Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/12
GAHC010265052025
2026:GAU-AS:2800
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/7063/2025
SRI ATUL DEKA
SON OF LAMBADHAR DEKA, RESIDENT OF PUB- DHARAMTUL, PODHARAMTUL, PS- JAGIROD, DIST.- MORIGAON, ASSAM, PIN- 782421
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 3 ORS
REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM, HOME
DEPARTMENT, DISPUR, GUWAHATI-06, KAMRUP (M)
2:DIRECTOR OF FIRE AND EMERGENCY SERVICE
HEAD QUARTER
PANBAZAR
GUWAHATI-01
3:DEPUTY DIRECTOR
FIRE AND EMERGENCY SERVICES
ASSAM
PANBAZAR
GUWAHATI-01
4:IN CHARGE
LAKHRA FIRE AND EMERGENCY SERVICE STATION
GUWAHATI- 781034
ASSA
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MS B SHARMA, MR D K NATH,MS M DAS
Advocate for the Respondent : GA, ASSAM,
Page No.# 2/12
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE N. UNNI KRISHNAN NAIR
ORDER
Date : 19-02-2026
Heard Mr. D.K. Nath, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. J.K.
Goswami, learned Addl. Sr. Govt. Advocate, Assam appearing for the respondents.
2.
As agreed to by the learned counsel for the parties, the present writ petition was
taken up for final consideration and is being disposed of by this order.
3.
The petitioner in the present proceeding has assailed an order dated 27-10-2021,
passed by the Disciplinary Authority imposing upon him the penalty of removal from
service, as well as treating the period of purported absence w.e.f. 30-05-2020 to 11-112020 as “leave without pay” by applying the Principle of “No Work, No Pay”.
4.
The petitioner while serving as a Driver at the Sonari Fire & Emergency Station,
came to be placed under suspension vide order dated 30-05-2020, basing on allegations
of misconduct emanating against him. Thereafter, the Disciplinary Authority proceeded to
issue a show-cause notice dated 29-10-2020 to the petitioner instituting a Departmental
Proceeding against him, invoking the provision of Rule 9 of the Assam Services (Discipline
& Appeal) Rules, 1964. At this stage, it is to be noted that the Disciplinary Authority had
vide order dated 10-03-2021, revoked the suspension order of the petitioner and had
reinstated him, in his service with retrospective effect, i.e. w.e.f. 12-11-2020. The
petitioner in his show-cause reply, did not specially deal with the allegations leveled
against him. The said reply not being found to be satisfactory, the Disciplinary Authority
proceeded to direct for an enquiry in the matter and for the purpose an Enquiry Officer as
Page No.# 3/12
well as a Presenting Officer came to be appointed. The petitioner is found to have
participated in the said enquiry. The Enquiry Officer after examining the witnesses
produced by the Presenting Officer and also upon recording the statement of the
petitioner, proceeded to submit his enquiry report on 21-08-2021, inter alia, holding that
the charges leveled against the petitioner stood established. A copy of the said enquiry
report is found to have been served upon the petitioner and he had also submitted his
representation thereto.
The Disciplinary Authority, thereafter, on perusal of the enquiry report in the light of
the contention made by the petitioner in the representation submitted by him in the
matter, proceeded to agree with the findings so recorded by the Enquiry Officer. Basing on
the materials coming on record, the Disciplinary Authority vide order dated 27-10-2021
concluded that the petitioner was found to be unfit for service in the Fire & Emergency
department. Accordingly, the petitioner was imposed with penalty of removal from service
with immediate effect. The Disciplinary Authority with regard to the purported period of
absence of the petitioner w.e.f. 30-05-2020 to 11-11-2020 held that the petitioner for the
said period would not be entitled to any monetary benefits and the period would be
treated as “leave without pay”.
Being aggrieved, the petitioner had preferred an appeal before the appellate
authority and therein had taken a plea of suffering from mental ailments. The appellate
authority on consideration of the appeal so filed by the petitioner proceeded vide order
dated 14-11-2022 to reject the said appeal and thereby, upheld the penalty of removal
from service as imposed upon the petitioner by the Disciplinary Authority. The Appellate
Page No.# 4/12
Authority with regard to the plea of mental ailments taken by the petitioner had
concluded basing on the materials brought on record that the petitioner had received
treatment in this connection only w.e.f. 28-12-2020, however, the misconduct alleged
against the petitioner had occasioned much prior thereto.
