Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/17
GAHC010288902025
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/7481/2025
SRI GOPAL AGARWALLA
S/O LATE SEW KUMAR AGARWALA
RESIDENT OF HOUSE NO.32, BASANTA DOLEY PATH, BELTOLA COLLEGE
ROAD, GUWAHATI, DIST. KAMRUP (M), ASSAM, PIN-7810296
VERSUS
OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LTD AND 4 ORS.
A GOVT. OF INDIA ENTERPRISE DULY INCORPORATED UNDER THE
COMPANIES ACT, 1956 HAVING ITS REGISTERED OFFICE AT PANDIT DEEN
DYAL UPADHAYAYA URJA BHAVAN, 5, NELSON MANDELA MARG,
VASANTA KUNJ, NEW DELHI -110070 AND
REGIONAL OFFICE AT NAZIR IN THE DISTRICT OF SIVASAGAR, ASSAM,
REPRESENTED BY THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR, EASTERN REGION,
ONGCL, NAZIRA, ASSAM, PIN-785684.
2:THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
ASSAM ASSET
NAZIRA SIVASAGAR
ASSAM.
3:THE GROUP GENERAL MANAGER
HEAD CCLG-CPD
8TH FLOOR
CENTRAL PROCUREMENT DEPARTMENT
CCLG-LAKSHMI NAGAR
NEW DELHI
110092.
Page No.# 2/17
4:THE SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER CPD-CCLG DELHI
OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED
SCOPE MINAR LAXMI NAGAR NEW DELHI.
5:ENQUIRYT OFFICER
GM(P)-HSE
ONGC
MH ASSET
MUMBAI
VASUDHARA BHAVAN
BANDRA EAST
MUMBAI- 400051
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR. A K GUPTA, MR. R K MAHANTA
Advocate for the Respondent : MR. P BARUAH,
Linked Case : WP(C)/114/2026
BIJAY KUMAR AGARWAL
SON OF LATE SEW KUMAR AGARWAL
RESIDENT OF ATHKEL
P.S. GELAKEY
DISTRICT- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
VERSUS
OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LTD. AND 4 ORS
A GOVT. OF INDIA ENTERPRISE DULY INCORPORATED UNDER THE
COMPANIES ACT
1956 HAVING ITS REGISTERED OFFICE AT PANDIT DEEN DAYAL
UPADHAYAYA URJA BHAVAN
NELSON MANDELA MARG
VASANTA KUNJ
NEW DELHI- 110070 AND
REGIONAL OFFICE AT NAZIRA IN THE DISTRICT OF SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
Page No.# 3/17
REPRESENTED BY THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
EASTERN REGION
ONGCL
NAZIRA
ASSAM
PIN- 785684
2:THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
ASSAM
ASSET
NAZIRA SIVASAGAR ASSAM
3:THE GROUP GENERAL MANAGER
HEAD CCLG-CPD
8TH FLOOR
CENTRAL PROCUREMENT DEPARTMENT
CCLG- LAKSHMINAGAR
NEW DELHI
110092
4:THE SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER CPD-CCLG DELHI
OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED SCOPE MINAR LAXMI
NAGAR NEW DELHI
5:ENQUIRY OFFICER
GM(P)-HSE
ONGC
MH ASSET
MUMBAI
VASUNDHARA BHAVAN
BANDRA EAST
MUMBAI- 400051
-----------Advocate for : MR. R S MISHRA
Advocate for : SC
ONGC appearing for OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LTD. AND 4 ORS
Linked Case : WP(C)/7418/2025
SHRI HITESH DUTTA
S/O- LATE RUPESWAR DUTTA.
R/O- BOKHOTA
P.O.- NANGALAMORA
DIST.- SIVSAGAR
Page No.# 4/17
ASSAM.
VERSUS
OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LTD
A GOVT. OF INDIA ENTERPRISE DULY INCORPORATED UNDER THE
COMPANIES ACT
1956 HAVING ITS REGISTERED OFFICE AT PANDIT DEEN DAYAL
UPADHAYAYA URJA BHAVAN
NELSON MANDELA MARG
VASANTA KUNJ
NEW DELHI-110070
AND
REGIONAL OFFICE AT NAZIRA IN THE DISTRICT OF SIVSAGAR
ASSAM
REPRESENTED BY THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
EASTERN REGION
ONGCL
NAZIRA
ASSAM
PIN- 785684.
