The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
17. In the result, it is hereby ordered that the claimant-petitioner is entitled to get compensation of ₹3,61,952/(Rupees Three lakh sixty one thousand nine hundred fifty two) only. The OP No.3 United India Insurance Co. Ltd., being the owner of the offending motor vehicle bearing Registration No. TR-03-3261 (Commander Jeep) is directed to make the payment of compensation in terms of Sec 168(3) of MV Act.,1988, to the claimant-petitioner within 30 (thirty) days from today along with interest thereon @ 7.5% per annum from the date of filing of claim petition dated
15. 02.2021 till payment/realization of the same. …….. ....................= [11] Aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the aforesaid judgment and award dated 18.08.2025, passed in Case No. T.S. (MAC) 12 of 2021 by the learned Tribunal, the appellant preferred the instant appeal before this Court seeking the following reliefs: <(1) admit the appeal; (2) call for the records from the Ld. Tribunal below; (3) issue notice upon the respondents; and (4) after hearing the parties would further be pleased enough to modify the impugned judgment and the awarded compensation of Rs.3,61,952/- (Rupees three lakhs sixty one thousand nine hundred fifty two) passed on 18.08.2025 by the Ld. Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal No.2, Gomati Judicial District, Udaipur in T.S. (MAC) 12/2021, to the extent of Rs.14,50,000/- or more, to the extent prayed by the appellants before the Ld. Tribunal otherwise the appellants would be highly prejudiced.......... …...................= [12] Mr. Arjun Acharjee, learned counsel appearing for the appellant submits that the appellant-claimant was a strong and energetic person and at the time of accident he was 33 years of age who used to earned Rs.20,000/- per month as Government servant under Education department and the alleged accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving by the driver of the vehicle. According to learned counsel due to the accident the cl…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAC. App. No.5 of 2026
Sri Biswajit Debnath. S/O. Sri Ajit Kumar Debnath Of Vill- Chaigharia,
Maharani, P.S. R.K.Pur, Udaipur, Gomati, Tripura.
…………Claimant/ Appellant.
VERSUS
1. Md. Ayoub Ali, S/O Sri Royaj Uddin Bapari Of West Bank of Amarsagar,
P.O & P.S- R.K.Pur, Udaipur, Gomati, Tripura
(Owner of TR-03-3261 Commander Jeep)
2. Md. Joynal Miah, S/O. Inush Miah of No.2 Fulkumari, P.O & P.SR.K.Pur, Udaipur, Gomati, Tripura.
(Driver of TR-03-3261 Commander Jeep).
3.
United India Insurance Company Ltd., Udaipur Branch,
Subhash Road, P.S. R.K.Pur, P.O- R.K Pur, Udaipur, Gomati Tripura
(Insurer of TR-03-3261 Commander Jeep).
4. ICICI Lombard General Insurance Company Ltd.
Kamakhya Tower 3rd Floor, Office No. 305/306, Christian Basty,
G.S.Road, Guwahati-781005.
(Insurer of TR-03-J-8229 Motor Bike)
……….Opposite parties/ Respondents
For the Appellant(s)
: Mr. Arjun Acharjee, Advocate
Ms. Moon Basu, Advocate
Ms. Arshita Dey, Advocate
For the Respondent(s)
: Ms. Ruma Majumder, Advocate
Mr. Bibek Banerjee, Advocate
Date of hearing and delivery of
Judgment & Order
: 26.03.2026
Whether fit for reporting
: NO.
__
HON’BLE JUSTICE DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD
J U D G M E N T & O R D E R(ORAL)
[1]
When the case is called, Mr. Arjun Acharjee, learned
counsel appears on behalf of the claimant appellant. Ms. Ruma Majumder,
learned counsel is present on behalf of respondents No.1 & 2.
[2]
This present appeal has been filed under Section 173(1) of
the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, by the appellant for enhancement of the
awarded compensation of Rs.3,61,952/- passed by the learned Member,
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal No.2, Gomati Judicial District, Udaipur by
the order dated 18.08.2025 in case No. T.S. (MAC) 12/2021.
