Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
B.A. No.83 of 2025
Sri Binod Sahni
S/O Godo Sahni
Of Jyoti Vihar Meerachak,
Sabour Road Zero Mile, Babupur, Bhagalpur,
Bihar-813210
---- Applicant on behalf of accused persons-in-custody
1. Smti. Rina Devi,
W/O Vinod Sahani
Of Jyoti Vihar Meerachak,
Sabour Road Zero Mile, Babupur, Bhagalpur,
Bihar-813210
2. Smti. Rinku Devi
W/O Sri Jobon Singh
Of Mohanpur, Goughatta,
P.O-Mohanpur, P.S.-Noughachia,
District-Bhagalpur, State-Bihar.
3. Laxmi Devi
W/O Sri Sita Prasad of Naya Godam
P.S.-Gaya Sadar, District-Gaya,
State-Bihar
4. Smt. Gita Devi
W/O Sri Mouli Mandal alias Bhanu
Of Kharti, P.O-Amour, P.S.-Godda,
District-Godda, State-Jharkhand.
---- Accused persons-in-custody
Versus
The State of Tripura
----Respondent(s)
For Applicant(s)
:
Ms. Megha Sarkar, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Raju Datta, P.P.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Order
26/09/2025
This bail application under Section 483 of BNSS, 2023
is filed by the applicant for granting bail to the accused persons in
custody namely Smt. Rina Devi, Smti Rinku Devi, Laxmi Devi and
Smti. Gita Devi in connection with Agartala GRPS case No.59 of
2025 for the offence punishable under Section 20(b)(ii)(C)/29 of
NDPS Act.
Heard Learned Counsel Ms. Megha Sarkar appearing on
behalf of the accused persons in custody and also heard Learned
P.P. Mr. Raju Datta appearing on behalf of the State-respondent.
As ordered earlier, this Court has received the record
from the Learned Trial Court and also, Learned P.P. has produced
the Case Diary.
At the time of hearing, Learned Counsel for the accused
persons in custody has drawn the attention of the Court referring
the contents of the FIR and submitted that the accused persons in
custody are not related to each other and they came from
different areas of Bihar and Jharkhand for visiting Tripura. On the
alleged day they were detained by police at Agartala Railway
station and from accused Laxmi Devi, 6kg 235g of dry ganja was
recovered, from accused Gita Devi, 6kg 210g dry ganja was
recovered, from Rina Devi, 5kg 540g dry ganja was recovered and
from another accused Rinku Devi, 5kg 640g dry ganja was
recovered. According to Learned Counsel for the accused persons,
the police at the time of registering the case, wrongly registered
the case under 20(b)(ii)(C)/29 of NDPS in place of registering the
case under Section 20(b)(ii)(B) of NDPS Act resulting which the
said accused persons being women are lodging in custody for
more than 110 days without any justified grounds and by this time
they have also acquired the right to be released on default bail but
the Learned Special Judge and even the Learned Session Judge
under Section 439(1)(a) of Cr.P.C. presently under Section
483(1)(a) of BNSS refused their bail application. Learned Counsel
also drawn the attention of the Court that there is no materials for
application of Section 29 of NDPS Act but only for the purpose of
incarceration of the accused persons in custody those Sections
were incorporated by the O/C of the concerned PS at the time of
registration of the case. In support of her contention, reliance was
placed upon one citation of Hon’ble Supreme Court of India
reported in 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1779 [titled as Nadeem
Ahamed Vs. State of West Bengal dated 05.08.2025] wherein
in para Nos.22 and 23, Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as under:
“22. Merely because the two accused, walking sideby-side, were apprehended simultaneously, and
both were carrying narcotic drug concealed on their
body, the said coincidental happening, by itself,
would not give rise to an inference that either of
them had the knowledge about the contraband
being carried by the other. These facts may give
rise to a suspicion, but suspicion, however, cannot
take place of proof.
