Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA No.44 of 2022
1.
Sri Ashutosh Debnath,
Age 60 years,
Son of Late Nishi Kanta Debnath,
R/O South Singicherra,
P.O. Singicherra, P.S. Khowai,
District: Khowai, PIN: 799 201
2.
Smt. Bakul Debnath,
Age 55 years,
Wife of Sri Ashutosh Debnath,
R/O South Singicherra,
P.O. Singicherra, P.S. Khowai,
District: Khowai, PIN: 799 201
3.(a) Smt. Sailabala Debnath,
Age 70 years,
Wife of Late Bhuban Chandra Deb Nath,
R/O Char Ganki, P.O. Ganki,
P.S. Khowai, District: Khowai,
PIN: 799 202
3.(b) Sri Babul Debnath,
Age 55 years,
Son of Late Bhuban Chandra Deb Nath,
R/O Char Ganki, P.O. Ganki,
P.S. Khowai, District: Khowai,
PIN: 799 202
3.(c) Sri Nakul Debnath,
Age 50 years,
Son of Late Bhuban Chandra Deb Nath,
R/O Char Ganki, P.O. Ganki,
P.S. Khowai, District: Khowai,
PIN: 799 202
3.(d) Sri Bipul Debnath,
Age 45 years,
Son of Late Bhuban Chandra Deb Nath,
R/O Char Ganki, P.O. Ganki,
P.S. Khowai, District: Khowai,
PIN: 799 202
3.(e) Smt. Rama Debnath,
Age 60 years,
Daughter of Late Bhuban Chandra Deb Nath,
Wife of Late Jatindra Deb Nath,
R/O Dashamighat, P.S. Teliamura,
District: Khowai
----Appellant-Defendant (s)
Versus
Sri Biswajit Dey,
Son of late Nirode Baran Dey,
Resident of BBC Para, P.S. Khowai,
P.O. Khowai Court, Sub-Division: Khowai,
District: Khowai, PIN: 799 202
---- Sole Respondent-Plaintiff (s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Adv.
Mr. K. Nath, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S. Lodh, Adv.
Date of Hearing
:
21.02.2024
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order :
26.02.2024
Whether fit for
Reporting
NO
:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This appeal is preferred by the appellant-defendants
challenging the judgment and decree dated 12.07.2022
passed by Learned District Judge, Khowai Tripura in
connection with Case No.Title Appeal 01 of 2021. By the
said judgment Learned First Appellate Court dismissing the
appeal affirmed and upheld the judgment passed by
Learned
Trial
Court
i.e.
Learned
Civil
Judge
(Junior
Division), Khowai Judicial District, Court No.1 in Title Suit
No.19 of 2013. Before entering in to the merit of the appeal
let us discuss about the subject matter of the dispute
amongst the rival parties.
02.
The present respondent as plaintiff filed a suit
before the court of Learned Civil Judge (Junior Division),
Khowai Judicial District, Court No.1 seeking the following
reliefs:
“i. Pass a decree declaring that the Plaintiff having
adversely possessed the suit land continuously for more
than the statutory period of 12 years as against the
Defendant No 1 has attained the non-evictable status and
continuous possession has matured into title as against
the Defendant No.1.
ii. Pass a decree of perpetual injunction restraining the
Defendants or their representatives, agents, workmen
from entering into the suit land or disturbing the peaceful
possession.
iii. If any deed of transfer is executed by the Defendant
No 1 in favour of the Defendant No 2 in respect of the
suit land is to be declared void and illegal.
iii.(a) The sale deed dated 13.12.2012 executed by the
Defendant No 2 in favour of his wife, i.e., the Defendant
No 3 by dint of deed of power of attorney executed by
Defendant No 1 is to be declared void, sham in character
and without consequence by a decree.
iv. Pass orders as to cost and any other order or orders
as may be deemed fit and proper for ends of justice.”
03.
