Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RFA No.18 of 2024
1. Sri Biswajit Bhattacharjee
S/O Lt. (Dr.) Bhaba Rn. Bhattacharjee
Resident of Krishnanagar, Thakurpalli Road,
Agartala, PS West Agartala, District West Tripura.
------ Plaintiff-Appellant
Versus
1. Smt. Maya Bardhan @ Maya Rani Bardhan (dead)
W/O Lt. Nalini Mohan Bardhan
(Struck out as per order dated 16-03-2016)
2. Sri Apu Bardhan
S/O Lt. Nalini Mohan Bardhan
3. Sri Tipu Bardhan
S/O Lt. Nalini Mohan Bardhan
4. Sri Debabrata Bardhan
S/O Lt. Nalini Mohan Bardhan
All are residents of Gakulnagar, PS Bishalgarh,
PO Sekerkot, District Sepahijala Tripura
5. Smt. Sima Bardhan (dead)
D/O Lt. Nalini Mohan Bardhan
(Struck out as per order dated 07-05-2016)
6. Smt. Dipa Sarkar (Chowdhury)
W/O Sri Litan Chowdhury
7. Smt. Rama Bhowmik (Chowdhury)
W/O Sri Debajit Chowdhury
8. Smt. Anita Chowdhury
W/O Sri Jishnu Chowdhury
All are of Bikramnagar, PS Amtali, District West Tripura
9.
Smt. Suparna Das (Sarkar)
W/O Sambhunath Sarkar
10. Sri Kripankar Chakraborty
S/O Ashutosh Chakraborty
Resident of Joynagar, Middle Road Agartala,
District West Tripura
11. Smt. Shila Chowdhury (Das)
W/O Bijan Kr. Das
12. Sri Suklab Roy
S/O Gauranga Ch. Roy
13. Sri Pradip Chakraborty
S/O Haradhan Chakraborty
14. Sri Uttam Hazari
S/O Gopal Hazari
15. Sri Haripada Natta Bhowmik
S/O Pramod Ch. Natta Bhowmik
16. Sri Haripada Debnath
S/O Birendra Debnath
17. Smt. Mukul Rani Deb
W/O Sankar Ch. Deb
18. Sri Rajkumar Bhuiya
S/O Iswarchandra Bhuiya
19. Sri Narayan Paul
S/O Ananta Paul
20. Sri Sibu Das
S/O Laxmi Kanta Das
21. Smt. Mira Ghosh
D/O Nithun Ghosh
22. Sri Bidyut Chowdhury
S/O Hamendra Chowdhury
23. Sri Dilip Ch. Deb
S/O Debendra Ch. Deb
24. Smt. Sushmita Deb (Sarkar)
W/O Kamal Kanti Sarkar
25. Sri Rajkumar Bhuiya
S/O Iswar Bhuiya
26. Sri Bijoy Kr. Sharma
S/O Rajmohan Sharma
27. Sri Rakesh Bhuiya
S/O Iswar Bhuiya
All are residents of Village Gakulnagar
PO Sekerkote, PS Bishalgarh, District Sepahijala, Tripura
------ Defendant-Respondents
28. Sri Partha Pratim Chakraborty
S/O Lt. Prabir Chakraborty
Resident of Krishnanagar, Thakurpalli Road
Agartala, PS West Agartala, District West Tripura.
------ Proforma Defendant-Respondents
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. Deba Ranjan Chowdhury, Sr. Adv,
Mr. Dipak Deb, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Abhijit Sengupta, Adv,
Date of hearing
:
25.04.2025
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
16.05.2025
Whether fit for
reporting
:
YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This first appeal under Section 96 of CPC is filed challenging
the judgment dated 13.06.2024 and consequential decree dated
19.06.2024 delivered by Learned Civil Judge (Senior Division),
Sepahijala District, Sonamura in connection with TS No.107 of 2015.
By the said judgment and decree Learned Trial Court has been
pleased to dismiss the suit preferred by the present appellant.
2.
Heard Learned Senior Counsel Mr. Deba Ranjan Chowdhury
assisted by Learned Counsel Mr. Dipak Deb appearing on behalf of the
appellant and also heard Learned Counsel, Mr. Abhijit Sengupta
appearing on behalf of the contesting respondents.
3.
Before proceeding with the merit of the appeal let us discuss
about the subject matter of the dispute amongst the rival parties.
According to the appellant-plaintiff, the suit land as described in the
schedule of the plaint along with other lands was originally owned by
one Colonel Raghubir Chandra Kochhar who purchased the same from
one
Nalini
Mohan
Bardhan,
the
predecessor-in-interest
of
the
contesting defendants No.1 to 5, and started possessing the same
after having its mutation which created in Khatian No.2065 in favour
of said Kochhar in the year 1970. Thereafter, said Raghubir Chandra
Kochhar in the year 1975 transferred his entire purchased land in
favour of one Prabir Chakraborty i.e. the father of pro-defendant
No.28 by executing one registered sale deed bearing No.I-5230 dated
26.04.1975 and accordingly said Prabir Chakraborty was inducted into
the possession of the said land. Dr. Bhaba Ranjan Bhattacharjee i.e.
the father of the appellant-plaintiff assisted financially to said Prabir
Chakraborty
in
purchasing the
aforementioned land,
so
Prabir
Chakraborty bequeathed his entire purchased land in favour of the
appellant-plaintiff by execution of one registered WILL vide no. III138 dated 19.05.2003. But after the execution of the said WILL in
favour of the appellant-plaintiff, the father of pro-defendant No.28
namely Prabir Chakraborty further transferred certain portion of land
out of the bequeathed land by execution of two registered sale deeds
vide No. I-264 and I-265 on 07.01.2004. During the revisional
survey, the entire land received by the plaintiff from the father of prodefendant No.28 by dint of registered WILL dated 19.05.2003 was
declared as 'Jotebriddhi' and the said land acquired the quantum of
2.29 acres. After the transfer of certain portion of the bequeathed
land measuring 2.29 acres by the father of pro-defendant No.28
Prabir Chakraborty, the remaining land left 2.17 acres and the father
of the plaintiff was inducted into the possession of the same.