23. If at all the prosecution intended to bring home
the charge of conspiracy, and club the contraband
recovered from both the accused persons together,
then positive proof to support the charge of
conspiracy had to be presented. Such proof could
not be substituted with mere inferences or
conjectures. Positive and tangible evidence was
necessary to establish, beyond reasonable doubt,
that both accused persons had prior knowledge of
the contraband in the other's possession. However,
upon carefully analysing the evidence available on
record, we find that, apart from the bald allegation
that both the accused were seen walking together
and were searched one after the other, not even a
semblance of evidence was led by the prosecution,
which can substantiate the charge of prior
conspiracy between the two accused persons.”
Relying upon the same, Learned Counsel Ms. Sarkar
submitted that the accused persons are not known to each other
and they had no knowledge of their possession of contraband
items by each of them. So, this principle also may be applied in
this case.
Finally,
Learned
Counsel
urged
for
releasing
the
accused persons on bail in any condition.
On the other hand, Learned P.P. strongly opposed the
bail application preferred on behalf of the accused persons and
referring the contents of the FIR, Learned P.P. submitted that it is
clear that on the alleged day the accused persons came to
Agartala by the same train when they were detained at Agartala
Railway Station and there are sufficient materials showing their
implication with the alleged offence. So, considering the materials
on record, Learned P.P. submitted that at this stage there is no
scope to consider the bail application of the accused persons and
prayed for rejecting the same. It was further submitted that from
the statement of the witnesses it is also clear that the accused
persons are involved with the alleged offence
and further
submitted that the story projected by defence is not true.
I have heard both the sides at length and perused the
Case Diary and also the record of the Learned Trial Court.
Now, here in this bail application, we are to see
whether the present case ought to have been registered under
Section 20(b)(ii)(B) of NDPS Act or not? In support of this
contention, Learned Counsel for the accused persons at the time
of hearing drawn the attention of the Court the copy of the seizure
list and referring the same, she submitted that the police in course
of seizure seized the contraband items individually from their
possession which attracts the offence punishable under Section
20(b)(ii)(B) of NDPS Act not under Section 20(b)(ii)(C) of NDPS
Act but the police has intentionally incorporated the said Section
for the purpose of unnecessary and illegal detention of the
accused persons in custody for their harassment.
As already stated, from the possession of the accused
persons namely Laxmi Devi, Gita Devi, Rina Devi, Rinku Devi,
contraband
items
were
recovered.
In
total
23kg
625g
of
contraband item was recovered.
Now, let us refer hereinbelow the provision of Section
20 of NDPS Act which provides as under:
“20. Punishment for contravention in relation to
cannabis plant and cannabis.- Whoever, in
contravention of any provision of this Act or any
rule or order made or condition of licence granted
thereunder,-(a) cultivates any cannabis plant; or
(b) produces, manufactures, possesses, sells,
purchases,
transports,
imports
inter-State,
exports inter-State or uses cannabis,
shall be punishable,(i) where such contravention relates to clause
(a) with rigorous imprisonment for a term which
may extend to ten years, and shall also be liable
to fine which may extend to one lakh rupees;
and
(ii) where such contravention relates to subclause (b),(A) and involves small quantity, with rigorous
imprisonment for a term which may extend to
one year, or with fine which may extend to
ten thousand rupees, or with both;
(B) and involves quantity lesser than
commercial quantity but greater than small
quantity, with rigorous imprisonment for a
term which may extend to ten years, and
with fine which may extend to one lakh
rupees;
(C) and involves commercial quantity, with
rigorous imprisonment for a term which shall
not be less than ten years but which may
extend to twenty years and shall also be
liable to fine which shall not be less than one
lakh rupees but which may extend to two
lakh rupees:
Provided that the court may, for reasons to be
recorded in the judgment, impose a fine exceeding
two lakh rupees.]”