In the plaint the respondent-plaintiff asserted
that the original defendant Bhuban Debnath No.1 was the
owner of the suit land, but the father of the respondentplaintiff was in possession of the suit land since 18.10.1962
and after his death in the year 1991 the respondent-plaintiff
started possessing the suit land and thus acquired right of
adverse possession. Initially one Bhuban Chandra Debnath
and Ashutosh Debnath were the original defendants in Title
Suit No.19/2013. Thereafter the respondent-plaintiff filed an
application before the Learned Trial Court under Order 1
Rule 10(2) read with Order VI Rule 17 of CPC for addition of
party and for amendment of pleading. Learned Civil Judge
vide
order
dated
12.02.2014
rejected
the
prayer
of
amendment of pleading and allowed the petition for addition
of party and thus one Smt. Bakul Debnath, i.e. the present
appellant No.2 was impleaded as defendant No.3. In the
amendment of plaint the respondent-plaintiff contended
that portion of suit land measuring 0.16 acre has been
transferred by registered sale-deed on 13.12.2012 by which
the present appellant No.1 by way of Power of Attorney
transferred a portion of suit land in favour of appellant No.2,
i.e his wife and the respondent-plaintiff contended that the
sale-deed dated 13.12.2012 was nothing but a mere paper
transaction and sham in character and in absence of
delivery of possession the said sale-deed was liable to be
declared
as
void.
Thereafter
the
respondent-plaintiff
preferred Civil Revision Petition before the High Court
against the order dated 12.02.2014 passed by Learned Civil
Judge
(Junior
Division),
Khowai,
West
Tripura
in
T.S.19/2013 and vide order dated 25.06.2014 passed in
CRP No.23 of 2014 the High Court allowed the petition and
also allowed amendment of pleading and addition of party in
connection with Case No. T.S.19/2013. After that said
Bhuvan Chandra Debnath died and his legal heirs i.e. the
present appellant Nos.3(a), 3(b), 3(c), 3(d) and 3(e) and
Bakul Debnath were substituted and later on Bakul Debnath
also died.
04.
The present appellant contested the suit by filing
written statement and it was asserted by the appellant that
suit land was never possessed by the father of the
respondent-plaintiff and after his death the respondent did
not possess the suit land. Rather it was all along under the
possession of the appellant-defendants. It was further
asserted that the appellant No.1 on the basis of Power of
Attorney transferred 0.16 acres of land to the wife of the
appellant No.2. Thus the appellant-defendants by the
written statement prayed for dismissal of the suit with
costs. Upon the pleadings of the parties Learned Court
below framed the following issues:
(i) Whether the suit is maintainable in its present
form and nature?
(ii) Whether the plaintiff has acquired non evictable
status and title upon the suit land on the principle of
adverse possession?
(iii) Whether the sale deed dated, 13.12.2012 is void
and sham in character?
(iv)Whether the plaintiff is entitled to the decree as
prayed for?
05.
Before
the
Learned
court
both
the
parties
adduced oral/documentary evidence on record as under:
(A) Defendants Witness:DW-1:- Ashutosh Debnath
DW-2:- Smt. Saila Debnath
DW-3:- Sri Haridhan Paul
(B) Defendants Exhibits:(1) Exhibit. A- Original General power of Attorney
executed
by
Bhuban
Ch.
Debnath
dated,
10.09.2012 in three sheets.
(2) Exhibit. A-1- Signatures of Bhuban Ch. Debnath
in the power of Attorney.
(3) Exhibit. B- Signatures of DW No.1 in the
Original sale deed being No.1-1414 executed by
Ashutosh Debnath in favour of his wife.
(4) Exhibit. C – 02 Nos. of certified copy of Khatian
No.3223 and 897.
(C) Plaintiffs Witnesses:PW-1:- Sri Biswajit Dey.
(D) Plaintiffs Exhibits:(1)Exhibit. 1- Certified copy of Khatian No.897 of
Mouja-Fatikroy in favour of Subal Das.
(2)Exhibit.2 – Certified copy of the order of District
Collector dated, 22.05.2013 along with enquiry
report from SDM, DCM, Revenue Inspector and
Tehshilder passed in Revenue case No.39 of 2012.
(E) Court Witness:- Nil.
(F) Court Exhibits:- Nil.
06.
