Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
RFA. No.41 of 2019
1.
Sri Amal Sarkar, S/O. Late Lal Mohan Sarkar, Resident of Gandhigram
P.S. Airport, Dist. West Tripura, Pin 799012
2.
Sri Mihir Lal Sarkar @ Paritosh Sarkar, S/O. Late Lal Mohan Sarkar
Resident of Gandhigram, P.S. Airport, Dist. West Tripura, Pin 799012
3.
Sri Bimal Sarkar @ Bimal Kr. Sarkar, S/O. Late Lal Mohan Sarkar,
Resident of Gandhigram, P.S. Airport, Dist. West Tripura, Pin 799012
4.
Sri Shymal Sarkar, S/O. Late Lal Mohan Sarkar, Resident of Gandhigram
P.S. Airport, Dist. West Tripura, Pin 799012
…..Appellants Defendants No. (1 to 4).
_V_E_R_S_U_S_
1.
Smti. Shila Sarkar (Deb) @ Shila Sarkar, @Shila Deb (Sarkar), W/O. Sri Ashis
Kr. Deb, D/O. Late Lal Mohan Sarkar, Resident of Deochhara, P.S. Panisagar,
Sub-Division - Panisagar, Dist. North Tripura, Pin 799260.
2.
Smti. Lila Deb (Sarkar) @ Lila Sarkar (Deb), wife of Sri Chinmoy Deb,
daughter of late Lal Mohan Sarkar, resident of Teliamura, P.S. Teliamura,
District: Khowai Tripura, Pin-799205.
3.
Smti. Manju Sarkar (Datta), W/O Sri Madan Datta, D/O late Lal Mohan Sarkar,
resident of Badharghat, P.S. A.D. Nagar, District- West Tripura, Pin-799003
…..Respondent-plaintiffs
4.
Sri Ajit Kumar Sarkar, son of late Lal Mohan Sarkar, resident of Gandhigram,
P.S. Airport, District- West Tripura.
5.
Sri Dilip Sarkar, son of late Lal Mohan Sarkar, resident of Gandhigram, P.S.
Airport, District- West Tripura.
***as per the Hon’ble Court’s order dated 03.09.2020 passed in I.A. 2 of 2020 the name
of respondent No.6 is incorporated as
6.
Arati Sarkar (Talukdar), wife of Sri Kumar Ranjan Talukdar, daughter of late
Lal Mohan Sarkar, resident of near the hosue of Ex MLA Sri Ratan Das, P.S.
West Agartala, District-West Tripura, Pin-799001.
***as per the Hon’ble Court’s order dated 12.03.2021 passed in I.A. No.03 of 2021
(petition for direction), the name of respondent No.7 has been deleted from the array of
parties.
….Respondent-defendant No.5-7
For Appellant(s)
:
For the respondent(s)
:
Date of hearing
:
Date of judgment and order:
Whether fir for reporting
:
Mr. S. M. Chakraborty, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. K. K. Pal, Advocate.
Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. R. Datta, Advocate.
Mr. S. Saha, Advocate.
Ms. A. Chakraborty, Advocate.
22.01.2025
05.02.2025
YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
_F_I_N_A_L_O_ R_ D_ E_ R_
[T. Amarnath Goud, J]
Heard Mr. S. M. Chakraborty, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. K.
K. Pal, learned counsel appearing for the appellants. Also heard Mr. D.
Bhattacharjee, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. S. Saha, learned counsel
and Mr. R. Datta, learned counsel appearing for the respondents.
[2]
This is an appeal filed under Section-96 of the Civil Procedure
Code, 1908 against the judgment dated 30.07.2019 in T.S.(P) 42 of 2015 passed
by the learned Civil Judge, Senior Division, Court No.1, Agartala, West Tripura.
