Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA No.26 of 2022
Sri Arun Chandra Paul
Son of Late Ashit Ranjan Paul
Resident of Santinagar,
PS – Teliamura,
District – Khowai, Tripura.
------ Appellant-Defendant No.1
Versus
1. Sri Tarun Paul,
Son of Late Ashit Ranjan Paul
Resident of Santinagar,
PS – Teliamura,
District – Khowai, Tripura.
------Respondent-Plaintiff
2. Smti Apu Rani Paul
Wife of Gopal Paul,
D/o, Late Ashit Ranjan Paul
Resident of village – Sanitala,
P.S.-Sidhai, District-West Tripura
3. Smti Tapu Rani Paul,
Wife of Sri Bikash Paul
D/o, Late Ashit Ranjan Paul
Resident of village – Gollabari,
PS – Teliamura, District – Khowai
Tripura.
4. Smti Shila Rani Paul,
Wife of Sri Babul Paul
Resident of Subhash Park,
P.S. – Khowai, District – Khowai.
Tripura.
------Respondents-defendants
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharjee, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S. Lodh, Adv.
Date of hearing
:
19.02.2024
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
23.02.2024
Whether fit for
reporting
:
NO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This appeal under Section 100 of CPC is preferred
challenging the judgment dated 09.12.2021 and decree dated
by 06.05.2022 passed by Learned District Judge, Khowai
District,
Tripura
in
connection
with
T.A.
No.06
of
dismissing the appeal of the appellant and by affirming the
judgment dated 20.03.2018 and decree dated 07.04.2018
passed by Learned Civil Judge (Jr. Division), Khowai in
T.S.(Partition) No.08 of 2011.
2.
Before proceeding with the merit of the appeal let us
discuss the subject matter of the dispute amongst the parties.
The respondent-plaintiff and his mother filed one suit for
partition before the Court of Learned Civil Judge (Jr. Division),
Khowai, Tripura alleging inter alia that the suit land measuring
0.12 acres recorded in Khatian No.739 comprising old C.S. plot
no.1241(part)
corresponding
to
Revisional
Survey
plot
No.1999,2001 described in the Schedule of the plaint was
originally owned and possessed by one Ashit Ranjan Paul till his
death on 29.12.2008 and after that, the respondent-plaintiffs
and the defendant i.e. herein referred as the appellant and
other pro-respondent-defendants
being the legal
heirs of
deceased enjoyed the suit land jointly. Owing to inconvenience
faced by respondent-plaintiffs, they approached the appellantdefendants on 07.02.2011 with a proposal for an amicable
partition claiming their 1/3rd shares upon the suit land which
was refused by the appellant-defendant No.1 who was trying to
possess the suit land in excess of his entitlement and the other
defendants remained silent to the respondent-plaintiffs. Finding
no alternative way, the respondent-plaintiffs filed the suit
claiming 1/3rd share over the suit land. It is to be noted here
that the original plaintiff No.1 was expired, so, by order dated
01.09.2016, her name was struck off from the record.
3.
It was the further case of the respondent-plaintiffs that
owing to transfer of the shop property owned by their
predecessor Ashit Ranjan Paul in favour of the
present
respondent-plaintiff by registered Gift Deed No.1-2766 recorded
in Khatian No.2303 appertaining to C.S. Plot No.2560(part)
corresponding to
R.S. Plot No.7119/8043, the suit shop was
outside the ambit of joint property as it was exclusively owned
by
the
present
respondent-plaintiff
and
this
fact
was
incorporated in the plaint by way of amendment of the plaint.
4.
The suit of the respondent-plaintiffs was contested only
by the present appellant as defendant No.1 and according to
him, all the property of the original owner was not brought into
hotchpot. It was further asserted by him that his father had left
some shop viti which were not included. It was also stated that
the present respondent-plaintiff had claimed to have such shop
viti by way of transfer by his father to him. But actually, no
such transfer took place and he further submitted that the
present respondent-plaintiff ousted all his co-sharers from the
suit land and therefore, the suit was not maintainable as no
prayer for recovery of possession was made. It was further
asserted by the present appellant-defendant No.1 that he was
possessing the suit land for more than 12 years adversely
against his co-sharers. Hence, the appellant-defendant No.1 by
his written statement prayed for dismissal of the suit with costs.
