Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA No.13 of 2023
Sri Chittaranjan Shil,
S/O Late Rajni Kanta Shil,
Vill:-Belabar (Shibir Tilla),
P.O-Charipara, P.S-Amtali,
Dist-West Tripura(85)
------ Appellant
Versus
1.
Sri Santosh Sengupta,
S/O Lt. Satyabrata Sengupta,
Vill-Madhya Charipara, P.O-Charipra,
P.S-Amtali, Dist-West Tripura.
2.
Sri Prantosh Sengupta,
S/O- Lt. Satyabrata Sengupta,
Vill-Madhya Charipara, P.O-Charipra,
P.S.-Amtali, Dist-West Tripura.
3.
Smt. Jhuma Sengupta (Gan),
W/O- Sri Kamal Gan,
D/O-Lt. Satyabrata Sengupta,
R/O-Office Lane, Agartala,
P.S.-West Agartala, Dist-West Tripura.
4. (a) Smt. Rupali Sen Gupta,
D/O Lt. Santi Narayan Sengupta,
R/O-Joynagar, P.O-Agartala,
P.S. –West Agartala,
Dist- West Tripura.
(b) Mr. Sankar Sen Gupta,
S/O-Lt. Santi Narayan Sengupta,
Vill-Madhya Charipara, P.O-Charipra,
P.S-Amtali, Dist-West Tripura.
(c) Mr. Shibu Sen Gupta,
S/O-Lt. Santi Narayan Sengupta,
Vill-Madhya Charipara, P.O-Charipra,
P.S-Amtali, Dist-West Tripura.
(d) Mr. Shakti Pada Sen Gupta,
S/O-Lt. Santi Narayan Sengupta,
Vill-Madhya Charipara, P.O-Charipra,
P.S-Amtali, Dist-West Tripura.
(e) Mrs. Ruma Sen Gupta(Taran),
D/O-Lt. Santi Narayan Sengupta,
R/O-Joynagar, P.O-Agartala,
P.S-West Agartala, Dist-West Tripura.
(f) Mr. Pranab Sen Gupta,
S/O-Lt. Santi Narayan Sengupta,
Vill-Madhya Charipara, P.O-Charipra,
P.S-Amtali, Dist-West Tripura.
(g) Mrs. Soma Sen Gupta,
D/O-Lt. Santi Narayan Sengupta,
R/O-Ramnagar Road No.10,
P.O-Ramnagar, P.S-West Agartala.
(h) Mr. Kajal Sen Gupta,
S/O-Lt. Santi Narayan Sengupta,
Vill-Madhya Charipara, P.O-Charipra,
P.S-Amtali, Dist-West Tripura.
5.
Sri Matilal Sengupta,
S/O Lt. Nripendra Sengupta,
Vill-Madhya Charipara, P.O.-Charipra,
P.S-Amtali, Dist.-West Tripura.
------ Respondents
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. Debalay Bhattacharya, Sr. Adv.,
Ms. Rashmi Bhattarcharjee, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Saktimoy Chakraborty, Sr. Adv.,
Mrs. Pinki Chakraborty, Adv.
Date of hearing
:
14.08.2025
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
28.08.2025
Whether fit for
reporting
:
YES
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This second appeal under Section 100 of CPC is preferred
challenging the judgment dated 22.07.2022 and decree dated
29.07.2022 delivered by Learned Additional District Judge, West
Tripura,
Agartala,
Court
No.5
in
connection
with
Case
No.TA/17/2021. By the said judgment and decree, Learned First
Appellate Court partly allowed the appeal reversing the judgment
delivered by Learned Trial Court in connection with Case No.
TS/105/2016 and also uphold the judgment and decree delivered
by Learned Trial Court in the same suit in TS(CC)/6/2017.
2.
Heard Learned Senior Counsel Mr. Debaloy Bhattacharya,
assisted by Learned Counsel, Ms. Rashmi Bhattacharjee appearing on
behalf of the appellant-defendant and also heard Learned Senior
Counsel Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, assisted by Learned Counsel, Mrs.
Pinki Chakraborty appearing on behalf of the respondent-plaintiffs.
3.
At the time of admission of appeal, the following substantial
question of law was formulated by this Court by order dated
01.09.2023:
“Whether single, one and common appeal is maintainable
against the judgment and decree passed in TS 105 of 2016 and
TS(CC) 06 of 2017?”
