The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. It was also the admitted position that the deceased, Suman Deb had valid driving licence at the time of accident. So, after hearing both the sides and in view of the principles of law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the aforenoted case, I am of the considered view that the Learned Tribunal below misinterpreted the terms of policy i.e. Exhibit-C (2 Sheets) and came to an observation that the policy was under ‘Act Policy’ and as such the petitioners were not entitled to get any compensation and thus dismissed the claim-petition, for which the matter needs to remanded back to the Learned Tribunal below to reconsider the matter afresh.
11. In the result, the appeal filed by the appellants is hereby allowed on contest. The award dated 17.04.2024 delivered in connection with case No.T.S.(MAC) 05 of 2022 is hereby set aside. The matter is remanded back to the Learned Tribunal below with a direction to allow the parties to adduce evidence afresh and also to determine whether the policy was a ‘Comprehensive/Package Policy’ or ‘Act Policy’ or not and thereafter, to deliver a fresh judgment/award in the light of the aforesaid judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court after proper appreciation of evidence. The entire exercise shall be completed within a period of six months from the date of receipt of the copy of judgment/order. Both the parties shall appear before the Learned Tribunal below on 05.12.2024. With this observation, this appeal stands disposed of. Send down the LCR along with a copy of the judgment/order. Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of. Purnita +05'30'
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAC App. No.76 of 2024
1.
Sri Bishnu Pada Deb,
S/o- Late Manmohan Deb.
2.
Smt. Usha Rani Deb,
W/o- Sri Bishnu Pada Deb
Both are residents of Mohanpur, Tarapur, P.S.- Sidhai,
District- West Tripura
…. Appellants (Claimants)
Versus
1.
Smt. Anita Acharya,
W/o- Sri Manik Ch. Acharya,
Residents of Mohanpur, Tarapur,
P.S.- Sidhai, District- West Tripura.
(Owner of TR-01-AE-6796, Motor Bike)
2.
The Divisional Manager,
United India Insurance Co. Ltd.,
Agartala Branch, Mantribari Road, Agartala,
District- West Tripura,
(Insurer of Motor Bike bearing No.TR-01-AE-6796)
….The Respondents (Opposite Parties)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. B. Saha, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S. D. Choudhury, Adv,
Mr. D. Sarkar, Adv.
Date of Hearing
:
20.11.2024
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order :
Whether fit for
Reporting
:
27.11.2024
YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This appeal is preferred under Section 173 of M.V.
Act challenging the judgment and award dated 17.04.2024
delivered by Learned Member, MAC Tribunal No.1, West
Tripura, Agartala in connection with case No. T.S. (MAC) 05 of
2022. By the said judgment and award, Learned Tribunal below
disposed of the case without any compensation i.e. with nill
award.
02.
Heard Learned Counsel, Mr. B. Saha appearing on
behalf of the appellants and also heard Learned Counsel, Mr.
D. Sarkar appearing on behalf of the respondent O.P. No.1 and
Mr. S. D. Choudhury appearing on behalf of the respondent
O.P. No.2 i.e. the Insurance Company.
03.
In course of hearing of argument, Learned Counsel
for the appellants submitted that in the alleged case, due to
accident two persons were expired on the said date and time
who were the brothers and in another connected case which
was registered before the Learned Tribunal below as T.S.(MAC)
No.04 of 2022 for the death of deceased Suman Deb, Learned
Tribunal by the judgment and award dated 17.04.2024
awarded compensation amounting to Rs.7,80,000/- with 9%
interest w.e.f. 10.01.2022 to till the date of actual payment
and fastened the liability of payment of compensation upon the
respondent O.P. No.2, i.e. the United Insurance Company
Limited. But in the present case, in respect of death of another
brother, Sourav Deb, Learned Tribunal below dismissed the
claim-petition on the ground that the policy of the offending
vehicle/bike
was
under
‘Package/Comprehensive
‘Act
Policy’
and
Policy’
not
under
ultimately
Learned
Tribunal below dismissed the claim petition.
Learned
Counsel
for
the
appellants
further
submitted that before the Learned Tribunal the appellantclaimant-petitioners submitted all the relevant documents, i.e.
the FIR and the copy of police report wherein in the police
report, it was specifically stated that on the alleged day,
accident occurred in between the bike of the deceased persons
which they were riding along with an unknown vehicle and
after the accident the offending vehicle fled away from the
place of occurrence and during investigation, the offending
vehicle could not be identified for want of eye witnesses,
resulting which the I.O. after completion of investigation laid
FR(T) for want of evidence. But the Learned Tribunal below in
the judgment/award has written that the bike of the O.P. No.1
was responsible for the alleged accident. So, Learned Counsel
submitted that since in the connected case, the Learned
Tribunal awarded compensation in favour of the petitioners for
the death of their another son, Suman Deb, so, in the present
case also the petitioner-appellants are entitled to get the
similar compensation and urged for allowing this appeal by
setting aside the award dated 17.04.2024 delivered by Learned
Tribunal below.
