Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:2370-DB
Digitally
signed by
ANURADHA
ANURADHA TIWARI
TIWARI
Date:
2026.01.15
17:05:02
+0530
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
CRMP No. 148 of 2026
Sourabh Singh Alias Saurbh Singh S/o A.K. Singh Aged About 35 Years
(Proprietor Of Om Sai Construction And Supplier) R/o Shiva Kripa Plot
No. 142/124, Pahirawa Boutique Road, Behind Jila Chikitsalaya, Vidyut
Nagar, Tehsil And District - Durg
... Petitioner
versus
State of Chhattisgarh Through Police Station - Sanaud, District - Balod
Chhattisgarh
... Respondent
(Cause-title taken from Case Information System)
For Petitioner
: Mr. Sandeep Jha, Advocate
For State/Respondent
: Mr. Priyank Rathi, Government Advocate
Hon'ble Shri Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Hon'ble Shri Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, Judge
Order on Board
Per Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
15.01.2026
1.
Heard Mr. Sandeep Jha, learned counsel for the petitioner as well
as Mr. Priyank Rathi, learned Government Advocate, appearing
for the State/respondent.
2.
The petitioner has filed the instant petition with the following
relief :-
“It is therefore, prayed that this Hon'ble Court may
kindly be pleased to allow the instant petition and
quash/set-aside the impugned FIR No. 0045/2025
registered on dated 09.06.2025 at P.S Sanauad
for the offence u/s 106 (1) of B.N.S. 2023, the
cognizance order passed by learned JMFC,
Balod (C.G.)on dated 04.11.2025 and the entire
criminal
proceeding
2382/2025)
initiated
(Criminal
against
the
Case
No.
petitioners
pursuant to FIR No. 0045/2025 and charge sheet,
in the interest of justice.”
3.
Brief facts of the case, in a nutshell are that on 07.06.2025, the
police conducted inquest proceedings after examining witnesses
namely Satanand Nishad, Rakesh Kumar Yadav, Bikhari Lal
Nishad, Sunil Kumar Nishad and Nemichand Sewta. As per the
inquest report dated 07.06.2025 at about 04:00 PM, the deceased
Yugal Kishore, while fitting an insulator on a forepin and
descending from the electric pole, met with an accident when the
PCC pole tilted and broke from about six inches above the
ground, falling over him. The deceased sustained severe waist
injuries and subsequently succumbed. The prosecution alleged
that the incident occurred due to supply of sub-standard material
by the contractor/petitioner and further alleged failure on the part
of the supervisor, Kishore Kumar, to provide safety tools. The
Marg intimation/inquest report No. 09/2025 prepared under
Section 194 of BNSS records the cause of death as injury caused
by the fall of an electric pole over the deceased at Dandesra Khar,
CHC Gurur, District Balod, at about 05:45 PM. The deceased was
aged 29 years and the death was stated to be premature and
untimely.
4.
On the basis of the said incident, FIR No. 0045/2025 was
registered against the petitioner for the offence under Section
106(1) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (earlier Section 304-A
IPC). A charge-sheet was filed and the learned Chief Judicial
Magistrate, Balod took cognizance on 04.11.2025. The petitioner
received show cause notices dated 01.10.2025 and 28.10.2025
issued by the Chhattisgarh State Power Distribution Company
Limited (CSPDCL). In reply, the petitioner stated that he has been
working as a contractor for the past eight years through his
registered firm Om Sai Contractor & Supplier and that PCC poles
can be procured only from CSPDCL-approved vendors. The pole
in question was purchased from an approved vendor, Shri Bihari
Enterprises, Durg, on 22.05.2025. It was specifically averred that
the pole failed due to compromised quality supplied by the
approved vendor, which resulted in the fatal accident. Shri Bihari
Enterprises supplied 8-meter, 140 kg PCC poles under GST
Invoice No. SBE/112 dated 22.05.2025 without furnishing any
quality/testing report, despite such report being mandatory under
CSPDCL terms and conditions.
