Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
AB No.61 of 2025
1. Sri Biswanath Deb,
Son of Sri Bhajan Deb,
Aged about 25 years
2. Sri Bhajan Deb,
Son of Sri Ashutosh Deb,
Aged about 52 years
3. Smt. Beauty Deb,
Wife of Sri Bhajan Deb,
Aged about 35 years
-All are residents of Chandinamura,
Near Netaji Club, P.S. West Agartala,
District: West Tripura, PIN:799 001
---Accused-Petitioner
-VsThe State of Tripura
---Respondent
For Applicant(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Ratan Datta, Adv.
Mr. Ankan Tilak Paul, Adv.
Ms. Saswati Nag, Adv.
Mr. Rajib Saha, Addl. P.P.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Order
20/08/2025
This pre-arrest bail application is filed by the accusedapplicants for granting them bail in connection with West Agartala
Women PS Case No.36 of 2025 for the offence punishable under
Section 85/80(2)/3(5) of BNS.
Heard Learned Counsel Mr. Ratan Datta along with Learned
Counsel Mr. A. Tilak Paul and Ms. S. Nag, Learned Counsel
appearing for the accused-applicants and Mr. R. Saha, Learned
Addl. P.P. appearing for the respondents.
As ordered earlier Learned Addl. P.P. has produced the CD
and also we have received the record from the Learned Trial
Court.
Taking part in the hearing Learned Counsel Mr. R. Datta first
of all drawn the attention of the Court referring the contents of the
FIR and submitted that the husband of the deceased victim has
already been granted bail by the Learned J.M. 1st Class (Court
No.6), Agartala, West Tripura in connection with Case No.2025
WAW 036 on 29.07.2025. The present applicants are the brotherin-law and in-laws of the deceased victim. Learned Counsel further
submitted that the deceased victim stayed separately in a rented
house owned by Sri Pradip Kumar Deb where the alleged
occurrence took place. So there is no scope to presume that the
present
accused-applicants
have
committed
the
offence. In
support of his contention Learned Counsel relied upon few
citations. Reliance is placed on one citation of Hon’ble Supreme
Court of India in Dara Lakshmi Narayana and Others vs. State
of Telengana and Another reported in (2025) 3 SCC 735 in
para Nos.25 and 26 Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as under:
“27. A mere reference to the names of family members in a criminal
case arising out of a matrimonial dispute, without specific
allegations indicating their active involvement should be nipped in
the bud. It is a well-recognised fact, borne out of judicial experience,
that there is often a tendency to implicate all the members of the
husband’s family when domestic disputes arise out of a matrimonial
discord. Such generalised and sweeping accusations unsupported by
concrete evidence or particularised allegations cannot form the basis
for criminal prosecution. Courts must exercise caution in such cases
to prevent misuse of legal provisions and the legal process and avoid
unnecessary harassment of innocent family members. In the present
case, Appellants 2 to 6, who are the members of the family of
Appellant 1 have been living in different cities and have not resided
in the matrimonial house of Appellant 1 and Respondent 2 herein.
Hence, they cannot be dragged into criminal prosecution and the
same would be an abuse of the process of the law in the absence of
specific allegations made against each of them.
28. In fact, in the instant case, the first appellant and his wife i.e.
the second respondent herein resided at Jollarpeta, Tamil Nadu
where he was working in Southern Railways. They were married in
the year 2015 and soon thereafter in the years 2016 and 2017, the
second respondent gave birth to two children. Therefore, it cannot
be believed that there was any harassment for dowry during the said
period or that there was any matrimonial discord. Further, the
second respondent in response to the missing complaint filed by the
first appellant herein on 5-10-2021 addressed a letter dated 11-112021 to the Deputy Superintendent of Police, Thirupathur SubDivision requesting for closure of the said complaint as she had
stated that she had left the matrimonial home on her own accord
owing to a quarrel with Appellant 1 because of one Govindan with
whom the second respondent was in contact over telephone for a
period of ten days. She had also admitted that she would not repeat
such acts in future. In the above conspectus of facts, we find that
the allegations of the second respondent against the appellants
herein are too far-fetched and are not believable.”