[3]
Yesterday when the case is called both sides present and the matter
was listed for hearing today. The facts of the case are Sri Lal Mohan Sarkar
passed away and on the strength of a WILL the children of the first wife filed a
suit. During the pendency of the suit, partition has taken place and accordingly,
the properties have been partitioned. Aggrieved by the partition, the defendants
in the suit i.e. the children of the first wife preferred an appeal. So, for the sake of
brevity the plaintiffs are referred as the party No.1A and the defendants of the
first wife are referred as party No. 1B. The children of the second wife, who are
the defendants, are referred to as the party No.2.
[4]
During the course of argument i.e. yesterday party Nos. 1A & 1B
i.e. the children of late Lal Mohan Sarkar reported before this Court that they
have settled the matter and they are withdrawing the main plaint itself since they
are satisfied with the settlement made outside the Court or in terms of the
partitioned-decree and they are not interested to pursue the present appeal and
also submitted and prayed to dismiss the appeal or permit to withdraw the same
and also to dismiss the main suit itself.
[5]
At this juncture, upon instructions learned senior counsel appearing
for the party No.2, the children of second wife made an objection before this
Court and contended that the respondents herein are not in favour of the
withdrawal of the appeal or the plaint and they are not accepting the present
partition made and express their willingness to contest the matter.
[6]
The succinct pleadings of the appellants-defendants are the
respondent Nos.1 to 3 initially filed the suit for preliminary decree for the
partition of the suit property, declaration of right title and interest with
consequential relief as well as for perpetual injunction under Sections-34, 38 and
39 of Specific Relief Act and under Section-2 of Partition Act against the full
blooded brothers i.e. the appellant Nos. 1 to 4 and step brothers and sister i.e.
respondent Nos.5 to 7 also against the mother i.e. respondent No.8.
[7]
Subsequently, by filing amendment petition sought cancellation of
WILL bearing No.-III-22, dated 15.03.1986 and registered sale deed vide No.I762, dated 11.02.1998. Initially, the learned Court after framing issue as well as
after closure of evidence and argument of date was fixed for judgment but the
learned Court passed an order on 26.11.2018 the plaintiffs along with other cosharers i.e. defendant Nos.2 to 8 executed a registered power of attorney vide No.
IV-97, Book No.IV, Volume No.1 and constituted defendant No.1 namely Amal
Sarkar as lawful attorney for management, sale transfer, partition etc. of the suit
land. The said power of attorney was a general power of attorney.
[8]
On the strength of the said power of attorney, defendant No.1 sold
part of the suit land, but as alleged, did not give the plaintiffs share of the sale
proceeds. On 15.03.2013 plaintiff No.1 again executed another register power of
attorney vide No. IV-141, Book No.IV, Volume No.2 and constituted defendant
No.1 namely Amal Sarkar as lawful attorney for management, sale, transfer,
partition etc of the suit land on behalf of said plaintiff No.1 namely, Shila Sarkar.
[9]
The plaintiff asserted that the WILL bearing No.-III-22 dated
15.03.1986 alleged to have been executed by Lal Mohan Sarkar was illegal and
not valid in the eye of law. They stated that at the time of execution of the
alleged WILL, Lal Mohan Sarkar was joint owner of land measuring 6.05 acres
along with his brother Anil Ch. Sarkar, but the said WILL was executed in
respect of the entire suit land. Due to that reason the WILL in question is illegal
and invalid. They further stated that after the death of Anil Ch. Sarkar, defendant
Nos. 1 to 4 purchased the share of Anil Ch. Sarkar from his legal heirs by
registered sale deed No.1-762.
[10]
The plaintiffs claim that their assertion that the WILL being invalid
which gets support from the fact that all the defendants and plaintiff Nos.2 and 3
executed power of attorney in respect of the suit land after the death of their
father late Lal Mohan Sarkar. As the constituted attorney did not hand over
respective shares against the consideration money to the plaintiffs, all of them
demanded partition of the suit land on 10.04.2015. But, defendant Nos. 1 to 6 did
not agree due to which they requested the defendant No.1 to return the original
power of attorney with a further request not to sake or transfer any part of the suit
land. But, the defendant No.1 did not handover the power of attorney and tried to
sell the suit land further. Thus, the plaintiff filed the suit for a decree of partition
over the suit land to declare their equal share and also for cancellation of WILL.
