The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
14. So, after hearing the submission of the Learned counsels of both the sides and also after going through the judgment of the Learned court below and also on perusal of the evidence on record it appears that the Learned Tribunal below after considering the oral/documentary evidence on record rightly and reasonably has delivered the judgment dismissing the suit of the appellant-plaintiff. Hence this court does not find any scope to interfere with the judgment and decree delivered by Learned Trial Court below and the same is accordingly liable to be dismissed.
15. In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant is hereby dismissed on contest but without any costs. The judgment and order dated 30.07.2022 and decree dated
04. 08.2022 delivered by Learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), Dharmanagar, North Tripura in connection with Case No. Money Suit 03 of 2017 is hereby upheld and the same is accordingly affirmed. Send down the LCRs along with a copy of this judgment. Prepare the decree accordingly. Pending application(s) if any, stands disposed of. MOUMITA Digitally 02:00:18 +05'30' Moumita
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RFA No.16 of 2023
Sri Dulan Bhattacharya,
S/O. Late Jogendra Ch. Bhattacharya,
resident of P.O. & P.S. Churaibari,
Dharmanagar, North Tripura
----Appellant(s)
Versus
Sri Debabrata Paul @ Tinku,
S/O. Late Sunil Ch. Paul,
resident of Padhya Kashipur,
P.S.Reshambagan, Agartala,
West Tripura
---- Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. S. Deb, Sr. Adv.
Mr. S. Datta, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S. M. Chakraborty, Sr. Adv.
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, Adv.
Date of Hearing
:
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order :
Whether fit for
Reporting
:
02.12.2024
07.12.2024
YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This appeal under Section 96 read with Order XLI of CPC
is filed challenging the judgment dated 30.07.2022 and decree
dated 04.08.2022 delivered by Learned Civil Judge (Sr.
Division), Dharmanagar, North Tripura in connection with
Money Suit 03 of 2017 dismissing the suit of the plaintiff.
02.
Heard Learned Senior Counsel Mr. S. Deb assisted
by Mr. S. Datta, Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
appellant-plaintiff and also heard Learned Senior Counsel Mr.
S. M. Chakraborty assisted by Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, Learned
counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent-defendant.
03.
In course of hearing of argument Learned Senior
counsel Mr. S. Deb appearing for the appellant-plaintiff first of
all drawn the attention of the court referring para nos.3, 4 and
5 of the plaint and also drawn the attention of the court
referring para nos.7, 8, 10 and 16 of the written statement
filed by the respondent-defendant and submitted that before
the Learned Trial court the respondent-defendant has failed to
show that he has paid Rs.3,00,000/- to the appellant-plaintiff
as mentioned in para No.7 of the written statement. But he
admitted that the appellant had received the amount of
Rs.30,000/- as mentioned in para-8 of the W/S and referring
the provisions of Order 8 Rule 4 of CPC, and Rule 5 he
submitted that by evasive denial the defendant cannot be
exempted from the liability of the payment of dues amount
and furthermore referring the statement of accounts of the
appellant which was marked as Exbt.3. Learned Senior
Counsel drawn the attention of the court that from the said
statement nowhere it will be found that the respondentdefendant has ever paid Rs.3,00,000/- as alleged to the
appellant-plaintiff of the suit. Learned Senior Counsel also
drawn the attention of the court the demand notice issued by
the appellant-plaintiff to the respondent-defendant (Exbt.1)
and the reply made by the said defendant Exbt.A (3 pages)
submitted that excepting Rs.30,000/- the appellant-plaintiff
did not receive that amount of Rs.3,00,000/- as alleged by the
defendant in two written statements. But the Learned Trial
Court below failed to appreciate the evidence on record
properly. He also drawn the attention of the court the
evidence on record of the witnesses of the parties and
submitted that the judgment and decree of the Learned court
below suffers from infirmities and urged for allowing this
appeal by setting aside the judgment and decree of the
Learned Trial Court below.
04.
