Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
GAHC010214122015
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT AT GUWAHATI
(The High Court of Assam, Nagaland, Mizoram and Arunachal Pradesh)
Principal Seat at Guwahati
WP(C) No. 7058/2015
Solim Uddin, S/O- Late Muzafar Ali,
Village- Matraghola, P.O. Kritanpara
P.S- Abhayapuri, Dist. - Bongaigaon, Assam,
PIN- 788151.
……………Petitioner
-Versus-
signed by
Deepjyoti Digitally
Deepjyoti Sarkar
Date: 2026.01.07
Sarkar
15:30:58 +05'30'
1.
The State of Assam,
Represented by the Commissioner and Secretary
to the Govt. of Assam, Education (Elementary)
Department, Dispur, Guwahati- 781006.
2.
Commissioner and Secretary, Govt. of Assam,
Finance (B) Dept., Dispur, Ghy-6.
The Director of Elementary Education,
Assam, Kahilipara, Ghy-19.
4.
The District Elementary Education Officer,
Bongaigaon, Assam.
5.
The Block Elementary Education Officer, Srijangram, DistBongaigaon, Assam.
..…………Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ROBIN PHUKAN
Advocate for the petitioner
Advocate for the respondents
:- Mr. M. U. Mahmud
:- Mr. B. Kaushik, (R-1,3,4,5)
Mr. A. Chaliha (R- 2)
Date of Hearing
:-
01.12.2025
Date on which judgment is reserved
:-
01.12.2025
Date of Judgment
:-
05.01.2026
:-
N/A
:-
Yes
Whether the pronouncement is of
the operative part of the judgment?
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced?
JUDGEMENT & ORDER (CAV)
Heard Mr. M. U. Mahmud, learned counsel for the petitioner.
Also heard Mr. B. Kaushik, learned standing counsel for the
Elementary Education Department, being respondent Nos. 1, 3, 4
and 5; and Mr. A. Chaliha, learned standing counsel for the Finance
Department, being respondent No. 2.
2.
In this petition, under Article 226 of the Constitution of India,
the petitioner has challenged the order, dated 20.12.2014,
(Annexure – 12), passed by the Secretary to the Government of
Assam, Education Elementary Department and also to direct the
respondent No. 2, 3, and 4 to pay the arrear as well as current
salary to the petitioner with effect from June 1994. Notably, vide
impugned order dated 20.12.2014, the respondent No. 1 had
rejected the claim of the petitioner for payment of salary.
Background Facts:3.
The background facts, leading to filing of the present petition
are briefly stated as under:“The petitioner was initially appointed as Asstt. Teacher in
Bongaigaon district, in the year 1994. After such appointment
he had received salaries only for (3) months. Thereafter, his
salary was stopped without any notice or showing any
reasons. Thereafter, as per the cabinet decision, the District
Elementary Education Officer, Bongaigaon, by order, dated 25-2006, attached the service of the petitioner in 196 No. Til
Pukhuri L.P. School, wherein he has been rendering his
service till date. But, the respondents have not released his
salaries from June, 1994, till date, in spite of repeated
demands.
Being aggrieved, the petitioner as well as 5 others had
filed a writ petition, being W.P. (C) No. 143/2009, before this
Court, and this Court, after hearing all the parties, vide order,
dated 16-03-2010, directed the Commissioner and Secretary
to the Govt. of Assam, Education Department to take
necessary step to release the arrear as well the current
salaries of the petitioner as well as others.
But, due to non-compliance of the said order, the
petitioners had instituted a contempt case, being Contempt
Petition (C) No. 263/2010, wherein this Court vide order
dated 10.01.2014, was pleased to direct to comply order,
dated 16-03-2010, passed in W.P. (C) No. 143/2009 in letter
and spirit within a period of 3 (three) months. Even then, the
respondent did not carry out the order. The petitioners then
filed another contempt case, vide No. 521/14, wherein the
respondent No. 1/ contemnor submitted before this Court
that the order has already been complied with vide order,
dated 20-12-2014.
Then having gone through the impugned order, dated
20-12-2014, passed by the respondent No. 1, it has been
found that the said order is absolutely perverse and non-est
in the eye of law which is also contradictory to other orders,
dated 16-3-2010 passed in W.P. (C) No. 143/2009 etc. The
respondent, instead of releasing the arrear as well as the
current salaries of others, has rejected the claim of the
petitioner by mentioning some unfounded stories in the
impugned order. The ground for such rejection is that in the
list of 288 employees, the name of the petitioner was not
figured within 82, which is misleading, as salaries also have
been provided to the candidates whose name figured in Sl.
No. 125 of the list of candidates, vide annexure 2 and 3 of
the writ petition.”
