Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA 28 OF 2022
Sri Biswajit Deb, son of late Ashutosh Deb,
resident of Matabari Tilla, Ompi Nagar,
P.O. Ompi Nagar, Sub-Division-Amarpur,
District-Gomati, Tripura.
...Defendant-appellant
Vrs.
Smt. Usha Rani Das, wife of late Sushil Das,
resident of Matabari Tilla, Ompi Nagar,
P.O. Ompi Nagar, Sub-Division:Amarpur,
District-Gomati, Tripura.
Present:
For the appellant(s)
…Plaintiff-respondent
: Mr. D.K.Daschoudhury, Advocate.
For the respondent(s)
: Mr. B. Banerjee, Advocate.
Date of hearing &
delivery of judgment
and order
: 30.09.2023
Whether fit for
reporting
: YES
HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Judgment & Order (Oral)
This is a second appeal under Section 100 of the Civil Procedure
Code,1908 [for short, the ―CPC‖] against the Judgment and Decree dated
04.04.2022, passed by the learned Additional District Judge, Gomati Judicial
District, Tripura in connection with Case No. TA 06/2018, whereby and
whereunder the learned first appellate court had reversed the judgment &
decree dated 28.06.2018, passed by learned Civil Judge (Sr. Division),
Udaipur, Gomati Judicial District, Tripura in connection with Case No. T.S.
40 of 2016.
2.
The plaintiff [respondent herein] instituted a suit for declaration
of right, title and interest along with a prayer for recovery of khas possession
and a decree for perpetual injunction against the defendant [appellant herein]
in the Court of learned Civil Judge, Sr. Division, Gomati Judicial District,
Udaipur, Tripura.
3.
The facts of the case, as projected by learned First Appellate
Court, may be reproduced here-in-below:
“The plaintiff’s (appellant herein) case, in brief, is that the suit
land described in the Schedule of the plaint is a land measuring 0.13
acres appertaining to Khatian No.1086 of C.S.Plot No.465, Hal Plot
No.676 under Mouja-Ompi Nagar which was originally belonged to
Shri Nagar Bashi Debnath S/o-Late Mahendra Ch. Debnath of Bijoy
Nagar, PS-Sidhai, District-West Tripura. The plaintiff purchased the
suit land from its original owner namely Shri Nagar Bashi Debnath by
a Registered Sale Deed vide No.1-264 dated 22-05-2007 at a
consideration amount of Rs.35,000/- and after the purchase plaintiff
got delivery of the possession from the vendor. According to the
plaintiff due to unintentional mistake of the scribe of the Deed the
boundary mentioned in the Deed was wrongly written though plaintiff
subsequently mutated her name in the ROR of the purchased land and
the land was recorded in the name of the plaintiff vide khatian
No.1086 of Mouja-Ompi. The plaintiff was possessing the suit land on
and from 10-05-2010 but defendant started spraying clouds about the
right, title and interest of the plaintiff over the suit land and further
declared that he would forcibly dispossessed the plaintiff. On 15-112020 at about 9:00 am the defendant along with hired people entered
into the suit land and dispossessed the plaintiff from the suit land
illegally. The plaintiff further alleged that as per her prayer the suit
land was demarcated by the Tahashildar, as per the order of the SDM,
Amarpur wherein the Tahashildar of Ompi Tahashil reported that the
suit land was under the illegal possession of the defendant. Under the
above facts the plaintiff filed this suit to declare the right, title and
interest over the Schedule land of the plaint and for recovery of khash
possession by evicting the defendant from the suit land by removing all
obstructions created therein along with cost of the suit.”
4.
Being summoned, the defendant appeared and contested the suit
by filing written statement and on the basis of the pleadings, learned trial
Court had framed the following issues:
I.
II.
III.
IV.
5.
Whether the suit is maintainable in its present form and nature?
Whether the plaintiff has right, title and interest over the suit
land mentioned in the Schedule of the plaint?
Whether the defendant is in wrongful possession of the suit
land?
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to get a decree as prayed for
with any other relief or reliefs?
On the basis of aforesaid issues, evidences were adduced by the
plaintiff side, but, the defendant did not adduce any evidence. Thereafter,
having heard the arguments of learned counsel appearing for the parties, the
learned trial Court dismissed the suit instituted by the plaintiff.
6.
Being aggrieved, the plaintiff has preferred first appeal before the
Court of learned District Judge, Gomati Judicial District and the said first
appeal was transferred to the Court of learned Additional District Judge,
Gomati for hearing. Learned Addl. District Judge after hearing recorded a
reversal decree vide judgment and decree dated 04.04.2022 and allowed the
appeal with the following findings:
―15.
In Sunil Das vrs. Babul Das, case No. RSA 32 of 2013 our
own High Court further observed in Para-14 that “………….. The
physical boundaries with efflux of time may change and unless
properly clarified it may create serious confusion at sometimes. As
such, it would be duty of the Civil Courts to prefer the description of
the physical boundaries as given referring to the settlement records.
The physical boundaries have their own advantages but when there is
incongruity between the reference by settlement records and the
physical boundaries, the physical boundaries may be kept aside for
purpose of identification of the land.”
16.
So, keeping in view the above position of law this Court is of
the opinion that where the suit property can be ascertained by survey
plot there is no bar to decree a suit on the basis of survey plots. In the
present case the plaintiff has properly mentioned C.S. plot No.465
corresponding to Hal Plot No.676 in the schedule of her plaint which
conformed with the settlement record vide Khatian No. 1086 i.e.
Exhibit1. Hence, this Court differ with the view of the learned trial
Court that the suit property is not identifiable for which the plaintiff
sought relief.
17.
