Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
It
[ 3443 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
WEDNESDAY, THE SEVENTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NARSING RAO NANDIKONDA
CITY CIVIL COURT APPEAL NO: 222 OF 2004
Appeal under section 96 of C.P.C against the Judgment and
Decree Dated 1907 2OO4 made in O S No 329 OF 1996 on the file of the
Court of the I Addrtronal Judge, City Small Causes Court-curn-6th Senior
Civil Jude, City Civil Court, Hyderabad
Between:
Sri D. Shivakumar, S/o Late Sri D. Nagabhushanam, Occ. Service R/o 1-9295/19, Srilaxmi Nilayam, Vidyanagar, Hyderabad.
..Appella nUPla intiff
AND
Sri S. Shyamsunder, S/o Sri S.J. Somayajulu, Occ. Service R/o 1-9-28511,
Vidyanagar, Hyderabad.
... Respo ndenUDefenda nt
l.A. NO: 1 OF 201 1(CCCAMP. NO: 85 OF 2011)
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
expedite the date of hearing in the above appeal preferably by fixrng a
convenrent date in the next week.
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2004(CCCAMP. NO: 11700 OF 2004)
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased To
grant in.junction in favour of the Petitioner/Appellant and against the
Respon dent/Defe nd ant restraining the Respondent his agents representatives,
etc.. from alienating, encumbering or otherwise creating any third party interest
and restrain the REspondent from changing or altering the Suit Schedule
Property as mentrorred in O.S.NO.329/1996 on the file of he lAddl Juddge,
CSCC-cum 6TH SCJ, CCC, Hyderabad
Counsel for the Appellant : Mrs. Manjari S. Ganu
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr. N.V. Anantha Krishna
The Court delivered the following:
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE NARSIING RAO NANDIKONDA
CITY CTVTL CO URT APPEAL N o.2 22 of 2OO4
DATE: O 7.U.1.20.26
Between:
D. Shivakumar
appellant/ Plaintiff
AND
S- Shyamsunder
...respondent/ defendant
JUDGMENT
This Appeal is preferred by the Appellant/plaintiff under Section
96 of the Civil Procedure Court, 1908, being .aggrieved by the
Judgment and Decree, dated 19'07'2004 passed in O'S'No '329
of
1996 by the Additional Judge, City Small Causes Court-cum
Vl Senior
Civil Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad and set aside the
suit with
CoStS.
2.
Heard Mrs. Manjari S' Ganu, learned counsel for the appellant
and Mr. N.V. Anantha Krishna, learned counsel for the respondent'
Perused. the entire material on record'
3.
The brief facts of the case are that the appellant entered into an
agreement of sale with the defendant under Ex'A4, which was duly
IJNR, /
cccA_222_2004
attested by DW-2. It is contended that there rvas z clear agreement
betweenthepartiesr,'herebythedefendantagreeclosellthesubject
flat for a total sale consideration of Rs. 5,00,()o )/-. It is further
contended that on i 1.01 . 1995, the plaintiff pai I a sum of Rs'
1,0O,OOO/- in cash to the defendant towards part [) tvment of
consideration, for which the defendalt executed a
the sale
-eceipt marked as
Ex.A1. Subsequently, the plarntiff paid Rs 75,'COl in cash on
31.01 . 1995 as evidence under Ex'A2 and a
further sum of
Rs. 75,000/- on'22.O3.i995, as evidence under E; A3 On the same
day, the defendant executed the agreement of saLt dated 22'03' 1995'
markedasEx.A4'whereinthedefendanthasadlrittedlyreceiveda
total sum of Rs. 3,75,000/- towards the sale cons t eration and it was
agreed that the balance of sale consideration of Rs ,25,000/- shall
be
paidonexecutionofsaledeed.WhentheptairlLffapproachedthe
defendant with the balance sale considerati: a, the defendanl
postponed the issue on one or other pretext' Tt e plaintiff came to
know that the defendant was trying to sell away r.J Le property to third
parties and got issued lega1 notice to the defendan - calling upon him to
register the suit property, but the defendant faj I :d to do the same
Hence, the suit is liled.
NNR,/
cccA_222 2004
Basing on the said pleadings the learned Trial Judge has framed
the following issues for Trial:
Issues:
Whether the plaintiff is entitled for relief of specihc
performance as PraYed for?
l1
Whether the plaintiff is entitled for alternative relief for
recovery of Rs.3,75,000/- as prayed for?
iii. To what relieP
5.