[11]
The defendant Nos.1 to 4 i.e. the present appellants by filing their
written statement raised the question of maintainability of the suit for nonjoinder
and misjoinder of parties and by the principles of estoppels, waiver etc. They
stated that during the life time of Lal Mohan Sarkar and Anil Chandra Sarkar
they got partition of their share, subsequently, the legal heirs of Anil Chandra
Sarkar sold their property of Lal Mohan Sarkar was transferred to the step
brothers and sisters of plaintiff and defendant Nos.1 to 4. Moreover, the plaintiff
and defendants also sold some property inherited from Lal Mohan Sarkar. The
execution of WILL by the Lal Mohan Sarkar was all along to the knowledge of
plaintiffs.
[12]
Having heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties and
gone through the material evidences on record, the learned Court below has
observed as under:
“In the result, the suit of the plaintiffs is decreed partly holding that they are
entitled for a decree declaring the WILL b/No.III-22 dated 15.03.1986 to be
void and liable to be cancelled. But at the same time, they are found to be
not entitled for a decree declaring the sale deed b/No.I-762 dated 11.02.1998
to be void. The plaintiffs are also found to be not entitled for a decree of
partition and perpetual injunction.
The plaintiffs are asked to submit the deficit Court-Fees within 14 days from
the date of this judgment.
The suit is disposed of on contest.”
[13]
The learned trial Court passed the decree declaring that the
plaintiffs are not entitled for a decree of partition and perpetual injunction but
most illegally declared the WILL No.III-22 dated 15.03.1986, which is liable to
be cancelled. Being aggrieved by the findings and judgment on the issue decided
about the WILL, the appellants herein have preferred the present appeal before
this Court for proper adjudication.
[14]
Mr. S. M. Chakraborty, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. K.
K. Pal, learned counsel appearing for the appellant-defendants has submitted that
the learned Court below committed serious error of law and fact at the time of
passing the impugned judgment. The learned Court below most illegally and
casually without considering the legality and evidence led by the defendants
Nos.1-4 declared the WILL No. III-22 dated 15.03.1986 to be void and liable to
be cancelled.
[15]
The wife of Lal Mohan Sarkar namely, Smti. Bela Rani Sarkar,
defendant No. 8 adduced her evidence supporting the stand taken by defendant
No. 1 to 4. When she categorically stated that, the legal heirs of Anil Chandra
Sarkar sold their share. She has duly identified the signature of her husband Lal
Mohan Sarkar in all eleven pages of WILL (Exbt. D). She has stated that the
property left by Lal Mohan Sarkar have been disposed by way of WILL. The
learned Court below miserably failed to appreciate the evidence of one attesting
witness of WILL namely Sri Nani Gopal Deb deposed on behalf of defendant
No. 1 to 4 as D.W.-5. And in his examination in-chief he stated that at the time of
execution of WILL, he was personally present and put his signature in the said
WILL as witnesses.
[16]
It has been contended that the learned Court below failed to
consider that the WILL was executed on 15.03.1986. The plaintiffs had their
knowledge since the death of their father. On the basis of WILL the plaintiff and
defendants divided their property among the step brothers and sisters. The
plaintiff initially filed the suit for partition and subsequently in the said partition
suit they challenged the validity of WILL but requisite Court fee was not paid for
such additional relief rendering the same liable to be dismissed. The learned
Court below ought to have considered the evidence of mother of plaintiffs and
defendants, who deposed in support of the case of defendant Nos. 1 to 4.
