Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/62
GAHC010255522025
2026:GAU-AS:2443
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/6625/2025
SPS CONSTRUCTION INDIA PVT. LTD.
THROUGH ITS AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVE MR MADHAV SINGLA
HAVING REGISTERED OFFICE AT 1006 1007 10TH FLOOR PEARLS BEST
HEIGHT 1 NETAJI SUBHASH PLACE PITAMPURA NEW DELHI 110034
VERSUS
UNION OF INDIA AND 2 ORS
THROUGH MINISTRY OF RAILWAYS HAVING ITS OFFICE AT 156 A RAISINA
ROAD RAJPATH AREA CENTRAL SECRETARIAT NEW DELHI 110001
2:NORTHEAST FRONTIER RAILWAY
THROUGH CHIEF ENGINEER HAVING ITS OFFICE AT CONSTRUCTION
OFFICE MALIGAON GUWAHATI 781011
3:LARSEN AND TOUBRO LIMITED
HAVING ITS OFFICE AT 8TH FLOOR VATIKA MINDSCAPE BUILDING
DELHI MATHURA ROAD FARIDABAD 12100
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR. K N CHOUDHURY, MR. TANUZ KASHYAP,N GAUTAM
Advocate for the Respondent : DY.S.G.I., MS M KAKOTY (R-3),R SARMAH(R-3)
Linked Case : WP(C)/5051/2025
SPS CONSTRUCTION INDIA PRIVATE LIMITED
THROUGH ITS AUTHORIZED REPRESENTATIVE MR. MADHAV SINGLA
AGE 30 YEARS.
HAVING REGISTERED OFFICE AT 1006-1007
10TH FLOOR
PEARIS BEST HEIGHT-1
Page No.# 2/62
PITAMPURA
NEW DELHI-110034
VERSUS
UNION OF INDIA AND ANR
THROUGH MINISTRY OF RAILWAYS HAVING ITS OFFICE AT 256 A
RAISINA ROAD
RAJPATH AREA CENTRAL SECRETARIAT
NEW DELHI-110001
2:NORTHEAST FRONTIER RAILWAY
THROUGH CHIEF ENGINEER HAVING ITS OFFICE AT CONSTRUCTION
OFFICE MALIGAON
GUWAHATI-781011.
------------
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DEVASHIS BARUAH
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. K. N. Choudhury, Sr. Advocate
: Mr. A. Mittal, Advocate
: Mr. V. Pahuja, Advocate
: Mr. T. Kashyap, Advocate
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. D. Das, Sr. Advocate
: Mr. K. Gogoi, CGC
: Ms. M. Khanna, Advocate
: Mr. R. Sarma, Advocate
·
Date on which Judgment was reserved
: 10.02.2026
·
Date of Pronouncement of Judgment
: 18.02.2026
·
Whether the pronouncement is of
the Operative Part of the Judgment
: N/A
Whether the full Judgment has been
Pronounced
: Yes
·
Page No.# 3/62
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (CAV)
Heard Mr. K. N. Choudhury, the learned Senior counsel
assisted by Mr. A. Mittal and Mr. V. Pahuja, the learned counsels
appearing on behalf of the Petitioner in both the writ petition. I
have also heard Mr. K. Gogoi, the learned CGC who appears on
behalf of the Respondent Authorities in both the writ petitions. Mr.
D. Das, the learned Senior counsel assisted by Ms. M. Khanna and
Mr. R. Sarma, the learned counsels appearing on behalf of the
Respondent No.3 in WP(C) No.6625/2025.
PREFACE:
2.
Both the writ petitions are inter related. In WP(C)
No.5051/2025, the Petitioner have assailed Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2
contained in the Request For Proposal (for short ‘RFP’) issued by
the Respondent Authorities and in the alternative have sought for
declaration that Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 in the RFP did not disqualify
such bidders who may have experienced history of any collapse in
respect of any of the projects in the last 3 years on account of
force
majeure
conditions
and/or
for
not
determined
and
adjudicated fault of theirs. Declaration was also sought for that the
Petitioner is not disqualified under the terms of the Clause
2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 in the RFP on account of the Sultanganj incident. The
Page No.# 4/62
Petitioner has also sought for a writ in the nature of Mandamus to
quash the rejection by the Respondents, the bid of the Petitioner in
respect of the RFP dated 19.05.2025, if done during the pendency
of the writ petition on the basis of the impugned Clause
2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 as well as also to quash any action(s) or steps
undertaken by the Respondents during the pendency of the writ
petition to further the tendering process arising out of the RFP
dated 19.05.2025 without considering the bid of the Petitioner and
restore status quo ante.
3.
The Petitioner in the interim also sought for certain directions
i.e. stay the effect, implementation and operation of Clause
2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 in the RFP dated 19.05.2025 and directions be issued
upon the Respondents to consider the bid submitted by the
Petitioner in pursuance to the RFP dated 19.05.2025 on its own
merits and not to consider the Sultanganj incident as a reason for
disqualification of the petitioner from the said tender. The
Petitioner also sought for interim directions that the Respondents
be restrained from taking any action to further the tender process
in respect of the RFP dated 19.05.2025 without considering the bid
of the Petitioner.
4.
It is pertinent to take note of that while the writ petition i.e.
Page No.# 5/62
WP(C) No.5051/2025 was pending, the Petitioner learnt that its
technical bid was rejected on 28.10.2025 as non-responsive in
terms with Clause 2.2.2.2 and Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP. The
Petitioner being aggrieved preferred a writ petition before this
Court
which
was
registered
and
numbered
as
WP(C)
No.6274/2025. When the said writ petition was moved before this
Court on 07.11.2025 with the records of WP(C) No.5051/2025, it
was informed by the learned counsel for the Respondents that the
Letter of Acceptance had already been issued in favour of the
Respondent No.3 in WP(C) No.6625/2025 on 06.11.2025. The said
writ petition being WP(C) No.6274/2025 was withdrawn and liberty
was granted to the Petitioner to again assail the impugned actions
which were the subject matter of WP(C) No.6274/2025 as well as
the Letter of Acceptance dated 06.11.2025. It is under such
circumstances WP(C) No.6625/2025 was filed seeking appropriate
directions for quashing the decision of the Respondent dated
28.10.2025 i.e. the date when the Petitioner’s Technical Bid was
rejected as well as the Letter of Acceptance dated 06.11.2025
issued to the Respondent No.3. The Petitioner had also sought for
directions to the effect that the Respondents be directed to
reevaluate the financial bids of the qualified bidders along with the
financial bid of the Petitioner.
Page No.# 6/62
BRIEF FACTS OF THE INSTANT CASE:
5.
A Request for Proposal (RFP) was issued by the Respondent
Authorities for Engineering, Procurement and Construction (EPC)
Mode of the 2nd rail cum road bridge over river Brahmaputra
including viaduct, retaining walls, embankment and minor bridges
including track work, OHE work, signaling and telecom work,
commissioning of stations and general work between Agthori and
Kamakhya Station from km 393.980 to km 401.120. The said
tender notice was issued on 19.05.2025. It is pertinent to take
note of that in the RFP dated 19.05.2025, various terms and
conditions were mentioned. Relevant herein is to take Note of
Section 2 of the RFP which is with the heading “INSTRUCTIONS TO
BIDDERS”. Clause 2.2 of Section 2 of the RFP stipulates about the
Eligibility and Qualification requirements of the Bidders. Clause
2.2.2.4 of Section 2 of the RFP is with the heading “Categories and
factors for evaluation of Technical Capacity”. Further to that, at
Clause (iii) of Clause 2.2.2.4 of Section 2 of the RFP, the Technical
Capacity for the purpose of the RFP are stipulated.
Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 being the focal point of the present
dispute is reproduced below:
“2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2
There
should
not
be
history
of
collapse
of
Page No.# 7/62
superstructure/substructure of any span of a bridge/flyover/ via-duct/metro
line work during construction/service in last 5 years, ending last day of month
previous to the one in which tender is invited. Undertaking in this regard shall
be submitted along with the bid.”
6.
A perusal of the above quoted Clause would show that for the
purpose of applying under the RFP and adjudge the Technical
Capacity, it was the requirement that there should not be history of
collapse
of
Superstructure/Substructure
bridge/flyover/
via-duct/metro
line
of
any
span
work
of
a
during
construction/service in last 5 years, ending the last day of month
previous to the one in which tender is invited. It is also the
requirement that an Undertaking in that regard has to be
submitted along with the bid.
7.
It appears from the materials on record that various bidders,
including the Petitioner submitted representations in respect to
various Clauses of the RFP including Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2. It is of
importance to take note of the representation submitted by the
Petitioner on 31.05.2025 which forms a part of Annexure-13 (Colly)
to
WP(C)
No.5051/2025.
At
paragraph
No.5
of
the
said
representation, the Petitioner had categorically mentioned that it
has vast experience in design and construction of bridges, open to
consider fail-safe design and construction. It was also mentioned
Page No.# 8/62
that the Petitioner encountered unforeseeable accidental collapse
of parts of few spans in respect to a bridge constructed in the
State of Bihar. It was also mentioned that the cause of the collapse
have not been detected. Paragraph No.5 of the said representation
being relevant as would be noticed at a later stage of the present
judgment is reproduced herein under:
“5.
