Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WA No.174 of 2022
Sri Biswajit Nandi,
S/o. Sri Narayan Nandi, resident of village- Devipur (Kenania),
P.S.-Madhupur, P.O-Kamalasagar,
District: Sepahijala Tripura.
----Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Sri Ratan Das, S/o Late Umesh Das, resident of Kenania, P.S.-Madhupur,
District-Sepahijala Tripura.
2. The State of Tripura, represented by the Secretary, DWS, Government of
Tripura, Agartala.
3. The Executive Engineer, DWS, Sub-Division-Bishalgarh, DistrictSepahijala, Tripura, Pin-799102.
4. The Block Development Officer, Bishalgarh R.D. Block, DistrictSepahijala Tripura, PIN-799102.
5. The Pradhan, Devipur Gram Panchayat, Sub-Division-Bishalgarh, P.S.Bishalgarh, District-Sepahijala Tripura, PIN-799102.
----Respondent(s)
WA No.175 of 2022
Sri Biswajit Sarkar,
S/o. Sri Shefal Sarkar, resident of village Kenania,
P.S.-Madhupur, P.O.-Kamalasagar,
District Sepahijala Tripura.
----Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Sri Sanjay Paul, S/o Sri Hiran Paul, resident of Kenania, P.S.-Madhupur,
District-Sepahijala Tripura.
2. The State of Tripura, represented by the Secretary, DWS, Government of
Tripura, Agartala.
3. The Executive Engineer, DWS, Sub-Division-Bishalgarh, DistrictSepahijala, Tripura, Pin-799102.
4. The Block Development Officer, Bishalgarh R.D. Block, DistrictSepahijala Tripura, PIN-799102.
5. The Pradhan, Devipur Gram Panchayat, Sub-Division-Bishalgarh, P.S.Bishalgarh, District-Sepahijala Tripura, PIN-799102.
----Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. K. Pandey, Advocate
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. M. Debbarma, Addl. GA
Date of hearing & delivery
of judgment & order
:
01.08.2024
Whether fit for reporting
:
Yes
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.D. PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
The above two writ appeals involve similar and identical
questions of law and facts, and as such, these are taken up and heard together
for disposal with the consent of learned counsel appearing for the parties.
2.
From the notes of the Registry dated 24.01.2023, 27.05.2024 and
26.06.2024, it reveals that notice has properly been served upon the
respondent no.1 of both the writ appeals. When the matter came up before this
Court on 27.06.2024, it was noted that “…From the note dated 26.06.2024, it
appears that the respondent no.1 has received the notice. However, till today
he has not entered his appearance. For ends of justice, further opportunity is
given to the respondent no.1 to appear and contest the proceeding. List the
matter on 01.08.2024.” But till today, the respondent no.1, the writ petitioners
of both the writ appeals have not entered their appearance to participate in the
proceeding.
3.
Both the writ appeals have been filed by respondent no.5 in
WP(C) No.697 of 2020 and WP(C) No.699 of 2020. The respondent no.1, Sri
Ratan Das in WA No.174 of 2022 had filed a writ petition bearing WP(C)
No.697 of 2020 stating inter alia that while he was performing his duties as
Pump Operator, suddenly he was asked not to continue his duties and
consequently he was discontinued by the respondents no.2, 3 and 4 of the writ
petition. It was the further case of the writ petitioner i.e. the respondent no.1
in the WA No.174 of 2022 that he was not allowed to continue his duties as
Pump Operator w.e.f. the month of April, 2018. It was contended before the
learned Single Judge that after the result of Tripura Legislative Assembly
Election in the year 2018, the writ petitioner was obstructed by some
miscreants from performing his duties. The petitioner had informed the matter
to the official authorities over telephone and on 09.04.2018 he informed the
matter in writing to the Block Development Officer, but, they neither had
taken any action against the miscreants nor provided necessary arrangements
for performing his duties. It was further informed to the Block Development
Officer, Bishalgarh that the respondent no.5 i.e. Biswajit Nandi, the appellant
herein was engaged as Pump Operator in his place. Having pleaded thus, the
writ petitioner/respondent no.1 had prayed for following reliefs in his writ
petition:
“(i) issue notice upon the respondents,
(ii) issue rule calling upon the respondents to show cause as
to why a Writ of mandamus should not be issued directing the
respondent No.3 & 4 to provide necessary arrangement for
performing the duty as Pump operator in his place of posting,
AND/OR
issue a writ in the nature of mandamus directing the
respondent No.4 to sign the work report of the petitioner
treating the duty of the petitioner w.e.f. April 2018 till the
date of resume his duties,
AND/OR
Issue a writ of mandamus directing the respondent No.3 to
release the salary of the petitioner w.e.f. April 2018 and may
pass any other order/orders as your Lordship may deem fit
and proper.”
