The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
19. By this order, we make it clear and that too in the form of directions that henceforth no Trial Court or any of the High Courts shall pass any order of grant of regular bail or anticipatory bail on any undertaking that the accused might be ready to furnish for the purpose of obtaining appropriate reliefs.” Relying upon the same, it appears that even if the accused petitioner is also willing to refund the said amount that cannot be a ground for consideration of his bail and furthermore, since there is involvement of accused with the alleged offence which reveals from the materials collected by IO up to the stage of investigation and I have also perused the orders passed by this Court in connection with B.A.41/2025, B.A.44/2025 and A.B.33/2025 and as such, I do not find that this is a fit case to grant the concession of pre arrest bail to the accused petitioner. Hence, the application filed by the petitioner accused stands devoid of merit and accordingly the same stands dismissed/rejected. Return back the CD to the I/O through Learned P.P. along with a copy of this order. Send down the record of Learned Trial Court along with a copy of this order. With this observation, the present application stands disposed of. MOUMITA Digitally 06:06:57 +05'30' Sabyasachi B
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
A.B.No.54 of 2025
Bidhan Chandra Saha,
Age 59 years,
son of Late Satish Saha,
resident of Ward No.7, Giridhari Pally,
P.S. R.K. Pur, Udaipur, District-Gomati Tripura
---- Applicant(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura,
represented by the Secretary
to the Department of Home
New Secretariat Complex
----Respondent(s)
______________________________________________________
For Applicant(s)
: Mr. Debalaya Bhattacharya, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Samar Das, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Raju Datta, P.P.
________________________________________________________
[---
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Order
28/08/2025
This pre-arrest bail application under Section 482 of BNSS is
filed for granting pre-arrest bail to the petitioner accused in connection
with
R.K.
Pur
P.S.
Case
No.29/25
under
Section
316(5)/318(4)/318(3)336(3)/340(2)/61(2)(a) of BNS, 2023.
[02]
Heard Learned senior counsel, Mr. Debalaya Bhattacharjee
assisted by Mr. Samar Das, Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
petitioner accused and also heard Mr. Raju Datta, Learned P.P.
appearing on behalf of the State-respondent. As ordered earlier,
Learned P.P. has produced the Case Diary. We have also received the
record from the Learned Trial Court below.
[03]
At the time of hearing, Learned senior counsel appearing on
behalf of the petitioner accused drawn the attention of the Court that
the present petitioner accused has been falsely implicated in this case
because a sum of Rs.7,30,000/- was credited to his account lying with
HDFC Branch, Udaipur, by any means but he did not deposit any
(2)
amount to the said branch save and except withdrawal of loan money
and immediately the petitioner accused consulted with the branch
authority but the bank authority did not give any response to his
request and thereafter, upon verification of accounts, he paid a sum of
Rs.3,00,000/- by a cheque to one Smt. Niyati Sarkar Roy on
21.01.2025 and he is ready to pay the balance amount of Rs.4,30,000/to the actual claimant, if ordered by this Court and urged for granting
pre arrest bail to the petitioner accused stating that he is innocent and
has been falsely implicated in this case.
[04]
On the other hand, Learned P.P. strongly opposed the bail
application and first of all drawn the attention of this Court referring the
contents of the FIR dated 18.02.2025 laid by one Suman Biswas to O/C
R.K. Pur Police Station wherein in para-C and D it was specifically
mentioned as under :
“(C) A complaint was lodged by Mrs. Niyati Sarkar Roy that
there are some unauthorized transaction in her account
number 99908787462675. Further she mentioned that there is
an Overdraft facility in the account, which she is not aware.
Customer claimed amount is Rs.25,50,261/-(Rupees Twenty
five Lac fifty thousand two hundred sixty one only).
(D) A complaint was lodged by Mrs. Suniti Datta Sen has
lodged a complaint that there are some unauthorized
transactions in her account number 50100543335395. Further
she mentioned that there is an Overdraft facility in the
account, which he is not aware of. Customer claimed amount
is Rs.20,93,000/- (Rupees Twenty Lac ninety three thousand
only).”