[17]
The learned Court below has passed the judgment simply basing on
the evidence of the plaintiff respondents and without discussion, consideration
and appreciation of the evidence of the defendant-appellant Nos.1-4. In their
written statement filed on 07.08.2015 the defendant-appellants raised the issue of
maintainability of the suit for non-joinder of parties and to be hit by the
principles of estoppels, waiver etc. They altogether denied what the plaintiffs
have stated in their plaint. They stated that during the lifetime of Lal Mohan
Sarkar and his brother Anil Ch. Sarkar they sold their joint property which is
described in the schedule of the plaint. The defendants claimed that unreasonably
the plaintiffs incorporated that joint property in this present suit.
[18]
The vital twist in the tale came when the defendants brought into
record that during his lifetime, their father has executed a WILL No. III-22 dated
15.03.1986 bequeathing his property in favour of his sons and specifically
mentioned that the plaintiffs are not entitled for any properties left by their father.
The defendants raised the issue of limitation stating that the plaintiffs should
have come within three years seeking cancellation of the said WILL. They stated
that the property left by their father has been peacefully possessed by them
constructing houses and cultivating crops.
[19]
In regard to the joint property of their father and uncle, they stated
that the said property has been amicably partitioned and the legal heirs of Anil
Ch. Sarkar have abandoned their shares. They further stated that the plaintiffs
and they themselves sold out the said property and the consideration money got
equally distributed amongst parties of both the sides. They admitted that the
plaintiffs have constituted, defendant No.1 their lawful attorney and on the
strength of said Power of Attorney he sold part of the joint properties distributing
the amount with themselves. They also admitted the second power of attorney
constituted by plaintiff No.1.
[20]
The defendants further mentioned that in his WILL their father
clearly stated that the plaintiffs are not entitled for any properties left by him.
They reasoned that the Power of Attorneys were executed as the name of the
plaintiff No.1 were wrongly recorded in the corresponding Khatian and during
sale of those properties, the said Power of Attorneys were executed.
Subsequently, they filed a case for deletion of the name of plaintiff No.1 from the
said Khatian.
[21]
In their subsequent written statement filed after amendment of the
plaint in addition the defendant stated that in the WILL at page No.10 one
condition is incorporated in which the testator (Lal Mohan Sarkar) intended that,
if the marriage of his daughters were given out of the proceeds of sale of his
property, none of his daughters will be entitled for any property left by him. The
defendants stated that in compliance with that condition plaintiff Nos. 1 and 2
was given marriage after death of Lal Mohan Sarkar and the expenditure was
borne from the personal savings amount of the answering defendants and also by
selling part of the property left by their father.
[22]
In this written statement the defendant stated that the Power of
Attorneys was executed to represent the plaintiffs, to create Khatian as per the
WILL etc. They categorically stated that the WILL was executed 30 years prior
and on the strength of that WILL the suit land get mutated in favour of the
answering defendants, but as wrongly included the name of plaintiff No.1 in the
finally published Khatian. To rectify the same the answering defendants filed an
application under Section-95 of TLR & LR Act which got numbered as Rev.
Case No.374 of 2015 and is pending before the D.M & Collector. Lastly, they
raised the issue that the plaintiffs sought cancellation of the registered WILL by
way of amendment of the plaint for which they required to file a separate
declaratory suit. It has been further contended that in addition they claimed that
the suit was initially filed for partition and subsequently, cancellation of WILL
was added by way of amendment. But for the newly added relief no further Court
fee is paid and the suit is not properly valued and hence prayed for its dismissal.
[23]
Mr. S. M. Chakraborty, learned senior counsel has vehemently
opposed the prayer of the plaintiffs, the respondents herein, stating that the suit is
not maintainable ab-initio as after addition of further prayer of cancellation of
WILL and sale deed, additional Court fee is not paid. He drew the attention of
the Court to the evidence of PW-1 Shila Sarkar who deposed that her step
brothers and sisters sold land which they inherited from their father. He stated
that this evidence of PW-1 gives a clear picture that the plaintiffs have
knowledge of the WILL.
