Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WA 27 of 2017
Sri Arindam Ghosh, Assistant Engineer, Drinking Water and
Sanitation (DWS) under Public Works Department, presently
posted on deputation in Police Engineering Cell, PHQ, Agartala,
West Tripura.
-----Appellant(s)
Versus
1. The State of Tripura, represented by the Principal Secretary to the
Government of Tripura, Public Works Department, New
Secretariat, P.O. New Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura
2. The Principal Secretary to the Government of Tripura, General
Administration (AR) Department, New Secretariat, P.O. New
Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura
3. Mr. Shantanu, IAS, (Inquiring Authority), the then
Commissioner of Departmental Enquiries, Government of Tripura,
Agartala
4. The Chief Engineer, Public Works Department (DWS), New
Secretariat, P.O. New Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura.
-----Respondent(s)
BEFORE
HON‟BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. INDRAJIT MAHANTY
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE S.G.CHATTOPADHYAY
For the Appellant(s)
: Mr. S. M. Chakraborty, Sr. Adv.
Ms. P. Chakraborty, Adv.
For the Respondent(s) : Mr. D. Sharma, Addl. G.A.
Date of hearing
: 14.12.2021
Date of delivery of
: 03.11.2022
Judgment & order
Whether fit for reporting :
Yes No
-2-
JUDGMENT&ORDER
[Per S.G.Chattopadhyay. J]
The present writ appeal is directed against the common
judgment and order dated 25.4.2017 passed by the learned Single Judge in
W.P.(C) No. 266 of 2011 and W.P.(C) No. 488 of 2011 whereby the
learned Single Judge dismissed both of the writ petitions.
[2]
The factual background of the case is as under:
By a memorandum dated 29.6.2006 vide No.F.11(6)-GA
(AR)/05/1406-1411, appellant, Arindam Ghosh and his colleagues, Sudip
Sinha and Siddhartha Sengupta were imputed by the Commissioner and
Secretary to the Government of Tripura in the GA (AR) Department on
the charge of misconduct and it was proposed under the said
memorandum that Departmental Proceedings under Rule 14 of the
Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1965
[for short CCS (CCA) Rules] would be carried out against them on the
following charge:
“ARTICLE NO. I.
That the said (1) Sri Arindam Ghosh, Assistant Engineer,
while functioning as Sub-Divisional Officer, Public Health
Engineering Sub-Division No-XVI, Ambassa, Dhalai during the
period from 22.08.2000 to 18.07.2003, (2) Sri Sudip Sinha, while
functioning as Jr. Engineer attached to the office of the S.D.O.,
P.H.E. Sub-Division No-XVI, Ambassa, Dhalai during the period
from 10.08.1999 till date and (3) Sri Siddartha Sengupta while
functioning as Junior Engineer attached to the office of the
WA 27 of 2017
-3-
S.D.O., P.H.E. Sub-Division No-XVI, Ambassa, Dhalai during the
period from 26.09.2000 to 06.07.2002 failed to maintain absolute
integrity and devotion to duty in so far as they failed to supervise
the construction of 40,000 gallon capacity of reinforced cement
concrete (RCC) overhead reservoir of 15.30 Mtr. staging height
taken up under the scheme of „Accelerated Rural Water Supply
Scheme (ARWS) at Kulai‟, Ambassa vide work order
No.F.7(5)/EE/PHE/KD-II/8201-8208 dated 30.02.1998 issued by
the Executive Engineer, PHE Division No-II, Kumarghat. After
the so-called execution of the construction of the work,
measurements were recorded in the measurement books (MB) by
Sri Sudip Sinha & Sri Siddartha Sengupta, both Junior Engineer
and 50% of the measurement were test checked by Sri Arindam
Ghosh, the then S.D.O., P.H.E. Sub-Division No-XVI, Ambassa.
Though the work was shown to have been completed on
17.11.2003, it was subsequently found that the said overhead tank
was defective and was completely useless. They were negligent in
supervising work and giving technical guidance. As a result, the
construction of reservoir was found defective after completion
and could not be made operational. It was completely useless. The
concrete used for the overhead tank was inadequately compacted
resulting in air voids in the mass of concrete. Re-inforcement
cover of the cylindrical wall of the tank was inadequate and
already rusted. Stone chips used in the concrete were not proper
grading. These defects resulted in water percolation from the
overhead tank and rendered the structure completely useless. For
negligence of them the State Government had to incur a financial
loss to the tune of Rs.15,15,243/- only paid to the contractor in six
running Bills.
By their above act, Shri Arindam Ghosh, the then SDO.,
PHE, Shri Sudip Sinha, Junior Engineer & Shri Siddartha
Sengupta, Junior Engineer committed gross misconduct which is
quite unbecoming of a Government servant and thus, they
violated Rule-3 of the Tripura Civil Service (Conduct) Rules,
1988.”