In suPPort of the case of the plaintiff, the plaintiff himself
examined as PWl and one K.R Dayashanker was examined as PW2
and got marked Exs.A1 to A6.
On behalf of the defendants, the
defendanthimselfexaminedasDWlandnodocumentsweremarked.
The handwriting expert was examined as CW1 and Ex'C1 was marked'
6.ThelearnedTrialJudgeaftergoingintoentirerecordarrdon
consideringtheoralanddocumentar5revidence,hasdismissedthe
Judgment and Decree uide O.S.No'329 of 1996 dated 19'07'2004'
7.
Being aggrieved by the same, the present appeal is Iiled on the
following grounds:
NN&/
cccA 222 2004
"The Court below failed to properly appreciate tlLr handwriting
expcrt's report (Ex.C1), which categorically contir ns that the
defendant has signed each page of Ex.A4, including .r I corections
and the questioned signaturcs rnarked as Q4 to Q7 t 'lly with the
admitted signatures ol- the det-endant. Despite thi:; clear expeft
opinion, thc Court bclow wrongly doubted the genuinc t rss of Ex.,A4.
the finding that Ex.A4 is materially altered is lega[[1
r
nsustainable,
as all corrections in Ex..A4 were duly signed by the delt r dant himself.
lhere is no allegation or evidcnce of alterations made
exccution.
ubsequent to
'fhe corrections do not affeot the validity or
'nforceability
of the agrcement. The Court below complctely misdirt :ted itself by
trcating signed corrections as material alterations'
Thc Court below misunderstood and misapplied : c ratio of the
Supreme Court judgment reported in (2002) 6 SCC 375. which clearly
holds that every alteration is not a material alteration a ld even postexecution alterations do not invzrlidate an agreement uol ss they affect
its enforceability.
In the prcsent case the correction relating rt sale of 1/6th
undivided share on page 2 is duly signed. The co^:clion in the
schedule mentioning 1250 Sq. feet is not even dis ruted by the
defendant. Hence, the reliance placed by the Court be t w on the said
judgment is whotly misplaced. The Court below conrr ritted a grave
error in rejecting the cvidence of P.W.2, the sole al ( iting witness.
whose testimony remained unshaken in cross-examina i rn and clearly
proved the execution of Ex.A4.
The rejection of his evidence merely becaust he could not
reoollect trivial details like the defendant's height or n: nber ofpages
after seven years is perverse and contrary to settlel principles of
evidence. The rejection of Ex.Al to Bx.A3 is enonert s because the
NNIT, /
cccA-722J004
pa)..rnen1s covered under these receipts are
acknowledged in Ex A.4
are similar' Merely
itself and the signatures on the receipts and Ex'A4
receipts' the Court
because. the handwriting cxpcrt did nor confirm the
below ought not to have ignored the admitted acknowledgment
plaintiff'
Ex.A4. This hnding should have rveighcd in favour ofthe
in
on a
The Courl below wrongly discredited the plaintiff based
that
minor discrepancy where P. W' I stated in cross-examination
it was
notice was sent by RPAD, whcreas in chief-examination'
of posting and
clearll, stated that the notice w'as sent under certi{-tcate
thataccidentalslipdoesnotaft-ectthevatidityofnotice'especially
not reply to the
when the address is undisputed and rhe rlelendant did
while
notice. The det-endant's conduct ought to have been considered
cxercising discretion undcr Section 20 of the Specific
Relief Act'
'fhe Cour't below failed to consider that against a sale
already paid Rs
consideration of Rs. 5,00,000/-, the plaintiff had
his frnancial
3,75,OOOi- and the plaintiff sufficiently explained
savings and also
capacity by bonowing from friends and using family
yet an
no separate issue was framed on readiness and willingness'
adverse finding was recorded. There was no
deny the reliefof specihc performance These
valid legal ground to
erors amount to serious
errors of law and fact, leading to an unjust
i
perfotmance."
I
I
I
denial of specific
8.
The learned counsel for the appellant submits that
:
t
,
time was prescribed for performance in the agreement
no specific
of sale' It is
I
t
I
I
further contended that the agreement stipulates that'
I
I
F
I
il
i
t
t
failure to execute the regular sale deed, the defendant
in the event of
shall refund the
NNR, / i
cccA_222_2004
amount of Rs. 3,75,000/- received, along with intt rest at the rate of
24uk per annum.
g.