4.
Now, let us discuss about the subject matter of the original
suit and the counter claim. The respondent-plaintiffs filed the title suit
bearing No.105 of 2016 for declaration of title, recovery of possession
and perpetual injunction before the Learned Trial Court. The case of
the respondent-plaintiffs, in short, was that originally one Tabdil
Hussain and four others were owners of the suit land and other lands
by paying Nazrana to the Maharaja Tripura from Taluk No.169 and
being owner of the suit land and other lands transferred the same in
favour of the original plaintiff No.4 (substituted by legal heirs),
plaintiff No.5 and predecessors of plaintiff Nos.1, 2, 3 and others by
exchange deed No.1-3832 dated 13.01.1964 and thereafter by
partition plaintiff Nos.4, 5 and predecessors of plaintiff Nos.1, 2 and 3
for land measuring 4.20 acres including the suit land. About 20 years
back the defendant was allowed to stay on the suit land as permissive
possessor. In the last part of December, 2015 plaintiffs requested the
defendant to vacate the suit land within 3 months. On 24.07.2016,
the defendant started construction over the suit land illegally when
the respondent-plaintiffs raised objection and again on 25.07.2016
the defendant was requested to vacate the suit land but the
defendant threatened the plaintiffs. On 03.08.2016 the plaintiffs
issued notice upon the defendant to vacate the suit land within 15
days but no action was taken. Hence the respondent-plaintiffs filed
the suit bearing No.TS/105/2016 before the Learned Trial Court for
declaration of title, recovery of possession and perpetual injunction.
The
original
defendant
filed
counter
claim
which
was
registered as TS(CC)/6/2017 in the same suit with the assertions that
original owner of the suit land was one Narendra Kumar Majumder
which was recorded in his name in Khatian No.2132. The defendant
purchased land measuring 5 gandas by two registered sale deeds
bearing No.1-6378 and 1-6577 dated 19.10.1987 from said Narendra
Kumar Majumder. The defendant sold land measuring 2 gandas out of
his purchased 5 gandas of land to one Tejendra Datta and the
defendant remained owner of land measuring 3 gandas and was
enjoying the same and respondent-plaintiffs have had no right, title
and interest over the same. It was also pleaded that due to wrong
entry in the revenue record, land measuring 2 gandas was shown in
favour of the plaintiffs and 1 ganda was shown in favour of the
defendant for which the dispute cropped up amongst the parties. It
was further pleaded that the defendant received notice of the
plaintiffs and the defendant issued reply to notice dated 15.06.2020
but the plaintiffs concealed said fact. The defendant further took the
plea that the plaintiffs wrongly described the boundary of the suit
land. Thus, the defendant by the counter claim prayed for declaration
of title and perpetual injunction against the plaintiffs.
5.
Upon the pleadings of the parties, Learned Trial Court framed
7 numbers of issues in TS/105/2016 and also framed 6 numbers of
issues in TS(CC)/6/2017 which are mentioned herein below:
Issues framed in TS/105/2016:
i) Is the suit maintainable in its present form and
nature?
ii) Have the plaintiffs any cause of action to institute
the instant suit?
iii) Have the plaintiffs right, title and interest over the
suit land?
iv) Is the story of possession of plaintiffs over the suit
land and their dispossession therefrom true? If so,
are the plaintiffs entitled to get possession of the
suit land?
v) Are the plaintiffs entitled to get an order of
perpetual injunction, as prayed for?
vi) Are the plaintiffs entitled to a decree, as prayed
for?
vii) What other relief/reliefs the plaintiffs are entitled
to?
Issues framed in TS(CC)/6/2017:
i) Is the suit maintainable in its present form and
nature?
ii) Has the counter claimant any cause of action to
institute the instant suit?
iii) Has the counter claimant right, title and interest
over the suit land?
iv) Is the counter claimant in possession of the suit
land? If so, is the counter claimant entitled to get
an order of perpetual injunction, as prayed for?
v) Is the counter claimant entitled to a decree, as
prayed for?
vi) What other relief/reliefs the counter claimant is
entitled to?