The operative portion of the judgment and order
dated 22.01.2021 passed by the Learned Trial court runs as
under:
“12.In the result, the instant suit is decreed with costs in
favour of the plaintiff Sri Biswajit Dey and it is declared
that he has right, title, interest and possession over the
suit land which has matured into title by way of adverse
possession against the true owner, Defendant No.1Bhuvan Ch. Debnath.
13. Perpetual injunction is also granted in favour of the
plaintiff Sri Biswajit Dey over the suit land with the result
that the defendants and their men/agents are perpetually
restrained from entering into the suit land or in anyway
disturbing the peaceful possession and enjoyment of the
said suit land by the plaintiff.
14. The sale deed being no.1-1414 dated 13.12.2012 is
hereby declared illegal, void for all purpose.
15. Prepare decree accordingly and put up for signature
within 14(fourteen) days from today.
16. The judgment is given under my hand and seal of this
court on this 22nd day of January, 2021.
17. The case is thus disposed of on contest.
18. Make necessary entry in the trial register.
19. Upload the judgment in CIS and consign the record to
the Record Room in due course of time.”
07.
Challenging the judgment the present appellants
preferred an appeal under Section 96 of CPC before the
Learned District Judge, Khowai Tripura which was numbered
as Title Appeal 01 of 2021 and after hearing of arguments
Learned First Appellate court by judgment and decree dated
12.07.2022 dismissed the appeal of the present appellant
upholding the judgment of the Learned Trial Court. The
operative portion of the judgment of the Learned First
Appellate Court runs as follows:
“The appeal is hereby dismissed.
The Judgment and decree passed by the trial court is
hereby upheld.
Send down the case record along with a copy of this
judgment to the Ld. Trial Court.
Accordingly, this appeal is disposed of on contest.
Make necessary entry in the relevant TR as well as in the
CIS.”
08.
Challenging that judgment the present appellants
have preferred this appeal before the High Court. At the
time of admission of the appeal before this High Court the
following substantial questions of law were formulated by
order dated 20.09.2022:
“(I) Whether the finding of the court below to the effect,
that, the Respondent is in possession of the suit land
being his name recorded in the Khatian of the suit land as
occupier is perverse in view of the Exhibit C i.e., Khatian
Nos.3223 & 897, wherefrom it is established, that, the
Appellant No.2 is Rayati of land measuring 0.16 acre out
of suit land measuring 0.17 acre and Respondent is not
shown either and permissive possessor or forceful
possessor of the suit land.
(II) Whether finding of the Court below declaring, that,
the Respondent has adverse possession over the suit
land is against the settled principle of law as to how
adverse possession is to be proved.”
09.
At the time of hearing of argument Learned
Senior counsel Mr. P. Roy Barman appearing for the
appellants
submitted
that
both
the
courts
below
misinterpreted the legal proposition of ‘adverse possession’
and came to an erroneous and perverse finding. According
to Learned senior counsel before the Learned Trial Court
there was no evidence of adverse possession to allow the
Learned Court below to grant the decree of adverse
possession in favour of the respondent-plaintiff. Because to
substantiate the contention of ‘adverse possession’ the
respondent-plaintiff save and except himself could not
adduce any further oral evidence on record nor could
produce
any
documentary
evidence
on
record
to
substantiate his claim. Learned senior counsel further
submitted that in the judgment of the Learned Trial court
there was no clear finding and observation regarding
acquisition of ‘adverse possession’ as alleged by the
respondent-plaintiff. He also drawn the attention of the
court the para numbers 2, 3, 5 and 6 of the plaint submitted
by the respondent-plaintiff and submitted that according to
the respondent-plaintiff since from the year 1962 the
respondent-plaintiff and his father were/are in possession of
the suit land, but in this regard no oral/documentary
evidence could be produced and proved by the respondentplaintiff. Furthermore, regarding possession no evidence
could be laid by the respondent-plaintiff and more so, the
Learned Trial Court below was not supposed to decide the
‘sale-deed’ as a sham transaction. But without proper
determination of the plea of adverse possession as alleged
by the respondent-plaintiff gave an erroneous observation
in favour of the respondent-plaintiff. Further, Learned senior
counsel submitted that to substantiate the inquiry report
and the order of the Revenue Authority no authority of the
Revenue Department was produced as witness by the
respondent-plaintiff
to
substantiate
his
case.