[24]
Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, learned senior counsel appearing for the
respondents herein, has stated that it is alleged by the defendants that deceased
Lal Mohan Sarkar executed one WILL but on the basis of the said WILL
mutation was not done. He further agitated that the WILL submitted by the
defendants has not been proved in compliance with Sections-67 and 68 of the
Evidence Act. He also argued that the attesting witness Nani Gopal Deb who
deposed is not the Nani Gopal Deb who actually signed as the attesting witness.
It has been further contended that the WILL relied by the defendants is only a
piece of paper and is clouded by suspicion as it is not acted upon till institution of
the suit. In support of his argument he has averred that even in the year 2013 the
plaintiffs constituted defendant No.1 to be the lawful attorney for the purpose of
sale of the suit land.
[25]
In terms of the WILL they have already exhausted their respective
shares by alienating the property and now it is not open for them that at this
juncture, once again came and contest the matter in respect of the properties of
the plaintiffs and the defendants who were the children of the second wife of the
deceased Lal Mohan Sarkar. The properties according to the share in terms of the
WILL of the persons are indicated in Khatian No. 1967/1. For the ready
reference the same may be extracted hereunder:
Description of interest and
possessor (in details) (6)
[26]
Rayati Possessor
Mihir Sarkar
Bimal Sarkar
Shyamal Sarkar
Amal Sarkar
Shila Sarkar, s/o Lal Mohan
Sarkar
Bela Sarkar, w/o Lal Mohan
Sarkar, Vill. Own (rajnagar),
P.O. Gandhigram
Share
(7)
Class to which land holder
belongs along with
particulars (8)
Special condition and
incidents of the
tenancy or holding (9)
Rayati Permanent
Revenue Increasable
Subordinate interest,
Separate Khatian No.
of Subordinate
Interest (10)
16667
16667
16667
16667
16667
16666
In order to find an answer to the issues involved herein, let us
relook through the evidence once again. P.W-1 Smt. Shila Sarkar is the plaintiff
No.1 who deposed that after death of their father all the plaintiffs and the
defendants started possessing the suit land by way of inheritance. She stated that
her father Lal Mohan Sarkar and deceased uncle Anil Ch. Sarkar were the lawful
owner and possessor of the land described in schedule C of the plaint. After death
of her uncle Anil Ch. Sarkar, his wife and children being his legal heirs sold out
their share of land to defendant Nos. 1 to 4 by way of registered deed. She
admitted that on 21.10.1998 she along with other plaintiffs and other co-sharers
executed one registered general POA appointing defendant No.1 as attorney in
respect of the suit land and on the strength of that Power of Attorney [PAO for
short], said defendant No.1 sold out some property without making any partition .
She also added that on 15.03.2013 she executed another POA appointing the
same defendant No.1 to manage, sale, transfer etc in respect of the land described
in schedule A and Schedule B.
[27]
In support of her testimony, she produced certified copies of
Khatian bearing No.537, 538 and 439 (Old). She has also produced the certified
copies of New Khatians and has also produced the registered Will dated
15.03.1986 along with these she placed the certified copy of registered sale deed
No. 1-762 dated 11.02.1998 and the two POAs stated above. In her crossexamination she admitted that her step brothers and sisters have sold their land
which they inherited from their father but she cannot say how her father gave the
said land to them. She admitted that her father executed a Will during his life
time which she came to know after institution of this suit. The remaining
suggestions were outright denied by her.