5.
Upon the pleading of the parties, Learned Court below
framed the following issues:
I. Whether the suit is maintainable in its present form and
nature?
II. Whether the father (Ashit Ranjan Paul) of the plaintiffs
and the defendants was the owner of the suit land?
III. Whether the land of Ashit Ranjan Paul under Khatian
No.2303 of Teliamura Mouja and Tehshil transferred vide
registered Deed No.1-2766 dated : 11.12.2006 in favour of
the plaintiff No.2?
IV. Whether the suit land is the joint property of the
plaintiffs and the defendants by way of inheritance?
V. Whether the suit land is liable to be partitioned among
the plaintiffs and the defendants in equal share each?
VI. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to get their share as
per prayer in the plaint of the suit?
VII. To what other relief/reliefs the parties are entitled to
get?
6.
To substantiate the issues, both the parties have
adduced oral/documentary evidence on record :
Name of the witnesses of the plaintiffs:
1. PW-1(plaintiff)
: Sri Tarun Paul
2. PW-2
: Sri Jiban Biswas
Exhibits of the Plaintiffs:
1. Exbt 1: Khatian No.739 of Mouja and Tehshil Teliamura.
2. Exbt 2: Khatian No.2303 of Mouja and Tehshil Teliamura.
3. Exbt 3: Certified to be true copy of the Gift Deed No.12766 compared with the original volume book.
Name of the witnesses of the defendents:
1. DW-1(defendant) : Sri Arun Chandra Paul
Exhibits of the Defendants:
1. Exbt A: Original agreement dated 02.09.12 containing
the signatures of the DW1.
2. Exbt B: Original memorandum dated 25.09.12 containing
the signatures of the DW1.
7.
The Learned Trial Court discussed all the issues in detail
but decided the issue No.III against the respondent-plaintiff but
decreed the suit by a judgment and order. The operative
portion of the Judgment runs as follows:
ORDER
I. The plaintiff has demonstrated his title and resultantly the
present suit succeeds by holding that the plaintiff is entitled
to get preliminary Decree declaring his interest to the
extent of 1/5th share of the suit land.
II. As discussed, since the plaintiff has perfected his 1/5th
share over the suit land, the defendants are hereby directed
to get the suit land to be equally partitioned effectuating the
1/5th share of the plaintiff and consequently the defendants
are bound to deliver the possession of 1/5th share of the
suit land in favour of the plaintiff.
III. However, the parties shall bear their own costs.
IV. A preliminary decree be drawn up accordingly within the
prescribed time.
V. The suit stands disposed of on contest.
VI. Make necessary Entry in the relevant TR.
8.
Challenging that judgment, the defendant No.1 of the
original suit as appellant preferred an appeal before the Court
of Learned District Judge, Khowai District, Tripura which was
numbered as T.A. No.06 of 2018 and the Learned District Judge
after hearing arguments of both the sides delivered the
judgment
on
09.12.2021.
The
operative
portion
of
the
judgment of the Learned First Appellate Court runs as follows:
ORDER
In the result, the appeal is dismissed being devoid of merit
with cost in favour of respondent no.1.
The parties to this appeal are directed to effectuate the
partition of suit land mutually within 03 months from today in
terms of decree of Ld. Trial Court, else Ld. Trial Court will take
up the matter of preparation of final decree in accordance
with law after notifying the parties.
The appeal is accordingly disposed of on contest.
It is to be mentioned here that Learned First
Appellate Court at the time of delivering the judgment
discussed and decided the issue No.III in favour of the
respondent-plaintiff Tarun Paul.
9.
Challenging the judgment of the Learned First Appellate
Court, the present appellant-defendant No.1 has preferred this
appeal under Section 100 of C.P.C. before the High Court. At
the time of admission of appeal by order dated 12.07.2022,
following substantial questions of law were framed:
i. Whether the certified copy of the Gift Deed is admissible
in evidence?
ii. Whether the judgments of the learned courts below are
perverse?
10.
