The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
09. 09.2025 Whether fit for reporting : √ HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA JUDGMENT & ORDER (S. Datta Purkayastha, J.) The judgment dated 29.03.2025 passed by the learned Addl. Judge, Family Court, Agartala, West Tripura in Title Suit (Judicial Separation) No.02 of 2022 and the related decree thereof, dismissing the petition of the appellant [hereinafter referred as the petitioner] for judicial separation, are under challenge in this appeal. [2] The marriage between the petitioner and the respondent was solemnized on 25.04.2012. According to the petitioner, after marriage, they led their happy conjugal life only for 1 month 28 days. [3] Just after the said period, the father of the petitioner suffered a cerebrovascular accident on 23.06.2012 and ultimately, died on 29.06.2012. When the petitioner was under observance of the post-death rituals of his father, he noticed certain abnormal behaviours of the respondent. When they were preparing to go for cremation of the dead-body, in such a mournful moment, the respondent expressed that she was hungry and became anxious about her food on that night. The respondent before marriage stated that she was pursuing the MCA first year course, but it was detected by the petitioner that she had only completed BCA course and did not get any admission in MCA Course. [4] the It is also alleg…
20. 06.2020, the petitioner stopped communicating with her and his daughter. It is further alleged that on 10.10.2020, the respondent found said Smt. Ghosh sitting in the vehicle of the petitioner beside him at Post Office Chowmuhani area, and seeing the respondent, immediately the petitioner left the place with the car. He also threatened her that if she would ask anything about said Smt. Ghosh, she would face dire consequences, and he would also marry Smt. Ghosh after giving divorce the respondent. [11] The respondent further grieved that the petitioner was also not looking after their baby, rather her father was paying some amount for the maintenance of both the mother and daughter. She also alleged that from the month of June, 2020, she had been tolerating mental and physical torture upon her by the petitioner, her mother-in-law and other family members, and they were planning to shift at Kolkata by selling their house only to oust her from her matrimonial home. She further stated that after institution of the instant case, the petitioner had gone to Kolkata with said Mohuya Ghosh and stayed there about one month with her. Since the year 2022, the petitioner was staying at Kolkata trying to settle there without her and her daughter, and on his return to Agartala on 27.03.2023, till date he did not even see or talk with her and her daughter, though she is ever ready to live with…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAT APP. No.15 of 2025
Sri Arindam Chakraborty
son of late Haradhan Chakraborty, resident of
Santa Kutir, Krishnanagar, Near UBI Bank,
Ramnagar Branch, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West
Agartala, District-West Tripura
……… Appellant(s)
–Versus–
Smt. Sushmita Adhikari,
wife of Sri Arindam Chakraborty, daughter of
Sri Subhas Chandra Adhikari, resident of
Hospital
Extension
Road,
Gandhighat,
Agartala, West Tripura-799001
Presently residing at :
Santa Kutir, Krishnanagar, near UBI Bank,
Ramnagar Branch, P.O. Agartala, P.S. West
Agartala, District- West Tripura
…….. Respondent(s)
For the Appellant(s)
:
Mr. S. Das, Adv.
Mr. S. Saha, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Adv.
Mr. K. Nath, Adv.
Date of hearing
:
26.08.2025
Date of delivery of
Judgment & order
:
09.09.2025
Whether fit for reporting
:
YES
NO
√
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
JUDGMENT & ORDER
(S. Datta Purkayastha, J.)
The judgment dated 29.03.2025 passed by the learned
Addl. Judge, Family Court, Agartala, West Tripura in Title Suit
(Judicial Separation) No.02 of 2022 and the related decree
thereof, dismissing the petition of the appellant [hereinafter
referred as the petitioner] for judicial separation, are under
challenge in this appeal.
[2]
The
marriage
between
the
petitioner
and
the
respondent was solemnized on 25.04.2012. According to the
petitioner, after marriage, they led their happy conjugal life only
for 1 month 28 days.
[3]
Just after the said period, the father of the petitioner
suffered a cerebrovascular accident on 23.06.2012 and ultimately,
died on 29.06.2012. When the petitioner was under observance of
the post-death rituals of his father, he noticed certain abnormal
behaviours of the respondent. When they were preparing to go for
cremation of the dead-body, in such a mournful moment, the
respondent expressed that she was hungry and became anxious
about her food on that night. The respondent before marriage
stated that she was pursuing the MCA first year course, but it was
detected by the petitioner that she had only completed BCA
course and did not get any admission in MCA Course.