[28]
Coming to the evidence of the defendants it is found that defendant
No.1 Amal Sarkar has deposed as D.W-1 whereas defendant No.8 deposed as
D.W-2. One Ajit Kr. Sarkar deposed as D.W-3 and thereafter evidence of one
Nani Gopal Deb is recorded on their behalf. D.W-1 Amal Sarkar rests his
defence on the Will purported to be executed by their father on 15.03.1986. He
stated that the marriage of plaintiff No.3 was given during the lifetime of their
father whereas the marriage of plaintiff Nos. 1 and 2 were given after his death,
expenditure being borne by them. He claimed that the plaintiff as per the said
Will is not entitled for any property left by their father. In support of his stand he
produced some documents like certified copy of some Khatians and the original
Will dated 15.03.1986. He has also produced the original death certificate,
survival certificate of their father and one original POA dated 15.03.2013.
[29]
On the strength of the said POA, he sold some of the property. He
also admitted the second Power of attorney to be executed by plaintiff No.1 and
on its strength again he sold some properties distributing the consideration
money amongst them. The remaining suggestions were denied by him.
[30]
D.W-2 on the other hand deposed that there was no jointly owned
property of Lt Lal Mohan Sarkar and his brother Anil Ch. Sarkar. She stated that
during his lifetime Lal Mohan Sarkar and his brother mutually partitioned their
land and the legal heirs of Anil Ch. Sarkar transferred their share to the
defendants. She also stated about the Will and its condition which is discussed
above. She stated in her cross-examination that the she did not file any W.S. She
further stated that the legal heirs of Anil Ch. Sarkar are also the co-sharers of the
suit land. She added that once they came to Agartala and sold their share. She
admitted that the legal heirs of Anil Ch. Sarkar filed a case against them which
got settled amicably.
[31]
D.W-3 is one Ajit Sarkar who is one of the defendants. He deposed
that his father executed one Will with a condition that if marriages of the
plaintiffs was held from the property of their father than they will not get any
share on the said property. He further deposed that defendant Nos. 1 to 4 did not
pay during the marriages of the plaintiffs. In his cross-examination he admitted
that during the life time of their father plaintiff No. 3 was given in marriage. He
further stated that after death of his father legal heirs of his uncle Anil Ch.
Sarkar, claimed their share over the suit land. Then they instituted a civil suit
against them. He further deposed that during the pendency of the suit they
abandoned their share for an amount of Rs. 1, 50,000/-. He also stated that after
death of his father plaintiff No 1 and 2 got married and the defendants No. 1 to 4
did not bear the expenditure of the said married.
[32]
In the light of the above let us have a look at the relevant
provisions of CPC. Under clause (b) and (c) of Rule 11 of Order VII CPC the
plaint can be rejected for non-payment of deficit court fee on being required by
the Court to correct the valuation within a time fixed by the Court and the if
plaintiff fails to do so or where the relief claimed is properly valued but the plaint
is returned upon paper insufficiently stamped, and plaintiff being called upon by
the Court to supply the requisite stamp paper within a time fixed by the Court
and plaintiff fails to do so. Proviso to Order-VII Rule-11 CPC would indicate
that time so fixed shall not be extended, unless the Court, for reasons to be
recorded, is satisfied of the cause shown. Thus, enlarging the time for payment of
deficit court fee or supplying the requisite stamp papers, as the case may be,
within the time fixed by the Court would necessarily mean and include that a
time is to be fixed by the Court for the plaintiff to comply with such direction or
the time frame within which deficiency is to be made good or complied. The
proviso would also indicate that power is vested to the Court to enlarge the time
on twin conditions incorporated therein, if satisfied would vest the Court with the
power to enlarge the time or extend the time to correct the valuation or supply the
requisite stamp papers, as the case may be.
[33]
Now, coming to the point of cause of action. The plaintiffs are
admittedly the legal heirs of original owner of the suit land Lal Mohan Sarkar.
They have produced the corresponding khatian in the name of their father. It has
been laid down that the plaintiffs requested the defendants for partition of the suit
land but they denied. The plaintiffs specifically mentioned that on 10.04.15 the
plaintiffs made the request for amicable partition which was denied by the
defendants. The term cause of action narrates the bundle of facts which give right
to any plaintiff to file any suit. The above narrated fact certainly depicts such
cause to remain present for the plaintiffs to have file this suit especially when the
plaintiffs rests their claim on khatian standing in the name of their deceased
father. The date of cause of action further speaks that the suit is filed within time.
