The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
6. The Deputy Chief Engineer(Construction), N.F. Railway, Badharghat, Agartala, Tripura. ..…. Respondent(s) For Appellant(s) : Mr. R.G. Chakraborty, Advocate. For Respondent(s) : Mr. Bidyut Majumder, Dy.S.G.I, Mr. K. De, Addl. G.A. HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT Date of hearing and delivery of Judgment and Order : 12th December, 2024. Whether Fit for Reporting : NO JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL) Heard Mr. R.G. Chakraborty, learned counsel appearing for the appellant and also heard Mr. Bidyut Majumder, learned Deputy S.G.I. appearing for the N.F. Railway and Mr. K. De, learned Additional Government Advocate appearing for the respondents-State. [2] The learned Writ Court refused to interfere in the writ petition which was preferred for the following reliefs: “(i) ISSUE RULE NISI calling upon the Respondents and each of them to show cause as to why a writ in the nature of mandamus and/or direction/directions and/or order/orders in the like nature shall not be issued compelling and directing the respondent Nos. 1 to 4 and each of them and/or all the respondents and each of them to issue necessary information to the Petitioner regarding acquisition of his land; (ii) ISSUE RULE NISI calling upon the Respondents and each of them to show cause as to why a writ in the nature of mandamus and/or direction/directions and/or order/orders in the li…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
WA No.131 of 2023
Sri Debabrata Nayak, son of late Hemanta Kumar Nayak, resident of
Pabiacherra Bazar, P.O. & P.S.- Kumarghat, Pin-799264, District- Unakoti.
...... Appellant(s)
VERSUS
1. The State of Tripura represented by the Secretary, Department of Revenue,
Government of Tripura, New Capital Complex, Agartala, 799010, DistrictWest Tripura.
2. The District Magistrate & Collector, Kailashahar, District-Unakoti, Tripura,
Pin-799282.
3. The Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Kumarghat, District-Unakoti, Tripura, Pin799264.
4. The Tehesildar, Kumarghat Tehesil, Kumarghat, District-Unakoti, Tripura,
Pin-799264.
5. The General Manager, N.F. Railway, Maligaon, Guwahati, Assam.
6. The Deputy Chief Engineer(Construction), N.F. Railway, Badharghat,
Agartala, Tripura.
..…. Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
: Mr. R.G. Chakraborty, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Bidyut Majumder, Dy.S.G.I,
Mr. K. De, Addl. G.A.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Date of hearing and delivery of Judgment and Order : 12th December, 2024.
Whether Fit for Reporting : NO
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Mr. R.G. Chakraborty, learned counsel appearing for the
appellant and also heard Mr. Bidyut Majumder, learned Deputy S.G.I.
appearing for the N.F. Railway and Mr. K. De, learned Additional
Government Advocate appearing for the respondents-State.
[2]
The learned Writ Court refused to interfere in the writ petition
which was preferred for the following reliefs:
“(i) ISSUE RULE NISI calling upon the Respondents and each of them to show
cause as to why a writ in the nature of mandamus and/or direction/directions
and/or order/orders in the like nature shall not be issued compelling and
directing the respondent Nos. 1 to 4 and each of them and/or all the
respondents and each of them to issue necessary information to the Petitioner
regarding acquisition of his land;
(ii) ISSUE RULE NISI calling upon the Respondents and each of them to show
cause as to why a writ in the nature of mandamus and/or direction/directions
and/or order/orders in the like nature shall not be issued compelling and
directing the respondents Nos.1 to 4 and each of them and/or all the
respondents and each of them to allow the petitioner to know the status of his
jote land under possession of the railways and his letter dated 27.06.2023 for
appropriate response thereto;
(iii) ISSUE RULE NISI calling upon the Respondents and each of them to show
cause as to why a writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or direction/directions
and/or order/orders in the like nature shall not be issued compelling and
directing the respondent nos. 1 to 4 and each of them and/or all the
respondents and each of them to produce all relevant papers before this
Hon’ble High Court enabling this Hon’ble Court to adjudicate the matter
regarding possession of N.F Railways on the jote property of the petitioner;
(iv) ISSUE RULE NISI calling upon the Respondents and each of them to show
cause as to why a writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or direction/ directions
and/or order /orders in the like nature shall not be issued compelling and
directing the respondent and each of them and/or all the respondents and
each of them to acquire the portion of land under the possession of the Indian
Railways and/or to acquire the whole landed property of the petitioner
adjacent thereto within Khatian No. 847 and to pay appropriate compensation
for the acquired lands in both the cases.
(v) After hearing the parties be pleased to make the Rules absolute;
(vi) And be pleased to pass further order/orders, direction/directions as this
Hon’ble High Court considered deemed fit and proper.”
[3]
Being aggrieved, the writ petitioner is in appeal before us.
[4]
The writ petition was preferred after 42 years of the acquisition
made under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 for the purposes of the railways.