Thereafter,
on
01.01.2005
the
father
of
pro-defendant
No.28
executed a registered Codicil vide No.I-175 in favour of the plaintiff
whereby he affirmed the bequeath of the land measuring 2.17 acres
in his favour. Unfortunately during his lifetime father of the prodefendant No.28 namely Prabir Chakraborty could not obtain his
name mutated in respect of his purchased land from the original
owner Col. Ragubir Chandra Kochhar and the record of rights of his
purchased land stood remained in the name of Col. Ragubir Chandra
Kochhar. After taking over the possession of the land as mentioned in
Schedule- A by the father of the plaintiff by dint of registered WILL
vide No.III-138 dated 19.05.2003 from the father of the prodefendant No.28, a probate proceeding under Section 276 of the
Indian Succession Act, 1925 was instituted to obtain probate of the
said WILL which was registered as case no. Misc(Probate) 07 of 2005.
Thereafter, as per the judgment and order dated 16.01.2008 passed
in connection with case No. Misc. (Probate) 07 of 2005, Learned Addl.
District Judge, Court No.2, West Tripura, Agartala was pleased to
grant Probate Certificate for the said WILL. After obtaining the
Probate Certificate when the appellant-plaintiff applied for mutation of
the land as mentioned in Schedule of the plaint that time his prayer
for mutation was dismissed by the Revenue Officer on the ground that
the said land has already been recorded in the names of the
defendant No.1 and others in RS Khatian No.316/2 appertaining to
C/S plot No.1956 corresponding to R/S plot No.2101. According to the
appellant-plaintiff, the creation of Khatian No.316/2 in favour of the
defendant No.1 and others by the Revenue Authority is illegal because
all along the suit land remained under the possession of Col. Raghubir
Chandra Kochhar, Prabir Chakraborty and the father of the plaintiff on
the strength of their respective deeds. Therefore, challenging the
creation of Khatian No.316/2, the appellant-plaintiff filed one petition
under Section 95 of the TLR & LR Act, 1960 before the District
Collector,
Sepahijala
which
was
registered
as
Revenue
Case
No.250/2006. In the said proceeding bearing case No.Revenue Case
250/2006, the District Collector, Sepahijala directed for field inquiry in
respect of land as mentioned in Schedule-A of the plaint by the DCM,
Bishalgarh and in that proceeding DCM, Bishalgarh had submitted a
field inquiry report in favour of the defendants. Thereafter on
12.07.2013 the District Collector, Sepahijala had disposed of the
application filed by the appellant-plaintiff under Section 95 of TLR &
LR Act, 1960 with direction to maintain status quo of the revisional
survey considering the field inquiry report. In the order dated
12.07.2013 the District Collector, Sepahijala suggested the plaintiff to
approach to the Revenue Authority afresh for mutation of the suit
land. Thereafter, fresh application for mutation was filed before the
concerned
Revenue
No.MR20130423.
Officer
Accordingly
which
notices
was
were
registered
as
case
issued
upon
the
defendants of that proceeding. On the date of the institution of the
suit the mutation proceeding was pending before the Revenue Officer.
But the issuance of notice by the Revenue Officer in the fresh
mutation proceeding had infuriated the defendants and since then
they were trying to dispossess the plaintiff from the suit land. During
the pendency of the suit before the Court and also taking advantage
of the functioning of the Court paralyzed due to the imposition of
Covid-19 lock-down, defendant Nos.9, 10 & 19 started construction of
building over the suit land specifically described in Schedule B1, B2
and B3 which are part of the land as mentioned in Schedule-A of the
plaint since 15.11.2019 till 20.08.2020. Thus they have dispossessed
the appellant-plaintiff from a portion of land as mentioned in
Schedule-A of the plaint as mentioned in Schedule B1, B2 and B3.
After that, the appellant-plaintiff filed the suit seeking declaration of
right, title, interest and possession over the land as mentioned in
Schedule-A of plaint, confirmation of possession, cancellation of
Khatian vide No.316/2, recovery of khas possession of the land as
mentioned in Schedule B1, B2 and B3 and also permanent injunction
over the remaining portion of land as mentioned in Schedule- A of the
plaint.
4.
Initially the suit was filed against the five principal defendants
and one proforma defendant. The pro-defendant No.28 was originally
pro-defendant No.6 but later on as per order dated 16.03.2016 the
name of the defendant No.1 Smt. Maya Bardhan was struck off from
the cause title of the plaint on account of her death in view of the
provision provided under Order I Rule 10(2) of CPC as her legal heirs
were already impleaded in the suit as defendant Nos.2 to 5.
Thereafter, as per order dated 07.05.2016 the name of the defendant
No.5 Smt. Sima Bardhan was also struck off from the cause title of
the plaint in view of the provision provided under Order I Rule 10(2)
of CPC on account of her death.