[4]
the
It is also alleged by the petitioner that even violating
family
practice,
during
the
period
of
such
post-death
observance, the respondent got the food cooked by their maid and
on this issue, she wildly quarrelled with her mother-in-law. On
that day, the petitioner requested his in-laws to take the
respondent back to their house temporarily for some days, as her
such behaviour was hurting their emotions. On the next date, his
father-in-law and mother-in-law both came to his house, but the
respondent also started quarrelling with her parents. It has been
also the allegation of the petitioner that during Shradha Ceremony
of his father, none from his in-laws' family attended the same
during day hours, rather they came only in the night.
[5]
It is also alleged by the petitioner that against his will,
all the gold ornaments of the respondent were kept in the locker
of her father. Even the respondent started pressurizing him to go
for a baby, being guided by her parents, though earlier they
decided to have the same only after 2½ years. In the year 2013,
the respondent after quarrelling with the petitioner on some trivial
issues, became unruly, and asked her parents to take her back to
home and on that occasion, her elder brother also slapped her to
control her. In the same year, the couple went to visit Puri on a
pleasant trip, but there also the respondent showed noncooperation and even went out from the hotel in the night at
about 10 pm without informing anything to the petitioner and
returned back only after he had informed the matter to her
parents over phone. Concerning that matter, the hotel manager
also rebuked them.
[6]
In the year 2014, the respondent gave birth of a
female child on 17th April and on release from the hospital, the
respondent attempted to go to her parents’ house straightway
from hospital at the instance of his in-laws, though ultimately, at
the request of the petitioner, she did not do so.
[7]
The petitioner in his petition also mentioned of many
such incidents of non-cooperation and quarrel by the respondent
with him to justify his claim of judicial separation. It is also
asserted by him that whenever his sister would come to his house
from Kolkata, she would be maltreated by the respondent. She
also did not provide proper food to his octogenarian aunt and did
not show any sympathy towards her during her illness. She also
would not follow the medical advices in respect of her minor
daughter. Once they went to Kolkata for treatment of their
daughter, and there also, the respondent exhibited her noncooperation and abnormal behaviour both on the way to Airport
and also inside the airport.
[8]
In the year 2020, the petitioner alleged, during Covid
period, his mother and his sister came from Kolkata and were in
isolation
in
the
home.
Therefore,
the
petitioner
told
the
respondent-wife to stay 14 days with her baby in her parents’
house. But after the said period of isolation was over, she did not
show any interest to join the petitioner again and returned to his
home some days later. In the month of September, 2021, when
the respondent tried to get physically intimate with him, he told
her to give him some space in life and to wait for some days, but
she strongly asserted her marital right without agreeing to said
request, and thereafter, she even threatened him by saying that if
he did not go for physical relationship with her, she would commit
suicide and leave a suicide note against him and his family
members. In the year 2021, his father-in-law also lodged a
baseless complaint to the club members of Dashamighat Club,
alleging an extramarital relation of the petitioner with his friend,
namely Mohuya Ghosh and that the petitioner was providing all his
earnings to said Smt. Ghosh on monthly basis and one of his
relatives, namely Pranab Bhowmik also threatened the husband of
said Smt. Ghosh asking Smti Ghosh to stop any sort of
communication with the petitioner.
[9]
It is also the grievance of the petitioner that before
marriage when he met the respondent, he found that she was
properly maintaining her personal hygiene but after marriage, he
noticed completely the converse. The respondent was alleged to
have passed her 10th Board Examination in three attempts. It is
also stated by the petitioner that both he and his wife are residing
under the same roof but in separate rooms from August, 2020. On
these grounds, the petitioner has sought for a decree of judicial
separation.
[10]
The
respondent
in
her
defence
stated
that
the
petitioner was maintaining extramarital relationship with said Smti
Mohuya Ghosh, who was his facebook friend, and she would
frequently visit the house of the petitioner, and even the petitioner
would talk with Smt. Ghosh in the late night also. From
20.06.2020, the petitioner stopped communicating with her and
his daughter. It is further alleged that on 10.10.2020, the
respondent found said Smt. Ghosh sitting in the vehicle of the
petitioner beside him at Post Office Chowmuhani area, and seeing
the respondent, immediately the petitioner left the place with the
car. He also threatened her that if she would ask anything about
said Smt. Ghosh, she would face dire consequences, and he would
also marry Smt. Ghosh after giving divorce the respondent.
