Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
AVINASH
SHARMA
WPS No. 8742 of 2023
Digitally signed
by AVINASH
SHARMA
Date: 2026.02.28
18:45:26 +0530
Judgment Reserved On : 09.02.2026.
Judgment Delivered On :28.02.2026.
Sonam Sahu D/o Churaman Sahu Aged About 23 Years R/o D-2/30, Officer
Colony, Devendra Nagar, Raipur, District Raipur (C.G.)
... Petitioner.
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through The Secretary, Department Of Law And
Legislature Affair, Mahanadi Bhawan, Atal Nagar, Nawa Raipur District Raipur
(C.G.).
2 - President Selection Committee District And Session Court, Durg, District Durg
(C.G.).
3 - Parmeshwari Sahu D/o Shri Bhagelu Ram Sahu Selection List At Sr. No. 34,
Through President, Selection Committee District And Session Court, Durg, District
Durg (C.G.).
4 - Shivali Yadav D/o Shri Munna Lal Yadav Selection List At Sr. No. 37, Through
President, Selection Committee District And Session Court, Durg, District Durg
(C.G.).
... Respondents.
For Petitioner
:
For State/Respondent No.1 :
For Respondent No.2
:
For Respondent Nos.3 & 4 :
Shri Ajit Singh, Advocate.
Shri Sangarsh Pandey, Govt. Advocate.
Shri Amrito Das, Advocate.
Shri Rishi Rahul Soni, Advocates.
({ Hon’ble Mr. Justice Amitendra Kishore Prasad })
C A V Order
1. By way of this Writ Petition, petitioner is challenging the final select list
dated 16.10.2023 (Annexure P/3) which relates to appointment to the
post of Assistant Grade-3 (women category) and for setting aside
order dated 17.10.2023 (Annexure P/4) by which, it has been informed
that there was typing error in computer tabulation and the same has
been amended and the petitioner has obtained 139.5 marks and as
the petitioner failed to obtain the required marks for selection to the
said post, she cannot be appointed.
2. The petitioner has prayed for the following reliefs:10.1 A writ and/or an order in the nature of writ of
appropriate nature kindly do issue to the respondents
authority and directed placed entire documents of the
records before this Hon'ble court pertaining the case of
the petitioner.
10.2 A writ and/or an order in the nature of writ of
appropriate nature kindly do issue to the respondents
authority and set aside the impugned selection list
dated 16.10.2023, so far relates to post of the Assistant
Grade-III in woman category and consequences setaside the order dated 17.10.2023 in respect of the
petitioner which is arbitrary, Illegal and without
procedure of the law, in the facts and circumstances of
the case.
10.3 A writ and/or an order in the nature of writ of
appropriate nature kindly do issue to the respondents
authority and after adopting the proper procedure of law
given effect to the selection list dated 03.10.2023 as
such is being issued accordance with law and selected
the petitioner on the post of Assistant Grade-III in
woman category, in the facts and circumstances of the
case.
10.4 Any other relief in the direction of this Hon'ble
Court.
3. Case as projected by the petitioner is like that by advertisement dated
09.06.2023, respondent no.2 has published various posts i.e. class-III
& class IV employee for direct recruitment and as per her eligibility
qualification, the petitioner applied for the post of Assistant Grade-III in
unreserved category. In advertisement, it appears that 12 posts has
been reserved
for woman category for Assistant Grade-III. On
03.09.2023, the petitioner appeared in written examination as per the
advertisement conditions as also for skill test examination and
ultimately the result has been declared on 03.10.2023 and the
petitioner secured 193.5 marks in written examination and obtained 31
rank in the selection list and as such total 66 candidates have been
selected on the post which has been filled up by them. That, on
selection list, the authority has also mentioned the condition that if any
candidate is having objection with regard to published selection list
then the same shall be filed up to 09.10.2023. At this juncture, the
petitioner submits that perusal of the final selection list dated
03.10.2023, it appears that the respondent no. 3 has obtained 107.5
marks in the written examination and found a place in over all merit list
at Sr.No. 463. According to information, number of persons filed
objections whatsoever they having the knowledge about the incorrect
action done by the authority and ultimately without any complaint and
objection by the petitioner, again final selection list dated 16.10.2023
has been published and surprisingly in the said list, the petitioner's
name has been removed and selected the respondent no.3 at Sr. No.
