Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
TH
DATED THIS THE 5
DAY OF JUNE, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE R DEVDAS
WRIT PETITION NO.39522 OF 2010 (SC-ST)
C/W
WRIT PETITION NO.50680 OF 2013(SC-ST)
IN W.P. NO.39522/2010
BETWEEN
SRI AMAVASAIAH
SINCE DEAD BY HIS LR
1 . SRI A THIMMAIAH
AGED 58 YEARS,
R/O GADIKOPPA,
SHIMOGA TALUK.
2 . SRI C KALLAPPA
SINCE DEAD BY LRs
a)
SMT. RATHNAMMA
W/O LATE L. CHANDRAPPA
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS
R/AT GADIKOPPA VILLAGE
SHIMOGA TALUK AND DISTRICT.
b)
SRI L. JAYARAM
S/O B.G. LAKSHMAN
AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS
R/AT GADIKOPPA VILLAGE
SHIMOGA TALUK
SHIMOGA DISTRICT.
c)
SRI RAJAIAH
S/O LATE HANUMAIAH
AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS
Digitally signed
by JUANITA
THEJESWINI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
R
-2-
R/AT GADIKOPPA VILLAGE
SHIMOGA TALUK
SHIMOGA DISTRICT.
3 . SMT NIRMALA
W/O MAHALINGA
AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS
R/AT MILLAGHATTA
SHIMOGA TOWN.
4 . SRI H.D. SRINIVASA GOWDA
S/O DUGGAPPAGOWDA
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS
R/AT MILLAGHATTA
SHIMOGA TOWN, SHIMOGA.
5 . SRI E.P. SANNI
SINCE DEAD BY HIS LRS.
a)
SMT. REENA SUNNY
W/O LATE E.P. SANNI
AGED ABOUT 59 YEARS
R/AT NO.750/5, VIJAYANAGAR
HINDALGA, BELGAUM
KARNATAKA – 591108.
b)
SMITHA D SOUZA
D/O LATE E.P. SANNI
AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS
R/AT NO.202, KARASWADA
ASMAS ARCADE
TIVM LE, NORTH GOA
GOA – 403526.
c)
SAUMYA SUNNY
D/O LATE E.P. SANNI
AGED ABOUT 37 YEARS
R/AT NO.549, VIJAYANAGAR
HINDALGA, BELGAUM
KARNATAKA – 591 108.
d)
SAMSON S. EZHAMALY
S/O LATE E.P. SANNI
AGED ABOUT 32 YEARS
-3-
R/AT SHAIKH BUILDING
2ND CROSS, VIJAYANAGAR
HINDALGA, BELGAUM
KARNATAKA – 59110.
6 . SRI HYDER SHARIFF
S/O ABDUL KHADER
AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS
R/O BHARATHI COLONY
SHIMOGA TOWN, SHIMOGA.
7 . SMT K.M. BHARATHI
W/O K.N. MANJAPPA
AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS
R/O KUMBARAKERI
SHIMOGA TOWN, SHIMOGA.
8 . SRI T.S. VENKATESH
S/O T.B. SIDDAPPA
AGED 50 YEARS
R/AT MILLAGHATTA
SHIMOGA TOWN, SHIMOGA.
9 . SRI SYED SIRAJUDDIN
S/O SYED YOUSUFF
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS
R/O MILLAGHATTA, SHIMOGA TOWN,
SHIMOGA.
...PETITIONERS
(BY SRI. K.N. NITISH., ADVOCATE FOR
SRI. K.V.NARASIMHAN., ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
HOSURAPPA
S/O NAGAPPA
SINCE DEAD BY LRs
A)
SMT. YELLAMMA
W/O LATE HOSURAPPA
AGED 60 YEAS.
B)
SRI H. NAGESHAPPA
S/O LATE HOSURAPPA
AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS.
-4-
C)
SMT. LAKSHMAMMA
D/O LATE HOSURAPPA
AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS.
D)
SMT. SAVITHRI
D/O LATE HOSURAPPA
AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS.
E)
SMT. SHEELA
D/O LATE HOSURAPPA
AGED ABOUT 30 YEARS.
ALL ARE R/O GOPALA
RANGANATH EXTENSION
SHIMOGA TOWN, SHIMOGA DISTRICT.