At the time of hearing of appeal, Learned Counsel for
the appellant drawn the attention of the Court that both the
Learned Courts below ignored the provisions of law regarding
proving of Gift Deed and come to an erroneous observation
beyond the prescribed provisions of law. Learned Counsel for
the appellant submitted that the respondent-plaintiff did not
produce the original Gift Deed before the Court. Nor took any
step to produce the same. Even to substantiate the case, the
respondent-plaintiff relied upon certified copy of Gift Deed
which was marked as Exhibit-3 series but without complying
with the mandatory provisions of law as mentioned in Section
64 and 65 of the Evidence Act, the document was taken into
evidence. According to Learned Counsel for the appellant, the
Learned Trial Court below in deciding issue No.III rightly come
to the conclusion that Exhibit-3 series was not proved in
accordance with law and accordingly decided the issue against
the respondent-plaintiff although decreed the suit. But the
Learned First Appellate Court after hearing argument of both
the sides reversed the finding of Learned Trial Court regarding
Issue No.III and ultimately decided the said issue in favour of
the respondent-plaintiff. It was further submitted that name of
the father of the respondent-plaintiff was Ashit Paul not Ashit
Chandra Paul or Ashit Ranjan Paul. But in the alleged Gift Deed
(Exhibit-3 series), it was written as Ashit Chandra Paul alias
Ashit Ranjan Paul. The respondent-plaintiff could not give any
proper account of that. So, according to Learned Counsel for
the appellant excluding the land of Exhibit-3 series, both the
Learned Courts below granted preliminary decree which was not
tenable in the eye of law. Learned Counsel for the appellant
submitted that since the certified copy of Gift Deed was not
proved in accordance with law and both the Learned Courts
below have failed to appreciate the legal provisions, so, the
interference of this Court is required and finally urged for
setting aside the judgment of the Learned First Appellate Court
regarding the determination of issue No.III in favour of the
respondent-plaintiff as the mandatory provision of law was not
complied with by the respondent-plaintiff.
11.
On
the
other
hand,
Learned
Counsel
for
the
respondent-plaintiff at the time of hearing submitted that the
present appeal is not maintainable as there is no substantial
question of law to be decided in the present appeal. Learned
Counsel further submitted that Learned First Appellate Court
after considering the legal provisions rightly delivered the
judgment in favour of the respondent-plaintiff and urged for
dismissal of the appeal with costs. It was further submitted that
in the pleading i.e. in the written statement, there was no
assertion or whisper that the Gift Deed i.e. Exhibit-3 series was
a forged one, it was not executed by their predecessor rather it
was executed by one Ashit Chandra Paul. But the actual name
of their predecessor was Ashit Paul but in this regard, no
documentary
evidence
was
produced
by
the
appellant
defendant in either of the forums. So, according to Learned
Counsel, although Learned Trial Court could not properly decide
the issue No.III in favour of the respondent-plaintiff but the
Learned First Appellate Court after considering the legal
provision decided the said issue in favour of the respondentplaintiff and further drawn the attention of the Court referring
the evidence of PW-1, Tarun Paul i.e. respondent-plaintiff and
submitted that the said witness PW-1 in course of examination
before the Learned Trial Court proved the certified copy of Gift
Deed bearing No.1-2766 dated 11.12.2016 which was marked
as Exhibit-3 series but during cross-examination of the said
witness, there was not a single question from the side of the
appellant regarding the validity of Exhibit-3 series. No objection
was raised by them that there was no scope to appreciate said
Exhibit-3 series. Nor they submitted any written objection
challenging the marking of Exhibit-3 series before the Learned
Trial Court even to the Learned First Appellate Court. It was
further submitted that the said certified copy of Gift Deed
(Exhibit-3 series) was marked without any objection from the
side of the appellant-defendant before the Learned Trial Court.
So, there was no scope to disbelieve Exhibit-3 series i.e. the
Gift Deed executed by the father of the respondent-plaintiff in
his favour.
12.
Further,
according
to
Learned
Counsel
for
the
respondent-plaintiff, although the appellant in course of hearing
of argument stressed upon Exhibit-A but in the written
statement submitted by the appellant-defendant before the
Learned Trial court, there was no whisper regarding execution
of Exhibit-A and furthermore, before the Learned First Appellate
Court also, no such plea was taken by the appellant-defendant
that Exhibit-A was not considered by the Learned Trial Court.