[3]
The brief facts of the case of the claimant as
enumerated in the claim petition before the learned tribunal are that on
02.06.2020 at about 6.30 hrs while claimant petitioner was coming towards
Udaipur from Maharani by riding his motor bike bearing registration No.
TR-03-J-8229 and he reached near Satrifung School, then one Commander
jeep came from the opposite direction with an abnormal high speed driven in
rush and negligent manner dashed the motor bike of petitioner, as result the
claimant petitioner received grievous fracture injury in his chest and other
bleeding injuries all over his body. It was pleaded that soon after the
accident, the injured-claimant petitioner was taken to Gomati District
Hospital, Udaipur, by the vehicle of Fire Service and on 02.06.2020 he was
admitted at Gomati District Hospital, Udaipur and considering the gravity of
injuries on 02.06.2020 he was referred to AGMC & GBP Hospital, Agartala
and he was admitted at AGMC and GBP Hospital, Agartala, on 02.06.2020
and was treated up to 04.06.2020 as indoor patient. Again on 04.06.2020,
the injured was admitted at ILS Hospital for better treatment and treated up
to 08.06.2020 as indoor patient at ILS Hospital, Agartala. It was further
contended that at ILS hospital Several X-ray and medical examinations and
also ORIF with LCP for radius & ulna done under GA on 06.06.2020. On
08.06.2020, the injured was discharged from ILS Hospital with advise to
attend at Ortho O.P.D after 14 days. Accordingly the injured was attended at
Ortho O.P.D., of ILS Hospital, Agartala for long period and he was also
under treatment of several private doctors and the injured is continuing his
treatment as private patient. It is further pleaded that after prolong treatment
the injured did not recover from his injuries and he contended before the
learned trial Court that he had already spent about Rs. 3,00,000/- for
treatment purpose of the injured including cost of medicine, medical
examinations, fees of Doctors, fooding, lodging and transportation etc. and
an amount of about Rs. 1,00,000/- would expected to be spent for future
treatment of the injured.
[4]
On account of such road traffic accident, a complaint was
lodged with the O/C of R.K Pur PS, which was registered as R.K. PS Case
No. 88 of 2020, under Sections 279/338 of IPC and under Section
177/184/187 of the MV Act. The claimant-petitioner alleged that the
accident occurred due to the rash and negligent driving/riding by the driver
of vehicle bearing registration No.TR-03-3261 (Commander Jeep). The
claimant-petitioner also stated that at the time of accident he was aged about
33 years old and was earning ₹20,000/- per month as a Govt. Servant
(Education department) and claimed total compensation to the tune of
₹14,50,000/- for the injuries sustained by him in a Road Traffic Accident.
[5]
The Opposite party (in short referred as the OP) Nos. 1 & 2
[respondents No.1 & 2 respectively in the present appeal] being the owner
and the driver of the vehicle bearing registration No. TR-03-3261
(Commander Jeep), on receipt of notice appeared and contested the case by
way of filing Written statement, denying and disputing the alleged accident
and also denied the age, monthly income of the injured claimant petitioner
and it is pleaded that on the alleged date of accident dated 02.06.2020 the
vehicle bearing No.TR-03-3261(Commander Jeep) was driven by O.P no.2,
Joynal Miah having valid and effective driving license bearing no.TR-03
20070015545 and the vehicle was fit for plying. It was further pleaded that
on alleged date of accident the vehicle belonging to O.P no.1, is insured with
United Ins. Co. Ltd. vide Policy no. 1309023119P116029065
w.e.f
17.03.2020 till 16.03.2021 covering the date of accident dated 02.06.2020.
As such, if any compensation is awarded in favour of the claimant petitioner
that may be borne by its insurer i.e by. O.P no.3 United India
Ins.Co.Ltd.(respondent no.3 herein).
