Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
RFA. No.04 of 2022
Sri Arunodoy Das & Another
.....Appellants
V_E_R_S_U_S
Smti. Anjali Das & Others
.....Respondents
For Appellant(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. D. R. Chowdhury, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. D. Deb, Advocate.
Mr. H. K. Bhowmik, Advocate.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
_O_ R_ D_ E_ R_
27/04/2023
Heard Mr. D. R. Chowdhury, learned senior counsel assisted by
Mr. D. Deb, learned counsel appearing for the appellants. Also heard Mr. H. K.
Bhowmik, learned counsel appearing for the respondents.
[2]
This appeal has been filed under Section-97 of the CPC against
the final order dated 01.02.2022 passed in partition suit vide No. T.S. (P) 41 of
2014 by the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Court No.4, West Tripura,
Agartala basing on preliminary decree dated 15.11.2017 and the report of
Survey Commissioner dated 19.02.2020.
[3]
The case, in brief, is that the subject matter of the partition in this
suit is a landed property wherein one Tin Ghar and one Ghar are in existence as
per the Khatian but at present the suit land there are two tin ghars and one ghar
and the suit land is situated at old Agartala near Chaturdash Debata Bari under
Mouja and Tahasil Uttar Champamura, revenuecircle Jirania having Touji No.
1352 appertaining to Khatian No. 76 corresponding to sabek plot No. 1969 /
5440, Hal plot No. 4562 bastu land measuring 24 satak. Originally the suit land
belonged to one Chandra Mohan Das, the father of the plaintiff, the respondent
herein and the defendants, the appellants herein and after his death the land as
inherited by the plaintiff and the defendants along with the mother namely
Smt.Puspa Rani Das and accordingly their names were recorded in the khatian
No. 76 by showing their respectful shares of the total suit land and so after the
death of Chandra Mohan Das the land became under the Title and the
ownership of the present plaintiff and the defendants along with Smt. Puspa
Rani Das.
[4]
As asserted by the plaintiff in the plaint that on 21.8.10 Puspa
Rani Das expired and the appropriate authority issued a death certificate and
after her death her share as recorded in Khatian No. 76 became vested under
the ownership of the other sharers i.e. the plaintiff and the defendants. At
present the entitlement of the land is to the plaintiff and all the defendants. The
plaintiff is the full blooded married sister of the defendants and on the other
way, the defendants are the full blooded brother of the present plaintiff. After
the marriage, the plaintiff is staying in her in-laws house and at no point of time
either verbally or in writing or the communication any paper was prepared to
forgo her right, title interest and the possession over the shares of the land of
the suit property.
[5]
Practically the defendant No.4 is staying at Dhaleswar and the
defendant Nos. 2 and 3 are now staying in the suit premises and the defendant
No.1 has started a construction in the suit premises without any consent or
without any amicable partition of the suit land amongst the co-sharers. The
plaintiff has no knowledge whether other co-sharers have given the consent for
the same but in no point of time, the plaintiff was taken into confident for the
consent or any amicable settlement of the suit land by providing her share and
thus the plaintiff is entitled to get share of the suit land, which would be one
fifth of the total land. For the long time plaintiff has been pursuing her legal
claim to the defendants but the defendants are taking different pleas at different
times and are not interested to give any share to the plaintiff and their only
target is to deprive the plaintiff from her legal claim.
[6]
The learned Court below after hearing the parties and having
observed the material evidence on record has observed as under:
“In view of the above discussion and decision it is hereby
ordered that the suit for partition filed by the plaintiff is decreed on contest
without cost.
The plaintiff and the defendants are entitled to get 1/5th
share each of the suit property as described in the schedule of the plaint.
So, accordingly the defendants are directed to make partition of the suit
property as per quantum of the share portion of the plaintiff and between
themselves and as per decree passed by this court within two
months from today. Otherwise, the plaintiff will have the liberty to get
their share of landed property after partition by a survey knowing
commissioner in due course of time.
