Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAT. APP.NO.16 OF 2025
Sri Abhinash Das, son of Late Jagabandhu Das of
Village Bilashpur, P.O. Dalugaon, P.S. & Sub-Division-Kailashahar,
District-Unakoti, Tripura-799280.
--- Appellant.
Versus
Smt. Swapna Suklabaidya (Das), wife of Sri Abhinash Das,
Daughter of Late Adhir Suklabaidya of village Bilashpur,
P.O.-Dalugaon, P.S. & Sub-Division-Kailashahar,
District-Unakoti, Tripura 799280.
--- Respondent.
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M.S. RAMACHANDRA RAO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA
For the Appellant
:
Ms. Paramita Dhar, Advocate.
For the Respondent
:
None.
Date of hearing
:
02.09.2025
Date of delivery of Judgment and Order: 25.09.2025
Whether fit for reporting
:
YES
NO
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(S. Datta Purkayastha,J)
We have heard Ms. Paramita Dhar, learned counsel for the
appellant.
2.
The judgment dated 10.02.2025, passed by learned Judge, Family
Court, Kailashahar, Unakoti Tripura in TS (Divorce) 77 of 2022 rejecting the
petition of the appellant, praying for a decree of divorce and the related decree
thereof, are under challenge in this appeal.
3.
The appellant as the petitioner filed the petition for divorce on the
ground of cruelty and desertion by the respondent. His marriage with the
respondent was solemnized in the year 1994 and in their conjugality two
daughters and one son were born. Both the daughters were given marriage
earlier and the son is now aged about 22 years.
4.
The grievances of the petitioner are that, since last 10 years, there
were changes in the behavioural pattern of the respondent. She started frequent
quarrelling with him without any reason and basis, and gradually the extent of
her cruelties also increased. She also stopped performing regular domestic
works, cooking, etc. and even filed case falsely implicating him. Lastly, on
20.07.2007 she willfully separated herself from the petitioner and started
residing in separate mess with her son. She also stopped maintaining any sort
of communication with him. It is also the grievance of the petitioner that the
respondent used to remain busy on her mobile handset and social media
platform like WhatsApp, Messenger, etc. in talking with the strangers.
According to the petitioner, he tried his level best to restore the situation, but,
the respondent denied to rejoin him. Therefore, he presented the petition for
divorce.
5.
The respondent, in her written objection stated that after marriage,
both the petitioner and his family members were cruel towards her and even,
on the day of marriage, they demanded Rs.7000/- from the respondent
followed by a threat that unless said payment was made, the petitioner would
withdraw himself from going throw the ceremonials of marriage. However, the
brother of the respondent somehow managed the amount and paid it to the
petitioner and, thereafter, the marriage was solemnized. She has been subjected
to both mental and physical torture after her marriage in the groom’s house and
it increased day by day. The well wishers and the relatives of the parties
attempted to mitigate the dispute by amicable settlement, but failed.
6.
It is also contended by her that about 3 years ago, once she
became ill as one tumour was detected in her uterus but, the petitioner denied
to arrange any treatment for her. She also heard that the petitioner was engaged
in extramarital relationship with another lady. According to her, the petitioner
several times tried to oust her from the house to marry that woman, and lastly,
after causing physical torture upon her, he forcefully separated himself from
the association of the respondent and since then, he has been living separately
from her and her son. Therefore, she was compelled to file a petition against
him seeking maintenance.
7.
During trial, the petitioner from his side, examined 3(three)
witnesses including himself and the respondent also examined herself and
another witness, namely, Narayan Bhowmik. The respondent also proved few
documents in the evidence relating to her treatment. Finally, learned Judge,
Family Court, after appreciating the evidences came to the conclusion that the
petitioner himself was responsible for such separation and he was trying to
take advantage of his own wrong and, therefore, learned Court below denied
the relief to the petitioner.
8.
Being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the findings returned by
learned Judge, Family Court, the petitioner being the appellant has filed the
instant appeal.
9.
During the course of hearing, learned counsel, Ms. Dhar submits
that for more than 8(eight) years i.e. from the year 2017, the respondent has
deserted the appellant and he is residing separately from her. Despite he being
an old person, the respondent did not perform her marital obligations towards
him. Learned counsel further argues that the learned Court below has
misappreciated the evidences leading to a wrong decision.
10.