Notwithstanding the vast experience in the Design and Construction of
the Bridges, open to consider fail-safe design and construction – we had
encountered unforeseeable an accidental collapse of part of few spans in chain
effect “C/o 2 x 2 Lane Bridge with footpath across River Ganga between
Sultanganj (Bhagalpur District) and Aguwani Ghat (Khagaria District) including
navigational span of cable stayed and approaches (Connecting NH-31 and NH80) in the State of Bihar on EPC mode”. As on date, it has not been detected
cause of collapse. Invariably every contract provides for the terms and
conditions for such unforeseeable accidents, insurance and indemnification
provisions within the Contract Agreements.”
It was also mentioned in the said representation that the said
Clause No.2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP is required to be deleted in the
interest of the benefit of better competition; benefit of learning
from accidents and make use of insight gained. Paragraph No.7 of
the said Representation being also relevant is reproduced herein
under:
“7.
We consider, clause 2.2.2.4(iii)(ii)(2) reads as under require review and
Page No.# 9/62
deletion in the interest of the benefits of better competition, benefit of learning
from accidents, make use of the insight gained. Such like clauses are conflict
of reasonableness. We humbly prays the Competent Authority may pleased to
delete the following clause in the larger public interest and public exchequer.
Such like clause never specified by the Government of India in earlier RFPS.
We quote most recent invitation of RFP (NIT) by the East Central Railways
“EPC for Construction of New BG Rail Bridge (1x32.086m Open Web Steel
Girder + 33x122.0m Open Web Steel Girder + 1x32.086m Open Web Steel
Girder) with Sub-structure of Double line Track and Superstructure of Single
line Track across River Ganga between Bikramshila and Katareah Stations on
New Railways Line Project of East Central Railways,” opening of Technical Bids
on 22.02.2025. There is no such like clause in the above work NIT. Such like
clause fall within the meaning of anti-competitive agreement. Beside,
disqualification of Bidder would have effect of prevent a party from the
privilege of entering into lawful relationship with the Government without an
opportunity of hearing and fair trial.”
8.
From the records and more particularly Annexure-13 (Colly), it
appears that on 03.07.2025, the Petitioner requested the
Honorable Member Infrastructure Railway Board for a meeting in
view of two tenders being floated by two divisions of Indian
Railways wherein additional conditions have been inserted which
bars experienced and eligible contractors like the Petitioner from
participating in the bidding process and restricting fair and healthy
practice of competition. One of the tenders referred to in the said
communication includes the present RFP.
Page No.# 10/62
9.
The records also show that similar to the Petitioner, various
other bidders also requested deletion or modification of Clause
2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2. A Pre Bid Meeting admittedly was held amongst the
various bidders wherein the Petitioner participated. On the basis of
the Pre Bid Meeting, clarifications were issued on 23.07.2025 in
respect to various Clauses of the RFP dated 19.05.2025 including
Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2. The Query as well as the remarks given qua
Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP being relevant is reproduced herein
under:
SN
Description
Query
Remarks
Additional
Deletion of above clause The Clarification has been
experience
2.2.2.4(iii)(ii)(2)
or incorporated in revised
(history
of modification as There should RFP. The Collapse of
collapse)
not be history of collapse of Superstructure
superstructure/ substructure /Substructure pertain to
of
any
span
of
a Design failure or quality
bridge/flyover/via-duct/metro related
failure
of
line
work
during permanent
structure
construction/service in last 2 would be considered in
years/3 years, ending last this clause only.
day of month previous to the
one in which tender is
invited.
10. It therefore appears that though certain bidders like the
Petitioner sought for deletion of Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP
and certain bidders sought for modification, the Respondent
Authorities decided to retain Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2. It was further
Page No.# 11/62
clarified that the collapse of the Superstructure/Substructure on
account of design failure or quality related failure of permanent
structure would only be considered for the purpose of the said
Clause.
11. On the basis of the clarifications given, which is Annexure-6 to
WP(C) No.5051/2025, a revised RFP was issued on the 23.07.2025.
Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP issued on 23.07.2025 reads as
under:
“2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2
There
should
not
be
history
of
collapse
of
superstructure/substructure of any span of a bridge/flyover/ via-duct/metro
line work during construction/service in last 3 (Three) years, ending last day of
month previous to the one in which tender is invited. Undertaking in this
regard shall be submitted along with the bid.”
The above quoted Clause would show that Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2
was retained but the period of five years was reduced to three
years.
12. It is further apposite to mention that in view of the revised
RFP issued on 23.07.2025, the last date for submission of the
financial and technical bid online was fixed on or before 27.08.2025
up to 14:30 hours and it was also mentioned that the bids received
online shall be opened on the date as mentioned in the Kit in the
Page No.# 12/62
Office of the General Manager/CON/MLG NF Railway Construction
Organization.
13. The Petitioner admittedly did not submit any representation
pursuant to the revised RFP. On the other hand, the Petitioner
avers at Paragraph No.37 of WP(C) No.5051/2025 that on account
of the given timelines for the submission of the bid, the Petitioner
submitted its bid. No date has been mentioned when the Petitioner
submitted the bid but taking into consideration the fact that
Petitioner submitted the bid is mentioned in the writ petition, it has
to be presumed that the writ petition was filed pursuant to the
submission of the bid. Be that as it may, a perusal of the filing form
mentions the date of filing to be 28.08.2025.
14. The record reveals that when the writ petition being WP(C)
No.5051/2025 was taken up for consideration, the learned
Coordinate Bench vide an order dated 01.09.2025 issued notice
making it returnable on 08.09.2025 and passed an interim direction
to the effect that as the Petitioner has already submitted its bid
which is scheduled to be opened on 02.09.2025, the Respondents
were directed to consider the bid of the Petitioner subject to
further orders of this Court. The relevant portion of the order dated
01.09.2025 being pertinent to the issue is reproduced herein
Page No.# 13/62
under:
“Considering that the petitioner has already submitted the bids, which is
scheduled to be opened on 02.09.2025 and also considering that the challenge
to terms of disqualification would require a detailed deliberation, which would
be taken up on the next returnable date; in the interim, it is provided that the
respondents shall consider the bids of the petitioner, subject to further order of
this Court.
Since, the matter relates to tender for construction of Rail cum Road
Bridge over river Brahmaputra; on or before the next date of listing, the
respondents may file their affidavit, so that an attempt may be made to
dispose of the matter.
List on 08.09.2025.”
15. It further appears from the records that the Petitioner filed an
application in WP(C) No.5051/2025 before this Court seeking
certain urgent reliefs. The said application was registered and
numbered as I.A.(Civil) No.3462/2025. In the said application, it
was mentioned that on 28.10.2025, the Petitioner was shocked to
learn that the Respondents in clear and blatant disregard to the
order passed by this Court dated 01.09.2025 declared that the
Petitioner’s technical bid was non-responsive as per Clause 2.2.2.2
and Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP. The Petitioner came to learn
this from the website of Indian Railways E-procurement system.
Page No.# 14/62
The Petitioner therefore sought for certain interim directions to the
extent that the Respondents be restrained from taking any steps to
further tendering process during the pendency of the writ petition
including issuance of the letter of award, signing a contract or
executing any other document in favour of the third party; restrain
the Respondents from taking any steps which would create third
party rights or interest in the said tender; stay the operation of the
result of the evaluation of the bids for the said tender as released
by the Respondents including the statement of the financial bids,
etc.
16. The said application was filed on 30.10.2025 and the learned
Coordinate Bench of this Court vide an order dated 31.10.2025
disposed of the said application without imposing any restraints
upon the Respondents as prayed in the Interlocutory Application.
Paragraph 15 and 16 of the order dated 31.10.2025 passed in I.A.
(Civil) No.3462/2025are reproduced herein under:
“15.
In view of all the above, this Court does not deem it appropriate to
agree to impose restraints on the respondents as prayed for in the
interlocutory application. It is however clarified that since this Court by order
dated 1.9.2025 has already observed that the consideration of the bid of the
petitioner would be subject to further orders to be passed by this Court, the
finding of the respondents that the bid of the petitioner is nonresponsive
would also be subject to further orders that may be passed in the writ petition.
Page No.# 15/62
16.
Interlocutory application is accordingly disposed of. The observations
made in this order are limited to the adjudication of the interlocutory
application only and would not have affect on the final adjudication of the writ
petition.”
17.
Pursuant to the order dated 31.10.2025 in I.A.(Civil)
No.3462/2025, the Petitioner moved the second writ petition
before this Court which was registered and numbered as WP(C)
No.6274/2025
challenging
the
decision
of
the
Respondent
Authorities in rejecting the technical bid as non-responsive in view
of Clause 2.2.2.2 as well as Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP.