Further,
Learned senior counsel drawn the attention of the court that
the Learned Trial Court below wrongly decided issue No.3 in
favour of the respondent-plaintiff and finally in absence of
proper evidence on record decreed the suit in favour of the
respondent-plaintiff
illegally
and
the
judgment
of
the
Learned First Appellate Court was nothing but a replica of
this judgment of the Learned Trial Court and finally urged
before the court to set aside the judgment of the Learned
First Appellate Court.
10.
On the contrary, Learned counsel Mr. S. Lodh
appearing for the respondent-plaintiff taking part in the
hearing and submitted that in para-2 of the plaint the
respondent-plaintiff specifically stated that since from the
date of 18.10.1962 the father of the respondent-plaintiff
was possessing the suit land within the knowledge of
Bhuban Chandra Debnath and after his death in the year
1991 the present respondent-plaintiff has been possessing
the suit land denying the right, title and interest of the
appellant-defendants
over
this
suit
land.
Thus
the
respondent-plaintiff has acquired the right of adverse
possession over the suit land and said Bhuban Chandra
Debnath during his lifetime never raised any protest. But in
the year 2012, suddenly the appellant-defendant No.2
(original
suit)
appeared
respondent-plaintiff
and
stating
raised
that
the
objection
to
defendant
the
No.1
(original suit) has sold the suit land to him by executing
registered sale-deed. It was further asserted that knowing
the same the respondent-plaintiff searched the matter to
the office of the Sub-Registrar, Khowai but he could not
trace out anything. According to him said Bhuban Chandra
Debnath
through
attorney
sold
the suit
land to
the
defendant No.3 (original suit) who collusively purchased the
same knowing fully that the respondent-plaintiff was in
forceful possession against the defendant No.1 (original
suit) for about 50 years. Thereafter, he filed an application
before the Collector, Khowai under Section 95 of the TRL &
LR Act claiming that his name has not been recorded in
column No.16 of the relevant Khatian No.897 as forceful
occupier and accordingly the District Collector arranged for
inquiry and on the basis of inquiry report the District
Collector directed SDM, Khowai to incorporate the name of
respondent-plaintiff in column No.16 of the relevant khatian
as forceful occupier and according to Learned counsel the
respondent-plaintiff was in possession of the suit land for
more than 50 years without any obstruction from any
corner by doing all acts of possession continuously, openly,
peacefully
and
adversely
against
the
defendant
No.1
(original suit) in hostile assertion of his right in the suit land
and thus he acquired right, title and interest of the suit
land.
Learned
counsel
further
submitted
that
as
the
respondent-plaintiff has been able to establish his ‘adverse
possession’ against the original true owner so the title of the
appellant-defendant No.1 has been extinguished by way of
adverse possession and he was possessing the suit land
which was adequate in continuity, publicity and without
interruption from any corner more than statutory period of
12 years. Finally Learned counsel for the respondentplaintiff
submitted
that
both
the
courts
below
after
considering oral/documentary evidence on record granted
decree in favour of the respondent-plaintiff and urged for
dismissal of this present appeal.
11.
I have heard arguments of both the sides and
gone through the records of the Learned courts below. To
substantiate the suit before the Learned Trial court the
respondent-plaintiff was examined as PW-1 and he relied
upon two documents which were marked as Exbt.1 and 2.
On the other hand, the appellant-defendants adduced three
witnesses and relied upon some documents which were
marked as exhibits. The respondent-plaintiff as PW-1 in his
examination-in-chief
in
affidavit
stated
that
suit
land
measuring 0.17 acres under Mouja West Singicherra of
Khatian No.897 appertaining to C.S. Plot Nos.1309/3892,
1309 corresponding to R.S. Plot No.1639 & 1640 of
Viti(Nal), shop(Nal) classes of land and the same was the
jote land of the original defendant No.1 and he was the sole
owner of the suit land and record of right was also prepared
in his name. He further stated that his father was in
possession of the suit land since from 18.10.1962 forcibly
i.e. by virtue of the right of adverse possession knowing
fully that the said defendant was the real owner of the suit
land and his father developed the suit land in its present
position and he constructed a shop therein which was the
earning source of his income and the rest other portion of
the suit land was used by his father for agricultural purpose.