[3]
The statement of imputation of misconduct and misbehavior
in support of the said Article of Charge was placed as well by the said
memorandum dated 29.6.2006 and the memorandum along with its
enclosures was communicated to the appellant and the other two accused
officers asking them to submit their written statement of defence within a
period of 10 days.
WA 27 of 2017
-4-
[4]
Manifestly, the charge crystallized that the appellant and his
accused colleagues were entrusted with the supervision of the
construction of a of Reinforced Cement Concrete (RCC) overhead
reservoir of 40,000 gallon capacity and 15.30 Mtr. staging height under
‘Accelerated Rural Water Supply Scheme (ARWS) at Kulai’. After
construction, it was found that the said overhead tank was defective and
completely useless which occurred due to negligence of the appellant and
his accused colleagues in supervising the work. As a result, the reservoir
could not be made operational. The charge contained that reinforcement
cover of the cylindrical wall of the tank was inadequate and already
rusted. Even the stone chips used in the concrete were not of proper
grading. Thus, it was imputed that the original writ petitioners (one of
whom is the appellant herein) were completely negligent in supervising
the construction work and due to their negligence, the defects resulted in
water percolation from the overhead tank and rendered the structure
completely useless which caused financial loss to the tune of
Rs.15,15,243/- to the State-respondents and the accused officers thereby
committed gross misconduct which was unbecoming of a Government
servant and a violation of Rule-3 of Tripura Civil Service (Conduct)
Rules, 1988.
WA 27 of 2017
-5-
[5]
The appellant and the other two accused officers denied the
charge by filing their written statement of defence. Since the Disciplinary
Authority was not convinced by their defence, Disciplinary Proceedings
continued against them. Shri Shantanu, commissioner of Departmental
Inquiry, Government of Tripura held the inquiry. After holding a fullfledged enquiry, the said Inquiry Officer had drawn up report on the basis
of the oral and documentary evidence adduced on behalf of the parties
and held that among the three accused officers, the charge against accused
officer, Siddhartha Sengupta, a Jr. Engineer at the relevant time was not
proved because, none of the witnesses gave any incriminating statement
against him. The Inquiry Officer held that prosecution successfully
established the case against the appellant namely, Arindam Ghosh and his
colleague Sudip Sinha who was a Jr. Engineer in the office of the S.D.O.,
P.H.E. Sub-Division No. XVI at Ambassa. It was proved that the concrete
used in the wall of the tank was inadequately compacted resulting in air
voids in the mass of the concrete and moreover the stone chips used in the
concrete were not of proper grading. The technical expert committee
constituted by the State government also found that the construction
portion of the overhead tank i.e. the cylindrical wall portion plus the top
dome was supervised by appellant, Arindam Ghosh and accused-officer
Sudip Sinha for whose negligence, the defects in the construction
WA 27 of 2017
-6-
occurred which had made the said overhead tank completely useless and
non-operational. The relevant extract of the report of the Inquiry Officer
is as under:
“……….After taking into consideration of the submission made
by both sides, I find that(a)
The Prosecution could establish that concrete used in the
wall of the tank was inadequately compacted resulting in
air voids in the mass of concrete and the stone chips used
in the concrete were not of proper grading observed by
the technical expert committee (Exbt. S/2). The defence
could not counter this satisfactorily. The construction of
this portion of the overhead tank i.e. cylindrical wall
portion plus the top dome was supervised by the A.O. Sri
Sudip Sinha, the then Jr. Engineer and Sri Arindam
Ghosh, A.O. was the Asstt. Engineer. As per MB No.462
(Exbt. S/5), the cost of this work comes to Rs.2,85,155/-.
(b)
The Prosecution could not prove the charge against the
A.O. Sri Siddhartha Sengupta, Jr. Enginer who
supervised the construction of bottom ring beam and
bottom slab. None of the prosecution witness has either
stated or adduced any evidence showing defect in
construction of the bottom ring beam and bottom slab.
Though, it may be a different fact that for technical
reasons best known to the expert committee, which could
not be found in their report (Exbt. S/2), they
recommended dismantling of the entire tank portion
including bottom slab portion also (excluding staging) and
its reconstruction. So, Sri Siddhartha Sengupta, A.O.
cannot be held guilty for it.
(c)
Since, I have already stated at (a) above that the
prosecution has proved that the compaction was not done
properly in construction of cylindrical portion of the
overhead tank and the stone chips used were not of
proper grading which is sufficient to prove that the A.O.s
Sri Arindam Ghosh & Sri Sudip Sinha failed to supervise
the construction of cylindrical wall portion plus dome.
Therefore, I do not find it necessary to go into the merits
of the allegation made by Sri Arindam Ghosh, A.O. that
the inner surface of the overhead tank was chiseled by the
contractor on instruction of the then Executive Engineer
just before the visit of the inquiry committee.