18. The said writ petition i.e. WP(C) No.6274/2025 was taken up
along with WP(C) No.5051/2025 on 07.11.2025. The learned
Central Government Counsel appearing for the Respondent
Authorities brought the attention of this Court that the Letter of
Acceptance for the said RFP had already been issued in favour of
the Respondent No.3 in WP(C) No.6625/2025. The said petition
being WP(C) No.6274/2025 was accordingly withdrawn by the
Petitioner with a liberty granted to the Petitioner to again assail the
impugned actions which were the subject matter of WP(C)
No.6274/2025 as well as the Letter of Acceptance. A copy of the
Letter of Acceptance was also handed over during the course of
the hearing on 07.11.2025 to the learned counsel who assisted Mr.
Page No.# 16/62
K.N. Choudhury, the learned Senior counsel for the Petitioner
during the course of the hearing. It is under such circumstances,
the third writ petition was filed by the Petitioner which is WP(C)
No.6625/2025.
19. It is pertinent to take note of that on 21.11.2025, when the
writ petition was taken up, this Court issued notice. However, this
Court was not inclined to pass any interim order at that stage. Be
that as it may, this Court however observed that both the writ
petition i.e. WP(C) No.5051/2025 and WP(C) No.6625/2025 were
required to be disposed off as early as possible. This Court further
observed that non-granting of interim directions as sought for by
the Petitioner on 21.11.2025 shall not create any equitable interest
in favour of the Respondent No.3.
20. The record reveals that the Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 had filed
an affidavit-in-opposition on 08.12.2025 in WP(C) No.6625/2025
justifying the rejection of the Petitioner's technical bid. The
Respondent No.3 also filed an affidavit-in-opposition on 04.12.2025
denying to the various allegations made by the Petitioner and also
bringing forth the Letter of Acceptance which was issued on
06.11.2025.
Page No.# 17/62
21. On 17.12.2025, when both the writ petitions were taken up,
after hearing the matter, the learned counsel appearing on behalf
of
the
Petitioner
sought
for
some
more
accommodation.
Accordingly, this Court directed the matter to be listed on
06.01.2026 for final disposal. Thereupon, the matter was again
listed before this Court on 21.01.2026 when at the request jointly
made by the learned Counsels appearing on behalf of the parties,
both the writ petitions were fixed on 10.02.2026 for final disposal.
22. At this stage, it is very pertinent to take note of the stand
taken by the Respondent Authorities in WP(C) No.6625/2025
assigning the reasons why the Petitioner's technical bid was
rejected for non-compliance to Clause 2.2.2.2 as well as Clause
2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP. Insofar as the rejection of the Petitioner's
technical bid in terms with Clause 2.2.2.2 of the RFP, it was
mentioned that the Clauses to be considered for financial capacity
of the bidder in the RFP are clauses 2.2.2.2, 2.2.2.8(i), 2.2.2.7(iii)
of the RFP and Serial No.4 of the instruction of the RFP i.e. “Year 1
will be the latest completed Financial Year preceding the bidding.
Year 2 shall be the year immediately proceeding Year 1 and so on.
In case, the Bid due date falls within 3 (three) months of the close
of the latest Financial Year, refer to Clause 2.1.13.”
Page No.# 18/62
Referring to Clause 2.1.13 of the RFP, it was mentioned in the
affidavit-in-opposition that as the bid due date was 27.08.2025,
which does not lie within three months of the preceding financial
year, the submission of the net worth of the year 2024-25 was
mandatory. It was also mentioned that since the document of the
latest concluded financial year was not submitted, the financial
condition is not satisfied as per Clause 2.1.13 of the RFP. Insofar as
the technical non-responsiveness of the Petitioner in terms with
Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP, it was mentioned that the
undertaking to be submitted in terms with Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of
the RFP was a mandatory document which the Petitioner failed to
submit, hence the Petitioner’s Technical Bid was non-responsive.
23. No affidavit-in-reply has been filed by the Petitioner against
the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the Respondent Authorities.
SUBMISSIONS MADE BY THE LEARNED COUNSELS FOR THE
PARTIES:
24. Mr. K. N. Choudhury, the learned Senior counsel appearing on
behalf of the Petitioner drew the attention of this Court to Clause
3.1.4 and submitted that for evaluation of the technical bid, the
Authority may at its sole discretion seek clarifications in writings
from any bidders regarding its technical bid. He submitted that the
Page No.# 19/62
words “may” though have been used in Clause 3.1.4, but it should
be understood as “shall” inasmuch as it is when the Authority
seeks clarifications, the bidders have an opportunity to explain that
there exists no deficiency. The learned Senior counsel submitted
that pursuant to the revised RFP issued on 23.07.2025, no such
steps were taken in that regard which caused serious prejudice to
the Petitioner.
25. The learned Senior counsel for the Petitioner further submitted
that Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP was void as it was vague,
uncertain and ambiguous. He submitted that as the said Clause is
vague and uncertain, it did not provide a level playing field in view
of its uncertainties. The non-providing of a level playing field
amongst the bidders on account of uncertain terms set out in the
tender results in violation of Article 14 of the Constitution and in
that regard referred to the judgment of the Supreme Court in the
case of Reliance Energy Ltd. and Another Vs. Maharashtra State
Road Development Corporation Ltd. and Others reported in (2007)
8 SCC 1 and specifically to Paragraph No.38 of the said judgment.
It is therefore the submission of the learned Senior counsel that
Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP lacked legal certainty on account of
its
vagueness
or
subjectivity
resulting
in
unequal
and
discriminatory treatment for which the said Clause be declared to
Page No.# 20/62
be violation of Article 14 of the Constitution and accordingly struck
down.
26.
The learned Senior counsel further submitted that the
Petitioner duly admits the 2 x 2 lane bridge with footpath across
River Ganga between Sultanganj (Bhagalpur District) and Aguwani
Ghat (Khagaria District) in the State of Bihar resulted in
unforeseeable and accidental collapse of parts of the few spans.
The learned Senior counsel submitted that the cause of the
collapse is yet to be ascertained. Under such circumstances,
barring the Petitioner to participate in the present tender process
amounts
to
blacklisting
the
Petitioner
by
the
Respondent
Authorities. and as such, Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP is liable to
be set aside and quashed. In that regard, the learned Senior
counsel referred to the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case
of Blue Dreamz Advertising Private Limited Vs. Kolkata Municipal
Corporation and Others reported in (2024) 15 SCC 264 and
specifically to Paragraph Nos. 24 to 26.
27.
The
learned
Senior
counsel
further
submitted
that
incorporation of Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 also violates the principles of
natural justice inasmuch as without an opportunity being given to
the bidder, straightaway a bidder is not allowed to compete. The
Page No.# 21/62
learned Senior counsel submitted that the Clause violates the
bidder's right to explain which is a facet of the principles of natural
justice. In that regard, the learned Senior counsel referred to the
judgment of the Division Bench in the case of Atlanta Limited Vs.
Union of India and Another reported in (2018) SCC OnLine Del
8269 and specifically referred to Paragraph Nos.25, 26 and 27 of
the said judgment.
28. The learned Senior counsel further submitted that the act on
the part of the Respondent Authorities to technically disqualify the
Petitioner on the ground of non-compliance with Clause 2.2.2.2
cannot be also sustained in law inasmuch as, the Petitioner has
more than requisite financial capacity as its net worth being
Rs.1124.58 crores as on the date of bid submission which is
substantially more than the required net worth in terms with
Clause 2.2.2.2 of the said RFP being Rs.75.43 crores. It was further
mentioned by the learned Senior counsel that the Petitioner is not
required to submit the audited Annual Reports for the year 202425 in terms with Clause 2.2.2.7.ii of the said RFP which allowed the
bidders to submit an undertaking in the circumstances the audited
Annual Reports are prepared prior to the date of submission of the
bid. The learned Senior counsel submitted that since the bid due
date was 27.08.2025 and the Petitioner had time till 30.09.2025 to
Page No.# 22/62
prepare and file its audited financial statements, the Petitioner had
submitted its net worth certificate for the financial year 2023-24
along with its financial statement for the preceding five years and
had also given undertaking in this regard in compliance to Clause
2.2.2.7.ii of the RFP.
29. The learned Senior Counsel further submitted that the act on
the part of the Respondent Authorities to make the Petitioner
technically non-responsive suffers from malice in law inasmuch as
the Respondent Authorities knew very well that in view of Clause
2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP being unconstitutional and being the
subject matter of the first writ petition, they could not have solely
rejected the Petitioner’s bid on the said Clause and as such
resorted to reject the Petitioner’s bid without application of mind.
The learned Senior Counsel therefore submitted that the action on
the part of the Respondents would come within the ambit of malice
in law and thereby violative of Article 14 and 19 of the Constitution
of India. It is also the contention of the learned Senior counsel that
the Respondents have considered the Petitioner’s bid with a
preconceived mind to reject the Petitioner on technical evaluation
itself.
30. Mr. K. Gogoi, the learned CGC appearing on behalf of the
Page No.# 23/62
Respondent Authorities submitted that the revised RFP was issued
on 23.07.2025 giving five days time to the bidders to submit their
technical and financial bid i.e. within 14:30 hours of 28.07.2025.