Referring the same Learned Counsel drawn the attention of
the Court that since in a case of this nature the family members of
the husband are implicated for which Hon’ble the Supreme Court
has considered the fact and observed that in such a situation there
is trend to implicate the family members to the prosecution and
urged for allowing the present applicants to go on bail in any
condition.
He also relied upon another citation of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court of India in Appasaheb & Anr. vs. State of Maharashtra
reported in AIR 2007 Supreme Court 763 wherein in para No.9
Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as under:
9. Two essential ingredient of Section 304-B IPC, apart from
others, are
(i) death of women is caused by any burns or bodily injury or
occurs otherwise than under normal circumstances, and (ii)
women is subjected to cruelty or harassment by her husband
or any relative of her husband for, or in connection with, any
demand for "dowry". The explanation appended to sub-section
(1) of Section 304-B IPC says that "dowry" shall have the
same meaning as in Section 2 of Dowry Prohibition Act, 1961.
Section 2 of Dowry Prohibition Act reads as under :"2. Definition of "dowry" - In this Act "dowry" means any
property or valuable security given or agreed to be given
either directly or indirectly(a) by one party to a marriage to the other party to the
marriage; or
(b) by the parent of either party to a marriage or by any other
person, to either party to the marriage or to any other person,
at or before or any time after the marriage in connection with
the marriage of the said parties, but does not include dowry or
mahr in the case of persons to whom the Muslim Personal Law
(shariat) applies.
In view of the aforesaid definition of the word "dowry" any
property or valuable security should be given or agreed to be
given either directly or indirectly at or before or any time after
the marriage and in connection with the marriage of the said
parties. Therefore, the giving or taking of property or valuable
security must have some connection with the marriage of the
parties and a correlation between the giving or taking of
property or valuable security with the marriage of the parties
is essential. Being a penal provision it has to be strictly
construed. Dowry is a fairly well known social custom or
practice in India. It is well settled principle of interpretation of
Statute that if the Act is passed with reference to a particular
trade, business or transaction and words are used which
everybody coversant with that trade, business or transaction
knows or understands to have a particular meaning in it, then
the words are to be construed as having that particular
meaning. (See Union of India v. Garware Nylons Ltd., AIR
(1996) SC 3509 and Chemicals and Fibres of India v. Union of
India, AIR (1997) SC 558). A demand for money on account of
some financial stringency or for meeting some urgent
domestic expenses of for purchasing manure cannot be
termed as a demand for dowry as the said word is normally
understood. The evidence adduced by the prosecution does
not, therefore, show that any demand for "dowry" as defined
in Section 2 of the Dowry Prohibition Act was made by the
appellants as what was allegedly asked for was some money
for meeting domestic expenses and for purchasing manure.
Since an essential ingredient of Section 304-B IPC viz. demand
for dowry is not established, the conviction of the appellants
cannot be sustained.
Further reliance has been placed in another citation of
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Dolat Ram and Others vs.
State of Haryana reported in (1995) 1 SCC 349 wherein in
para No.s 2 and 3 Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as under:
“2. In a case arising out of FIR No. 735 dated 8-11-1993,
relating to the alleged dowry death of Smt Sunita wife of Anil
Kumar, the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Rohtak granted
anticipatory bail to the parents and the brother of the husband
of the deceased Smt Sunita and directed that they be released
on bail on their furnishing bail bonds in the sum of Rs 10,000
each with one surety each of the like amount in the event of
their arrest to the satisfaction of the Arresting Officer. No bail
has however been granted to the husband Anil Kumar. The
State of Haryana filed a petition in the High Court of Punjab
and Haryana seeking cancellation of the anticipatory bail,
granted to the appellants by the Additional Sessions Judge,
Rohtak on 12-11-1993. The learned Single Judge of the High
Court by his order dated 8-9-1994, cancelled the bail
observing:
Dowry death is a serious matter and cannot be taken so
lightly. No positive finding has been recorded by the
Additional Sessions Judge in his order to the effect that the
respondents and the deceased were living separately. No
prima facie case is made out which could justify the grant of
anticipatory bail. To my view of thinking, concession of
anticipatory bail granted by the Additional Sessions Judge,
was totally uncalled for. The order dated 12-11-1993 is,
therefore, set aside and the respondents are directed to be
taken into custody."