2.
THE ASSISTANT COMMISSONER
SHIMOGA SUB-DIVISION
SHIMOGA.
3.
THE DEPUTY COMMISSONER
SHIMOGA DISTRICT, SHIMOGA.
4.
THE COMMISSIONER
SHIMOGA URBAN DEVELOPMENT
AUTHORITY, SHIMOGA.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. SHAMANTH NAIK, HCGP., FOR R2 & R3
SRI S.V. PRAKASH, ADVOCATE, FOR R1A TO R1E
SRI A.V. GANGADHARAPPA, ADVOCATE FOR R4)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLE 226
OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE
ORDERS AT ANNEXURE J DATED 3.4.2007 PASSED BY THE
RESPONDENTS NO.2, AND ANNEXURE K, DATED 28.10.2010
PASSED BY THE RESPONDENT NO.3 AND GRANT AN
INTERIM ORDER TO STAY THE OPERATION OF THE ORDERS
AT ANNEXURES-J, DATED 3.4.2007 PASSED BY THE
RESPONDENTS NO2, AND ANNEXURE K, DATED 28.10.2010
PASSED BY THE RESPONDENT NO.3, IN CASE NO.
SC/ST/1/2007-08 AND SC/ST/4/2007-08 AND ETC.
-5-
IN W.P. NO. 50680/2013
BETWEEN
SHIMOGA URBAN DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
SHIMOGA, REP. BY ITS COMMISSIONER
COMMERCIAL COMPLEX, 100 FEET ROAD
VINOBA NAGAR, SHIMOGA – 577 204.
...PETITIONER
(SRI A.V. GANGADHARAPPA, ADVOCATE)
AND
1.
THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
SHIMOGA DISTRICT
SHIMOGA – 577 201.
2.
THE ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER
SHIMOGA SUB DIVISION
SHIMOGA - 577 201.
AMAVASAIAH S/O GUJJARAIAH
SINCE DEAD BY LEGAL REPRESENTATIVE
3.
SMT THIMMAMMA
W/O LATE AMAVASAIAH
AGED ABOUT 70 YEARS
R/O MILLAGHATTA
SHIMOGA TALUK AND
DISTRICT – 577 201.
(RESPONDENT NO.3 IS DELETED
VIDE ORDER DATED 26/08/2015)
4.
THIMMAIAH
S/O LATE AMAVASAIAH
AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS
C/O H RAJANNA
R/A NO.E-135, 2ND CROSS
GOPALAGOWDA LAYOUT
SHIMOGA – 577 201.
-6-
5.
SMT YELLAMMA
W/O LATE HOSURAPPA
AGED ABOUT 68 YEARS.
6.
H NAGESHAPPA
S/O LATE HOSURAPPA
AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS.
RESPONDENTS NO.5 AND 6
ARE RESIDING
BEHIND SHANIDEVARA TEMPLE
KORAMARA BEEDHI, GOPALA
SHIMOGA TOWN -577 201.
7.
SMT LAKSHMAMMA
D/O LATE HOSURAPPA
AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS.
8.
SMT SAVITHRI
D/O LATE HOSURAPPA
AGED ABOUT 44 YEARS.
9.
SMT SHEELA
D/O LATE HOSURAPPA
AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS.
RESPONDENTS NO.7 TO 9
ARE RESIDING
OPPOSITE TO PADMA TALKIES
KORAMARA KERI, GOPALA
SHIMOGA TOWN – 577 201.
10 .
KALLAPPA
S/O LATE GUJJARAIAH
SINCE DEAD BY LRs.
-7-
10(A) SMT. RATHNAMMA
W/O LATE L. CHANDRAPPA
AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS
RESIDING AT GADIKOPPA
VILLAGE, SHIMOGA TALUK
SHIMOGA DISTRICT.
10(B) L. JAYARAM
S/O B.G. LAKSHMAN
AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS
RESIDING AT GADIKOPPA VILLAGE
SHIMOGA TALUK
SHIMOGA DISTRICT.