4. The respondent No.3 had filed affidavit-in-opposition, wherein
it had taken a stand that the petitioners were initially appointed
as Assistant Teachers in different ME Madrassas by the DEEO,
Bongaigaon during the year 1993-1994 without following any
selection process. Thereafter, their services have been regularized
against
non-sanction
posts.
Therefore,
they
belonged
to
irregularly appointed teachers as identified by the Manoharan
Committee and the Task forces. It is also stated that the
appointments of the petitioners were made by the then authority
by ignoring the statutory rules. The decision of the Government to
regularize the service of the irregularly appointed teachers was
taken advantage of by unscrupulous elements to regularize the
service of the petitioners, who never participated in any selection
process under the law. It is also stated that the petitioners earlier
approached this Court vide WP(C) No. 143/2009, praying for
payment of salary w.e.f. date of joining i.e. 12.5.2006 and this
Court vide order dated 16.3.2010, directed the Commissioner and
Secretary,
Government
of
Assam,
Education
(Elementary)
Department to take necessary steps to release arrear and current
salary of the petitioners and for this purpose, whatever enquiry is
required to be done, that should be done by the authority.
Thereafter, the Government Constituted a screening committee
for the purpose of screening of the illegal/irregularly appointed
teachers working in LP/ME schools for the period 1991-2001 in
respect of the cases in Lower Assam Division including
Bongaigaon district, vide Notification dated 7.1.2012, and
pursuant to the aforesaid notification, the petitioners had
appeared before the screening committee and the screening
committee had furnish the report which indicates that out of the
six petitioners, the posts sanction order held by the petitioners
could not be verified as same was not produced before the
verification authority. It is also stated that due to non-availability
of budget allotment of fund and retention of the respective posts
held by the petitioners, they are not receiving salary till date.
Further, due to non-receipt of Finance (SIU) approval, salary of
the petitioners could not be paid. It is also stated that
appointments and regularization of 125 Nos. of teachers of
Bongaigaon District including the petitioners were challenged in
WP(C) No. 2346/2008 (Bharat Chandra Sarkar & Ors. –vs.- State
of Assam & Ors.) and this Court vide order, dated 8.5.2013 was
pleased to set aside their regularization orders and being
aggrieved, the State & Ors. had preferred writ appeals and same
were disposed of vide order dated 20.5.2014, in WA No. 211/2013
by setting aside the Judgment and Order dated 8.5.2013 and
further directed for fresh hearing by the writ Court and the
aforesaid writ petitions are pending for adjudication before this
Court and therefore, the State is not able to take any decision on
the matter.
Submission of learned counsel for the petitioner:5.
Mr. Mahmud, learned counsel for the petitioner has launch
multipronged attack upon the impugned order, dated 20.12.2014,
(Annexure – 12), passed by the Secretary to the Government of
Assam, Education Elementary Department. Mr. Mahmud submits
that the impugned order was passed ignoring the direction issued
by this Court vide order dated 16.3.2010, in WP(C) No. 143/2009.
Instead the Secretary to the Govt. of Assam, Education
Department, had taken into account irrelevant materials for
rejection of claim of the petitioner. Mr. Mahmud submits that the
petitioner was initially appointed as Asstt. Teacher in Bongaigaon
district, in the year 1994 and he was paid salary only for (3)
months and thereafter, his salary was stopped. He also submits
that the State Cabinet had taken a decision on 24.02.2005, to
regularize the service of 125 candidates of Bongaigaon district as
per the cabinet decision. Thereafter, the Director Elementary
Education, Assam had regularized 125 numbers of teachers of
Bongaigaon district vide Order dated 30.01.2006 and the name of
the petitioner figured in serial No. 118 of the said list. And
thereafter, District Elementary Education Officer, Bongaigaon, by
order, dated 2-5-2006, attached the service of the petitioner in
196 No. Til Pukhuri L.P. School, wherein he has been rendering
his service till date. But, the respondents have not released his
salaries from June, 1994, till date, in spite of repeated demands.
5.1. Mr. Mahmud also submits that the petitioner along with 5
others had filed a writ petition, being W.P. (C) No. 143/09, before
this Court, and this Court, after hearing all the parties, vide order,
dated 16-03-2010, directed the Commissioner and Secretary to
the Govt. of Assam, Education Department to take necessary step
to release the arrear as well as the current salaries of the
petitioner along with others. But, said order was not complied
with for which Contempt Petition (C) No. 263/2010, was instituted
wherein, this Court had directed the contemnor to comply the
order, dated 16-03-2010, passed in W.P. (C) No. 143/2009 in
letter and spirit within a period of 3 (three) months. Even then
the respondent did not carry out the order. The petitioners then
again instituted another contempt case, vide No. 521/14, wherein
the respondent No. 1/ contemnor submitted before this Court that
the order has already been complied with vide order, dated 2012-2014.