To substantiate the issues, the original plaintiffs relied upon
some documents which were marked as Exhibits and the respondentplaintiffs adduced only one witness namely Sri Matilal Sengupta who
was examined as PW-1. On the other hand the contesting defendant
adduced six numbers of witnesses and relied upon some documentary
evidence which were marked as exhibits. For the sake of convenience,
the names of the witnesses and the exhibited documents of the
parties are mentioned herein below:
(A) Plaintiffs' Exhibits :i) Finally published Khatian Nos.1986/1 and
1986/2 under mouja-charpara in 2 sheets
marked as Exbt.1A and Exbt.1B respectively.
ii) Exchange deed bearing No.1-3832 dated
13.01.1964 in 32 sheets marked as Exbt.2.
iii) Demand notice dated 03.08.2016 marked as
Exbt.3.
iv) Postal receipt dated 03.08.2016 marked as
Exbt.4.
v) Survey settlement map old and new in 2
sheets marked as Exbt.5/A and Exbt.5/B.
(B) Plaintiffs' Witnesses :i) PW.1 Sri Matilal Sengupta.
(C) Defendant's Exhibits :i) Original copy of the
13.05.2009 Exbt.A.
legal
notice
dated
ii) Certified copy of Khatian No.4241 Exbt.B.
iii) Original copy of registered sale deed vide
No.1-6577 marked Exbt.C.
iv) Original copy of registered sale deed vide
no.1-6578 Ext.D.
v) Certified copy of trace map
Charipara sheet No.1(P) Ext.E.
of
mouja-
vi) Certified copy of Khatian NO.2135 marked
Ext.F.
vii) Certified copy of Khatian No.542 marked
Exbt.G.
(D) Defendant's Witnesses :i) DW.1 Sri Chittaranjan Shil.
ii) DW.2 Sri Dulal Majumder.
iii) DW.3 Sri Dilip Kumar Datta.
iv) DW.5 Smt. Ankit Bhowmik.
v) DW.6 Ashim Saha.
Finally, on conclusion of trial Learned Trial Court by judgment
dated 16.09.2021 dismissed the suit of the plaintiffs now the
respondents herein and also decreed the counter claim of the original
defendant now the appellant herein. For the sake of convenience, the
operative portion of the judgment dated 16.09.2021 is reproduced
herein below:
ORDER
11. In the result, the suit of the plaintiff bearing
No.T.S.105 of 2016 is dismissed opining that the
plaintiffs have failed to prove their right, title and
interest over the suit premise identifying the same
properly.
The suit of the plaintiff bearing No.T.S 105 of 2016 is
disposed of on contest with cost.
On the other hand the counter-claim bearing
No.T.S(CC) 06 of 2017 is hereby decreed with the
observation that the counter-claimant has right, title
and interest over the suit premise described in his
counter-claim along with confirmation of possession.
The counter-defendants are restrained to cause any
disturbance with the peaceful possession of the
counter-claimant over the suit premise described in
the schedule of the counter-claim.
The counter-claim bearing No.T.S(CC) 06 of 2017 is
disposed of on contest with cost.
Make necessary entry in the relevant Trial Register.
Prepare decree accordingly and put up before me for
signature within 14(fourteen) days from today.
Challenging that judgment, the respondent i.e. the original
plaintiffs filed an appeal before the Learned First Appellate Court
under Section 96 of CPC and the Learned First Appellate Court by the
judgment dated 22.07.2022 and decree dated 29.07.2022 disposed of
the appeal partly modifying the judgment delivered in TS/105/2016
and uphold the judgment delivered in connection with TS(CC)/6/2017.
For the sake of convenience, the operative portion of the judgment
runs as follows:
ORDER
TS 105 of 2016
In the result I find the appeal against the judgment
and decree passed in TS 105 of 2016 is liable to be
allowed partly and stands allowed partly. It is hereby
declared that plaintiffs are owner of their land of
khatian No.1986/1, CS plot No.1743/P, RS Plot
No.3719 land measuring 0.050 acres.
TS(CC) 06 of 2017
In the result, I find, the appeal against the judgment
and decree passed in TS(CC) 06 of 2017 is liable to
be dismissed and stands dismissed and the
Judgment and decree of the Ld. Trial Court is upheld.
This appeal is disposed of on contest.
Prepare appellate decree accordingly
before me for signature within 15 days.
and
place
Send down the Trial Court Record along with a copy
of this Judgment and decree.
