The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
7. As such, we are inclined to interfere in the impugned order of termination. The order dated 17.10.2022 is set aside. However, considering the gravity of the charges, the respondents are allowed liberty to pass a fresh order in accordance with law after due opportunity to the petitioner. We, however, make it clear that this exercise should be completed within a period of two months from the date of receipt of the copy of the order. The order does not entail reinstatement of the petitioner during this time. However, in case the respondent-employer is inclined to take a view favourable to the petitioner after the outcome of the fresh exercise, petitioner would be entitled to consequential benefits.
8. The writ appeal stands allowed and disposed of in the aforesaid terms. Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of. (ARINDAM LODH), J (APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ Pulak PULAK BANIK 18:31:47 +05'30'
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
W.A. No.122/2023
Sri Dipankar Deb
……… Appellant(s).
VERSUS
The State of Tripura & others
………Respondent(s).
For Appellant(s)
: Mr. B.N. Majumder, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. B. Paul, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Kohinoor N Bhattacharyya, G.A.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Order
13/12/2023
Heard Mr. B.N. Majumder, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr.
B. Paul, learned counsel appearing for the appellant and Mr. Kohinoor N
Bhattacharyya, learned Government Advocate, appearing for the respondentsState.
2.
The writ petitioner is the appellant who is aggrieved by the
impugned order dated 25.08.2023 passed in WP(C) No.971 of 2022 whereby
the challenge to the order of termination of appointment of the petitioner dated
17.10.2022 has been declined, inter alia, holding as under:
"In view of above and after gone through material evidence on
record, the present petition stands dismissed by upholding the
termination order issued by the respondents. However, insofar as the
termination is concerned, this Court is not inclined to express its opinion
on the allegations made which are pending investigation and trial filed
before the Court below vide West Agartala P.S. Case No.2022
WAG069 and about taking expeditious actions on the requisition placed
by the West Agartala Police Station under Section-91 of Cr. P.C in
relation to the criminal case registered against the petitioner. In that
view of the matter, the present petition stands dismissed. As a sequel,
miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall stand closed."
3.
Petitioner was a contractual employee appointed as a Logistic
Specialist in the year 2011 initially for 11 months which were extended from
time to time by the competent authority. However, on the charges of illegal
gratification, an inquiry was conducted against him which indicted the
petitioner. Based on the inquiry report (Annexure-6 to the writ petition), a
show-cause was issued upon him on 13.07.2022. Petitioner denied the
allegations vide his reply dated 30.09.2022. However, by the impugned order
dated 17.10.2022, the contractual engagement of the petitioner was terminated
invoking Clause-2 of the memorandum dated 31.12.2010 of his contractual
engagement by giving one month's notice. Learned Writ Court, however,
refused to interfere in the order of termination also taking into consideration
that the investigation and trial of the Criminal Case being West Agartala P.S.
case No.2022WAG069 is pending. The learned Court also took into
consideration the purported statement of the petitioner before the committee
admitting his guilt. However, Mr. B.N. Majumder, learned senior counsel for
the petitioner, submits that even though the petitioner was a contractual
employee, if his termination on the face of it is based upon charges, it is
stigmatic in nature though the employer has wisely chosen to invoke the notice
clause for terminating him. The stigma would continue to stare at him for the
rest of his career in any future employment. He submits that if his contractual
engagement has been terminated on allegations, proper opportunity to defend
should have been accorded. Since the order of termination is based on
invocation of the notice clause, petitioner is not able to properly defend himself
in respect of the allegations made in order to exonerate himself from the alleged
charges. As such, the impugned order being stigmatic in nature having been
passed without proper opportunity to defend, the same deserves to be set aside.
Learned Writ Court, however, failed to consider this aspect of the matter.
Therefore, petitioner is in appeal.
4.
Mr. Kohinoor N Bhattacharyya, learned Government Advocate,
has defended the order of termination but he is unable to overcome the legal
plea raised by the writ petitioner that the termination order, on the face of it, is
stigmatic in nature though the contractual engagement has been ended on one
month's notice invoking Clause-2 of the memorandum dated 31.12.2020.
5.