2:THE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
ASSAM ASSET
NAZIRA
SIVSAGAR
ASSAM.
3:THE GROUP GENERAL MANAGER
HEAD CCLG-CPD
8TH FLOOR
CENTRAL PROCUREMENT DEPARTMENT
CCLG- LAKSHMINAGAR
NEW DELHI-110092.
4:THE SUPERINTENDING ENGINNER CPD-CCLG DELHI
OIL AND NATURAL GAS CORPORATION LIMITED SCOPE MINAR LAXMI
NAGAR
NEW DELHI
5:ENQUIRY OFFICER
GM(P)- HSE
ONGC
Page No.# 5/17
MH ASSET
MUMBAI
VASUDHARA BHAVAN
BANDRA EAST
MUMBAI-400051.
-----------Advocate for : MS M NIROLA
Advocate for : MR P BARUAH appearing for OIL AND NATURAL GAS
CORPORATION LTD
- BEFORE -
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY KUMAR MEDHI
Advocate for the petitioner in WP(C) No. 7481/2025 : Shri. A.K Gupta
Advocate for the petitioner in WP(C) No. 7418/2025 : Ms. M. Nirola
Advocate for the petitioner in WP(C) No. 114/2026 : Shri. R.S Mishra
Advocate for the respondents
: Shri. I. Choudhury, Sr. Adv.
Shri. P. Barua, ONGC
Date on which judgment is reserved
: 28.08.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment
: 17.09.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the
operative part of the judgment ?
: No
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced?
: Yes
JUDGMENT & ORDER
1.
The cause of action in these 3 writ petitions being common and
analogous, those were heard together and disposed of by this common
judgement and order. The challenge is with regard to the decision of the
ONGC, initiating action for blacklisting the petitioners and also for
Page No.# 6/17
forfeiture of the EMD.
2.
At the outset, the learned counsel for the petitioners have clarified
that the present challenge would be on the subject matter of forfeiture of
the EMD. It may be mentioned that, while issuing notice, this particular
issue was also noted by this Court on 07.01.2026, when this Court had
observed that there were apparently two separate and distinct causes of
action.
3.
As per the facts projected, a Notice Inviting Tender (hereinafter NIT)
dated 16.05.2025 was issued by the ONGC for the work “Annual Rate
Contract for Construction of various Drill sites and other Civil jobs for
exploratory and development location at Jorhat Asset for 3(three) years
(2025-2028)”. The petitioners claim to have submitted their respective
bids for quantum of work of 16% and had also deposited the EMD of
₹29,35,000/-. However, vide an e-mail dated 02.09.2025, the bids of the
petitioners were rejected on the ground of violation of Section 2(1)(b) of
the Integrity Pact. It was alleged that the IP addresses of the petitioners
mentioned in the portal were the same. The petitioners claim to have
submitted representation, which was, however, rejected and thereafter on
08.12.2025, show cause notices were issued against the petitioners under
Section 2(1)(b) of the Integrity Pact requiring to show cause as to why the
petitioners should not be blacklisted. It is this cause of action for which
the present writ petitions were instituted. As noted above, it has however,
been clarified that since 2 distinct causes of action were sought to be
amalgamated, the petitioners would restrict the present challenge only to
Page No.# 7/17
the aspect of forfeiture of the EMD.
4.
I have heard Shri A.K. Gupta, learned counsel for the petitioner in
WP(C)/7481/2025; Ms. M. Nirola, learned counsel for the petitioner in
WP(C)/7418/2025 and Shri R.S. Mishra, learned counsel for the petitioner
in WP(C)/114/2026. I have also heard Shri I. Choudhury, learned Senior
Counsel assisted by Shri P. Barua, learned counsel for the respondents
ONGC.
5.