Challenging that judgment, the respondent as appellant i.e.
the original defendant has preferred this appeal before this High
Court.
6.
At the time of hearing, Learned Counsel for the appellant-
defendant submitted that the respondent-plaintiffs filed one suit for
declaration of title and for recovery of possession and for perpetual
injunction, and the present appellants as defendants filed one counter
claim, claiming declaration of title and perpetual injunction against the
original plaintiffs and after conclusion of trial, Learned Civil Judge
(Senior Division), Court No.1, West Tripura, Agartala, dismissed the
suit filed by the respondent-plaintiffs in TS/105/2016 and decreed the
counter claim filed by the present appellant. Learned Senior Counsel
further submitted that in view of Section 96 of CPC, there was no
scope on the part of the Learned First Appellate Court to deliver a
common judgment and decree in the first appeal but the Learned First
Appellate Court, ignoring the provisions of law by a common
judgment and decree, disposed of the appeal. Although the present
appellant has not been materially affected by the said judgment and
decree of the Learned First Appellate Court but in view of the settled
position of law, the same is not permissible. Learned Senior Counsel
also referred Para Nos.3, 6 and 8(a) of the judgment delivered by the
Learned First Appellate Court and submitted that the Learned First
Appellate Court, misconstruing the provisions of law delivered one
judgment because there was no scope to hear common appeal against
the judgment and decree passed in TS/105/2016 and TS(CC)/6/2017
by the Learned First Appellate Court.
Learned Senior Counsel further drawn the attention of the
Court referring the memo of appeal filed by the respondent-plaintiffs
in the caption that the respondent-plaintiffs only challenged the
judgment delivered by Learned Trial Court in TS/105/2016 but in
absence of proper court fees, Learned First Appellate Court, ignoring
the provisions of Section 96 of CPC, heard and decided both the suit
Nos.TS/105/2016 and TS(CC)/6/2017. Learned Senior Counsel again
drawn the attention of the Court that the appeal valued at Rs.
1,05,000/- being the value of original title suit but no separate
valuation was shown for the connected TS(CC)/6/2017 and no court
fees was paid for the connected counter claim. But Learned First
Appellate Court, ignoring the prayer, in para No.8 of the judgment
decided to formulate the following points for decision of the appeal
which are mentioned hereinbelow:
(a) Whether
single,
one
and
common
appeal
is
maintainable against the judgment and decree passed in
TS 105 of 2016 and TS(CC) 06 of 2017?
(b) Whether the plaintiffs or defendant is the owner of the
suit land and whether the defendant is in possession on
the land of plaintiffs or on his purchase land?
(c) Whether the Judgment of the Ld. Trial Court is required
to be interfered?
It was again submitted in the caption, although only the
judgment and decree in respect of TS/105/2016 was challenged but in
the
relief,
the
respondent-plaintiffs
sought
reliefs
for
setting
aside/quash/reversing the judgment and decree of both the title suit
and the connected counter claim. So, in view of the settled legal
position, the judgment and decree of the Learned First Appellate
Court cannot be sustained in the eye of law and urged for setting
aside the judgment dated 22.07.2022 and decree dated 29.07.2022
delivered by Learned Additional District Judge, West Tripura,
Agartala, Court No.5 in connection with Case No.TA/17/2021, on
the ground that against two judgments one single appeal was not
maintainable.
7.
On the other hand, Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. S.M.