10(C) SRI RAJAIAH
S/O LATE HANUMAIAH
AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS
RESIDING AT GADIKOPPA VILLAGE
SHIMOGA TALUK
SHIMOGA DISTRICT.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI SHAMANTH NAIK, HCGP FOR R1 & R2
R3 DELETED V/O/D.26.08.15
R4 SERVED - UNREPRESENTED
SRI S.V. PRAKASH, ADVOCATE FOR R5 TO R9
SRI. K.N. NITISH., ADVOCATE FOR
SRI. K.V.NARASIMHAN., ADVOCATE FOR R10(A) TO
R10(C))
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLE 226
OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO CALL FOR
THE RECORDS QUASH THE ORDER DT.3/4/2007 PASSED BY
THE R-2 VIDE ANNX-E AND THE ORDER DT.28.10.10
PASSED BY THE R-1 VIDE ANNX-F RESPECTIVELY IN SO FAR
AS THEY RELATE TO THE DIRECTION FOR PAYMENT OF
COMPENSATION IS CONCERNED AND ETC.
THESE WRIT PETITIONS HAVING BEEN HEARD AND
RESERVED ON 09.04.2026 AND COMING ON FOR
PRONOUNCEMENT OF ORDERS, THIS DAY, THIS COURT
MADE THE FOLLOWING:
-8-
CORAM: HON'BLE MR JUSTICE R DEVDAS
CAV COMMON ORDER
(PER: HON'BLE MR JUSTICE R DEVDAS)
These two writ petitions are filed in respect of the
impugned orders passed by the respondent-Assistant
Commissioner,
Shivamogga
Sub-Division
and
the
Deputy Commissioner, Shivamogga District. Therefore,
these two writ petitions were clubbed, heard together
and are being disposed of by this common order.
2. Brief facts which are germane for consideration
of these writ petitions are that 3 Acres 19 Guntas of
land in Sy.No.88 of Gadikoppa village, Shivamogga
Taluk and District were granted in favour of one
Sri.Nagappa in the year 1952. Saguvali Chit was issued
in favour of Sri.Nagappa on 09.01.1953.
Part of the
land measuring 1 Acre 29 ½ Guntas were sold by Smt.
Yallamma, wife of Sri.Nagappa in favour of the 1st
petitioner
-
Sri.Amavasaiah
on
27.09.1967.
The
remaining extent of 1 Acre and 29 ½ Guntas were sold
by Smt.Yallamma in favour of the 2nd petitioner –
-9-
Sri.Kallappa on 26.11.1967. It should be noticed here
that during the course of these proceedings, petitioners
No.1 and 2 died and their legal representatives have
been
brought
on
record.
Sri.Hosurappa,
the
son
Sri.Nagappa,
filed
a
of
petition
the
Respondent
No.1,
original
grantee
before
the
Assistant
Commissioner on 01.02.1989, invoking Sections 4 and 5
of the Karnataka Scheduled Castes and Scheduled
Tribes (Prohibition of Transfer of Certain Lands) Act,
1978 (for short, ‘the PTCL Act’).
The petition was
allowed on 28.03.1989, while directing resumption and
restoration of the lands in favour of the legal heirs of
the original grantee.
Aggrieved by the said order,
petitioners No.1 and 2 filed an appeal before the Deputy
Commissioner.
In the meanwhile,
part of the lands
were notified for acquisition at the hands of the 4th
respondent-Shivamogga Urban Development Authority
(which has also filed the connected writ petition in
W.P.No.50680/2013).
The
Deputy
Commissioner
allowed the appeals and set aside the orders passed by
- 10 -
the Assistant Commissioner.
the
contesting
Aggrieved by the order,
respondent
No.1
herein
filed
W.P.No.14550/1992. This Court held that the Assistant
Commissioner was required to
find out whether the
land was granted for upset price or a price lesser than
the upset price or whether it was a free grant.
The
Assistant Commissioner was required to state the rule
applicable, having regard to the date of the grant and
the nature of the grant.
This Court found that there
were contradictory opinions in this regard at the hands
of
the
Assistant
Commissioner
and
the
Deputy
Commissioner. Therefore, the writ petition was allowed
while quashing the orders passed by the Assistant
Commissioner as well as the Deputy Commissioner and
the
matter
was
remanded
back
to
the
Assistant
Commissioner for fresh consideration.
3.