He further stated that his father died in the year 1991 and
since then he has been possessing the suit land as one of
the successor in the way his father possessed and on expiry
of the stipulated period of 12 years the right of adverse
possession was ripened and he was also possessing the suit
land in continuation of his father denying the right, title and
interest of the lawful owner i.e. the defendant No.1 but said
defendant No.1 never raised any objection and thus he was
possessing the suit land more than 50 years without any
interruption from any corner. On 21.09.2012 the defendant
No.2
appeared
and
raised
objection
to
his
peaceful
possession and stated that he has purchased the suit land
by virtue of registered sale-deed. But he could not trace out
any deed. Later on, he filed an application before the
Collector, Khowai for recording his name. The matter was
inquired by SDM, Khowai along with other Revenue staff
when it was found that he was the forceful occupier of the
suit land and he possessed the same more than the
statutory period and accordingly he filed the suit. He relied
upon khatian No.897 which was marked as Exbt.1 and
relied upon certified copy of the order of the District
Collector dated 22.05.2013 which was marked as Exbt.2 in
five sheets. During cross-examination save and except
denial nothing came out relevant. He further stated that he
heard Bhuban Chandra Debnath executed Power of Attorney
in favour of one Ashutosh Debnath and said Ashutosh
Debnath by way of sale-deed transferred the suit land to
one Bakul Debnath. But he volunteered that the suit land
was never handed over to said Bakul Debnath and all along
it was under his possession. He further stated that he knows
that the Amin and Tehshildar are required to enquire any
land prior to mutation. But in the instant case they did not
visit the suit land. But again he was put under crossexamination with the negative form that the Amin and
Tehshildar did not visit the suit land and he filed a prayer
before the SDM, DCM for cancellation of the khatian of
Bakul Debnath.
12.
As already stated the present appellants as
defendants
adduced
three
witnesses.
DW-1,
Ashutosh
Debnath in his examination-in-chief tried to support his
version in the written statement. He also relied upon the
original Power of Attorney executed by Bhuban Chandra
Debnath on 10.09.2012 marked Exbt.A in three sheets,
sale-deed No.1-1414 executed by him in favour of his wife
and identified his signature marked Exbt.B and submitted
two numbers of certified copy of finally published khatian
No.3223 marked as Exbt.C and certified copy of finally
published Khatian No.897 marked Exbt.C. During crossexamination he stated that he reside along with his wife and
Bhuban Debnath breathed his last at Charjanki and stayed
therein for a period of 35 years and Nirode Dey had a shop
located in the land of Bhuban Debnath.
Similarly, DW-2 in her examination-in-chief tried
to support the version of DW-1 and in her examination-inchief she stated that her husband Bhuban Chandra Debnath
executed a Power of Attorney in favour of Ashutosh Debnath
and identified her signature on the Power of Attorney
marked as Exbt.A1 in four pages. During cross by the
respondent-plaintiff she stated that they did not sell any
land and Ashutosh Debnath is her nephew who was given
some power. But they did not get any purchase money.
13.
DW-3, Haridhan Paul also in his examination-in-
chief tried to support the version of DW-1. During cross he
deposed that Bhuban Debnath breathed his last at Charjanki
and the distance between the suit land and Charjanki is
about 05 kms.
These are the synopsis evidence on record of the
parties.
14.