In view of the aforesaid discussions, this Court finds that the
learned trial Court was in error and guided by some misconception of
law and thereby dismissed the suit of the plaintiff i.e. the present
plaintiff-appellant vide decree dated 03.07.2018 in TS 40 of 2016 over
the “Schedule C” land. Accordingly the judgment and decree dated
03.07.2018 passed by the learned Civil Judge (Sr. Divn.), Gomati
District, Udaipur in TS 40 of 2016 is hereby reversed being devoid of
merits. The right, title and interest of the plaintiff-appellant over the
suit land is hereby declared and she is entitled to recovery of khas
possession of the suit land by evicting the defendant therefrom. Hence,
the Appeal is allowed.
Considering the factual aspects of this case parties are
directed to bear their own costs.
Thus the appeal is hereby disposed of on contest.
Prepare decree accordingly.”
In view of the aforesaid judgment, decree was prepared.
7.
Feeling aggrieved, the appellant/defendant has preferred the
instant second appeal challenging the findings of learned first appellate Court
whereby the suit was decreed in favour of the respondent/plaintiff.
8.
At the time of admission of the instant second appeal, following
substantial questions of law have been formulated:
(i) Whether a sale deed without correction of
identification of land where the suit land is identified both by
survey number and boundary description which are
contradictory to each other held to be valid and can be relied
on?
(ii) Whether the report of the Tehshilder without proving it
by examination of the maker can be relied on as to the
identification of the suit land as proper evidence of
possession?
9.
Heard Mr. D.K.Daschoudhury, learned counsel appearing for the
appellant [the original defendant] and Mr. B. Banerjee, learned counsel
appearing for the respondent [the original plaintiff]. The parties will be
addressed here-in-below according to the original suit.
10.
During the course of hearing, Mr. Daschoudhury, learned counsel
appearing for the defendant has relied upon the findings of the learned trial
Judge wherein, learned Judge observed that the land was not identified
because of an error in mentioning the boundary in the sale deed.
11.
I have gone through the findings of learned trial Judge where he
discussed this issue at Para 7 of the judgment. According to me, learned trial
Court had totally misdirected himself. It is no more res integra that the
physical boundaries with efflux of time may change and unless properly
clarified it may create serious confusion in identifying the suit land. As such,
it would be the duty of the Civil Courts to prefer the description of the
physical boundaries as given in reference to the settlement records. The
physical boundaries have their own advantages, but, when there is incongruity
between the reference of settlement records and the physical boundaries, the
physical boundaries may be kept aside for purpose of identification of the
land.
12.
In the context of the present case, Order VII, Rule 3 of CPC may
be reproduced, which reads as under:
―3.Where the subject-matter of the suit is immovable
property—Where the subject-matter of the suit is immovable property, the
plaint shall contain a description of the property sufficient to identify it,
and, in case such property can be identified by boundaries or numbers in
a record of settlement or survey, the plaint shall specify such boundaries
or numbers.‖
13.
On plain reading of the above provisions, it emerges that a
property can be identified either by a boundary or by any other specific
description. Learned first appellate Court in his findings had referred to the
decision of Subhaga & Ors. Vrs. Shoba & Ors., (2006) 5 SCC 466, wherein
the Supreme Court held that –“a property can be identified either by boundary
or by any other specific description is well established.”
14.
In the case of Monoranjan Dutta Vrs. Narayan Dhar, (2007) 2
GLR 593, the Gauhati High Court at Para 10 has held that –
―Admittedly, in the instant case, no such boundary or
number of the record of settlement or survey is provided by the plaintiff
in the plaint. Now, the question is to whether the provisions of Order 7,
Rule 3 is to be interpreted as a mandatory one, non-compliance of
which would be fatal to the validity of the decree. Order 7, Rule 3 has
been amended by the High Court by adding certain portion at the end of
the Rule like that of the amendment made by the Calcutta High Court,
which reads as follows:“and where the area is mentioned, such description shall
further state the area according to the notation used in the record of
settlement or survey, with or without, at the option of the party, the
same area in terms of the local measures.”
In fact the said amendment of the Rule was originally
made by the Calcutta High Court and the same is continuing even after
creation of the Gauhati High Court, covering as of Calcutta High
Court.”
15.
Again, I may profitably refer the case of Zarif Ahmaed Vrs.
Mohd. Farooq, (2015) 13 SCC 673, where the Supreme Court has held that –
Object of Order VII, Rule 3 is that the description of the property must be
sufficient to identify it. The property can be identifiable by boundaries or by
number in a public record of settlement or survey. It can be described even by
plaint map showing the location of the disputed immovable property.
16.
Applying the aforesaid principles in the present case, it is seen
that the suit land is clearly identifiable by mentioning the survey plot numbers
and there is no confusion in it. When the land can be clearly identified, then,
the principle that boundary will prevail over the plot numbers, when there is
contradiction in mentioning the plot numbers and the boundary, in that case,
the principle that boundary will prevail over the plot numbers will not apply.
The principle that the boundary will prevail over the plot numbers, will be
applicable only when it is not possible to identify the land by the survey plot
numbers, and there is apparent contradiction between the plot numbers and the
boundary. As I said earlier, in the present case, the plaintiff has been able to
establish the correctness of the plot numbers in his plaint which conform the
plot numbers mentioned in her sale deed making the suit land easily
identifiable.
17.
In the above conspectus, I find no infirmity in the findings of the
learned First Appellate Court in taking a view different than that of the view
of the learned Trial Court thereby confirming the judgment and decree passed
by learned First Appellate Court. As a corollary, the instant second appeal
stands dismissed.
JUDGE
signed by SANJAY GHOSH
SANJAY GHOSH Digitally
Date: 2023.10.19 15:50:52 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review