According to the appellant-plaintiff, after institution of the suit
when summons were issued upon original defendant Nos.1 to 5, then
a written statement was jointly filed by the defendant Nos.2 to 4
contesting the suit on 16.03.2016. Later on, as per order dated
10.02.2017 and based on the pleadings of the defendant Nos.2 to 4,
defendants No.6 to 8 were added in the suit. Thereafter, the said
defendants No.6 to 8 have jointly filed a written statement on
08.05.2017 contesting the suit. On the basis of pleadings of the
defendant No.6 to 8 in their written statement, defendant Nos.9 to 27
came to be added in the suit as per order dated 08.09.2017 passed in
the suit in view of the provision provided under Order 1 Rule 10 (2) of
CPC. Thereafter, after the addition of defendant Nos. 9 to 27 in the
suit, written statement was jointly filed by the defendant No.9, 11, 14
to 17, 19, 20 and 22 on 24.04.2018. Similarly, the defendant No.10
has singularly filed his written statement on 01.09.2018. No written
statement was filed by the defendant Nos.12, 13, 18, 21 and 23 to 27
and pro-defendant No.28. So, by order dated 04.10.2018 the
defendant No.12, 13, 18, 21 & 23 to 27 were barred to file the written
statement in the suit due to expiry of statutory period of 90 days as
required under Order VIII Rule 1 of CPC.
After that, on 17.12.2020 the appellant-plaintiff had filed an
application under Order VI Rule 17 of CPC seeking leave to amend the
plaint for the purpose of insertion of some new facts, cause of action
and also for specific relief against the defendant Nos.9, 10 and 19.
The said application was registered as case No.Civil Misc. (J) 04 of
2020 and vide order dated 29.01.2022, the same petition was
allowed. Accordingly, the plaint was amended. On 02.03.2022
amended
plaint
was
submitted
by
the
appellant-plaintiff
and
additional court fee was paid and after filing of amended plaint,
defendant Nos.9, 19 jointly filed their additional written statement on
05.04.2022. Similarly, the defendant No.10 also filed additional
written statement on 05.04.2022.
According to the defendant Nos.2, 3 & 4 their predecessor
namely Nalini Mohan Bardhan was the original owner and possessor of
the said land measuring 2.29 acres appertaining to C/S plot No.1956
recorded in C/S Khatian No.216 but after his death, the defendant
Nos.1-5 became the joint owners and possessors of the aforesaid land
and on application for mutation, the record of rights was also
prepared in their name in Khatian No.316/2 reflecting their possession
over
2.29
acres
of
land
appertaining
to
C/S
Plot
No.1956
corresponding to R/S plot No.2101. After the creation of the record of
rights, the said defendant Nos.2 to 4 transferred land measuring 2.21
acres out of 2.29 acres in favour of the defendant Nos.6 to 8 by
executing the registered sale deed vide No.I-670 dated 05.08.2013 on
consideration money amounting to Rs. 30,40,000/- and accordingly,
possession was handed over to them and as per due process of
mutation, R/S Khatian No.2396 reflecting the transfer of land
measuring 2.21 acres was created in their favour. It was further
submitted by defendant Nos.2 to 4 that this land was further
transferred by the defendant Nos.6 to 8 by sale in favour of other
purchasers
and
all
those
purchasers
were
duly
inducted
into
possession of the purchased land by raising boundary pillars,
commissioning of water and electricity connection. When the plaintiff
filed an application under Section 95 of the TLR & LR Act, 1960 before
the District Collector, Sepahijala for correction of records by removing
the names of defendant Nos.1 to 5 by cancelling khatian No.316/2,
the then District Collector after considering the reports submitted by
the Director of Land Record and Settlement directed to maintain
status-quo of the Revisional Survey records. Later on, when the
appellant-plaintiff prayed for mutation afresh, that time his prayer
was dismissed. It was further submitted by defendant Nos.2 to 4 that
their predecessor never transferred any land in favour of Col. Ragabir
Chandra Kochhar and thereafter said Kochhar did never transferred
the land to any other person and furthermore, said kochhar had no
title over the land.
The defendant Nos.6 to 8 in their written statement submitted
that the predecessor of the defendant Nos.1-5 Nalini Mohan Bardhan
was the original owners-in-possession of the suit land and he never
transferred the land in favour of Col. Raghubir Chandra Kochhar. The
defendant Nos.6 to 8 have completely supported the pleadings of the
defendant Nos.2 to 4 and admitted that they have purchased land
measuring 2.21 acres out of the total land measuring 2.29 acres from
them by dint of the registered sale deed bearing No.I-670 dated
05.08.2013 and also obtained record of rights vide Khatian No.2396 in
their favour. It was further submitted by the said defendants that
they have further transferred different portions of their purchased
land to 21 other bonafide purchasers by executing different registered
sale deeds. As such, they prayed for dismissal of the suit.
The defendant No.10 also contested the suit by filing written
statement denying the assertions of the appellant-plaintiff in the
plaint. He submitted that he has purchased a portion of suit land from
the defendant Nos.6 to 8 by dint of the registered sale deed No.I-654
dated 14.08.2014 and prior to purchase, he had conducted search
about the title of the land when it was found that the defendant
Nos.6-8 have/had valid title over the suit land. He also obtained
mutation, domestic electricity connection and water supply from the
concerned authority and he also relied upon the pleadings of the
defendant Nos.1 to 8.