On
remand, the
Assistant
Commissioner
recorded a finding that as per the grant records, the
lands
were
granted
in
favour
of
Sri.Nagappa
on
17.07.1952 in terms of order bearing No.DSA 4 DD
- 11 -
48/1951-52
and
09.01.1953.
It was found that the land was granted
freely
therefore,
and
Saguvali
the
applicable was 15 years.
Chit
was
issued
non-alienation
on
clause
However, the Assistant
Commissioner was of the opinion that commencing from
17.07.1952, the date on which the grant was made, 15
years
would
elapse
on
16.07.1967
and
the
sale
transactions happened on 27.09.1967 and 26.11.1967
and therefore, the provisions of the PTCL were not
attracted in the present case. Accordingly, the petition
filed by respondent No.1 was dismissed.
In appeal, the
Deputy Commissioner upheld the orders of the Assistant
Commissioner.
Respondent No.1 filed writ petition
No.22094/1998 and this Court found that the relevant
rule applicable as on the date of the grant viz.,
17.07.1952 was sub-rule(8) of Rule 43 of the Mysore
Land Revenue Rules, framed under Section 233 of the
Mysore Land Revenue Code and according to the said
Rule, the period of non-alienation was forever and
therefore, on facts, it was found that the findings of the
- 12 -
authorities were incorrect.
Further, it was also found
that only 1 Acre 06 Guntas were notified and acquired
and
compensation
Smt.Thimmamma
R.Amavasaiah.
of
wife
Rs.69,000/of
the
was
1st
paid
to
petitioner,
This Court therefore held that 2 Acres
13 Guntas remained at the hands of the petitioners No.1
and 2 and in that regard, the matter was to be
reconsidered by the Assistant Commissioner.
This
Court held that since 1 Acre 06 Guntas were notified
and acquired, the said lands are no more agricultural
lands and therefore, the claim of respondent No.1
herein to that extent cannot be sustained.
4.
Aggrieved
by
such
an
observation,
respondent No.1 herein filed W.A.No.4982/1998 and the
Hon’ble Division Bench, by order dated 24.07.1999
accepted the contention of respondent No.1 herein and
held that the land was notified and acquired during the
pendency of the proceedings before the Assistant
Commissioner, in the year 1992 and therefore, it cannot
be held that the provisions of the PTCL Act are not
- 13 -
attracted in respect of the acquired lands.
For that
reason, the observations made by the learned Single
Judge was set aside while directing the Assistant
Commissioner to reconsider the matter in respect of the
entire extent of 3 Acres and 19 Guntas.
5.
Pursuant
to
the
remand,
the
Assistant
Commissioner found on verification of the grant records,
that the lands were granted in favour of Sri.Nagappa on
17.07.1952 and Saguvali Chit was issued on 09.01.1953
and that it was a free grant. Therefore, in terms of the
prevailing rules, the lands which were granted in favour
of Sri.Nagappa, a person belonging to the depressed
classes, could not be alienated forever.
It was also
found that the original grantee belonged to Korama
community, which was listed in the Scheduled Castes
List.
The Assistant Commissioner also held that the
Shivamogga Urban Development Authority (for short,
SUDA)
was required to deposit
the compensation
amount before the civil court, after having come to
know that a petition was filed by respondent No.1
- 14 -
before
the
Assistant
Commissioner,
provisions of the PTCL Act.
invoking
the
At any rate, it was found
that respondent No.1 and the other legal heirs of the
original grantee were entitled to receive compensation
at the hands of SUDA in respect of 1 Acre 06 Guntas of
land.
Nevertheless,
the
Assistant
Commissioner
directed resumption and restoration of the entire extent
of 3 Acres 19 Guntas of lands in
favour of the legal
heirs of the original grantee. The petitioners No.1 and 2
herein,
aggrieved
by
the
order
of
the
Assistant
Commissioner preferred an appeal before the Deputy
Commissioner. The Deputy Commissioner dismissed the
appeals filed by petitioners No.1 and 2.
It should be
noticed here that though SUDA, being a party before
the
Assistant
Commissioner
and
suffering
adverse
orders at the hands of the Assistant Commissioner, it
did
not
prefer
an
appeal
Learned
Counsel
before
the
Deputy
Commissioner.