Shri Gupta, the learned counsel for the petitioner in WP(C) 7481/2025
has submitted that the impugned action of forfeiture of the EMD has been
done without any application of mind and on mere surmises and
conjectures. He has submitted that though it is a matter of fact that the
bid system was online, the same was done through a common service
provider – one Shri Durlov Gogoi, who renders such online service in the
city of Sivasagar. He has submitted that for more than a decade, such
services are being offered by the aforesaid gentleman and accordingly, the
IP address of the petitioner was identical with the bids of the other parties
who had also submitted online bids from the said service provider. He has
submitted that, from the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the ONGC, it
appears that the action was taken on certain discernible grounds, namely,
same IP address, same Chartered Accountant who gave the certificates,
identical appendices BP-1, BP-2 and BP-3 and identical appendix GU. So
far as the petitioners in WP(C)/7481/2025 and WP(C)/114/2026 are
concerned, there is another ground that the parties were brothers and
therefore, it was assumed that there was a connivance. The learned
Page No.# 8/17
counsel has submitted that the aforesaid reasons are untenable on facts
as well as in law.
6.
By referring to the affidavit-in-reply filed on 19.08.2026, the learned
counsel for the petitioner has submitted that it was very common for the
contractors in Sivasagar to avail the services of the said Shri Durlov Gogoi.
He has submitted that the process being online and there was lack of
expertise, the petitioner, along with others availed such services which is a
mere coincidence and cannot be assumed to form a cartel. He has also
given the explanation that having a certificate from the same Chartered
Accountant is also a mere coincidence and would not be conclusive of
forming a cartel. As regards the relationship between the petitioners in
WP(C)/7481/2025 and WP(C)/114/2026, he submits that though as a
matter of fact, the proprietor of one of the petitioner is the brother of the
other petitioner, they have independent business and therefore, the same
cannot be conclusive of forming a cartel. He has clarified that 30 nos. of
bidders had participated in the bid who could quote either 16% or 20%.
He has submitted the petitioners have quoted 16% and in the process,
others would also get some part of the work.
7.
In support of his submission, Shri Gupta, the learned counsel for the
petitioner has relied upon the following case laws:
i)
AIR Online 2018 SC 736 [Rajasthan Cylinders &
Containers Limited V. Union of India].
ii) AIR online 2026 Gau 19 [M/s Versha Technotrade Pvt.
Ltd. V. State of Assam]
Page No.# 9/17
iii) 2026:BHC-Nag: 6315 [M/s G.H. Khandelwal V. Amravati
Municipal Corporation]
8.
In the case of Rajasthan Cylinders (supra), the concept of bid
rigging has been explained by the Hon’ble Supreme Court. In the case of
Versha (supra), this Court had held that if there is a common site visit by
two bidders where such cite visit is mandatory, no definite conclusion can
be drawn that a cartel was formed. In the case of Khandelwal (supra) a
Division Bench of the Bombay High Court has submitted that mere
participation of two parties who are related as son and father would not
by itself constitute forming of a cartel.
9.
The learned counsel for the petitioner has accordingly submitted that
the impugned action is unsustainable in law and is liable to be set aside.
10. Supporting the submissions of Sri Gupta, Shri Mishra the learned
counsel for the petitioner in WP(C)/114/2026 has added that the work
distribution methodology would not permit assumption of formation of a
cartel. He has submitted that in total, 30 nos. of bidders had participated
in the tender process and the work is to be distributed amongst 6 bidders.
He has submitted that the petitioners are 3(three) in numbers and
therefore, they cannot form a cartel. In this connection, he has relied
upon Clauses (iv) and (v) of the bid document. He has further submitted
that the prices were yet to be opened and therefore, the conclusion of
forming a cartel is premature.
11. Ms. Nirola, learned counsel for the petitioner in WP(C)/7418/2025
Page No.# 10/17
has adopted the arguments of the learned counsel for the petitioners in
the other two petitions and submitted that the writ petition be allowed.
12. Per contra, Shri I. Choudhury, learned Senior Counsel for the ONGC
has submitted that the contentions advanced towards the challenge made
by the petitioners are wholly unsustainable in law. He has submitted that
it is not only the 3 petitioners against whom the allegation of cartel is
there and as a matter of fact, out of 30 nos. of participating bidders, the
allegation of forming a cartel is against 15 nos. He has informed that it is
a different matter that the rest 12 nos. of bidders have not come to the
Court challenging such decision. He has clarified that the challenge on the
aspect of blacklisting has already been given up by the petitioners and the
present challenge is only with respect to the forfeiture of EMD.
13. The learner Senior Counsel for the ONGC has submitted that on
11.11.2025, the contracts were already given and thereafter the writ
petitions were filed. However, such allotments of contracts were not the
subject matter of challenge and there was no interim order. Further, the
petitioners did not take any steps for modification of the writ petitions or
amendment so as to implead the successful bidders. He has also brought
the attention of this Court to the order passed on 07.01.2026, wherein this
Court had observed that there are two distinct and separate causes of
action.