04.
On
the
other
hand,
Learned
Counsel
for
the
Insurance Company, Mr. S. D. Choudhury appeared and
submitted that the Learned Tribunal below rightly dismissed
the claim-petition of the present appellants i.e. the claimantpetitioners because for the offending motor bike as per policy,
no additional premium was paid for the pillion rider. So,
Learned Tribunal below rightly dismissed the claim-petition.
Learned Counsel for the owner of the bike submitted
to pass appropriate order.
05.
I have heard submission of both the sides and gone
through the judgment/award of the Learned Tribunal below.
Here in the given case, the present appellants as claimantpetitioners submitted a claim-petition to the Learned Tribunal
below alleging inter alia that on 23.01.2020 at about 11.45
p.m., the appellant-petitioner No.2 received one telephonic
call, when she was informed that her brother residing at
Agartala was suffering from serious illness and accordingly, she
informed her two sons to proceed for Agartala to attend their
maternal uncle and accordingly, they requested the respondent
O.P. No.1 to provide the motor bike bearing TR-01-AE-6796 to
them and on the way Suman Deb was riding the bike and his
brother Sourav Deb was the pillion rider and when they
reached near Fatikcherra Bazar on Agartala- Simna Road by
riding the motor bike, that time they met with an accident.
After the accident, the local people of Fatikcherra shifted both
of them to GBP Hospital and the attending Doctors declared
both of them as dead. After that post mortem examination was
conducted over the dead body of the deceased and on
25.01.2020 the father of the said deceased lodged one written
complaint to O.C. Sidhai P.S. and accordingly, Sidhai P.S. case
bearing No.09/2020 under Section 279/304(A) of IPC was
registered.
It was further submitted that said Suman Deb, who
was riding the bike was having valid driving licence and Sourav
Deb was 23 years old and was running one hotel business and
used to earn Rs.30,000/- per month. Accordingly, the claimpetition was filed which was registered as T.S.(MAC) No.05 of
2022. Before the Tribunal both the parties adduced their
evidence and finally, Learned Tribunal below dismissed the
claim-petition on the ground that the policy of insurance was
an ‘Act Policy’ and Learned Tribunal below also relied upon two
citations of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India reported in
(2006) 4 SCC 404 (United India Insurance Co. Ltd.
Shimla vs. Tilak Singh and Others) and (2007) 5 SCC 428
(Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Meena Variyal) and
finally, dismissed the claim-petition.
06.
I have also perused the exhibited documents relied
upon by the appellant-claimant-petitioners. It appears that on
the alleged accident, a police case was registered vide Sidhai
P.S. case No.09/2020 and on conclusion of investigation, the
I.O. laid final report for want of evidence, but from the police
report, it appears that on the alleged day, the accident took
place due to collision in between two vehicles, but one of the
vehicles could not be identified for want of evidence as the
driver of the another vehicle fled away soon after the accident.
So, the I.O. laid FR(T).
07.
To substantiate the claim-petition, the appellants
adduced both oral/documentary evidence on record but from
the evidence, it appears that the presence of another vehicle to
the place of occurrence at the time of accident was not clearly
mentioned as revealed from the investigation of I.O., just they
simply stated that the accident occurred. However, in the
connected case, which was registered as T.S.(MAC) No.04 of
2022, Learned Tribunal below awarded compensation for the
death of the rider, Suman Deb who was also the son of the
present appellants.
08.
Hon’ble the Supreme Court in National Insurance
Company Limited vs. Balakrishnan and Another dated
20.11.2012 reported in (2013) 1 SCC 731 Wherein Hon’ble
the Apex Court in para Nos.24, 25 & 26 observed as under:
“24. It is extremely important to note
here that till 31-12-2006 the Tariff
Advisory Committee and, thereafter,
from 1-1-2007 IRDA functioned as the
statutory regulatory authorities and they
are entitled to fix the tariff as well as the
terms and conditions of the policies by
all insurance companies. The High Court
had issued notice to the Tariff Advisory
Committee and the IRDA to explain the
factual position as regards the liability of
the insurance companies in respect of an
occupant in a private car under the
“comprehensive/package policy”. Before
the High Court, the competent authority
of IRDA had stated that on 2-6-1986, the
Tariff Advisory Committee had issued
instructions
to
all
the
insurance
companies to cover the pillion rider of a
scooter/motorcycle
under
the
“comprehensive policy” and the said
position continues to be in vogue till
date. It had also admitted that the
“comprehensive policy” is presently
called a “package policy”. It is the
admitted position, as the decision would
show, the earlier Circulars dated 18-31978 and 2-6-1986 continue to be valid
and
effective
and
all
insurance
companies are bound to pay the
compensation in respect of the liability
towards an occupant in a car under the
“comprehensive/package
policy”
irrespective of the terms and conditions
contained in the policy. The competent
authority of the IRDA was also examined
before the High Court who stated that
the Circulars dated 18-3-1978 and 2-61986 of the Tariff Advisory Committee
were incorporated in the Indian Motor
Tariff effective from 1-7-2002 and they
continue to be operative and binding on
the insurance companies. Because of the
aforesaid factual position, the Circulars
dated 16-11-2009 and 3-12-2009, that
have been reproduced hereinabove, were
issued.