The defendant Nos.9, 11, 14, 15, 16, 17, 19, 20 & 22 have
also filed their written statement. It was submitted that the defendant
No.9 purchased a portion of suit land by dint of registered sale deed
No.I-881 dated 05.08.2015 at the consideration sum of Rs. 2 lakhs
from defendant Nos.6 to 8 and after purchase he has applied for
mutation and accordingly the same was granted in Khatian No.3092 in
his favour. Similarly, the defendant Nos.14, 15, 16, 19, 20 & 22 have
purchased different other portions of the land from the defendant
Nos.6 to 8 by dint of different registered sale deeds and submitted the
details of their title deeds but the defendant Nos.11, 16 and 17 have
not mentioned the details of their title deeds in their written
statement. They also submitted that they are the bonafide purchaser
of the different portion of land. Hence, by the written statement the
said defendants prayed for dismissal of the suit with costs.
The defendant Nos.9, 10 and 19 have specifically denied all
the averments made by the appellant-plaintiff in their additional
written statements with regard to the new facts alleged at paragraph
No.16(a) added by the appellant-plaintiff by way of amendment of his
pleadings.
5.
Upon considering the pleadings of the parties, Learned Civil
Judge(Sr. Div), West Tripura, Agartala vide order dated 01.03.2009
framed some issues and thereafter considering the pleadings in the
amended plaint as well as the written statements, some additional
issues were framed by the Court on 05.08.2022. For the sake of
convenience, I would like to refer herein below the issues formulated
in the suit by the Learned Court below:
ISSUES
i)
Whether the suit is maintainable in its present
form and nature?
ii)
Whether plaintiff has cause of action in the suit?
iii)
Whether plaintiff is entitled to the decree for
declaration
of
right,
title,
interest
and
confirmation of possession over the suit land?
iv)
Whether plaintiff is entitled for permanent
injunction, restraining defendants, their men and
agents from entering into the suit land?
v)
Whether the plaintiff is entitled for decree as
prayed for in the suit?
vi)
What other relief/reliefs the parties are entitled
in the suit?
ADDITIONAL ISSUES
i)
Whether the defendant No.9, 10 and 19 during
the period from 15.11.2019 till 20.08.2020 had
illegally dispossessed the plaintiff from the
plot(s) of land described in schedule B1, B2 and
B3 to the plaint and constructed building and
other structures thereon?
ii)
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to recovery of the
plot(s) of land described in schedule B1, B2 and
B3 to the plaint?
To substantiate the issues, the parties in dispute have
adduced oral/documentary evidence on record which are reproduced
herein below:
Witnesses of the appellant-plaintiffs:
i) PW-1: Sri Biswajit Bhattacharjee
ii) PW-2: Sri Jiban Das
iii) PW-3: Sri Pradip Dasgupta
iv) PW-4: Sri Ratan Sarkar
v) PW-5: Smt. Tamasa Rani Datta (Debbarma)
Witnesses of the respondent-defendants:
i)
DW-1: Sri Apu Bardhan
ii)
DW-2: Debijit Chowdhury
iii)
DW-3: Shila Choudhury (defendant No.11)
iv)
DW-4: Sri Asish Choudhury
v)
DW-5 Sambhunath Sarkar
vi)
DW-6:
Smt.
Suparna
(defendant No.9)
vii)
DW-7: Smt.
No.19)
viii)
DW-8:
Sri
Kripankar
(defendant No.10)
Narayan
Das
Paul
Court’s Witness:
i)
CW-1: Sri Narayan Ch. Sarkar
Exhibits of the appellant-plaintiffs:
(Sarkar)
(defendant
Chakraborty
i)
Exbt.-1(a) to 1(e): Original title deed vide
No.1-5230 dated 26.04.1975 in 5 sheets on
identification by PW1.
ii)
Exbt.-2(a) to 2(d): Original power of
attorney registered vide No.IV-9 dated
01.01.2005 in 4 sheets on identification by
PW1.
iii)
Exbt.-3(a)
to
3(i):
Original
Probate
Certificate in c/w case No.Misc(Probate)07
of 2005 dated 16.01.2008 in 9 sheets on
identification by PW1.
iv)
Exbt.-4: Certified to be true copy of khatian
vide No.2065 obtained through RTI in 1
sheet on identification by PW-1.
v)
Exbt.-5: Photocopy copy of Khatian vide
No.316/1 in 1 sheet on identification by
PW-1.
vi)
Exbt.-6: Photocopy copy of Khatian vide
No.316/2 in 1 sheet on identification by
PW-1.
vii)
Exbt.-7: Original copy of mutation notice
vide No.MR-20130423 dated 29.11.2014 in
1 sheet on identification by PW-1.
viii)
Exbt.-8: Original copy of notice dated
11.06.2015 issued by the Hahashildar N.C.
Nagar TK in 1 sheet on identification by
PW-1.
ix)
Exbt.-9: Certified copy of order dated
12.07.2013 passed by the court of DM &
Collector, Sepahijala in c/w Revenue Case
No.250 of 2006 in 1 sheet on identification
by PW-1.