In view of the above, I find and hold that the
prosecution could prove the charge against the A.O.s
namely (i) Sri Arindam Ghosh, & (ii) Sri Sudip Sinha that
they failed to supervise the construction of 40,000 gallon
capacity of reinforced cement concrete (RCC) overhead
WA 27 of 2017
-7-
reservoir of 15.30 Mtr. Staging height taken up under the
scheme of „Accelerated Rural Water Supply Scheme
(ARWS) at Kulai‟, Ambassa. But the prosecution could
not prove the charge against Sri Siddhartha Sengupta,
A.O. In the result, decision on Point No.(i) is given in
affirmative and decided in favour of the Prosecution for
the Accused Officers namely (i) Sri Arindam Ghosh, &
(ii) Sri Sudip Sinha and against the defence. However,
decision on Point No.(i) is given in negative and decided in
favour of the defence and against the prosecution for the
A.O. Sri Siddhartha Sengupta.
Point No.(ii):- Since the decision on Point No.(i) is
given in affirmative and decided in favour of the
prosecution for the Accused Officers namely (i) Sri
Arindam Ghosh, & (ii) Sri Sudip Sinha, therefore, I find
and hold that the prosecution could prove the charge
against the A.O.s namely (i) Sri Arindam Ghosh, & (ii)
Sri Sudip Sinha that they failed to supervise the
construction of 40,000 gallon capacity of reinforced
cement concrete (RCC) overhead reservoir of 15.30 mtr.
Staging height taken up under the scheme of „Accelerated
Rural Water Supply Scheme (ARWS) at Kulai‟,
Ambassa.
But the prosecution could not prove the charge
against Sri Siddhartha Sengupta, A.O. as discussed at
point No.(i) above, therefore, decision on this point No.(ii)
for the A.O. Sri Siddhartha Sengupta is given in negative
and decided in favour of the defence and against the
prosecution. In the result, I hold that the Accused Officers
namely (i) Sri Arindam Ghosh, & (ii) Sri Sudip Sinha
failed to maintain absolute integrity, devotion to duty and
acted in a manner which is unbecoming of a Government
servant violating Rule-3 of the Tripura Civil Services
(Conduct) Rules, 1988.
9.
As an upshot of the discussions made herein above
the Point No.(i) & (ii) has been decided in favour of the
prosecution in respect of the Accused Officers namely (i)
Sri Arindam Ghosh, & (ii) Sri Sudip Sinha. Whereas, the
prosecution could not prove the charge against the A.O.
Sri Siddhartha Sengupta. Therefore, after due
consideration of both oral and documentary evidences of
both parties and their written briefs and my individual
assessment, I find and hold that the prosecution could
prove the charge drawn up under Article-I of the
Annexure-I of the instant proceeding/charge Memo
against the A.O.s namely (i) Sri Arindam Ghosh, & (ii)
Sri Sudip Sinha. But the prosecution could not prove the
charge against Sri Siddhartha Sengupta, A.O. and it is
decided accordingly.”
WA 27 of 2017
-8-
[6]
After the Inquiring Authority submitted its report (Annexure-
4 to the writ petition), the charged officers were served with a copy of the
report by memorandum dated 10.2.2010 (Annexure- 4 to the writ petition)
and they were asked to submit their written representation, if any, against
the findings of the Inquiring Authority within 15 days from the date of
receipt of the memo.
[7]
Each of the charged officers furnished their written
representations within the stipulated period of time. The Disciplinary
Authority, after consideration of their representation provisionally
decided to impose the following penalty on them:
[8]
“i)
The pay of Accused Officers namely Shri Arindam
Ghosh, Assistant Engineer and Shri Sudip Sinha, Junior
Engineer shall be reduced to the lower stage in the time
scale of pay for a period of 3(three) years with cumulative
effect;
ii)
The actual financial loss to the Government which work
out to Rs.2,85,115/- (Two lakhs eighty five thousand one
hundred and fifteen only) shall be recovered from the
Accused Officers Shri Arindam Ghosh, Assistant
Engineer and Shri Sudip Sinha, Junior Engineer, equally
from their salary.”
After consultation with Tripura Public Service Commission
in terms of the Rule 15(4) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 and further
considering all aspects of the matter, the Disciplinary Authority by
memorandum dated 08.12.2010 under No.F.11(6)-GA(AR)/2005/2147-
WA 27 of 2017
-9-
2151 imposed the following penalty on appellant, Arindam Ghosh and
accused officer Sudip Sinha:
[9]
“i)
The pay of Accused Officers namely Shri Arindam
Ghosh, Assistant Engineer and Shri Sudip Sinha, Junior
Engineer be reduced to the lower stage in the time scale of
pay for a period of 3(three) years with cumulative effect;
ii)
The actual financial loss to the Government which work
out to Rs.2,85,115/- (Two lakhs eighty five thousand one
hundred and fifteen only) be recovered from the Accused
Officers Shri Arindam Ghosh, Assistant Engineer and
Shri Sudip Sinha, Junior Engineer, equally from their
salary.”