The appellants are aggrieved of the cancellation of the
anticipatory bail, granted to them. Hence this appeal.
3. It appears to us that whereas the learned Additional
Sessions Judge was not justified in observing in the last
paragraph of his order while granting anticipatory bail "it
appears that possibly these accused-appellants have been
roped in falsely", at that initial stage, when possibly the
investigation was not even completed let alone, any evidence
had been led at the trial, the High Court also fell in error in
cancelling the anticipatory bail granted to the appellants for
the reasons, which have been extracted by us above. The
learned Additional Sessions Judge had noticed that even
according to the statement in the FIR, the appellants were
living separately from the deceased and her husband and that
the factum of separate residence was also supported by the
ration
card.
These
considerations
were
relevant
considerations for dealing with an application for grant of
anticipatory bail.”
Relying upon those citations Learned Counsel submitted that
considering the facts and circumstances there is no scope to
disallow the application for granting pre-arrest bail filed by the
applicants since the victim and her husband used to reside
separately and the husband of the deceased victim has already
been granted bail by the Learned Trial Court.
He also relied upon one citation of this High Court in Smt.
Sova Saha and Anr. vs. The state of Tripura in A. B. No.3 of
2023.
On the other hand, Learned Addl. P.P. countering the
submission made by Learned Counsel appearing for the applicants
drawn the attention of this Court that the investigation of the case
is in progress and from the statements of the witnesses so far
collected by I.O. up to this stage of investigation there is sufficient
materials
against
the
present
petitioner-accused
persons
regarding their involvement with the alleged offence prior to the
death of the deceased. So, at this stage Learned Addl. P.P.
submitted that there is no scope to consider pre-arrest bail
application filed by the present accused-applicants.
It was further submitted that as alleged by the Learned
Counsel for the applicants that the victim committed suicide but
since the investigation of the case is in progress. So at this stage
there is no scope to form an opinion as to whether the victim has
committed suicide or not or whether she has been murdered or
not. So Learned Addl. P.P. urged for dismissal of the bail
application filed by the applicants.
The prosecution story was set into motion on the basis of an
FIR laid by one Subal Das being the father of the deceased to O/C
West Agartala Police Station (Women) alleging inter alia that the
marriage of her younger daughter Kajal Das was solemnized on
17.02.2020 as per Hindu Marriage rites and customs. It was
further mentioned in the FIR that initially their marital relation was
very peaceful but after few days the husband and in-laws of her
daughter started causing physical and mental torture upon his
daughter. Further, his daughter gave birth to a son who is
presently aged about 10 months and a daughter who is aged
about 4 years. It was further mentioned that the accused person
started torturing upon his daughter on regular basis and they used
to drag his daughter along with her children outside the
matrimonial home and considering the matrimonial life of his
daughter they gave some money on the demand of her in-laws
and her husband. Even the mother-in-law of the deceased used to
cause torture upon the daughter of the deceased who was aged
about 4 years. After that, his grand-daughter was brought to his
residence owing to the torture inflicted upon her. It was also
mentioned that when his grand-daughter was hospitalized at GBP
Hospital, the accused persons left the hospital leaving his granddaughter and went to their house without treating her and finding
no alternative his daughter returned back to her parental house
with her children. After few days, the accused persons took his
daughter to her matrimonial house giving assurance they would
not cause any further assault to his daughter but on 14.07.2025
he came to know that his daughter has been found to be hanged.