M.
On the other hand, Learned Senior Counsel Mr. S.
Chakraborty
assisted
by
Learned
counsel
Mr.
S.
Bhattacharjee, first of all drawn the attention of the court that
the present appeal is not maintainable as because the
appellant-plaintiff has not come before the court with clean
hands. He first of all drawn the attention of the court the
evidence of CW-1, Tamoghna Bhattacharjee and his deposition
and also Exbt.BS series from where it is clear that on
15.05.2013 Rs.3,00,000/- was transferred by the respondentdefendant to the account of the appellant-plaintiff and that
was duly credited to the respective account of the appellantplaintiff. So Learned Senior counsel submitted that there was
no infirmity in the judgment delivered by Learned Trial court
and urged for dismissal of this appeal with costs.
05.
Here, in the case at hand the appellant-plaintiff
filed the suit before the court of Learned Civil Judge, Senior
Division for realization of money amounting to Rs.8,31,507/-.
According to the appellant-plaintiff the plaintiff is a Timber
Merchant and has been doing his timber business with name
and fame and used to purchase timber/logs from various land
owners and also used to sell the name to the different
persons. The appellant-plaintiff purchased 49.693 cum of
round block timber from one Sudhir Ch. Dey and Dilip Narayan
Das of Kurti and sold out the aforesaid 49.693 cum of round
block timber to the respondent-defendant @ Rs.9750/- per
cum with the condition that the respondent-defendant would
pay the purchased money amounting to Rs.4,84,507/- only by
installments time to time after selling the purchased round
block timber with the further condition that the respondentdefendant must make all the payment of the said timber
within three years from the date of 1st delivery and accordingly
the appellant-plaintiff delivered the logs as per the following
dates:
Sl.
No.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
06.
Date
Lorry No.
T.P No.
Volume(M3)
14.08.2013
16.08.2013
18.08.2013
28.08.2013
28.08.2013
TRL 3367
TRL 3992
TRL 3367
TRL 3367
TR01-1606
683480
683481
683482
683483
683486
9.633
9.936
10.133
10.024
9.967
It was further stated by the appellant that the
respondent-defendant paid total amount of Rs.1,53,000/- only
against the purchased round block timber through cheques out
of total amount of Rs.4,84,507/- which are as follows:
Sl.
No.
1.
2.
3.
07.
The
Date
Amount(Rs.)
17.08.2013
09.10.2013
16.04.2014
53,000/50,000/50,000/-
appellant-plaintiff
further
stated
that
the
defendant-respondent did not pay the balance amount of
Rs.3,31,507/- to the appellant. As such the plaintiff was
entitled to the balance amount of Rs.3,31,507/-. It was also
stated that the appellant-plaintiff time to time requested the
defendant-respondent to make payment of the said balance
amount, but each
and
every
occasion
the
respondent-
defendant requested the appellant-plaintiff to wait for some
months. In this way many months and time has been elapsed
and on the expiry of three years i.e. w.e.f. 14.08.2013 the
appellant-plaintiff approached to respondent-defendant on
01.09.2016 for payment of the balance amount and the
respondent-defendant took 6 months time for payment of the
balance amount but failed. Thereafter the appellant-plaintiff
further requested the defendant for making payment of the
balance
amount,
but
the
respondent-defendant
did
not
response and due to that the plaintiff was suffering both
mentally and physically and sustained huge loss and so he was
entitled to Rs.2,00,000/- for business loss, Rs.1,00,000/- for
pain and sufferings and Rs.2,00,000/- for loss of good
reputation of business.
08.
The appellant-plaintiff further asserted that finding
no other alternative the appellant compelled to serve one
advocate’s
notice
dated
25.03.2017
to
the
respondent-
defendant with demand and request to pay Rs.8,31,507/- to
the appellant-plaintiff within a period of seven days after
receipt of the notice. But in pursuance of the said notice the
respondent-defendant gave a reply through his engaged
lawyer on 04.04.2017 wherein it was stated that he already
paid the amount to the plaintiff. Hence the plaintiff-appellant
has filed the suit.