4.
The State-respondents contesting the writ petition contended
before the learned Single Judge that “the representations submitted by the
petitioners’ was forwarded to the Principal Secretary, Govt. of Tripura,
PWD(DWS) Department on 20.11.2018. Thereafter, the Chief Engineer, PWD
(DWS) by the communication under No.F.1(47)-CE/PWD/E/2018
dated
02.01.2019 addressed to the Executive Engineer, DWS Division Agartala-I/
Agartala-II/ Ambassa/ Kamalpur/ Kumarghat/ Dharmanagar/ Udaipur/
Belonia had requested all concerned to repair all the abandoned IRP at the
earliest possible time and to submit action taken report by 31 st January, 2019
for apprising the competent authority.” The respondent no.5, i.e. the appellant
herein could not appear or file any counter affidavit before the learned Single
Judge.
5.
The writ petitioner in WP(C) No.697 of 2020 contended before
the learned Single Judge that the respondents-State did not act upon his
representation, rather, verbally assured him that his prayer for allowing him to
resume his duties would be considered, but, ultimately there was no positive
result.
6.
Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties,
learned Single Judge disposed of the writ petitions in the manner as under:
“12. In this perspective, these writ petitions are disposed of with
the following directions:
(a) The petitioners shall be allowed to discharge their duties as
the Pump Operator forthwith.
(b) The Officer-in-Charge of the concerned police stations is
directed to give the necessary protection to the petitioners.
(c) The allegations as made by the petitioners regarding
obstruction made by the unruly persons from performing
their duties, shall be inquired into by the Block Development
Officer/s and after giving the reasonable opportunity to the
petitioners, the decision on the salary for the period which
has not been paid to the petitioners shall be taken up by the
Block Development Officers. If it is found that the petitioners
were resisted by the unruly villagers, their salary shall be
paid in full as the administration has totally failed to provide
the petitioners the due protection. However, if it is found that
the petitioners have been deliberately absenting themselves
from their duties, necessary action, in accordance with law,
may be taken by the competent authority i.e. Block
Development Officer.
(d) The entire exercise shall be completed within a period of
three months from today.
13. With the aforesaid observations and directions, all these writ
petitions stands disposed of.”
7.
When the matter has come up before this Court, we scrutinized
the records relating to the writ petitions. From the note of the Registry dated
02.02.2022, it is revealed that notice has properly been served upon
respondents no.4 and 5. The respondent no.5 in both the writ petitions are the
appellants herein. This fact was further reflected in the order dated 03.03.2022
passed by learned Single Judge of this Court. From the note of Registry dated
07.05.2022 in WP(C) No.697 of 2020 it is revealed that none of the
respondents had filed counter affidavit. So, the writ petition was disposed in
absence of counter affidavit vide judgment and order dated 10.05.2022.
8.
We have heard Mr. K. Pandey, learned counsel appearing for the
appellants. Also heard Mr. M. Debbarma, learned Addl. GA appearing for the
respondents-State.
9.
The respondent no.1 of both the writ appeals (the writ
petitioners) did not enter their appearance despite reasonable opportunities
provided to them. Since these writ appeals are concerned to the year 2022, we
have taken up the matters as these are listed for hearing today.
10.
Mr. Pandey, learned counsel for the appellants has submitted that
during pendency of the writ petitions, the appellants were not provided with
reasonable opportunity to participate in the writ proceeding. Mr. Pandey has
further submitted that the writ petitioners have no locus to file the writ
petitions as the post of Pump Operator is not a civil post. There is no
recruitment rule for the post of Pump Operators since no post of Pump
Operator was ever created under Article 309 of the Constitution of India.
Hence, the post of Pump Operator cannot be said to be a civil post. Learned
counsel for the appellants has placed reliance upon an order dated 03.07.2023
passed in WP(C) No.890 of 2022 titled as Sri Shyamapada Pal vs. The State
of Tripura and 12 Ors.
11.