The Disciplinary Authority agreed with the findings of the
Inquiring Authority in respect of accused appellant and Siddhartha
Sengupta (Jr. Engineer) and closed the proceedings against him.
[10]
Against the said order of penalty, the appellant filed
departmental appeal before the Chief Secretary, Government of Tripura
(Appellate Authority) by filing a memorandum of appeal dated 02.2.2011
on the following grounds:
(i)
The Expert Committee appointed by the Government while
conducting on the spot inquiry into the alleged negligence of
the appellant in supervising the construction work of the
overhead tank had taken a videograph, copy of which was
not furnished to the appellant which caused prejudice to the
appellant in making his defence before the Inquiring Officer.
WA 27 of 2017
-10-
(ii)
Appellant wanted to further cross-examine Shri R.K.
Majumder, Chairman of the Expert Committee. He was also
summoned by the Inquiring Authority for further crossexamination by the appellant. But, said Shri R.K. Majumder
did not turn up before the Inquiring Authority. As a result,
the appellant was prejudiced in his defence.
(iii)
Similarly, Shri Bishu Debbarma, Executive Engineer who
was also a member of the expert committee did not also turn
up before the Inquiring Authority for further crossexamination by the appellant which affected defence of the
appellant.
(iv)
The expert committee held spot inquiry in absence of the
appellant
and
submitted
report
without
giving
any
opportunity to the appellant to offer an explanation before
the said technical expert committee.
(v)
Shri Bishu Debbarma, Executive Engineer who was also
entrusted with the supervision of the construction work was
made a member of the expert committee, which was
completely unfair and illegal.
WA 27 of 2017
-11-
[11]
The said Departmental Appellate Authority by an order dated
24.5.2011 under No.F.11(6)-GA(AR)2005/1019-1020 upheld the findings
of the Disciplinary Authority and dismissed the appeal observing as
under:
“4.
Charges framed against the Charged Officers
were proved during the inquiry. After consideration of all
aspects and the views of the TPSC, the Disciplinary
Authority has imposed penalty of reduction in pay along
with recovery of financial loss caused to the Government
from the Charged Officers, Shri Arindam Ghosh and Shri
Sudip Sinha.
5.
Issues raised by the Appellant:
5.1
Document in Sl. No.7 of Annexure-III of the
charge sheet is a videograph CD of the Kulai Overhead
Tank, containing the report of the Technical Expert
Committee, constituted for investigation of the
construction of the tank, under the Chairmanship of Shri
Ranjit Majumder. This CD was not supplied to the A.O.
by the P.O. inspite of an order from the I.A.
From records it appears that Sri Ranjit
Majumder has submitted his investigation report along
with videograph CD to the Deputy Secretary, PWD and
that during inspection of the listed documents mentioned
in Annexure-III of the charge-sheet, the PO did not place
the CD before the I.O. However, the inquiry was held
based on available records.
5.2
Prosecution witnesses Shri R.K. Majumder and
Shri Bishnu Debbarma were not available for cross
examination even though notices were issued and the I.A.
closed the chapter of cross examination of both these
witnesses.
The contention of the A.O. is not correct. In order
sheet dated 19.05.09 I.A. has noted that in consultation
with the P.O. and the I.O. further scope was given to the
prosecution in this regard.
6.
The disciplinary proceedings are to be conducted
as per available records based on preponderance of
probability. In case some documents are not available, the
proceeding has to be dealt based on available records and
corroborative evidence after giving reasonable
opportunity to the charged officer. In the instant case,
Disciplinary Authority appears to have taken such an
approach.
WA 27 of 2017
-12-
After careful consideration of all issues raised in
the appeal petition, I find no merit/new points in the
contention of Shri Arindam Ghosh for setting aside the
order of the Disciplinary Authority. Accordingly, the
appeal is rejected and the order of Disciplinary Authority
is upheld.”
[12]
Aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the said order of the
Departmental Appellate Authority, appellant, Arindam Ghosh filed
W.P.(C) 266 of 2011 claiming following relieves:
“ (i)
To issue rule to the respondents to show cause as
to why the inquiry report (Annexure 4 to the writ
petition), punishment order (Annexure-5 to the writ
petition) and appellate order (Annexure-7 to the writ
petition) should not be declared bad and void.
(ii)
To quash the same accordingly for being born and
fostered in bad faith of the Respondents, being shaped
without affording the principle of natural justice, and
without following the rule of evidence to find the
petitioner guilty.”