The reason being that on 19.05.2025, the RFP was issued
containing various terms and conditions. Various intending bidders
had submitted representations, including the Petitioner herein. On
the basis of the said representations, the Respondent Authorities
held a Pre Bid Meeting with all the bidders. The Petitioner was very
much present in the said Pre Bid Meeting and thereupon various
clarifications were issued in respect to the queries made by the
various bidders, which is Annexure 6 to the writ petition being
WP(C) No.5051/2025. The learned CGC submitted that the
Petitioner sought for deletion of Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP
understanding properly its ambit to the effect that the Petitioner
would not be able to participate if the said clause remained. In that
regard he referred to the representation dated 31.05.2025
submitted by the Petitioner and more particularly Paragraph Nos. 5
and 7 of the said representation. The learned CGC further
submitted that the Respondent Authorities were not inclined to
delete the said Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP but rather reduced
the period from 5 years to 3 years. It is therefore submitted that
the stand taken by the Petitioner in both the writ petitions that
Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP as well as the clarification is vague
Page No.# 24/62
and uncertain is nothing but an afterthought for which the instant
proceedings are nothing but an utter abuse of the process of the
Court.
31. The learned CGC further submitted that the submission so
made by the learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioner that on
account of force majeure also a bidder would be disqualified is
totally misconceived inasmuch as it was clarified that the said
Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP would only be applicable if there
was a collapse of the Superstructure/Substructure on account of
design failure or quality related failure of the permanent structure.
Therefore, the submission so made that the Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of
the RFP is vague, uncertain and indefinite is totally misconceived.
The learned CGC also submitted that the Petitioner very well knows
that the collapse of the bridge over the river Ganga in the State of
Bihar was due to design failure which is mentioned in the order of
the learned Patna High Court dated 14.09.2023 and referred to
Paragraph No.3 of the said order.
32. The learned CGC further submitted that even a perusal of the
Undertaking given by the Petitioner at the time of submission of its
Bid do not mention that the collapse of the spans of the bridge was
on account of force majeure and now the Petitioner is trying to
Page No.# 25/62
improve its case. The learned CGC further referring to the order
dated 14.09.2023 passed by the learned Patna High Court
submitted that it is clearly mentioned that “The design would now
be redone and remodeled with modified technology” and the
Petitioner had taken up itself the liability insofar as the building the
collapsed spans with no extra cost to the Government. The learned
CGC therefore submitted that a very perusal of the said order
would show that the design was faulty which the petitioner very
well knew, else why the Petitioner would have agreed to do the job
at its own expense if it was not its fault.
33.
The learned CGC referred to various judgments of the
Supreme Court on the scope of judicial review. The judgments
relied upon were:
(i)
Air India Limited Vs. Cochin International Airport Limited and
Others reported in (2000) 2 SCC 617 and referred to paragraph
No.7.
(ii)
Jagdish Mandal Vs. State of Orissa and Others reported in
(2007) 14 SCC 517 and referred to Paragraph No.22.
(iii) Balaji Ventures Private Limited Vs. Maharashtra State Power
Generation Company Ltd. and Another reported in (2022) SCC
Page No.# 26/62
OnLine SC 1967 and referred to Paragraph Nos. 11 and 12.
(iv) Uflex Limited Vs. Government of Tamil Nadu and Others
reported in (2022) 1 SCC 165 and referred to Paragraph No.47.
(v)
BTL EPC Limited Vs. Macawber Beekay Private Limited and
Others reported in (2024) 12 SCC 614 and referred to Paragraph
Nos. 35 and 36.
34. The learned CGC further submitted that Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2
of the RFP was not only applied against the Petitioner but was
applied against everybody who wanted to participate. Various
bidders on account of the said Clause did not participate. However,
six bidders participated and after carrying out the technical
evaluation, it was only found that two bidders, namely the
Respondent No.3 and one Afcons Infrastructure Limited were
technically responsive. Under such circumstances, there cannot be
a malice in law as alleged by the Petitioner.
35. The learned CGC submitted that as regards the disqualification
of the Petitioner on the aspect pertaining to Clause 2.2.2.2, the
certificate of net worth provided by the Petitioner did not mention
anything as regards the net worth of the Petitioner for the year
2024-25. He submitted that the Petitioner only produced the net
Page No.# 27/62
worth up to the year 2023-24 only and as such, the said document
was incomplete as the bid due date was 27.08.2025 which does
not lie within three months of the preceding financial year. The
learned CGC further submitted that the submission of the net
worth of the year 2024-25 was mandatory and as the document of
the latest concluded financial year was not submitted by the
Petitioner, the financial condition was not satisfied in terms with
Clause 2.1.13 of the RFP. He therefore submitted that the
Petitioner’s submission of Annexure-3 was incomplete and hence
the Petitioner was disqualified on account of non-compliance with
the financial submission criteria as per Clause 2.2.2.2 of the RFP.
36. Mr. D. Das, the learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of
the Respondent No.3 submitted that the Petitioner herein cannot
complain about ambiguity or uncertainty of Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of
the RFP or for that matter there being no level playing field
inasmuch as the Petitioner very well knew the ambit of Clause
2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 and this aspect of the matter is further clear from the
fact that the Petitioner had submitted a representation on
31.05.2025 wherein the Petitioner sought for deletion of the said
Clause inasmuch as, without deletion of the said Clause, the
Petitioner would not be in a position to participate. He further
referred to the document enclosed as Annexure-13 (Colly) to
Page No.# 28/62
WP(C) No.5051/2025 wherein also the Petitioner requested the
Hon’ble Member Infrastructure, Railway Board for a meeting to
discuss the bar created by Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2. He further
submitted that the Petitioner was very much present in the Pre Bid
Meeting and he very well knew what was clarified in the Pre Bid
Meeting held on 23.07.2025 in respect to Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2.
37.
The learned Senior counsel further submitted that the
Petitioner very well knew that Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP shall
only be applied in the case of design failure or quality related
failure of the permanent structures. The learned Senior counsel
further referring to the undertaking so submitted by the Petitioner
dated 26.08.2025 enclosed to the additional affidavit filed in WP(C)
No.5051/2025 contended that there is not a whisper also that the
construction of the bridge in Bihar fell on account of force majeure
or it had no relation with design failure or quality related failure of
the permanent structure. The learned Senior counsel further
elaborating submitted that although there is no format provided
but there is no undertaking to the effect given that there was no
history of collapse of Superstructure/Substructure of any span of
bridge flyover via-duct Metro line work during the construction
service in last three years ending the last day of the month
previous to one in which the tender is invited. The learned Senior
Page No.# 29/62
counsel therefore submitted that as the Undertaking was not
submitted, the Respondent Authorities have rightfully rejected the
technical bid of the Petitioner.
38. The learned Senior counsel further referring to Clause 3.1.6
which is at Section 3 of the RFP with the heading “Criteria for
evaluation of the technical bid” submitted that in terms with Clause
3.1.6.1(g), the technical bid can be rejected if it contains any
condition or qualification, the very undertaking so submitted by the
Petitioner was qualified. In addition to that, the learned Senior
counsel also referred to Clause 2.1.7 of the Instruction to the
Bidders and submitted that any condition of qualification or any
other stipulation contained in the bid shall render the bid liable to
rejection as a non-responsive bid. The learned Senior counsel
submitted that the Undertaking was not only conditional but also
qualified and containing stipulations which is not in terms with
Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 and as such, the Respondents have rightly
rejected.
39. The learned Senior counsel also submitted that the Petitioner
herein admittedly had submitted the bid and thereupon challenged
Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP by filing the writ petition thereafter.
In that regard, the learned Senior counsel referred to the judgment
Page No.# 30/62
of the Supreme Court in the case of National High Speed Rail
Corporation Limited Vs. Montecarlo Limited and Another reported
in (2022) 6 SCC 401 and referred to Paragraph No.44 wherein the
Supreme Court held that once the writ Petitioner participated
having knowledge of Clause in the ITB, it was not open for the
Petitioner to challenge the same. The learned Senior counsel
therefore submitted that the Petitioner knew about Clause
2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP and participated in the tender process by
submission of the bid as is mentioned in Paragraph No.37 WP(C)
No.5051/2025 and thereupon challenged the said clause. The
learned Senior counsel submitted that in that view of the matter,
the instant writ petition on that count should be dismissed.
40. The learned Senior counsel further referred to the judgment of
the Supreme Court in the case of Afcons Infrastructure Limited Vs.
Nagpur Metro Rail Corporation Limited and Another reported in
(2016) 16 SCC 818 and more particularly to Paragraph No.15 and
submitted that as the Respondent Authorities having authored the
tender documents, they are the best person to understand and
appreciate its requirements and interpret those documents. The
learned Senior counsel further submitted that in the said judgment,
the Supreme Court further observed that even if the owner or the
employer of the project may give an interpretation to the tender
Page No.# 31/62
documents that is not acceptable to the Constitutional Courts, but
that by itself is not a reason for interfering with such interpretation.
POINTS FOR DETERMINATION:
41. The following points for determination arise in the present
proceedings:
(i)
Whether the Petitioner can challenge Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of
the RFP by filing a writ petition pursuant to submission of its bid?
(ii)
Whether Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP read with the
clarification is uncertain, vague and ambiguous thereby not
providing a level playing field?
(iii) Whether Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP is arbitrary and
malafide?
(iv) Whether Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP as framed amounts
to blacklisting?