After going through the pleadings of the parties
and also after going through the evidence on record of the
parties adduced before the Learned Trial Court and also
after going through the judgments of the Learned Court
below it appears that there was/is no dispute on record that
the suit land was/is under peaceful possession of the father
of the respondent-plaintiff since from the year 18.10.1962
and after his death in the year 1991 the respondent-plaintiff
has been possessing the suit land. It is also on record that
in a portion of suit land there is a shop and the rest portion
of the suit land was possessing by the respondent-plaintiff
for agricultural purpose. The appellant-defendants by the
trend of cross-examination of the respondent-plaintiff could
not raise any cloud to disbelieve his evidence. Similarly from
the order of the Learned District Collector along with the
inquiry reports marked as Exbt.2 in five sheets it appears
that the Learned District Collector in his order dated
22.05.2013
specifically
observed
that
the
respondent-
plaintiff is the forceful occupier of the land under Khatian
No.897 Mouja West Singicherra for the last 50 years and
accordingly ordered for incorporating his name as ‘forceful
occupier’ in the respective column No.16 of the khatian. The
said order also has not been challenged by the present
appellants. The appellants relied upon the title deed
executed by the appellant Ashutosh Debnath as an attorney
in favour of Bakul Debnath which was marked as Exbt.B.
But from the evidence on record it appears that the deed
was executed without any possession and also without any
consideration money. In this regard I would like to refer
herein below the definition of ‘Sale’ as mentioned in
Section-54 of Transfer of Property Act, 1882:
“54. “Sale” defined.- “Sale” is a transfer of ownership in
exchange for a price paid or promised or part-paid and
part-promised.”
15.
From the aforesaid provision it appears that sale
is a transfer ownership in exchange of price paid. But here
in the given case there is no evidence on record from the
side of the appellants that for execution of sale-deed the
party had received any consideration money. There is also
no evidence on record that delivery of possession was
handed over to Bakul Debnath either by Bhuban Debnath or
by Ashutosh Debnath. So Learned Trial Court below in
deciding issue No.4 rightly decided that the sale-deed dated
13.12.2012 was nothing but a mere paper transaction which
has got no legal validity in the eye of law. In respect of
issue No.3 Learned Court below relied upon few judgments
of the Hon’ble Apex Court. Similarly, the Learned First
Appellate
court
came
to
the
observation
that
the
respondent-plaintiff has been forcefully occupying the suit
land for the last 50 years denying the right, title and
interest of the original owner i.e. the defendant No.1 and
the appellant-defendant Ashutosh Debnath during his crossexamination specifically stated that Nirode Dey i.e. the
father of the respondent-plaintiff had a shop over the suit
land of Bhuban Debnath. The report of SDM and the final
order of the District Collector discloses about the possession
of the respondent-plaintiff over the suit land for a long
period. So in my considered view the Learned First
Appellate Court also rightly delivered the judgment in favour
of the respondent-plaintiff upholding the judgment of the
Learned Trial Court.
16.
Learned senior counsel for the appellant in
course of hearing of argument relied upon two citations. In
Poona Ram vs. Moti Ram and Others reported in (2019)
11 SCC 309 in para No.15 Hon’ble the Apex Court observed
as under:
“15. The crux of the matter is that a person who asserts
possessory title over a particular property will have to
show that he is under settled or established possession
of the said property. But merely stray or intermittent acts
of trespass do not give such a right against the true
owner. Settled possession means such possession over
the property which has existed for a sufficiently long
period of time, and has been acquiesced to by the true
owner. A casual act of possession does not have the
effect of interrupting the possession of the rightful
owner. A stray act of trespass, or a possession which has
not matured into settled possession, can be obstructed or
removed by the true owner even by using necessary
force. Settled possession must be (i) effective,(ii)
undisturbed, and (iii) to the knowledge of the owner or
without any attempt at concealment by the trespasser.
There cannot be a straitjacket formula to determine
settled possession. Occupation of a property by a person
as an agent or a servant acting at the instance of the
owner will not amount to actual legal possession. The
possession should contain an element of animus
possidendi. The nature of possession of the trespasser is
to be decided based on the facts and circumstances of
each case.”
In Ravinder Kaur Grewal and Others vs.
Manjit Kaur and Others reported in (2019) 8 SCC 729,
Hon’ble the Apex Court in para No.60 further observed as
under:
“60. The adverse possession requires all the three classic
requirements to coexist at the same time, namely, necvi
i.e. adequate in continuity, necclam i.e., adequate in
publicity and necprecario i.e. adverse to a competitor, in
denial of title and his knowledge. Visible, notorious and
peaceful so that if the owner does not take care to know
notorious facts, knowledge is attributed to him on the
basis that but for due diligence he would have known it.