[13]
Accused officer, Sudip Sinha claimed similar relieves by
filing W.P.(C) No.488 of 2011 under Article 226 of the Constitution.
[14]
The State-respondents filed counter affidavit(s) to resist the
writ petitions before the learned Single Judge in which it was asserted on
behalf of the State-respondents that writ petitioners A. Ghosh (Appellant
herein) and Sudip Sinha completely failed to supervise the construction of
40,000 gallon capacity Reinforced Cement Concrete (RCC) overhead
reservoir at Kulai, Ambassa as a result of which, the reservoir was found
defective and it could not be made operational. The said defects resulted
WA 27 of 2017
-13-
in huge financial loss to the Government to the tune of Rs.15,15,243/-.
The State-respondents further asserted before the learned Single Judge
that a technical expert committee comprising of four Sr. Engineers of
P.W.D. investigated into the causes of defects in the said overhead tank
and came to the conclusion that negligence of the writ petitioners in
supervising the work and their failure in giving proper technical guidance
to the contractor and labourers and inadequate reinforcement cover of the
cylindrical wall of the tank as well as the use of substandard stone chips
in the concrete resulted in water percolation from the overhead tank and
rendered the structure completely useless. The respondents claimed in
their counter reply that all documents including the copy of the video CD
were supplied to the writ petitioners and they were given full opportunity
of hearing before the Inquiring Authority. It was stated that the appeal
preferred by the writ petitioners against the penalty imposed on them was
also duly considered by the Departmental Appellate Authority and the
said appeal was rejected by the departmental appellate authority by a
detailed order.
[15]
The counsel appearing for the writ petitioners argued before
the learned Single Judge that the Inquiring Authority did not examine two
vital witnesses namely, Shri R.K. Majumder who was the Chairman of the
technical expert committee and Shri Bishu Kumar Debbarma another
WA 27 of 2017
-14-
member of the said technical expert committee. As a result, the writ
petitioners were deprived of the opportunity of cross-examination of those
two vital witnesses. Learned counsel of the writ petitioner also argued
before the learned Single Judge that the principles of natural justice were
not followed in letter and spirit during the disciplinary proceedings held
against the writ petitioners for which, the said proceedings were liable to
be quashed.
[16]
The State-counsel, on the other hand, supported the findings
of the Disciplinary Authority and urged before the learned Single Judge
for setting aside the writ petitions filed by the petitioners.
[17]
Having found no merit in the writ petitions, the learned
Single Judge dismissed both of the writ petitions observing as under:
“…….7. The aforesaid findings are technical in nature, which, in
turn, are based on the Technical Expert Committee. Whether the
concrete used in the wall of the tank was inadequately compacted
resulting in air voids in the mass of concrete and the stone chips
used in the concrete were not of proper grading (as?) are matters
which could be easily observed by the technical committee
(Exbt.S/2). It is not within the province of a writ court to
reappreciate the evidence recorded by the Technical Expert
Committee. However, the finding that the construction of the
reservoir was found defective after completion and could not be
made operational; it was completely useless, are self-evident or
res ipsa loquitor. No formal proof is necessary in a case of this
nature. It is not the case of the petitioner that the reservoir
constructed under his very nose is not defective and is really
operational. Judicial review in a case of this nature, which
requires examination by technical expert, is extremely limited.
The legal position is best described in the words of Chief Justice
Neely quoted with approval by the Apex Court in Jal Mahal
Resorts (P) Ltd. v. K. P. Sharma and others, (2014) 8 SCC 804, at
page 863, which are in the following terms:
WA 27 of 2017
-15-
“140. At this juncture, we take note of two
overriding considerations which combined,
narrow the scope of review. The first is that of
deference to the views of administrative experts
and the other we take assistance from the words
of Chief Justice Neely who expressed as follows:
„I have very few illusions about my own
limitations as a judge and from those
limitations I generalise to the inherent
limitations of all appellate courts
reviewing rare cases.‟
The learned Chief Justice further observed as
follows:
“I am not an accountant, electrical engineer,
financier, banker, stock broker, or systems
management analyst. It is the height of folly to
expect judges intelligently to review a 5000 page
record addressing the intricacies of public utility
operation.
It is not the function of a judge to act as a super
board, or with the zeal of a pedantic schoolmaster
substituting its judgment for that of the
administrator. The result is a theory of review
that limits the extent to which the discretion of the
expert may be scrutinized by the non-expert
judge. It was suggested that the alternative for the
court is to desist itself from interference on
technical matters, where all the advantages of
expertise lie with the agencies. If the court were to
review fully the decision of an expert body such as
State Board of Medical Examiners, it would find
itself wandering amid the maze of therapeutics or
boggling at the mysteries of the pharmacopoeia.”