It is the contention of the appellants herein as well as the
respondents-State that after the result of Tripura Legislative Assembly
Election held in the year 2018, the original writ petitioners i.e. the respondents
no.1 herein, were absenting from their duties and after waiting for a
considerable period, the appellants were engaged as Pump Operators in the
interest of the villagers to distribute/circulate water in the village. According
to learned Addl. GA, an enquiry was held and the original writ petitioners
were found to be unauthorizedly absenting themselves from their respective
duties without prior information to the authority concerned that caused the
stoppage of water supply in the village. In that situation, the Panchayats were
compelled to engage the writ-appellants as Pump Operators in the interest of
public.
12.
In a similar matter, one of the learned Single Judge of this Bench
(A. Lodh, J), while disposing the case of Sri Shyamapada Pal(supra)
observed that “It is settled proposition of law that a person having not held
civil post cannot seek mandamus or the court cannot exercise its discretionary
and extra-ordinary jurisdiction, as enshrined under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India. The petitioner may claim compensation in an
appropriate forum, if he feels that illegalities have been committed towards
him by the respondents.”
13.
It is no longer res integra that in the context of Articles 309, 310
and 311, a post denotes an office. A person who holds a civil post under a
State holds “office” during the pleasure of the Governor of the State, except
as expressly provided by the Constitution. A post under the State is an office
or a position to which duties in connection with the affairs of the State are
attached, an office or a position to which a person is appointed and which
may exist apart from and independently of the holder of the post. Again, a
post is an employment, but every employment is not a post. A casual labourer
is not the holder of a post. A post under the State means a post under the
administrative control of the State.[Ref: The State of Assam and Ors. vs.
Kanak Chandra Dutta, AIR 1967 SC 884(Five-Judge Bench)]
(emphasis supplied)
14.
In the instant cases, what we find that the respondent no.1(here-
in-after referred to as the writ petitioners, for convenience) of both the present
writ appeals have failed to substantiate that they were appointed by a State
authority. On scrutiny of the records, we find that the writ petitioners did not
submit any appointment letter or even engagement letters issued by any
authorities of the State. On query to learned counsel appearing for the writ
petitioners, it comes to fore that it is an admitted position that they were not
having any engagement letters. The writ petitioners also have not disclosed
under whose instruction they were engaged as Pump Operators. They also
failed to furnish any document to establish that the post of Pump Operator
exists in the department or under the relevant Panchayats. Added to it, the writ
petitioners have failed to establish that the posts they held are under the
administrative control of the State.
15.
In WP(C) No.697 of 2020, the petitioner, Sri Ratan Das has only
stated that by virtue of a resolution taken by Devipur Gram Panchayat he was
appointed on 01.01.2008, but no copy of such resolution has been submitted
by him. Moreso, it is not clear whether the resolution had fixed the
remuneration of the Pump Operator. In view of this Court, we are unable to
come to a finding that the writ petitioners have been able to establish that at
any point of time they had developed master-servant relationship with the
State-respondents. That apart, resolution taken by Panchayats cannot be said
to have any statutory force. In the considered view of this Court, such
engagement of the writ petitioners, can, at best, be said to be a service on the
basis of oral contract between them and the persons concerned who engaged
them.
(emphasis supplied)
16.
Another important feature is that the engagement of the writ
petitioners did not prescribe any definite rate of pay, which is one of the
essential components for a post in any service. Even assuming that the writ
petitioners were engaged by Panchayats on the basis of oral contract, then
also, it does not contemplate that the writ petitioners used to hold a civil post
as defined under Articles 309, 310 and 311 of the Constitution of India.
17.
At best, the writ petitioners may seek enforcement of the terms of
the oral contract that they might have entered with the persons engaging them,
but the remedy of Article 226 is unavailable to enforce such contract. To say it
otherwise, the writ petitioners cannot ask for constitutional remedy under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India and if they were aggrieved by any
conduct of the State-respondents, then, the appropriate remedy would be to go
for civil litigation claiming legitimate damage.
18.