[11]
The respondent further grieved that the petitioner was
also not looking after their baby, rather her father was paying
some amount for the maintenance of both the mother and
daughter. She also alleged that from the month of June, 2020, she
had been tolerating mental and physical torture upon her by the
petitioner, her mother-in-law and other family members, and they
were planning to shift at Kolkata by selling their house only to
oust her from her matrimonial home. She further stated that after
institution of the instant case, the petitioner had gone to Kolkata
with said Mohuya Ghosh and stayed there about one month with
her. Since the year 2022, the petitioner was staying at Kolkata
trying to settle there without her and her daughter, and on his
return to Agartala on 27.03.2023, till date he did not even see or
talk with her and her daughter, though she is ever ready to live
with him.
[12]
During hearing, the petitioner examined himself and his
mother to prove his case and the respondent examined total 4
witnesses including herself and proved 2[two] joint photographs
and one certified copy of the counselling report of Women
Commission to prove her case.
[13]
On consideration of the total evidence, the learned trial
court held that the petitioner was maintaining extramarital
relationship with his paramour, said Smt. Ghosh and therefore, he
himself had treated his wife with mental cruelty. On that ground,
the trial court rejected the petition for judicial separation. Learned
trial court also observed that the petitioner had neglected the
respondent in taking her care and in cohabiting with her due to his
illicit relationship with said Mohuya Ghosh.
[14]
We have heard Mr. S. Das, learned counsel appearing
for the appellant and Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel
appearing for the respondent.
[15]
Mr.
Das,
learned
counsel
argues
that
regarding
continuous cruelty done by the respondent upon the petitioner
since her marriage, sufficient evidence were led in this regard, but
learned court below failed to appreciate the same and without any
basis or evidence, most illegally, held that the petitioner was
maintaining an extramarital relationship with said Smti Mohuya
Ghosh. Mr. Das, Ld. Counsel argued that Ld. Trial court has
attached some undue and extra importance to some joint
photographs of the petitioner with said Smti Ghosh, which were
not even proved properly in the evidence. According to learned
counsel, the mother of the petitioner also supported the case of
the petitioner in her evidence to establish that the life of the
petitioner was completely devastated due to unruly and turbulent
behaviour of the respondent and the cruelty done upon him by
her.
[16]
Mr. P. Roy Barman, learned senior counsel appearing
for the respondent submits that the respondent is still living in the
house of the petitioner with a hope that the petitioner would once
realize his mistake and would join her but the petitioner is not
taking any care of her or her minor daughter, rather he is
indulging in extramarital relationship with another lady.
[17]
We have given due consideration to the submissions of
both sides. From the impugned judgment, it appears that the
learned trial court has taken note of the admission of both the
petitioner and his mother during their cross-examination that the
respondent is still willing to live with the petitioner. PW-2 also
admitted that from October, 2022 her son has been staying at
Kolkata and occasionally, he would visit his residence at Agartala.
The petitioner himself also admitted in his evidence that he did not
take the respondent and his daughter to Kolkata for a single
occasion since 2020. Thus, it appears that he is more interested to
live separately from the respondent. Interestingly, PW-2 i.e. the
mother of the petitioner in her evidence also stated that she could
not say anything about the issues and differences between the
petitioner and the respondent. The above said evidences of PW.2
show that she did not corroborate with the evidence of the
petitioner on the material points.
[18]
The petitioner has also not examined said Smti Mohuya
Ghosh or her husband to prove his allegation that the parents and
family members of the respondent had tried to humiliate said Smt.
Ghosh and her husband through the said club members and
threatened them.
[19]
The
allegations
of
the
petitioner
that
after
the
marriage, he came to know that the respondent had only obtained
the degree of BCA and was not pursuing MCA, does not amount to
cruelty to entitle him to get the decree. Even urging for physical
intimacy by the respondent as alleged also cannot be turned as
mental cruelty. Non-attending in the Shradha Ceremony of the
deceased father of the petitioner by the family members of the
respondent during day hours, does not project any case of cruelty,
rather, such allegation of the petitioner demonstrate his own
bigotry in accepting the situation.