Adverse possession cannot be decreed on a title which is
not pleaded. Animus possidendi under hostile colour of
title is required. Trespasser’s long possession is not
synonym
with
adverse
possession.
Trespasser’s
possession is construed to be on behalf of the owner, the
casual user does not constitute adverse possession. The
owner can take possession from a trespasser at any point
in time. Possessor looks after the property, protects it
and in case of agricultural property by and the large
concept is that actual tiller should own the land who
works by dint of his hard labour and makes the land
cultivable. The legislature in various States confers rights
based on possession.”
Referring
the
aforesaid
citations
Learned
senior
counsel submitted that to prove adverse possession three
classic requirements must be proved in declaring adverse
possession namely nec vi i.e. adequate in continuity, necclam i.e., adequate in publicity and nec precario i.e. adverse
to a competitor, in denial of title and his knowledge and
further submitted that the plaintiff-respondent before the
Learned
Trial
court
could
not
prove
the
aforesaid
requirements of law to substantiate his case of adverse
possession which the Learned Courts below erred in
deciding the case and delivery of judgment and finally
submitted for setting aside the judgment of the Learned
First Appellate Court.
17.
In this regard I would like to refer herein below
one citation of the Hon’ble Apex court in Vasantha (Dead)
Thr. Lr. vs. Rajalashmi @ Rajam (Dead) Thr. Lrs.
reported in 2024 SCC OnLine SC 132 in para-43, Hon’ble
the Apex Court observed as under:
“43. In Saroop Singh v. Banto:2005 SCC OnLine SC 1486
(2-Judge Bench), this Court observed that Article 65
states that the starting point of limitation does not
commence from the date when the right of ownership
arises to the plaintiff but commences from the date the
defendant's possession becomes adverse. Further relying
on Karnataka Board of Wakf v. Govt. of India (2-Judge
Bench), it observed that the physical fact of exclusive
possession and the animus possidendi to hold as owner
in exclusion to the actual owner are the most important
factors that are to be accounted in cases related to
adverse possession. Plea of adverse possession is not a
pure question of law but a blend of fact and law.
Therefore, a person who claims adverse possession
should show: (a) on what date he came into possession;
(b) what was the nature of his possession; (c) whether
the factum of possession was known to the other party;
(d) how long his possession has continued; and (e) his
possession was open and undisturbed. A person pleading
adverse possession has no equities in his favour. Since he
is trying to defeat the rights of the true owner, it is for
him to clearly plead and establish all facts necessary to
prove his adverse possession.”
18.
Here in the given case from the evidence on
record it appears that since from the year 1962 i.e on and
from 18.10.1962 the predecessor of the respondent-plaintiff
possessed the suit land by raising one shop therein and also
by cultivating the rest part of the suit land and after his
death the present plaintiff in the year 1991 has been
possessing the suit land within the true knowledge of said
Bhuban Debnath and the other appellants denying their
right, title and interest and in view of the principle of law
laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India it appears
that in the given case the respondent-plaintiff has been able
to prove his right, title and interest over the suit land by
way of adverse possession and also has been able to prove
that the sale-deed dated 13.12.2012 was nothing but a
sham and void transaction and in my considered view both
the courts below after elaborate discussions of the issues
framed came to the proper and reasonable finding and
decreed the suit in favour of the respondent-plaintiff of this
appeal for which this court does not find any scope to
interfere with the judgment of the Learned First Appellate
Court. The substantial questions of law formulated are
accordingly answered in favour of the respondent-plaintiff of
this appeal.
19.
In the result, the appeal filed by the present
appellants is hereby dismissed on contest with costs. The
judgment and decree of the Learned First Appellate Court in
Title Appeal No.1 of 2021 is hereby upheld and accordingly
it is affirmed. The respondent-plaintiff is entitled to get all
the reliefs as awarded by Learned Trial Court confirmed by
Learned First Appellate court.
Pending application, if any, stands disposed of.
Prepare the decree accordingly and send down
the LCRs along with a copy of the judgment.
JUDGE
signed by
MOUMIT Digitally
MOUMITA DATTA
2024.02.28
A DATTA Date:
04:08:34 -08'00'
Moumita
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review