We may profitably refer to the decision of the Supreme Court in
the case of Kulchhinder Singh and Ors. vs. Hardayal Singh Brar and Ors.,
reported in (1976) 3 SCC 828, wherein speaking for the Bench, Krishna Iyer,J
clarifying the concept of civil posts observed thus:
“11. There is no doubt that some of the legal problems argued by Sri
Ramamurthy deserve in an appropriate case jurisprudential study in
depth, although much of it is covered by authority. But assuming, for
argument's sake, that what he urges has validity, the present case meets
with its instant funeral from one fatal circumstance. The writ petition,
stripped of embroidery and legalistics, stands naked as a simple
contract between the staff and the society agreeing upon a certain
percentage of promotions to various posts or an omnibus, allembracing promise to give a quota to the existing employees. At its best,
the writ petition seeks enforcement of a binding contract but the neat
and necessary repellant is that the remedy of Article 226 is unavailable
to enforce a contract qua contract. We fail to see how a supplier of
chalk to a government school or cheese to a government hospital can
ask for a constitutional remedy under Article 226 in the event of a
breach of a contract, bypassing the normal channels of civil litigation.
We are not convinced that a mere contract agreeing to a quota of
promotions can be exalted into a service rule or statutory duty. What is
immediately relevant is not whether the respondent is State or public
authority but whether what is enforced is a statutory duty or sovereign
obligation or public function of a public authority. Private law may
involve a State, a statutory body, or a public body in contractual or
tortious actions. But they cannot be siphoned off into the writ
jurisdiction.
12. The controversy before us in substance will turn on the construction
and scope of the agreement when the claim to a quota as founded
cannot be decided in writ jurisdiction without going back on wellsettled guidelines and even subverting the normal processual law —
except perhaps in extreme cases which shock the conscience of the
Court or other extraordinary situation, an aspect we are not called
upon to explore here. We are aware of the wide amplitude of Article 226
and its potent use to correct manifest injustice but cannot agree that
contractual obligations in the ordinary course, without even statutory
complexion, can be enforced by his short, though, wrong cut.”
19.
After thoughtful consideration of the principles laid down here-
in-above, it can easily be said that the post of Pump Operator is not a civil
post. Furthermore, after scruitinizing the judgment and order passed in
connection with the instant appeals, it is found that the learned Single Judge
while disposing of the writ petitions has not considered the legal aspect
whether the post of Pump Operator is a civil post as contemplated under
Article 311 of the Constitution of India and in that situation, as to whether the
writ court can exercise its discretionary and extraordinary jurisdiction as
enshrined under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. Another aspect
which ought to have considered, but some way, escaped the notice of the
learned Single Judge was that, whether the original writ petitioners were
obstructed by miscreants or not, was purely a disputed question of fact, which
is beyond cavil of writ jurisdiction of this Court.
20.
On perusal of the records, we do not find any of such document
that the writ petitioners i.e. the respondent no.1 in both the above writ appeals
had ever lodged any complaint to the police station alleging that they were
obstructed by the miscreants from performing their respective duties since the
month of April, 2018. The writ petitioners have even not mentioned the names
of the miscreants in their writ petitions who hindered their performance of
duties as Pump Operators. So, in absence of disclosure of such facts, the writ
petition itself, according to this Court, appears to be frivolous.
21.
There is yet another important aspect that, in our opinion,
warrants brief discussion. Under the scheme of Panchayats as encapsulated in
Article 243 of Part IX of Constitution of India, “Panchayat” means an
institution of self-government constituted under Article 243B, for the rural
areas. The powers of a Panchayat are defined by the Constitution and relevant
State laws as in the State of Tripura it is governed by the Panchayat Act, 1993.
Generally, Panchayats have the authority to appoint staff, but only within the
framework of rules and regulations set up by the State government.
If the State government has not framed recruitment rule for a
particular post, in that case, Panchayat has no power or authority to appoint
any person. As a corollary, any appointment made without rules has to be
considered as illegal.
22.
In the instant case, the writ petitioners have failed to show that
the post of “Pump Operator” ever existed under the respondent-Panchayats or
was ever created by the State vesting a power upon concerned Panchayats to
fill up or appoint any one under it. Since the learned Single Judge had not
considered those important and material aspects, in our opinion, the judgment
and order passed by learned Single Judge cannot sustain. As such, in the
considered view of this Court, the reliefs granted and the directions passed
upon the State-respondents while disposing of the writ petitions by learned
Single Judge needs to be interfered with and it is interfered with.
23.
For the reasons recorded and discussed here-in-above, we find
merit in both the writ appeals and resultantly, both the writ appeals preferred
by the appellants stand allowed.
The judgment and order passed by learned Single Judge in
WP(C) No.697 of 2020 and WP(C) No.699 of 2020 stand set aside and
quashed.
JUDGE
Snigdha
signed
SAIKAT Digitally
by SAIKAT KAR
Date: 2024.08.28
KAR
15:39:53 +05'30'
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review