It is further argued that the plarntiff was llu'ays ready and
u.illing to perform his part of the contract and wii i ready to pay the
balalce sale consideration of Rs. 1,25,000/-, but th< defendant did not
come forward to execute the sale deed. The pla I Ltiff issued a legal
notice under Ex.A5 against the defendant, whi<:. r was sent under
certihcate of posting.
10. It is atso further contended by the learr-r: 1 counsel for the
appellant that the plaintiff got issued certificate of 1; rsting under Ex.A6
to the house No.1-9-285/1, the address whiclL is shown in the
evidence is one and the same and further argued hat the defendant,
by {iling the written statement, has denied the aJ eged transactions,
though he has admitted that the plaintiff is knou'n -o him and pointed
out that the defendant has categorically denied t} e execution of the
agreement of sale as well as the receipts alleged to I ave been issued by
him in favour of the plaintiff and also further brorr Jht to the notice of
this Court that the report submitted by the Joint Director, Forensic
Science Laboratory, relied upon Ex.Xl and Ex.C-. which is the said
report marked through CW1 (the Joint Director).
NNR, /
cccA222_2004
1. On a perusal of the said report, the learned counsel for the
appeilant submitted that the standard signatures marked as
51 to
S8 and the questioned signatures marked as Q 1 to Q3' which
found on the receipts (Ex.A1 to A3), and Q4 to Q7' which are
are
found on
the agreement of sale, were examined by the expert' According
to the
opinion of CW1, the Joint Director of the Forensic Science Department'
the person who wrote the red enclosed starldard signatures ma'rked
S 1 to S8 also wrote the red-enclosed signatures
as
marked as Q4 to Q7'
but did not wrrte the red-enclosed. signatures marked as Q 1 to Q3'
L2. In other words, the signatures marked as Q4 to Q7 were opined
to have been executed by the same person who signed S 1 to S8'
namely, the defendant, whereas the signatures marked as Q1
to Q3
were not written by the defendant'
I
13. Further, with regard to the original u'ritings deciphered in the
red-enclosed portions marked as Q8 to Q11' CW1 opined
I
I
I
I
that the
alterations found therein pertain to QB' wherein the document
originally reflected a morLgage transaction '
14. The learned counsel for the defendant contended that the
agreement in question is a forged document and in view
of the material
alterations found. therein, the same cannot be relied upon
I
t
or
NN& /,
cccA 222 2004
considered by this Court. It was further contenrlr I that the receipts
marked as Ex.A1 to A3 have not been duly proved n accordance with
lau' and that a mere reference to the alleged paym I rts under Ex Al to
A3 in Ex.A4, the agreement of sale does not validt te such payments.
He further pointe d out that PW2, during his exanr nation, specifically
stated that he does not know one Shyam Sundar He also drew the
attention of this Court to the cross-examinatio - of the witnesses.
n'herein the material alterations in the documenl v ere not denied. I1
was also argued that there is a substantial d i ference betu'een a
mortgage deed ald an agreement of sale, arrd that he a-lteration of the
nature of the transaction from mortgage to sale c,) rstitutes a material
alteration affecting the validity of the document.
15. With regard to the forensic report, he : ubmitted that the
questioned signatures marked as Ql to Q3 are no in a continuous or
natural florv ar-rd appear to be blocked signatur: ;, thereby it was it
serious doubt on their genuineness.
16. The learned counsel for the respondent/defc r dalt arglred that in
any event, there was no proper service of notic: was issued on the
defendant. He pointed out that the Under Certifi: rte of Posting (UCP)
relied upon by the handwriting of the plaintiff, zur I the date on which
NNR, /
cccA,222 2004
it was allegedly written has not been established'
been obtained at a later point
submitted that the UCP appears to have
of time, namely on 2lst March' as per
the endorsement of the postal
authorities He further contend'ed that the
the notice sent was posted by registered
questions as to whether
post' and whether a UCP can
service
be treated as constituting deemed
According to him, a UCP, by itself'
He further
which require strict scrutiny'
does not raise a presumption of
servlce
L7.
He contended that as per Section
1 14 of the
Indian Evidence Act'
particularly lllustration (f), extracted below:
"that the common course of bttsiness
has been followed in
Particular cases"
service'
He submitted that it is not a deemed
of service of notice frled in respect
of service of notice'
18. He further argued that the material
was
document indicate that the transaction
I
mortgage ' He submitted that though
,.