According to him by way of pre-planned conspiracy the accused
persons killed his daughter by strangulating her and after killing
her left her in the toilet room for demand of dowry. These are the
sum and substances of the FIR laid by the informant.
I have heard the submissions of both the sides and perused
the citations referred by Learned Counsel appearing for the
applicants and also the Case Diary produced by the prosecution.
On perusal of the CD it appears that by this time the I.O. has
recorded the statements of some of the witnesses and the
informant as well as his family members. The I.O. also by this
time has collected the P.M. examination report. It is the admitted
position that the principal accused Bishal Deb was produced under
arrest to the court of Learned J. M. 1st Class on 16.07.2025 and
thereafter on 29.07.2025 he was released on interim bail. The
present applicants are in-laws of the deceased victim and brotherin-law. On perusal of the statements of the witnesses so far
recorded by I.O. up to the stage of investigation prima facie it
appears to this Court that there is no dispute on record in respect
of the marriage of the deceased victim with the principal accused
Bishal Deb. From the statement of witnesses so far recorded it
appears that there were some familical dispute amongst the rival
parties of this case. It is on record that due to familical unrest at
one point of time the victim left the matrimonial home and took
shelter to the residence of her father. From the statement of the
witnesses further it appears that the deceased victim and her
husband used to reside separately wherein the alleged incident
took place. Now whethre the deceased committed suicide or she
was killed or not, it is the matter of adjudication to be decided by
the Trial Court. The informant and his family members in course of
their statements made to I.O. almost reiterated the same version.
However, other independent witnesses also tried to support the
same version’. But surprisingly from the statements of the
witnesses so far recorded by I.O. nowhere I find the specific time
and date when the victim was subjected to cruelty by the alleged
accused persons and also nowhere I find when the alleged money
as raised by the prosecution was given to the alleged accused
persons. It is also not specifically mentioned on which dates, the
victim was subjected to cruelty by the accused persons. So it
appears that although witnesses of the prosecution supported the
story of causing physical assault upon the alleged victim by the
accused persons but they could not give any specific account
regarding the involvement of individual accused persons with the
alleged crime. Rather it appears that all the witnesses made a
confusing statement that the victim was subjected to torture by all
the accused persons. However, as the investigation of this case is
in progress so at this stage there is no scope to give any specific
observation regarding innocence of the accused persons with the
alleged crime which may be decided later on if charge-sheet is
filed during trial of this case. However, considering the materials
on record so far collected by the I.O. upto this stage of
investigation I do not find any scope to disallow the pre-arrest bail
application filed by the accused applicants.
So, considering all, after hearing both the sides it appears to
this Court that this is a fit case where the concession for granting
pre-arrest bail be allowed in favour of the accused applicants.
Accordingly, the accused-applicants may be released on bail
in the event of their arrest of their execution of bail bond of
Rs.50,000/- with one surety of like amount each, to the
satisfaction of the O/C of the concerned PS with the following
terms and conditions:
(i) that the accused applicants shall not leave the jurisdiction
of the O/C of the concerned PS without prior permission from the
O/C of the concerned PS.
(ii) that the accused applicants shall not make any attempt
to tamper the evidence on record of the prosecution.
(iii) that the accused applicants shall make themselves
available for interrogation before I.O. as and when called for, for
the sake of investigation of this case.
In case of violation of the conditions of the bail the I.O shall
be
at
liberty
to
approach
to
the
concerned
Court
for
dismissal/cancellation of the concession of pre-arrest bail granted
to the accused applicants.
With this observation this pre-arrest bail application stands
allowed and disposed of.
A copy of this order be supplied to Learned Counsel
appearing for the accused-applicants for information.
Return back the CD to the I.O. through Learned Addl. P.P.
Send down the record to the Learned Trial Court along with a
copy of this order.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Moumita
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2025.08.20 06:36:28
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review