Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
FAO.No.01 of 2023
Sri Dibakar Roy
.....Defendant-O.P. Petitioner
_V_E_R_S_U_S_
Rajibkanti Gupta & Others
.....Plaintiff-petitioner-respondents
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S. M. Chakraborty, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. S. Lodh, Advocate.
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, Advocate.
Mr. S. Noatia, Advocate.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
_O_ R_ D_ E_ R_
19/10/2023
Heard learned counsel Mr. S. Lodh, for the petitioner-defendant
and Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel for the respondent-plaintiff. The
arguments advanced before the learned Court below by both the parties are
reiterated.
[2]
This appeal has been filed under Order-XLIII Rule-1(r) of the
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 against the order dated 14.06.2023 passed in
Civil Miss 35 of 2023 arising out of T.S. 11 of 2023 passed by the learned Civil
Judge Senior Division, Court No.2, North Tripura, Dharmanagar.
[3]
The facts in brief are that the respondent No. 1 filed a suit in the
Court of the learned Civil Judge Senior Division, North Tripura, for perpetual
and prohibitory injunction with some other consequential relatives. Along with
the said suit he filed an application under Order-39, Rule 1 and 2 of the Code of
Civil Procedure, 1908 for restraining the appellant and his men and agents from
entering into the suit land. According to the respondent No. 1 he is the joint
owner of the suit land as the name of his deceased father was reflected in the
records of right and he claim is based on the said entry in the records of right
when the said respondent in the injunction petition stated that he along with his
mother transferred their share of land in the plot number of the suit land to his
wife. The appellant contest the same and he stated that the respondent No.1 has
no right, title, interest and possession over the suit land and he also failed to
make out any prima facie case in his favour and for the balance of convenience
and inconvenience was not in his favour. The learned Court below after hearing
the injunction petition did not appreciate the pleadings and the documents filed
before it and in gross violation of natural justice and settled law of the land
passed the order of injunction against the present appellant.
[4]
Hence the present appeal has been preferred before this Court for
redress.
[5]
The learned Court below after hearing the parties and on perusal
of the material evidence on record has observed as under:
“Thus, the petitioner is still a co-sharer of the suit land and he has the
locus standi to file an application praying for injunction against any third
party. Hence, I hold that basing on Khatian no. 3516/1 of Mouja:
Dharmanagar, the petitioner has prima facie case here.
Secondly, if the position of the suit land, the land purchased by respondent
no.1 and the common path falling under RS plot no. 6404 as shown in
page no.8 of registered gift deed no. 1-01461 dated 17.07.2013 is taken to
be the correct position of the aforesaid pieces of land, respondent no.1
would suffer no loss if temporary injunction is granted restraining him
from entering into the suit land as he can directly go to the common path
situated on the Western side of the land purchased by him in auction. On
the other hand, if by chance or by evil motive respondent no.1 enters into
the suit land, the right of peaceful possession of the suit land by the
petitioner would be affected. Hence, I hold that the petitioner has balance
of convenience in his favour in the instant case.
Thirdly, Ld. Counsel for respondent no.1 has rightly pointed out that in
para no. 14 of the original application, the petitioner has stated that he has
filed the original suit for declaration and other consequential reliefs, but in
para no. 22 of the plaint, only a decree of perpetual injunction has been
prayed for. However, in my considered opinion, order XXXIX rule 1 of
CPC does not lay down that temporary injunction may be prayed for and
granted only when the relief of declaration of title is prayed for inthe
original suit.
Order XXXIX rule 1 of CPC lays down only two conditions for granting
of temporary injunction which areas follows:
a) The land over which injunction is prayed for is the suit land, and
b) Such land is in danger of being wasted, damaged or alienated by any
party or being sold in execution of a decree, or the defendant threatens or
intents to remove or dispose of his property to defraud his creditors, or the
defendant threatens to dispossess the plaintiff or otherwise cause injury to
him in relation to the suit land.
In the instant suit, the land measuring 0.049 acre falling under RS plot no.
6415 of Mouja: Dharmanagar is the suit land and the original application
clearly reveals that respondent no.1 attempted to encroach upon the same
on 24.04.2023 which, if done, would amount to causing of injury to the
petitioner in his right of peaceful possession of the suit land. Therefore,
only because the petitioner has not prayed for the relief of declaration of
title in the plaint, the merits of this case is not affected. Rather, it appears
to me that if during pendency of the original suit, respondent no.1 illegally
encroaches into the suit land, the very purpose of filing the original suit
would be frustrated and the petitioner would suffer irreparable loss.