09.
The
sole
respondent-defendant
appeared
and
submitted written statement wherein it was stated that the
appellant-plaintiff has suppressed the fact that an amount of
Rs.3,00,000/- was paid by him in advance to the plaintiff from
the State Bank of India C.C. Account directly to the account of
the plaintiff and the defendant reserved his right to submit the
bank statement before the court to show the falsity of the
statement.
It
was
further
stated
that
the
respondent-
defendant has paid another amount of Rs.30,000/- in cash on
07.07.2014
and
the balance amount of Rs.1507/- was
relinquished by the appellant-plaintiff verbally after receipt of
the full payment but to the utter surprise and misfortune the
appellant-plaintiff despite receipt of the full payment filed the
suit. It was further asserted that the suit was by this time
barred for which the same was liable to be dismissed.
However, upon the pleadings of the parties Learned court
below framed the following issues:
(1)
Whether the suit is maintainable?
(2)
Whether the suit is barred by law of limitation?
(3)
Whether plaintiff sold out 49.693 cum of round block
timber
to
the
defendant
for
consideration
of
Rs.4,84,507/- within the period of 14.08.2013 to
29.08.2013?
(4)
Whether defendant failed to make payment of balance
consideration money of Rs.3,31,507/- to plaintiff within 3
years from the date of first delivery since 14.08.2013?
(5)
Whether Plaintiff suffered any loss in business and
reputation and sufferings due to non-payment of the
balance money?
(6)
Whether defendant make payment of total Rs.3 lacs to
the plaintiff from his C.C Account and Rs.30,000/- in cash
on 07.07.2014?
(7)
Whether there is cause of action in this suit?
(8)
Whether plaintiffs are entitled to get decree of recovery
of total Rs.8,31,507/- along with interest @ 18% per
annum w.w.f. 01.04.2017?
10.
To substantiate the issues the appellant-plaintiff
was examined and cross-examined as PW-1 and relied upon
some documents which were marked as Exbt.1 and Exbt.2. On
the
other
hand,
the
respondent-defendant
submitted
examination-in-chief in affidavit of two witnesses who were
examined as DW-1 and DW-2 and they relied upon some
documents which were marked as Exbt.A to Exbt.D which are
as follows:
(A) Plaintiff-Appellant’s Witness:PW-1:- Dulan Bhattacharya
(B) Plaintiff-Appellant’s Exhibits:(1) Exbt.1 as a whole- Advocate notice dated
25.03.2017.
(2) Exbt.2 – Copy of reply of advocate notice dated
04.04.2017
(C) Defendant-Respondent Witnesses:DW-1:- Debabrata Paul
DW-2:- Tejendra Majumder
(D) Defendants Exhibits:(1)
Exbt.A- Reply of Advocate’s notice dated
25.03.2017 sent on 04.04.2017.
(2)
Exbt.C – Registered Letter slip bearing
No.RE.4695513118 IN
(3)
Exbt.D – Accounts Statement relating to
defendant
dated
24.05.2017
vide
AC
No.32952042713 SBI MBB College Branch.
(E) Court Witness:CW-1 – Sri Tamoghna Bhattacharjee
CW-2 – Sri Saibal Kanti Roy
(F) Material Exhibit : Nil
11.
Finally on conclusion of trial Learned court below
dismissed the suit. The operative portion of the judgment and
order of the Learned Trial Court dated 30.07.2022 is narrated
below:
“21. In the result on the basis of the above discussion
and deliberation, the suit is dismissed on merits.
The cost of the suit shall be borne by the plaintiff.
This suit is disposed off accordingly on contest.
Sherestedar is directed to prepare decree accordingly
and place it before the undersigned within 15 days.
This Judgment and Order is passed on this 30th day of
January, 2022 under the seal and signature of the Court.
Make necessary entry in the Trial Register.