So, at this stage, there is no scope on the part of the appellantdefendant to agitate this issue that Exhibit-A was not properly
appreciated by the Learned Courts below and finally urged for
dismissal of the appeal with costs.
13.
I have heard detailed argument of both the sides and
gone through the records of the Learned Court below. It is the
admitted
position
that
the
respondent-plaintiff
could
not
produce the original Gift Deed as alleged but he relied upon
certified copy of Gift Deed which was marked as Exhibit-3 series
before the Learned Trial Court during trial. The respondentplaintiff also preferred another witness to substantiate his case
namely Sri Jiban Biswas, Staff of Sub-Registry Office, Khowai
who as PW-2 deposed that on 11.12.2006, one Gift Deed was
executed in their office in between Ashit Chandra Paul alias
Ashit Ranjan Paul and Sri Tarun Paul bearing No.1-2766. He
further deposed that he preferred one certified copy of the
same and identified Exhibit-3 series in comparison with the
original volume book.
During his cross, nothing came out relevant. But at the
time
of
hearing
of
argument,
Learned
Counsel
for
the
respondent-plaintiff did not submit anything in this regard. Even
Learned Counsel for the appellant also did not submit anything.
More so, the Learned Courts below at the time of delivery of the
judgment failed to appreciate the evidence of said PW-2. So,
the contentions of Learned Counsel for the appellant that
Exhibit-3 series was not duly proved, is not correct and not
tenable in the eye of law.
14.
Here, I would like to refer relevant provision of Section
63 and 65 of the Evidence Act which provides as under:
“63. Secondary evidence.-Secondary evidence
means and includes(1)certified
copies
given
under
provisions hereinafter contained;
the
(2)copies made from the original by
mechanical processes which in themselves
insure the accuracy of the copy, and copies
compared with such copies;
(3)copies made from or compared with the
original;
(4)counterparts of documents as against
the parties who did not execute them;
(5)oral accounts of the contents of a
document given by some person who has
himself seen it.”
“65. Cases in which secondary evidence
relating to documents may be given.Secondary evidence may be given of the
existence, condition or contents of a
document in the following cases(a) when the original is shown or appears to
be in the possession or powerof the person against whom the
document is sought to be proved, or of
any person out of reach of, or not
subject to, the process of the Court, or
of any person legally bound to produce
it.
And when, after the notice mentioned in
Section 66, such person does not
produce it;
(b) when the existence, condition or
contents of the original have been proved to
be admitted in writing by the person against
whom it is proved or by his representative
in interest;
(c) when the original has been destroyed or
lost, or when the party offering evidence of
its contents cannot, for any other reason not
arising from his own default or neglect,
produce it in reasonable time;
(d) when the original is of such a nature as
not to be easily movable;
(e) when the original is a public document
within the meaning of Section 74;
(f) when the original is a document of which
a certified copy is permitted by this Act, or
by any other law in force in India, to be
given in evidence;
(g) when the originals consist of numerous
accounts or other documents which cannot
conveniently be examined in Court, and the
fact to be proved is the general result of the
whole collection.
In cases (a), (c) and (d), any secondary
evidence of the contents of the document is
admissible.
In case (b),
admissible.
the
written
admission
is
In case (e) or (f), a certified copy of the
document, but no other kind of secondary
evidence, is admissible.
In case (g), evidence may be given as to the
general result of the documents by any
person who has examined them, and who is
skilled
in
documents.”
the
examination
of
such
From the aforesaid provisions, it appears since the
Exhibit-3 series was a certified copy of Gift Deed so the
respondent-plaintiff before the Learned Court below duly proved
the said document in accordance with law. So, there is no scope
to disbelieve Exhibit-3 series and in my considered view,
Learned Trial Court below failed to appreciate the evidence of
PW-2 and also failed to appreciate the legal provisions as
mentioned in Section 63, and 65 of Evidence Act. The appellate
Court although decided the issue in favour of the respondentplaintiff but did not mention anything in respect of evidence of
PW-2 in proving Exhibit-3 series. More so, said Exhibit-3 series
was also proved and marked as Exhibit without any objection
from the side of the present appellant also.
15.