[34]
In the present case, another facet also requires to be considered that
the WILL is admitted to be a conditional WILL. In this regard, the evidence of
DW8 i.e. mother of the parties to the suit deserves discussion. Defendant No. 8 is
her written statement admitted execution of the WILL but stated that it is one of
the condition of the WILL that if marriage of the plaintiffs was held during the
lifetime of the testator or after his death if the expenditure in that case borne by
his sons from second marriage i.e. defendants No. 1 to 4, only in that case the
plaintiffs will not get any share over the property left by him. She further stated
that the marriages of the plaintiffs took place after the death of Lal Mohan Sarkar
and defendants’ No. 1 to 4 did not bear the expenditure of such marriage.
[35]
She supported the suit of the plaintiffs and prayed for a decree of
partition. However, she deposed as DW-2 stating altogether a different story
stating that the marriage of plaintiff No. 3 was given during the lifetime of her
husband and the remaining plaintiffs were given in marriage after his death the
expenditure of which was borne by defendants’ No. 1 to 4. However, she also
admitted execution of power of attorney and that the legal heirs of Anil Chandra
Sarkar transferred their entire share in favour of the plaintiffs and defendants No.
1 to 4 and herself. She also admitted that the sale proceed obtained on the
strength of POA executed by the plaintiffs was distributed amongst all of them.
[36]
The said evidence of DW.2 is totally beyond her pleading as in her
W/S she stated that the condition of the WILL was not fulfilled due to which the
plaintiffs are entitled for a decree of partition but in her evidence she stated that
the said condition was fulfilled. Her evidence being in contrary to her pleading
cannot be considered and outright discarded. Having discussed the above
situation it gets clear that the WILL purported to be executed by the testator is a
conditional WILL and there is no cogent evidence on record as to the fulfillment
of such condition.
[37]
The defendants in one end is admitting execution of POAs by the
plaintiffs and sale of part of the suit land distributing the proceed amongst
themselves and on the other end is denying the share of the plaintiffs on the basis
of the WILL in question. Presently, this Court is not going into the discussion of
fulfillment of the condition of the WILL as its execution is not free from
suspicion as per the above discussion. To sum up this Court is of the opinion that
the defendants could not remove the suspicious circumstance roaming around the
execution of the WILL bearing no. III-22 dated 15.03.1986 and accordingly, is
liable to be declared canceled. The plaintiffs are found to be entitled for a decree
of declaration in this respect.
[38]
The defendant Nos. 1 to 4 in their written statement submitted that
the legal heirs of Anil Chandra Sarkar abundant their share and subsequently, the
plaintiffs and the defendants sold out the said property distributing the
consideration money amongst both the plaintiffs and the defendants. On perusal
of documents adduced by both the sides it is found that neither the plaintiffs nor
the defendants adduced any evidence regarding the legal heirs of Anil Chandra
Sarkar admitted to have died. Going through the relevant Khatians it is found that
the land described in C schedule is recorded in the name of Lal Mohan Sarkar
and Anil Chandra Sarkar.
[39]
The contentions made by Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, learned senior
counsel appearing for the respondents cannot be appreciated since he has not
preferred any suit nor he has challenged the judgment and decree of the Court
below and Order-23 of CPC is not applicable to the facts and circumstances of
the case. As per evidence of the party No.2, the clients of Mr. D. Bhattacharjee,
learned senior counsel, the children of the first wife in their cross examination
has categorically stated as under:
“I cannot say the dag No and khatian No. of the suit land. I filed no suit
claiming land of my share against the present plaintiff as well as other
defendants.
I constructed my house at Gorkhabasti in the year 1984. At that time I was
posted at Agartala in the office of the Industry and commerce. My father
expired in the year 1989. I did not file any suit/case challenging any khatian
of the suit property.