Exhibits of respondent-defendants:
i)
Exbt.A: Certified to be true copy of finally
published old khatian No.216 in one sheet
on identification by DW1.
ii)
Exbt.B: Order dated 12.07.2013 passed in
Revenue Case No.250/2006 by the court of
the
DM
&
Collector,
Sepahijala,
Bishramganj in one sheet on identification
by DW-1.
iii)
Exbt.-C: Certified to be true copy of the
letter issued by the Dy. Director, Land
Records and Settlement Govt. of Tripura
addressing
to
the
DM
&
Collector,
Sepahijala, Bishramganj dated 30.03.2013
in one sheet on identification by DW-1.
iv)
Exbt.-D: Certified to be true copy of the
letter issued by the Director, Land Records
and Settlement Govt. of Tripura addressing
to
the
DM
&
Collector,
Sepahijala,
Bishramganj dated 16.05.2013 in one sheet
on identification by DW1.
v)
Exbt.-E: Certified to be true copy of finally
published RS khatian No.316/1 in one
sheet on identification by DW-1.
vi)
Exbt.-F: Certified to be true copy of finally
published khatian No.316/2 in one sheet
on identification by DW-1.
vii)
Exbt.-G: Certified to be true copy of finally
published computerized khatian No.316/1
in one sheet on identification by DW-1.
viii)
Exbt.-H: Certified to be true copy of finally
published computerized khatian No.316/2
in one sheet on identification by DW-1.
ix)
Exbt.-I: Certified to be true copy of finally
published computerized khatian No.316/3
in one sheet on identification by DW-1.
x)
Exbt.-J: Certified to be true copy of finally
published computerized khatian No.2396 in
one sheet on identification by DW-1.
xi)
Exbt.-K(a) to K(j): Original registered sale
deed vide No.1-670 dated 08.08.2013 in
ten sheets on identification by DW-1.
xii)
Exbt.L(a)
to
L(b):
Digitized
finally
published khatian No.3340 in two sheets on
identification by DW-1.
xiii)
Exbt.-M(a)
to
M(z):
Digitized
finally
published khatian Nos.3339, 3336, 3321,
3297, 3209, 3146, 3115, 3108, 3092, 3074,
3053, 2908, 2874, 2871, 2860, 2772, 2735,
2682, 2647, 2616, 2612, 2590, 2542, 2534,
2532 and 2396 on identification by DW-1.
xiv)
Exbt.-N(as a whole): Original registered
sale deed vide No.I-654 dated 14.08.2014
executed
by
Smt.
Dipa
Sarkar
(Chowdhury),
Smt.
Rama
Bhowmik
(Chowdhury) and Smt. Anita Chowdhury in
favour of DW-8 in five sheets on
identification by DW-8.
xv)
Exbt.-O(as a whole): Original money
receipt for payment of Rs.343/- dated
22.05.2015 issued by the Asst. Engineer,
DWS
Sub-Division,
Badharghat,
West
Tripura, in favour of DW8 regarding cost for
installation of domestic water supply
connection in one sheet on identification by
DW-8.
xvi)
Exbt.-P(as a whole): Original letter dated
20.05.2015 issued in favour of DW-8 by the
Asst.
Engineer,
DWS
Sub-Division,
Badharghat,
West
Tripura,
regarding
domestic water supply connection in one
sheet on identification by DW-8.
xvii)
Exbt.-Q(as a whole): Original estimate
dated 20.05.2015 issued by the Asst.
Engineer, DWS Sub-Division, Badharghat,
West Tripura in favour of DW-8 for
domestic connection water supply in one
sheet on identification by DW-8.
xviii)
Exbt.-R(as a whole): Certified copy of the
registered sale deed vide No.I-565 dated
18.05.2015 executed in favour of DW-6 by
the defendant No.6-8 in three sheets on
identification by DW-7.
Exbt.-S(as a whole): Certified copy of the
registered sale deed vide No.I-881 dated
05.08.2015 executed in favour of DW-6 by
the defendant No.6-8 in three sheets on
identification by DW-6.
xix)
Finally on conclusion of trial, Learned Trial Court below
dismissed the suit filed by the appellant-plaintiff. The operative
portion of the judgment and order of the Learned Trial Court below
runs as follows:
89. Thus, on the basis of the above discussion, I
decline to grant the relief prayed by the plaintiff to
declare Khatian No.316/2 created in favour of the
defendant nos.1-5 to be void and inoperative in law
for ouster of jurisdiction of this Court in view of Sec.
188 of the TLR & LR Act, 1960.
90. Since all the preceding issues have been decided
in negative and against the plaintiff, thus, the
plaintiff is not entitled to any of the reliefs as prayed
for or any other relief in the circumstances of this
case. However, the answering defendants shall be
entitled to the cost of defending this suit.
Consequently, these two issues are also decided in
negative and against the plaintiff.
ORDER
91. In the result, the suit is dismissed on contest
with cost being devoid of merits.
92. Prepare the decree accordingly and place before
me for signing within 15 days from today.
Challenging that judgment, this present appeal is preferred
before this Court.
6.
At the time of hearing of argument, Learned Senior Counsel
Mr. D. R. Chowdhury appearing on behalf of the appellant-plaintiff has
drawn the attention of the Court that the judgment and decree of the
Learned Trial Court below suffers from infirmities as because the
Learned Trial Court based on the provision of Section 188 of TLR Act
dismissed the suit without considering the probate certificate granted
by the Court of competent jurisdiction. He further submitted that
before the Learned Trial Court below the appellant-plaintiff could
prove the probate certificate granted by the competent Court and also
submitted that on the basis of probate certificate the appellantplaintiff acquired title over the land but the Learned Trial Court below
did not consider the same. Learned Senior Counsel further submitted
that when the appellant-plaintiff came to know that the suit land was
recorded in the name of some other persons immediately he filed an
application for mutation of the suit land in his favour but that was not
considered as the suit land was recorded in the name of different
other persons. Thereafter, the appellant-plaintiff filed proceeding
under Section 95 of TLR and LR Act before the District Collector,
Sepahijala but the District Collector, Sepahijala on the basis of report
of DCM, Bishalgarh passed an order which was contrary to the law
and also directed the present appellant to apply for fresh mutation. It
was also reflected in the order that the land which was recorded in the
name of Kochhar was never in existence at any point of time and as
such the findings of District Collector, Sepahijala was also perverse.