Being aggrieved with the penalty imposed upon him as well as the order of the
Appellate Authority, the petitioner has instituted the present proceeding.
5.
Mr. D.K. Nath, learned counsel for the petitioner after reiterating the facts noticed,
hereinabove, has submitted that the petitioner at the relevant period of time was
suffering from mental ailments and accordingly, he was not in a position to take requisite
steps for defending himself before the Enquiry Officer. Mr. Nath submits that the petitioner
because of his condition was also prevented from cross-examining the witnesses as
produced by the Presenting Officer in the enquiry. Mr. Nath by referring to the orders
passed by the Disciplinary Authority has submitted that the said order of penalty as
imposed upon the petitioner of removal from service is clearly disproportionate to the
allegations leveled against the petitioner in the matter and accordingly, this Court would
require to interfere with the said penalty and direct the Disciplinary Authority to impose
any other penalty which would not have the effect of termination of service of the
petitioner. Mr. Nath also by referring to the order passed by the Disciplinary Authority has
submitted that the Disciplinary Authority erroneously has construed that the petitioner
was unauthorisedly absent during the period w.e.f. 30-05-2020 to 11-11-2020, inasmuch
as, the petitioner was during the said period placed under suspension. Accordingly, Mr.
Nath submits that for the said period the petitioner would be entitled to his due
Page No.# 5/12
remuneration. Mr. Nath has also clarified that the petitioner during the period of
suspension was not paid any subsistence allowance.
6.
Per contra, Mr. J.K. Goswami, learned Addl. Sr. Govt. Advocate, Assam submits that
although an affidavit in the matter has not filed by the respondent authority, he is
furnishing the original records of the Departmental Proceeding instituted against the
petitioner. Mr. Goswami submits that the petitioner, herein, being a member of a
disciplined force and being engaged as a Driver in Fire and Emergency service, his
conduct is clearly unbecoming of a member of the disciplined force. Mr. Goswami submits
that the allegation leveled against the petitioner vide show-cause notice dated 29-102020 was literally admitted to by the petitioner in his show-cause reply as well as in the
statement made by him during the enquiry. Mr. Goswami by taking this Court through the
records, as produced by him, has submitted that the departmental witnesses who had
deposed during the enquiry had established the misconduct committed by the petitioner
in the matter and the petitioner although was granted an opportunity to cross-examine
such witnesses, the petitioner categorically declined the same. Mr. Goswami further
submits that the petitioner has not contended of any prejudice being caused to him in
effectively defending the charge framed against him. Mr. Goswami by referring to the
enquiry report has submitted that the Enquiry Officer after taking into consideration all
relevant factors had proceeded to conclude that the petitioner, herein, was guilty of the
charges so framed against him vide the show-cause notice dated 29-10-2020. Mr.
Goswami submits that although the petitioner was held to be unauthorisedly absent for
the period w.e.f. 30-05-2020 to 11-11-2020, during the said period the petitioner was
Page No.# 6/12
under order of suspension.
7.
Mr. Goswami in the above premises has submitted that there being no procedural
error highlighted in the matter by the petitioner and the conclusions drawn by the Enquiry
Officer towards holding the charges leveled against the petitioner to have been
established being so based on the materials coming on record during the enquiry, the
Disciplinary Authority having concurred with the findings of the Enquiry Officer, the
penalty imposed upon the petitioner would not mandate an interference from this Court.
8.
I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and have also perused the
materials available on record.
9.
The petitioner vide a show-cause notice dated 29-10-2020 was charged as
follows:“While you were posted at Sonari Fire & Emergency Services Station, the In-
charge of Sonari Fire & Emergency Services Station reported that you are very
Indiscipline and habitual alcoholic. On 27/05/2020 you were creating nuisance
under influence of liquor and urinated inside the barrack while all staffs were in the
barrack. On 28/05/2020 you were found positive in alcohol test done at Sub
Divisional Civil Hospital, Sonari, Charaideo. Accordingly, you were produced in O.R.
on 30/05/2020 and heard you in person where you were found guilty. So, you were
placed under suspension w.e.f. 30/05/2020 PM for your indiscipline conduct.
