The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
27. 07.2018 delivered in T.S.(Divorce) 37 of 2016 by the Judge, Family Court, Udaipur, Gomati District, Tripura. By the said judgment dated 27.07.2018 which has been challenged under this appeal, the Judge, Family Court, Udaipur has dismissed the petition for granting decree of divorce having observed as follows: “Another question which revolves in our mind is that as to why the respondent started leaving matrimonial home frequently after few months of their marriage. It is not that immediately after marriage she started leaving her matrimonial home. Why after few months? There is no allegation made by the Petitioner as to any illicit relationship of the respondent. So, again and again the question comes to surface as to why she used to leave her matrimonial home frequently. She alleged that she was being tortured both mentally and physically by the Petitioner over the demand of dowry. For this reason she filed a criminal case u/s 498-A of IPC against the Petitioner. Admittedly, the said case ended in compromise. So, the allegation of torture made by the respondent cannot be ruled out straight away. In fact, I find no ground to disbelieve the respondent as the veracity of the respondent could not be shaken. So, the overall circumstances as discussed above, indicates that the Petitioner himself is at fault. According to Section 23(1)(a) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 the Petitioner…
04. 10.2010, the respondent started behaving as if she was a guest in the family of the appellant. The respondent started insisting the appellant to be Ghar Jamai meaning the resident husband. But, since the appellant did not agree, the respondent started misbehaving with him and finally, she left the matrimonial home. On 05.01.2012, the respondent left the matrimonial home and never came back. It has been alleged that the respondent has filed one complaint under section 498A of the IPC in the R.K. Pur Womens Police Station and on the basis of the said complaint, a specific police case under section 498A was registered and investigated. On completion of the investigation, a police report was filed against the appellant. It has been stated that the respondent had initiated a further proceeding under section 125 of the Cr.P.C for having the maintenance from the appellant and that was allowed by the Judge, Family Court, Udaipur with a direction to the employer to recover the maintenance allowance every month from his salary. Thereafter, a proceeding [under Section 127 of the Cr.P.C.] was also initiated by the respondent for enhancing the maintenance allowance. The respondent by filing a written statement denied all those allegations leveled against her and categorically stated that it is the appellant who was not discharging his marital obligations and duties. She has further stated t…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAT App. No. 15 of 2018
Sri Bijan Kumar Sarkar
……..Appellant(s)
Versus
Smt. Aparna Das (Sarkar)
……..Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. K. Nath, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Rajib Saha, Adv.
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE S. TALAPATRA
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE S.G. CHATTOPADHYAY
Order
10/03/2022
[S. Talapatra, J.]
Heard Mr. K. Nath, learned counsel appearing for the
appellant as well as Mr. Rajib Saha, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent.
This appeal under section 19(1) of the Family Courts Act,
arises
from
the
judgment
dated
27.07.2018
delivered
in
T.S.(Divorce) 37 of 2016 by the Judge, Family Court, Udaipur, Gomati
District, Tripura. By the said judgment dated 27.07.2018 which has
been challenged under this appeal, the Judge, Family Court, Udaipur
has dismissed the petition for granting decree of divorce having
observed as follows:
“Another question which revolves in our mind is that
as to why the respondent started leaving matrimonial home
frequently after few months of their marriage. It is not that
immediately after marriage she started leaving her
matrimonial home. Why after few months? There is no
allegation made by the Petitioner as to any illicit
relationship of the respondent. So, again and again the
question comes to surface as to why she used to leave her
matrimonial home frequently. She alleged that she was
being tortured both mentally and physically by the
Petitioner over the demand of dowry. For this reason she
filed a criminal case u/s 498-A of IPC against the Petitioner.
Admittedly, the said case ended in compromise. So, the
allegation of torture made by the respondent cannot be
ruled out straight away. In fact, I find no ground to
disbelieve the respondent as the veracity of the respondent
could not be shaken. So, the overall circumstances as
discussed above, indicates that the Petitioner himself is at
fault. According to Section 23(1)(a) of the Hindu Marriage
Act, 1955 the Petitioner cannot take the advantage of his
own wrong. So, the Petitioner cannot be granted divorce on
the ground of cruelty. Hence, Issue no.I is decided in
negative against the Petitioner.
Next comes Issue no.II, i.e. the question of „desertion‟.
The essence of „desertion‟ under Hindu Marriage Act is
the forsaking the abandonment of ones spouse by the other
without reasonable cause and excuse. In the instant case it
has been already established that there are sufficient
reasons for the respondent for living separately from the
Petitioner. It has also been established that the Petitioner
has been giving maintenance allowance according to the
order of this court u/s 125 Cr.P.C. The fact that a husband
makes a maintenance allowance to a wife whom he refused
to maintain or neglected to maintain is no answer to a
charge of „desertion‟. The plea of the Petitioner is that for a
long period like (4 years) the Petitioner and the respondent
have been living separately and according to the Petitioner
such long separation made the relationship between the
Petitioner and the respondent dried. Here, I am of different
opinion as the „separation‟ may be as long as 50 years but if
the Petitioner himself is liable for such long separation, he
must not be allowed to take the advantage of his own
wrong otherwise, the very purpose of the Hindu Marriage
Act will be frustrated. Hence, issue no.II is also decided in
negative and against the Petitioner.”
Thereafter, the Judge, Family Court has inferred that in view
of the findings, as noted above, the relief as sought by the appellant in
the petition cannot be granted.