He further submitted that the then District Settlement authority on
the basis of document produced by said Kochhar mutated the land in
his favour which he later on transferred to one Prabir Chakraborty and
after that Prabir Chakraborty executed a will in favour of the present
appellant and bequeathed the suit land to him. He further submitted
that if the suit land was not in existence at any point of time then how
the settlement authority recorded the suit land in favour of Col.
Kochhar. Although said Prabir Chakraborty i.e. the testator of the Will
could not mutate the land in his favour. Furthermore, Learned Senior
Counsel again submitted that although no record of rights could be
prepared in the name of Prabir Chakraborty but since Prabir
Chakraborty stepped into the shoe of said Kochhar so in absence of
any
documentary
evidence
in
his
name,
the
suit
was
also
maintainable. But the Learned Trial Court below without finding out
the actual truth regarding the title of Raghubir Chandra Kochhar came
to the observation that the suit was not maintainable. Learned Senior
Counsel also submitted that the land recorded in the name of
Raghubir Chandra Kochhar and the land purchased by the different
purchaser is totally different which has got nexus with each other but
the Learned Trial Court without going into the root of the case
decreed the suit most arbitrarily which needs to be interfered with by
this Court. It was also submitted that initially the appellant-plaintiff
filed suit for declaration and perpetual injunction but by this time
COVID-19 spread across the country for which there was total
disruption of official works as because there was lockdown across the
country and taking this advantage the respondent-defendants No.9,
10 and 19 made some construction over the suit land and ousted the
appellant-plaintiff from the suit land for which the appellant-plaintiff
was also compelled to amend his plaint wherein decree for recovery of
possession was also sought for. Learned Senior Counsel further
submitted that there are numerous judgments holding that in a case
of this nature the Civil Court can also interfere because the revenue
forum has got no authority to pass any decree but the Learned Trial
Court below did not consider the same and dismiss the suit of the
appellant-plaintiff without any basis. It was also submitted that said
probate certificate was never challenged and also the Khatian
standing in the name of said Raghubir Chandra Kochhar was never
challenged by any other person including the present respondentdefendants to any other forum. As such, on the basis of said probate
certificate the appellant has acquired right, title, interest over the suit
property.
Regarding the concluding observation of the Learned Trial
Court below that the jurisdiction of Civil Court is barred in view of the
provision of Section 188 of TLR & LR Act, Learned Senior Counsel has
relied upon one citation of Privy Council reported in AIR 1940 Privy
Council 105 [titled as Secretary of State vs. Mask & Co. dated
15.03.1940] wherein in page 110 c1 the Lordships of Privy Council
observed as under:
“It is settled law that the exclusion of the
jurisdiction of the Civil Courts is not to be readily
inferred, but that such exclusion must either be
explicitly expressed or clearly implied. It is also well
settled that even if jurisdiction is so excluded, the
Civil Courts have jurisdiction to examine into cases
where the provisions of the Act have not been
complied with, or the statutory tribunal has not
acted in conformity with the fundamental principles
of judicial procedure.”
Learned Senior Counsel further referred another citation
reported in (2016) 1 TLR 166 [titled as State of Tripura and Ors.
Vs. Dilip Kumar Majumder and Ors. dated 08.12.2015] wherein
in para No.20 this High Court observed as under:
“20. The question that has been raised that whether
the civil court has got the jurisdiction to determine
the dispute which may fall within the ambit of
section 15 of the TLR & LR Act, 1960. Proviso to
section 188 of the TLR & LR Act which has not been
printed in some of the subsequent editions even
though that was not deleted by any amendment,
clearly provides that when the dispute is relatable to
the question of title or determination of the title then
the bar as created under Section 188 of the TLR & LR
Act would not be applicable. Apart that, it is well
settled that when it is a question of title, the revenue
court does not have any jurisdiction, it is the civil
court and the civil court alone is to determine the
question of the title. If there arises a situation of coterminus jurisdiction then the option remains with
the person who would take the action at law to opt
the forum. As such the argument that has been
advanced by Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel cannot
be sustained. Apart that another latent issue has
been made part of the substantial question of law is
that whether would extinguishment of the title of the
true owner when the true owner is the Government
and the land is the Government land be under
section 27 read with article 112 of the Limitation Act
1963 or can such prescription eclipse the provisions
of section 15 of the TLR & LR Act, 1960? Section 15
of the TLR & LR Act, 1960 confers power to evict the
illegal
or
unauthorized
possessor
from
the
Government land. Section 27 or article 112 if read
together clearly, it makes out a special provision.
The special provision always derogates the general
provision. If the law is not interpreted in that way,
the provisions of section 27 or article 112 of the
Limitation Act would be rendered otiose and no court
can interpret law to make it otiose. It must be made
workable. It has to be stated clearly that provisions
of section 15 of the TLR & LR Act, 1960 is subject to
provision of section 27 read with article 112 of the
Limitation Act, 1963 and, thus, the first substantial
question is answered in the negative.