8. I may also reproduce below the scope of judicial review in a
departmental enquiry propounded by the Apex Court in High
Court of Judicature at Bombay v. Shashikant S. Patil and another,
(2000) 1 SCC 416, at page 422 :
“16. The Division Bench of the High Court seems to have
approached the case as though it was an appeal against
the order of the administrative/disciplinary authority of
the High Court. Interference with the decision of
departmental authorities can be permitted, while
exercising jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution if such authority had held proceedings in
violation of the principles of natural justice or in violation
of statutory regulations prescribing the mode of such
enquiry or if the decision of the authority is vitiated by
considerations extraneous to the evidence and merits of
the case, or if the conclusion made by the authority, on
the very face of it, is wholly arbitrary or capricious that
no reasonable person could have arrived at such a
WA 27 of 2017
-16-
conclusion, or grounds very similar to the above. But we
cannot overlook that the departmental authority (in this
case the Disciplinary Committee of the High Court) is the
sole judge of the facts, if the enquiry has been properly
conducted. The settled legal position is that if there is some
legal evidence on which the findings can be based, then
adequacy or even reliability of that evidence is not a matter
for canvassing before the High Court in a writ petition filed
under Article 226 of the Constitution.”
(Italics supplied)
9. In my judgment, the instant case is one without fear of
contradiction that there is definitely some evidence, i.e. the
evidence of the Technical Expert Committee, on which the
findings of the enquiry officer can be based. Once it is so held, it
is not the business of this Court to examine the adequacy or even
the reliability of that evidence. After all, the role of this Court is
only a secondary role, whereas the role of the disciplinary
authority is a primary role. This Court cannot usurp the function
of the disciplinary authority. Though some witnesses were not
examined by the enquiry officer despite repeated request to that
effect made by the petitioner, the findings of the Technical Expert
Committee, which was duly exhibited as Exbt.S/2 by the
Department, and the evidence of PW-4 (BK Debbarma, the then
jurisdictional Executive Engineer) are not assailable and such
evidence, in any case, can be said to constitute some evidence to
prove the guilt of the petitioner in a departmental enquiry. It is
true that such evidence may not be adequate to prove the guilt of
that petitioner beyond reasonable doubt, but then, we are here
not dealing with a criminal case; that makes all the difference.
10. The result of the foregoing discussion is that there is no merit
in this writ petition, which is, accordingly, dismissed. However,
on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the parties are
directed to bear their respective costs. Interim order, if any
stands vacated.
WP(C) No.488 of 2011
As the facts in this case and the facts in the foregoing case
are on all fours, this writ petition must also meet the same fate.
Resultantly, this writ petition has no merit and is, therefore,
dismissed without costs. Interim order, if any, stands vacated.”
[18]
Accused-officer, Arindam Ghosh has filed the present appeal
challenging the said judgment of the learned Single Judge. We have heard
Mr. S.M. Chakraborty, learned senior counsel appearing for the appellant
along with Ms. P. Chakraborty, learned advocate. Heard Mr. D. Sharma,
learned Addl. G.A. representing the State-respondents.
WA 27 of 2017
-17-
[19]
The appellant has challenged the judgment of the learned
Single Judge mainly on the following grounds:
(i)
Shri R.K. Majumder, Chairman of the technical expert
committee did not turn up for cross-examination by the
appellant before the Inquiring Authority. As a result, the
appellant was prejudiced in his defence.
(ii)
The appellant was not given any opportunity to crossexamine the members of the technical expert committee on
the videograph taken by such committee during their spot
investigation. This apart, the technical expert committee held
the said spot investigation in absence of the appellant. As a
result, appellant was deprived of the opportunity of offering
an explanation before the technical expert committee.
(iii)
Shri Bishu Kumar Debbarma, Executive Engineer, who was
also entrusted with the supervision of the construction work
of the said reservoir was included in the technical expert
committee as a member, which was completely illegal and
against the principles of natural justice.
[20]
Counsel appearing for the appellant has argued before us that
the principles of natural justice were not followed by the Disciplinary
WA 27 of 2017
-18-
Authority in conducting the Disciplinary Proceedings against the
appellant for which, the entire Disciplinary Proceedings against him is
liable to be quashed.
[21]
The State-counsel, on the other hand, has argued that full
opportunity of hearing was given to the appellant during Disciplinary
Proceedings held against him. Learned counsel has contended that the
appellant also availed the opportunity of filing an appeal before the
Departmental Appellate Authority. The Departmental Appellate Authority
decided the appeal on merit by a reasoned judgment. According to the
State-counsel, High Court can only exercise its limited jurisdiction to
interfere with the order passed in a Departmental Proceedings only when
it is proved to the satisfaction of the Court that errors of law or procedural
error has occurred resulting in manifest miscarriage of justice or violation
of the principles of natural justice. Counsel has argued that since the
appellant has been penalized in Departmental Proceedings on the charge
of gross misconduct in terms of the procedure prescribed under the
relevant statute after providing full opportunity of hearing to him, the
orders of the Disciplinary Authority do not call for any interference by
this Court.