6.
Sri K.V.Narasimhan, appearing for
Sri.K.N.Nitish,
for
petitioners No.1 to
- 15 -
9 submitted, while pointing out to orders passed in
W.P.No.14550/1992
remanding
the
dated
matter
25.08.1995,
back
to
the
that
while
Assistant
Commissioner, this Court had directed the Assistant
Commissioner to verify from the records as to whether
the original grantee belonged to Scheduled Caste
community; whether the grant was for an upset price,
less than upset price or a free grant and what was the
rule applicable having regard to the said facts. But, the
Assistant Commissioner has not looked into the original
grant orders. It is contended that the findings given by
the Assistant Commissioner cannot be accepted on the
face of it. It is further contended that in terms of the
acquisition notification dated 05.11.1992, as found at
Annexure-A in Writ petition No.50680/2013, the total
extent of land held by petitioners No.1 and 2 in
Sy.No.88 was 3 Acres and 19 Guntas, out of which 05
Guntas were kharab and the remaining extent was 3
Acres and 14 Guntas, and what was notified for
acquisition is 3 Acres and 04 Guntas. In terms of the
- 16 -
request made by the petitioners, SUDA passed a
resolution on 25.04.1994 accepting to delete 50% of
the acquired land from acquisition and accordingly, the
writ petition filed at the hands of petitioner No.1 –
Sri.Amavasaiah in W.P.No.2158/1993 was disposed of in
terms of the memo filed by the petitioner. Thereafter,
award was passed only in respect of 1 Acre and 06
Guntas at the rate of Rs.69,000/- and the remaining
land was given up by SUDA in favour of the petitioners.
It is therefore contended that the petitioners acquired
independent title in respect of the remaining extent of
land and the provisions of the PTCL Act cannot be
applied to the lands retained by the petitioners, in
accordance with law.
In this regard, learned Counsel
places reliance on M.Narasimha Murthy and Others
Vs. The Deputy Commissioner, Bangalore District
and Others reported in ILR 2015 Kar 954.
7.
Learned
Counsel
further
submitted
that
although the PTCL Act came into force on 01.01.1979,
the petition before the Assistant Commissioner was filed
- 17 -
on 01.02.1989, after delay of 10 years and therefore,
the Assistant Commissioner should have dismissed the
petition on the ground of delay and laches alone.
Learned Counsel sought to place reliance on a decision
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Ningappa
Vs. Deputy Commissioner & Ors. (2020) 14 SCC
236 and the subsequent judgments of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court
in the case of Nekkanti Rama
Lakshmi Vs. State of Karnataka and Others (2020)
14 SCC 232.
8.
Learned
Counsel
Sri.A.V.Gangadharappa,
appearing for SUDA, submitted there is no bar in law to
acquire lands granted to persons belonging to SC/ST
community. It is submitted that the lands were notified
for acquisition on 05.11.1992
and the acquisition
notification was issued in the name of Sri.Amavasaiah
and Sri.Kallappa, whose names were reflected in the
RTCs.
Challenge was raised by Sri.Amavasaiah before
this Court in Writ Petition No.2158/1993.
Since SUDA
was not able to proceed on account of the writ petition
- 18 -
filed before this Court, the authority accepted the
proposal given by the land owners and passed a
resolution on 25.04.1994 to delete 50% of the acquired
lands from acquisition.
was disposed of.
Accordingly, the writ petition
Thereafter, 06 Guntas of the land
were required for formation of a road in the layout.
Therefore, the said 06 Guntas were requisitioned from
the owners and they agreed to give up 06 Guntas on
condition of allotment of a site in lieu of compensation.
Accordingly, the 06 Guntas were utilized by SUDA, after
allotment of an alternative site in favour of the land
owners.
SUDA
has
already
paid
compensation
of
Rs.69,000/- for acquisition of 1 Acre 06 Guntas and
therefore, no further claim can be made against SUDA.
9. Per contra, learned Counsel for the contesting
respondent No.1 submitted that the Hon’ble Division
Bench has already held in W.A.No.4982/1998 dated
24.07.1999, that the provisions of the PTCL Act would
be applicable even in respect of the notified lands, since
the notification was issued during the pendency of the
- 19 -
proceedings before the Assistant Commissioner.