5.
During investigation, a concrete core sample of the broken PCC
pole was tested by Marshal Geo Test Laboratory (LLP), Raipur.
The test report dated 19.06.2025 revealed that though the
specified grade was M-40, the average grade of the sample was
only M-21.65, which was substantially below the prescribed
standard. The petitioner has already deposited a sum of
₹10,91,584/- before the Labour Commissioner, Durg, under
Section 8(1) of the Workmen’s Compensation Act, 1923. In Case
No. 39/EC Act/2025, the Labour Commissioner, by order dated
17.11.2025, directed disbursement of the said amount to the
dependents of the deceased.
6.
Mr. Sandeep Jha, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that
the
impugned
FIR
No.
0045/2025
is
frivolous,
vague,
misconceived and not sustainable in the eyes of law and,
therefore, deserves to be quashed. It is submitted that there is no
material on record to establish any proximate, direct or
foreseeable negligence on the part of the petitioner. Mere
occurrence of an accident at the worksite does not automatically
fasten criminal liability upon the contractor, in absence of proof
that the petitioner’s act was the causa causans of the death.
Reliance is placed upon the recent judgment of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Yuvraj Laxmilal Kanther v. State of
Maharashtra (Criminal Appeal No. 2356 of 2024, decided on
07.03.2025), wherein it has been categorically held that mere
absence of safety gear or a general allegation of negligence is
insufficient to attract criminal liability under Sections 304-A IPC /
106(1) BNS unless reckless and direct negligence is established.
7.
Mr. Jha further submitted that the petitioner was compelled to
procure PCC poles only from CSPDCL-approved vendors and,
accordingly, the pole in question was purchased from Shri Bihari
Enterprises, an approved vendor of CSPDCL. The petitioner
neither manufactured the PCC pole nor had any role in
determining its material composition or strength. Subsequent
laboratory testing clearly revealed that although the prescribed
standard was M-40, the pole strength was substantially lower
(around M-21.65 / M-24.98 N/mm²), which clearly indicates supply
of defective and sub-standard material by the approved vendor.
No quality testing report was supplied along with the GST invoice,
in blatant violation of CSPDCL’s own terms and conditions, and
no fault can be attributed to the petitioner for the same.
8.
Mr. Jha also submits that CSPDCL itself failed to undertake
quality inspection at the time of supply, as the approved vendor
did not raise any inspection call, which is the real and proximate
cause
of
the
unfortunate
incident.
Despite
this,
the
manufacturer/approved vendor of the PCC pole has not been
arrayed as an accused, even though product liability squarely lies
upon the supplier/manufacturer where the product is inherently
defective. Such liability extends even in the absence of privity of
contract, particularly when the end-user (the deceased labourer)
suffered fatal consequences.
9.
It is contended by Mr. Jha that the entire charge-sheet proceeds
on an erroneous premise that the petitioner “supplied” the
defective pole, whereas in reality he merely procured the same
from an approved vendor for execution of Work Order No. 763
dated 08.08.2025. A bare perusal of the charge-sheet further
reveals that the witness statements are verbatim and identical,
reflecting serious procedural irregularities and rendering their
evidentiary value highly doubtful.
10.
It is further contended by Mr. Jha that the petitioner has already
discharged his statutory obligation under the Employees’
Compensation Act by depositing a sum of ₹10,91,584/- before the
Learned Labour Commissioner, Durg, which has been ordered to
be disbursed to the dependents of the deceased. This clearly
demonstrates absence of any mens rea, recklessness or criminal
intent attributable to the petitioner.
11.
It is argued by Mr. Jha that the charge-sheet, FIR and
accompanying materials completely fail to disclose the essential
ingredients of negligence, actus reus or mens rea so as to
constitute an offence under Section 106(1) of BNS. No specific
evidence has been brought on record to show that the petitioner
alone was responsible for the defective PCC pole or that his
actions directly resulted in the death of the deceased.