WA 27 of 2017
-19-
[22]
We have considered the submissions made before us by
learned counsel representing the parties. We have also perused the entire
record of the case.
[23]
The Apex Court has examined the scope of judicial review in
service matters in a catena of decisions. In State of Andhra Pradesh and
Others vs. S. Sree Rama Rao reported in AIR 1963 SC 1723, the Apex
Court has succinctly held that the High Court is not a court of appeal over
the decision of the authority holding disciplinary proceedings against a
public servant. Observation of the Apex Court in the said judgment is as
under:
“7....The High Court is not constituted in a proceeding
under Article 226 of the Constitution a court of appeal over the
decision of the authorities holding a departmental enquiry
against a public servant: it is concerned to determine whether the
enquiry is held by an authority competent in that behalf, and
according to the procedure prescribed in that behalf, and
whether the rules of natural justice are not violated. Where there
is some evidence, which the authority entrusted with the duty to
hold the enquiry has accepted and which evidence may
reasonably support the conclusion that the delinquent officer is
guilty of the charge, it is not the function of the High Court in a
petition for a writ under Article 226 to review the evidence and to
arrive at an independent finding on the evidence...... ”.
[24]
In the case of B.C.Chaturvedi vs. Union of India and others
reported in (1995) 6 SCC 749:(AIR 1996 SC 484), the Apex Court held
that in disciplinary proceedings when the conclusion arrived at by the
disciplinary authority receives support from the evidence, the disciplinary
authority can hold the charged officer guilty and the court / tribunal
WA 27 of 2017
-20-
cannot sit over the decision of the disciplinary authority as an appellate
authority to re-appreciate the evidence and arrive at its own findings on
such evidence. In the said judgment the Apex Court observed as under:
“12. Judicial review is not an appeal from a decision but a review
of the manner in which the decision is made. Power of judicial
review is meant to ensure that the individual receives fair
treatment and not to ensure that the conclusion which the
authority reaches is necessarily correct in the eye of the court.
When an inquiry is conducted on charges of misconduct by a
public servant, the Court/Tribunal is concerned to determine
whether the inquiry was held by a competent officer or whether
rules of natural justice are complied with. Whether the findings
or conclusions are based on some evidence, the authority
entrusted with the power to hold inquiry has jurisdiction, power
and authority to reach a finding of fact or conclusion. But that
finding must be based on some evidence. Neither the technical
rules of Evidence Act nor of proof of fact or evidence as defined
therein, apply to disciplinary proceeding. When the authority
accepts that evidence and conclusion receives support therefrom,
the disciplinary authority is entitled to hold that the delinquent
officer is guilty of the charge. The Court/Tribunal in its power of
judicial review does not act as appellate authority to reappreciate the evidence and to arrive at its own independent
findings on the evidence. The Court/Tribunal may interfere
where the authority held the proceedings against the delinquent
officer in a manner inconsistent with the rules of natural justice
or in violation of statutory rules prescribing the mode of inquiry
or where the conclusion or finding reached by the disciplinary
authority is based on no evidence. If the conclusion or finding be
such as no reasonable person would have ever reached, the
Court/Tribunal may interfere with the conclusion or the finding,
and mould the relief so as to make it appropriate to the facts of
each case.
13.The disciplinary authority is the sole judge of facts. Where
appeal is presented, the appellate authority has co-extensive
power to reappreciate the evidence or the nature of punishment.
In a disciplinary inquiry, the strict proof of legal evidence and
findings on that evidence are not relevant. Adequacy of evidence
or reliability of evidence cannot be permitted to be canvassed
before the Court/Tribunal. In Union of India v. H.C. Goel [(1964)
4 SCR 718: AIR 1964 SC 364 (1964)1 LLJ 38], this Court held at
page 728 that if the conclusion, upon consideration of the
evidence, reached by the disciplinary authority, is perverse or
suffers from patent error on the face of the record or based on no
evidence at all, a writ of certiorari could be issued.”
