Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:THC:695
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
CRP No.07 of 2026
Sri Ashes Deb, Son of Late Amalendu Deb, Resident of Village-Dhaleswar,
Nutanpally Road No.2, P.O.-Dhaleswar, P.S.-East Agartala, District-West
Tripura, Pin-799007.
……… Petitioner(s).
VERSUS
1. The State of Tripura, represented by the Secretary, Public Works
Department (R & B), Government of Tripura, Agartala, having his Office at
Secretariat Building, P.O.-Kunjaban, P.S.-New Capital Complex, DistrictWest Tripura, Pin-799006.
2. The Executive Engineer, LTV Division, PWD (R & B), Manu, Dhalai,
Tripura.
………Respondent(s).
For Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Somik Deb, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. Jishan Samed, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. Promod Sahu, Advocate.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO
Date of hearing & judgment
: 19.05.2026.
Whether fit for reporting
: YES.
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard both sides.
2.
This Revision is filed by the petitioner challenging the order
dt.24.11.2025 passed by the District Commercial Court, West Tripura,
Agartala in Ex(M) No.29 of 2021 filed under Section 36 of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996 read with Order XXI Rule 10 of CPC, 1908 for
enforcement of arbitral award dt.29.01.2021 of the Sole Arbitrator in
Arbitration Case No.10(SCD) 2019.
3.
There was a contract agreement between the petitioner and the
respondents bearing No.07/SE-V/EE/LTV/PWD/M/2013-14 in relation to
work of "MTC" of Manu-Kanchanpur road (L-22.00 km) during the year
2026:THC:695
2013-14. The work involved formation, repairing the pot holes and restoration
of road surface by providing metalling, grouting in different stretches, recarpeting and seal coating of the whole road surface in connection with
protection work (Portion from 3.90 to 8.40 km).
4.
Disputes arose between the parties and the petitioner invoked the
Arbitration Clause in the agreement between the parties.
5.
After contest, the Arbitrator pronounced his award on 29.01.2021
(Annexure-1). In paras-25 and 26 of the Arbitral Award, the Arbitrator held as
under:
"25. In view of the issue wise discussion and decision
made above, the petitioner is entitled to get Rs.46,19,899/- +
Rs.2,20,000/- + Rs.2,37,995/-, total Rs.50,77,894/- out of which,
an amount of Rs.12,48,502/-, as decided under Issue No.6, shall
be set off and the amount, therefore, stands at Rs.38,29,392.00/and on this amount, the petitioner is entitled to get interest @ 9%
per annum from 04.12.2018.
26.
The payment of awarded amount of Rs.38,29,392/-
should be made within 90 days from the date of award along with
cost part as awarded under Issue No.5, i.e. Rs.1,81,722/-. In case
of failure to make payment within 90 days, entire amount shall
carry interest @ 12% per annum from 04.12.2018."
6.
After the award was pronounced, the respondents wrote a letter
on 01.06.2021 to the petitioner asking the petitioner to attend their office for
collection of the awarded amount after deduction of the cost of materials
utilized by the petitioner which had been issued to the petitioner by the
department.
7.
Petitioner responded to the said letter on 15.06.2021 vide
Annexure-3. In the said letter, he referred to the fact that the respondents had
2026:THC:695
not paid any money during the period of 90 days from the date of the award,
i.e. before 29.04.2021 and so the petitioner contended that he is entitled to
interest @ 12% per annum on the awarded sum w.e.f. 04.12.2018. After
adding the period of interest, he stated that he is entitled to Rs.52,14,448/comprising of Rs.40,11,114/- (Principal) + Rs.12,03,334/- (Interest). Thus
after adding the interest component to the principal, the petitioner said that
the cost of materials supplied to him by the department i.e., Rs.20,61,789/- can
be deducted from the sum of Rs.52,14,448/- and the respondents should,
therefore, pay Rs.31,52,661/-.
8.
