and accordingly, the
appellant-plaintiff filed a prayer for amendment of plaintiff
before the Learned Court below which was dismissed by
order dated 15.03.2019. So, after hearing both the sides and
going through the citations referred by Learned Counsel for
the appellant, it appears that this suit be remanded back to
the Learned Court below with a direction to the appellantplaintiff to submit a fresh prayer for amendment of plaint for
land measuring 14 decimals (7 gandas) mentioning specific
and
clear
boundary
based
on
the
report
of
Survey
Commissioner and the Learned Court below shall pass a
fresh judgment after allowing amendment of the application
of the appellant-plaintiff on hearing both the sides. Learned
Trial Court below may rely upon the earlier evidence on
record, if not required to be recorded fresh evidence.
28.
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant-
plaintiff is hereby allowed on contest. The judgment and
decree dated 29.09.2021 and 01.10.2021 respectively of the
Learned First Appellate Court, Belonia, South Tripura in
connection with case No.T.A.No.14 of 2019 as well as the
judgment and decree dated 15.03.2019 passed by Learned
Civil Judge, Junior Division, Belonia, South Tripura in
connection with case No.T.S.No.20 of 2008 is hereby set
aside. The suit be remanded back to the Learned Trial Court
below with a direction upon the appellant-plaintiff to submit
a fresh prayer for amendment of plaint in respect of 14
decimals of land mentioning clear description of the property
and the Learned Court below shall after hearing both the
sides, allow the petition and thereupon pass a fresh
judgment and decree based on Survey Commissioner’s
Report and evidence on record within a period of three
months from the date of receipt of the copy of this
judgment. Both the parties shall accordingly appear before
the Learned Trial Court below for further proceeding on
12.08.2024.
Send down the LCRs along with a copy of the
judgment.
Prepare decree accordingly.
Pending
application(s),
if
any,
also
stands
disposed of.
JUDGE
MOUMITA DATTA DATTA
Date: 2024.07.30 18:16:26 +05'30'
Purnita
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review