(v)
Whether the Respondents were justified in rejecting the
technical bid of the Petitioner in terms with Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of
the RFP?
Page No.# 32/62
(vi) Whether the Respondents were justified in rejection of the
petitioner's technical bid in terms with Clause 2.2.2.2 in the facts
and circumstances of the instant case?
(vii) Whether the action on the part of the Respondents to reject
the Technical Bid of the Petitioner amounts to malice in law?
ANALYSIS AND DETERMINATION:
FIRST POINT FOR DETERMINATION:
42. The Petitioner at Paragraph No.37 of the writ petition being
WP(C) No.5051/2025 had categorically stated that the Petitioner
has submitted the bid pursuant to the revised RFP dated
23.07.2025. In other words, the filing of the writ petition i.e. WP(C)
No.5051/2025 is pursuant to the submission of the bid by the
Petitioner. A question therefore arises as to whether the Petitioner
herein
would
have
the
locus
standi
to
challenge
Clause
2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP after submission of such bid. In this
regard, this Court finds it relevant to take note of the judgment of
the Supreme Court in the case of National High Speed Rail
Corporation Limited (supra) and more particularly Paragraph No.44
which is reproduced herein under:
“44. Under the circumstances, the High Court has committed a grave error in
Page No.# 33/62
holding that Clauses 28.1 and 42.5 are patently illegal, more particularly, in the
absence of any challenge to the same and also on the ground that once the
original writ petitioner participated having knowledge of the aforesaid clauses
in ITB, thereafter it was not open for the original writ petitioner to challenge
the same. The original writ petitioner was knowing right from the very
beginning with respect to the confidentiality clause contained in Clause 28 and
that grounds on which the bids of unsuccessful bidders are not selected shall
be communicated only after a final decision to award the contract is
communicated under Clause 42. If the original writ petitioner was aggrieved
either it would not have participated and/or ought to have challenged such
clauses before participating in the tender process. Under the circumstances,
the impugned judgment and order passed by the High Court holding Clauses
28.1 and 42.5 as patently illegal cannot sustain and the same also deserves to
be quashed and set aside.”
43. From the above quoted paragraph of the judgment passed by
the Supreme Court in the case of National High Speed Rail
Corporation Limited (supra), it is clear that the intending bidder if
aggrieved by a Clause in the tender document, the bidder has to
either challenge the Clause and not participate or challenge the
Clause and thereafter participate. In the instant case, the Petitioner
clearly mentioned at Paragraph No.37 of WP(C) No.5051/2025 that
the Petitioner participated in the bid process due to time
constraint. Under such circumstances, it is the opinion of this Court
that the Petitioner cannot challenge Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the
RFP.
Page No.# 34/62
44. This Court also finds it relevant to observe that the Petitioner
knew the effect of Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP as would be
apparent
from
the
RFP
issued
on
19.05.2025
and
the
representation submitted on 31.05.2025. The Petitioner did not
challenge the said Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP but challenged
the same only after submission of the bid.
45. Under such circumstances, it is the opinion of this Court that
the Petitioner in the present facts cannot challenge Clause
2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP.
46. The above answers the first point for determination.
SECOND POINT FOR DETERMINATION:
47. The second point for determination is not needed to be
discussed in view of the opinion rendered in the first point for
determination. Be that as it may, as this Court heard the learned
Senior counsel for the Petitioner who contended that Clause
2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP suffers from vagueness, ambiguity as well
as lack of certainty, this Court finds it appropriate to deal with the
said contention.
48. Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP as it stood when the RFP was
Page No.# 35/62
issued on 19.05.2025 as well as the revised RFP issued on
23.07.2025 have already been quoted in the previous segments of
the instant judgment.
49. From a perusal of Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP as it stood
on 19.05.2025, it is clear that for the purpose of the RFP, there
should not be history of collapse of Superstructure or Substructure
of any span of bridge/flyover/via-duct/metro line work during
construction/service in the last five years ending last day of the
month previous to the one which tender is invited. An undertaking
in that regard has to be submitted along with the bid. The change
in Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP brought about by the revised
RFP is that five years was reduced to three years.
50. During the course of the hearing, the Chief Engineer, NF
Railway
was
present
and
he
had
explained
the
terms
‘Superstructure’ and ‘Substructure’. This Court finds it relevant to
briefly deal on this aspect. As per the Chief Engineer, the
Superstructure of the bridge is the entire upper portion located
above the bearings that directly carries the traffic load and spans
the distance between supports. It includes deck, girders, trusses,
parapets etc. The Chief Engineer further explained that the critical
component between the Superstructure and the Substructure are
Page No.# 36/62
the bearings. All the components below the bearings are known as
the Substructure. He explained that the Substructure of the bridge
is the entire lower component located below the bearings designed
to support the Superstructure and transfer all loads safely to the
ground. The key elements of Substructure in respect to a bridge
include abutments, piers, foundations etc.
51. There is no doubt that taking into account that both the
Petitioner and the Respondent No.3 are experienced in the
business of construction of bridges are aware of these two terms.
This aspect is further clear from the fact that the Petitioner herein
had submitted a representation on 31.05.2025 thereby requesting
the Tendering Authority that Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP should
be deleted inasmuch as if the said Clause remains, the Petitioner
having encountered unforeseeable and accidental collapse of parts
of the few spans in the bridge constructed across River Ganges
between Sultanganj (Bhagalpur District) and Aguwani Ghat
(Khagaria District) in the State of Bihar would not be able to
participate. In the previous segments of the instant judgment, this
Court had quoted Paragraph 5 and Paragraph 7 of the
representation dated 31.05.2025.
52. It is also a matter of record that in respect to the Clause
Page No.# 37/62
2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP, while the petitioner sought for deletion,
various other bidders sought for modification thereby reducing the
period of time from 5 years to 2/3 years. In that regard, a Pre Bid
Meeting was held by the Respondent Authorities with various
prospective bidders and in the said Pre Bid Meeting, various
Clauses of the RFP were taken up for consideration including
Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP. The Clarification which was given
on 23.07.2025 in respect to the query pertaining to Clause
2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP had already been quoted above. It
appears from the clarification that if the collapse of the
Superstructure/Substructure pertain to design failure or quality
related failure of permanent structure, the said aspect would only
be considered for the purpose of the said Clause. In other words,
the Tendering Authorities shall not take into consideration while
evaluating Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP if there is a collapse of
the
Superstructure/Substructure
on
account
of
any
other
circumstances except design failure or quality related failure of the
permanent structure.
The learned Senior counsel for the Petitioner submitted that
there is ambiguity and lack of uncertainty in the expression
‘permanent structure’. The said submission appears to be an
afterthought inasmuch as there is no mention in the Undertaking
Page No.# 38/62
so submitted that the spans of the bridge which collapsed in the
State of Bihar were not permanent structures.
53. The Petitioner did not submit any representation seeking any
clarification but submitted the bid. In the said bid so submitted, the
Petitioner submitted an Undertaking for the purpose of Clause
2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP that too without prejudice. Contents of the
said Undertaking is relevant and as such the same is reproduced
herein under:
“Date 26.08.2025
Without Prejudice
Sub: Construction of 2nd rail cum road bridge over river Brahmaputra including
viaduct, retaining walls, embankment and minor bridges including track work, OHE
work, signaling and telecom work, commissioning of stations and general work
between Agthori and Kamakhya Station from km 393.980 to km 401.120.
UNDERTAKING
That
the
Bidder
refers
to
Clause
1396714/2025/O/O/DY.CE/CON/3/MLG/NFR
2.2.2.4(iii)(ii)2
tender
of
the
RFP
no.CE-CON-AK-EPC-2025-02,
and at the outset, without prejudice to all rights, has to contend as under:
It is the Bidder’s firm submission that Clause-2.2.2.4(iii)(ii)2 is void inter alia under
Ss 29, 23, 24, 65 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, simultaneously being
Page No.# 39/62
discriminatory and also violative of Constitutional considerations binding on the
Government Contracts. The Bidder’s e-mail representations dated 31.05.2025 and
05.07.2025, have also not been responded by the Competent Authority within the
Railways.
That the qualification requirement under the above-referred Clause 2.2.2.4(iii)(ii)2
read with the remarks in reply to Pre-Bid Query Sr. No.22 being: “The Clarification
has been incorporated in revised RFP. The Collapse of Superstructure/Substructure
pertain to Design failure or quality related failure of permanent structure would be
considered in this clause only”; is patently ambiguous, unenforceable and merits
declaration as being void under S 29 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 and also
being violative of Articles 14, 19, 21 and 32 of the Constitution of India.
Subject to the foregoing, it is disclosed in respect of unforeseen, unforeseeable
collapse of part of spans on 30.04.2022, 04.06.2023 in respect of “..Sultanganj –
Aguwanighat..” project: under instructions of the Employer therein (the BRPNNL)
and as per Order dated 14.09.2023 of the Hon’ble High Court of Judicature at Patna
under PIL (bearing Case No.CWP No.8209 of 2023) Petition, re-execution of collapse
part of spans work by the Bidder is in progress under the Force Majeure Clause 21.6
read with the Contract Agreement as a whole. Finally, the matter in respect thereof
is to be resolved within the modalities of the Contract Agreement therein as a
whole.