In his letter, he also stated that this is issued without prejudice to
his rights to challenge the Arbitral Award dt.29.01.2021 on other grounds/
claims where he had not succeeded before the learned Arbitrator.
9.
There was no response to this letter of the petitioner from the
respondents.
10.
Petitioner, therefore, filed Execution Petition No.29 of 2021
under Section 36 of the Act as mentioned above. He claimed in the Execution
Petition Rs.52,90,077/-.
11.
The respondents filed a counter affidavit thereto raising the
contention that the petitioner had filed an application under Section 34 of the
Act for setting aside the same award ; and that the place where the Execution
Petition should be filed would be the Court at Dhalai District, and not in
Agartala, West Tripura. They, therefore, prayed for the dismissal of the
Execution Petition. There was an amendment to this counter affidavit wherein
an additional plea was taken by the respondents that there were overpayments
made to the petitioner. They also raised certain contentions on the merits of
2026:THC:695
the case which they could not have done in the Execution Petition because
there is no scope for going into those aspects at the execution stage.
12.
Both parties then filed calculation memos before the trial Court.
13.
The calculation memo filed by the petitioner before the Court
below is Annexure-8.
In the said calculation memo, the petitioner first calculated the
principal amount and added interest amount @ 12% from the date of the
award till the date of the Execution Petition, i.e. 27.06.2023 and claimed
Rs.62,17,226/-. From that amount, he deducted the cost of utilized materials of
Rs.20,61,789/- and arrived at Rs.41,55,437/- and after adjusting some amounts
which have been paid subsequently ultimately claimed Rs.19,16,943/-.
14.
When the matter was ultimately taken up by the Executing Court,
the respondents filed a calculation memo admitting that the total awarded
amount is Rs.40,11,114/-, but deducting the cost of utilized departmental
materials of Rs.20,61,789/- which they claimed that the petitioner had agreed
in his letter dt.15.06.2021. After setting off the amount paid, they arrived at
the balance of Rs.6,70,021/- as payable to the petitioner.
15.
The Executing Court then considered Clause 98(a) of the
agreement and the contents of the letter dt.15.06.2021 sent by the petitioner to
the respondents and accepted the stand of the respondents, i.e. that there ought
to be a deduction from the principal amount of Rs.40,11,114/- of the cost of
works of Rs.20,61,789/- and only thereafter interest @ 12% is to be added to
the principal. It then dismissed the Execution Petition by the impugned order
stating that the petitioner's calculation sheet failed to deduct the admitted
liability and, therefore, an inflated claim was made. It noted that the
2026:THC:695
respondents deducted the cost of the materials prior to the computation of
interest consistent with the contract, terms and equity and the payment made
by the respondents fully satisfied the award.
16.
Challenging the same, this Revision is filed.
17.
Mr. Somik Deb, learned Senior counsel appearing for the
petitioner, seeks to contend that before the arbitrator, the respondents had not
raised any contention that there should be a set off of the cost of the materials
supplied to the petitioner by the respondents, which had been used by the
petitioner in the execution of the contract.
He further contends that after the award is passed, the
respondents had proposed vide letter (Annexure-2) to deduct the cost of
materials which had been utilized without indicating how the deduction is to
be made, i.e. whether it should be made from the principal amount or whether
it should be made from the principal amount after adding the interest awarded
by the Arbitrator to the petitioner.
Counsel for the petitioner further contends that the petitioner had
made a counter offer in his letter dt.15.06.2021 (Annexure-3) to the
respondents that first the principal and the interest @ 12% for delay in making
payment beyond 90 days from the date of award should be computed, that
they should then be added,
and then only the cost of materials can be
deducted.
Counsel contends that this counter offer of the petitioner was
never accepted by the respondents and, therefore, there is no question of
making any deduction of the cost of materials supplied to the petitioner by the
department worth Rs.20,61,789/- because the agreement of the petitioner for
2026:THC:695
such a deduction was conditional on the deduction being made after adding
the interest, and not before adding the interest.