Furthermore, Ashit Paul and Ashit Ranjan Paul was not
the same person could not prove any documentary evidence on
record. Rather in the written statement submitted before the
Learned Court below, it appears that the appellant-defendant
also admitted the name of the father as Ashit Ranjan Paul. So,
legally, the plea of the appellant-defendant cannot be accepted
by this Court that Ashit Paul alias Ashit Ranjan Paul was not the
same person.
16.
Regarding Exhibit-A, Learned Counsel for the appellant
drawn the attention of the Court to draw an inference in favour
of the appellant-defendant but it appears that the same was an
unregistered document and the contents of the same also could
not be proved. On perusal of Exhibit-2, it appears that the land
of respondent-plaintiff has been mutated in favour of the
respondent-plaintiff vide MR case No.204/96 which draws an
inference under Section 43 of TLR & LR Act of 1960 which
provides as under:
43. Publication of the record of rights.(1) When a record of rights has been prepared, the
survey officer shall publish a draft of the record in
such manner and for such period as may be
prescribed and shall receive and consider any
objections which may be made during the period of
such publication, to any entry therein or to any
omission therefrom.
(2) When all objections have been considered and
disposed of in accordance with the rules made in
this behalf, the survey officer shall cause the record
to be finally published in the prescribed manner.
(3) Every entry in the record of rights as finally
published shall, until the contrary is proved, be
presumed to be correct.
There is no rebuttable evidence on record in this regard
from the side of appellant. Even challenging Exhibit-2, no step
was taken by the present appellant-defendant and in the
considered opinion of the Court, the Revenue Authority finding
the respondent-plaintiff in possession of the suit shop mutated
the said land in his favour and ROR also prepared in his name.
Exhibit-1 is the Khatian standing in the name of Ashit Ranjan
Paul i.e. the predecessor of the parties for land measuring 0.12
acres. Further, on perusal of Exhibit-3 series, it appears that on
the body of same, the name of the donor was written as Ashit
Chandra Paul alias Ashit Ranjan Paul.
17.
Learned Counsel for the appellant in course of hearing
relied upon one citation of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India.
In Saurav Jain and another v. M/s. A. B. P. Design and
another dated 05.08.2021 reported in AIR 2021 SC 3673,
Hon’ble Apex Court in para 30 of the said judgment observed as
under:
“30. This Court in Bharat Kala Bhandar (P) Ltd. v.
Municipal Committee :AIR 1966 SC 249 dealt with a
civil appeal where a contention had not been raised
in the suit or in the grounds of appeal before the
High Court, and was advanced before this Court for
the first time. Although the Court noted that the
scope of the appeal cannot be broadened at the
instance of the parties, if a plea raises a question of
considerable importance, it can entertained by this
Court. In a similar vein, this Court in Vasant Kumar
Radhakisan Vora v. Board of Trustees of the Port of
Bombay :(1991) 1 SCC 761, noted that pure
questions of law which go to the root of the
jurisdiction in a case can be raised for the first time
in an appeal under Article 136 of the Constitution.”
Referring the same, Learned Counsel for the appellant
has drawn the attention of the Court that although the
appellant-defendant could not raise any objection at the time of
admission and marking of document i.e. Exhibit-3 series but
still the appellant has got the scope to raise this issue even
before this Court also at this stage. Since, it is already
discussed that Exhibit-3 series was duly proved in accordance
with Section 63 and 65 of the Evidence Act, so, the aforesaid
citation as relied upon by the Learned Counsel for the appellant
cannot be applied at this stage.
18.
Per contra, Learned Counsel for the respondent-plaintiff
referred the citation of Hon’ble Supreme Court of India. In
Dayamathi Bai(Smt) v. K. M. Shaffi dated 04.08.2004
reported in (2004) 7 SCC 107, wherein the Hon’ble Apex
Court in para 14 observed as under:
“14. To the same effect is the judgment of the Privy
Council in the case of Gopal Das v. Thakurji :AIR
1943 PC 83 in which it has been held that when the
objection to the mode of proof is not taken, the
party cannot lie by until the case comes before a
court of appeal and then complain for the first time
of the mode of proof. That when the objection to be
taken is not that the document is in itself
inadmissible but that the mode of proof was
irregular, it is essential that the objection should be
taken at the trial before the document is marked as
an exhibit and admitted to the record. Similarly, in
Sarkar on Evidence, 15th Edn., p.1084, it has been
stated that where copies of the documents are
admitted without objection in the trial court, no
objection to their admissibility can be taken
afterwards in the court of appeal. When a party
gives in evidence a certified copy, without proving
the circumstances entitling him to give secondary
evidence, objection must be taken at the time of
admission and such objection will not be allowed at
a later stage.”