From the aforesaid provision of NDPS Act, it appears
that in 20(b), the language is used “produces, manufactures,
possesses,
sells,
purchases,
transports,
imports
inter-State,
exports inter-State or uses cannabis”, meaning thereby, the said
Section deals with possession along with other ingredients. If it is
so and if we see the prosecution case i.e. the seizure list and
consider that each individual accused persons possess identical
contraband items to their bag, in that case, it is highly doubtful as
to whether Section 20(b)(ii)(C) of NDPS Act would attract in this
case or not. However, the investigation of the case is in progress.
Till today no charge-sheet is submitted by I/O. If the I/O could
show in the seizure list that collectively 23kg 625g of dry ganja
was found from the possession of the accused persons, in that
case, it could have been believed that Section 20(b)(ii)(C) would
attract in this case. Even if it is assumed that 23kg 625g of dry
ganja was recovered collectively from the accused and if the case
is ended in charge-sheet, in that case at the time of framing of
charge the concerned Court is to indicate the
amount of
contraband items recovered from the possession of each one of
the accused persons, not total quantum of contraband items
recovered. Situated thus, prima facie it appears that the case was
not properly registered by the O/C of the concerned PS at the time
of registration of this case.
Furthermore, Section 29(1) of NDPS Act also provides
as under:
Punishment for abetment and criminal conspiracy.(1) Whoever abets, or is a party to a criminal
conspiracy to commit, an offence punishable under
this Chapter, shall, whether such offence be or be
not committed in consequence of such abetment or
in pursuance of such criminal conspiracy, and
notwithstanding anything contained in section 116
of the Indian Penal Code (45 of 1860), be
punishable with the punishment provided for the
offence.
(2) ….”
Moreover, from the Case Diary at this stage, I also do
not find any materials showing implication of any of the accused
persons with the offence punishable under Section 29(1) of NDPS
Act. Moreso, there is no other evidence on record that the accused
persons are involved in some other case/cases. Situated thus,
considering the materials on record, in the considered opinion of
this Court, the present accused persons deserve to be released on
bail. However, in this regard, in Prabhas Mandal Vs. State of
Kerela, reported in 2025 Supreme(Online)(KER)4380, the
High Court of Kerela in para Nos.6 to 10 observed as under:
“6. This Court considered the contention of the
petitioner and the Public Prosecutor. Admittedly,
the contraband seized from the petitioner is
intermediate quantity. The offence alleged is under
Section
20(b)(ii)B
of
NDPS
Act.
In
such
circumstances, the rigor under Section 37 of the
NDPS Act is not applicable. No criminal antecedents
are alleged against the petitioner. Petitioner is in
custody from 15.11.2024 onwards. Considering the
facts and circumstances of the case, I think the
petitioner can be released on bail after imposing
stringent conditions. But I make it clear that, if the
petitioner is involved in similar offence in future,
the Investigating Officer is free to file appropriate
application before the Jurisdictional Court for
cancellation of bail, and if such an application is
filed, the Jurisdictional Court is free to pass
appropriate orders in accordance with law, even
though this order is passed by this Court.
7. Moreover, it is a well accepted principle that the
bail is the rule and the jail is the exception. The
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Chidambaram. P v
Directorate of Enforcement [2019 (16) SCALE 870],
after considering all the earlier judgments,
observed that, the basic jurisprudence relating to
bail remains the same inasmuch as the grant of bail
is the rule and refusal is the exception so as to
ensure that the accused has the opportunity of
securing fair trial.