[05]
Learned P.P. further drawn the attention of the Court that in
the second FIR it was specifically mentioned that after going through
the statement of account of the alleged fraudulent transaction it was
found that huge amount of money was transferred in the account of 1)
Mrs. Priyanka Paul, 2) Mr. Kanai Saha and 3) Mr. Bidhan Chandra Saha
i.e. the present petitioner accused. Learned P.P. thereafter drawn the
attention of the Court referring another FIR dated 10.01.2025 laid by
one Niyati Sarkar Roy to O/C R.K. Pur P.S. wherein it was mentioned
that the relationship manager Sri Abhishek Sarkar played fraud and
withdrawal amount and liquidation of her fixed deposit and transferred
(3)
the money of his account to the present petitioner accused and others.
Referring those FIRs, Learned P.P. submitted that the investigation of
the case is in progress and there is direct allegation against the
petitioner accused showing his involvement with the alleged offence. He
also referred the statements of some of the witness recorded by IO
during investigation and submitted that from the statements of those
witnesses it is crystal clear that the present petitioner accused is also
one of the conspirator of the alleged scam and he along with others
with the staff of the bank committed misappropriation of public money
from the respective accounts and referring the orders passed by this
Court in B.A.No.44/2025 dated 07.07.2025, B.A.No.41/2025 dated
27.06.2025 and A.B.No.33/2025 dated 07.08.2025, Learned P.P.
submitted that in those bail applications this Court elaborately discussed
all the issues and rejected bail applications and this present petitioner
accused is also standing on the same footing and as such, no lenient
view can be taken at this stage. Furthermore, Learned P.P. submitted
that even the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Gajanan Dattaray
Gore vs. State of Maharashtra and Anr. reported in 2025 SCC
OnLine SC 1571 in para Nos.15,16,18 and 19 specifically stated that
even
as
alleged
by
Learned
senior
counsel
that
he
refunded
Rs.3,00,000/- to Niyati Sarkar Roy still there is no scope to grant pre
arrest bail to the present petitioner accused and urged for dismissal of
this bail application.
[06]
I have heard detailed arguments of both the sides. It is on
record that on the basis of FIR laid by Suman Biswas, Branch Manager,
HDFC Branch, Udaipur to O/C R.K.Pur P.S. on 18.02.2025 this present
case has been registered against the petitioner accused and others. It is
also on record that on the basis of another FIR laid by one Niyati Sarkar
Roy another R.K. Pur P.S. Case No.5/2025 has been registered against
the petitioner accused. Further, it also appears that on fraudulent
(4)
withdrawal of money forging the signatures of different customers 4/5
cases were registered against the staff of HDFC, Udaipur Branch and
some other individual persons. This present case was registered against
the petitioner on the basis of the FIR as stated above laid by Suman
Biswas. In the FIR it was clearly mentioned that at the instance of
Abhishek Sarkar, Assistant Manager of the Branch, money was
withdrawn from different accounts of the customers by using fraud and
malpractice and those huge amount of money was transferred in the
account of different persons including the present petitioner accused.
[07]
From another connected FIR on the basis of which R.K. Pur
P.S. Case No.5/2025 has been registered laid by Niyati Sarkar Roy it
appears that at the instance of Abhishek Sarkar so many unauthorized
transaction took place including fraudulent withdrawal and liquidations
of her fixed deposit and her money was transferred to the account of
different persons namely Priyanka Paul, Kanai Saha, Asish Majumder
and the present petitioner accused also.
According to Niyati Sarkar
Roy,
of
another
informant
a
sum
Rs.25,50,261/-
was
illegally/fraudulently withdrawn from her account by using different
illegal means and methods. I have also perused the statement of
witnesses recorded by IO during the stage of investigation. It appears
that from the branch of HDFC, Udaipur a sum of Rs.82,13,261/- was
fraudulently withdrawn by the present petitioner accused and others in
illegal
association
with
the
staff
of
the
HDFC
branch.