5.2.
Mr. Mahmud also submits that the impugned order, dated
20-12-2014, is absolutely perverse and non-est in the eye of law
which is also contradictory to other order, dated 16-03-2010
passed in W.P. No. 143/09 etc. The ground for such rejection is
that in the list of 288 employees, the name of the petitioner was
not figured within 82, which is misleading, as salaries also have
been released to the candidates whose names figured in the list
of 125 candidates who have been regularized as per cabinet
decision.
5.3.
Mr. Mahmud also submits that though the list of 125
candidates was set aside by a learned Single Judge of this Court
in WP(C) No. 2346/2008, vide order dated 08.05.2013, filed by
Bharat Ch. Sarkar and Others, yet the state had preferred one
appeal being Writ Appeal(W/A) No. 211/2013, wherein the order
dated 08.05.2013, so passed by the learned Single Judge had
been set aside and the matter was remanded for fresh hearing,
vide order dated 11.11.2021. And as such, the Cabinet Decision
dated 24.02.2005 and the consequent regularization order dated
30.01.2006, of the petitioner and 124 others came to be restored.
And as such the respondent authority has no option but to carry
out the direction to release the salary of the petitioner, as per
order, dated 16-03-2010 passed in W.P. (C) No. 143/2009.
5.4. It is also the submission of Mr. Mahmud that the WP(C) No.
2346/2008, which was remanded to the learned Single Judge for
hearing a fresh, was subsequently dismissed for non prosecution
by a Co-ordinate Bench of this Court vide order dated 11.11.2021.
And as such, the regularization order so passed by the Director
Elementary Education as per Cabinet Decision has attained finality
and therefore, Mr. Mahmud has contended to allow this petition
directing the respondent authority to release the current and
arrear salary of the petitioner forthwith.
5.5. On another ground also Mr. Mahmud attacked the impugned
order that one Anjumanara Khatun, Hafizur Rahman, Naresh Ch.
Mandal and one Tulshi Barman whose names were there in the
list of 125 candidates and whose services were regularized by the
Director Elementary Education, has been receiving salary and
some of them received the same pursuant to order of this Court,
but the claim of the petitioner was rejected arbitrarily.
5.6.
Mr. Mahmud has also referred following decision in support
of his submission:(i)
Man Singh vs. the State of Uttar Pradesh
Through Secretary & Ors., reported in 2022
LiveLaw(SC) 341.
Submission of learned counsel for the respondent:6.
Per contra, Mr. Kaushik, learned standing counsel for the
respondent authorities has supported the impugned order. He
submits that as per report of the Monoharan Committee, the
name of the petitioners were in the list of irregular teachers of
Bongaigaon, who were appointed as Assistant Teachers in
different ME Madrassas by the DEEO, Bongaigaon during the year
1993-1994 without following any selection process. Thereafter,
their services have been regularized against non-sanction posts.
Mr. Kaushik also submits that the petitioners earlier approached
this Court vide WP(C) No. 143/2009 praying for payment of salary
w.e.f. date of joining, i.e. 12.5.2006 and this Court, vide order
dated 16.3.2010, directed the Commissioner and Secretary,
Government of Assam, Education (Elementary) Department to
take necessary steps to release arrear and current salary of the
petitioners after conducting enquiry. Thereafter,
one screening
committee for the purpose of screening of the illegal/irregularly
appointed teachers working in LP/ME schools for the period 19912001 in respect of the cases in Lower Assam Division including
Kamrup (M), Kamrup (R), Nalbari, Barpeta, Bhubri, Goalpara and
Bongaigaon district, vide Notification dated 7.1.2012, and
pursuant to the aforesaid notification, the petitioners had
appeared before the screening committee and the screening
committee had furnish the report which indicates that out of the
six petitioners, the posts sanction order held by the petitioners
could not be verified as same was not produced before the
verification authority.
6.1. Mr. Kaushik also submits that due to non-availability of
budget allotment of fund and retention of the respective posts
held by the petitioners and also for non-receipt of Finance (SIU)
approval, salary of the petitioners could not be paid. Mr. Kaushik
further submits that the appointments and regularization of 125
Nos. of teachers of Bongaigaon District including the petitioners
were challenged in WP(C) No. 2346/2008 by one Bharat Chandra
Sarkar & Ors. and this Court vide order, dated 8.5.2013 had set
aside their regularization orders. Thereafter, the State had
preferred writ appeal and same were disposed of vide order dated
20.5.2014, in WA No. 211/2013 by setting aside the Judgment
and Order dated 8.5.2013 and further directed for fresh hearing
by the writ Court and the aforesaid writ petitions are pending for
adjudication before this Court and therefore, the State is not able
to take any decision on the matter.