Secondly, you are remaining unauthorised absence from duty w.e.f. 31/05/2020 to
till date.
Earlier, D/P No. 16/2018 was drawn up against you for your gross
indiscipline conduct which was disposed off by awarding stoppage of 2 (two)
Annual Increment with Cumulative effect. Inspite of that you have not try to reform
yourself.”
10.
A perusal of the said show-cause notice would reveal that the allegations leveled
Page No.# 7/12
against the petitioner was that he was a habitually indisciplined personnel and was
addicted to alcohol. It was further alleged that on 27-05-2020, the petitioner had created
a nuisance under the influence of liquor and had urinated inside the barrack while all staff
were present. It is also alleged that on 28-05-2020, the petitioner being found to be in an
intoxicated condition was sent to the Sub-Divisional Civil Hospital, Sonari at Charaideo for
examination and the same was confirmed from the result of his blood test. Further
allegation levelled against the petitioner is that he had unauthorisedly remained absent
from duty w.e.f. 31-05-2020. The show-cause also refers to earlier proceedings drawn
against the petitioner in the form of DP No. 16/2018 and award of penalty of stoppage of
02 (two) annual increments with cumulative effect upon him. The allegations reveal that
inspite of the earlier proceeding instituted against the petitioner, the petitioner had not
reformed himself. The petitioner is found to have submitted his show-cause reply in the
matter and therein had contended that he would never cause any negligence and/ or
commit any misconduct during his duty hours and if he was found to commit such
misconduct he would be liable to be terminated. The Disciplinary Authority had not taken
cognizance of the admission made by the petitioner in his show-cause reply and had
proceeded to direct for an enquiry in the matter. Accordingly, an Enquiry Officer and a
Presenting Officer came to be appointed.
11.
This Court has perused the deposition made by the departmental witnesses in the
matter and finds that the departmental witnesses had brought on record materials
towards establishing the allegations levelled against the petitioner. The petitioner is found
to have been given the opportunity to cross-examine the departmental witnesses,
Page No.# 8/12
however, the petitioner had declined to do so. Thereafter, the statement of the petitioner
was recorded, wherein, he admitted to the allegations levelled against him. Basing on the
said materials coming on record, the Enquiry Officer vide the report dated 21-08-2021
proceeded to hold the petitioner guilty of the charges so framed against him. The Enquiry
Officer in his findings had contended that the allegations leveled against the petitioner
was established by the evidences coming on record. However, the Enquiry Officer had not
returned any finding with regard to the allegation of the petitioner remaining
unauthorisedly absent. A copy of the said enquiry report was forwarded to the petitioner
vide communication dated 07-09-2021 and the petitioner is found to have submitted a
representation, thereon.
12.
The Disciplinary Authority, thereafter, on consideration of the enquiry report in the
light of the contention raised by the petitioner in his representation, had proceeded to
consider the matter for determining the penalty that would now be required to be
imposed upon the petitioner. It is to be noted that the Disciplinary Authority had on
perusal of the findings of the Enquiry Officer concurred with the same. Having concurred
with the findings of the Enquiry Officer, the Disciplinary Authority proceeded to draw a
conclusion to the effect that the petitioner was found to be unfit for service in Fire &
Emergency department where he would be required to be available 24 hours in alert and
sound mind to save the property of the public from fire and disaster. Basing on the said
conclusion, the Disciplinary Authority proceeded to impose upon the petitioner the penalty
of removal from service with immediate effect. Further the period of purported absence of
the petitioner w.e.f. 30-05-2020 to 11-11-2020, he was held to be not entitled to any
Page No.# 9/12
monetary benefits by invoking the Principle of “No Work No Pay”. The petitioner,
thereafter, preferred an appeal in the matter before the Appellate Authority and therein
had taken a plea of suffering from mental ailments since 2018. The Appellate Authority on
consideration of the contemporaneous records as well as the contentions raised by the
petitioner in his appeal along with the documents so annexed to the appeal memo,
proceeded vide order dated 14-11-2022, to reject the appeal preferred by the petitioner
and thereby upheld the order of the Disciplinary Authority.
13.