He contends that the respondents in the counter affidavit/
objection filed in the Execution Petition have also not taken the plea of
adjustment of the cost of materials, and without even raising such an
objection, it was not open to them to have contended that the deduction should
be made from the principal first and then only interest should be added and
that the Executing Court ought not to have accepted the contention of the
respondents.
18.
Counsel for the respondents does not dispute the fact that before
the learned Arbitrator, the contention regarding adjustment of cost of materials
supplied to the petitioner by the department, which were utilized by the
petitioner, was never raised. Therefore, it was not open to the respondents to
seek to deduct the same post award in the execution proceedings.
19.
Counsel for the respondents also does not dispute the fact that in
the written objection filed in the Execution Petition also there was no pleading
raised by the respondents that they were entitled to deduct the cost of the
materials supplied to the petitioner by the department standing at
Rs.20,61,789/- at all.
20.
He also does not dispute that while the respondents had proposed
vide letter dt.01.06.2021 (Annexure-2) to simply deduct the cost of materials
utilized without indicating whether the said deduction should be from the
principal or principal after adding the interest.
21.
Admittedly no reply was sent to the petitioner's response
dt.15.06.2021 (Annexure-3) by the respondents, wherein the petitioner offered
2026:THC:695
that the deduction should be done, if at all, after adding the principal and the
interest @ 12%.
22.
In my opinion, the offer of the respondents to the petitioner in
Annexure-2 dt.01.06.2021 was responded by a counter offer from the
petitioner vide Anneuxure-3 dt.15.06.2021. There is absolutely no evidence to
show that the respondents had accepted the petitioner's counter offer contained
in Annexure-3 dt.15.06.2021 at any subsequent point of time. So it cannot be
said that the petitioner had agreed to the deduct the cost of the materials
supplied to the petitioner by the department standing at Rs.20,61,789/- and
that such deduction can be done before adding the interest.
23.
So there could not have been a deduction from the awarded
amount at all of the cost of materials supplied to the petitioner by the
department of Rs.20,61,789/- when such a contention was not raised by the
respondents before the Arbitrator.
24.
More so, because the executing Court cannot go behind the
award. (see S.P. Misra and others v. Mohd. Laiquddin Khan and another1
and Radhey Shyam Gupta v. Punjab National Bank and another2.)
25.
The Executing Court, therefore, had no business to go behind the
Arbitral Award and rely on the counter offer made by the petitioner in his
letter dt.15.06.2021 (Annexure-3) and proceed to adjust the cost of materials
also while computing the amount to be paid to the petitioner by the
respondents before adding the interest@12%.
26.
It is also settled law that where payments are made by the
judgment debtors to the decree holder, the payments made ought to be
(2019) 10 SCC 329
(2009) 1 SCC 376
2026:THC:695
adjusted first towards interest, next to the costs and last to the principal as held
by the Supreme Court in the case of Gurpreet Singh v. Union of India3 and in
the case of V. Kala Bharathi and others v. Oriental Insurance Company
Limited, Branch Chitoor4. The legal position contained in the above decisions
is also not disputed by the counsel for the respondents.
27.
Since the Court below has thus erred in taking into account the
amount of Rs.20,61,789/-, which is the cost of materials supplied to the
petitioner by the respondents erroneously which it could not have done, this
Revision is allowed; the judgment dt.24.11.2025 of the Executing Court in
EX(M) No.29 of 2021 is set aside and the matter is remitted back to the said
Court to compute the amount, if any, payable to the petitioner, strictly in
accordance with the above decisions of the Supreme Court without setting off
the cost of materials supplied to the petitioner by the department of
Rs.20,61,789/-. This exercise shall be completed within 2(two) months from
today.
28.
Revision is allowed in view of above terms.
Pending application(s), if any, stands disposed of.
(M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO, CJ)
Pulak
signed by PULAK BANIK
PULAK BANIK Digitally
Date: 2026.05.22 15:51:56 +05'30'
(2006) 8 SCC 457
(2014) 5 SCC 577
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review