12.
Lastly, learned counsel places reliance upon the celebrated
judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in State of Haryana v.
Bhajan Lal, 1992 Supp (1) SCC 335, and submits that the
present case squarely falls within the parameters laid down
therein. The criminal proceedings are manifestly attended with
mala fides, initiated with an ulterior motive, and are nothing but an
abuse of the process of law. If the FIR, cognizance order and
consequent criminal proceedings in Criminal Case No. 2382/2025
are not quashed at this stage, the petitioner would be subjected to
unwarranted hardship, which is wholly unsustainable in law.
13.
On the other hand, Mr. Priyank Rathi, learned Government
Advocate appearing for the State/respondent opposes the
submissions advanced by learned counsel for the petitioner and
submits that
14.
On the other hand, Mr. Priyank Rathi, learned Government
Advocate appearing for the State/respondent, opposes the
submissions advanced by learned counsel for the petitioner and
submits that the impugned FIR and the consequential criminal
proceedings are legally justified and based on cogent material
collected during investigation. It is contended that the death of the
deceased occurred during execution of official work under the
supervision and control of the petitioner–contractor, who was
responsible for ensuring supply of safe and standard material as
well as for providing adequate safety measures at the worksite.
15.
Mr. Rathi further submits that the incident, resulting in the collapse
of the PCC pole over the deceased labourer, prima facie
establishes negligence attributable to the petitioner, thereby
attracting the offence under Section 106(1) of the Bharatiya
Nyaya Sanhita, 2023. Merely stating that the PCC pole was
purchased from an approved vendor does not absolve the
petitioner of his statutory and contractual duty of care towards the
labourers engaged by him. It was incumbent upon the petitioner,
as the executing contractor, to ensure that the material used was
of requisite quality and strength and that necessary safety
equipment was provided. Failure to do so constitutes criminal
negligence, which can be examined only during trial and not at the
stage of quashing.
16.
It is argued by Mr. Rathi that the laboratory test report
categorically establishes that the strength of the PCC pole was
much below the prescribed standard, and such sub-standard
material was admittedly used at the worksite under the petitioner’s
control. The chain of circumstances clearly discloses a prima facie
case linking the petitioner’s acts and omissions with the accidental
death of the deceased, and therefore the ingredients of Section
106(1) BNS are duly satisfied. He further submits that the
question as to whether the approved vendor or manufacturer is
also liable is a matter of evidence and does not dilute the
petitioner’s responsibility. At this stage, the Court is only required
to see whether the allegations in the FIR and the material
collected disclose commission of a cognizable offence, which they
clearly do.
17.
It is submitted by Mr. Rathi that the alleged similarity of witness
statements or the defence of having paid compensation under the
Employees’ Compensation Act are matters of defence and
mitigation, which cannot be adjudicated in proceedings under
Section 528 BNSS. Such defences must be tested during a fullfledged trial. Placing reliance on settled principles of law, learned
Government Advocate submits that the inherent jurisdiction of this
Court to quash criminal proceedings is to be exercised sparingly
and with great circumspection. As such, the present petition
deserves to be dismissed.
18.
We have heard learned counsel appearing for the respective
parties at length and have carefully perused the documents
annexed with the present petition.
19.
From perusal of the FIR, it transpires that upon receipt of
information regarding the accidental death of the deceased, Yugal
Kishore, inquest proceedings were initiated initially without a
registered case number and subsequently Marg Intimation No.
09/2025 under Section 194 BNSS was registered. During the
inquest and spot inspection, the police examined and recorded
statements of the panch and eyewitnesses, namely Satanand
Nishad, Rakesh Kumar Yadav, Bhikhari Lal Nishad, Sunil Kumar
Nishad and Nemichand Sevata.
20.
The FIR discloses that on 07.06.2025 at about 04:00 PM, the
deceased, while performing electric line work by fixing an insulator
and hanging the electric wire on the pole, had descended a few
feet when the PCC electric pole allegedly bent, broke from about
six inches above the ground and fell over him, crushing his waist,
as a result of which he succumbed to injuries during treatment.