6.2. Further contention of Mr. Kaushik is that the name of the
petitioners were in the list of irregular teachers of Bongaigaon
District and as such they are not entitled to any relief as prayed
for.
6.3.
Mr. Kaushik has also referred to following decisions to
bolster his submissions:(i) The State of Bihar and Others vs. Devendra
Sharma, reported in (2020) 15 SCC 466.
(ii) WP(C) No. 2346/2008 (Bharat Ch. Sarkar &
Ors-Vs-State of Assam & Ors.
7. Having heard the submission of learned Advocates of both the
parties, I have carefully gone through the petition and the
documents placed on record and also perused the impugned
order dated Dispur the 20th December, 2014 (Annexure-12) so
passed by the Secretary to the Government of Assam, Education
Elementary Department. Also gone through the decisions referred
by Mr. Mahmud, learned counsel for the petitioner and also by Mr.
Kaushik, learned standing counsel for the respondent authorities.
8.
From the contentions being made in the respective pleadings
of the parties and also from the submissions of learned counsel
for both the parties, following facts and circumstances emerges:(i)
The petitioner was initially appointed as Asstt. Teacher in
Bongaigaon district, in the year 1994 and he was paid
salary only for (3) months and thereafter, his salary was
stopped.
(ii)
As per report of the Monohoran Committee, the name of
the petitioner figured in the list of irregular teachers of
Bongaigaon District.
(iii)
The State Cabinet had taken a decision on 24.02.2005 to
regularize the service of 125 irregular teachers of
Bongaigaon District.
(iv)
As per the cabinet decision, the Director Elementary
Education, Assam had regularized 125 numbers of
teachers of Bongaigaon District vide Order dated
30.01.2006.
(v)
The name of the petitioner figured in serial No. 118 of the
said list.
(vi)
Thereafter,
District
Elementary
Education
Officer,
Bongaigaon, by order, dated 2-5-2006, attached the
service of the petitioner in 196 No. Til Pukhuri L.P.
School, wherein he has been rendering his service till
date.
(vii)
But, the respondents have not released his salaries from
June, 1994, till date, in spite of repeated demands.
(viii) Then the petitioner along with 5 others had filed a writ
petition, being W.P. (C) No. 143/2009, before this Court,
and this Court, after hearing all the parties, vide order,
dated 16-03-2010, directed the Commissioner and
Secretary to the Govt. of Assam, Education Department
to take necessary step to release the arrear as well the
current salaries of the petitioner.
(ix) But, said order was not complied with for which Contempt
Petition (C) No. 263/2010, was instituted wherein, this
Court had directed the contemnor to comply order,
dated 16-03-2010, passed in W.P. (C) No. 143/2009 in
letter and spirit within a period of 3 (three) months.
(x)
But, thereafter also the respondent did not carry out the
order for which the petitioners again instituted another
contempt case, vide No. 521/14, wherein the respondent
No. 1/ contemnor submitted before this Court that the
order has already been complied with vide order, dated
20-12-2014, by which the claim of the petitioner was
rejected.
(xi)
And this order, dated 20-12-2014, is under challenge in
the present petition.
(xii)
The list of 125 teachers, whose services were regularized
by the Director Elementary Education, Assam was set
aside by a learned Single Judge of this Court in WP(C)
No. 2346/2008, vide order dated 08.05.2013, on being
challenged by one Bharat Ch. Sarkar and Ors.
(xiii) The State had preferred one appeal, being Writ
Appeal(W/A) No. 211/2013, wherein the order dated
08.05.2013, so passed by the learned Single Judge had
been set aside and the matter was remanded for fresh
hearing, vide order dated 11.11.2021.
(xiv)
In view of order dated 11.11.2021, the regularization
order dated 30.01.2006, so passed by the Director
Elementary Education, Assam pursuant to the Cabinet
Decision dated 24.02.2005 came to be restored.
(xv)
The WP(C) No. 2346/2008, which was remanded to the
learned
Single
Judge
for
hearing
afresh,
was
subsequently dismissed for non prosecution by a Coordinate
Bench
of
this
Court
vide
order
dated
11.11.2021.
(xvi) And as such, the regularization order so passed by the
Director Elementary Education as per Cabinet Decision
has attained finality and as such the respondent
authority has no option, but to carry out the direction to
release the salary of the petitioner, as per order, dated
16-03-2010 passed in W.P. (C) No. 143/2009.
(xvii) One Anjumanara Khatun, Hafizur Rahman, Naresh Ch.