As per the statements made at paragraph 3 of the rejoinder affidavit of the
writ petitioner itself, the acquisition was made on 24.02.1981 and the award
was published on 09.03.1981. 42 years thereafter the writ petitioner
approached the Writ Court in WP(C) No.92 of 2023 for relief claiming
himself to be the land owner. The writ petition was disposed of to enable the
petitioner to pursue his representation before the respondent-authorities.
Thereafter, certain letters were issued by the Sr. Divisional Engineer,
Northeast Frontier Railway, Lumding on 04.04.2023 and by the Land
Acquisition Collector, Unakoti, Kailashahar addressed to General Manager,
Northeast Frontier Railway on 16th June, 2023 asking him to find out the
relevant records of the land. Thereafter, the instant writ petition was
preferred bearing WP(C) No.549 of 2023 for the above reliefs.
[5]
Learned Writ Court refused to interfere in the matter with an
observation that the issue is with regard to the disputed question of fact
involving the acquisition of the land and whether the respondent paid
compensation or willing to pay or not.
[6]
Mr. R.G. Chakraborty, learned counsel for the appellant has
submitted that the State-respondents in their counter affidavit have also
accepted that the land in respect of the R.S. Plot No.3894, 3895 & 3896 of
Mouja Pabiacherra under Khatian No.847 measuring 01.11 acres were
purchased by the father of the petitioner through three sale deeds of the year
1979, 1980 & 1981. It is submitted that no notice was issued in favour of the
petitioner’s father in respect of acquisition of the land since the land was
shown as khas land in the record of rights. Petitioner was asked to produce
certain documents by the DM & Collector, Unakoti District on 26.03.2024
such as (a) R.O.R of jote land (b) current Khatian (c) copies of order under
Section 11(3) revenue case (d) sale deeds executed by Prafulla Kumar Das
and (e) Any other documents on C.S Plot No.2168, 2116 and 2182 of Mouja
Pabiacherra to support his claim. Petitioner appeared on 26.03.2024 and
submitted only two copies of sale deeds and requested time for submission
of other documents asked for.
[7]
It is submitted that petitioner’s father died about three years
back. Petitioner has come to know of the possession of Railways only
through Sri Pandit Sarkar who was in the possession of plot No.3896/P.
Thereafter, he approached the respondent-authorities. However, the learned
Writ Court has refused to interfere in the matter.
[8]
The Respondents-State has filed a counter affidavit. It is their
categorical assertion that on scrutiny of available records, the suit land
measuring 1.11 acres under Plot Nos.2168, 2182 was khas land recorded in
Government Khatian No.1011 and old plot No.2116 as Forest Department
which were acquired for construction of metre-gauge railway line from
Dharmanagar to Kumarghat vide declaration dated 24.02.1981 of the
Revenue Department, Government of Tripura published in Tripura Gazette
on 09.03.1981. During acquisition of the land for construction of metregauge railway line from between the aforesaid two stations the two plots in
question were recorded as khas land vide draft Khatian No.1011 under
Pabiacherra Mouja and one plot recorded as Forest Department land for
which no notice was issued to the petitioner or his father. It is submitted that
the acquisition was done in the year 1981 while revisional survey operation
was started from the year 1982 and the record of rights were finally
published in 1989. The matter was further enquired through a team of
officials like DCM, Kumarghat Revenue Circle who submitted a report as
per which the final published Revisional Khatian No.847 of Mouja
Pabiacherra shows CS Plot Nos.2168, 2116 and 2182 which are R.S Plot
Nos.3896 3895 and 3894 recorded in Column No.19 as Rayati in favour of
Hemanta Kumar Nayek son of Joy Narayan Nayek of Kumarghat. These
lands are under possession of Railway Department by way of constructing
rail track and other construction. Rest 0.12 acres from R.S. Plot No.3896/P is
under possession of Sri Pandit Sarkar by way of constructing bamboo
fencing.
[9]
The Deputy Director, Land Records & Settlement, Government
of Tripura furnished copy of draft Khatian and copy of mutation application
of Sri Hemanta Kumar Nayek filled in Form No.21 but the copy of the order
passed in Case No.232/1981 under Section 11(3) could not be furnished as it
was not traceable even after thorough search. Thereafter, the office of DM &
Collector, Unakoti District issued a notice to the petitioner on 26.03.2024 to
appear with all copies of orders, documents. He only submitted two sale
deeds of the year 1980 and 1981 and stated that no other document is
available on this issue.
[10]
Based on these averments, learned counsel for the State submits
that the acquisition of the suit land was done in the year 1981 and Railway is
currently utilizing the land. Consequent upon revision of record of rights the
possession of Railway authorities is shown. The ROR entry No.847 held by
petitioner shows the entire land measuring 1.11 acres under the possession
of Railway Authorities. Therefore, it is quite surprising as to how the land
was mutated either in favour of Hemanta Kumar Nayek or in favour of the
petitioner without having any possession over the land which is the key
factor in order to get mutation of land. It is also astonishing that after lapse
of 42 years the petitioner has come forward with a demand to make payment
of compensation claiming the suit land as his settled land. Based on these
averments, learned counsel for the State submits that such a claim is wholly
barred by delay and laches. Moreover, the acquisition proceedings of the
year 1981 based upon the entries made in the old draft record of rights
showing it as khas land and that of Forest land cannot be questioned at this
length of time to seek compensation by the petitioner. It is further submitted
that even if the record of rights was corrected in the year 1989 the remarks
column shows Railway as the possessor but father of the petitioner or
petitioner never objected to such entries nor made any inquiry. Since the
acquisition has become final in view of the prescription of law and the
notification issued under the Land Acquisition Act 1894, this Court in
exercise of writ jurisdiction should refrain from interfering in the matter at
the behest of the writ petitioner whose claim is grossly barred by
unexplained delay and laches.