I
I
offers to purchase, and such a recital
originally intended to be a
in iaw' it is the vendee who
itself reflects inconsistency in
to the questioned Portion
the document' He furtLrer drew attention
which mentlons an
(CWl)'
expert
forensic
gtO
Ty-tfre
AS
marked
i
alterations found in the
the agreement recites that the
but
vendor offered to sell the property'
I
arrd that there is no proof
NNR, /,.
cccA 222 2004
arnount of Rs.5,0O,OO0/-, and contended that .l Le said amount rs
consistent rt'ith a mortgage transaction rather thz n a:r agreement ol
sale ald that the testimony of PW2 has no evident ary value, vvhereas
the expert evidence remains uncontroverted. Rell i- 1 upon the forensir:
report and the exhibits on record, he submitt<:<i rhat Ex.A4 clearll'
demonstrates that the document is materially al,-r red and cannot bo
relied upon. He further argued that, till date, nr arnount has beerr
deposited lrv the plaintiff, nor the plaintiff pleadec rr proved readiness
and willingness as required under 1aw.
19. It rvas lurther contended that the Under (l:rtificate of Posting
(UCP) procluced before the Court is wholly unbel evable. Though the
date mentioned thereon is 18.03.1996, it cannot b : presumed that the
notice was posted on that date, much less th a - it was served or-t
25.03.1996. He pointed out that no opportuni, was given to the
defendant to respond to the alleged notice, as th: suit itself was filed
immediately on 25.03.1996. According to him, it cr monstrates that the
plaintiff did not issue a genuine legal notice a.rr,l faiied to wait for a
reasonable period to ascertain whether the defelr I rnt had accepted or
rejected the demand. Consequently, he submitt€ I that no cause of
action had arisen for the plaintiff to institute the s r it.
NNR,/
cccA_222 2004
2(-. He lastiy submitted that when the written statement
denies the
claimintoto,itarnountstoadenialofallmaterialaverments'andthe
defendant is not requlred to deny each and
every element separately'
2L. He further argued that PW2 was a planted u'itness'
solely for the purpose of supporting the plaintiff's
case' Drau'ing the
attention of this Court to the evidence of PW2' particularly
No.2 of his deposition, he submitted that' PW2
the plaintiff paid a cash amount of Rs 2'OO'O00/-
brought rn
paragraph
stated that
to the defendant and
that an agreement of sale was executed between them
in his presence'
onwhichhealsosignedasawitness.Hefurtherstatedthatareceipt
of
issued by the defendalt acknowledging. the receipt
was
Rs.2,00,OoO/-. It was further contended that the
testimony of PW2
cannot be believed, as he was a planted witness
introduced only to
substantial
prove the alleged transaction' According to him' nothing
the
can be pulled out from the evidence of PW2 to establish
evidence
execution or genuineness of the agreement of
evidence does not help the case of the plaintiff'
I
sale' and therefore' his
NNR, / I
cccA_222.-2001
22. He further argued that the decision citetl by the plaintiff,
reported in Krovidi Kameswaramma And Oth ers V/s Kudapa
Balamayya And Anotherl, dated 14.O7.199a, held 1
.rat:
ttluinti//'mu.\t Loma lo lht ('ourt v'ilh clean h L \. mort so itl
lht) Lase ol u plaintiff who seck-s an equitoble rel L' of speci.lic
perlitrmonte 'l'|rc relicl'h-v u,ay ol speci/ic performante r u tuithin thc
distraliott of lh(. Court. lt is absolutely neccssary tht lhe plointi/f
should unnc to the C(nrt t,ilh clcun hunds. In other \t ) tls a pluinf i/-[
vho sels u1t u.lul.se Luse (unnol crpecl a Courl of equi.t lo grunl him
rht rclie.l ln t'it* o.f rlrc .finding thut the plaintiff has .fi.i ':d to pay thtt
amtrunt rlut' bt thc erul of ,lartuary l9ll3 it is cle ar lhai rt lrus c(tme up
seltin1 oul u.filsc plau anLl thot he has commilted dcla t r rtf the tenn.s
'fhis again implie.s that he is not rcodt
'nd v'illing to
o.f the contrdtt.