[20]
According to the petitioner, just after 1 month and 28
days of their marriage, the respondent started behaving cruelly
with him and to support such contention, he has brought the
allegations of demand of food on the day of death of his father,
getting the food prepared by the maid during the period of postdeath observance, quarrelling with his mother ignoring her
emotion, and keeping all gold ornaments in the locker of her
father etc., which do not constitute cruelty to that extent to justify
the claim of the petitioner for granting a decree of judicial
separation. He also brought the story of cruel behaviour of the
respondent with him in the year 2013 by asking her parents as to
why she was given marriage with the petitioner and that she
would not stay with him, but said allegations get defeated due to
the expression of the respondent that she is still willing to live with
petitioner and even she has not left her matrimonial home till date
despite the petitioner abandoned her there, by shifting to Kolkata.
Even it is the admission of the respondent and her mother both in
their evidence that the respondent is still willing to live with the
petitioner. The alleged non-cooperation and unusual behaviour of
the respondent during their visit at Puri in the year 2013 and
non-adherence to the medical advice by the respondent for the
well being of her daughter and non-cooperation during Kolkata trip
etc. appear to have been already condoned by the petitioner due
to his continuing co-habitation with her. After so many years are
passed, he cannot grieve against the same.
[21]
In A. Jayachandra v. Aneel Kaur, (2005) 2 SCC 22,
the Apex Court observed that cruelty which is a ground for
dissolution of marriage may be defined as willful and unjustifiable
conduct of such character as to cause danger to life, limb or
health, bodily or mental, or as to give rise to a reasonable
apprehension of such a danger. The question of mental cruelty has
to be considered in the light of the norms of marital ties of the
particular society to which the parties belong, their social values,
status, environment in which they live. If from the conduct of the
spouse
same
is
established
and/or
an
inference
can
be
legitimately drawn that the treatment of the spouse is such that it
causes an apprehension in the mind of the other spouse, about his
or her mental welfare then this conduct amounts to cruelty. Said
decision was also referred in Mayadevi vs. Jagdish Prasad, AIR
2007 SC 1426.
[22]
Insignificant quibbling and minor trifling between the
couple in matrimonial life are natural. Undue magnifying of the
same does not ipso facto entitle a party to get the decree of
judicial separation or divorce. In the instant case, nothing could
be established by the petitioner that the behaviour of the
respondent was so persistent and regular in treating him with such
extent of cruelty so as to cause reasonable apprehension in his
mind that it would be harmful for him to live with her. Even, what
have been asserted by him, also could not be proved by him due
to lack of corroboration by his mother. Therefore, we do not find
any reason to interfere with the judgment passed by the learned
court below.
[23]
In the instant case, learned trial court resorting to
provision of Section 14 of the Family Courts Act and a decision of
Delhi High Court in case of Deepti Kapoor vs. Kunal Julka,
2020 SCC OnLine Del 672, has given over emphasis on few
photographs of the petitioner with said Smt. Ghosh which were
proved by the respondent in her evidence. The same were stated
to have captured by some unknown person and were transmitted
to the cell phone of the respondent via Whatsapp. According to the
learned trial court, the said joint photographs were of the
petitioner and said Smt. Ghosh in sitting, standing and roaming
position in the puja pandals. Based on said photographs, learned
trial court came to the conclusion that said Smt. Ghosh was the
paramour of the petitioner, and was maintaining extramarital
relationship with him. The learned trial court missed the aspect
that admissibility of evidence and reliability of same are quite
different. One piece of evidence duly proved may not be reliable
for several reasons. Nowhere, the learned court below observed
that the said photographs reflected unusual intimacy of both the
petitioner and said Smt. Ghosh but despite the same, such
decision
on
alleged
extramarital
relationship
was
rendered.
Learned trial court also missed to examine the authenticity of the
same despite the fact that those photographs in a very strange
manner came from an unknown source to the respondent. Said
Smti Ghosh was not a party to that proceeding and had no
opportunity to be heard before she was castigated as a paramour
of another person. She did not even have any scope to defend the
allegations brought against her or also to explain the photographs.
[24]
In view of the above, though we do not find any reason
to interfere with the judgment of the learned trial court but the
observations made by the learned trial court in several places of
the impugned judgment that said Smt. Ghosh was the paramour
of the petitioner and was maintaining extramarital relationship
with him, are expunged.
[25]
In terms of the above discussions, the appeal is
dismissed.
Pending application(s), if any, also stand disposed of.
Registry is to prepare decree accordingly.
Send a copy of this judgment to the learned trial court.
Furnish a copy of this judgment and decree to the
parties free of cost.
(S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA, J)
signed by SUJAY GHOSH
SUJAY GHOSH Digitally
Date: 2025.09.09 11:35:36 +05'30'
Sujay
(M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO, CJ)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review