Record shall be sent to the Record Room after due
compliance.”
12.
I have heard detailed argument of both the sides
and gone through the record of the Learned Court below
including the judgment and decree delivered by the Learned
Trial Court. As already stated to substantiate the suit Learned
Trial Court in total framed eight nos. of issues. Learned Court
below at the time of delivery of judgment discussed the
evidence on record in detail and after perusal of the
oral/documentary evidence on record decided the issues
accordingly and
deciding
issue
observation
finally dismissed the suit. However, in
No.6 Learned
that
the
court below came to the
defendant
submitted
a
reply
of
Advocate’s notice dated 23.03.2017 sent on 04.04.2017,
Registered Letter slip bearing No.RE.469551318 and Accounts
Statement
relating
to defendant
dated 24.05.2017
vide
Account No.32952042713 of SBI MBB College Branch. The
court cited witness has exhibited bank statement consisting of
3 pages and transaction dated 15.05.2013. Learned Trial
Court below on considering the evidence on record and the
documents exhibited by the respondent-defendant specially
Exbt.B came to the observation that on 15.05.2013 an amount
of Rs.3,00,000/- was debited from the account of Joyram
Timber against Account No.32952042713 and the same was
transferred
and
credited
to
the
account
vide
No.0010987597757 belonging to the appellant-plaintiff.
13.
The appellant-plaintiff tried to counter the said
argument
of
the
respondent-defendant
by
showing
the
account statement of SBI Branch relating to the period with
effect from 01.04.2010 to 31.03.2011 [Exbt.3] and Learned
Senior Counsel in course of hearing of argument drawn the
attention of the court that the transaction was a continuous
business
transaction
which
was
not
disputed
by
the
respondent-defendant. There is also no contrary evidence on
record from the side of the appellant that the said payment of
Rs.3,00,000/- was made by the respondent-defendant for
some other purpose or for discharging previous debts which
was not related to the present cause of action. Moreso, on
perusal of Exbt.3 it appears that it has got no nexus with the
plaint filed by the appellant-plaintiff and on perusal of the
evidence of court witnesses and other evidence on record and
the evidence of DWs it further appears that the defendant also
made payment of Rs.30,000/- in cash to the appellant-plaintiff
on 07.07.2014 relinquishing the balance amount of Rs.1507/on
the
request
of
respondent-defendant
the
respondent-defendant.
could
prove
that
he
Thus
the
had
paid
Rs.3,00,000/- to the plaintiff-appellant from his C.C. account
and also Rs.30,000/- in cash on 07.07.2014 to the appellantplaintiff. So finally Learned Trial Court below came to the
observation that the defendant was able to make payment of
the balance consideration money of Rs.3,31,507/- to the
appellant-plaintiff within three years from the date of first
delivery i.e. on 14.08.2013 and ultimately decided the issues
against the appellant-plaintiff and also in favour of the
respondent-defendant.
14.
So, after hearing the submission of the Learned
counsels of both the sides and also after going through the
judgment of the Learned court below and also on perusal of
the evidence on record it appears that the Learned Tribunal
below after considering the oral/documentary evidence on
record rightly and reasonably has delivered the judgment
dismissing the suit of the appellant-plaintiff. Hence this court
does not find any scope to interfere with the judgment and
decree delivered by Learned Trial Court below and the same is
accordingly liable to be dismissed.
15.
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant is
hereby dismissed on contest but without any costs. The
judgment and order dated 30.07.2022 and decree dated
04.08.2022 delivered by Learned Civil Judge (Senior Division),
Dharmanagar, North Tripura in connection with Case No.
Money Suit 03 of 2017 is hereby upheld and the same is
accordingly affirmed.
Send down the LCRs along with a copy of this
judgment.
Prepare the decree accordingly.
Pending application(s) if any, stands disposed of.
JUDGE
signed by
MOUMITA Digitally
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2024.12.09
DATTA
02:00:18 +05'30'
Moumita
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review