From the petition that was filed for granting divorce on the
ground of cruelty and desertion under section 13(1)(ia)&(ib) of the
Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, the appellant has alleged, inter alia, that
after his marriage with the respondent which has been solemnized on
04.10.2010, the respondent started behaving as if she was a guest in
the family of the appellant. The respondent started insisting the
appellant to be Ghar Jamai meaning the resident husband. But, since
the appellant did not agree, the respondent started misbehaving with
him and finally, she left the matrimonial home. On 05.01.2012, the
respondent left the matrimonial home and never came back. It has
been alleged that the respondent has filed one complaint under section
498A of the IPC in the R.K. Pur Womens Police Station and on the basis
of the said complaint, a specific police case under section 498A was
registered and investigated. On completion of the investigation, a police
report was filed against the appellant. It has been stated that the
respondent had initiated a further proceeding under section 125 of the
Cr.P.C for having the maintenance from the appellant and that was
allowed by the Judge, Family Court, Udaipur with a direction to the
employer to recover the maintenance allowance every month from his
salary. Thereafter, a proceeding [under Section 127 of the Cr.P.C.] was
also initiated by the respondent for enhancing the maintenance
allowance.
The respondent by filing a written statement denied all
those allegations leveled against her and categorically stated that it is
the appellant who was not discharging his marital obligations and
duties. She has further stated that she never asked the appellant to be
Ghar Jamai as alleged or otherwise. She has also denied that
continuously since 2012 she had been living separately. In Para 12 of
the written statement, the respondent has stated as follows:
“The opposite party [the respondent herein] informed
the matter to her parents and the parents of the opposite
party expressed their inability to fulfill the illegal demand
of the petitioner. The petitioner and his relatives
thereafter always used to torture both mentally and
physically on demanding the said cash dowry.”
She has however admitted that she filed a complaint under
section 498A of the IPC and initiated the proceeding under section 125
of the Cr.P.C for justice and maintenance.
Mr. Nath, learned counsel has initially submitted that
institution of the complaint under section 498A and acquittal of the
appellant from the charge itself is sufficient proof of cruelty. Hence, the
Judge, Family Court has committed a serious illegality by not
appreciating that fact. Mr. Nath, learned counsel has further submitted
that the respondent is unwilling to restitute the conjugal life and that is
the reason why she has been living separately from the appellant from
2012 by depriving him from the right of cohabitation. For this purpose,
Mr. Nath, learned counsel has brought us to the judgment of the trial
court. According to him, the acquittal is without any blemish. For this
purpose, he has taken us to the finding as recorded in the judgment of
acquittal, which reads as follows:
“In the result, I find, the prosecution has failed to prove
its case of the offence punishable under Section 498A of
IPC against accused namely Sri Bijan Kumar Sarkar and,
therefore, the accused namely Sri Bijan Kumar Sarkar is
acquitted from the liability of the offence punishable
under Section 498A of IPC. The accused is set at liberty
forthwith.”
Mr. Nath, learned counsel has further submitted that this
appeal deserves to be allowed by granting the decree of divorce. But,
when this Court querying Mr. Nath on the statement made by the
appellant [PW-1] to the effect that “Once she left the matrimonial home
and filed criminal case against me and my mother which was settled on
compromise.” He had no answer and incidence of such compromise has
been recorded in the cross examination by the trial judge i.e. the
Judicial Magistrate First Class, Court No.1, Gomati District in the
following manner:
“In cross-examination P.W.3 stated that at present
dispute has amicably been settled between her daughter
and her husband with the intervention of their well
wishers and she was present in the said settlement and
now her daughter is residing peacefully with her husband
and she has no grievance against her son in law.”
Similarly, the respondent has also stated in her crossexamination which has been recorded by the Judicial Magistrate First
Class, Court No.1, Gomati District in the following manner:
“In cross-examination P.W.2 stated that at present the
dispute has been amicably been settled between her and
her husband with the intervention of their well wishers
and now she is residing peacefully and she has no
grievance against her husband and she does not like to
proceed further with the case.”
Mr. Nath, learned counsel has further contended that this
cannot be taken into consideration as the appellant has suffered the
derogation in the estimate of the society.
Mr. R. Saha, learned counsel appearing for the respondent
has taken us to one part of the deposition of DW-1, the respondent
herein, where she has stated as follows:
“I still visit the house of the petitioner but I cannot stay
there due to continuous dispute. The petitioner also visits
our house. There is still relation between me and the
petitioner. I am still willing to continue my matrimonial
relation with the petitioner.”
DW-2 has also corroborated that part of the statement of
the respondent.
We have scrutinized the records and re-read the entire
evidence available therein and appreciated the submissions extended by
the learned counsel for the parties.
It appears to us that the appellant has failed to prove the
grounds such as cruelty and desertion. His endeavour to prove went
haywire. The appellant [PW-1] has admitted that on the basis of the
compromise by the respondent [DW-1] did not state anything in the
trial. This was so done by the respondent with hope of restitution of
conjugal life. The trial court, has accordingly, acquitted the appellant.
In the considered opinion, we are of the further view that
such acquittal cannot be utilized for establishing cruelty against the
other spouse. Moreover, we do not find any evidence relating to
desertion as the element of animus has not been proved. That apart,
the statement of DW-1 as quoted above, has not been confronted
during her cross-examination. Even she has denied that she is not
willing to continue with the matrimonial relation.
On overall assessment of the evidence as noted above, we
do not find any merit in this appeal. Accordingly, the same stands
dismissed.
Draw
the
decree
accordingly.
Send
down
the
thereafter.
JUDGE
Sabyasachi G
JUDGE
LCRs
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review