The copies of the testimonies of the witnesses of both sides are
submitted by the appellant and on consideration of the same, it is found that
both the appellant and his witnesses, namely, Bhabotosh Baidya and Bipul
Majumder have given omnibus statements that since last 10 years, the
respondent would frequently quarrel with the appellant without any reason and
her cruelties upon the appellant increased gradually. She also stopped herself
from performing regular domestic works, cooking etc. and even filed case
falsely implicating the appellant. Not a single incident of cruelty, either mental
or physical, has been stated by the appellant in his petition or in the evidences
of himself or his witnesses. Though he stated that the respondent had filed case
against him but, no document in this regard was also submitted.
11.
In fact, there is no fixed parameter for determining cruelty in
matrimonial dispute inasmuch as the concept of cruelty differs from person to
person depending on their social status, level of upbringing, extent of
sensitivity, educational, societal and cultural background, financial status, etc.
What is cruelty for a woman in a particular case may not be cruelty for a man
and vice versa. Therefore, appreciation of evidences generally blends with
some amount of subjectivity, nevertheless, the ingredients which constitute the
cruelty are objective. The burden always lies on the petitioner to prove the
cruelty and desertion on the touchstone of preponderance of probability.
12.
Relevantly, a recent decision of the Supreme Court in the case of
Smt. Roopa Soni Vrs. Kamalnarayan Soni, (2023)16 SCC 615 deserves
reference in this context and the relevant paragraph no.7 is extracted hereunder :
“7. We would like to emphasize that an element of subjectivity has to
be applied albeit, what constitutes cruelty is objective. Therefore, what is
cruelty for a woman in a given case may not be cruelty for a man, and a
relatively more elastic and broad approach is required when we examine a
case in which a wife seeks divorce. Section 13(1) of the Act of 1995 sets
contours and rigours for grant of divorce at the instance of both parties.
Historically, the law of divorce was predominantly built on a conservative
canvas based on the fault theory. Preservation of marital sanctity from a
societal perspective was considered a prevailing factor. With the adoption of
a libertarian attitude, the grounds for separation or dissolution of marriage
have been construed with latitudinarianism.”
13.
According to the petitioner, on 20th July, 2017 the respondent had
separated herself from him whereas in his cross-examination, the appellant
admitted that the respondent was still residing in his own house, rather he was
residing in the house of witness Bhabotosh Baidya. Said fact itself indicates
that the respondent never left her matrimonial home abandoning the appellant.
He also admitted that he had no contact with his children who are now well
grown up. This fact shows that his children are also hostile towards him and
not towards their mother. Despite his assertion that local people and relatives
including Panchayat members tried to restore their conjugal life by way of
settlement, but no satisfactory evidence has been led by him in this regard.
14.
The testimonies of his other two witnesses are also not
satisfactory. According to PW-2, Bhabotosh Baidya, he heard such story of
torture from the appellant but he did not personally witness the same. PW-3,
Bipul Majumder is also similarly a hearsay witness. According to him, he
heard from the appellant that the respondent did not perform household works
and that the respondent and her son had attempted to physically hurt the
appellant.
15.
The respondent, on the other hand, stated in her evidence that the
appellant had received PMAY-G house building benefit from the government
and after receiving the amount, he left the house leaving the respondent alone
there. She also stated that when she was seriously ill, after said tumour was
detected, the appellant denied any sort of treatment to her and after separation
he even stopped paying any maintenance, leading the respondent and her son
to severe hardship. In her cross-examination, she stated that for last 3/4 years,
she did not know the whereabouts of the petitioner. To support her version, she
also examined another witness, namely, Narayan Bhowmik whose house is
situated at a distance of 500 cubits from her house. Said witness supported her
version.
16.
Therefore, on consideration of the evidences as a whole, we find
no error in the impugned judgment. Mere bald statements implicating the
spouse with allegations of cruelty and desertion are not sufficient to entitle a
person to get a decree of divorce.
17.
The appeal is dismissed being devoid of merit.
Registry is to prepare decree accordingly and communicate a copy
of this judgment and decree to the learned Court below.
Interim application(s), if any, stands disposed of.
(S. DATTA PURKAYASTHA, J)
SANJAY GHOSH
Sanjay
Date: 2025.09.25 17:02:33 +05'30'
(M.S.RAMACHANDRA RAO, CJ)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review