21.
It is further reflected in the FIR that the police attributed the cause
of the accident to alleged failure of the contractor, Saurabh Singh,
in providing proper quality electric poles and to alleged negligence
of the supervisor, Kishore Kumar Sahu, in not providing safety
equipment at the worksite. On this basis, a prima facie offence
under Section 106(1) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita was said to
be made out against both the accused.
22.
The FIR further indicates that during investigation, spot inspection
was conducted, a site map was prepared, the broken electric pole
was seized, and samples thereof were sent for quality testing.
Reports were obtained from the Executive Engineer, Civil
Division, Raipur and Executive Engineer, Project Division, Durg,
wherein deficiency in the quality of the PCC pole was noted. It is
also stated that both accused were summoned, questioned and
allegedly accepted negligence in not checking the quality of the
pole and in not providing safety equipment. Both accused were
arrested on 18.08.2025 and later released on bail, the offence
being bailable, and thereafter Charge Sheet was filed.
23.
Considering the matter in its entirety, it clearly emerges that the
unfortunate death of the deceased occurred during execution of
electrical work at the worksite under the control and supervision of
the petitioner–contractor and the co-accused supervisor. The
investigation discloses that the electric pole used at the site was
found to be of sub-standard quality and that no adequate safety
equipment had been provided to the labourer. The laboratory
report indicating that the strength of the PCC pole was
substantially below the prescribed standard lends prima facie
support to the prosecution case. These facts, taken cumulatively,
disclose a live and direct nexus between the acts and omissions
attributed to the petitioner and the fatal incident, sufficient at this
stage to constitute the offence punishable under Section 106(1) of
the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023.
24.
The contentions advanced on behalf of the petitioner that the pole
was procured from an approved vendor, that no quality report was
furnished by the supplier, that CSPDCL failed to conduct
inspection, and that the manufacturer or vendor ought to have
been arrayed as an accused, are essentially matters of defence.
Such pleas necessarily involve appreciation of evidence,
examination of contractual obligations, determination of the extent
of duty of care and apportionment of liability, all of which fall
squarely within the domain of the trial Court and cannot be
adjudicated in proceedings invoking inherent powers of this Court.
25.
Similarly, the plea that the petitioner had already deposited
compensation under the Employees’ Compensation Act, though a
relevant mitigating circumstance, cannot ipso facto absolve the
petitioner of criminal liability, if otherwise made out. Payment of
compensation in a civil or statutory framework does not eclipse
criminal prosecution where the ingredients of the alleged offence
are prima facie disclosed.
26.
This Court also finds no merit in the submission that the witness
statements are identical or that there are procedural irregularities
vitiating the entire investigation. At the stage of considering a
petition for quashing, this Court is not required to meticulously
examine the credibility or probative value of witness statements.
Unless the materials on record are so absurd, inherently
improbable or wholly insufficient to constitute any offence, the
criminal proceedings ought not to be interdicted.
27.
The scope of interference under Section 482 CrPC / Section 528
BNSS is well circumscribed. The power is to be exercised
sparingly, with great caution and only in the rarest of rare cases to
prevent abuse of the process of law or to secure the ends of
justice.
28.
This Court is satisfied that the prosecution has placed sufficient
material to justify the continuation of criminal proceedings and that
the allegations, if taken at their face value, make out a prima facie
case against the petitioner. Any observation on the merits of the
defence at this stage would amount to a premature evaluation of
evidence and may cause prejudice to either party at the trial.
29.
Accordingly, the petition being devoid of merit, is hereby
dismissed. It is, however, clarified that all observations made
herein are confined only to the adjudication of the present petition
under Section 528 BNSS and shall not influence or prejudice the
trial Court in any manner while deciding the case on its own
merits, in accordance with law.
30.
There shall be no order as to costs.
Sd/(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
Anu
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review