Furthermore, admittedly the suit land situates in the heart of Dharmanagar
Town, the area which remainsthickly populated by common people
throughout the day. Situated thus, if respondent no.1 attempts to forcefully
enter into the suit land during pendency of the original suit, law and order
situation may be adversely effected in the said area which would be
against the public interest.
As a conclusion to the above discussion, the application filed by the
petitioner under order XXXIX rules 1, 2 and 3 of CPC stands allowed.
Respondent no.1 and his men and agents are hereby restrained from
entering into the suit land and from disturbing peaceful possession of the
petitioner over the same in any manner during pendency of the original
suit no. TS 11 of 2023.
With this observation, the instant case stands disposed off on contest.”
[6]
Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has
submitted that the learned trial Court below ought to have considered that as
per provisions of section 43(3) of the Tripura Land Revenue and Land Reforms
Act, 1960 the entry in the records of right has the presumptive value unless
contrary is proved and the statement made in paragraph Nos. 3 and 4 of
injunction petition are in total contradiction with the entry of the records of
right. As per the statement made in those paragraphs, it is clear that the
respondent No. 1 transferred the entire share of his predecessor in interest along
with his mother and thus he was having no share in the suit land. Apart from
that, the plot, which the said respondent No. 1 purchased from the share of his
co- owners (respondent Nos. 9 & 10) is separate not involved in the injunction
petition and that lane is recorded in a new record of right bearing khatian
No.9926 with separate particulars.
[6.a]
It has been contended that the learned trial Court ought to have
considered that after transfer of the share of the respondent No. 1 from plot No.
6415, i.e., the suit land, the respondent No. 1 is no longer a joint owner of the
plot No. 6415 as per law he has no locustandi to file the suit with injunction
petition. The learned trial Court below should have considered that the petition
of the respondent No. 1 did not fulfil any of the conditions as laid down under
Order-XXXIX Rule-1 and 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. The learned
Court below should have considered that the respondent No. 1, his mother and
the predecessor in interest of the respondent Nos. 3 to 5 had transferred their
share by meets and bounds and nobody challenged the said deed and in absence
of any such prayer learned Court below arbitrarily and illegally came to the
conclusion that boundary in the said deed is not correct;
[6.b]
It has been further submitted that the learned Court below ought
to have appreciated that the respondent No. 1 failed to prove his possession
over the suit land as he at the time of transferring his share of land from the plot
No.6415 of the suit land to his wife, also transferred his possession over the
suit land to his wife and in absence of possession of the respondent No.1 over
the suit land the question of suffering of irreparable loss by the respondent
No.1 does not arise.
[6.c]
Mr. Lodh, learned counsel has argued that the learned Court
below should have considered that the respondent No. 1 had to show prima
facie case in his favour but in his petition for injunction at Paragraph No. 3 and
4 it is specifically stated that the share of his father in plot No.6415 of the suit
land is transferred by him and his mother, since deceased, and he had handed
over the possession of the land to his wife and thus he had failed to establish
the prime facie case in his favour, but the learned Court below most illegally
and mechanically came to a conclusion that the respondent No. 1 has a prima
facie benefit in his favour. The respondent No. 1 failed to show and establish
the balance of convenience and inconvenience in his favour but the learned trial
Court below measurably failed to appreciate the same.
[07]
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel appearing for the plaintiff-
respondent has submitted that the case of the respondent-plaintiff is that the
said passage is not a passage and the property of the defendant is behind the
said property of the plaintiff and if the access is blocked, the property gets
frustrated. The defendant purchased the said property in a bank auction in the
SARFAESI proceeding and in the said proceeding, the said passage which is
under dispute is shown as a accessible passage measuring 10 feet in breadth
and 30 feet in length.
[08]
It has been averred that the affidavit of the respondents is placed
on record and it has been categorically stated that the respondent-plaintiffs
stating that the petitioner-defendant is not facing any inconvenience and right
of entry is not blocked since he is having right of access in addition to the
passage which is under dispute. The said contention has not been denied by
way of any rejoinder by the petitioner-defendants. It is not on record nor there
is any bank record obtained from the bank which is placed before this Court to
say that the bank has acquired the said passage and same is alienated in the
auction to the petitioner-defendant and thus, the defendant has right over it.
[09]
In support of the claim of the plaintiff, he has placed the revenue
records and also the partnership documents which are executed between the
wife of the plaintiff with 3rd party together who became the defaulter with the
Tripura Gramin Bank against whom SARFAESI proceeding is initiated for the
loan obtained from the bank.