We have considered the submission of learned counsel for the
parties and taken note of the relevant pleadings placed from the record. The
chronology of relevant facts leading to the impugned termination order of the
petitioner need not be repeated here. However, we are inclined to extract the
order of termination dated 17.10.2022 hereunder as ex facie it is stigmatic in
nature containing references to the allegations made and the report of the
inquiry committee thereupon indicting the petitioner:
"No.F.3(5-4142)/FWPM/SHFWS/Procurement/Conf./2022/S-I
Government of Tripura
Health & Family Welfare Department
Office of the Mission Director
National Health Mission
Dated: 17.10.2022
MEMORANDUM
WHEREAS Sri Dipankar Deb was appointed to the post of Logistic
Specialist under the State Health & Family Welfare Society on contractual basis vide
Memorandum No. F.3(5-2023)-FWPM/SHFWS/2010, dated 31.12.2020;
AND
WHEREAS, a grave allegation of receiving illegal gratification from
suppliers was received against Sri Deb, following which an enquiry committee
headed by Dr. Kamal Reang, Member Secretary of the State Health & Family
Welfare Society, conducted a probe into the allegation;
AND
WHEREAS, from the report submitted by the enquiry committee vide
no.F.3(5-4142)-FWPM/SHFWS/PROC CONF/2022, dated 20.04.2022, the allegation
of receiving illegal gratification by Sri Deb appears to have been prima facie
established;
AND
WHEREAS, a criminal case against Sri Deb U/S 406, 468 IPC and U/S
7 of the Prevention of Corruption Act was registered vide West Agartala P/S Case
No.2022WAG069, dated 06.05.2022;
AND
WHEREAS, a letter was issued from the office of the Principal
Accountant General (Audit), Tripura, vide no.POS/CA/NHM/2021-22/09, dated
12.07.2022, referring to the dubious remittances to the bank account of Sri Deb and
another person (Sri Nayan Banik) stated to be a relative and close associate of Sri
Deb, and about taking expeditious actions on the requisition placed by the West
Agartala Police Station U/S 91 CrPC in relation to the criminal case registered against
Sri Deb;
AND
WHEREAS, a show-cause notice was issued to Sri Deb vide no.F.3(54142)-FWPM/SHFWS/Procurement Conf./2022/S-I/4049-50, dated 13.07.2022,
asking him to adduce reasons as to why his contractual service should not be
discontinued/terminated;
AND
WHEREAS, the reply submitted by Sri Deb on 30.09.2022 to the
show-cause notice has been carefully examined, and no cogent explanations appear to
have been made out in the reply accounting for several dubious monetary remittances
made to the bank accounts of Sri Deb and the person allegedly his relative and close
associate/accomplice;
AND
WHEREAS, the alleged corrupt practices and illegal acceptance of
gratification by Sri Deb had led to a host of adverse media reports, bringing in
considerable disrepute to his employer;
AND
WHEREAS, it appears that unless stringent actions are taken against
Sri Deb, it may set an alarming precedent and may encourage other officials to
indulge in similar corrupt practices with impunity;
AND
WHEREAS, the Clause No.2 of the Memorandum No.F.3(5-2023)FWPM/SHFWS/2010, dated 31.12.2010, whereby Sri Deb was appointed, clearly
lays down that "The appointment is purely on temporary and contractual basis and
liable to be terminated at any time without assigning any reason thereof with 1(one)
month's notice from either side";
AND
WHEREAS, after taking into consideration the gravity of the
allegations subsisting against Sri Deb, and the totality of the circumstances as stated
hereinbefore, it appears that retaining Sri Deb in the contractual service has become
entirely untenable;
NOW THEREFORE, in accordance with the Clause No.2 of the
Memorandum No.F.3(5-2023)-FWPM/SHFWS/2010, dated 31.12.2010, Sri Dipankar
Deb, Logistic Specialist, shall take notice that his contractual engagement under the
State Health & Family Welfare Society shall stand terminated on elapse of 1(one)
month from the day of the service of this Memorandum to him, without any further
correspondence in this regard.
This is issued with the approval of the Health & FW Deptt., Govt. of
Tripura, vide U.O. No.3333, dated 11.10.2022.
To
Sri Dipankar Deb, Logistic Specialist,
O/o the MD, NHM, Palace Compound, Agartala, Tripura.
Sd/- (17.10.2022)
(S. Das, TCS, SSG)
Mission Director
National Health Mission, Tripura
(Addl. Secretary, Health & FW Dept.)"
6.
In case of a contractual engagement if the termination is based on
allegations, the respondent-employer ought to have derived its decision on the
outcome of the inquiry proceedings instead of invoking notice clause for his
termination when the entire text of the termination order is otherwise stigmatic
in nature. In such a situation, even though the termination appears to be
innocent by invoking one month notice clause but the stigma attached to the
termination would continue to operate against the employee in future.
7.
As such, we are inclined to interfere in the impugned order of
termination. The order dated 17.10.2022 is set aside. However, considering the
gravity of the charges, the respondents are allowed liberty to pass a fresh order
in accordance with law after due opportunity to the petitioner. We, however,
make it clear that this exercise should be completed within a period of two
months from the date of receipt of the copy of the order. The order does not
entail reinstatement of the petitioner during this time. However, in case the
respondent-employer is inclined to take a view favourable to the petitioner after
the outcome of the fresh exercise, petitioner would be entitled to consequential
benefits.
8.
The writ appeal stands allowed and disposed of in the aforesaid
terms.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
(ARINDAM LODH), J
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
Pulak
Date: 2023.12.15
PULAK BANIK 18:31:47 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review