perlitrm hrs purt ol the contracl. It is (Lxiomalic tLt nlar that the
pluintilJ'u,ho sets up a.fhlse plea of payment and fails t, substantidtc
thut he is ulu'u.t s reudl'and willing to pcrform his part , I lhe conlrdcl
cunnot .seek ttta relief of specific performance. In u st ilar casc this
(-.ourt in K.Vcnksla Subbayya v. K. Venkateswantl r observed a-s
'.ln),
;fttllot+,s:
"Irre.;pet:lt'a o.f tut.v olhar .fctcl the averment in thr. aint und the
notice i.\ sullicienl to hold that he v'qs not readv r nd willing lo
perlbrnt his purl ol lhe obligalbn under Ex.A-l ant' hal opart the
plainrifl :nho .seeks cquilable remedy of specific pe)'l tl'monce musl
come to thc Courl wilh clean hands".
Il is Lntegorically' observed there thdl the plaintif|'t . o had set up u
ful;c plL,a of pu.yment of a major portion of the purctr se money Ytus
rutt onll, disentilled to the discretronary relief on the 1 ound that 7 ha
hus sel u1t a.fulse plau but also on the ground that, th:, ,lisc'loses thul
he t'os ntt ready and v,illing to perform his part o.l'il t contract. l'l/e
arc in respecll l agr@ment v'ith the view taken in tl i deci.sion. T'he
principle that Impart delicto potior est condilio defL'nc; is also to the
e/ltct thttr in tase of equal guill lhe defqrulant alone : nuld succeed.
So on applitution of this principle dlso the fiAiii 1 must fail .fbr
srtting up a -fulse plcu. f'rom alL the ubove principh.s it is clcur thut
' 1998(s)ALD68
NNR, /
cccA_222_2004
the plaintrJJ who docs not comc to lhe Clurt wilh clean hunds cannol
succeed. "
2g. He also contended that the plaintiff has not approached the
court u,ith clean hands and was further submitted that although PW1,
in his evidence, stated that the legal notice was sent by registered post
with acknowledgment due, but no acknowledgment has been hled
before the court. on the contrary, the record clearly discloses that the
plaintilf relied only upon an Under Certihcate of Posting' marked as
Ex.A6, which is wholly unreliable and cannot be believed'
24. [n support of his contentions, he further placed reliance on the
judgment of the Honble Supreme Court reported in Lourdu Mari
David and Ors V/s Louis Chinnaya Arogiaswamy and Ors2' dated
09.08.1996, held that:
''It is settled ltn, that lhe parly u'ho seeks to avuil of the aquitable
juris<liction oJ' a C.ourt anr) specilic petformance being aquitable
relief, musl come lo the Court with clean hands; ln olher v'ords lhe
purty who makes false allegulions does not come with clean hands
and is not entitled lo lhe equitable relief The Division Bench has
pointed out in the iutlgment three grounds which disentitle the plaintilf
to the equiluble rclief a.s he came with d positive case of incotrect and
"
Jalse facts.
2s.Thecruxofthecaseisthat,infactthattheplaintifl,sentire
claim is founded upon Ex.Al to 4'6 and Ex'Al to A3 which are the
'ntR t996 sc zgta
NNR,
/,
cccA 222 2004
receipts alleged to have been executed by
Ie defendant on
11.01.1995,23.O1.1995, and 30.01.1995 respectile .v. The defendant
has categorically clenied the execution of the agrer:rr :nt of sale marked
as Ex.A4, dated 22.03.1995, contending that the ; ud agreement u'as
never executed by him. He has specifically deniecl t-rat he ever offered
to sell the flat to the plaintiff or that he agreed to sc I the propert5r for a
total consideration ol Rs.5,0O,000/-. The defrr Ldant has further
denied the issuance of the receipts rnarked as E> Al to A3 and the
alteged payments said to have been made by the p eintiff there under.
He has aiso specifically denied the payment of Rs. 2,OO,000/- alleged
to have been made by the plaintiff on 22.03.1995.
26. As already discussed by this Court in the pri ceding paragraphs,
the nature of the tr-ansaction originally being :L mortgage and the
material alterations found in the documents i re important. Th<:
findings relating to the material alterations and tht expert evidence, as
extracted and analyzed ea-rlier, are required to b,: read into and form
part of, the present discussion.