34 mentioning marks allotted to her as 184.5. In the said list, name of
total selected 66 persons have been published and at the same time,
name of 142 candidates who said to be waiting list candidate has been
published. It is submitted that on 17.10.2023 the authority has clarified
that since selection committee on 12.10.2023 found certain correction
in the written examination of the petitioner therefore her marks has
been corrected and the same time it has also been mentioned with
regard to 184.5 marks allotted to respondent no.3 as per the decision
of the selection committee, therefore without adopting proper and fair
procedure and without any giving opportunity of hearing, the selection
of the petitioner has been cancelled /rejected, thus the action and
decision taken by the authority is illegal, arbitrary, liable to be set
aside. Perusal of the advertisement, it appears that the entire selection
process has been done according to skill test and at the time of
checking the answer sheet each and every minute correction has been
pointed out, therefore since the petitioner has clearly obtained 193.5
marks and no such complaint or allegation with regard to any undue
advantage or fault of the tabulation of the marks allotted to the
petitioner has been made, the authority has themselves took decision
and re-checked the entire skill test answer sheet and without
intimating the petitioner about the same, has corrected and debarred
the petitioner from the selection list. Advertisement nowhere assigns
condition with regard to re-checking or re-totaling of the marks unless
and until any specific allegation has been made, however the authority
has without any assigning reason just mentioned the decision of the
selection committee dated 12.10.2023 and corrected the marks of the
respondent no.3 from 107.5 to 184.5. Since entire scenario was
changed and one person who was earlier selected now was
unselected and the candidate who secured less marks was
subsequently found suitable for selection. In seleciton process of any
post, there is need for transparency and fair procedure so that the
method of correction would be acknowledged by the candidates but no
such procedure has been adopted and behind the back entire decision
has been taken which is not sustainable under the law. That, the
petitioner arrayed as party respondents as namely Parmeshwari Sahu,
Respondent No.3 who selected due to correction of the her marks and
also arrayed party to the respondent namely Shivali Yadav,
Respondent No.4 who obtained 181.5 marks. As per the total post
vacant i.e. 12 woman category, if petitioner would have been selected
and the marks of Parmeshwari Sahu, Respondent No.3 was found to
be correct then last candidate would be out of selection list, therefore,
these two candidates have only been arrayed as respondents from the
selection list, rest of the other candidates would not effect and no
grievances against them. In view of above, it is clear that the authority
has not adopted the proper procedure and not followed the condition
mentioned in the advertisement and without assigning any reason the
candidature or selection of the petitioner has been cancelled and
marks has been reduced, thus there is no other option except to
approach this Court.
4. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that initially the select list of
the post of Assistant Grade-3 was prepared, in which, name of the
petitioner found its place as a selected candidate on securing 193.5
marks, however, subsequently another select list has been prepared in
which, petitioner was shown to have secured 139.5 marks. Learned
counsel submits that the respondent authorities have illegally
corrected the earlier select list and vide letter dated 17.10.2023, they
have clarified that according to decision of select committee on
12.10.2023, marks have wrongly been calculated and awarded, as
such, the said mistake has been rectified. Learned counsel for the
petitioner further submits that subsequent rectification in the select list
is not in accordance with law, therefore, this Petition may be allowed
while setting aside the subsequent select list and direct the respondent
authorities to consider the earlier select list for the post of Assistant
Grade-3.