It is not a fact that I am deposing falsely after supporting the case of the
plaintiffs Our father during his life time bequeathed by a WILL land
measuring 10 gandas to me and 10 gandas to my brother Dilip Sarkar.
Subsequently, I sold my share. After the death of father I came to know
about the WILL. All the parties were well aware of the WILL.”
[40]
For the purpose of reference, Order-23 of CPC may be reproduced
hereunder:
“1. Withdrawal of suit or abandonment of part of claim.-(1) At any time
after the institution of a suit, the plaintiff may as against all or any of the
defendants abandon his suit or abandon a part of his claim:
Provided that where the plaintiff is a minor or other person to whom the
provisions contained in Rules 1 to 14 of Order XXXII extend, neither the
suit nor any part of the claim shall be abandoned without the leave of the
Court.
(2) An Application for leave under the proviso to sub-rule (1) shall be
accompanied by an affidavit of the next friend and also, if the minor or such
other person is represented by a pleader, by a certificate of the pleader to the
effect that the abandonment proposed is, in his opinion, for the benefit of the
minor or such other, person.
(3) Where the Court is satisfied,(a) that a suit must fail by reason of some formal defect, or
(b) that there are sufficient grounds for allowing the plaintiff to institute a
fresh suit for the subject-matter of a suit or part of a claim,
it may, on such terms as it thinks fit, grant the plaintiff permission to
withdraw from such suit or such part of the claim with liberty to institute a
fresh suit in respect of the subject-matter of such suit or such part of the
claim.
(4) Where the plaintiff(a) abandons any suit or part of claim under sub-rule (1), or
(b) withdraws from a suit or part of a claim without the permission referred
to in sub-rule (3),
He shall be liable for such costs as the Court may award and shall be
precluded from instituting any fresh suit in respect of such subject-matter or
such part of the claim.
(5) Nothing in this rule shall be deemed to authorise the Court to permit one
of several plaintiffs to abandon a suit or part of a claim under sub-rule (1), or
to withdraw, under sub-rule (3), any suit or part of a claim, without the
consent of the other plaintiffs.”
[41]
Mr. D. Bhattacahrjee, learned senior counsel appearing for the
respondents submits before this Court that it is not open for the plaintiffs and the
defendant appellants herein to collude with each other and in the name of
compromise they cannot withdraw by depriving the party No.2. In terms of the
clients of Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, learned senior counsel as stated (supra) they have
already alienated their respective shares now, it is not open for them to come and
contest.
[42]
Mr. S. M. Chakraborty, learned senior counsel appearing for the
appellant further contended that when the plaintiffs have decided to withdraw the
suit and not interested to pursue the litigation, there cannot be any objection and
have neither challenged the WILL nor they have challenged the partition decree
and they well come the partition decree and they got their shares as per WILL.
There was no challenge by the party No.2 or before any Court except making
their submission as the party defendants and it is now open for the defendants to
oppose the withdrawal.
[43]
This Court finds force in the arguments of Mr. S. M. Chakraborty,
learned senior counsel. Defendants to the suit have not chosen to contest upon
the judgment and decree of the Court below and have not challenged the same.
They have not filed a suit either challenging the WILL nor any claim upon the
partition. Therefore, it is not open for them now to seek any relief in a case that is
not filed by them.
[44]
In view of above observations, the present appeal stands disposed
of being withdrawn by the plaintiff-respondents without any objection by the
contesting appellant-defendants, accordingly, the judgment dated 30.07.2019 and
the consequential decree dated 06.08.2019 stands set aside. As a sequel,
miscellaneous application, pending if any, shall stand closed. Prepare the decree
accordingly.
B. PALIT, J
A. Ghosh
ANJAN GHOSH
Date: 2025.04.29 13:12:52 +05'30'
T. AMARNATH GOUD, J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review