Chakraborty, appearing on behalf of the respondent-plaintiffs, drawn
the attention of the Court that the contention raised by Learned
Senior Counsel for the appellant-defendants cannot be accepted at
this stage because there was no perversity or irregularity in the
judgment delivered by Learned First Appellate Court. Learned Senior
Counsel Mr. Chakraborty further submitted that Section 99 of CPC
protects the case of the respondent-plaintiffs and there is no chance
of defeating the appeal in view of the said provision of Section 99 of
CPC. Learned Senior Counsel further submitted that at the time of
determination of the appeal, Learned First Appellate Court gave
specific observation regarding maintainability of one common appeal
against the judgment and decree passed in TS/105/2016 and
TS(CC)/6/2017. Learned Senior Counsel further submitted as alleged
by Learned Senior Counsel for the appellant-defendants, if there is
any deficiency of court fee in that case, there is no scope on the part
of the present appellant to be prejudiced in the appeal and
furthermore, in view of Section 149 of CPC, the issue regarding
deficiency of court fees is to be decided by the Court not by the
present appellant and in support of his contention, Learned Senior
Counsel referred one judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court
reported in AIR 1953 SC 419 [Narhari and others Vs. Shankar
and others], wherein in Para No.4 Hon'ble the Apex Court observed
as under:
“4. In the judgment of the High Court, though
reference is given to some of these decisions, it is
merely mentioned that the appellant relies on these
decisions. The learned Judges perhaps thought that
in the presence of the Hyderabad Judicial Committee
decision in „17 Deccan L R 322(A)‟, they need not
comment on these decisions at all. There is also a
later decision of the Judicial Committee of the State
in „Bansilal v. Mohanlal‟, 33 Deccan LR 603 (F-G),
where the well known and exhaustive authority of
the Lahore High Court in –„Mst. Lachmi v. Mst. Bhuli‟,
AIR 1927 Lah 289 (H), was followed. In the Lahore
case, here were two cross suits about the same
subject matter, filed simultaneously between the
same parties, whereas in the present case, there was
only one suit and one judgment was given by the
trial court and even in the first appeal to the Sadar
Adalat, there was only one judgment in spite of there
being two appeals by the two sets of defendants. The
plaintiffs in their appeal to the High Court have
impleaded all the defendants as respondents and
their prayer covers both the appeals and they have
paid consolidated court-fee for the whole suit. It is
now well settled that where there has been one trial,
one finding, and one decision, there need not be two
appeals even though two decrees may have been
drawn up. As has been observed by Tek Chand J. in
his learned judgment in –„AIR-1927 Lah 289(H)‟,
mentioned above, the determining factor is not the
decree but the matter in controversy. As he puts it
later in his judgment, the estoppels is not created by
the decree but it can only be created by the
judgment. The question of res judicata arises only
when there are two suits. Even when there are two
suits, it has been held that a decision given
simultaneously cannot be a decision in the former
suit. When there is only one suit, the question of res
judicata does not arise at all and in the present case,
both the decrees are in the same case and based on
the same judgment, and the matter decided concerns
the entire suit. As such, there is no question of the
application of the principle of res judicata. The same
judgment cannot remain effective just because it
was appealed against with a different number or a
copy of it was attached to a different appeal. The two
decrees in substance are one. Besides, the High
Court was wrong in not giving to the appellants the
benefit of Section 5 of the Limitation Act because
there was conflict of decisions regarding this
question not only in the High Court of the State but
also among the different High Courts in India.”
Referring the same, Learned Senior Counsel submitted that
where there is one trial, one finding and one decision, there need not
be two appeals even though two decrees may have been drawn up.
Here in the case at hand, by a common trial, both the title suit and
the counter claim was decided by the Learned Trial Court. So, in view
of the settled position of law, there need not be two separate appeals
be filed seeking redress.
8.
Learned Senior Counsel also referred another judgment of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court of India reported in (2014) 10 SCC 702
[Tajender Singh Ghambhir and another Vs. Gurpreet Singh and
others] wherein in Para Nos.8 and 11, Hon'ble the Apex Court
observed as under:
“8. The scheme of the above provision is clear. It
casts duty on the court to determine as to whether
or not court fee paid on the plaint is deficient and if
the court fee is found to be deficient, then give an
opportunity to the plaintiff to make up such
deficiency within the time that may be fixed by the
court. The important thread that runs through subsections (2) and (3) of Section 6 of the 1870 Act is
that for payment of court fee, time must be granted
by the court and if despite the order of the court,
deficient court fee is not paid, then consequence as
provided therein must follow.
11. The High Court was also in error in holding that
the deficiency in court fee in respect of the plaint
cannot be made good during the appellate stage. In
this regard, the High Court, overlooked the wellknown legal position that an appeal is continuation
of the suit and the power of the appellate court is
coextensive with that of the trial court. It failed to
bear in mind that what could be done by the trial
court in the proceeding of the suit, can always be
done by the appellate court in the interest of
justice.”
Referring the same, Learned Senior Counsel drawn the
attention of the Court, if it is found that there was deficiency of court
fee in securing the relief, in that case there is scope for paying the
deficient court fees and even the matter regarding deficient court fees
can also be decided during appellate stage also by the Learned
Appellate Court.