[6]
The OP No. 3 i.e. United Insurance Company Limited being
impleaded as insurer of the offending vehicle bearing registration No. TR03-3261(Commander Jeep), on receipt of notice, appeared and contested the
case before the learned trial Court by filing written statement and denied the
narration made in the claim petition and the manner in which the accident
was described to have taken place. They also denied the age, income and
avocation as well as the health condition of the injured at the time of
accident and it was further pleaded that in case of violation of any terms and
conditions of the insurance policy, O.P no.3 would not be held responsible to
indemnify the owner. The OP No. 3 further pleaded that O.P no.3, is not
liable to pay any compensation, until and unless it is proved that the person
on wheel was driving the alleged vehicle, having valid and effective driving
license.
[7]
The O.P no. 4, ICICI Lombard General Insurance Company
Ltd.(respondent No.4 herein) being impleaded as insured of the motor bike
bearing registration no.TR-03-J-8229 after receipt of notice appeared and
filed Written statement before the learned Court below and also stated that
the accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving the driver of the
vehicle bearing no.
TR-03-3261(Commander Jeep), as such O.P no.4.
cannot be held liable to make payment of any compensation in favour of the
claimant petitioner.
[8]
Thereafter, on the basis of the pleadings the following
issues were framed by the learned Court below on 29.08.2022:
(1)
Whether Sri Biswajit Debnath, S/O. Sri Ajit Kumar Debnath,
sustained injuries in a road traffic accident on 02.06.2020 at about 6.30 hrs
hours at Fulkumari near Satraifung School onUdaipur -Amarpur Road,
under R.K Pur, PS. due to rash and negligent driving by driver of the motor
bike bearing no. TR-03-J8229(motor Bike) and TR-03-3261(Commander
Jeep)?
(2)
Is the claimant-petitioner is entitled to be compensated under
Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. If so, to what extent and who shall be liable to pay
such compensation?
[9]
During trial, the claimant-petitioner Sri Biswajit Debnath,
appellant herein examined himself as PW.1 and he also exhibited some
documents on behalf of him which were as follows:
(1) Exhibit 1/1 to 1/4- Certified copy of FIR and ejahar.
(2) Exhibit 2/1 to 2/2- Certified copy of seizure list sheets.
(3) Exhibit 3/1 to 3/2- Certified copy of injury reports
(4) Exhibit 4 (series)- Certified copy of final report.
(5) Exhibit 5 ( series)- Original discharge summary.
(6) Exhibit 6/1 to 6/4- Original prescription.
(7) Exhibit 7/1 to 7/31- Original cash memos.
(8) Exhibit 8- Photocopy of RC of vehicle bearing registration no TR 03 J
8229, on comparing with the original.
(9) Exhibit 9- Photocopy of Insurance policy valid from 16-04-2019 to 1504-2024 of vehicle bearing registration no TR 03 J 8229 comparing with the
original.
(10) Exhibit 10- Photocopy of driving licence on comparing with the
original.
(11) Exhibit 11- Original discharge summary in 01 sheet.
(12) Exhibit 12/1 to 12/3 - Original prescriptions in 03 sheets.
(13) Exhibit 13/1 to 13/21- Original cash memos in 21 sheets.
On the other hand O.P no.2, the Joynal Miah driver of the alleged
vehicle bearing registration No. TR-03-3261 (Commander Jeep), examined
himself as OPW-1 and exhibited some documents which were as follows:1) Exhibit-A- Information regarding the vehicle bearing registration No. TR
03 3261(Commander Jeep) from the office of the District Transport Officer,
Gomati District, Udaipur.
2) Exhibit- B- Photocopy of driving license bearing No. TR 0320070015545
on comparing with the original.
[10]
Learned trial Court below on perusal of all the
relevant records and upon hearing the parties, decided the case by its
judgment and award dated 18.08.2025 passed in Case No. T.S. (MAC) 12 of
2021 in the following manner:
<.................O R D E R
17.