[10]
In the year 2014 said Anusree Gupta (the wife of plaintiff) started
running a partnership Hotel business under the name and style as "Hotel
Ratdin" with one Chayan Bhattacharjee by entering into a partnership deed
vide No. IV-00149 date 19/08/2013 taking loan from Tripura Gramin Bank in
exchange of mortgaging her recorded property under R.S. Plot No. 6415/19361
under Khatian No. 9491 of Dharmanagar town Mouja, before Tripura Gramin
Bank and the said hotel is standing over there adjacent to eastern boundary line
of the suit land and whereas the suit land is situated in between the „Hotel
RATDIN‟ and adjoining path under R.S. Plot No. 6404 connected with the
main Road, therefore these business partners convinced the plaintiff by saying
that they will purchase the suit land by executing registered sale deed from the
plaintiff along with other co-sharers thereto for using the same in order to
access into the hotel along with light motor vehicles from the main road
through the adjoining path under R.S. Plot No.6404 and they were seeking few
time as necessitated to pursue this legal process for preparing deed of
conveyance of the suit land and thereby they requested the plaintiff to use the
suit land temporarily just for access into the hotel.
[11]
In view of the above, this Court is of the opinion that the plaintiff
preferred a suit seeking injunction against the defendant in respect of the
property which is said to be a open land abating to the property of the common
property of the plaintiff and his family members and the defendant is the
hotelier under the name and style as Hotel Ratdin and the defendant is using the
property of the plaintiff for egress and ingress and their peace is being
disturbed and the nature of the property is also changed. The learned Court
below after hearing both the parties was pleased to grand injunction order
under Order-XXXIX Rules-1, 2 and 3 of the CPC restricting the defendants
from granting injunction and the suit is also pending. Being aggrieved by the
said order of injunction dated 14.06.2023 the present FAO has been filed.
[12]
Admittedly, petitioner/auction purchaser herein is a third party
and has purchased the property through bank. The bank is not the party. Since a
portion of composite property was under use as common utility which is shown
as passage, the defendant cannot claim the right title and interest upon the same
as no specific title to the said suit property of the family members have been
alienated to the defendant. Mere showing the passage in the plan does not
confirm any right. The bank is not a party before the Court and no document is
placed before this Court to show that the bank has attained its alienated right
upon the property in dispute in order to further auction of the same in favour of
the defendants. The said issue needs to be decided finally.
[13]
When the bank has not conferred with the title upon the particular
property, it cannot convey the better title to the defendant in the suit. Mere
showing the boundaries as passage on the western side of the boundary does
not indicate that the defendant-petitioner is having a road upon the same unless,
it is decided in the main suit. The petitioner has not placed any evidence on
record to convince this Court in support of his argument to say that the passage
as indicated in the boundaries is only the passage which adds as an access to
the hotel of the petitioner. In the absence of evidence on record and supporting
documents from the bank (who is not in the judicial proceeding) deciding the
same at an interlocutory level would be deciding the main suit itself. The
argument of Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel that the defendant-petitioner in the
light of the contention made in the affidavit by the plaintiff-respondent has no
approach away to the hotel is befitted in the light of the contention made in the
affidavit by the plaintiff-respondent stating that there is a way, which has not
been rebutted. Thus, the said argument is negated
[14]
For the purpose of reference, the contention of Mr. S.
Bhattacharjee, learned counsel with regard to the approach away, may be
reproduced thus “It is pertinent to mention here that after the institution of suit
and passing of the order dated 14.06.2023 the applicant is using the path
mentioned in dag No.6426 of Khatian No.2373 for land measuring 0.015 satak
of path (way) of class of land to access to the HOTEL RATDIN. Said path runs
parallel to the suit land after the common path measuring 10 feet breadth and
30 feet in length which is dag No.6404 of Khatian No.2373.”
[15]
In view of the above observations and the material evidence on
record and since the main suit is to be decided, this Court is not inclined to
interfere with the order passed by the learned Court below and thus, the same
stands dismissed. If the argument of Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel is
appreciated and the finding is given in his favour, it would be amounting to
deciding the main suit. Since the suit is pending on the file of the learned Court
below, it is expected that the same would be considered as early as possible.
[16]
Accordingly, the present petition stands dismissed. As a sequel,
miscellaneous application pending, if any, shall stand closed.
(T. AMARNATH GOUD), J
A. Ghosh
signed
ANJAN Digitally
by ANJAN GHOSH
2023.10.30
GHOSH Date:
12:41:15 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review