This Court on perusal of the materials on record finds that the petitioner has not
highlighted any procedural impropriety committed by the authorities in conduct of the
proceeding against him.
14.
This Court has perused the findings so recorded by the Enquiry Officer and has
found that the findings of the Enquiry Officer is in tune with the evidence adduced in the
matter by the departmental witnesses as well as the statement of the petitioner, herein,
and no perversity is found with regard to such findings. This Court, thereafter, has
perused the order dated 27-10-2021, passed by the Disciplinary Authority and finds that
the Disciplinary Authority had concurred with the findings of the Enquiry Officer and there
is no perversity found with regard to the conclusion arrived at in the matter by the
Disciplinary Authority. The penalty that is to be imposed being one which is in the realm
of the Disciplinary Authority, this Court does not find that the penalty of removal from
service imposed upon the petitioner to be disproportionate to the allegations established
against the petitioner. This Court notices that the petitioner is a member of a disciplined
force and the conduct that was alleged and established against the petitioner naturally
Page No.# 10/12
renders the petitioner unfit to continue in a disciplined force like Fire & Emergency
service. Accordingly, the punishment of removal from service as imposed upon the
petitioner is found to be proportionate to the allegation established against the petitioner
and the same would not call for any interference.
15.
Having drawn the said conclusion, this Court has perused the order dated 14-11-
2022 passed by the Appellate Authority. This Court finds that in the appeal, the petitioner
has taken a plea of suffering from mental ailments. However, such plea is not found to
have been taken by the petitioner during the conduct of the Departmental Enquiry against
him. There is no materials brought on record by the petitioner to reveal that he had
approached the Enquiry Officer and the Disciplinary Authority raising a plea that he was
suffering from mental ailments and was accordingly not in a position to effectively defend
the charges levelled against him. This Court finds that the Appellate Authority had rightly
appreciated the records in the matter and had come to a conclusion that the petitioner
during the time when he had committed the misconduct so alleged against him was not
found to be suffering from any mental ailments. This Court from the records produced
also finds that subsequently a certificate was issued by the Doctors attending upon the
petitioner that the petitioner was fit from all ailments. The above being the position, the
petitioner also being found to be an alcohol dependent person, the conduct of the
petitioner, accordingly, is not found to be in connosance with that required of a person
belonging to a disciplined force. Accordingly, this Court does not find any error with the
conclusion drawn by the Appellate Authority in the matter and accordingly, the order
dated 14-11-2022 would also not mandate any interference.
Page No.# 11/12
16.
Having drawn the above conclusions, this Court would now examine the decision of
the Disciplinary Authority with regard to the period of purported absence of the petitioner
w.e.f. 30-05-2020 to 11-11-2020. This Court finds that the petitioner was placed under
suspension vide order dated 30-05-2020 and he continued to remain under suspension. A
person under suspension cannot said to be unauthorizedly absent. The petitioner’s
suspension was revoked vide an order dated 10-03-2021 with retrospective effect, i.e.
w.e.f. 12-11-2020. Accordingly, the petitioner, for the period from 30-05-2020 to 11-112020 cannot be held to be unauthorizedly absent. Accordingly, the said period of
suspension would now be mandated to be regularized by the Disciplinary Authority by
passing a speaking order in the matter.
17.
The Disciplinary Authority would now pass an speaking order towards regulating
the said period of suspension of the petitioner w.e.f. 30-05-2020 to 11-11-2020 within a
period of 03 (three) months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order. The
Disciplinary Authority while passing the speaking order shall also take note of the
submission made by the learned counsel for the petitioner that the petitioner during the
period of suspension was not authorized with any subsistence allowance. Subject to the
direction with regard to the manner in which the period of absence of the petitioner w.e.f.
30-05-2020 to 11-11-2020 is to be so construed, the penalty as imposed upon the
petitioner by the Disciplinary Authority vide the order dated 27-10-2021, as well as the
order dated 14-11-2022 passed by the Appellate Authority are not interfered with.
18.
In view of the above, the present writ petition is held to be devoid of any merit and
the same stands dismissed. However, there would be no order as to cost.
Page No.# 12/12
19.
The original records so produced by Mr. J.K. Goswami, learned Addl. Sr. Govt.
Advocate, Assam be returned forthwith.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review