Mandal
and one Tulshi Barman whose names were
there in the list of 125 candidates and whose services
were regularized by the Director Elementary Education,
has been receiving salary and some of them received the
same pursuant to order of this Court, but the claim of
the petitioner was rejected.
9.
Moving forward this Court deemed it appropriate to peruse
the impugned order dated 20th December, 2014, which is
extracted here in below:GOVERNMENT OF ASSAM,
EDUCATION (ELEMENTARY) DEPARTMENT
No. ELC/WPC1143/2009/13/P/270,
20th December, 2014
Dated Dispur the
O R D E R
Perused:- The Order did. 16/03/2010 passed by Hon'ble
High Court in WP(C)143/2009 (Md. Solim
Uddin & 5 Ors -Vs-State of Assam & Ors) in
connection with payment of arrear & current
salaries of the petitioner who were
appoimed irregularly as Assistant Teachers
in LP/UP school under undivided Bongaigaon
District during 1991-2001 as reflected in
the report of the Monoharan Committee
Also read:-
1. The petition dtd. 12/01/2011 and did.
15/09/2014 submitted by Md. Solim
Uddin & 5 Ors.
2.Report
No.
EHA-22/09/119,
did.
30/05/2014 submitted by DEE. Assam.
3.Report
No.
GG/12/2014/6
dtd
27/11/2014 submitted by Commissioner
of Lower Assam Division
Findings:- It appears that the Hon'ble High Court in
its order dtd. 16/03/2010 passed in
WP(C)143/2009
directed
that
the
Commissioner & Secretary Govt. of Assam.
Education Department would cause to take
necessary steps so that the arrear and
current salaries of the petitioners are
released and for this purpose whatever
enquiry is required to be done that should
be done by the authority keeping in mind
the fact as indicated above in the order
The Commissioner & Secretary is also
directed to make a necessary communication
wherever found necessary to the Finance
Department for granting necessary sanction
to which there is no objection as indicated
by the Finance Department provided that the
petitioners are duly appointed by the
authority. ............... In the said
order the Hon'ble High Court has observed
that the petitioners has also brought to
the notice of the court about the order dtd
23/12/2008 passed in WP(C) No. 3696/2008 by
which the similarly situated teachers were
granted
relief
by
the
court
on
consideration.
Pursuant to the order dtd 16/3/2010
passed in WP(C)No.143/2009, the Department
taken up the matter of release of arrear
and current salaries of the petitioners for
consideration. The matter was also referred
to
Finance
Department
and
Additional
Advocate General, Assam, Gauhati High
Court. But it is seen that Shri Bharat Ch.
Sarkar and ors challenge the regularization
of 125 teachers of Bongaigaon District
which covered by Monoharan Committee. In
the list of said 125 teachers of Bongaigaon
District name of all the petitioners of
instant case were also included. The case
of Bharat Ch. Sarkar has been disposed of
by the Hon'ble High Court dtd, 08/05/2013
with
the
opinion
that
likewise
in
Bongaigaon District, different lists(s) of
irregularly
appointed
teachers
were
generated by falsely projecting the names
in the list as those identified by the
Manoharan Committee and the task forces.
But
in
reality,
the
last
regular
appointment in Bongaigaon was made in the
year 1993 and since none in this district
was
identified
to
the
a
irregular
appointee,
it
is
obvious
that
the
regularization
of
beneficiaries
in
Bongaigon district, could not have been
based on the recommendation of Manoharan
Committee. Therefore, it is clear that in
this district also, so called list of
irregularly
appointed
teachers
were
generated.
The appointments in Bongaigaon and
Karimganj districts in these 2 (two)
proceedings were made by ignoring the
Statutory Rules. The decision of the Govt
to
regularize
the
service
of
the
irregularly appointed teachers was taken
advantage of by unscrupulous elements to
regularize the service of those who never
participated
in
selection
process.
Moreover, these beneficiaries were not
appointed through any competent appointment
order. Therefore, the private respondents
cannot be put in the category of irregular
appointees and it has to be declared that
their appointments are absolutely illegal
In such circumstances, the State cannot
invoke the power under Article 162 of the
constitution to regularize the service of
people
who
were
appointed
through
fraudulent process Here appointment orders
were fabricated and fake appointment lists
were generated and there was no declaration
by the Manoharan Committee that the private
respondents
are
in
the
category
of
irregular appointees. In such backdrop
having regard to the ratio of the Supreme
Court decisions referred to above. I feel
that the petitioners have made out a case
for judicial intervention. Consequently the
regularization of the respondent Nos. 8-132
in the WP(C) No. 2346/2008 is held to be
unsustainable
and
it
is
declared
accordingly
by
quashing
the
impugned
orders.
On
the
same
reasoning,
the
adjustment
appointment
in
Karimganj
district of respondent No. 16-138 in the
WP(C) 7492/2005 are hold to be illegal and
consequently
the
impugned
order
dtd.