27. In view ol the categorica-l denial of the entirr transaction as well
as the alleged payments by the defendant, the ini ial burden squarely
lies upon the plaintiff to prove the execution of the documents and the
NNR, /
cccA_222J004
payments alleged to have been made by him to the defendant The
plaintiff has relied upon Ex.A1 to A4, with Ex.AS being the lega1 notice.
whereas Ex.Al to A3 are the receipts alleged to have been issued by
the defendart. Before going into the further discussion, it is relevant
to extract section 87 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, which
reveals as follows:
",1ry' nnterial allcralion ol' a negotiable instrumenl renders lhc
same tttitl tts ttguittst uny one v'ho is a parly thereto al tha time ttl
making suth ulleralion and does nol consenl lhereto, unless it was
ntatl<: in ortler l<t corry ottl lhe common intention o/ the originul
par tie s.
Alleratktn by indorsee. And any such aheration, i.f madc
by an inclorsee. dischargcs his indorser Jiom all liability to
him in
respecl of
the consideration thereoJ "
2A. The learned counsel for the appellant submitted that, at the
instance of the defendant, the receipts and the agreement of sa-ie were
sent to the Forensic Science Department for expert opinion with regard
to the genuineness of the signatures.
29. The evidence of CW 1 clearly shows that he exarnined the
disputed writings and signatures marked as Ql to Q1l and compared
them with the standard signatures marked as
S
to
s8. After such examination, he furnished his opinion with reasons on
2S.OT.2o}3,whichismarkedasEx.Cl.Inhiscross-examination'CW1
NNR, / (
cccA 222J004
stated that Ex.Cl is his report, the contents mad(r z re true and correct '
and further adrnitted that there are a-iterations in F,; .A4
30. With regard to the evidence of CWl, th<, igh there was no
cross exarnination on behalf of the plaintiff chal r nging the findings
relating to the signatures marked as Q4 to Q7, it is r-elevarlt to note
that there was also no rebuttal evidence adduced rv the defendant to
disprove the expert opinion that the said signat rres belong to the
defendalt. In the absence of anv rebuttal evidrr ce, the hndings of
CW1 remain unchallenged. This establishes that I )x.A4 was executed
by the defendant
31. Insofar Ex.Al to A3 are concerned, as righ r contended by the
learned counsel for the plaintiff, once Ex.A4 is rroved through the
evidence of CW1 and Ex.Ci, and when the said aleement itself refers
to the payments covered under Ex.Al to A3, it follou,s that the
amounts mentioned therein were paid by the pla I tiff and received by
the defendant. Per contra, the execution of Ex.A.- necessarily leads to
acceptance of amounts mentioned in the receipts .l ; well.
32. Though certain alterations were pointed or t by the defendant
with reference to the portions marked as Q4 to eti the same do not, in
the opinion of this Court, affect the intention of rl e parties. The mere
NN1T, ,J
cccA 222 2004
useoftheword*mortgage,,inthealteredportiondoesnotchangethe
overall purpose and nature of the document, it clearly evidences
as an
agreement of sale.
33. Coming to the aspect of time, it is admitted that' in the
the
cross-examination of PW i, the defendant elicited that Ex'A4'
agreement of sale does not stipulate aly specihc time for
execution of
the sale deed. The agreement contains a clause to the effect that
as
and when the plaintiff is ready and pays the balance sale
consideration, the defendant shall execute the sale deed either
in
favour of the plaintiff or any nominee'
34. In such circumstances, time cannot be construed as the essence
of the contract. Therefore, the plaintiff was required to express
by
readiness and willingness to perform his part of the contract
his
issuingalegalnoticetothedefendantandthereafterseekexecutionof
i
i
the sale deed.
I
i
l
35. In the present case, the principal dispute between the parties
is
with regard to the issuance and service of the legal notice' According
to the plaintiff, the legal notice was issued under Ex'AS on
18'03' 1996'
It is the plaintiffs case that the said notice was sent under certificate
NNR, / ;'
ccc.A 222 2004
of posting to the address mentioned in the agreem3 rt. Admittedly, the
present suit was fiied on 25.03.1996
36. Even assuming that the notice u,as posted r n 18.03. 1996, the
suit having been instituted on 25.03.1996, it r evident that the
)
i
plaintiff did not even wait for a period of seven di rs. The defendant,
therefore, was not afforded reasonable or suflicien t time to respond to
l
I
I
the alleged notice. Further, since the notice is ci: imed to have been
I
I
sent only under certificate of posting, the same ci nnot be treated as
I
rl
I
t
I
proof of service on the defendalt.