Accordingly, undertaking is given. This undertaking is without prejudice to all the
rights of the Bidder, including to avail the Constitutional remedies and interim relief
simultaneously to prevent possibility of declaration of non-responsive status to the
Bidder by the doctored misuse of Clause-2.2.2.4(iii)(ii)2 by the Competent Authority.
For SPS Construction India Pvt. Ltd.
Page No.# 40/62
(Deepak Singla)
Director”
54. A perusal of the above quoted Undertaking would not reveal
the reason why the petitioner has referred to Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2
of the RFP as well as the clarification so given on 23.07.2025 to be
patently ambiguous, unenforceable and is required to be declared
void. There is no mention in the Undertaking that the bridge which
was constructed by the Petitioner in the State of Bihar over the
River Ganges wherein admittedly parts of spans collapsed on
30.04.2022
and
04.06.2023
have
nothing
to
do
with
Superstructure/Substructure of the bridge or for that matter
anything to do with design failure or quality related failure of the
permanent structures.
55. In this regard, this Court now finds it relevant to take note of
the judgment relied upon by the learned Senior counsel appearing
on behalf of the Petitioner i.e. in the case of Reliance Energy Ltd.
(supra) wherein reference was drawn to Paragraph No.38. The said
paragraph being relied upon is quoted herein under:
“38. When tenders are invited, the terms and conditions must indicate with
legal certainty, norms and benchmarks. This “legal certainty” is an important
aspect of the rule of law. If there is vagueness or subjectivity in the said
norms it may result in unequal and discriminatory treatment. It may violate
Page No.# 41/62
doctrine of “level playing field”.”
56.
The question therefore arises as to whether Clause
2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP lacks legal certainty and devoid of norms
and benchmarks. In the opinion of this Court, Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2
of the RFP does not lack legal certainty or is devoid of norms and
benchmarks. It is also the opinion of this Court that taking into
account the Petitioner's stand taken in the representation
submitted on 31.05.2025, it cannot be said that the Petitioner was
not able to discern the meaning of the said Clause. The clarification
which was given on 23.07.2025 further clarifies that for the
purpose of the said Clause, collapse of the Superstructure or
Substructure would be considered if it relates to design failure or
quality related failure of the permanent structure. Under such
circumstances, it is therefore the opinion of this Court Clause
2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP cannot be said to be vague, void or
ambiguous on the ground of lacking legal certainty. The said
Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP cannot also be said to be lacking
norms or benchmarks. The principle laid down by the Supreme
Court in the case of Reliance Energy Ltd. (supra) cannot be applied
to the present facts. At the cost of repetition, this Court opines that
Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 read with the clarification given on 23.07.2025
is clear, unambiguous and definite.
Page No.# 42/62
57. This decides the second point for determination.
THIRD POINT FOR DETERMINATION:
58. Let this Court now deal with the third point for determination
as to whether Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP is arbitrary and
malafide.
At the outset, it is observed that the Petitioner cannot challenge
the Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP as arbitrary and malafide after
having submitted the bid.
Be that as it may, this Court would deal with the said point for
determination as the learned Senior counsel had contended that
the Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP is arbitrary and malafide.
59. The Respondent Authorities have invited RFP from eligible
bidders for construction of a rail cum road bridge over the River
Brahmaputra at a huge estimated project cost of approximately
Rs.1508 crores. The Respondent Authorities being the Tendering
Authority has the right as well as expertise to decide the terms of
the RFP. The Supreme Court in the case of Jagdish Mandal (supra)
observed that such contracts are commercial transactions. The
Tendering Authority while stipulating the terms of the RFP decided
Page No.# 43/62
to insert a Clause debarring those bidders who have history of
collapse
of
Superstructure/Substructure
of
any
span
of
bridge/flyover/via-duct/metro link work during construction/service
in the last 3 (three) years ending last day of the month previous to
one in which tender is invited. The clarification which was given on
23.07.2025 further made it clear that the said Clause would only be
considered for cases where Superstructure/Substructure had
collapsed due to design failure or quality related failure of the
permanent structure. The clarification made it therefore clear that
if there is collapse of Superstructure/Substructure on account of
force majeure, the same would not be considered for the purpose
of Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP.
60.
The question therefore is can it be said that Clause
2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP is arbitrary or malafide. At this stage, this
Court finds it relevant to take note of the judgment of the Supreme
Court in the case of Air India Ltd. (supra) wherein the Supreme
Court observed that when a contract is awarded by the State, it is
essentially a commercial transaction. In arriving at the decision,
considerations which are paramount are commercial consideration.
The State can choose its own method to arrive at such decision
and it can fix its own terms of invitation to the tender and that is
not open to judicial scrutiny. In fact, more than 30 years ago, in
Page No.# 44/62
the case of Tata Cellular Vs. Union of India reported in (1994) 6
SCC 651, the Supreme Court had categorically observed that the
terms of invitation to tender cannot be open to judicial scrutiny
because invitation to tender is in the realm of contract.
Under such circumstances, the petitioner who challenges Clause
2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP has to set up a case of arbitrariness and
malafide which would shock the conscience of this Court. Merely
stating that the reason for having reduced the period from 5 years
to 3 years in order to accommodate some bidders would not
suffice taking into consideration that the Tendering Authority has
the discretion to do so. In fact, entering in such dispute in exercise
of the powers of judicial review would tantamount to transgression
upon the authority of the Tendering Authorities.
61. Considering the above, it is the opinion of this Court that the
Petitioner had failed to demonstrate how Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of
the RFP is arbitrary or malafide.
62. The above answers the third point for determination.
FOURTH POINT FOR DETERMINATION:
63. The fourth point for determination has been formulated on the
Page No.# 45/62
basis of the submissions made by the learned Senior counsel for
the Petitioner that Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP amounts to
blacklisting. In that regard, the learned Senior counsel has referred
to the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of Blue Dreamz
Advertising Private Limited (supra) and specifically emphasized
upon paragraph Nos. 24 to 26. While dealing with the present
point for determination, it is also apposite to take note of the
submission of the learned Senior counsel insofar as Clause 3.1.4 of
the RFP inasmuch as it is the submission of the learned Senior
counsel that the Respondent Authorities ought to have sought
clarification from the Petitioner before rejecting the Technical Bid of
the Petitioner. In addition to the above, this Court while dealing
with the present point for determination would also deal with the
submission made by the learned Senior counsel for the Petitioner
that Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP violates the principles of
natural justice. In that regard, the learned Senior counsel for the
Petitioner referred to the judgment of the learned Division Bench of
the Delhi High Court in the case of Atlanta Limited (supra) and
specifically laid emphasis upon the observation made at Paragraph
No.25 of the said judgment.
64. This Court in the previous segments of the instant judgment
has detailed out the facts. When the RFP was issued on
Page No.# 46/62
19.05.2025, options were open to various bidders including the
Petitioner to seek clarification and/or submit representations. The
Petitioner admittedly submitted representation on 31.05.2025
whereby the Petitioner sought for deletion of Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2
of the RFP. In the said representation, there is no mention that the
Petitioner did not understand the scope and ambit of Clause
2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP rather the Petitioner stated that the said
Clause would debar the Petitioner from participating in view of
collapse of few spans of the bridge constructed by the Petitioner
over the River Ganges in the State of Bihar.
65. The materials on record further show that the Respondent
Authorities had a Pre Bid Meeting amongst various intending
bidders including the Petitioner who participated in the Pre Bid
Meeting. After that, clarifications were issued on 23.07.2025 which
is enclosed as Annexure-6 to the writ Petition being WP(C)
No.5051/2025. Insofar as Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP, it was
clarified that while considering the said Clause, only collapse of
Substructure/ Superstructure on account of design failure or quality
related failure of permanent structure would be considered.
66.
In the backdrop of the above, this Court has failed to
understand on what basis, the learned Senior counsel for the
Page No.# 47/62
Petitioner had submitted that Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP
amounts to blacklisting. It appears most likely that the Petitioner
herein had failed to understand the difference between blacklisting
and a Clause incorporated in a tender by the Tendering Authority
seeking certain eligibility conditions. The law laid down by the
Supreme Court in the judgment rendered in the case of Blue
Dreamz Advertising Private Limited (supra) under no circumstances
would be applicable to the facts of the instant case as the case
before the Supreme Court was a simple case of blacklisting and
had nothing to do with the Tendering Authority incorporating
requisite eligibility conditions. In this regard, this Court finds it
pertinent to observe that the Supreme Court in the case of Uflex
Limited (supra) had categorically observed that in every tender,
there are certain qualifying parameters whether it be technology or
turnover. The Court cannot in exercise of judicial review sit over in
judgment what should be the turnover required for an entity to
participate. The said principle of law squarely applies to the
present case inasmuch as the Tendering Authority herein is
competent to set out the eligibility conditions. In the present case,
the Tendering Authority had set out various eligibility conditions
including Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP. The question is whether
the intending bidder can question the eligibility conditions if it does
not suit the intending bidder. The answer would be in the negative
Page No.# 48/62
unless and until the eligibility condition(s) are grossly arbitrary.