5. Learned State counsel submits that claim of the petitioner that her
name was mentioned in the provisional select list is unreasonable as
it is settled principle of law that name of a candidate finding its place in
the provisional select list will not accrue any right in the favour of the
candidate to be appointed on the said post. It is an exclusive right of
the employer to scrutiny the candidature of each and every candidate
till the publication of the final selection list. In the provisional select list,
petitioner got 193.5 marks, however, in the final select list, she got
139.5 marks as in the provisional select list, there was some
typographical mistake and to correct the same, final select was
prepared subsequent to provisional select list. Hence, this Writ Petition
lacks merits which may be dismissed by this Court.
6. Learned counsel appearing for Respondent No.2 submits that
petitioner’s entire claim is founded upon the provisional merit list dated
03.10.2023, however, this reliance is legally unsustainable because
the list was inherently conditional and tentative. The said provisional
list carried a specific caveat warning all candidates that the selection
committee retained powers to rectify any tabulation or clerical errors.
The provisional merit list explicitly contained conditions regarding its
provisional nature and the correction of errors, which is as under:
"उपरो्ሹानुसार घोषि त अनंतितम चयन परिरणाम में अंकण /
टंकण / मु्ቖण / ्ቚषिकया संबंधी ्ቔुषिट होने पर भत# कमेटी,
जि%ला एवं स्ቔ न्यायालय, द्ቇु , में संधारिरत मूल डाटा के
आधार पर तैयार सूची ही मान्य हो्ቇी एवं त्स
ु ार चयन
परिरणाम संशोतिधत षिकया %ा सके्ቇा।"
7. The aforesaid condition puts all candidates including the petitioner on
clear notice that the marks show in the provisional list were subject to
verification and that any clerical errors discovered during verification
would be rectified. By participating in the examination process and
accepting her provisional ranking, the petitioner impliedly accepted
these terms and conditions, therefore, now she cannot deviate from
those conditions. Further, it is a settled principle of law that a
candidate does not acquire an indefeasible right to appointment based
merely on the inclusion of their name in a merit list and this principle
applies with even greater force to a ‘provisional list’ which is expressly
subject to rectification. The entry of 193.5 marks was a factual
impossibility and a mistake of fact, not a result of a conscious
assessment of merit. The Administration has an inherent right and duty
to correct such bona fide mistakes to ensure that public employment is
granted based on actual merit and not accidental errors.
8. Learned counsel for Respondent No.2 also submits that even if the
petitioner were afforded an opportunity to make a representation or be
heard prior to the rectification, the outcome would remain wholly
unchanged as no amount of representation could alter the
mathematical reality of the marks awarded on the physical answer
script. As such, petitioner cannot claim an indefeasible vested right
based on a mistake that is unequivocally contradicted by the
documentary evidence of her own answer sheet.
9. Learned counsel for Respondent No.2 now moves on to submit with
regard to another contention raised by the petitioner that rectification
of her marks was violative of the principles of natural justice as no
notice or opportunity of hearing was afforded to her before correcting
the clerical error. In this regard, it is respectfully submitted that this
argument is liable to be rejected under the “Doctrine of Empty
Formality” or “Useless Formality Theory”. The law does not compel the
performance of a futile act, and the cancellation of an advantage
gained solely through a clerical mistake does not require the rigorous
observance of natural justice when the facts are indisputable as in the
present case, it is indisputable that the petitioner scored 139.5 marks
in her examination and the same was made clear in the final merit list
when clerical error in calculation of the petitioner’s marks was rectified
by the respondents. He places reliance on the judgment passed in the
matter of State of Manipur & Ors. vs. Y. Token Singh & Ors.
{(2007) 5 SCC 65} by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, which held that the
principles of natural justice are not a straitjacket formula and that
where the facts are admitted, the principles of natural justice were not
required to be complied with, particularly when the same would result
in futility.
10. Further reliance is placed by Respondent No.2 on the judgment of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of Aligarh Muslim
University v. Mansoor Ali Khan { (2000) 7 SCC 529}. In the said
case, the Apex Court invoked the “useless formality” theory and held
that where there are admitted or indisputable facts, and only one
conclusion is possible, the Court may not issue its writ to compel the
observance of natural justice.