8. Moreover, in Jalaluddin Khan v. Union of India
[2024 KHC 6431], the Hon'ble Supreme Court
observed that:
“21. Before we part with the Judgment, we must
mention here that the Special Court and the High
Court did not consider the material in the charge
sheet objectively. Perhaps the focus was more
on the activities of PFI, and therefore, the
appellant's
case
could
not
be
properly
appreciated. When a case is made out for a grant
of bail, the Courts should not have any hesitation
in granting bail. The
allegations of the prosecution may be very
serious. But, the duty of the Courts is to consider
the case for grant of bail in accordance with the
law. "Bail is the rule and jail is an exception" is a
settled law. Even in a case like the present case
where there are stringent conditions for the
grant of bail in the relevant statutes, the same
rule holds good with only modification that the
bail can be granted if the conditions in the
statute are satisfied. The rule also means that
once a case is made out for the grant
of bail, the Court cannot decline to grant bail. If
the Courts start denying bail in deserving cases,
it will be a violation of the rights guaranteed
under Art.21 of our Constitution.”
(underline supplied)
9. In Manish Sisodia v. Directorate of Enforcement
[2024 KHC 6426], also the Hon'ble Supreme Court
observed that:
“53. The Court further observed that, over a
period of time, the trial courts and the High
Courts have forgotten a very well-settled
principle of law that bail is not to be withheld as
a punishment. From our experience, we can say
that it appears that the trial courts and the High
Courts attempt to play safe in matters of grant
of bail. The principle that bail is a rule and
refusal is an exception is, at times, followed in
breach. On account of non-grant of bail even in
straight forward open and shut cases, this Court
is flooded with huge number of bail petitions
thereby adding to the huge pendency. It is high
time that the trial courts and the High Courts
should recognize the principle that "bail is rule
and jail is exception".”
10. Considering the dictum laid down in the above
decision
and
considering
the
facts
and
circumstances of this case, this Bail Application is
allowed with the following directions:
1. Petitioner shall be released on bail on
executing a bond for Rs.50,000/- (Rupees Fifty
Thousand only) with two solvent sureties each
for the like sum to the satisfaction of the
jurisdictional Court.
2. The petitioner shall appear before the
Investigating Officer for interrogation as and
when required. The petitioner shall cooperate
with the investigation and shall not, directly or
indirectly make any inducement, threat or
promise to any person acquainted with the facts
of the case so as to dissuade him/her from
disclosing such facts to the Court or to any
police officer.
3. Petitioner shall not leave India
permission of the jurisdictional Court.
without
4. Petitioner shall not commit an offence similar
to the offence of which he is accused, or
suspected, of the commission of which he is
suspected.
5. If any of the above conditions are violated by
the petitioner, the jurisdictional Court can cancel
the bail in accordance to law, even though the
bail is granted by this Court. The prosecution
and the victim are at liberty to approach the
jurisdictional court to cancel the bail, if there is
any violation of the above conditions.”
I have also gone through the aforesaid citation. The
accused persons are lodging in custody on and from 02.06.2025.
The citation as referred by Learned Counsel for the accused
persons in custody is not applicable in toto at this stage which
may be taken up for consideration in course of trial. However,
considering the materials on record and the period of incarceration
of the accused persons in custody, this Court is of the considered
view that the rigors of provision of Section 37 of NDPS Act would
not apply against any of the accused persons in custody at this
stage.
Accordingly, the accused persons namely, Laxmi Devi,
Gita Devi, Rina Devi, Rinku Devi may be released on interim bail
till 20.12.2025 of their furnishing bail bond of Rs.50,000/- each
with one local surety of like amount to the satisfaction of Learned
Special Judge, West Tripura, Agartala with condition that they
shall appear before IO once in every fortnight till filing of chargesheet and they shall not tamper evidence on record nor they shall
leave the jurisdiction of the concerned Court without prior
permission of the Learned Trial Court, in default, they shall remain
in Judicial Custody as before. In case of the violation of terms and
conditions, the I/O shall be at liberty to pray for cancellation of
their bail.
With this observation, this bail application stands
disposed of.
Send down the record of Learned Trial Court along with
a copy of this order.
Return back the Case Diary to IO through Learned P.P.
along with a copy of this order.
Also, a copy of this order be supplied to Learned
Counsel for the accused persons in custody for information and
compliance.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Deepshikha
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2025.09.26
17:55:16 -07'00'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review