The
Hon’ble Division Bench set aside the findings of the
learned Single Judge, who had held in Writ Petition
No.22094/1998 that 1 Acre and 06 Guntas which were
notified and acquired for the benefit of SUDA was no
more agricultural land and therefore, the provisions of
the PTCL Act would not attracted. The decision of the
Hon’ble Division Bench is binding on the parties and on
this Court.
Neither the petitioners nor SUDA raised a
challenge to the orders passed by the Hon’ble Division
Bench. In that view of the matter, it is submitted that
all such contentions raised by the learned Counsels for
the petitioners and SUDA cannot be considered, having
regard to the decision of the Hon’ble Division Bench, in
the earlier round of litigation. Learned Counsel would
further submit that the writ petition filed by SUDA in
Writ Petition No.50680/2013 is required to be dismissed
on the ground that SUDA did not file an appeal before
the
Deputy
Commissioner,
challenging
the
orders
passed by the Assistant Commissioner. SUDA cannot be
- 20 -
permitted to file a writ petition challenging the orders
passed by the Assistant Commissioner and the Deputy
Commissioner.
10.
Heard
learned
for
Sri
K.V.Narasimhan,
in
W.P.No.39522/2010,
Gangadharappa,
for
Counsel
appearing
learned
the
Sri.K.N.Nitish,
for
petitioners
Counsel
Sri.A.V.
petitioner-SUDA
in
W.P.No.50680/2013, learned Counsel Sri.S.V.Prakash
for the contesting respondent No.1, learned High Court
Government Pleader Sri.Shamanth S.Naik, and perused
the petition papers.
11.
Having regard to the chronology of events, it
is clear that the petition under Sections 4 and 5 of the
PTCL Act was filed by respondent No.1-Sri.Hosurappa
on 01.02.1989 and orders were passed by the Assistant
Commissioner on 28.03.1989, directing resumption and
restoration of the lands. Matter was remanded back to
the Assistant Commissioner in terms of the orders
passed
by
this
W.P.No.14550/1992.
Court
on
25.08.1995
in
Subsequently, the matter was
- 21 -
once
again
Commissioner
remanded
by
back
order
W.P.No.22094/1998.
to
dated
the
Assistant
17.08.1998,
in
Further, orders were passed by
the Hon’ble Division Bench in W.A.No.4982/1998 on
24.07.1999,
clarifying
W.P.No.22094/1998.
the
orders
passed
in
At no point of time, did the
petitioners raise the question of delay and laches.
When the matters are remanded by this Court with
specific directions, the authority is required to consider
the matters in terms of the directions issued by this
Court.
The petitioners cannot be permitted to urge the
question of delay and laches before this Court at this
length of time.
Accordingly, the submissions made by
the learned Counsels for the petitioners, regarding the
delay and laches, is hereby rejected.
12. The learned Counsel for the petitioners also
contended that the Assistant Commissioner did not
comply
with
the
directions
issued
by
this
Court,
inasmuch as, he did not verify from the original Grant
records as to whether the grant was for an upset price;
- 22 -
lesser than upset price or a free grant. These directions
which
were
issued
earlier
by
this
Court
in
W.P.No.14550/1992 is in consonance with the judgment
of the Division Bench in the case of Pedda Reddy Vs.
State of Karnataka ILR 1993 KAR 551. However, the
Hon'ble Supreme Court, in the case of Guntaiah and
Others Vs. Hambamma and Others (2005) 6 SCC
228 has watered down the said judgment and overruled
the judgment of the Full Bench of this Court in the case
of Smt.Hambamma Vs. The State of Karnataka &
Ors. ILR 1999 KAR 261. The Hon'ble Supreme Court
held at paragraph Nos.12, 13 and 14 as follows:
“12. When the Rule itself says that where
the grant is made free of cost or at a price
which is less than the full market value, such
grant shall be subject to the condition that the
land shall not be alienated for a period of 15
years from the date of the grantee taking
possession of the land after the grant, such
conditions could be imposed on any grant
made to the party.
- 23 -
13. In any case, the High Court failed to
take into account the clear language employed
in Section 4, according to which any transfer of
granted land made either before or after the
commencement of this Act ‘in contravention of
the terms of the grant of such land’ shall be
null
and
void
(emphasis
supplied).