Having held so, this appeal is allowed partly in terms
of the above.
Prepare the decree accordingly and thereafter send
down the records.”
Referring the same, he submitted that inspite of pendency of
revenue proceeding civil Court has got the jurisdiction to determine
the dispute where question of title is involved.
Further, referring the jurisdiction of civil Court Learned Senior
Counsel also referred another citation of full bench of Gauhati High
Court reported in AIR 1990 Gauhati 17 [titled as Daulatram
Lakhani v. State of Assam and others dated 29.08.1988]
wherein in para No.22 the Hon’ble Gauhati High Court observed as
under:
“22. From what has been stated above, we would say
that in a matter like the one at hand civil court’s
jurisdiction would not be barred in the following
cases:
(1) when the order under Rule 18 is patently
illegal or without jurisdiction.
(2) Where the remedy provided by the Regulation
to adjudge the objection raised is not sufficient;
(3) where complicated questions relating to title
are involved; or
(4) where the plaintiff seeks declaration of his
title over the land from which he is sought to be
evicted.”
Learned Senior Counsel thereafter submitted that since on the
ground of want of title Learned Trial Court below determined all the
issues framed and since the probate certificate was never challenged
by any person to any other forum and till today it stands legally good
and lawful so the decision of Learned Trial Court below on the issues
appears to be unsustainable in the eye of law for which this appeal is
preferred and the appellant has been able to establish that the
judgment of the Learned Trial Court below suffers from perversity and
infirmity as such the same needs to be interfered with by setting aside
the judgment and decree delivered by the Learned Trial Court below.
7.
On the other hand, Learned Counsel for the contesting
respondents has drawn the attention of the Court that originally the
suit land was belonging to one Nalini Mohan Bardhan and after his
death as per law of inheritance his legal heirs became the owners in
possession of the suit land and on different occasions they have
transferred portion of suit land to different persons and those
subsequent purchasers by this time were made parties in the suit
before the Court but surprisingly before the Learned Trial Court below
the appellant-plaintiff could not adduce any document showing title of
Raghubir Chandra Kochhar over the suit land. According to Learned
Counsel granting of probate does not confer any title over the suit
land and before the Learned Trial Court below the appellant-plaintiff
could not produce any document showing his title over the suit land or
could not adduce any document as to how he derived title over the
suit property save and except production of probate certificate before
the Court. Thus the Learned Trial Court below rightly came to the
observation that the appellant-plaintiff had no title over the suit land
and decided all the issues in negative against the appellant-plaintiff of
the case and ultimately dismissed the suit. According to Learned
defence Counsel there was no infirmity in the judgment delivered by
Learned Trial Court and it was a reasoned one. So, Learned Counsel
for the contesting defendants finally urged for dismissal of this appeal.
8.
I have heard detailed argument of both the sides and perused
the record of the Learned Court below including the judgment and
decree delivered by Learned Trial Court below. Admittedly the suit
land was originally belonged to one Nalini Mohan Bardhan being the
predecessor of Maya Bardhan, Apu Bardhan and others. It was the
case of the appellant-plaintiff that from said Nalini Mohan Bardhan
one Raghubir Chandra Kochhar purchased the suit land which was
recorded in
his
name in Khatian No.2065
and
thereafter he
transferred the land to Prabir Chakraborty who purchased the same
with the financial support of the father of the appellant-plaintiff and
thereafter, Prabir Chakraborty executed a Will in favour of the present
appellant-plaintiff and also a Codicil and after that, based on the ‘Will’
one probate was obtained which was never challenged by any other
person including the contesting respondent-defendants. But when the
appellant-plaintiff approached for mutation that time it revealed to
him that the suit land was recorded in the name of different persons
and his mutation was not allowed. Thereafter he approached to the
District Collector, Sepahijala by filing petition under Section 95 of TLR
& LR Act but no effective order could be passed. Rather the District
Collector ordered for maintaining status quo and also advised the
appellant-plaintiff to apply for fresh mutation. In the meantime he
filed the suit.
There is no dispute on record that Nalini Mohan Bardhan was
the owners-in-possession of the suit land originally who transferred
the land according to the appellant-plaintiff to Raghubir Chandra
Kochhar but surprisingly before the Learned Trial Court below the
appellant-plaintiff could not produce any document as to how the land
was purchased by Raghubir Chandra Kochhar from Nalini Mohan
Bardhan which created a doubt in the mind of the Learned Trial Court
below regarding title of the appellant-plaintiff. However, it is on record
that the said land was recorded in the name of Raghubir Chandra
Kochhar in Khatian No.2065. From the order of District Collector,
Sepahijala, it emerges that the suit plot recorded in the name of said
Raghubir Chandra Kochhar in Khatian No.2065 was never existed
rather it was imaginary one but on perusal of the certified copy of
khatian (Exbt.-4) issued by the settlement authority it appears that
the khatian was prepared under Section 43(3) of TLR & LR Act vide
case No.103/1970 by the Revenue Officer. So definitely it can be
presumed that on the basis of a mutation proceeding the Khatian was
opened in his name but surprisingly the appellant could not produce
the record of the said proceeding before the Learned Trial Court below
to draw any inference. Before this Court also, the appellant-plaintiff
although relied upon the document but could not submit anything in
this regard. The contesting respondent-defendants also did not submit
anything in this regard rather Learned Counsel confined his argument
to the fact that although the original owners-in-possession was Nalini
Mohan Bardhan and after his death the same was recorded in the
name of his legal heirs which was recorded in their name in khatian
No.316/1 but it is the admitted position that the CS plot number as
mentioned in Exbt.-4 i.e. the Khatian of said Raghubir Chandra
Kochhar and the CS plot as mentioned in Khatian in the name of legal
heirs of said Nalini Mohan Bardhan namely Maya Rani Bardhan and
others are completely different. It cannot be believed that the
settlement authority without perusing any documentary evidence on
record allowed mutation and created Khatian No.2065 in the name of
Raghubir Chandra Kochhar.