05/02/2005 issued by the DEE, Assam is
quashed. In view of the conclusion the
State is directed to ensure that their
services
are
discontinued
forthwith"
However, Govt. preferred an appeal being
No. WA.211/2013 challenging the impugned
judgement & order dtd. 08/05/2013 passed by
the learned single judge in WP(C) No.
2346/2008 (Bharat Ch. Sarkar & Ors-Vs-State
of Assam & Ors) in consideration of the
irreparable loss and suffering faced by the
petitioner who were regularized pursuant to
the Cabinet decision and have rendered
services for a long time without break.
Subsequently, by order dtd. 20/05/2014, the
Division Bench allowed the Writ Appeal to
set aside the judgment & order dtd.
08/05/2013 and directed for fresh hearing
by the writ court.
Meanwhile,
Govt.
constituted
a
screening
committee
for
the
purpose
screening
of
the
illegal
irregularly
appointed teachers working in LP/ME schools
for the period 1991-2001 in respect of the
cases in Lower Assam Division covering
Kmarup(M), Kamrup (R), Nalbari, Barpeta,
Dhubri, Goalpara and Bongaigaon District
vide notification No. ELC/WP(C)1048/2004/
988/P1-111/41 dtd. 07/01/2013. It also
appear that Md. Solim Uddin and 5 Ors
petitioners in WP(C) 143/2009, have already
appeared before the aforesaid screening
committee. Therefore, the Chairman of the
screening committee was asked to furnished
the report immediately. From the report of
the screening committed as forwarded by the
Commissioner of Lower Assam Division vide
letter No GG/12/2014/6 did. 27/11/2014.
Inter-alia, it appears that the post
sanction
order
in
respect
of
the
petitioners could not be verified as the
same
was
not
produced
before
the
verification authority during the screening
by the DEEO office and as such it could not
be ascertained whether appointments are
made against sanctioned or non-sanctioned
posts. Besides, it appears from the report
that out of 6 (xix) petitioners the name of
4 (four) namely (1) Abdur Rashid (2)
Hafizar Rahman (3) Solim Uddin (4) Mostafa
Ahmed
were
recommended
by
the
Sub
Divisional. Advisory Board (SDLAC), North
Salmara Sub-Division, Abhayapuri and 2
(two) petitioners namely (1) Sahjahan Ali
Ahmed and (2) Assatan Nesssa was not been
recommended by the Sub-Divisional Advisory
Board along with two other petitioners (1)
Sahajahan Ali Ahmed (2) Asatan Nessa. The
petitioner Abdur Rashid is it Sl. 169.
Hafizur Rahman at Si. 106 and Solim Uddin
at St 360. All the selected petitioners are
below St. 82 in the select list of General
Candidates
furnished
by
the
DEEO,
Bongaigaon.
However, on scrutiny of the records as
available in the Department, it reveals
that the names of (1) Sahajahan Ali Ahmed
(2) Asatan Nessa does not appear in the
photocopy of the select list prepared by
the Sub-divisional Committee. Therefore,
these appointments are irregular and cannot
be regularized. It is also seen that
although the Commissioner. Lower Assam
Division has mentioned that Mostafa Ahmed
was recommended by the Sub-Divisional
Committee, but the name of Shri Mostafa
Ahmed could not be located in the photocopy
of the select list as available in the
file. Besides, there were only 82 (eighty
two)
sanctioned
post
for
Bongaigaon
District as per letter No. ECA.20/94/6 dtd
06/07/94. Therefore, only 82 persons are
entitled for appointment. The name of the
three petitioners namely Hafizur Rahman.
Abdur Rashid and Solim Uddin (appeared at
No. 106,169 and 360 respectively in the
select list. These petitioners are from the
General Category and they are not entitled
for appointment below from 82 of the select
list. Their appointments are irregular
excess and cannot be regularized in view of
law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court
and Hon'ble Gauhati High Court.
In view of the enquiry as stated above
the claim of the petitioners cannot be
entertained.
This is issued in compliance of order
16/03/2010 passed by Hon'ble High Court in
WP(C)143/2009.
Sd/R.C. Jain, IAS
Secretary to the Govt. of Assam
Education (Ele.) Department
10.
This impugned order, when considered in the light of the
submissions, so advanced by Mr. Mahmud, learned counsel for
the petitioner, this Court finds sufficient force in his submission. It
appears from the impugned order that basically on the following
ground the claim of the petitioner for releasing his salary was
rejected:(i)
One Shri Bharat Ch. Sarkar and Others
challenged
the
regularization
of
teachers of Bongaigaon District which were
covered by Monoharan Committee, in WP(C) No.