The
violation of the terms of grant itself gives rise
to the action under Section 4 read with Section
5.
So long as the terms of the grant
prohibiting transfer are not opposed to any
specific provision of law, they cannot be
violated and the transferee gets no rights by
virtue of such invalid transfer. That is the sum
and substance of Section 4 which has not been
duly considered by the High Court.
14. It is also pertinent to note that the
prohibition regarding alienation is a restrictive
covenant binding on the grantee. The grantee
is not challenging that condition. In all these
proceedings, challenge is made by the third
party
who
purchased
the
land
from
the
grantee. The third party is not entitled to say
that the conditions imposed by the grantor to
the grantee were void. As far as the contract
of sale is concerned, it was entered into
between the Government and the grantee and
- 24 -
at that time the third-party purchaser had no
interest in such transaction.
Of course, he
would be entitled to challenge the violation of
any statutory provisions but if the grant by
itself specifically says that there shall not be
any alienation by the grantee for a period of
15 years, that is binding on the grantee so
long as he does not challenge that clause,
more so when he purchased the land, in spite
of being aware of the condition.
The Full
Bench seriously erred in holding that the land
was
granted
under
Rule
43-J
and
that
Authorities were not empowered to impose any
conditions
regarding
alienation
without
adverting to Section 4 of Act 2 of 1979. These
lands were given to landless persons almost
free of cost and it was done as a social welfare
measure to improve the conditions of poor
landless persons. When these lands were
purchased by third parties taking advantage of
illiteracy and poverty of the grantees, Act 2 of
1979 was passed with a view to retrieve these
lands from the third-party purchasers.
When
Act 2 of 1979 was challenged, this Court
observed
in
Manchegowda
v.
State
Karnataka2 (SCC pp.310-11, para17).
of
- 25 -
“17. xxxx xxx xxxx” …”
(Emphasis supplied)
13. Therefore, it is clear that the petitioners
cannot raise such a contention that the Assistant
Commissioner was required to find out whether the
grant was for an upset price, lesser than upset price or
a free grant. On the other hand both the authorities
have found after remand that lands were granted in
favour of Sri Nagappa on 17.07.1952 in terms of order
bearing No.DSA 4 DD 48/1951-52 and saguvali chit was
issued on 09.01.1953. The finding of this Court in
W.P.No.22094/1998 that sub-rule (8) of Rule 43 of the
Mysore Land Revenue Rules, would apply to a grant
made in the year 1952-53 and according to the said
Rule, the granted land cannot be alienated forever and
it is the said Rule that prevails. The grantee could not
have sold the property to any person. The petitioners
have not challenged the said finding and the same has
attained finality.
- 26 -
14. The contention of the petitioners is that
pursuant to the acquisition notification, 3 Acres and 09
Guntas, out of 3 Acres and 14 Guntas were notified and
the lands stood vested with the State Government.
Pursuant to a resolution passed by SUDA, 50% of the
notified
lands
were
deleted
from
acquisition
and
therefore, an independent title came to be vested with
the petitioners. The provisions of the PTCL Act cannot
therefore be invoked in respect of the said properties.
This submission also cannot be accepted for the reason
that the Hon’ble Division Bench in W.A.No.4982/1998
dated 24.07.1999 held that the lands were acquired
during the pendency of the proceedings before the
Assistant Commissioner. It was therefore held that the
nature of the land has to be considered as on the date
of the grant or on the date of filing the petition before
the Assistant Commissioner. In that view of the matter,
the observations of the learned Single Judge to that
extent was set aside and directions were issued to the
Assistant
Commissioner to
reconsider the
case
in
- 27 -
respect of the entire extent of lands, including the lands
acquired by SUDA. This finding of fact and the decision
of the Hon’ble Division Bench has attained finality.
Neither the petitioners nor SUDA questioned the orders
passed by the Hon’ble Division Bench. The findings and
the decision of the Hon’ble Division Bench are binding
on the parties, the respondent authorities and on this
Court. The said issue cannot be re-opened.