Under such circumstances, Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP in
the opinion of this Court does not amount to blacklisting.
67. Let this Court now deal with the contention that Clause
2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP violates the principle of natural justice. It
is relevant to take note of the judgment of the Supreme Court in
the case of Jagdish Mandal (supra) wherein the Supreme Court at
Paragraph No.22 categorically observed that principles of equity
and natural justice stay at a distance while evaluating tenders and
awarding contracts as such transactions essentially are commercial
transactions. Paragraph No.22 of the said judgment is reproduced
herein below:
“22.
Judicial review of administrative action is intended to prevent
arbitrariness, irrationality, unreasonableness, bias and mala fides. Its purpose
is to check whether choice or decision is made “lawfully” and not to check
whether choice or decision is “sound”. When the power of judicial review is
invoked in matters relating to tenders or award of contracts, certain special
features should be borne in mind. A contract is a commercial transaction.
Evaluating tenders and awarding contracts are essentially commercial
functions. Principles of equity and natural justice stay at a distance. If the
decision relating to award of contract is bona fide and is in public interest,
courts will not, in exercise of power of judicial review, interfere even if a
procedural aberration or error in assessment or prejudice to a tenderer, is
made out. The power of judicial review will not be permitted to be invoked to
Page No.# 49/62
protect private interest at the cost of public interest, or to decide contractual
disputes. The tenderer or contractor with a grievance can always seek
damages in a civil court. Attempts by unsuccessful tenderers with imaginary
grievances, wounded pride and business rivalry, to make mountains out of
molehills of some technical/procedural violation or some prejudice to self, and
persuade courts to interfere by exercising power of judicial review, should be
resisted. Such interferences, either interim or final, may hold up public works
for years, or delay relief and succour to thousands and millions and may
increase the project cost manifold. Therefore, a court before interfering in
tender or contractual matters in exercise of power of judicial review, should
pose to itself the following questions:
(i)
Whether the process adopted or decision made by the authority is
mala fide or intended to favour someone;
OR
Whether the process adopted or decision made is so arbitrary and irrational
that the court can say: “the decision is such that no responsible authority
acting reasonably and in accordance with relevant law could have reached”;
(ii)
Whether public interest is affected.
If the answers are in the negative, there should be no interference
under Article 226. Cases involving blacklisting or imposition of penal
consequences on a tenderer/contractor or distribution of State largesse
(allotment of sites/shops, grant of licences, dealerships and franchises) stand
on a different footing as they may require a higher degree of fairness in
action.”
68. Now let this Court take into consideration the submission of
the learned Senior counsel for the Petitioner that if an opportunity
Page No.# 50/62
would have been given by invoking Clause 3.14 of the RFP, the
Petitioner could have explained that reason for the collapse of the
spans of the bridge over the River Ganges in the State of Bihar
which is yet to be ascertained. It is pertinent to observe that the
revised RFP was issued on 23.07.2025 after the initial RFP had
been issued on 19.05.2025. The Petitioner after the issuance of the
initial
RFP
on
19.05.2025
submitted
a
representation
on
31.05.2025. Opportunity was provided to all bidders in the Pre Bid
Meeting wherein the Petitioner participated and thereupon
clarifications were issued on 23.07.2025 as well as the revised RFP
on 23.07.2025. Under such circumstances, it does not lie in the
mouth of the Petitioner to submit that principles of natural justice
was not adhered to, irrespective of the fact that principles of equity
and natural justice have no role to play in the evaluation of tenders
and awarding of contracts, which is the settled proposition of law.
69. The judgment in the case of Atlanta Limited (supra) rendered
by the learned Division Bench of the Delhi High Court is also not
applicable to the facts of the instant case.
70. Under such circumstances, it is therefore the opinion of this
Court that neither Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP amounts to
blacklisting nor it violates the principles of natural justice. It is also
Page No.# 51/62
the opinion of this Court that the Petitioner herein having already
submitted the bid prior to filing of the writ petition cannot raise the
issue
that
Clause
2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2
of
the
RFP
amounts
to
blacklisting/violates the principles of natural justice.
71. This answers the fourth point for determination.
FIFTH POINT FOR DETERMINATION:
72. In the previous segments of the instant judgment, this Court
has quoted Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the revised RFP. This Court has
also quoted the Undertaking which was submitted by the Petitioner
in pursuance to the Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP. A perusal of
the said Undertaking under no circumstances can be said to be an
Undertaking in terms with Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP. The
Respondent Authorities being the Tendering Authority have also
viewed it in that manner. In this regard, this Court finds it relevant
to reproduce paragraph Nos. 35 and 36 of the judgment in the
case of BTL EPC Limited (supra).
“35. It is settled law that in contracts involving complex technical issues, the
Court should exercise restraint in exercising the power of judicial review. Even
if a party to the contract is “State” within the meaning of Article 12 of the
Constitution, and as such, is amenable to the writ jurisdiction of the High
Court or the Supreme Court, the Court should not readily interfere in
commercial or contractual matters. This principle has been reiterated in a
Page No.# 52/62
recent judgment of this Court. J.B. Pardiwala, J., speaking for the Bench in
Tata Motors Ltd. v. Brihan Mumbai Electric Supply & Transport Undertaking
held: (SCC p. 18, para 50)
“50.
This Court being the guardian of fundamental rights is duty-
bound to interfere when there is arbitrariness, irrationality, mala
fides and bias. However, this Court has cautioned time and again
that courts should exercise a lot of restraint while exercising their
powers of judicial review in contractual or commercial matters. This
Court is normally loathe to interfere in contractual matters unless a
clear-cut case of arbitrariness or mala fides or bias or irrationality is
made out. One must remember that today many public sector
undertakings compete with the private industry. The contracts
entered into between private parties are not subject to scrutiny
under writ jurisdiction. No doubt, the bodies which are State within
the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution are bound to act fairly
and are amenable to the writ jurisdiction of superior courts but this
discretionary power must be exercised with a great deal of restraint
and caution. The courts must realise their limitations and the havoc
which needless interference in commercial matters can cause. In
contracts involving technical issues the courts should be even more
reluctant because most of us in Judges’ robes do not have the
necessary expertise to adjudicate upon technical issues beyond our
domain. The courts should not use a magnifying glass while
scanning the tenders and make every small mistake appear like a
big blunder. In fact, the courts must give fair play in the joints to
the government and public sector undertakings in matters of
contract. Courts must also not interfere where such interference will
cause unnecessary loss to the public exchequer.”
36.
The Court ought to defer to the discretion of the tender inviting
Page No.# 53/62
authority which, by reason of having authored the tender documents, is best
placed to interpret their terms. The Courts ought not to sit as courts of appeal
but review the decision-making process and examine arbitrariness or mala
fides, if any.”
73. The above quoted paragraphs clearly show that the Court
ought to defer to the discretion of the Tender Inviting Authority
which by reason of having authored the tender documents is best
placed to interpret their terms. In the instant case, as the
Respondent Authorities upon perusal of the Undertaking were of
the opinion that the said Undertaking was not in terms with Clause
2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP. This Court cannot sit over the said opinion
of the Tendering Authority.
It is therefore the opinion of this Court that the Respondents
were justified in rejecting the technical bid of the Petitioner in
terms with Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP.
74. This answers the fifth point for determination.
SIXTH POINT FOR DETERMINATION:
75. The sixth point for determination relates to the rejection of the
Petitioner’s technical bid in terms with Clause 2.2.2.2 of the RFP.
Page No.# 54/62
76. Clause 2.2.2.2 relates to financial capacity. It stipulates as
under:
“2.2.2.2.
Financial Capacity: The Bidder shall have a minimum Net
Worth (the “Financial Capacity”) of amount equals to 5% (Five percent)
of the Estimated Project Cost at the close of the preceding Financial Year.”
77.
This Court has taken note of Annexure-13 to WP(C)
No.6625/2025 wherein it is mentioned that the Petitioner’s bid was
held to be non-responsive in terms with Clause 2.2.2.2 and Clause
2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP. In this regard, this Court had perused the
Minutes of the Technical Committee which were produced before
this Court pursuant to the order passed by this Court on
17.12.2025. At Serial No.4 of the Minutes of the Technical
Committee insofar as the Petitioner is concerned, it is mentioned
that the Petitioner had submitted Financial Capacity in the
prescribed format vide Annexure-III of Appendix-IA with the details
of the Petitioner’s Bankers and their certified and audited
documents which was signed by Jaslin Kaur for Subhash Vipin &
Co. CA. It is also mentioned that the total net worth at the end of
the financial year came to 1124.58 crores. Further to that, the
Technical Committee also mentioned that the net worth should
have been submitted for the financial year 2024-25. However the
same was not submitted. The Petitioner had only submitted for
Page No.# 55/62
financial year up to 2023-2024 from 2019-20. Serial No.4 of the
Minutes of the Tender Committee insofar as the case of the
Petitioner is concerned is reproduced herein below:
S.N.