37. In the absence of reliable proof of service o- notice and withoul
granting suffrcient time to the defendant after tht: alleged issuance of
notice, it cannot be said that a valid cause of acti,r r has arisen for thr:
plaintiff to institute the present suit
38. Though there is legal notice was said to t, ve been posted on
18.03.1996 issued through certificate of postir-r: the same carr br:
treated as proof of service as per the Section 27 o1 he General Clauses
Act. However, in the absence of any material I dicating the actual
date of ser'ice of the said notice and without aly rleading or evidence
to establish t.l.at there was a refusal on the part of the defendant, such
service cannot be conclusively inferred. Admittec J ,,, as per the Clause
NNR, /
cccA,222_2004
5oftheagreementofsale,thereisnospecifictimeforexecutionof
sale deed and law of limitation is applicable. It is further contended
thatincasevendorfailstoexecutethesaledeedinfavourofVendeeor
his nominee, the Vendor sha1l refund the advance and earnest money
of Rs.3,75,OOO/- received together with interest at the rate of 24ok pet
annum from date of execution of the agreement of sale'
39. In view of the finding given by CWl under ExCl' the sard
agreement of sale was duly executed by the defendant Though the
execution u,as denied, the evidence placed by the plaintiff proves the
agreement of sale, thereby binding the parties to the covenants thereof.
However,theplaintiffisnotentitledforspecificperformanceofthe
agreement, as no cause of action had arisen to seek the compensation'
The piaintiff has not placed any evidence to show that there was a
dernand for execution of the sale deed or refusal on the part of the
defendant.Further,itiscontendedthattheplaintiffisreadyand
willing to place his part of contract in absence of such demand or
refusal.Though,anoticewasissued,theplaintiffdidnotevenwaitfor
the reply or refusal on the part of the defendant' Consequently' the
cause of action for seeking specific performance ca-nnot be said to have
arisen. Admittedly, in view of Ex.C1 and the evidence of CW1' the
defendant has received t[e total sum of Rs'3,75,000/- under Ex'A4'
NNR, / 1
(accA_222_2004
40. Though it is contended that trxs.Al to A3 u't: 3 not prol'ed, CWI
admitted that the said documents were not signe. b1' the defendant.
However, the finding given by thc CWl, the signrr ures on Ex.A4 are
that of the defenclant and shorvs that acknowledgnt :nt of rer:eipt of the
advance of Rs.1,75,OOO/- on the dates mett rned therein and
Rs.2,00,000/- at the time of execution of the agr:ement of sale. In
vier.','of the Clause 5 of the agreement of sale, the' lefendant is bound
to refund the amount in case the said sa-le d,: d is not executec.
in favour of the plaintiff. In the present case, as t-lL ; Court having helci
that the plaintiff is not entitled for the speci{ic rerformance of tht:
agreement and in alternate the plaintiff is not t ntitled for relief or
refund by invoking Clause 5 of the agreement o' saie. As such, tht:
findings which are given by the learned trial Cou' that the plaintiff is
not entitled for specifrc performance of agreer renl of sale dated
i
22.O3.1995. But considering the above discussi'; rs made before this
i
Court, this Court holds that the plaintiff is entitlr I for the a-lternative
i
relief for recovery of srlm of Rs.3,75,OOO/-. Furthr r, tl're hndings given
by the learned trial Court that no amounts were raid to the plaintiffs
to defendants under Exs.Al to 43 and ,,{4 is not L re agreement of sale
executed by defendant and the learned trial
il
I
I
i
lourt came to the
2t
NNIT, /
cccA]22_2004
conclusion that Exs.AS and 46 u,ere not genuine documents and they
have created for the purpose of the suit, hard to accept'
4L. It appears that the learned tria-l court ignoring the evidence of
CW1 and the expert opinion Ex.C1, the alterations which are made in
the agreement of sale does not amounts to material alterations. As
such, the Ex.A4 hold.s good and the same cannot be said that it is not
a genuine document and created for the purpose of suit'
42. In view of the above discussion, while holding that the agreement
of sale as genuine, this Court also finds that in the absence of any
demand by the plaintiff and refusal on the part ol the defendant for the
specific performance is not granted.