The preliminary decree be prepared accordingly.
With the aforesaid observation the present case is decreed on contest
without cost.
Make necessary entry in the concerned TR.”
[7]
Mr. D. R. Chowdhury, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. D.
Deb, learned counsel appearing for the appellants has submitted that the
judgment and decree dated 01.02.2022 accepting the report of the Survey
Commissioner dated 19.02.2020 without proper appreciation on the objection
of the defendant Nos.1 & 4 appellant and in passing the final decree of partition
is bad in law and not warranted b y the facts and circumstances of the case. He
has further submitted that the Court below committed wrong and illegalities in
appreciating the report of the Survey commissioner wherein, the shares of the
parties have not been properly ascertained by proper assessment of the value of
the respective shares of the parties and thereby, the final decree passed by the
learned Court below is not metes and bounds as per the equal shares of the
parties as stated in the preliminary decree.
[8]
It has been further contended that the learned Court below in
accepting the report of the Survey Commissioner did not look into the way of
allotment of shares to the parties even without keeping the possession of the
parties as construction of the buildings and huts in their respective allotted
portions causing demolition of the buildings of the defendants No.1 and 4
where the allotted shares of the plaintiff-respondent and the other defendant
No.3 as have been provided by the Survey commissioner not only of much
more area and the much more value and without any damage of huts and
buildings within their allotted portions which is not according to the
preliminary decree of partition by metes and bounds and cannot be legally
considered as legal.
[9]
In making partition and in ascertainment of the shares of the
parties the Survey Commissioner provided two passages/pathway one in the
northern side of the allotted portion of the land of the defendant No.4 and
another in the Southern side of the portion of the land allotted to the defendant
No.1 one measuring 10tf in breadth and 80 ft in length and another 6 ft in
breadth and 80 ft in length by which the total land measuring 16 ft x 80 ft. of
land i.e. 1 ½ gandas of the land have been misused whether if only one
pathway would be made in the middle of the land allotted to the defendant No.1
and defendant No.4 with the space measuring 10 ft breadth x 80 ft in length
then more than 3 kara i.e. below 1 ganda of land which could be distributed in
the share of the defendant No.1 and 4 even though the value of the shares of the
land allotted to the defendant No.1 and 4 cannot be said as equal with the
allotted shares of land of the plaintiff-respondents.
[10]
In view of above submission advanced by the learned senior
counsel appearing for the appellants, this Court is of the view that they have
objection over the report of the Survey Commissioner. But this Court after
having observed the Survey Commissioner report has noticed that the
defendant JD No.2 and 4 were present during field working. It is crystal clear
that the partition was made in presence of both the parties and had any
objection of anybody then it would surely be raised before at the spot while
field work was going on.
[11]
In the report, it has also been mentioned that the entire partition
was made according to the choice of the parties and since there were some
dwelling huts over the suit land hence, the partition was made without
disturbing the possession of the existing shareholders considering the valuation
of the land. Furthermore, the Survey Commissioner’s report speaks the fact that
the suit land was demarcated to the best of the ability of the skill and judgment
equalizing the shares considering the actual position of the suit land particularly
to the fact where huts and constructions are thereon and all the share holders
duly consented to partition the land without disturbing their peaceful
possession as it was before. Hence, it will not be prudent to accept the
objection raised only by the defendant JD No.4 causing inconvenience to the
other shareholders.
[12]
It has been observed from the records that the final decree has
been prepared in accordance with the preliminary decree considering the
Survey Commissioner Report. Thus, in view of above analysis, this Court is of
the opinion that if the learned Court below passes a fresh decree by extracted
the Survey Commissioner’s report in its order and re-issues a fresh decree; this
issue can easily be resolved. Thus, the same is ordered.
[13]
In the light of the above, the present appeal stands disposed of to
the extent as indicated above. Draw the decree accordingly. Send down the
LCRs forthwith. As a sequel, miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall
stand closed.
JUDGE
A. Ghosh
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review