Learned Counsel further referred another judgment of
the Privy Council. In Siddik Mahomed Shah v. Mt. Saran and
others dated 25.10.1929 reported in 1929 SCC OnLine PC
79, wherein Hon’ble Apex Court observed as under:
“This is a hopeless appeal. A certain Hote Khan is
alleged by the appellant, who is in possession of
certain lands which belonged to Hote Khan to have
given these lands to him. That story is not accepted,
and there are concurrent findings as to the fact by
both Courts. After Hote Khan’s death there was a
transference of the lands in question by mutation of
names effected upon the application of Hote Khan’s
widow. The Judicial Commissioners think it very
probable that Hote Khan’s widow being an ignorant
person and with no one to help her, transferred the
lands in that way in order that her spiritual adviser
might hold them as trustee. The spiritual adviser,
who is the appellant wishes to keep them first upon
the ground already specified which their Lordships
have already disposed of and, secondly upon the
ground that it was a girt made by the widow herself
but that claim was never made in the defence
presented and the learned Judicial Commissioners
therefore, very truly find that no amount of
evidence can be looked into upon a plea which was
never put forward. The result is that their Lordships
will humbly advise His Majesty that the appeal
should be dismissed. As the respondents have not
appeared, there will be no order as to costs.”
Referring the same, Learned Counsel submitted that
before marking of the document i.e. Exhibit-3 series, it was the
duty of the appellant-defendant to raise objection but no such
objection was made by the appellant. So, at this stage, there is
no scope to accept the plea.
19.
In this regard, I would like to refer one judgment of this
Court. In RSA No.52 of 2022 dated 08.02.2023, the High
Court of Tripura in para 9, 10, 11 and 12, observed as under:
“9. Certified copy of any document is treated as
secondary evidence as contemplated under Section
63 of the Evidence Act. Admitted fact is that the
plaintiffs/appellants have produced certified copy of
the sale deed and not the original copy of the sale
deed.
Section 63 of Evidence Act reads as under:
“63. Secondary evidence.-Secondary evidence
means and includes(1)certified copies given under the provisions
hereinafter contained;
(2)copies
made
from
the
original
by
mechanical processes which in themselves
insure the accuracy of the copy, and copies
compared with such copies;
(3)copies made from or compared with the
original;
(4)counterparts of documents as against the
parties who did not execute them;
(5)oral accounts of the contents of a
document given by some person who has
himself seen it.”
Section 65 of the Evidence Act deals with the
cases in which secondary evidence relating to
documents may be given.
Section 65 reads as under:
“65.Cases in which secondary evidence
relating to documents may be given.Secondary evidence may be given of the
existence, condition or contents of a
document in the following cases(a)when the original is shown or appears to
be in the possession or powerof the person against whom the
document is sought to be proved, or of
any person out of reach of, or not
subject to, the process of the Court, or
of any person legally bound to produce
it.
And when, after the notice mentioned in
Section 66, such person does not produce
it;
(b) when the existence, condition or
contents of the original have been proved to
be admitted in writing by the person against
whom it is proved or by his representative
in interest;
(c) when the original has been destroyed or
lost, or when the party offering evidence of
its contents cannot, for any other reason not
arising from his own default or neglect,
produce it in reasonable time;
(d) when the original is of such a nature as
not to be easily movable;
(e)when the original is a public document
within the meaning of Section 74;
(f)when the original is a document of which
a certified copy is permitted by this Act, or
by any other law in force in India, to be
given in evidence;
(g)when the originals consist of numerous
accounts or other documents which cannot
conveniently be examined in Court, and the
fact to be proved is the general result of the
whole collection.
In cases (a), (c) and (d), any secondary
evidence of the contents of the document is
admissible.
In case (b),
admissible.
the
written
admission
is
In case (e) or (f), a certified copy of the
document, but no other kind of secondary
evidence, is admissible.