25. It is also worthy to note that the
High Court, after referring to individual
circulars issued by various insurance
companies,
eventually
stated
thus:
(Yashpal Luthra case: yashpal Luthra v.
United India Insurance Co. Ltd., 2011
ACH 1415 (Del)
“27. In view of the aforesaid, it is
clear
that
the
comprehensive/package policy of a
two-wheeler covers a pillion rider
and comprehensive/package policy
of
a
private
car
covers
the
occupants and where the vehicle is
covered
under
a
comprehensive/package
policy,
there is no need for the Motor
Accidents Claims Tribunal to go into
the question whether the insurance
company is liable to compensate for
the death or injury of a pillion rider
on a two-wheeler or the occupants
in a private car. In fact, in view of
the TAC’s directives and those of
the IRDA, such a plea was not
permissible and ought not to have
been raised as, for instance, it was
done in the present case.”
26. In view of the aforesaid factual
position, there is no scintilla of doubt
that a “comprehensive/package policy”
would cover the liability of the insurer
for payment of compensation for the
occupant in a car. There is no cavil that
an “Act Policy” stands on a different
footing from a “Comprehensive/Package
Policy”. As the circulars have made the
position very clear and the IRDA, which
is presently the statutory authority, has
commanded the insurance companies
stating that a “Comprehensive/package
policy” covers the liability, there cannot
be any dispute in that regard. We may
hasten to clarify that the earlier
pronouncements
were
rendered
in
respect of the “Act policy” which
admittedly cannot cover a third-party
risk of an occupant in a car. But, if the
policy is a “comprehensive/package
policy”, the liability would be covered.
These aspects were not noticed in the
case of Bhagyalakshmi: Bhagyalakshmi
v. United Insurance Co. Ltd., (2009) 7
SCC 148 and, therefore, the matter was
referred to a larger Bench. We are
disposed to think that there is no
necessity to refer the present matter to a
larger Bench as the IRDA, which is
presently the statutory authority, has
clarified the position by issuing circulars
which have been reproduced in the
judgment by the Delhi High Court and we
have also reproduced the same.”
09.
Here in the given case, on perusal of Exhibit-C, i.e.
the Insurance Policy Certificate (2 sheets) as relied upon by
the respondent O.P.W.1, it appears that the said policy was a
‘Package Policy’ not an Act Policy, permitted seat capacity two
and the validity of the period of insurance was w.e.f.
04.06.2019 to 03.06.2020 and the alleged accident took place
on 23.01.2020 and the said Insurance Certificate was issued in
the name of Smt. Anita Acharya, i.e. the respondent O.P. No.2,
vide policy No.1309003119P103059138.
10.
It was also the admitted position that the deceased,
Suman Deb had valid driving licence at the time of accident.
So, after hearing both the sides and in view of the principles of
law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the aforenoted
case, I am of the considered view that the Learned Tribunal
below misinterpreted the terms of policy i.e. Exhibit-C (2
Sheets) and came to an observation that the policy was under
‘Act Policy’ and as such the petitioners were not entitled to get
any compensation and thus dismissed the claim-petition, for
which the matter needs to remanded back to the Learned
Tribunal below to reconsider the matter afresh.
11.
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellants is
hereby allowed on contest. The award dated 17.04.2024
delivered in connection with case No.T.S.(MAC) 05 of 2022 is
hereby set aside. The matter is remanded back to the Learned
Tribunal below with a direction to allow the parties to adduce
evidence afresh and also to determine whether the policy was
a ‘Comprehensive/Package Policy’ or ‘Act Policy’ or not and
thereafter, to deliver a fresh judgment/award in the light of the
aforesaid judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court after proper
appreciation
of
evidence.
The
entire
exercise
shall
be
completed within a period of six months from the date of
receipt of the copy of judgment/order. Both the parties shall
appear before the Learned Tribunal below on 05.12.2024. With
this observation, this appeal stands disposed of.
Send down the LCR along with a copy of the
judgment/order.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed
of.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Purnita
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2024.11.29 11:41:18
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review