WA 27 of 2017
-21-
[25]
Similarly, in State Bank of Bikaner and Jaipur Vs. Nemi
Chand Nalwaya reported in (2011) 4 SCC 584: (AIR 2011 SC 1931)
Apex Court held that question whether evidence against the charged
officer was adequate or reliable in the departmental proceeding would not
be a ground for interfering with the findings of the disciplinary authority
if it is seen that enquiry has been fairly conducted and the findings are
also based on evidence. Observation of the Apex Court is as under:
“7. It is now well settled that the courts will not act as an
appellate court and reassess the evidence led in the domestic
enquiry, nor interfere on the ground that another view is possible
on the material on record. If the enquiry has been fairly and
properly held and the findings are based on evidence, the
question of adequacy of the evidence or the reliable nature of the
evidence will not be grounds for interfering with the findings in
departmental enquiries. Therefore, courts will not interfere with
findings of fact recorded in departmental enquiries, except where
such findings are based on no evidence or where they are clearly
perverse. The test to find out perversity is to see whether a
tribunal acting reasonably could have arrived at such conclusion
or finding, on the material on record. Courts will however
interfere with the findings in disciplinary matters, if principles of
natural justice or statutory regulations have been violated or if
the order is found to be arbitrary, capricious, mala fide or based
on extraneous considerations.”
[26]
In Union of India vs. P.Gunasekaran reported in (2015) 2
SCC 610 : (AIR 2015 SC 545), the Apex Court laid down the following
parameters for the High Courts while exercising power under Article
226/227 of the Constitution on similar issue:
“13. Under Article 226/227 of the Constitution of India,
the High Court shall not:
(i) re-appreciate the evidence;
(ii) interfere with the conclusions in the enquiry, in case
the same has been conducted in accordance with law;
WA 27 of 2017
-22-
(iii) go into the adequacy of the evidence;
(iv) go into the reliability of the evidence;
(v) interfere, if there be some legal evidence on which
findings can be based.
(vi) correct the error of fact however grave it may appear
to be;
(vii) go into the proportionality of punishment unless it
shocks its conscience.”
[27]
Same ratio has been reiterated by the Apex Court in the case
of Pravin Kumar vs. Union of India and Others reported in (2020) 9SCC
471 wherein the Apex Court held as under:
“28. It is thus well settled that the Constitutional Courts
while exercising their powers of judicial review would not
assume the role of an appellate authority. Their
jurisdiction is circumscribed by limits of correcting errors
of law, procedural errors leading to manifest injustice or
violation of principles of natural justice. Put differently,
judicial review is not analogous to venturing into the
merits of a case like an appellate authority.”
[28]
We have examined the case within the parameters laid down
by the Apex Court in the judgments cited to supra. In the given context,
the Disciplinary Authority imputed that the petitioners committed
misconduct by showing negligence in supervising the construction of a
Reinforced Cement Concrete (RCC) overhead reservoir of 40,000 gallon
capacity at Kulai in Ambassa and as a result of their negligence in
supervising the work and issuing proper instructions to the contractors
and labourer engaged in the work, stone chips of substandard quality were
used and the reservoir were found defective and it could not be made
WA 27 of 2017
-23-
operational. Due to such negligence, the State Government suffered
financial loss to the tune of Rs.15,15,243/-.
[29]
The learned Single Judge has viewed that the technical
expert committee constituted by the State Government to investigate into
the causes of defect in the reservoir has categorically opined that such
defects occurred due to negligence of the appellant and other engineers
entrusted with the supervision of the work.
[30]
Learned Single Judge discarded the contention of the counsel
of the petitioner that evidence recorded during the DP was inadequate to
hold the appellant guilty to the charge viewing that in a Departmental
Enquiry, guilt of the accused-officer need not be proved beyond
reasonable shadow of doubt. The standard of proof required in a
Disciplinary Proceeding is preponderance of probability. Learned Single
Judge has also held that in a writ petition against the order of the
Disciplinary Authority, Court cannot take the role of Disciplinary
Authority and on the basis of such observations, the learned Single Judge
declined to interfere with the findings of the Disciplinary Authority.
[31]
On a bare perusal of the record, it would emerge that the
Disciplinary Authority after examining the whole evidence recorded by
the Inquiring Authority agreed with the findings of the Inquiring
WA 27 of 2017
-24-
Authority and came to the conclusion of guilt of the appellant. Apparently
Shri R.K. Majumder, chairman of the technical expert committee and Shri
Bishu Kumar Debbarma, member of the said technical expert committee
were examined by the Inquiring Authority and they were also crossexamined by the appellant. Therefore, his contention that he was deprived
of cross-examining those two witnesses is devoid of merit. The contention
of the appellant that Bishu Kumar Debbarma was entrusted with the
supervision of the construction of the said reservoir is not acceptable for
lack of evidence in this regard. The appellant could not also place any
material before this Court to come to a conclusion that the principles of
natural justice were not followed during the Disciplinary Proceedings
against the appellant.
[32]
In these circumstances, we find no infirmity in the judgment
of the learned Single Judge. Resultantly, the appeal stands dismissed.
In terms of the above, the case is disposed of.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
(S.G.CHATTOPADHYAY) J
Sabyasachi G.
WA 27 of 2017
(INDRAJIT MAHANTY) CJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review