14. By drawing the attention of this Court to the affidavit-in-opposition
filed by the ONGC on 08.04.2026, the learner Senior Counsel has
submitted that guidelines have been framed by the Competition
Page No.# 11/17
Commission of India. He has submitted that in such guidelines, certain
“warning signals” are indicated which would be discernable from the
documents. Those include bidders being sister concerns, same mistakes in
the bids, same IP address etc. For ready reference, the said warning
signals given by the Competition Commission of India are extracted here
in below:
“(ii) Warning Signals in Documents
·
Bids were prepared by the same person or were prepared jointly.
·
Identical mistakes/corrections in the bid documents or letters
submitted by different companies, such as spelling errors.
·
Bids from different companies contain similar handwriting or
typeface or use identical forms or stationery.
·
Bid documents from one company make express reference to
competitors' bids or use another bidder's letterhead or fax number.
·
Bids from different companies contain identical mis-calculations.
·
Bids from different companies contain a significant number of
identical estimates of the cost of certain items.
·
The packagings from different companies have similar postmarks or
post metering machine marks.
·
Bid documents from different companies indicate numerous last
minute adjustments, such as the use of erasers or other physical
alterations.
·
Bid documents submitted by different companies contain less detail
that would be necessary or expected, or give other indications of not
being genuine.
Page No.# 12/17
·
Two or more bidders offered same nomenclature or brand name of
specialized product although they claim to be manufacturers.
·
Bids submitted by firms are sister concerns or have common
directors in their Board of Directors or having more than 50% stake or
shareholding in the other firm.
·
Bids submitted by the bidder is incomplete or submit less
credentials although have the potential to do the work or qualify in the
tender.
·
Bids of one or more bidders have the same language mistakes or
some stylistic similarities (the use of identical terminology, identical
mistakes in the calculations, identical crossing outs or changes of
certain figures, identical handwriting when the tender documentation
should be completed in handwriting).
·
When submitted electronically the documents of the different
bidders, contain edits made by the same people, or edits made at one
and the same time.
·
Bidders are having the same address/office/authorized signatory
etc.
·
Bidders having position of common Key Managerial Person (KMP) or
Partner or Proprietor.
·
Bidders using same email ids.
·
Bids received from same IP address.
·
Bids submitted within short span of time.”
15. He has also drawn the attention of this Court to the requirement of
Integrity Pact (IP) for tenders above Rs.1(one) crore as found in Clause (f)
Page No.# 13/17
of the tender document read with Section 2(1)(b). He has also referred to
the techno-commercial bid evaluation criteria, more particularly, Clause
4.0(h.ii) that offers of bidders violating the provisions of the Integrity Pact
would be rejected and by following such provision the bids have been
rejected. He has also drawn the attention of this Court to the aspect that
there is an Independent External Monitor (IEM) under Section 8 which can
be approached by any aggrieved bidders. He has submitted that, as a
matter of fact, the petitioner in WP(C)/114/2026 had approached the said
IEM which was rejected on 28.10.2025. He has submitted that such
rejection is not the subject matter of challenge. He has also submitted
that in paragraph 5.3, the IEM has stated the reasons of such rejection
which are germane and not liable for any interference.
16. In support of his submissions, the learned Senior Counsel for the
ONGC has drawn the attention of this Court to the following decisions:
i) Air India Ltd V. Cochin International Airport Ltd. [(2000)
2 SCC 617]
ii) Silppi Constructions Contractors V. Union of India
[(2020) 16 SCC 489]
17. In the case of Cochin International (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme
Court had reiterated that judicial review under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India is not an appeal and the examination is of the
decision-making process and the Court should weigh the private grievance
against larger public interest.
18. In the case of Silppi Constructions (supra), it has been laid down
Page No.# 14/17
that in matters of contract, there should judicial restraint and Court should
not easily interfere which commercial decision made by the State or its
instrumentalities.
19. The rival submissions advanced in the Bar have been duly considered
and the materials placed before this Court have been carefully examined.
20. As appears from the writ petitions, the challenge was structured both
on the aspect of blacklisting as well as forfeiture of the EMD. However, as
noted above, it has been clarified that the present challenge would be
confined to the aspect of forfeiture of the EMD.