9.
Learned Senior Counsel Mr. Chakraborty again referred
another citation of Hon'ble Gauhati High Court reported in AIR 1994
Gauhati 12 [Kailash Singh Vs. Hiralal Dey], wherein in Para
No.14, Hon'ble Gauhati High Court observed as under:
“14. Section 99 is very clear that no decree shall be
reversed or substantially varied on the ground of
non-joinder or mis-joinder of parties or causes of
action or any error, defect or irregularity in any
proceeding not affecting the merit of the case or
jurisdiction of the court. Although according to Mr.
Khetri this section does not include signing and
verification of the plaint, I am of the opinion that the
expression “any error, defect or irregularity in any
proceeding in the suit” will also include signing and
verification of the plaint as laid down in Rules 14 and
15 of Order 6, C.P.C. In this connection attention of
this court has been drawn by Mr. Sarma to a decision
of the Punjab and Haryana High Court in Smt.
Mukhtiar Kaur v. Smt. Ghulab Kaur, AIR 1977 Punj &
Har 257. In that case, the plaint and the verification
was not signed by the plaintiff, but by his lawyer. But
the plaintiff in the witness box supported all the
averments made in the plaint. The court observed
that the counsel for the plaintiff was presumed to be
acquainted with the facts of the case. So the
verification of the plaint made by him can be
accepted. Moreover, it is a defect which only amount
to an irregularity and can be ignored for rejecting the
plaint. It was also held that legal position is that
want of verification has not the effect of making the
plaint void and it merely amounts to an irregularity.
Regarding signing of the pleadings although the High
Court recorded that decisions are not uniform, the
prominent view is that irregularity in signature of a
plaint is a mere defect of procedure and does not
affect the jurisdiction of the Court.”
Referring the same, Learned Senior Counsel submitted that in
view of the provision of Section 99 of CPC, there is no scope to
reverse the judgment delivered by the Learned First Appellate Court
for any error, defect or irregularity in any proceeding, not affecting
the merit of the case or the jurisdiction of the Court. Finally, Learned
Senior Counsel urged for dismissal of this appeal as no substantial
questions of law leans in favour of the present appellant of this
appeal.
10.
I have heard both the sides at length and perused the
judgment delivered by Learned First Appellate Court and also gone
through the citations referred by Learned Senior Counsel appearing
on behalf of the respondent-plaintiffs.
At the time of hearing Learned Senior Counsel for the
appellant drawn the attention of the Court referring Section 96 of CPC
which provides as under:
“96. Appeal from original decree.- (1) Save where otherwise
expressly provided in the body of this Code or by any other law
for the time being in force, an appeal shall lie from every decree
passed by any Court exercising original jurisdiction to the Court
authorized to hear appeals from the decision of such Court.
(2) An appeal may lie from an original decree passes ex parte.
(3) No appeal shall lie from a decree passed by the Court with the
consent of parties.
(4) No appeal shall lie, except on a question of law, from a decree
in any suit of the nature cognizable by Courts of Small Causes,
when the amount or value of the subject-matter of the original
suit does not exceed ten thousand rupees.”
From the aforesaid provision, it appears that appeal may be
preferred from every decree passed by any Court exercising original
jurisdiction. Here in the case at hand, the original title suit and the
counter claim were clubbed together in the same suit and both the
parties adduced common evidence and finally on conclusion of trial
Learned Trial Court delivered a common judgment and decree was
prepared accordingly.
11.
Now, the question which was raised by Learned Senior
Counsel for the appellant at the time of hearing that whether a single
common appeal was maintainable in the instant matter or not. In this
regard, Learned First Appellate Court at the time of delivery of
judgment relied upon and discussed the decision of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court of India in Premier Tyres Limited vs. Kerala State
Road Transport reported in AIR 1993 SC 1202 wherein in para
Nos.3 and 4 Hon'ble the Apex Court observed as under:
“3. The validity of this finding has been assailed by
Shri Raja Ram Aggarwal, the learned Sr. Advocate
appearing on behalf of the appellant. It is urged that
Section 11 of the Civil Procedure Code does not apply
as such. According to him since both the suits were
connected and decided by a common order the issue
in neither suit can be said to have been decided in a
former suit. Therefore, the basic ingredient of
Section 11 of the C.P.C. was not satisfied. The
submission derives some support from observations
in Narhari v. Shanker, that, 'even when there are two
suits it has been held that decision given
simultaneously cannot be a decision in the former
suit'. But this decision was distinguished in Sheodan
Singh v. Smt. Daryao Kunwar 1966 SC 1332, as it
related to only one suit, therefore, the observations
extracted above were not relevant in a case where
more than one suit were decided by a common order.