Test
Responsiveness Responsive Remarks
Documents
Clause 3.1.6.1(a) of RFP Yes
(Annex-III of AppendixIA : Financial Capacity of
the Bidder)
The Bidder has submitted “Financial
Capacity” in prescribed format vide
Annex-III of Appendix-IA with the
details of Bidder’s Bankers. (Doc 12,
Page 24), and their certified and audited
documents which is signed by Jaslin
Kaur for Subhash Vipin & Co. CA (Firm
registration no-012898N against UDIN
No-25539633BMIJXM3162 Total Net
worth at the end of Financial year
comes to 1124.58 Cr. (Doc 22)
The Net worth Should be submitted
for Financial Year 2024-25: Not
Submitted. Bidder has submitted for
Financial Year Upto 2023-24 from 201920.
78. The above quoted portion at Serial No.4 of the Minutes of the
Technical Committee would also show that insofar as Clause
3.1.6.1.(a) of the RFP, it was observed that the Petitioner’s bid was
responsive. The copy of the Minutes of the Technical Committee so
produced before this Court and more particularly in relation to the
Petitioner is kept on record and marked with the letter “X”.
79. A further perusal of the Minutes of the Technical Committee
Page No.# 56/62
insofar as the Petitioner is concerned would show that the
Technical Committee observed that the Petitioner did not fulfill the
Technical Capacity of eligibility criteria as per Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2
of the RFP. Therefore, the Technical Committee of the Respondents
only recommended that the Petitioner’s Technical Bid is required to
be rejected as per Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP only.
80.
The
Technical
Committee
further
forwarded
their
recommendations to the Competent Authority to accept, reject or
modify
the
Competent
Technical
Authority
recommendation
with
Committee’s
accepted
certain
the
recommendation.
Technical
observations.
The
The
Committee’s
Competent
Authority also further stated that the Petitioner did not have the
technical eligibility as the financial statement of 2024-25 [3.1.6.1.
(a)] was not submitted. The relevant portion of the observations
made by the competent authority is reproduced herein under:
“Decision : TCR Accepted
TCR Accepted. Following observations made. 1. Dineshchandra R. Agarwal
Infracon Pvt. Ltd., Ahmedabad:-Non-Responsive because (i) Appendix 1B
[3.1.6.1(a)] Not submitted. (ii) The authorized person of Gammon for JV has
not signed the JV agreement [3.1.6.1.(e)]. (iii) Financial statement for 2024-25
[3.1.6.1.(a)] not submitted. 2. PNC Infratech Ltd., Agra – BBJ not eligible
because (i) MOA, AOA and Bard resolution not submitted as per [3.1.6.1(a)].
Page No.# 57/62
Responsiveness in question (ii) Technical eligibility as per Clause 2.2.2.4.(iii) no
work for 35% cost (528 cr) for 76.2m span or well foundation is submitted.
(iii) For 10% criteria for JV partner BBJ has submitted two (02) works, but no
JV agreement is submitted as per para 2.2.2.4.(iii), Note 1. 3. Rall Vikas Nigam
Limited, New Delhi Technical Eligibility Not fulfilled. (i) History of collapse
undertaking not submitted, failed in 2.2.2.4.(iii)(ii)2. 4. SPS construction India
Private Limited Panchkula Non-responsive and Technical Eligibility not (i)
Financial statement for 2024-25 [3.1.6.1.(a)] not submitted. (ii) History of
collapse undertaking not submitted, failed in 2.2.2.4(iii)(ii).2. 5. Larsen and
Tubro Limited – Eligible 6. Afcons Infrastructure Limited Mumbai – Eligible
project code. Total Cost is given by the client certificate at DOC-16, page 1 &
page 2, and by Auditor at DOC-6 page 5 & page 6. Payment in last five years
is more than 10% of estimated cost and thus this is eligible project. The
bridge is having steel OWG multiple spans more than 76.2m on client signed
drawing DOC-16, page 3. This qualifies OWG criteria. Well Foundation is
already covered in project code.”
81. Therefore, the question therefore arises as to whether the
Petitioner had the financial capacity in terms with Clause 2.2.2.2
which has to be adjudged in terms with clause 3.1.6.1.(a) of the
RFP. The Petitioner admittedly submitted the documents for the
financial year 2019-20 to 2023-24 but did not submit for the
financial year 2024-25.
82. In this regard, it is pertinent to take note of the requirement
of the documents to be submitted for financial capacity. Clause
2.2.2.7 of the RFP deals with Submission in support of Financial
Page No.# 58/62
Capacity. The Sub-Clauses (i), (ii) and (iii) of Clause 2.2.2.7 of the
RFP being relevant is reproduced herein under:
“2.2.2.7:
i.
Submission in support of Financial Capacity
The Technical Bid shall be accompanied by the Audited Annual Reports
which includes Balance sheets and P&L Accounts of the Bidder (of each
member in case of a Consortium/Joint Venture and also of associates if
any, whose financial capacity is being claimed) for the last 5 (five)
Completed Financial Years, preceding the year in which the Bid is
submitted. Any certificate issued by Statutory Auditor/CA must include
UDIN.
ii.
In case the annual accounts for the latest financial year are not audited
and therefore the Bidder cannot make it available, the Bidder shall give an
undertaking to this effect and the statutory auditor shall certify the same.
In such a case, the Bidder shall provide the Audited Annual Reports for 5
(five) years preceding the year for which the Audited Annual Report is not
being provided.
iii.
The Bidder must establish the minimum Net Worth specified in Clause
2.2.2.2 and provide details as per format at Annex-III of Appendix-IA.”
83. A perusal of the above quoted Sub-Clause (ii) of Clause
2.2.2.7 of the RFP stipulates that in case the Annual Accounts for
the latest financial year are not audited and therefore the bidder
cannot make it available, the bidder shall give an undertaking to
that effect and the Statutory Auditor shall certify the same. It is
Page No.# 59/62
also the requirement that the bidder shall provide the Audited
Annual Reports for five years preceding the year for which the
Audited Annual Report is not being provided.
84. It is seen from Annexure-7 of WP(C) No.6625/2025 that an
Undertaking was given by the Director of the Petitioner Company
and certified by the Chartered Accountant. This Court can very well
take judicial notice that for the purpose of filing the audited returns
for the year 2024-25, the last date was 30.09.2025 and as the
Petitioner’s financial statement for the financial year 2024-25 was
not prepared as on 27.08.2025, the Petitioner had submitted the
certificate which was certified by the Chartered Accountant on
22.08.2025. Therefore, in the opinion of this Court though the
Audited Annual Reports for the financial year 2024-25 was not
submitted by the Petitioner but as the Petitioner had submitted the
Undertaking which is Annexure-7 to the writ petition being WP(C)
No.6625/2025, the Petitioner’s bid could not have been rejected in
terms with Clause 2.2.2.2 or Clause 3.1.6.1.(a) of the RFP.
85. This answers the sixth point for determination.
SEVENTH POINT FOR DETERMINATION:
86. The present point for determination arises on the issue as to
Page No.# 60/62
whether the actions on the part of the Respondents to reject the
Petitioner’s Technical Bid as non-responsive constitutes malice in
law. The learned Senior counsel submitted that the rejection of the
Petitioner’s Technical Bid in spite of the order passed by this Court
on 01.09.2025 amount to malice in law. He submitted that in view
of the order dated 01.09.2025, the Respondent Authorities knew
that the Petitioner could not have been held to be technically nonresponsive on account of Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP and as
such the Respondent Authorities have resorted to reject the
Petitioner’s Technical Bid on the basis of Clause 2.2.2.2 of the RFP
which under no circumstances would be applicable for rejecting the
Petitioner’s Technical Bid.
87. This Court finds it pertinent to observe that vide an order
dated 01.09.2025, the learned Coordinate Bench of this Court in
the interim directed the Respondents to consider the bid of the
Petitioner which shall be subject to further orders to be passed by
this Court.
88. A perusal of the order dated 01.09.2025 would not show that
this Court put any restraint upon the Respondent Authorities to
proceed with the evaluation of the bids submitted. The said order
dated 01.09.2025 only directed that the Petitioner’s bid should also
Page No.# 61/62
be taken into consideration along with other bids. The Clause
2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2
of
the
RFP
was
not
stayed.
Under
such
circumstances, the Respondent Authorities considered the bid of
the Petitioner as would be apparent from a perusal of the Minutes
of the Technical committee as well as the observations made by
the Competent Authority. It is also necessary to observe that this
Court only held that the consideration shall be subject to further
orders of this Court. The order dated 31.10.2025 by the learned
Coordinate Bench also makes it clear that the decision to hold the
Petitioner’s bid as technically non-responsive would be subject to
the orders passed in WP(C) No.5051/2025.
89. Under such circumstances, merely because one of the grounds
of rejection being not a permissible ground, it cannot be said that
the decision to hold the Petitioner non-responsive on the ground of
non-compliance with Clause 2.2.2.4.iii.ii.2 of the RFP suffers from
malice in law.
90. The above answers the seventh point for determination.
CONCLUSIONS:
91. Accordingly, this Court is of the opinion that both the writ
petitions have to fail for which both the writ petition stands
Page No.# 62/62
dismissed.
92. There shall be no order as to costs.
Bijoy
Saha
Digitally signed
by Bijoy Saha
Date: 2026.02.19
10:45:21 +05'30'
Comparing Assistant
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review