During
investigation also the IO collected the different statement of accounts of
different consumers. It appears that from the account of one Runa
Ghosh a sum of Rs.4,50,000/- was credited to the account of the
present petitioner accused. In course of investigation, the IO also
recorded the statement of some of the consumers/customers of the said
HDFC Branch of Udaipur whose accounts were defalcated fraudulently
by different persons. This present petitioner accused moved one bail
(5)
application to the Court of Learned Sessions Judge which was also
disallowed by order dated 10.06.2025 in B.A.21/2025.
On perusal of
the case diary it appears that there is a big scam of misappropriation of
money belonging to different consumers and in this scam, not only the
few staff of the banks are involved but they in association with the
present accused and others committed the offence as alleged. Learned
senior counsel at the time of hearing although submitted that the
accused has refunded Rs.3,00,000/- to one Niyati Sarkar Roy on
21.01.2025 but (Annexure-5) in this regard no such intimation was
given by him to the police, even, no such documentary evidence was
produced and proved by the accused before this Court or to the Learned
Court below to substantiate that he had no knowledge about the
unauthorized transfer of fund to his account from other source which as
a bonafide citizen of country he cannot ignore his responsibility and
after perusal of the materials on record there is no scope to believe that
he was/is totally innocent about the alleged offence because in both the
FIRs as alleged there was clear indication against him showing his
involvement with the alleged offence. So, the submission of Learned
senior counsel for the accused that he is willing to refund back the
amount to the other consumer does not make any credence of this
Court showing his innocence with the alleged crime. In this regard,
reliance is placed upon the citation of the Hon’ble apex Court in
Gajanan Dattaray Gore vs. State of Maharashtra and Anr.
reported in 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1571 wherein in para Nos.15,16,18
and 19 Hon’ble Apex Court specifically stated as under :
“15. We have noticed over a period of time that orders of
regular bail and anticipatory bail are being passed by
different High Courts subject to deposit of some amount.
16. We have come across cases like the one in hand
where accused persons have gone to the extent of filing
affidavits in the form of undertaking that they would
deposit a particular amount within a particular period
and then conveniently resile from such undertakings
saying it is an onerous condition.
(6)
18. The case in hand is one in which the appellant on his
own free will and volition filed an affidavit in the form of
an undertaking before the High Court that he would
deposit an amount of Rs. 25,00,000/- but ultimately
resiled to do so and the High Court had to cancel the
bail. It was too much for the lawyer of the appellant to
argue before the High Court that asking his client to
deposit Rs. 25,00,000/- was unreasonable. It reflects on
the professional ethics.
19. By this order, we make it clear and that too in the
form of directions that henceforth no Trial Court or any
of the High Courts shall pass any order of grant of
regular bail or anticipatory bail on any undertaking that
the accused might be ready to furnish for the purpose of
obtaining appropriate reliefs.”
Relying upon the same, it appears that even if the accused
petitioner is also willing to refund the said amount that cannot be a
ground for consideration of his bail and furthermore, since there is
involvement of accused with the alleged offence which reveals from the
materials collected by IO up to the stage of investigation and I have
also perused the orders passed by this Court in connection with
B.A.41/2025, B.A.44/2025 and A.B.33/2025 and as such, I do not find
that this is a fit case to grant the concession of pre arrest bail to the
accused petitioner.
Hence, the application filed by the petitioner accused stands
devoid of merit and accordingly the same stands dismissed/rejected.
Return back the CD to the I/O through Learned P.P. along
with a copy of this order.
Send down the record of Learned Trial Court along with a
copy of this order.
With
this
observation,
the
present
application
stands
disposed of.
JUDGE
signed by
MOUMITA Digitally
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2025.08.29
DATTA
06:06:57 +05'30'
Sabyasachi B
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review