The Court further held that where more than one suit
were filed together and main issues were common
and appeals were filed against the judgment and
decree in all the suits and one appeal was dismissed
either as barred by time or abated then the order
operated as res judicata in other appeals, 'In the
present case there were different suits from which
different appeals had to be filed. The High Court's
decision in the two appeals arising from suits Nos.
77 and 91 was undoubtedly earlier and therefore the
condition that there should have been a decision in a
former suit to give rise to res judicata in a
subsequent suit was satisfied in the present case.
The contention that there was no former suit in the
present case must therefore fail'. In Shri Ramagya
Prasad Gupta v. Sri Murli Prasad, an effort was made
to get the decision in Sheodan Singh (supra)
reconsidered. But the Court did not consider it
necessary to examine the matter as the subject
matter of two suits being different one of the
necessary ingredients for applicability of Section 11
of the C.P.C. were found missing.
4. Although none of these decisions were concerned
with a situation where no appeal was filed against
the decision in connected suit but it appears that
where an appeal arising out of connected suits is
dismissed on merits the other cannot be heard, and
has to be dismissed. The question is what happens
where no appeal is filed, as in this case from the
decree in connected suit. Effect of non filing of
appeal against a judgment or decree is that it
become final. This finality can be taken away only in
accordance with law. Same consequences follows
when a judgment or decree in a connected suit is not
appealed from.”
Learned Trial Court further referred another judgment of the
Hon’ble Bombay High Court in Nilkanth vs. Sri Vidyanand in second
appeal No.464 of 2016 dated 03.05.2018 wherein in para No.27, the
said High Court observed as under:
“27. ..... It was held that in the facts of that case,
filing of one appeal where there was one trial and
one finding could not be said to be in contravention
of any provision of the code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
In that context, it does not appear that the ratio of
the aforesaid Judgment is that in every case where
there is a decree passed by a trial court decreeing
the suit and dismissing the counter claim, only one
appeal can be filed or that filing of two appeals
would be contrary to law.”
And finally Learned Trial Court relied upon judgment of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in Narhari (supra) and came to the
conclusion that one common appeal is maintainable when there has
been one trial, one finding and one decision.
12.
In the case at hand although the appellant before the
Learned First Appellate Court challenged the dismissal of the suit filed
by the plaintiffs but in the relief portion plaintiffs as appellant before
the Learned First Appellate Court prayed for setting aside the
judgment and decree of both the title suit and counter claim and
finally Learned First Appellate Court was pleased to modify the
judgment of the Learned Trial Court in respect of suit filed by the
plaintiffs now the respondent herein but uphold the judgment of the
Learned Trial Court in respect of the counter claim filed by the original
defendants now the appellant herein.
13.
The citations referred by Learned Senior Counsel Mr. S.M.
Chakraborty in this regard appears to be more significant and I do not
find any perversity or irregularity in the judgment delivered by the
Learned First Appellate Court regarding disposal of common appeal
against the judgment passed in TS/105/2016 and TS(CC)/6/2017.
14.
Further, I would like to refer the relevant provision of Section
99 of CPC which provides as under:
“99. No decree to be reversed or modified for error or irregularity
not affecting merits or jurisdiction.- No decree shall be reversed
or substantially varied, nor shall any case be remanded, in appeal
on account of any misjoinder or non-joinder of parties or causes
of action or any error, defect or irregularity in any proceedings in
the suit, not affecting the merits of the case or the jurisdiction of
the Court:
Provided that nothing in this section shall apply to non-joinder of
a necessary party.”
From the aforesaid provision it appears that no decree be
reversed or varied on the ground of any error, defect or irregularity in
any proceeding in the suit not affecting the merits of the case or
jurisdiction of the Court.