[11]
Mr. Bidyut Majumder, Learned Deputy S.G.I appearing for the
respondents-Railway has also made submission to the same effect.
[12]
Mr. R.G. Chakraborty, learned counsel for the appellant in
reply has placed reliance upon the case of Sukh Dutt Ratra and another
versus State of Himachal Pradesh and others, reported in (2022) 7 SCC
508 in Civil Appeal No.2773 of 2022 dated 06.04.2022 particularly
paragraphs 16, 17 & 18 and submitted that the Apex Court has held that the
constitutional right under Article 300-A cannot be defeated merely on the
ground of delay and laches of the land owner when his private property
being expropriated. The facts of the case show that that the appellant Sukh
Dutt Ratra and Bhagat Ram claimed to be owners of land situated at Mauzal
Sarol Basach, Tehsil Pachhad, District Sirmaour, Himachal Pradesh. They
alleged that the respondents-State utilized the subject land and adjoining
lands for the construction of the Narag Fagla Road in 1972-73 but no land
acquisition proceedings were initiated nor compensation given to the
appellants or owners of the adjoining land. The facts of the said case further
reveal that it was only after the judgment of the Himachal Pradesh High
Court that land acquisition proceedings were initiated under the Act of 1894
vide notification dated 16.10.2001. Thereafter, similarly situated land
owners filed writ petitions before the High Court which was allowed by the
High Court with the direction to acquire lands of the writ petitioners under
the Act with consequential benefits. Subsequently, other similarly situated
owners also received the benefit of these directions.
[13]
This led the appellants to file a writ petition before the High
Court in 2011 seeking compensation for the subject land or initiation of
acquisition proceedings under the Act. The High Court relying upon a Full
Bench decision held that the matter involved disputed questions of law and
fact for determination on the starting point of limitation which could not be
adjudicated in writ proceedings. It was accordingly disposed of with liberty
to file a civil suit in accordance with law. Aggrieved thereby the appellants
had approached the Apex Court through these appeals. The instant decision,
evidently makes it clear that acquisition proceedings were initiated only
pursuant to the directions of the High Court since 2001 at the behest of
adjoining land owners who were granted compensation. The writ petitioner
alleged that their land has been taken by the State in 1972, 1973 without any
acquisition. Their writ petitions were dismissed on ground of delay and
laches and apparently they had approached the Court after 38 years in 2011.
[14]
The facts of the present case are distinguishable since in the
present case the acquisition proceedings were concluded in the year March,
1981 itself for the purposes of Railway construction. At that point of time,
the record of rights in the old C.S Plot showed these two Plots No.3894 and
3895 as khas land and Plot No.3896 at Mouja Pabiacherra as Forest
Department land. The record of rights were revised in the year 1989 when
apparently the name of the father of the present petitioner was entered 8
years after the acquisition was complete but it still showed the land to be in
possession of the Railways. Even though the land was shown in the
possession of the Railways, the father of the petitioner or the present
petitioner did not raise their claim in respect of such possession of the
railways or acquisition in the name of railways for 42 years till they
approached this Court in the year 2023 for the first time. It is therefore,
evident that the present case is not one where the State has expropriated the
private property of the petitioner without any acquisition proceedings. The
acquisition proceedings concluded in the year 1981 were based upon the
record of rights where the name of the father of the petitioner was not
reflected even if he might have purchased the said land by way of sale deeds
of 1979, 1980 & 1981. Acquisition proceedings of 1981 therefore could not
be faulted on those counts since notifications are issued on the basis of the
revenue records and the record of rights maintained by the State.
[15]
In the wake of these background facts and circumstances, it is
also apparent that even after notice issued by the DM & Collector, Unakoti
on 26.03.2024 the petitioner could only produce two sale deeds and none of
the other documents. The writ petitioner has not been able to overcome the
gross and inordinate delay in approaching the Writ Court for redressal of his
grievances in respect of the acquisition completed in the year 1981 itself. As
such, the decision relied upon by learned counsel for the petitioner in the
case of Sukh Dutt Ratra (supra) would not come to his aid.
[16]
For the above reasons, we are of the considered view that the
writ petition being barred by gross delay and laches was fit to be dismissed
on those counts itself. We therefore, refuse to interfere in the impugned
order.
Accordingly, the instant writ appeal is dismissed.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
(BISWAJIT PALIT) J
DIPESH DEB
Date: 2024.12.19 17:49:11
+05'30'
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH) CJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review