9.
Section 42 and 43 of TLR & LR Act deals about preparation of
record of rights and publication of record of rights. In this regard, I
would like to refer the relevant provisions of Section 42 and 43(3) of
TLR & LR Act which are as under:
“42. Preparation of record of rights.- It shall be the
duty of the survey officer to prepare a record of
rights for each village showing the area of each
survey number and other particulars and any other
record or register, in accordance with the rules made
under this Act:
Provided that where for any reason a record of rights
cannot be prepared in respect of the entire village it
shall be lawful for the survey officer to prepare
separate records of rights for different areas of such
village and notwithstanding anything contained in
this Act or any rule made thereunder, a record of
rights when finally published shall not be called in
question in any court on the ground that it was not
prepared in respect of the entire village.
43. Publication of the record of rights.- (3) Every
entry in the record of rights as finally published
shall, until the contrary is proved, be presumed to be
correct.”
There is no evidence on record that challenging that Khatian
No.2065 any person objected creation of said khatian in the name of
Raghubir Chandra Kochhar. The Learned Trial Court below at the time
of elaborate discussions of all the issues only came to the observation
that the appellant-plaintiff could not prove any title over the suit land
and the Khatian No.2065 was not in force. Although both the parties
fairly submitted that the land recorded in the name of said Raghubir
Chandra Kochhar and also in the name of legal heirs of Nalini Mohan
Bardhan are quite different. Thus, it appears that without going into
the root of preparation of record of rights, Learned Civil Court
determined the suit and came to the observation that in view of
Section 188 of TLR & LR Act, 1960 that this present suit is not
maintainable. The mutation officer or the District Collector at the time
of passing of the order dated 12.07.2013 in connection with Revenue
Case No.250 of 2006 under Section 95 of TLR & LR Act, 1960 did not
go into the root of the matter and gave an observation which
according to this Court was not in accordance with the factual
aspects. However, those orders have not been challenged before this
Court. If it is found that the CS plot numbers as mentioned in the said
Khatian No.2065(Exbt.-4) does not in existence in that case the
plaintiff will not be entitled to get any relief from the Court.
Admittedly, the contesting respondents could not cast any doubt over
probate certificate/Will, etc as relied upon by the appellant-plaintiff
but they confined to their argument that the appellant could not prove
any title belonging to Raghubir Chandra Kochhar over the suit land.
But it is on record that on the basis of mutation proceeding No.103 of
the
said
Khatian
No.2065(Exbt.-4)
was
created
by
the
settlement authority probably the order was passed by Assistant
Survey and Settlement Officer for which the matter needs further
examination and consideration by the Learned Trial Court below.
10.
In absence of the specific findings regarding preparation of
said Khatian No.2065 by the settlement authority, the issues
determined
by the Learned Trial
Court
below appears to
be
unreasonable for which this Court is of the considered view that the
decision of the Learned Trial Court needs to be interfered with and
accordingly the judgment and decree delivered by Learned Trial Court
needs to be set aside and accordingly the matter is remanded back to
the Learned Trial Court to determine following issues afresh:
i) Whether the appellant-plaintiff has got right,
title, interest and possession over the suit land?
ii)
Whether
the
appellant-plaintiff
was
dispossessed from the suit land?
iii) Whether the appellant-plaintiff is entitled to the
decree as prayed for?
In determining the issues both the parties be asked to adduce
fresh evidence on record i.e. both oral and documentary evidence. In
addition to that, Learned Trial Court below shall seek a report from
Director, Land Records and Settlement, Tripura referring Exbt.-4
(Khatian No.2065) asking as to how the said Khatian was prepared by
the then settlement authority and to produce the record of mutation
proceeding if available and if necessary by sending a team of
surveyors physically to identify the land of the said Khatian and
thereafter if necessary to examine and record the evidence of the
staff of the settlement department to support the factual report giving
scope to the contesting respondents for cross-examination if any and
after that to deliver a fresh judgment covering the factual aspects in
accordance with law.
11.
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant is hereby
allowed on contest with costs. The judgment dated 13.06.2024 and
consequential decree dated 19.06.2024 delivered by Learned Civil
Judge, Senior Division, Sepahijala District, Sonamura, Tripura in
connection with TS No.107 of 2015 is hereby set aside. The matter is
remanded back to the Learned Trial Court with a direction to take
fresh evidence of both the parties and prior to that, the Learned Trial
Court below shall obtain a report from the Director of Settlement
authority referring Exbt.-4 i.e. Khatian No.2065 as indicated above in
earlier paragraph and after that shall deliver a fresh judgment in
accordance with law.
The parties shall appear before the Court of Learned Civil
Judge, Senior Division, Sepahijala District, Sonamura, Tripura on
12.06.2025.
With this observation, the appeal stands disposed of.
Send down the LCR along with a copy of this judgment to the
respective Courts.
Pending applications(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Deepshikha
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2025.05.17
15:44:35 -07'00'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review