43. This court holds that the plaintiff is not entitled for any specihc
performance, but the plaintiff is entitled for the recovery of said
amounts under the agreement of sale along with interest. Hence, for
the above said reasons, these points are partly answered in favour of
the appellant.
44. Therefore, the findings of the trial court deserves to be set aside.
Consequently, the Judgment and Decree dated 19 07'2004 passed in
O.S.No.329 of 1996 by the Additional Judge, Cit]" Small Causes Court-
cum-Vl Senior Civil Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad is set aside'
I
I
t
I
NNR, / r=
cc('A 222 2004
45. Accordingly, this City Civil Court Appeal is pr rtiy a_llou,ed. partl),
decreeing the suit to the extent of granting a ::lief of recoverv oi
amount of Rs.3,75,000/- paid by the plaintiff to rl c defendant under
Ex.A4 agreement of sale, with interest at l2ok p( r annum from the
date of the agreement till the date of judgment o1 _he trial Court and
future interest at 670 per annum from the date of rl:cree till the date ol'
realization rejecting the claim of specihc perform:ur:r: of the ztgreemenl
of sale. Each party shall bear their own costs.
As a sequel, miscellaneous applications, if anv pending, shall
stald closed.
SE/ K. SRINIVASA RAO
JOINT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY'
SECTION OFFICER
To,
'Ihe I Additional Judge, City Small Causes Court-crtt - 6th Senior Crvil
Jude, Crty Civil Court, Hyderabad.(With records)
One CC to Allrs. lvlanjari S. Ganu, Advocate [OPUC]
One CC to [vlr. N.V. Anantha Krishna, Advocate IOPU( ]
Two CD Copies
D lt, SI,
.
\ I
+
HIGH COURT
DATED:0710112026
irtE S Lq I c
r)
(J
z
2I Jl' ?l?6
C)
^\
*
IFS PATT)i
JUDGMENT
CCCA.No.222 of 2004
PARTLY ALLOWING THE CCCA
,6'\
[,
t
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
WEDNESDAY, THE SEVENTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NARSING RAO NANDIKONDA
CITY CIVIL COURT APPEAL NO: 222 OF 2004
Between:
Sri D. Shivakumar, S/o Late Sri D. Nagabhushanam, Occ. Service R/o 1-9295/19, Srilaxmi Nilayam, Vrdyanagar, Hyderabad.
...Appella n UPIa intiff
AND
Sri S. Shyamsunder, S/o Sri S.J. Somayajulu, Occ: Servrce Rlo 1-9-28511,
Vidyanagar, Hyderabad.
...RespondenUDefendant
Appeal under section 96 of C.P.C against the Judgment-and Decree Dated
19.07.2004 made in O.S.No.329 OF 1996 on the file of the Court of the I
Additional Judge, City Small Causes Court-cum-6rh Senror Civil Jude, City Civil
Court, Hyderabad.
This appeal coming on for hearing and upon perusing the grounds of appeal,
the Judgment and Decree of the Lower Court and the material papers in the Case
and upon hearing the arguments of Mrs. Manjari S. Ganu, Advocate for the
Appellant and of Mr. N.V. Anantha Krishna, Advocate for the Respondents.
This Court doth Order and Decree as follows:
1. That the CCCA be and hereby rs partly allowed,
2. That the Judgment and Decree dated 19 07 -2004 passed in O.S. No. 329
of 1996 by the Additional Judge, City Small Causes Court-cum-Vl Senior
Civil Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad be and hereby is set aside;
3. That partly decreeing the suit to the extent of granting a relief of recovery
of amount of Rs. 3,75,000/- paid by the plaintiff to the defendant under Ex.
44 agreement of sale, with
agreement ti' the crate
6%o per annum front
interest at 12o/o perann,
of rudgment of the triar
) tronr the date of
the
courl rnd future rnterest at
the date of decree till the
date
relecting
the claim of specific performance
of the agreeme", .; , j:j"t"'"n
4. That each party shall bear
thejr own costs;
SD/- ( 5p111yASA RAO
\"
//TRUE COPY//
INT REGISTRA
\
AirTroN oFFrcER
To,
E;,? J#"r?;?,:ma,
ii.""^?i$
two CD Copies
ca uses court-cum-6
Sen ror c rvrr
HIGH COURT
DATED:0710112026
DECREE
CCCA.No.222 of 2004
PARTLY ALLOWING THE CCCA
I
I
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review