2346/2008 wherein such regularization is
held to be unsustainable and accordingly the
same was set aside vide order dated
08.05.2013.
(ii)
The Govt. had preferred an appeal being No.
W/A No. 211/2013 challenging the impugned
judgement & order dtd. 08/05/2013 passed by
the learned single judge in WP(C) No.
2346/2008 (Bharat Ch. Sarkar & Ors-Vs-State
of Assam & Ors). And subsequently, by order
dtd. 20/05/2014, the Division Bench allowed
the Writ Appeal to set aside the judgment &
order dtd. 08/05/2013 and directed for fresh
hearing by the writ court.
(iii) Govt. constituted a screening committee for
the purpose of screening of the illegal
irregularly appointed teachers working in
LP/ME schools for the period 1991-2001 in
respect of the cases in Lower Assam Division
covering Kmarup(M), Kamrup (R), Nalbari,
Barpeta, Dhubri, Goalpara and Bongaigaon
District vide notification No. ELC/WP(C)
1048/2004/988/P1-111/41 dtd. 07/01/2012. It
also appears that Md. Solimuddin and 5
others petitioners in WP(C) 143/2009, have
already
appeared
before
the
aforesaid
screening Committee.
(iv)
From the report of the screening committee
as forwarded by the Commissioner of Lower
Assam Division vide letter No GG/12/2014/6
dtd. 27/11/2014. Inter-alia, it appears that
the post sanction order in respect of the
petitioners could not be verified as the
same
was
not
produced
before
the
verification authority during the screening
by the DEEO office and as such it could not
be ascertained whether appointments are made
against sanctioned or non-sanctioned posts.
(v)
The report indicates that out of 6 (six)
petitioners the name of 4 (four) namely (1)
Abdur Rashid (2) Hafizur Rahman (3) Solim
Uddin (4) Mostafa Ahmed were recommended by
the Sub Divisional Advisory Board (SDLAC),
North Salmara Sub-Division, Abhayapuri and 2
(two) petitioners namely (1) Sahjahan Ali
Ahmed and (2) Assatan Nesssa was not been
recommended by the Sub-Divisional Advisory
Board along with two other petitioners (1)
Sahajahan Ali Ahmed (2) Asatan Nessa. The
petitioner Abdur Ras
hid is in Sl. 169.
Hafizur Rahman at Sl. 106 and Solim Uddin at
Sl. 360.
(vi)
There were only 82 sanctioned post for
Bongaigaon District as per letter No.
ECA.20/94/6 dtd 06/07/94. Therefore, only 82
persons are entitled for appointment. Since
the name of the three petitioners namely,
Hafizur Rahman, Abdur Rashid and Solim Uddin
appeared at Sl. Nos. 106, 169 and 360
respectively in the select list and they are
from the General Category, and as such they
are not entitled for appointment below from
82 of the select list.
(vii)
11.
Their appointments are irregular excess and
cannot be regularized in view of law laid
down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court and by
this Court.
However, none of these grounds assigned in the order
appears to be sound and justified. As submitted by Mr. Mahmud,
learned counsel for the petitioner, though the list of 125 teachers,
whose services were regularized by the Director Elementary
Education, Assam was set aside by a learned Single Judge of this
Court in WP(C) No. 2346/2008, vide order dated 08.05.2013, on
being challenged by one Bharat Ch. Sarkar and Ors. yet, the State
had preferred one appeal being Writ Appeal(W/A) No. 211/2013,
wherein the order dated 08.05.2013, so passed by the learned
Single Judge had been set aside and the matter was remanded
for fresh hearing, vide order dated 11.11.2021 and as such, the
regularization order dated 30.01.2006, so passed by the Director
Elementary Education, Assam pursuant to the Cabinet Decision
dated 24.02.2005 came to be restored and after the WP(C) No.
2346/2008, which was remanded to the learned Single Judge for
hearing a fresh, was subsequently dismissed for non prosecution
by a Co-ordinate Bench of this Court vide order dated 11.11.2021,
and that being so, the regularization order so passed by the
Director Elementary Education as per Cabinet Decision has
attained finality and as such the respondent authority has no
option, but to carry out the direction to release the salary of the
petitioner, as per order, dated 16-03-2010 passed in W.P. (C) No.
143/2009.
11.1. Further the respondent No.1 had relied upon the report of
the screening committee constituted by the Govt. for the purpose
of screening of the illegal irregularly appointed teachers working
in LP/ME schools for the period 1991-2001 in respect of the cases
in Lower Assam Division covering Kamrup (M), Kamrup (R),
Nalbari, Barpeta, Dhubri, Goalpara and Bongaigaon district vide
notification
No.
ELC/WP(C)
1048/2004/988/P1-111/41
dtd.