21.
The forfeiture of EMD triggers from a decision arrived at by the
ONGC that the petitioners had formed a cartel. Though a protection was
made by the petitioners that there were in total 30 nos. of bidders and
therefore, 3 petitioners could not have formed a cartel, however, such
projection appears to be factually incorrect inasmuch as allegation of
forming a cartel has been made against 15 nos. of bidders and 12 nos. of
bidders have not put the aforesaid decision to challenge. It is only the 3
(three) nos. of petitioners have come before this Court by filing Writ
Petitions. Therefore, the contention that a cartel cannot be formed by 3
parties cannot be countenanced.
22. Coming to the merits of the case, the respondent ONGC has arrived
at the conclusion based upon certain objective satisfactions. Such
objective satisfactions have been incorporated in the affidavit-inopposition filed by the ONGC. Amongst others, it has been stated that the
Page No.# 15/17
IP addresses (49.37.100.115) of all the petitioners are the same; the CA
certificate which is mandatory in nature were issued by the same
Chartered Accountant; identical appendix in BP1, BP2 and BP3 have been
furnished by all the petitioners; the Appendix GU is also identical. As noted
above, there is also an additional ground so far as the petitioners in
WP(C)7481/2025 and WP(C)114/2026 are concerned that the petitioners
are brothers. The petitioners had given certain explanations that it was a
common practice to avail the services of one Shri Durlov Gogoi in
submitting bids which are in the online mode. It is also submitted that
certificates taken by the same Chartered Accountant is a mere
coincidence.
23. Though the ground taken that the petitioners in WP(C)/7481/2025
and WP(C)/114/2026 regarding brothers may not, by itself be a ground to
assume formation of a cartel, the same is to be examined from the point
of view of the “warning signals” which has been given in the form of
guidelines by the Competition Commission of India to avoid any
cartelisation. While two brothers may do business independently and
being brothers, would not by itself be a reason to presume formation of a
cartel, the same may still be one of the factors to come to a conclusion of
such cartelization. The guidelines by the Competition Commission of India
have already been extracted above. The same include committing the
same mistake, submission of bids from the same IP addresses etc.
Though the petitioners have come up with the explanation that one Shri
Durlov Gogoi was an expert in submitting bids through e-mode, when
such practice was declared by the Competition Commission of India to be
Page No.# 16/17
one of the factors to presume formation of a cartel, the petitioners should
have taken due care and attention not to submit bids through one IP
address. As revealed in the deliberation, there were in total 30 nos. of
bidders and cartel has been found against 15 nos. The same would imply
that so far as the other 15 nos. of successful bidders are concerned, they
had submitted online bids through different IP addresses.
24. This Court is unable to accept the submissions and explanations
made on behalf of the petitioners that furnishing of a certificate by the
same Chartered Accountant is a mere coincidence. The petitioners ought
to have been alert and vigilant so that such scope of drawing a
presumption leading to levelling of an allegation does not arise. As noted
above, the rest of the 15 nos. of bidders had also submitted CA
certificates which clearly appear to be from different Chartered
Accountants. This Court has also noticed that apart from the aspect of the
Certificate by the same CA, the appendices of the bids submitted by the
petitioners are identical.
25. This Court is of the considered opinion that the decision-making
process taken by ONGC has been done on the basis of objective materials
which are discernible from the materials made available. Under those
circumstances, the scope of interference in such decision making process
would be absolutely circumscribed. This Court has also noticed that the
power to forfeit EMD which is a part of Section 4 of the Integrity Pact
namely, Section 4(1)(1) is not the subject matter of challenge.
26. In the case of Silppi Construction (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme
Page No.# 17/17
Court has laid down the principles that exercise of judicial review in
matters pertaining contract should be circumscribed and such interference
can be made only when a case of gross illegality, perversity and
unreasonableness is made out. However, in the instant case, the decision
appears to be reasonable which appeals to the mind of a common man.
27. In view of the aforesaid discussions, the writ petitions are held to be
devoid of any merit and are accordingly dismissed. The interim orders
operating are vacated.
28. This Court makes it clear that the present adjudication is only on the
aspect of forfeiture of the EMD and therefore, the petitioners would be at
liberty to challenge the decision on blacklisting, if so advised.
29. No order as to costs.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review