In the result, it is hereby ordered that the claimant-petitioner is
entitled to get compensation of ₹3,61,952/(Rupees Three lakh sixty one
thousand nine hundred fifty two) only. The OP No.3 United India
Insurance Co. Ltd., being the owner of the offending motor vehicle bearing
Registration No. TR-03-3261 (Commander Jeep) is directed to make the
payment of compensation in terms of Sec 168(3) of MV Act.,1988, to the
claimant-petitioner within 30 (thirty) days from today along with interest
thereon @ 7.5% per annum from the date of filing of claim petition dated
15.02.2021 till payment/realization of the same. …….. ....................=
[11]
Aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the aforesaid judgment
and award dated 18.08.2025, passed in Case No. T.S. (MAC) 12 of 2021 by
the learned Tribunal, the appellant preferred the instant appeal before this
Court seeking the following reliefs:
<(1)
admit the appeal;
(2)
call for the records from the Ld. Tribunal below;
(3)
issue notice upon the respondents; and
(4)
after hearing the parties would further be pleased enough to
modify the impugned judgment and the awarded compensation of
Rs.3,61,952/- (Rupees three lakhs sixty one thousand nine hundred fifty
two) passed on 18.08.2025 by the Ld. Member, Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal No.2, Gomati Judicial District, Udaipur in T.S. (MAC) 12/2021,
to the extent of Rs.14,50,000/- or more, to the extent prayed by the
appellants before the Ld. Tribunal otherwise the appellants would be highly
prejudiced.......... …...................=
[12]
Mr. Arjun Acharjee, learned counsel appearing for the
appellant submits that the appellant-claimant was a strong and energetic
person and at the time of accident he was 33 years of age who used to earned
Rs.20,000/- per month as Government servant under Education department
and the alleged accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving by the
driver of the vehicle. According to learned counsel due to the accident the
claimant was deprived from his earning income but, the learned tribunal
below failed to appreciate the same and passed the impugned judgment and
awarded the compensation of Rs.10,500/- (30 x 350) and Rs.4,900/- (14 x
350) only for loss of income which is illegal in the eye of law. Mr. Acharjee,
learned counsel for the appellant further contends that insofar as other
compensation heads are concerned including future treatment of the injured
appellant, the same are also very meagre and the same should be enhanced
by this Court. He, therefore, urges this Court to set aside/modify the
impugned order dated 18.08.2025 passed by the learned trial Court in Case
No. T.S. (MAC) 12 of 2021.
[13]
Heard and perused the evidence on record.
[14]
Upon hearing the submissions made at the Bar and on
consideration of the materials on record, this Court is of the opinion that
though it is contended that the claimant was a government servant drawing
Rs.20,000/- per month salary at the time of accident, no document with that
regard was produced before the learned trial Court. The appellant claimant
was given ample opportunity to produce evidences or to bring to the notice
of the learned tribunal if there had been any such documents regarding his
employment but, during trial the claimant failed to produce so. Now, the
appellant, by filing this appeal, has raised new issues which were not raised
before the learned tribunal. The contention raised by the learned counsel for
the appellant that the income of the victim was not taken into consideration
and the compensation awarded with regard to other heads also is very
meagre, is without merit, since the Tribunal has assessed the income of the
victim alongwith other compensation heads and passed the award on the
basis of the available records/documents and the surrounding circumstances,
which this Court finds to be reasonable and just.
[15]
Hence, this present appeal filed by the appellant is liable to
be dismissed and the impugned judgment & award dated 18.08.2025, passed
in Case No. T.S. (MAC) 12 of 2021 by the learned Tribunal needs to be
affirmed and upheld observing that the issues not raised before the learned
tribunal below cannot be adjudicated upon by this Court entertaining the
new grounds. Accordingly, the same is ordered.
[16]
With the above observations and directions, the present
appeal stands dismissed and hereby the same is disposed of. The impugned
order dated 18.08.2025, passed in Case No. T.S. (MAC) 12 of 2021 by the
learned Tribunal is hereby affirmed. As a sequel, miscellaneous
application(s), pending if any, shall also stand closed.
DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD, J
Sabyasachi.G.
SABYASACHI GHOSH GHOSH
Date: 2026.03.30 16:54:53 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review