15. Even otherwise, this Court is of the considered
opinion that it would be futile on the part of the
petitioners to argue that they acquired independent title
from SUDA or the State Government pursuant to the
deletion of 50% of the notified lands, in favour of the
petitioners. The argument of acquisition of a fresh title
may hold good insofar as the alternate site allotted in
favour of the petitioners, pursuant to the utilization of
06 guntas of land. For the same reason, this Court is
also of the considered opinion that having regard to the
eminent domain power of the State Government in
acquiring lands of private individuals in accordance with
- 28 -
the statutes governing land acquisition, any allotment
made by the statutory body such as SUDA cannot be
disturbed, even if the provisions of the PTCL Act are
applicable and have an overriding power on other
statutes.
16. To that extent, although the writ petition filed
by SUDA, without challenging the orders passed by the
Assistant
Commissioner
before
the
Deputy
Commissioner/appellate authority can be dismissed on
that
ground
alone,
nevertheless,
taking
into
consideration the allotments of sites made by SUDA in
favour of the various persons in terms of the provisions
of the rules of allotment, the impugned orders passed
by
the
Assistant
Commissioner
and
Deputy
Commissioner are required to be read down, insofar as
the lands acquired by SUDA. However, the legal heirs
of the original grantee, including respondent No.1
herein are entitled for payment of compensation at the
hands of SUDA.
- 29 -
17. It is required to be noticed that SUDA was a
party
to
the
proceedings
in
W.P.No.22094/1998.
Though SUDA suffered adverse orders at the hands of
this Court commencing from 1998, it has taken no steps
to
protect
itself
in
the
matter
of
payment
of
compensation. SUDA should have issued notice to the
petitioners
herein
compensation.
in
the
matter
of
payment
of
SUDA, in its writ petition has clearly
stated that the Deputy Commissioner passed an order
directing SUDA not to disburse the compensation in
respect of the lands in question till 05.06.1997.
It is
stated in the petition that compensation was paid to
Smt.Thimmamma on 23.12.1995. Nevertheless, SUDA
could have issued notice to Smt.Thimmamma or her
legal heirs to re-deposit the compensation amount,
having regard to the directions issued by the Deputy
Commissioner.
Further, a vacant site was allotted in
favour of Smt.Thimmamma on 20.05.1999, much after
the orders were passed by the Deputy Commissioner.
- 30 -
This shows that SUDA has ignored the claim raised by
respondent No.1, at its own peril.
18. Insofar as the claim of the petitioners that the
same principles as are applicable to the allottees at the
hands of SUDA should be applied to the purchasers of
the sites at the hands of the petitioners, in the layout
formed by them in the property in question, this Court
is of the considered opinion that the petitioners have
failed
to
place
any
material
either
before
the
respondent-authorities or before this Court to show that
the layout was formed in accordance with law.
information
is
placed
before
this
Court
No
regarding
conversion of the lands, sanction and permissions
obtained at the hands of the competent authority to
form the layout. Therefore, the benefit given to the
allottees at the hands of SUDA, cannot be given to the
other petitioners who claim to be purchasers of sites at
the hands of petitioners No.1 and 2.
19. For the reasons stated above, this Court
proceeds to pass the following:
- 31 -
ORDER
i)
W.P.No.39522/2010 stands dismissed.
ii)
W.P.No.50680/2013
is
partly
allowed
while modifying the orders passed by the
respondent-Assistant
Commissioner,
Shivamogga Sub-Division at Annexure ‘E’
dated 03.04.2007.
iii)
1 Acre and 06 guntas of lands in Sy.No.88
of Gadikoppa Village, Shivamogga Taluk
and District, which was acquired by SUDA
for formation of a residential layout shall
not be resumed or restored to the legal
heirs of the original grantee. However,
SUDA
is
hereby
directed
to
pay
compensation of Rs.69,000/- along with
simple interest calculated at the rate of 6%
per annum commencing from the date of
the award i.e., 21.12.1995 till the date of
payment, to the legal heirs of the original
grantee Sri Nagappa.
The payment shall
be made as expeditiously as possible and
at any rate within a period of six months
from the date of receipt of a certified copy
of this order.
- 32 -
Pending I.As., if any stand disposed of.
Sd/(R DEVDAS)
JUDGE
DL/JT
CT:JL
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review