Here in the case at hand Learned Senior Counsel for the
appellant at the time of hearing could not place any materials before
the Court regarding any error defect or irregularity in the suit save
and except the plea that two separate appeals were required to be
filed but on bare perusal of the aforesaid provision and the citation
referred by Learned Senior Counsel of the Hon'ble Gauhati High Court
as stated above, I do not find any scope to take a reverse opinion,
which has been decided by the Learned First Appellate Court at the
time of delivery of judgment and the principle of citation referred by
Hon'ble Gauhati High Court also appears to be more significant for
decision of this present appeal.
15.
Regarding filing of deficient court fees, it appears that before
the Learned First Appellate Court, no such plea was taken by the
present appellant, rather, it appears that the issue regarding nonfiling of requisite court fees could not be raised before the Learned
First Appellate Court, and in view of Section 149 of CPC, there is
scope for filing of deficient court fees subject to the decision of the
Court.
The
respondent-plaintiffs
as
appellants
in
TA/17/2021
challenged the judgment of TS/105/2016, but in the relief portion,
they sought for setting aside the common judgment delivered by
Learned Trial Court in TS/105/2016 and TS(CC)/6/2017 and the
respondent-plaintiffs as appellants only determined the value of the
appeal in respect of TS/105/2016 and paid ad valorem court fee but
no court fees was submitted/deposited in respect of TS(CC)/6/2017.
However, at the time of hearing, Learned Senior Counsel referred one
citation
of
the
Hon'ble
Supreme
Court
in
Tajender
Singh
Ghambhir(supra) wherein Hon'ble the Apex Court clearly observed
that the Appellate Court also can exercise the same jurisdiction which
can be exercised by the Learned Trial Court in the proceeding of the
suit.
Here in the case at hand, it appears that although both the
judgment and decree of the TS/105/2016 and TS(CC)/6/2017 were
challenged by the respondent-plaintiffs as appellant in TA/17/2021,
but the appellant deposited ad valorem court fees only in respect of
the appeal filed against the judgment and decree in TS/105/2016,
although no separate court fees was submitted in TS(CC)/6/2017 by
the appellant now the respondent-plaintiff herein. So, the respondentplaintiffs needs to be deposited the additional ad valorem court fees of
similar amount which he deposited before the Learned First Appellate
Court at the time of filing of appeal under Section 96 of CPC within a
period of 2 months from the date of this judgment.
16.
At the time of hearing of argument, Learned Senior Counsel
for the present appellant could not place any satisfactory ground
before this Court for interference in this second appeal as because no
substantial question of law stands in favor of the present appellant.
17.
However, from the records of Learned First Appellate Court
and Learned Trial Court, it appears that although the Learned Trial
Court, by common judgment, disposed of both the main suit and the
counter claim, but passed a common decree, which in my considered
view, was not proper. Learned Trial Court, at the time of preparation
of decree, could prepare two separate decrees for the main suit and
the counter claim to avoid any confusion.
18.
So, after hearing of both the sides and also after going
through the citations as referred by Learned Senior Counsel for the
respondent-plaintiffs, I am of the considered opinion that the present
appellant has failed to make out any substantial question of law to be
decided in his favor, as such, there is no merit in the appeal and
accordingly, the same stands dismissed being devoid of merit.
19.
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant-defendant is
hereby dismissed.
No order is passed as to costs.
The
judgment
dated
22.07.2022
and
decree
dated
29.07.2022 delivered by Learned Additional District Judge, West
Tripura,
Agartala,
Court
No.5
in
connection
with
Case
No.TA/17/2021 is hereby affirmed and the same is accordingly
upheld.
The respondent-plaintiffs be asked to deposit the ad valorem
court fees of the same amount which they deposited before the
Learned First Appellate Court at the time of filing of first appeal within
a period of 2(two) months from the date of passing of this judgment.
Only in the event of deposit of balance ad valorem court fees, the
respondent-plaintiffs shall be at liberty to avail the benefit of the
decree passed by the Learned First Appellate Court in TA/17/2021.
With the aforesaid observation, the present appeal stands
disposed of.
Prepare decree accordingly.
Send down the records to the Learned Trial Court and the
Learned First Appellate Court along with a copy of this judgment and
order.
Pending applications(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Deepshikha
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2025.08.29
16:28:26 -07'00'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review