11. Learned counsel for Respondent No.2 submits that applying the
aforesaid precedents to the present case, the fact that the petitioner
secured 139.5 marks is an indisputable fact derived directly from her
answer sheet (Annexure-R/2A). Even if a notice were issued and a
hearing granted, the petitioner could not arguably change the
mathematical reality of the marks recorded on her physical answer
sheet.
12.Learned counsel appearing for Respondent No.2 while concluding
submits that there is nothing illegal in correction of selection list as
earlier due to mistake, the marks obtained by the candidates could not
be calculated properly. He submits that the actual marks which have
been obtained by the petitioner i.e. 139.5 were reflected as 193.5 due
to clerical and typographical error during the data entry of tabulation.
Therefore, when re-tabulation was done, it was found that the
petitioner has actually obtained 139.5 marks and thus, she could not
get selected. The aforesaid mistake is a procedural mistake which was
also rectified subsequently as such, claim of the petitioner is baseless,
misconceived and liable to be turned down by this Court.
13. Learned counsel for Respondent Nos.3 and 4 submits that grounds
raised by the petitioner on the basis of marks shown in provisional
selection list is baseless as marks allotted to the petitioner in skill test
was reflected incorrectly due to typographical mistake in computer
tabulation which was subsequently corrected and the petitioner was
awarded 139.5 marks. Similarly, marks of Respondent No.3 was also
reflected incorrectly and was corrected as 184.5 marks. On the basis
of said correction in allotment of marks, petitioner was not entitled to
be appointed on the post of Assistant Grade-III whereas insofar as
Respondent No.3 is concerned, her marks were corrected from 107.5
to 184.5 and as such, Respondent No.3 was entitled to be appointed
on the post of Assistant Grade III. The final selection list (Annexure
P/3) was prepared after due correction in allotment of marks and as
such, there is no illegality in the final selection list and therefore, this
Writ Petition being devoid of merits may be dismissed by the Court.
14. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record
available with the Writ Petition.
15.From perusal of the record, it is quite vivid that the earlier select list
dated 03.10.2023 was having some defect while awarding marks to
the candidates which has been subsequently corrected. The petitioner
on the basis of the provisional select list dated 03.10.2023 has
obtained 193.5 marks. However, there being a defect in the provisional
select list dated 03.10.2023, the same was rectified and it was
informed that wrongly in the provisional select list dated 03.10.2023,
marks obtained by the petitioner has been reflected as 193.5,
however, the actual marks secured by the petitioner was informed vide
Annexure P/4 as 139.5. The said error occurred while calculating and
tabulating the marks and was rectified by way of impugned select list
dated 16.10.2023, which cannot be said to be illegal.
16. Further, upon going through the answer sheet (Annexure R/2-A) of the
petitioner carefully and on perusal of the same, it appears that no
illegality has been committed by the respondent authorities in
calculating the marks obtained by the petitioner which is 139.5 which
was wrongly reflected as 193.5 marks in the provisional select list.
Moreover, on going through the answer sheet of Respondent No.3
who has been selected on the post in question, initially she secured
107.5 and on her answer sheet getting counter checked, she secured
184.5 marks and was selected to the post in question.
17. On the basis of aforesaid discussion, this Court is of the view that
there is no such illegality or perversity in the impugned select list dated
16.10.2023 (Annexure P/3) as the same was issued just to correct the
mistakes occurred in the provisional select list dated 03.10.2023
(Annexure P/2) which has rightly been corrected, therefore, in the
opinon of this Court, the subsequent select list dated 16.10.2023 is
genuine and in accordance with law.
18. In the result, the Writ Petition being devoid of merits is liable to be and
is accordingly dismissed.
Sd/-
(Amitendra Kishore Prasad)
Judge
Avinash
The date when the
The date when the
The date when the judgment is
judgment is reserved
judgment is
uploaded on the website
pronounced
09.02.2026
28.02.2026
Operative
Full
------
28.02.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review