07/01/2012. Said committee was constituted after the order dated
16/03/2010, being passed in WP(C)143/2009, where in it was
directed that the Commissioner & Secretary Govt. of Assam.
Education Department would cause to take necessary steps so
that the arrear and current salaries of the petitioners are released
and for this purpose whatever enquiry is required to be done that
should be done by the authority keeping in mind the fact as
indicated above in the order. The Commissioner & Secretary is
also directed to make a necessary communication wherever found
necessary to the Finance Department for granting necessary
sanction to which there is no objection as indicated by the
Finance Department provided that the petitioners are duly
appointed by the authority.
11.2. In the said order, the this Court has also observed that the
petitioners had brought to the notice of the Court about the order
dtd. 23/12/2008, passed in WP(C) No. 3696/2008, by which the
similarly situated teachers were granted relief by the Court on
consideration.
11.3. It is well settled that the direction issued by this Court in
the order dated 16/03/2010, so passed in WP(C)143/2009, has to
be considered in the light of the facts and circumstances that had
already in existence. Subsequent events should not have been
considered by the respondent No.1 while rejecting the claim of
the petitioner.
11.4.
It is also not in dispute that one Anjumanara Khatun,
Hafizur Rahman, Naresh Ch. Mandal
and one Tulshi Barman
whose names were there in the list of 125 teachers and whose
services were regularized by the Director Elementary Education,
has been receiving salary and some of them received the same
pursuant to order of this Court. Being similarly situated, the claim
of the petitioner should not have been rejected by the respondent
No.1 and on such count, the impugned order appears to be
arbitrary and on this count also the same is liable to be interfered
with.
12. It is to noted here that on another ground also the impugned
order cannot withstand the legal scrutiny. In the case of Man
Singh (supra), Hon’ble Supreme Court has held as under:The Single
Judge in
its order
dated
11.05.2000 maintained the order dated 24.12.1998
of cancellation of appointment of the appellant
as Principal on account of violation of Chapter 3
Rule 4 of U.P. Educational Manual prescribes that
a close relation mentioned in said Rule cannot be
appointed as Principal.
The appellant was appointed as a principal
in the year 1974-75 when junior High School was
upgraded as High School and was recognized by the
State Government. Thus, the appellant has worked
for almost 24 years before the services came to
be cancelled for the reason that he is Reason:
relative
of
the
member
of
the
Selection
Committee.
The order dated 24.12.1998 also records that
the money be recovered from the appellant which
has been paid to him, as a result of his
irregular appointment for the post of Principal.
We find that the High Court has failed to
consider the fact that even if the appointment
was irregular, the appellant had discharged the
duties and in lieu of duties, he had to be paid.
The State cannot take any work from any employee
without payment of any salary.”
12.1.
Besides, a Division Bench of this Court also in the case of
State of Assam and Ors. vs. Arunima Chetia, reported in
(2016) 3 GLR 198, held as under:“9. Upon hearing the rival contentions and
after going through the order of the learned
single Judge in question, it is an admitted
fact that all the respondents in the appeals
are continuously working as teacher and their
salaries are being paid by virtue of the
Court's order. Arrears of salary from July
2007 are not being paid. When the respondents
are continuously serving as teacher, the
question whether they are illegally appointed
or otherwise it matter-less. However, for the
services rendered by the private respondents
and availed by the State, on the principle of
"quantum merit" the salaries have to be paid.
In that view of the matter we find no ground
to interfere in the order of the learned
single Judge. Accordingly the appeals are
dismissed.”
12.2. And in view of the aforesaid proposition of law, the ground
for rejection of claim of the petitioner for payment of arrear salary
fails to withstand the legal scrutiny and on this count alone and
also on the principle of "quantum meruit" the same is liable to
be interfered with.
13. Under the given factual and legal matrix the impugned order
No. ELC/WP(C)1143/2009/13/Pt/370, Dated Dispur the 20th
December, 2014 passed by the respondent No.1, failed to
withstand the legal scrutiny and accordingly, the same stands set
aside and quashed.
14.
By a mandamus of this Court, the state respondents, more
particularly the respondents No. 1,2 and 3 are directed to pay the
current and arrear salary to the petitioner, with effect from June
1994 till date.
15.
Let the exercise, mentioned in para No. 14 be carried out
within a period of three months from the date of receipt of
certified copy of this order. The petitioner shall obtain a certified
copy of this order and place the same before the respondent
authorities, within a week from today. In the event of failing to
carry out the direction in para 14, the entire amount of arrear
salary shall carry interest @ Rs. 9% per annum from the date of
accrual till final payment.
16.
In terms of above, this writ petition stands disposed of
leaving the parties to bear their own costs.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review