In case (g), evidence may be given as to the
general result of the documents by any
person who has examined them, and who is
skilled
in
the
examination
of
such
documents.”
10. In the instant case, the question raised and as
urged by learned counsel for the appellants that the
certified copy of the sale deed, when exhibited by
the Court without any objection from the opposite
party, is deemed to have been proved and its
admissibility in evidence cannot be questioned at a
later stage.
11. In R.V.E. Venkatachala Gounder vs. Arulmigu
Viswesaraswami & V.P. Temple, (2003) 8 SCC 752
Hon’ble Supreme Court held that “Ordinarily, an
objection to the admissibility of evidence should be
taken when it is tendered and not subsequently. The
objections as to admissibility of documents in
evidence may be classified into two classes:
(i) an objection that the document which is sought
to be proved is itself inadmissible in evidence; and
(ii) where the objection does not dispute the
admissibility of the document in evidence but is
directed towards the mode of proof alleging the
same to be irregular or insufficient. In the first case,
merely because a document has been marked as „an
exhibit‟, an objection as to its admissibility is not
excluded and is available to be raised even at a later
stage or even in appeal or revision. In the latter
case, the objection should be taken when the
evidence is tendered and once the document has
been admitted in evidence and marked as an
exhibit, the objection that it should not have been
admitted in evidence or that the mode adopted for
proving the document is irregular cannot be allowed
to be raised at any stage subsequent to the marking
of the document as an exhibit....”
12. In the context of the present case, this Court
finds that the defendants did not raise any objection
when the certified copy of the sale deed was
produced by the plaintiffs and taken into evidence
by the learned trial Court being marked as (Ext.3
series). In this situation, certified copy of the
original sale deed cannot be said to be inadmissible
in evidence since the said deed was permitted to be
exhibited by the defendants without any objection
as regards the foundational aspects for nonproduction of original sale deed. In Dayamathi Bai
(supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court had referred to
Venkatachala Gounder‟s case (supra) and also took
note of a passage from Sarkar on Evidence, 15th
Edn., p.1084, where it has been stated that where
copies of the documents are admitted without
objection in the trial Court, no objection to their
admissibility can be taken afterwards in the court of
appeal. When a party gives in evidence a certified
copy, without proving the circumstances entitling
him to give secondary evidence, objection must be
taken at the time of admission and such objection
will not be allowed at a later stage. There is no
quarrel with the aforesaid enunciation of law.”
20.
So, after hearing both the sides and after going through
the records of the Learned Court below, it appears that since
the
respondent-plaintiff
could
prove
Exhibit-3
series
in
accordance with law which the Learned Trial Court below failed
to appreciate the evidence of PW-2 in proving the Gift Deed.
The Learned First Appellate Court as already stated although
decided the issue No.III in favour of the respondent-plaintiff but
did not discuss anything regarding proving of Exhibit-3 series
by the witness of respondent-plaintiff and furthermore, there
was also no objection from the side of the present appellantdefendant in proving and marking the document as Exhibit. So,
in my considered view, the Learned First Appellate Court rightly
delivered the judgment in favour of the present respondentplaintiff affirming the judgment of the Learned Trial Court
regarding preliminary decree. Thus, the substantial question of
law as formulated leans in favour of the respondent-plaintiff of
this appeal.
It is to be noted here that the Learned Trial Court
although decided issue No.III against the respondent-plaintiff at
the time of delivery of judgment but in the decree, shown the
quantum of land as 0.12 acres i.e. the suit land as mentioned in
the plaint. Since there is no infirmity of the judgment passed by
Learned First Appellate Court, so, the present appeal deserves
no interference at this stage.
21.
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant-
defendant No.1 is hereby dismissed on contest with costs. The
judgment dated 09.12.2021 and decree dated 06.05.2022
passed by Learned District Judge, Khowai, Tripura in T.A. No.06
of 2018 is hereby upheld and accordingly, it is affirmed. The
suit property be partitioned in pursuance of the decree of the
Learned Trial Court below affirmed by the Learned First
Appellate Court.
Prepare decree accordingly.
Send down the LCRs.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Deepshikha
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2024.02.28
04:00:58 -08'00'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review